• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

Paleo-Balkan & Balto-Slavic - Common Proto Language

Just a follow up to the above suggestion about the tribal name of 'maduat(eni)' and the possible relation to the word 'medved'. If we use both components of the word with Sanskrit equivalents, it looks almost identical:

- ed (PIE) -> atti (SKR), at (THR)
- médhu (PIE) -> madhu (SKR), madu (THR)

Sanskrit: madhuatti
Thracian: maduat

There is one thing that may or may not pose an issue, and that is the case ending for the word 'medu', which developed into 'medv(ed)'. It is said to be a Slavic partitive (sg.) case, and this case ending apparently originated from the ablative case. The same word in the ablative case for Sanskrit is described in the below comparison table; however, this may just mean that the Slavic and Thracian case endings (in this instance) are more similar to each other than they are to the one in Sanskrit.



What are your thoughts on the above Slovak?

Sound theory SoM. I think we can add maduat to the list of the deciphered Thracian words, as well as its components madu - honey and ati - to eat. Furthermore, I think you are getting a better and better grasp of the declination system and how it works. I congratulate you on your effort.
 
Thanks mate, good to hear you're in agreement with respect to the 'maduateni', because the similarities were just too much to ignore. Regarding the declination system, I have corrected many of my misconceptions, and although I still have more to learn, I have come a long way in terms of understanding how it works. To be honest, much of it I owe to your (constructive) criticism during previous discussions.
 
This I copied from a book called "Grammar of Modern Indo-European". I would take the reconstructions with a grain of salt, but it is still quite interesting to see how some linguists reconstructed the IE languages. Unfortunately the book does not cite references.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------
The so-called Schleicher's fable is a poem composed in the reconstructed Proto-Indo-European language, published by August Schleicher in 1868, originally named - The Sheep and the Horses‖. It is written here to show the evolution of PIE from its first reconstructable stages until the latest IE proto-languages known.

1. English
2. Late PIE, 3.000 BC
3. Proto-Anatolian, 2.500 BC
4. European PIE, 2.500 BC
5. Proto-Indo-Iranian, 2.000 BC
6. Proto-Greek, 2.000 BC
7. Proto-Tocharian, 1.000 BC
8. Proto-Celtic, 1.000 BC
9. Proto-Italic, 1.000 BC
10. Proto-Germanic, 500 BC
11. Proto-Slavic, 1 AD
12. Proto-Baltic, 1 AD
13. Proto-Armenian, 1 AD


1. The Sheep and the Horses
2. Xowis ʔékwōs-qe.
3. Háwis áswes-ki.
4. Owis ekwōs-qe.
5. Ávis áçvās-ka.
6. Ówis íkwoi-qe.
7. Ówi júkweñ-ke.
8. Ówis éqoi-k(h)e.
9. Ówis ékwoi-qe.
10. Áwiz ékhwaz-ukh.
11. Óvĭs ésvŭ-če.
12. Ávis ášvai-ke.
13. Hóvih ēšwuh-kh.

1. A sheep that had no wool
2. Χowis, qesjo wlʔneħ ne ʔest,
3. Háwis, kuis húlana na est,
4. Owis, qesio wḹnā ne est,
5. Ávis, kahja vṛnā na āst,
6. Ówis, qého lānā ne ēst,
7. Ówi, kúse wlānā ne es,
8. Ówis, qésjo wlənā ne est,
9. Ówis, qésjo lāna ne est,
10. Áwiz, khwes wúlnō ne ist,
11. Óvĭs, čéso vlĭna ne jázĭt,
12. Ávis, káso vìlno ne ašt,
13. Hóvih, khéhjo gálana ne ēs(th),

1. saw horses,
2. ʔékwoms spekét,
3. áswus spekét,
4. ekwoms spekét,
5. áçvans spaçát,
6. íkwos spekét,
7. júkwes śpäkät,
8. éqos skhekét,
9. ékwos spekét,
10. ékhwanz spekhét,
11. ésva spesét,
12. ášvus spekít,
13. ēšwoh sphekhe(th),

1. one pulling a heavy wagon,
2. ʔóinom cṛχum wóghom wéghontṃ,
3. ānan wurhún wágan wéganzam,
4. oinom carúm woghom wéghontṃ,
5. áinam garúm vágham vághantam,
6. énon barún wókhon wékhontã,
7. énem karäm wákṃ wäkantäm,
8. óinom barúm wokhom wékhontam,
9. oinom craum wokhom wekhontem,
10. áinan karún wágan wéganthun,
11. ínŭ žarŭõ vózŭ vézõtẽ,
12. áinam ģarũ vážam véžantim,
13. énam erkúm wóĵã wéĵonã,

1. one carrying a big load,
2. ʔóinom-qe mégeħm bhórom,
3. ānan-ki mékan báran,
4. oinom-qe megām bhorom,
5. áinam-ka mágham bháram,
6. énon-qe mégān phóron,
7. énem-ke mäkām parm,
8. óinom-k(h)e məgam bórom,
9. oinom-qe məĵam phórom,
10. áinan-ukh mékon báran,
11. ínŭ-če méža bórŭ,
12. áinam-ke méģam báram,
13. énam-kh mékã bórã,

1. and one carrying a man quickly.
2. ʔóinom-qe dhʔghmónṃ ʔoʔku bhérontṃ.
3. ānan-ki teggánam aku báranzam.
4. oinom-qe dhghmonṃ ōkú bhérontṃ.
5. áinam-ka ghámanam āçu bhárantam.
6. énon-qe khthónon ōku phérontã.
7. énem-ke tkámnam ākä pärantäm.
8. óinom-k(h)e d(okh)oniom ōku bérontam.
9. oinom-qe khómonem ōku pherontem.
10. áinan-ukh gúmanan ākhu béranthun.
11. ínŭ-če žmónŭ asŭ bérõtẽ.
12. áinam-ke zmónam uoku bérantim.
13. énam-kh zmónã ušu béronã.

1. The sheep said to the horses:
2. Xowis nu ʔékwobhjos wewqét:
3. Háwis nu áswaz hwewkét:
4. Owis nu ékwobhos wewqét:
5. Ávis nu áçvabhjas ávaukat:
6. Ówis nu íkwobos éweweqet:
7. Owi nä júkwebos wäwkät:
8. Ówis nu éqobos wewqét:
9. Ówis nu ékwobhos wewqét:
10. Áwiz nu ékhwamaz wewkhéth:
11. Óvĭs nŭ ésvomŭ vjučét:
12. Ávis nu ášvamas vjaukít:
13. Hóvih nu ēšwoboh égojkhe(th):

1. “My heart pains me,
2. “Kṛd ħéghnutoi ʔmoí,
3. “Kart áknuta(ri) mai,
4. “Kṛd ághnutoi moí,
5. “Ghṛd ághnutai mai,
6. “Kard ákhnutoi moi,
7. “Kärt ágnätai me,
8. “Krid ágnutor mai,
9. “Kord ákhnutor mei,
10. “Hurt ágnuthai mai,
11. “Srĭd áznutĕ mĕ,
12. “Šird ágnutai mai,
13. “Sart égnuthe me,

1. seeing a man driving horses”.
2. ʔékwoms ħégontṃ wíʔrom wídṇtei”.
3. áswus ákantun wíran wítanzi”.
4. ekwoms ágontṃ wīrom wídṇtei”.
5. áçvans aĵantam vīram vídanti”.
6. íkwos ágontã wíron wídãtei”.
7. júkwes ākantän wírem wítsante”.
8. éqos ágontom wírom wídanti”.
9. ékwos ágontom wīrom wídentei”.
10. ékhwanz ákanthun weran wítanthī”.
11. ésvŭ ágõtŭ vírŭ vídẽti”.
12. ášvai ágantim víram vídintei”.
13. ēšwuh ákonthã gárã gítanthi”.

1. The horses said: “Listen, sheep,
2. ʔékwōs tu wewqónt: “Kludhí, χówi!
3. Áswes tu wewkúnz: “Klutí, háwi!
4. Ekwōs tu wewqónt: “Kludhí, owi!
5. Áçvās tu ávaukant: “Srudhí ávi!
6. Íkwoi tu éweweqont: “Kluthí, ówi!
7. Júkweñ tä wäwkant: “Klutí, ow!
8. Éqoi tu wewqónt: “Kludí, ówi!
9. Ékwoi tu wewqónt: “Kluthí, ówi!
10. Ékhwaz wéwkhant: “Khludí, áwi!
11. Ésva tu vjúčõt: “Sludĭ, óve!
12. Ášvus tu vjáukant: “Šludí, ávi!
13. Ēšwoh thu égojkhõ: “Ludí, hóvi!

1. our hearts pain us when we see this:
2. kṛd ħéghnutoi ṇsméi wídṇtbhjos:
3. kart áknuta(ri) anzás wítantaz:
4. kṛd ághnutoi ṇsméi wídṇtbhos:
5. ghṛd ághnutai asmái vídantbhjas:
6. kart ágnutoi ahmá wídãtbios:
7. kärt āknete ánsme wítäntbe:
8. krid ágnutor ansméi wídantbjos:
9. kord akhnutor ensméi wídentbhos:
10. khurt áknuthai únsmi wítunthmaz:
11. srĭd áznutĕ ẽsmí vídẽtmŭ:
12. šird ágnutai insméi vídintmas:
13. sart égnuthoi asmí gítan(th)bos:

1. a man, the master, makes the wool of the sheep
2. ħner, pótis, χowjom-ṛ wḷʔneħṃ
3. anér, pátis, háwjan-ar húlanan
4. ner, potis, owjom-ṛ wḹnām
5. nar, pátis, ávjam-ṛ vṛnām
6. anér, pótsis, ówjon-ar lānān
7. när, pats, ówjāp-är wlānām
8. ner, phótis, ówjom-ri wlənām
9. ner, pótis, ówjom-or lānam
10. ner, pháthiz, áwjan-aur wúlnōn
11. ner, pódĭs, óvjemĭ-rĭ vlĭnõ
12. ner, pats, ávjam-ir vìlnom
13. a(n)ír, phóthis, ówjã-ar gálanam

1. into a warm garment for himself.
2. swébhi chermóm wéstrom qṛnéuti.
3. sfébi wermán wéstran kurnúti.
4. sebhi chermóm westrom qṛneuti.
5. svábhi gharmám vástram kṛnáuti.
6. sephi thermón wéstron qernéuti.
7. säpi särmam wästram kärnóiti.
8. sébi germóm wéstrom qrunéuti.
9. sébhi ghwermúm wéstrom qornéuti.
10. síbi wárman wést(h)ran khwurnéuthi.
11. sĕbi germŭ véstrŭ črĭnjutĭ.
12. ébi garmám véstram kirnjáuti.
13. (k)íbi ĵermã gésthrã kharnójthi.

1. And the sheep has no wool”.
2. Xowjom-qe wḷhneħ ne ʔésti”.
3. Háwjan-ki húlana ne észi”.
4. Owjom-qe wḹnā ne esti”.
5. Ávjam-ka vṛnā na ásti”.
6. Ówjon-qe lānā ne ésti”.
7. Owjāp-ke wlānā nä ésti”.
8. Ówjom-k(h)e wlanā ne ésti”.
9. Ówjom-qe lāna ne ésti”.
10. Áwjan-ukh wúlnō ne ísti”.
11. Óvjemĭ-če vlĭna ne jázĭtĭ”.
12. Ávjam-ke vìlno ne ášti”.
13. Hóvjã-kh gálana ne ésthi”.

1. Having heard this, the sheep fled into the plain.
2. Tod kékluwos χowis ħégrom bhugét.
3. Tat kékluwas háwis ágran pugét.
4. Tod kékluwos owis agrom bhugét.
5. Tat sásruvas ávis áĵram ábhugat.
6. Tot kékluwos ówis ágron éphuget.
7. Tä käklewe ówi ākre bekät.
8. Tod kéluwos ówis ágrom bugét.
9. Tud kékluwos ówis ágrom phugít.
10. That khékhluwaz áwiz ákran bukéth.
11. To sésluvŭ óvĭs ágrŭ bugĭt.
12. Ta šéšluvas ávis ágram bugít.
13. Da khékhlugah hóvih ákrã ébuke(th).
 
The Phrygians were originally called Brygians, and their equivalent for Zeus is recorded as Bagaois, related to 'bog' in Slavic languages and 'bhag' in Indo-Iranian languages. Here is a link to where decipherments have been attempted with regard to the Phrygian language:

http://www.maravot.com/Phrygian.html

BABA: MEM EFAIS: PROITA FOST TIPA NA EPOS: SKENEM AM: EL AES



[Translation: Papa (Attis, also called Papas, husband of Cybele, Mater) of the breast, mammary? (L. mamma-ae; It. mammella; Fr. mamelle); alternatively, to the mother (It. mamma)? or the self, same (Fr. même) he spoke out (L. effor-fari; Etr. EFA, EFAN, EFAS, EFE): therefore, consequently (L. proinde and proin) of the stock, trunk, shaft (L. fossa-ae; It. fusto; Fr. fut; Sanskrit, yasti; stick, club, L. fustis-is, Etr. 8VST) of the model, figure on a wall, type (L. typus-i; It. tipo; Fr. type; Gr. typos, Polish, typ; Etr. TIPE, TIPES) indeed, truly (L. ne [nae]; Etr. NA) of the epic poem (L. epos): Skenem? (re: L. scio, scire, to know, understand; Etr. SCIS) I love, like (L. amo-are; Etr. AM, AMA, AMaPa, AMaPEN, AMAR, AME, AMEM, AMI, AMIE, AMO): the olives? (Gr. elaia) or alternatively, her (L. eius, illius; It. ella; Fr. elle, elles) bronze, metal (L. aes, aeris)] Note: See XE-12, E LAES in the context suggesting, "from Laius."
Phrygian phonology:

 
Delodephius said:
This I copied from a book called "Grammar of Modern Indo-European". I would take the reconstructions with a grain of salt, but it is still quite interesting to see how some linguists reconstructed the IE languages.
The reconstruction is definetly way off, but for what they knew back then compared to what is known now, I suppose they can be forgiven. It is interesting to take the below into consideration, which is the previous comparison for the word 'gold':
aurum (Latin)
aur (Romanian)
ar (Albanian)
oro (Italian)
ór (Irish-Celtic)

zar (Old Iranian)

salta (Thracian)
zalto (Proto-Slavic)
zelts (Latvian)
zlato (Macedonian)

gold (German)
guld (Dannish)
gull (Norwegian)
It would seem that the Balto-Slavic-Balkan, Indo-Iranian and Germanic proto languages once formed a common group before Germanic split and became a Centum language. It may also explain why Germanic shares some cognates with Thracian, in addition to the more obvious (and numerous) cognates it shares with Balto-Slavic. It would also support the assertion that Italic and Celtic languages belonged to a common group. Although it is a suggestion based on one example, many more can be found.
 
The town Edirne (Maced. Odrin) derives its name from the Roman Emperor Hadrian (by way of Hadrianopolis, Engl. Adrianople). It is located at the confluence of three rivers, one of which is the historically significant Marica. The original name of the town was Uskudama and comes from the Thracian words for 'water' (usku) and 'settlement' (dama) - the second word already having been discussed in a previous example on this thread (see 'damastini'). It has been suggested that the first component of the word developed as follows:

http://groznijat.tripod.com/thrac/thrac_4a2.html

PIE wed - Thracian ud -> udsko -> utsko -> usko - ultimately usku, probably with case ending u instead of o.

There appears to be a parallel in the Celtic word usce, which means the same. Also interesting, however, is the sk ending of the word, which resembles that of nouns in Slavic languages. Here are some possible Slavic comparisons:

Udsku-dama (Thracian)
Vodsku-dom (Slavic)
Vodskov-dom (Slavic)
Vodski-dom (Slavic)

The town of Uskudama became popularised by the name of Odrysia, which was a Greek rendition based on the Thracian tribal name that probably sounded more like Udrusi. The latter, in turn, derived from the Thracian word for an 'otter', which is a water animal, see comparison below:

Udro (PIE)
Udra (Thracian)
Ūdra (Baltic)
Vidra (Slavic)

Another Thracian tribal name was Bebrykes, and is also based on a type of animal, a 'beaver', see below comparison:

Bhebhrus (PIE)
Bebrus (Thracian)
Bebrus (Baltic)
Bebr (Slavic)

After palatalisation, the k at the end of the word could develop as Bebryk -> Bebrych -> Bebrytsi. A significant observation that can be made from all of the above is that there appears to be a trend among the Thracians in which they use the name of an animal to designate a tribal name. This lends further weight to the possibility regarding the Maduateni. After Slavic became the dominant linguistic branch in the Balkans and absorbed the related Paleo-Balkan languages, some words were replaced while some were retained in slightly altered forms.
 
Slovak,

These are the texts we've discussed in the past. Below are the two longest inscriptions that have survived in the Thracian language. The first is the golden ring from around the Plovdiv area, whereas the second is from the Preslav area, so it is probable that there is some dialectal differences.



Here is some further information on them:

http://groznijat.tripod.com/thrac/thrac_6.html
http://193.19.172.24/PUBLIC/IMAGES/...research/Publikacii/P_Dimitrov_13_01_2009.pdf

I have put them all in capital (Latin) letters in the below for easier comparison:

First:
ROLISTENEASNERENEATILTEANISKOARAZEADOMEANTILEZYPTAMIIERAZILTA

Second:
EBAR. ZESASNINETESAIGEK. A NBLABAIGN NYASNLETEDNYEDNEINDAKATR. S

There are some parts of both that appear common enough to possibly identify as words, such as ASN. For the purpose of clarification, this Thracian word means 'I, me', and developed as follows:

- eǵ’hom - Proto Indo-European
- eź’ham - Proto Balto-Slavic (and Paleo-Balkan)

The 'm' then changed to an 'n' at some point, so following on:

- jāzun - Proto Slavic (development of 'j' at the beginning of the word)
- asn - Thracian (devoiced z -> s, which seems to be common in some Thracian words)

Eventually, the 'n' was also dropped at the end of the word, so the surviving literary examples would thus be:

- jaz - Slovenian
- jas - Macedonian
- ja - Macedonian and other
- az - Macedonian and other
- aš - Lithuanian
- es - Latvian
 
Here is some information regarding the Thracian ring inscription:
In the same neighbouhood besides the ring there were found other items belonging to a burial – a golden diadem, a small golden spoon, two triangular golden plates, a broken bronze vessel, a round bronze mirror and a broken bronze bracelet. It was obvious that the golden ring belonged to the burial of a noble Thracian. The reading of the letters poses no difficulties but division of the text into words is uncertain. Up to now there appeared more than 20 translations of this text [See D. Detschew, Die thrakischen Sprachreste, Wien, 1957, pp. 567-582], none of them being commonly accepted. Here we list the interpretations of the Buglarians academicians D. Dechev and Vl. Georgiev.

D. Dechev proposed the following reading:

Text: Rolisteneas Nerenea tiltean esko Arazea domean Tilezupta mie erazilta
Translation: “I am Rolesteneas, a descendant of Nereneas. Tilezipta, an Arazian woman,
delivered me to the ground (i.e. buried me).”

Vl. Georgiev also thought that the ring was specially made for a solemn (three-days long) exposure of the deceased before he was buried. He also utilized the Herodotus’ account that some Thracian tribes had the custom when some noble Thracian dies, to bury with him one of his favourite wives. He proposed the following reading:

Text: Rolistene, as Nerenea Tiltea nesko arazea do mean tilezyptam, ie eraz elta
Translation: “Rolistene (=You, Rolisten), I, Nerenea Tiltea, die peaceful next to [you] my dear deceased,
who nourished (brough up) the children.”

Here is one example of how the words may be broken down:

ROLISTENE ASN, ERENEA TI, LTEA NISKO A RAZ EA DOME ANTI, LEZY, PTAMI IE RAZ I LTA
 
Even this example is open to some interpretation, such as the full stop being considered an 'O', and the 'II' symbol being considered an 'N', the '>' being considered as 'L' or 'Y'.




Slovak, we discussed this elsewhere a very long time ago, you made some of the following observations (quoted below) which seemed interesting:
This inscription is written on piece of stone resembling a tombstone. It was found in a graveyard. So, on it should be a text that is typically written on tombstones, like the name of the deceased, numbers: years, dates, or some form of a message. Note: One thing typical about grave inscriptions in the Balkans, especially the older ones from the first times when the Old Cyrillic was used, is that the message on the tombstone is in the 1st person singular, as if the dead man was talking of his fate.........

What I noticed is the word ΛΕΤ (let) which in most Slavic languages means 'year' or 'years' and then I noticed the ΕΔΝ (edn) which means 'one'.............The only thing that seem certain to me is ΕΔΝΕΝ-Ι-ΔΑΚΑ which definitely means 'eleven' in Thracian.
There may be two possibilities here. For the first, if we follow the logic you suggested regarding the numbers, dates, etc that are typical for a gravestone, then we could probably identify a few numbers:

ΛΕΤ (year) ΕΔΝΥ (one) ΕΔΝΕ-ΝΙ-ΔΑΚΑ** (eleven) TP (three)

**This breakdown seems to make more sense, as the Slavic word for 'eleven' comes from EDIN-NA-DESET, literally, 'one on ten'. Although the 'ten' in Thracian had not developed a satem reflex thus rendering it closer to Greek and Latin, the combination of words (if this is what it means in Thracian) to make 'eleven' resembles Slavic more, as seen below:

- Ednenidaka (Thracian, one-on-ten)
- Edinadeset (Slavic, one-on-ten)
- Endeka (Greek, one-ten)
- Undecim (Latin, one-ten)


The second possibility could be a dedication from a parent if we consider the word ΔΑΚΑTP to mean 'daughter', in which case it could be broken down as such:

ΛΕΤΕ (this year) ΔΝΥ (this day) ΕΔΝΕ (one) ΝΙ (our) ΔΑΚΑΤP** (daughter)

**If it developed something like dhughter -> dakater -> deshter.

The whole sentence could be:

NY ΑΣΝ ΛΕΤΕ ΔΝY ΕΔΝΕ ΝΙ ΔΑΚΑΤΡΟ ΣΟΕΒΑ, ΡΟΖΕΣ ΑΣΝ, Η ΝΕ ΤΕΣΑ ΙΓΕ ΚΟΑ ΝΒYΑ ΒΑΗΓΝ, or
NY ΑΣΝ ΛΕΤ ΕΔΝY ΕΔΝΕΝΙΔΑΚΑ ΤΡΟ, ΣΟΕΒΑ ΡΟΖΕΣ ΑΣΝ Η ΝΕ ΤΕΣΑ ΙΓΕ ΚΟΑ ΝΒYΑ ΒΑΗΓΝ, or
NY ΑΣΝ ΛΕΤ ΕΔΝY ΕΔΝΕΝΙΔΑΚΑΤ, ΡΟΣΟΕΒΑ ΡΟΖΕΣ ΑΣΝ, Η ΝΕ ΤΕΣΑ ΙΓΕ ΚΟΑ ΝΒYΑ ΒΑΗΓΝ.

I may be way off here and all of the below could be wrong, but would like to see your thoughts on if:

- the ending of -EBA is related to DEBA, as in the Thracian placenames MURIDEBA, ITADEBA, etc?
- ΙΓΕ is related to the relative pronoun in Slavic іжє?
- NBYA is related to PIE nébhos, Slavic nebo, etc?
- ΡΟΖΕΣ is related to rozh//ruzh for a 'rose' or rod/rozhd for 'birth'?
 
Paleo-Balkan languages, like Balto-Slavic, share a close affinity with Indo-Iranian. In addition to the grammar, there are several cognate words such as sindu, drava, etc. Some more Thracian names which may have possible connections to Balto-Slavic are place name Bisalta - 'by/beside gold', personal name Thamyris - 'give peace/greatness', and tribal name Sycaeboae - 'sword fighters'. The first example can be pretty much confirmed, the second two require further research.

Another interesting place name is Drabescus, which is the ancient name of modern Drama, located in the Macedonian part of today's Greece. It may be related to other placenames further north, such as Drava in Serbia and Drawa in Poland. A medieval fortress named after the latter was known as Drawsko, which is very close to Dravsko < Dravesko (Drabescus). Another with a similar ending is Bromiscus.

http://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=Perseus:text:1999.04.0064:entry=bromiscus-geo
BROMISCUS (Βρομίσκος), a town of Mygdonia in Macedonia, near the river by which the waters of the lake Bolbe flow into the Strymonic gulf. (Thuc. 4.103.) It was either upon the site of this place or of the neighbouring Arethusa that the fortress of Rentine was built, which is frequently mentioned by the Byzantine historians. (Tafel, Thessalonica, p. 68.) Stephanus calls the town Bormiscus, and relates that Euripides was here torn to death by dogs; but another legend supposes this event to have taken place at Arethusa, where the tomb of the poet was shown. [ARETHIUSA, No. 6.]
 
personal name Thamyris - 'give peace/greatness', and tribal name Sycaeboae - 'sword fighters'. The first example can be pretty much confirmed, the second two require further research.
Thamyris would be a cognate of Slavic root *da - give and myr - peace, later mir. Suffix -is evolved in Proto-Slavic into short -ǐ and later was lost in Post-OCS period.
If sycae is the sword sica, then boae most likely means warrior or fighter, from a pre-iotified form of the root *boj - battle, fight.
 
Thanks for the input Slovak, those Thracian examples were too similar to ignore. There are, of course, other matters to consider, such as dialectal differences, spelling differences, etc, depending on the word or author. That is why syca and sica are quite possibly the same word with a slightly different spelling, just like the possibility with myr and mir.

Have you given any more thought to one of the earlier posts regarding the Thracian inscription on the gravestone?
ΛΕΤ (year) ΕΔΝΥ (one) ΕΔΝΕ-ΝΙ-ΔΑΚΑ** (eleven) TP (three)

**This breakdown seems to make more sense, as the Slavic word for 'eleven' comes from EDIN-NA-DESET, literally, 'one on ten'. Although the 'ten' in Thracian had not developed a satem reflex thus rendering it closer to Greek and Latin, the combination of words (if this is what it means in Thracian) to make 'eleven' resembles Slavic more, as seen below:

- Ednenidaka (Thracian, one-on-ten)
- Edinadeset (Slavic, one-on-ten)
- Endeka (Greek, one-ten)
- Undecim (Latin, one-ten)


The second possibility could be a dedication from a parent if we consider the word ΔΑΚΑTP to mean 'daughter', in which case it could be broken down as such:

ΛΕΤΕ (this year) ΔΝΥ (this day) ΕΔΝΕ (one) ΝΙ (our) ΔΑΚΑΤP** (daughter)
 
If sycae is the sword sica, then boae most likely means warrior or fighter, from a pre-iotified form of the root *boj - battle, fight.
Here are some paragraphs from a wiki article about the Boii:
The Boii (Latin plural, singular Boius; Greek Βόϊοι) were one of the most prominent ancient Celtic tribes of the later Iron Age, attested at various times in Cisalpine Gaul (northern Italy), Pannonia (Hungary and its western neighbours), in and around Bohemia, and Transalpine Gaul. In addition the archaeological evidence indicates that in the 2nd century BC Celts expanded from Bohemia through the Kłodzko valley into Silesia, now part of Poland.........

The "warrior" derivation was adopted by the linguist, Julius Pokorny, who presented it as being from Indo-European *bhei(ə)-, *bhī-, "hit;" however, not finding any Celtic names close to it (except for the Boii), he adduces examples somewhat more widely from originals further back in time: phohiio-s-, a Venetic personal name; Boioi, an Illyrian tribe; Boiōtoi, a Greek tribal name ("the Boeotians") and a few others.[6] Boii would be from the o-grade of *bhei-, which is *bhoi-. Such a connection is possible if the original form of Boii belonged to a tribe of Proto-Indo-European speakers long before the time of the historic Boii. The Celtic tribe of central Europe must in that case be a final daughter population of a linguistically diversifying ancestor tribe...........
The Boii originated from an area which could be identified as historically Balto-Slavic territory, and if Pokorny's suggestion is to be accepted, then their name is also cognate with the Slavic word 'boi' which also means 'fight'. And I don't agree with the last line in the above quote which suggests that all peoples with a similar name originally belonged to the same tribe.
 
Punic was a Semitic language spoken by the people in north African places such as Carthage and a number of Mediterranean islands (even the name Hispania is said to be Punic). These people were originally Phoenician colonists from Tyre. Both Carthage and Macedonia had experienced interaction with the Greek language, and both were taken over by Rome around the same time. Their conquest introduced Latin as the official language and made the influence of Greek even more prevalent. Despite this, however, the Punic language continued to survive in Carthage throughout the Roman period. According to Augustine of Hippo the Punic language was still spoken in Carthage during his time in the 5th century AD:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Punic_language

And if the Punic language is rejected by you, you virtually deny what has been admitted by most learned men, that many things have been wisely preserved from oblivion in books written in the Punic tongue. Nay, you ought even to be ashamed of having been born in the country in which the cradle of this language is still warm.
They were taken over soon after this by the Vandals and possibly some Slavic-speaking counterparts (wiki cites Mallory & Adams "Encyclopedia of Indo-European Culture), but were back in the hands of the Roman Empire after Belisarius and others defeated them. That remained the situation until the period between 640AD to 670AD, when the Arabs conquered the region and the rest of north Africa.

The Arabic language was introduced to the region and quickly adopted by the local population - it is only from then that the Punic language becomes completely extinct. Given that it lasted through the influence of Greek and Latin, it is highly probable that the pre-existing commonality between Arabic and Punic as Central Semitic languages facilitated the rise of the former and the disappearance of the latter.

This raises an interesting parallel which can be see when compared to the extinction of Paleo-Balkan languages during the introduction of Slavic. It is reasonable to assume that a similar process took place, where speakers of languages such as Thracian adopted Slavic more readily than either Greek or Latin because the first two belonged to the same linguistic family.
 
For reference, there is a Thracian placename called 'Zaldapa', which is a compound word stemming from 'zalda' (gold, in Macedonian 'zlato') and 'apa' (water). There is a Macedonian word which may be related to 'apa', and that is 'kapi', which can mean 'drip' or 'wash'. This Thracian name must have been given to an area where there is an abundance of water, a lake, river, etc.
 
The Phrygian words 'gordion' and 'granicus' look very similar to Macedonian (and other Slavic) words such as 'grad/gorod' (city) and granitsa (border), as do 'bedu' and 'bagaios' with 'voda' (water) and 'boga' (god). Another possible Phrygian word that I found which looks identical to one that we use today is 'zagora'. According to Arrian in the Periplus Ponti Euxini:
And from there to Sinope is 40 stades; the Sinopeans are colonists of the Milesians. From Sinope to Karousa, 150; there is an anchorage for ships. From there to Zagora is again another 150; from there to the river Halys is 30.
 
Sound theory SoM. I think we can add maduat to the list of the deciphered Thracian words, as well as its components madu - honey and ati - to eat.
Further to the above, there is also the Illyrian personal name of Madena which is probably related. As previously mentioned in various threads, a number of other Illyrian names appear to have links to names in Slavic languages, such as Glavus (Glavoš) and Grabos (Graboš). The latter would then mean 'oak' and be cognate with the below:

grabh - (Proto Indo-European)
grab - (Slavic languages)
grabis (Baltic; Prussian)
grabion (Anc. Macedonian)
 
Back
Top