Pelister
New member
SoM, you're compartmentalising the relevant points and missing the picture in its totality.
I’ll start with Indigeneity itself. Indigeneity is largely a political construct, and we can conclude this from the fact, which you rightly point out, everyone has migrated to their "ancestral" land at some point. Within that context, Indigeneity, as I understand it, has varying definitions to a degree, but generally rests on two key features.
The first is the concept of ‘first peoples’. Indigenous groups are usually considered to be the original inhabitants (or more specifically, directly descendent from original inhabitants or a combination of original inhabitants) of the territory in question.
Secondly, and this is related to the first, the culture and identity of Indigenous groups is formed within, and in some cases directly influenced by, the territory in question.
In this discussion, the territory in question is Kurdistan, not Anatolia. The Kurds meet the criteria above, the Turks do not. The Kurds are considered to be descendent from original inhabitants of the Kurdish region. Further, their culture and identity originally formed in Kurdistan.
The Turks on the other hand, are a settler group and we know from the historical record that their origins are in Central Asia. Turkish culture and identity originally formed in Central Asia and they are largely descendent from the original peoples of Central Asia. Therefore, they can be considered Indigenous to Central Asia.
There are many anthropologists that talk about the deep connections that indigenous people have with the landscape, which they argue can only come from a very long occupation of the territory. It is manifested in totemic rituals and emblems, in places and in representations. For example, in the Macedonian tradition there are certain "hidden places" in the landscape, usually the most beutiful, which are imbued with "magic". It might be a beuatiful glade, a shady spot under a tree by a river. These are places of sickness "and" healing, and it is a common belief that they are the resting place of an ancient warrior (male and female).
Shh ... don't tell the New Greeks. Before we know it they be stealing the tradition.