Coolski
New member
http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2012/apr/17/tim-berners-lee-monitoring-internet?CMP=twt_gu
The above article discusses the new measures being investigated by the UK to introduce internet monitoring.
I'm assume that 99% of people are strongly against this type of behaviour, and liken it to the undemocratic, dictatorial regimes that the west so often criticises.
Why then do we have these self proclaimed bastions of freedom such as the USA demanding that Google hands over sensitivie and private information from their servers, and the UK taking it to another level with a government controlled monitoring system. It's the type of behaviour that I think is very serious.
Prior to 2000, it was quite easy for a government and its associated media machine to push all sorts of propaganda out there, and for everyone, even the "free thinkiers" to accept it as truth.
Since then, the development of user-generated content, a two-way interaction between websites and users generally referred to as web 2.0, has given people a taste of real freedom. This has allowed the promotion of truth and lies at the same time, but generally speaking, it has been a revolutionary platform in terms of freedom of information.
I just want to point something out regarding one aspect of this freedom of information which we've had a glimpse of.
Remember the yugoslav wars, most wars prior to 2000? Most information was controlled by few media channels reporting news according to the political interests of the countries/players behind the channels. There were very few disputes or noticeable challenges to the information being transmitted to viewers. It was a one-way means of communication, and without the resources and coverage of a media outlet, one person with a contradictory source was unlikely to promote counter-arguments to what was being uniformly reported. In terms of public opinion in the west, those wars were considered black and white. Good vs Evil. If the good prevailed, success, if not, failure.
Fast-forward to the latest Iraq and Afghanistan wars and we see a totally different picture. The classic style of propaganda reporting has been exposed by the freedoms available in web 2.0. It is not as easy for politicians to lie to the public and expect to get away with it, as there is always someone with a camera in their pocket and an instant internet connection that can expose what is really happening. That is, in a world with real-time first-hand sources, traditional power brokers are powerless.
Let's go even further and see what happened in the north african revolutions in which twitter and facebook were instrumental in empowering populations to take control of their country.
Wikileaks is another case which shows just how free the "free world" is, and that case deserves a whole discussion on its own.
To comment on something closer to home, let's consider the impact of freedom on the web on our ability as Macedonians to share and discuss information. We know that most institutions wouldn't publish information that would question the fundamental beliefs in balkan history regarding Macedonia, and we sure as hell don't have any powerful political allies that could push our cause in the media or internaltional politics. We would be crippled without the freedoms we're enjoying on the web.
These kinds of tools that enable the freedom of information and empower everybody with the ability to publish information scare traditional power brokers. Their strategies to control these tools scare me. My question is, are citizens in the west going to sit on their hands and let this kind of thing happen?
Has anybody seen any significant acts of resistance against the attempts of western governments to control the internet?
The above article discusses the new measures being investigated by the UK to introduce internet monitoring.
I'm assume that 99% of people are strongly against this type of behaviour, and liken it to the undemocratic, dictatorial regimes that the west so often criticises.
Why then do we have these self proclaimed bastions of freedom such as the USA demanding that Google hands over sensitivie and private information from their servers, and the UK taking it to another level with a government controlled monitoring system. It's the type of behaviour that I think is very serious.
Prior to 2000, it was quite easy for a government and its associated media machine to push all sorts of propaganda out there, and for everyone, even the "free thinkiers" to accept it as truth.
Since then, the development of user-generated content, a two-way interaction between websites and users generally referred to as web 2.0, has given people a taste of real freedom. This has allowed the promotion of truth and lies at the same time, but generally speaking, it has been a revolutionary platform in terms of freedom of information.
I just want to point something out regarding one aspect of this freedom of information which we've had a glimpse of.
Remember the yugoslav wars, most wars prior to 2000? Most information was controlled by few media channels reporting news according to the political interests of the countries/players behind the channels. There were very few disputes or noticeable challenges to the information being transmitted to viewers. It was a one-way means of communication, and without the resources and coverage of a media outlet, one person with a contradictory source was unlikely to promote counter-arguments to what was being uniformly reported. In terms of public opinion in the west, those wars were considered black and white. Good vs Evil. If the good prevailed, success, if not, failure.
Fast-forward to the latest Iraq and Afghanistan wars and we see a totally different picture. The classic style of propaganda reporting has been exposed by the freedoms available in web 2.0. It is not as easy for politicians to lie to the public and expect to get away with it, as there is always someone with a camera in their pocket and an instant internet connection that can expose what is really happening. That is, in a world with real-time first-hand sources, traditional power brokers are powerless.
Let's go even further and see what happened in the north african revolutions in which twitter and facebook were instrumental in empowering populations to take control of their country.
Wikileaks is another case which shows just how free the "free world" is, and that case deserves a whole discussion on its own.
To comment on something closer to home, let's consider the impact of freedom on the web on our ability as Macedonians to share and discuss information. We know that most institutions wouldn't publish information that would question the fundamental beliefs in balkan history regarding Macedonia, and we sure as hell don't have any powerful political allies that could push our cause in the media or internaltional politics. We would be crippled without the freedoms we're enjoying on the web.
These kinds of tools that enable the freedom of information and empower everybody with the ability to publish information scare traditional power brokers. Their strategies to control these tools scare me. My question is, are citizens in the west going to sit on their hands and let this kind of thing happen?
Has anybody seen any significant acts of resistance against the attempts of western governments to control the internet?