Agamoi Thytai said:
That's why i consider your "specialist" Borza as a mediocre.........
Spare me, your assertions about Borza are extremely comical, and I am no particular mood for jokes.
But even if we accept for the sake of the argument that Herodotus refers only to the current events.....
Accept it, because that is what it is. He had a perfect opportunity to mention the Macedonians as Greeks already subjugated at that time, yet he didn't - as Borza correctly highlights.
“These Thessalians are wise men; this, then, WAS THE PRIMARY REASON FOR THEIR PRECAUTION, LONG BEFORE when they changed to a better mind, for they perceived that their country would be easily and speedily conquerable.
http://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/...:section=2
Here fits perfectly the passage about "the sons of Aleus,the first Greeks who surrendered to Xerxes"
How does that contradict what Borza says about the Thessalians being the first Greeks to submit to the Persians? Doesn't it corroborate what he says?
Since they speak the same language, they should end their disputes by means of heralds or messengers, or by any way rather than fighting; if they must make war upon each other, they should each discover where they are in the strongest position and make the attempt there. THE GREEK CUSTOM THEN IS NO GOOD;AND WHEN I MARCHED AS FAR AS THE LAND OF MACEDONIA,IT HAD NOT COME INTO THEIR MINDS TO FIGHT".
http://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/...:section=2
Well,who were those Greeks whom Mardonius met in Macedonia?
Probably Hellenic colonists given that his march through Macedonia would have been in close proximity to the coast, and therefore the shortest distance back to Asia. These would be the same Hellenic colonists who had their homes burned to the ground by Phillip and the Macedonians a century or so later.
"This was the stated end of their expedition, but they intended to subdue AS MANY OF THE GREEK CITIES as they could. Their fleet subdued the Thasians, who did not so much as lift up their hands against it; their land army ADDED THE MACEDONIANS to the slaves that they had already, for all the nations nearer to them than Macedonia had been made subject to the Persians before this".
http://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/...:section=1
This reference to Greek cities relates to Thasos and the Greek colony there, it doesn't imply that the Macedonians are Greek, nor was Macedonia ever a Greek city. A poor attempt at manipulation, and you have the audacity to question Borza's knowledge and interpretation....please.
Wild assumptions!Herodotus was there,Borza not.
A number of Borza's assertions are corroborated by others, and he is highly regarded by several of his peers where it concerns ancient Macedonian history. Your simplistic approach is to take everything at face value in the hope it results favouring your narrative, the problem with that is, the minute you decide to show some consistency you end up having to have to believe in dragons, fairies and Medusa. Do you believe in Medusa? If an individual came up to you today and said that he is descended from a mythical figure (akin to Medusa), and that was his basis for claiming 'Greekness', would you believe him? Put things into perspective and apply some logic.
That's why he stated they were of Doric stock being himself a Dorian.
Nowhere does Herodotus state that the Macedonians are of "Doric stock", that's just a figment that your imagination has conjured, and nothing more.
Even if we accept Borza's claim that the story of Alexander's participation in the Olympic games was his own invention,it's not acceptable for supposed specialist to ignore that besides Alexander I,two other Argead kings participated and won in the Olumpics:Archelaos around 400 BC and Philip II in 356 BC:
They were the only Macedonian kings that bothered to interfere on a higher level in Hellenic society from 498 BC to 359 BC, when Phillip assumed the throne. That's 3 people in a period of 139 years. And they were not even accepted into the games as Macedonians, but as Heraclidae, ie; descendants of a Heracles, a myth. Do you disagree?
I don't know how he refered to himself but most sources call him Poseidippus the Macedonian:
They're all modern sources, not contemporary or near-contemporary.
Note also this:Athenaus wrote in "Deipnosofists" that Poseidippus describes in his comedies the cooks as slaves because it was the Macedonians that introduced it to the Greek world the cooks as slaves:
Where does it say the Macedonians introduced it to the "Greek" world? I don't see Poseidippus being specifically identified as a Macedonian either, is there more to the passage on the links that elaborates?
I agree,some Romans may have been described as Philhellenes,fonds of Greek culture,litterature e.t.c. and even honoured as such by Greeks,but no Roman ever declared himself to be a Hellene.
It was more than just fondness, it was participation and imitation, not too unlike the Macedonians. Hadrian's nickname was the '
Greekling', Titus Pomponius gave himself the nickname of '
Atticus', while Plutarch remarks that the Greeks saw in Titus Flaminius '
a Greek in his voice and language'. These are but a few examples of the Romans' infatuation with ancient Hellenic culture at the time. They picked up from where the Macedonians left.
I don't see any contradiction here.Polyaenus expressed first his regional (Macedonian) and later his ethnic (Greek) identity.The latter always overshadows the former.
You're applying that same poor revisionism, again. Where does he say 'regional'? Polyaenus says Macedonian
nation, and equates it with the Persians. He then goes on to make a clear distinction between Macedonians and Greeks. There is no confusion for anybody other than those that deliberately avoid the truth.
As for the distinction between "Greeks" and "Macedonians",there are numerous similar cases of Athenians speaking of "Athenians attacking Hellenes", of Thebans mentioning "Hellenes fighting against Thebans" and so on,so that's not a solid proof.
Nowhere does it compare Hellenes vs Athenians or Hellenes vs Thebans as opposing nations. There are several other varying examples that can be produced to further corroborate that point, which don't have equivalents with Athenians or Thebans.
Nothing,i just couldn't find any mention of the words "Greci" or "Hellenes" in ethnic sense from that time.However,as i said in some older post of mine,it would be equally difficult to find any mention of ethnic French,Germans,English e.t.c during the same time
The Hellenic identity disappeared after Christianity spread throughout the Roman Empire, that's why you can't find reference to it. It was a term frowned upon. The French and English nations (and languages) were formed and came to be formed well after the disappearance of the Hellenes; they don't claim an undisturbed line to antiquity so your analogy is incorrect.
The image is very clear:There were Greeks and Slavs,he doesn't speak of Greek-speaking Slavs.................It is also recorded by many other Byzantine authors and well known that most of those Slavs were transported by the Byzantine emperors to the interior of Asia Minor while Greek colonists from that area and Sicily were settled in their place.The rest was Hellenized in the cource of the centuries.
He doesn't have to speak of Greek-speaking Slavs, his other assertions, like that of Hellas being completely Slavicised, speaks volumes. Their subsequent adoption of the Greek language resulted from the Roman identity and Christianisation - not "Hellenisation", a term that would have been detested by Porphyrogenitus and his contemporaries. And those 'Slavs' that were transported to Asia Minor left plenty of their kinsmen in the Peloponnese to continue applying their own place-names in abundance for centuries later. Which Greek colonists from Asia were settled where? Are you sure you aren't referring to the Armenian populations settled in the Balkans?
This abstract here is really a mess and that's why i did not quoted it.
You didn't quote it become it doesn't sit well with you far-fetched interpretations. There is no confusion at all. The Greeks are those that speak Greek as their main tongue, and in that way they are differentiated from the 'Slavs' - it is a linguistic identity, not an 'ethnic' one. The Hellenes are merely those that (once) followed pagan gods, and aren't directly tied to one or the other.
How do you think is it that all the Balkan Slavs and the Russians as well call us "Grtsi" and not "Romans"?Why do you think medieval texts writen in Serbian,Bulgarian and Russian speak mostly of Greeks instead of Romans?If Byzantines themselves had not used the term "Greki" how did all the above peoples become acquainted with it?
At the time of the disruptions of the 6th century AD, Latin was still the official language of the Roman Empire in the east. This means that both Balkan natives and invaders from the Danube and beyond (at that time) were more accustomed with the term used in Latin, hence, they called your language Greek, like most others. This identity was later applied by outsiders to all citizens of East Rome as a result of Greek being the official language. It is only the Greek-speakers themselves who chose to identify their own language as Roman, discarding the term Hellene and rejecting the term Greek; such was their affection for the foreign imperial term.
Your theory doesn't hold water,given that Latins used to call Byzantines "Graeci" and their empire "imperium Graecorum" in order to reject their claims as inheritors of the old Roman empire.So why should they adopt at that time an ethnic name which their arch-rivals applied to them in an almost derogatory manner,if their incentive was only their hatred of Latins and the need to face off Latin imperialism,as you believe?
Who is "they", a handful of nobles or educated types? If by "they" you mean Greek-speaking people in general, then they didn't apply any 'ethnic' name. Those few that did toy with the idea, were using the term 'Hellene', and not 'Greek'.
The term "Hellene" was not always used as synonumous for "pagan" in the Bible,some times it's used with its ethnic meaning.
St Paul almost always used Hellene in comparison to Jew in a religious manner, for example -
There is neither Jew nor Hellene, slave nor free, male nor female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus. In the Gospel of Mark 7:26 - "
The woman was a Hellene, a Syrophœnician by nation; and she besought him that he would cast forth the devil out of her daughter. The nationality/ethnicity of the woman is stated to be Syrophœnician, by her religion she is a Hellene. Interestingly, it is not 'Hellene' but 'Heathen' which is used in Ulfilas's Gothic, Wycliffe and Coverdale. Where is the term 'Hellene' used in an ethnic manner?
Thus Byzantine authors prefered sometimes the term "Graikoi",when it was neseccary to emphasize one's ethnic origin:
http://books.google.com/books?id=O5J...raikoi&f=false
This is one east Roman author, and the term 'Graikoi' is in reference to the Greek-speakers from Italy in the western 'sphere', not those in traditional east Roman territories such as the Balkans and Anatolia, where Greek-speakers identified as Romans.
I asked for an example where Michael Palaeologos calls himself emperor of the Greeks, not a modern passage lacking citation. Is there any contemporary text or document where Michael referred to himself by the term 'Greek' or not?
Too many pebbles to be considered as triffles,i would add.
Hardly. I was being generous, because over the space of 2,000 years they are more like dust particles than pebbles.
That's irrelevant,what matters here is whether he self-identified as Hellene.
He does identify as a Hellene, an absolute rarity among the millions living in the same empire during that period. My point is still very relevant to you though, as his definition of Hellenic living space doesn't include Macedonia, which renders him useless to the cause you're pursuing here as a Greek at a Macedonian forum.
Commoners in medieval time usually didn't leave any records,writings e.t.c. not to mention that more than half were illiterate.It is the intelligentsia that left such stuff in every society,so we have to draw our conclusions only by this very limited material.
They may not have left many records but their actions and deeds were recorded by others.
There is no record of a collective Hellenic identity, you would even be hard-pressed to find the people of the Hellas Theme referred to as Hellenes. Your dozen or so people don't count as
the 'intelligentsia', this is merely your attempt at giving coherence to a few statements made over a period of 2,000 years.
If you add to the history of classical Athens that "he called contemporary Greeks descendands of men both great and wise",it's not hard to imagine whom he considered as his ancestors.
All I see is a secondary source. Do you have his actual quote? What term does he use for Greeks?
I don't see any confusion.On the contrary,i see that more educated Greeks started to clarify this misunderstanding to their fellow illiterate compatriots
That's because you're confused yourself. Hellenes WERE Idolaters and pagans. This is the interpretation of the Bible and of Christian society for nearly 2,000 years.
I doubt there did exist in late 18th century-early 19th century any Macedonians,Albanians,Vlachs,let alone Gypsies who used the word "Romios" for self-identification.
Generally speaking, from the 19th century and prior, all Christians of the Rum Millet in the Ottoman Empire were referred to as Romans (Rumlar) officially and internally. Externally (mainly by the west) they were referred to as Greeks - for the previously stated reasons relating to religion, location and the main language of the (eastern) church. Self-identification, however, is another matter. Of all the non-Latin members of the Rum Millet, it is only the Greek-speakers who assume this generic Roman label as something specific in reference to their language and people.
That's again irrelevant to the topic.It's the view of an 19th century Brittish author,however what matters here is what some educated people in Greece thought of their language and how they called it in 16th century.
That is the same author who cites your source, so it is relevant, and pertinent. Those “educated people” who made such statements, when “
taken collectively, cannot, in fact, be so properly called an individual people, as a religious sect………”. Period. For all you know Zygomalas and Cabasilas could be Albanians, like so many other ‘Greeks’ at the time.
Hardly. You reference to a few educated types says very little about the collective sentiment of their Albanian kinsmen, who were happy to watch the English take archaeological artefacts from ancient ruins during Ottoman times, without protest. Without the Great Powers, there would be no Greece or Greeks - as they are known today.
Isn't it strange that only the other athletes protested against Alexander's participation and not the Hellanodikai,who were the main rersponsible to check whether an athlete fulfilled the criterion of Greek origin?
Your theories are strange. Their cause for protest is because they knew he wasn’t a Hellene, and not because of some perceived ‘threat’ to their sporting valour. Alexander’s acceptance to the games is also highly dubious given that his name appears nowhere on the records of that Olympiad.
Athenian hegemonism,which was mainly expressed at that time through Demosthenes and he himself in particular didn't actually give a shit about the "Hellenic cause".All what they really cared was to restore Athenian hegemony,this was their further aim and real "cause".
The assertions about Demosthenes’ sentiments based on your own misguided attempt to deny the distinction between Macedonians and Hellenes are becoming entertaining. But, let’s say for argument’s sake, that Demosthenes didn’t care for the ‘Hellenic cause’ (nice selection of words by the way, to distinguish it from the Macedonian cause). Nearly the WHOLE of Hellas did care, and they supported Demosthenes in an Athenian-led struggle of Hellenes against the Macedonians. What were they then, a pack of morons following a single moron? Or maybe, just maybe, the Hellenes united against the common Macedonian foe, as is evidenced in sources from antiquity.
However there was a pro-Macedonian fraction too in Athenian political scene and in other cities too,like Corinth who didn't view Macedonians as barbarians.
What makes you say that Corinth didn’t view the Macedonians in the same way that other Hellenes did?
Not even in the time of the Persian wars was made such fuss by any Athenian politician against the "barbarian invaders".
The Macedonian conquest of Greece differs markedly to the efforts made by the Persians, and there are several factors to consider, like Macedonia’s proximity to Greece, her rise as a powerful state in the same continent, Phillip’s policies and alliances, etc.
Borza's favourite sport is certainly self-contradiction:
http://www.google.com/search?q=there...A1&tbo=1&hl=el
The quote you keep repeating in the link, where Borza states that there is “
no reason to deny the Macedonians’ own tradition about their early kings and the migration of the Makedones” – it goes on to say the following (which you conveniently left out) – “
We have already suggested that a branch of those highlanders, the Argeadae, may have migrated out of the Haliacmon basin into the piedmont of northern Pieria”. The migration that Borza refers to is from Haliacmon in Macedonia, and not Argos in the Peloponnese! It would seem that your favourite sport is manipulation and blatant fabrications.
Any specific names?I can't recall any Thracian,Illyrian,Paeonian e.t.c. claiming to be Greek in 490 BC.
I never said they claimed to be Greek, I said they claimed a heritage from mythical figures (inaccurately) considered to be ‘Hellenic’. Scythians did it, and so did the Persians. Have you actually read all of Herodotus’ works, or do you read only those extracts that appear to be beneficial for your cause? The mythical fiction is the sole basis for some Macedonian kings claiming kinship with certain ‘Hellenic’ figures from the past. There is absolutely nothing else that essentially connects them to the society of Hellenes prior to Alexander I, aside from a brief citation from Hesiod, which is again, in reference to mythical events.
I don't need too.The translation "old racial rivalry" is wrong,ask any Classic scholar and you'll see.
The sources on all of your links are word for word the exact same, which means that they have been copied from one another. Nevertheless, “
racial rivalry between Greek and Macedonian” or “
strife between the Grecians and Macedonians, concerning the honour of their respective nations”, still spells the same thing - Macedonians and Greeks are two separate and perpetually distinct entities (nations, tribes, races, whatever), with a high degree of mutual animosity towards each other, hence Arrian’s quote.
So, in total, how many people identified (or were identified) as Hellenes from the spread of Christianity till the end of the 18th century? 15? 20? One for every century? Two for every century? This is what you base the continuity of a Hellenic identity on?