Coolski
New member
Pelister said:Here's your original post. I pointed out to you to look at the response in this thread ! You were assuming that when people use the term "Macedonian for the Macedonians" they mean it in a racist way, that is, a Macedonia for no one else. The responses in this thread completely shatter your assumption. That is "not" what people mean by it, when they say it. Now, you say that you are certain that is what some people mean when they say it. This is just another assumption you are making, ignoring what little empirical evidence you have right here.
Pelister, my first post generalised what 'Macedonia for the Macedonians' meant to people in the modern context. The majority of the posts in this thread proved this generalisation wrong, however the majority of people on this forum have read up on Macedonian matters and the historical context behind the statement. I hoped that I had clarified this in my post previous to this one. I will continue to believe that the other interpretation is still going to exist (if not on this forum) because the majority of the population (Macedonian or not) may not be informed about the historical context behind the statement. It is important that great care is taken when using the statement. This was why I wanted to explore the statement.
Pitu Guli fought for Macedonia's Nationhood. To me that makes him a part of the Macedonian nation. I will see what I can find in terms of quotes.Pelister said:I would also say to you that provide me with the evidence that Pitu Gule "felt" Macedonian?
Agreed.Pelister said:The development and the emergence of the Macedonian Nationality is inextricably interwined with the struggles and sacrifices of the Macedonian ethnic group.
For the millionth time, I do not suggest that they are separate. I do suggest that they are not exactly the same entity. There is a difference between saying 'separate' and 'not exactly the same'.Pelister said:So, to split them, or suggest that the Macedonian Nationality is separate from the Macedonian ethnic group, is an exercise is abstract reasoning, nothing more.
Which came first? It's hard to know in my opinion. You would have to go back to the formation of unique human culture to know the answer. I would also note that over time, ethnic groups instigate nations in some instances, and in others nations instigate ethnic groups. I would say that this process goes back and forth in time.Pelister said:Which came first? The Macedonian ethnic group, or the Macedonian Nationality? One in fact follows the other. One embodies the other, and vice versa. This is important to note. The Greeks for example, argue that there is a Macedonian Nationality [in your terms], but no Macedonian, hence the Macedonian creatd by Tito ...etc. I think you are ignorant of the part Macedonians played in the emergence of their own Nationality.
With regards to the Macedonian nation, I do not believe that the Macedonian nation was created by Tito. I believe that the Macedonian nation was developed when people who felt Macedonian together, came together and desired an independent existence. This can historically date back as far as sources indicate, and as far as i'm aware, these sources would predate the birth of Tito's grandfather. In reality it can date back prior to the existence of sources, but it can not be deemed historical to make this claim.
Pelister said:The whole point of these negtotions is to Denationalize the Macedonian, i.e., separate the ethnic group from the emergence of their Nationality, in historical terms, which is what you are doing
The whole point of the negotiations is to remove the Macedonian nation and the Macedonian ethnicity from the face of the planet. The Greeks started off from the position that there is no Macedonian ethnicity to even talk about (they did this quietly), and attacked only our nation's name (with aggression). Now that they have been forced to explain their position of our ethnicity, and it is now that they are trying to separate two things which they previously persisted were non existant.
The thing is Pelister, The Macedonian ethnic group is a part of the Macedonian nation, and the Macedonian nation is a part of the ethnic Macedonian identity, however they are not the same thing. They are not completely separate, but they are not the same thing.
This statement which I just wrote does not separate the Macedonian nation and ethnicity, nor agree with the Greek position, which is that there is no such thing as either a Macedonian ethnicity or Macedonian nation. Their position also fails to recognise the difference between a Nation and Ethnic identity, which is why they treat ethnic Macedonians like crap.
Exploring our own identity makes us more comfortable in defending ourselves against those who wish us harm, by attacking flaws in their definitions and showing how our existence is more robust than that of the attackers. Why avoid exploring this when there is nothing to fear? The Grci are on shaky ground ideologically, and we are just pushing them from our stronger foundations based on reality.
Last edited: