Soldier of Macedon
Senior Member
The prevailing language in the markets and shopping centres of Australia is English, are you trying to tell me that all of the Macedonians, Greeks, Vietnamese, Ethiopians and Samoans who speak this common English language are all "culturally" English and can lay claim to Henry the VIII? This is a reason for the modern Greek to claim some Armenians and Slavic-speakers from the Medieval period as 'ancestors', because of the common language used?The Byzantine Empire was as multi-ethnic as the Roman Empire. However, the prevailing language and culture were Greek/and Greco-Roman and Latin/Roman respectively regardless of a person's ethnic background.
So? During this very same period, the East Romans (Who never called themselves Byzantines or Greek) referred to the West Romans as Latins, despite the fact that the kings and a large part of the population were undoubtedly Germanic-speakers. That sort of leaves the 'Greek' theory in the pile of unrealistic where it belongs. Westerners used the term 'Greek' for citizens of East Rome, for Eastern Christians and the Eastern (Orthodox) Church, there are several accounts of the Russian Church being referred to as the 'Greek' Church. There is no 'ethnic' connection to the modern Greek people who seem to enjoy usurping the former use of the term 'Greek' for eveything it is worth, whether related or not.With regard to how Greek the Byzantine Empire was, I will say that after the coronation of Charlemagne in 800AD as "Holy Roman Emperor", the kingdoms in Western Europe typically referred to the "Byzantine" Empire as Empire of the Greeks and the Byzantine Emperor as Emperor of the Greeks. Of course this annoyed greatly the Byzantine rulers who saw themselves as the true and legitimate heirs to the Romans.
Show me a credible contemporary (or near) source that refers to Palaiologos as of "ethnic Greek" and "ethnic Serb" extraction.With regard to the last emperor of Byzantium (Constantine Palaiologos) I never recall reading he was of Armenian extract, but instead of Greek (father's side) and Serbian (mother's side) background.
Well then Greeks today have a false picture of history, and you have just contradicted yourself, for earlier you clearly make mention of the multi-ethnic character of East Rome and now you are trying to claim all of her history for the mere nation of the modern Greeks? I don't think so. The Italians can claim the original Romans as they were their Latin ancestors and it was they who began the state which turned into an empire. However, they cannot claim the Roman Empire in all of its glory and history, they cannot claim the Balkan and Germanic rulers of later periods, as Rome was much more than just Italy.Greeks today seen themselves as the inheritors of Byzantine Empire owning to it predominately Greek language and culture, just as the Italians see themselves as the inheritors of the Roman Empire, the Turks to the Ottoman Empire, and the Arabs to the Arabian Caliphate Empire.
Language yes, but what makes the culture 'Greek' in the modern sense you would like to interpret it today? The culture of East Rome, although drawing much from previous Greek and Macedonian civilizations and the native populations, was nevertheless Roman to begin with, and was later mixed with Eastern Christianity. By what right do the modern Greeks claim this empire or its culture as 'theirs'? Because of the official language of the state? Meaning that all the Germanic rulers and their people in West Rome were Italians because they used Latin as an official language? Do modern Italians claim the deeds of the Germanic rulers in West Rome?In all cases the Empires were multi-ethnic, but there was a predominate language and culture in all of them.
By the way, using 'Hellenism' in the context of the East Roman CHRISTIAN state reveals how you yourself may be out of your league with this topic, of course, you can prove me otherwise by showing me a chronology of all the examples of the word 'Hellenism' during the life of East Rome, along with all of the people who self-identified as 'Hellenes'.
I eagerly await. If you cannot provide this (which I know you cannot), please cease using the term 'Hellenism' in relation to an East Roman Empire that despised anything 'Hellenic' as devil-worshipping.