• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

Priscus at the court of Attila the Huns

You are not very reasonable, you are writing bullshit the whole time, whats your age, 8?

I totally agree with Onur, you cannot have a discussion with someone who believes in fairy tales.
 
It isnt related, I said it so you can maybe discover your own bloodline, not every Macedonian is pure you know, like Onur said, we Turks dont care about bloodline, we all consider ourselves as Turks just like everyone in the Ottoman Empire considered theirselves as Ottomans.

I can trace back 3 generations Macedonians both sides of my family (paternal and maternal) and don't need any "discovery" of my bloodline because I know who I am - Indigenous Macedonian! :) Who says Macedonians are "pure" anything? Please don't invent such nonsense and stick to facts here on MTO. We (some of us, IMO, the more enlightened ones!) say we are predominantly of indigenous stock and I have yet to see/hear anyone claim "pure" anything.


Im just telling you facts, Kemals bloodline is Turkmen he is not mixed,
the Huns who came to Europe do got mixed.
Perhaps the people who claim Kemal as a Macedonian can challenge your claims but Kemall did not look like a typical "Turkmen" to me.

608ataturk1.jpg

Mustafa Kemal, the blue-eyed "pure Turkmen"? :)


A+Seljuk+Turk+Warrior.jpg

Seljuk Warrior

Seljuk01.jpg

Seljuk Warrior

seljuk1100Large.gif

Seljuk Turk Empire circa 1100 AD


for example Attila himself was a pure Turk
And what did the "pure" Turk like Attila look like back then?

but still the first Huns who came to Europe were Turkic peoples from the east.
And what did they look like, Caucasian or Mongoloid/Asian?

--------------

You are not very reasonable, you are writing bullshit the whole time, whats your age, 8?
Cheap belittling snide remarks of someone having no facts to argue with and hoping no one will notice once the thread turns over onto a new page.

I totally agree with Onur, you cannot have a discussion with someone who believes in fairy tales.

As above and the pot calling someone else black is the case again! I am beginning to think you are just an alternate login for the same person!?

seljuk_warriors_enh.jpg


I stated the following on another thread and stand by it!:

Onur, you don't have much to stand on in respect of official Turkish and MAINSTREAM view regards the original homeland (Altai region of Mongolia) of the Turko-Mongol language bearers, i.e they were an Asiatic race akin to Mongols.

Secondly, if I were to accept your view (of which we are not clear on what it is) that it was not minority Turko-Mongol state forming elites that introduced Turkic languages into Anatolia (and elsewhere in Europe and Central Asia) but that it was the result of some HYPOTHETICAL CAUCASIAN Turko-speaking MASS INVASIONS (e.g. from "Pamir", as Petar Dobrev and Co would have us believe), I would have to give credence to the MASS "SLAV" invasion THEORY (HYPOTHESIS) of the Macedonian Peninsula (Balkans) unless we could "prove" that the Macedonic ("Slavonic") languages were native to Macedonia and the surrounding area/s. This I am NOT prepared to accept as language is NOT always a determinant for national identity or for indigenity.

-------------

Indigen, are you aware that you are acting like a 14 year old internet warrior? OR you are really one of them?
Pot calling someone else black and especially when they are losing the plot! :)

So, if we look at the medieval sources rather than your cartoons, that's how they describe Khazars.
I told you before, you have a dismissive excuse for anything that does not fit your world-view of white Caucasian (and linguistically related to Sumerian) Turks and you are as stubborn as any Greek or Bulgarian nationalist. :)

---------

Jordanes' description of the Huns, Brothers of the Bulgars:

"...a stunted, foul and puny tribe, scarcely human, and having no language
save one which bore but slight resemblance to human speech. Such was the
descent of the Huns...

...This cruel tribe, as Priscus the historian relates, settled on the
farther bank of the Maeotic swamp. They were fond of hunting and had
no skill in any other art. After they had grown to a nation, they disturbed
the peace of neighboring races by theft and rapine...

...Now in my opinion the evil spirits, from whom the Huns are descended...

...As many as they captured, when they thus entered Scythia for the first
time, they sacrificed to Victory. The remainder they conquered and made
subject to themselves. (126) Like a whirlwind of nations they swept across
the great swamp and at once fell upon the Alpidzuri, Alcildzuri, Itimari,
Tuncarsi and Boisci, who bordered on that part of Scythia. The Alani also,
who were their equals in battle, but unlike them in civilization, manners
and appearance, they exhausted by their incessant attacks and subdued. (127)
For by the terror of their features they inspired great fear in those whom
perhaps they did not really surpass in war...

THEIR FEATURES WERE:

"...They made their foes flee in horror because THEIR SWARTHY ASPECT WAS
FEARFUL, and they had, if I may call it so, a sort of shapeless lump, not a
head, with pin-holes rather than eyes. Their hardihood is evident in their
wild appearance, and they are beings who are cruel to their children on the
very day they are born. For they cut the cheeks of the males with a sword,
so that before they receive the nourishment of milk they must learn to
endure wounds. (128) Hence they grow old beardless and their young men are
without comeliness, because a face furrowed by the sword spoils by its scars
the natural beauty of a beard. They are short in stature, quick in bodily
movement, alert horsemen, broad shouldered, ready in the use of bow and
arrow, and have firm-set necks which are ever erect in pride. Though they
live in the form of men, they have the cruelty of wild beasts...."

----------------------------

Oxford Bulgar Historian Stefan Nikolov:
"...And the Avars WERE "Mongoloide" for sure, believe me...."

Bozhidar Dimitrov:
"...Bulgarians belong to the same ethnolingual group as the Huns, the Avars,
the Pechenegs and the Cumans, i.e., the peoples, parts of which are to flow
into the Bulgarian nation between the 7th and 14th centuries...."


Dimiter Markovski:
"Khan Asparouh's Bulgaro-Turks"


"The year 681 accepted as Year One of Bulgaria's history."

"...Banner of the Proto-Bulgarian troops consisted of horse's tail
attached to a spear..."


Jordanes description of Attila the Hun: "flat nose and a swarthy complexion, showing evidence of his origin"

-------------

32301793560978674.jpg

Racial type and descendants
Victorious Bulgar warrior with captive, featured on a ewer from the Treasure of Nagyszentmiklos

Our results suggest that the Cumanians, as seen in the excavation at Csengele, were far from genetic homogeneity. Nevertheless, the grave artifacts are typical of the Cumanian steppe culture; and five of the six skeletons that were complete enough for anthropometric analysis appeared Asian rather than European (Horváth 1978, 2001), including two from the mitochondrial haplogroup H, which is typically European. It is interesting that the only skeleton for which anthropological examination indicated a partly European ancestry was that of the chieftain, whose haplotype is most frequently found in the Balkans.

Source Link
 
Last edited:
Indigen, i see that you started spamming the thread now, by repeatedly posting your crap over and over again with same cartoons by creating giant msg frame!!! good for you!!!

But i can guess that you are probably thinking like "i am macedonian on a macedonian forum, so i have a right to spam but you are just a turko-mongol, so stfu"!!!!
sigh...


I told you before, you have a dismissive excuse for anything that does not fit your world-view of white Caucasian (and linguistically related to Sumerian) Turks and you are as stubborn as any Greek or Bulgarian nationalist.

Indigen, you expect me to accept your cartoons and deny numerous 8-9-10th century Roman, Byzantine, Arab, Jewish records(i wrote some of them above). You also want me to accept Jordanes`s descriptions like "Huns, Turks descendant from evil spirits", which he wrote like 200 years after Attila`s death and deny Priscus`s eyewitness records from his meeting with Attila.

I said that you are obsessive and hopeless with a reason.





As above and the pot calling someone else black is the case again! I am beginning to think you are just an alternate login for the same person!?

Hah!! probably you do that yourself, so expect me to do the same? Ask admins about our IPs, as far as i remember Ottoman said he was living in outside Turkey while i am not. I am not a low life like you dude. Dont think that everyone is like yourself!


Now go ahead, write just one sentence and quote all your crap in a giant frame again.
 
Last edited:
I find this subject quite interesting. I must admit that i dont know much about the origin of the turkish people.
As i understand Onur, he is saying that modern day turkish speaking peoples like Finlandians, Hungarians and Turks from Turkey are predominantly genetic descents from turkish colonists from the middle ages and not descending from autohtonous peoples in those regions who had accepted the turkish language. But if that is so, than those peoples should all resemble each other, finlandians should look like hungarians and turks. But i think that Finlandians are similar to sweeds and Norwegans, Hungarians are similar with Romanians and Serbs from northern serbia and Turks from Turkey share many comon features with Macedonians.
My opinion is that the population in modern Turkey is dominantly autohtonous, but also there is a large percent of turkish genes.
I must say again that i am not very familiar with this subject and i am just sharing my opinion.
And there is no need for arguing with such tone and hostility guys, we are not enemyes if we have diferent opinion on something,,,
:)
 
Good post Astibo, one thing I would note is that the group of languages should be named under the umbrella term of Ural-Altaic, as not all of them are Turkic.

In my opinion, the proto-people of the Ural-Altaic group were no doubt 'eastern-oriental' looking, for want of a better word. However, it is clear that there was an increase of inter-racial mixing with 'western-caucasian' looking people the further west they travelled. Once they integrated with the larger local populations of their current destinations in Anatolia, central Europe and Scandinavia, many, if not most, came to resemble the locals themsleves, while retaining some elements of their ancestry. Those that live between the old and new homelands share features of both to varying degrees.
Onur said:
Thats what medieval documents says but ofc not all Turks was blondish. There was brown haired and eyed ones too since Turks was never homogeneous throughout history but it was rather an unity of various people who speaks Uralic-Altaic languages.

And as you can read here, blond haired and blue/green eyed Cuman Turks left us one of the most important work of Turkic language in 12th century. A collection of Turkic riddles, sample sentences for conversation in Turkic and a dictionary with a total of 4500 Turkic words.
Onur, do you find the reference to 'eastern-oriental' looking people incorrect as the description of the early ancestors of the Turks? Although I am not sure why there was a necessity to steer this topic on to a 'racial' analysis, surely you don't believe that the Turkic people that were kindred to the early Huns bordering Chinese territory in the 4th century were 'western-caucasian' looking? A century later, Attila was in the territory and company of people speaking Slavic languages, and he was most certainly of mixed breed himself, to what degree though is arguable.

http://people.ucalgary.ca/~vandersp/Courses/texts/jordgeti.html
Attila was lord over all the Huns and almost the sole earthly ruler of all the tribes of Scythia; a man marvellous for his glorious fame among all nations.
In the land of Scythia.....Dacia, encircled by the lofty Alps as by a crown. Near their left ridge, which inclines toward the north, and beginning at the source of the Vistula, the populous race of the Venethi dwell, occupying a great expanse of land. Though their names are now dispersed amid various clans and places, yet they are chiefly called Sclaveni and Antes.
When they had mourned him with such lamentations, a strava, as they call it, was celebrated over his tomb with great revelling.
Only a privileged group among the many nations over whom he ruled would be allowed to perform such an act. Who else then, would "they" be, and who else would "call it" like that? Perhaps the European element in the lineage of Attila was of people speaking a Slavic language afterall.
 
"Efendiler, benim atalarım Anadolu'dan Rumeli'ye gelmiş Yörük Türkmenler'dendir "
M.Kemal Atatürk

"Gentlemen, my ancestors came from Anatolia to Rumelia and they are Turkmen Yörük "
M. Kemal Ataturk
I doubt very much that Kemal was fully Turkmen. His mother was Macedonian by origin, his father was probably Turkish, Albanian or a combination of both. See below:

http://www.macedoniantruth.org/forum/showthread.php?t=457&page=8
http://www.macedoniantruth.org/forum/showthread.php?t=457&page=9
http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,860057-2,00.html
http://www.nyu.edu/classes/keefer/ww1/blythe.html
 
SOM you are absolutely right,That's another myth busted by TM.The Father of All the Turks (who left no legitimate heirs) was born in 1881 in Salonika, then part of the Ottoman Empire, of a mild Albanian father and a forceful Macedonian mother.


http://www.nyu.edu/classes/keefer/ww1/blythe.html

He was of solid peasant stock of Albanian and Macedonian origins; he had pale blue eyes and light hair and coloring.

Just because he was the Father of the Turks does not mean he was ethnically Turkish. Another example of a "father figure" would be modern "greece's" own Rigas Velenstinlis who was a Vlach by ethnicity.
 
Last edited:
Ataturk was NOT Macedonian or Albanian, that are claims without any evidence, these are words spoken from Ataturks own mouth, several people witnessed these words.


"Efendiler, benim atalarım Anadolu'dan Rumeli'ye gelmiş Yörük Türkmenler'dendir "
M.Kemal Atatürk

"Gentlemen, my ancestors came from Anatolia to Rumelia and they are Turkmen Yörük "
M.Kemal Atatürk


and according to Falih Rıfkı Atay, Ali Rıza's roots have come from Söke in Aydın Province. His mother Zübeyde is thought to be of Turkish and according to Şevket Süreyya Aydemir, her roots have come from Turkoman (Türkmen) and in his family, there was roumor that they have come of Yörük.

http://www.eupedia.com/forum/showthread.php?t=26124 <<< read this link for more info.

YouTube - Proof: Mustafa Kemal Ataturk was Yörük Turkmen! True Origins

Even if Ataturk was an Macedonian Albanian I ask myself this question; what has he ever done for your people? just nothing.

Ataturk declared himself as a Turk and he gave us Turks the greatest gift.

But as I posted many times before he is Turkmen, its just end of discussion for me.
 
It`s pointless to investigate Ataturk`s bloodline since he was born in a time and place where there was no difference between Macedonian, Albanian or Turkish muslims. This is even against Ataturk`s conception of patriotism and nationalism. He had never questioned people`s bloodline as long as they are Turkish in terms of ideas and this is still valid in today`s Turkey since there is no difference at all between myself and my Bosnian or Macedonian friends here in Izmir.

So, even if Ataturk would be Macedonian or Albanian, he served to Turkey in the end and he is more Turkish to me than someone with pure Turk blood from central Asia. There is no such a thing either since Turks never consisted of people with exact same bloodline even 1000+ years ago. Actually every society in the world is like that except some isolated tribes like Aborigines but they prefer to hide it unlike Turks. Turks doesn't hide cuz we are perfectly comfortable with it since big majority of Turkish people doesn't give any importance to bloodlines.

Racism never became an important factor among Turkish people throughout history and i believe this is the most advanced expression of nationalism unlike the primitive one with racism.
 
It`s pointless to investigate Ataturk`s bloodline since he was born in a time and place where there was no difference between Macedonian, Albanian or Turkish muslims........even if Ataturk would be Macedonian or Albanian, he served to Turkey in the end and he is more Turkish to me than someone with pure Turk blood from central Asia.
Ottoman said:
Ataturk was NOT Macedonian or Albanian, that are claims without any evidence, these are words spoken from Ataturks own mouth, several people witnessed these words..............Even if Ataturk was an Macedonian Albanian I ask myself this question; what has he ever done for your people? just nothing. Ataturk declared himself as a Turk and he gave us Turks the greatest gift.
Ottoman, perhaps Onur can teach you a few lessons in manners, because your messages are similar, but the way they are conveyed differ markedly. You're unreasonable and confrontational, unnecessarily. Don't mistake the general collective of members here as an enemy, but at the same time, remember that you are at a forum where Macedonians are a majority, so a bit of diplomacy on your part wouldn't be harmful either.

Personally, I am only interested in the historical side of the matter. I am not going claim that Kemal was "a" Macedonian, but he does appear to have a Macedonian heritage from his mother's side (she may also have been mixed with Turkish or Albanian), and that I will claim. In the quote that is provided above he speaks of his ancestors, but he doesn't refer to all of his ancestry. Part of the heritage of his father, mother or grandparents may very well have been Turkmen, however, given his life and origins in Macedonia and the sources claiming so, to discount the likely possibility of Kemal being part Macedonian is ludicrous. Of course, his actions were for the betterment of the Turkish people, and despite the discussion about his background, nobody here is disputing that he identified and lived as a Turk (which may suggest that the his father was Turkish and not Albanian, or mixed). Here is what Andrew Mango writes, as quoted in Wikipedia:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mustafa_Kemal_Atatürk#cite_note-4

Atatürk's parents and relatives all used Turkish as their mother tongue. This suggests that some at least of their ancestors had originally come from Turkey, since local Muslims of Albanian and Slav origin who had no ethnic connection with Turkey spoke Albanian, Serbo-Croat or Bulgarian* (or Macedonian: my note), at least so long as they remained in their native land., But in looks Ataturk resembled local Albanians and Slavs.[...] But there is no evidence that either Ali Riza or Zübeyde was descended from such Turkish nomads. page 28; It is much more likely that Atatürk inherited his looks from his Balkan ancestors.[...] But Albanians and Slavs are likely to have figured among his ancestors.
 
Just find me something where Ataturk clearly states he has Macedonian roots, he doesnt mention this once in his lifetime, he may have Slavic roots because of his hair and eye colour, Ataturk was only educated in Macedonia, there is nothing else bonding him to Macedonia.

By the way Ataturk was against the Ottoman imperial house, he exiled the last sultan.
 
Good post Astibo, one thing I would note is that the group of languages should be named under the umbrella term of Ural-Altaic, as not all of them are Turkic.

In my opinion, the proto-people of the Ural-Altaic group were no doubt 'eastern-oriental' looking, for want of a better word. However, it is clear that there was an increase of inter-racial mixing with 'western-caucasian' looking people the further west they travelled. Once they integrated with the larger local populations of their current destinations in Anatolia, central Europe and Scandinavia, many, if not most, came to resemble the locals themsleves, while retaining some elements of their ancestry. Those that live between the old and new homelands share features of both to varying degrees.

Actually SoM, the presence of Uralic peoples in what is today Scandinavia, Finland, Estonia and almost entire European and part of Asian northern Russia precedes the arrival of Indo-Europeans into Europe. It is actually an established fact that Uralic people were the first people to settle these northern parts right after the Ice Age. There is no discontinuity in archaeological findings in Uralic speaking areas since at least the Mesolithic period. At the map I posted on the PBPBS threat the grey area above the coloured IE ones was inhabited by the Uralic peoples since the stone age. They were most likely the first settlers of Europe who moved north periodically as the glaciers retreated and the Indo-Europeans followed behind them from the south. The Proto-Uralic language can be reconstructed going back up to 7 millennium BC.

I was always curious why Uralic peoples are mostly blond or brown haired with blue eyes, but the stereotype of them being Asian looking came from biased sources linking them to the Turks. I would say that Uralic peoples are more European than the Indo-Europeans being here before them and all.

The Hungarians originally lived in the most southern part of the Uralic area and were the only Uralic people to adopt a nomadic life (well, except the northernmost Sami people who migrate with their reindeer), most likely under the influence of Iranic or Turkic peoples from the south. To my knowledge the Ural-Altaic theory has almost been completely rejected, and what remains of it is an idea in the Nostratic and Eurasiatic theories, but even there the Uralic and Altaic languages are not linked specifically just to one another but rather as a part of a macrofamily that includes other language families as well, like Indo-European, Japonic, Afro-Asiatic and so on.
 
Last edited:
Actually SoM, the presence of Uralic peoples in what is today Scandinavia, Finland, Estonia and almost entire European and part of Asian northern Russia precedes the arrival of Indo-Europeans into Europe. It is actually an established fact that Uralic people were the first people to settle these northern parts right after the Ice Age. There is no discontinuity in archaeological findings in Uralic speaking areas since at least the Mesolithic period. At the map I posted on the PBPBS threat the grey area above the coloured IE ones was inhabited by the Uralic peoples since the stone age. They were most likely the first settlers of Europe who moved north periodically as the glaciers retreated and the Indo-Europeans followed behind them from the south. The Proto-Uralic language can be reconstructed going back up to 7 millennium BC.
Ok Slovak, I am open to the above as I haven't researched it as much as you have.
I was always curious why Uralic peoples are mostly blond or brown haired with blue eyes, but the stereotype of them being Asian looking came from biased sources linking them to the Turks.
Why do you think they were linked to Turks in certain sources?
To my knowledge the Ural-Altaic theory has almost been completely rejected, and what remains of it is an idea in the Nostratic and Eurasiatic theories, but even there the Uralic and Altaic languages are not linked specifically just to one another but rather as a part of a macrofamily that includes other language families as well, like Indo-European, Japonic, Afro-Asiatic and so on.
Aren't there some features that are only shared by languages in the suggested 'Ural-Altaic' theory, such as being agglutinative? Or do they not all share this feature? How would you explain the other similarities between Turkic and Hungarian, for example, in that comparative sentence that Onur has posted a few times?
 
Just find me something where Ataturk clearly states he has Macedonian roots, he doesnt mention this once in his lifetime.......
He doesn't have to mention it. A logical interpretation of the facts and sources would lead to this conclusion, in spite of your personal views.
.........he may have Slavic roots because of his hair and eye colour
No such thing as 'Slavic' roots, it's a language, not an ethnicity. And the Slavic-speaking peoples in Macedonia are the Macedonians. So you've just contradicted yourself.
Ataturk was only educated in Macedonia, there is nothing else bonding him to Macedonia
Testament of your ignorance.
 
Soldier of Macedon said:
Why do you think they were linked to Turks in certain sources?
Well the only Uralic people that have been linked or presented as Turks were the Hungarians, since like the Turkic peoples they were first nomads and had a somewhat similar culture and a sounding language like the Turkic peoples. But this only goes for the Hungarians. Other Uralic peoples, except maybe those who lived on the Turkic border have anything similar with the Turkic peoples.

Soldier of Macedon said:
Aren't there some features that are only shared by languages in the suggested 'Ural-Altaic' theory, such as being agglutinative? Or do they not all share this feature? How would you explain the other similarities between Turkic and Hungarian, for example, in that comparative sentence that Onur has posted a few times?
There are many agglutinative languages out there, like Dravidian languages, Sumerian, most Mesoamerican languages, etc. You'll need to read a comparative study of Uralic and Altaic languages. As for vocabulary, I've read that the only similarity that exists is with Hungarian and these are most likely borrowings. From the 200 or so reconstructed Proto-Uralic words that are common for all Uralic languages none of them have cognates in Turkic languages.

Which Onur's examples?
 
Well the only Uralic people that have been linked or presented as Turks were the Hungarians, since like the Turkic peoples they were first nomads and had a somewhat similar culture and a sounding language like the Turkic peoples. But this only goes for the Hungarians. Other Uralic peoples, except maybe those who lived on the Turkic border have anything similar with the Turkic peoples.

The other so-called Uralic peoples like Finns, Estonians migrated from Eurasia too but they were living close to Siberia, kinda separated from other Eurasian people like Turks, Hungarians who lived in southern side, around today`s Ukraine, Kazakhstan. But ofc they use similar language as ours and Turkic have few 100 common words with Estonian&Finnish language. Our grammar rules are already mostly same.


Turks and Hungarians have more common things cuz when the ancestors of Hungarians seperated from Khazar empire and migrated in to the Panonia, they were consisted of 8-9 tribes. It`s known that 3-4 of these tribes was Turkic like Szekely and Csango. Also, they created Hungary on top of the ~400 year old Avar Turkic state. Then in 13th century, Turkic Cumans and Pechenegs seek refuge in Hungary because of Mongol advancements of Ghengis Khan. They consisted about 30% of Hungary`s total population and they had autonomy inside Hungary from 13th century to 18th century named Kunsag, Cumania and their autonomy abolished after they fully integrated into Hungarian people and lost their original Turkic language. Today, they only know few songs with Turkic lyrics remained from their medieval day.

In a documentary for Turkish tv, they have gone to the Hungarian villages and recorded one of their old songs Cuman Turkic. Here it is, red one is Cuman Turkic, blue is Turkish. I can easily understand his Turkic;
YouTube - ‪Hun-Kuman Prayer from Hungary (with Lyrics)‬‏



Also, for about the first ~200 years of Hungary, these people was known as Turks and Panonia was named as Tourkia. Most lprobably, because their ruling core was Turkic while they were still Tengrist shamans. Only after most of them converted as christians, they started to be known as Magyars. If they wouldn't be Turkic speaking, why they would be crowned as "king of Turks and Tourkia"?? I`ve wrote a msg about this b4;

http://www.macedoniantruth.org/forum/showpost.php?p=100899&postcount=101




There are many agglutinative languages out there, like Dravidian languages, Sumerian, most Mesoamerican languages, etc. You'll need to read a comparative study of Uralic and Altaic languages. As for vocabulary, I've read that the only similarity that exists is with Hungarian and these are most likely borrowings. From the 200 or so reconstructed Proto-Uralic words that are common for all Uralic languages none of them have cognates in Turkic languages.

Which Onur's examples?

The similarities between Hungarian and Turkic is not only agglutinative suffixes. There are many more than that. Yes Hungarian has about ~4000 Turkic words today but these are not Ottoman era borrowings like in Serbian, Macedonian, Bulgarian. In Hungarian language, the words of some human body parts, organs, some animals, most of horse riding terminology, most of agriculture terms are Turkic. I mean, in Serbian language, there are borek, bahcha, musluk but in Hungarian language, words for vegetables like apple, barley, wheat are Turkic. You dont think like Hungarians learned the apple from 16th century Ottoman era, do you?

There are few 100 examples of common Turkic-Hungarian early medieval words here;

http://member.melbpc.org.au/~tmajlath/turkic1.html



And this was my message here from last year, SOM was talking about this;
You took these words in Ottoman era like Serbs, Bosnians, Greeks did but there is one interesting fact about Hungarian language like this. There is a famous sentence to indicate similarity between Hungarian and Turkish;

English; I have a lot of small yellow apples in my pocket

Turkish; Cebimde cok kucuk sari elma var

Hungarian; Zsebemben sok kicsi sarga alma van


If you don't believe, copy&paste these and translate to English in google :)


It`s a striking example and ofc the word order is same in both languages. Hungarians didn't adopt these words from us in Ottoman era unlike you did. They adopted these words in era of the Hun Empire and/or Khazar Empire(4th to 9th century or earlier) because Ottoman Empire took control of Hungary at 16th century and it`s impossible that they learned these Turkish words for "apple, pocket" from us as late as 16th century. Also some grammatical suffixes and words like "who, whose, whom..." are similar too, so it cannot be 16th century borrowings. 16th century, Ottoman era adoptions in Hungarian language are quite same as yours like Boza, borek, charsi etc.

Also a lot of agriculture and horse riding terminology in current Hungarian language are Turkish words too.


English - Turkish - Hungarian
Whose book - Kimin kitabi - Kinek könyve
Who - Kim - Ki
Many - Cok - Sok
Little - kucuk - kicsi
With whom - Kiminle - Kivel

Apple - elma - alma
My apple - elma(m) - alma(m)
My apples - elma(larim) - alma(im)



http://member.melbpc.org.au/~tmajlath/turkic1.html



If you read my message here. You can see same grammatical features as with Turkic-Hungarian in old Bulgarian language (NOT old church slavic but Bulgar Turkic);

http://www.macedoniantruth.org/forum/showpost.php?p=63393&postcount=15
 
Last edited:
You dont think like Hungarians learned the apple from 16th century Ottoman era, do you?
Well, your entire article is following an underlying idea that I'm an ignorant pro-Westerner, so I'm just not going to answer.
 
Well, your entire article is following an underlying idea that I'm an ignorant pro-Westerner, so I'm just not going to answer.

No, i didn't imply that. That was only a question to you cuz you said that Turkic words in Hungarian can only be Ottoman borrowings just as in other Balkan languages.

I think you are using that as an excuse and you prefer not to respond cuz what i wrote here contradicts your mostly imaginary thoughts and ideas. Just like the map you`ve posted in other thread with pretty absurd claims like Germanic languages existed in Europe for 3000-5000 years and it wasn't the aglo-saxons who bring it first in England.

It`s obvious that you have some interest to these issues but i see that you ignore some historical facts if it`s not suitable for your own ideology and you start to create your own imaginary thoughts in place of those, like your claims of "existence of Germanic languages in western Europe for 3000-5000 years"!!!
 
Last edited:
No, i didn't imply that. That was only a question to you cuz you said that Turkic words in Hungarian can only be Ottoman borrowings just as in other Balkan languages.
Actually I didn't say that. I thought I was pretty clear saying Hungarian borrowings from Turkic languages were from before their arrival into the Pannonian plain.

I think you are using that as an excuse and you prefer not to respond cuz what i wrote here contradicts your mostly imaginary thoughts and ideas.
I prefer not to respond because I feel that it would be too exhaustive for me to debate something I'm only a bit interested in, and even less if the people who I'm responding to are someone I don't like.

"existence of Germanic languages in western Europe for 3000-5000 years"
I'm actually saying it's since the Mesolithic period, so about 10.000 years. You wouldn't understand why, since I already tested you on some of the key points you would need to know to understand it. You can however change that if you start with reading these in order:

http://www.continuitas.org
http://languagecontinuity.blogspot.com
http://www.proto-english.org

Call me arrogant, but I know from experience that one cannot debate with someone else if both don't understand the other's knowledge.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top