toothpaste
Banned
In fact according to Thucydides the various tribes were expelled from what became kingdom of Macedon of the Argeads.Вардарец;1731 said:#1
#2
Yes, i am aware that the second map predates the first, it can be easily seen.
BUT, did the Macedonians drove the Paeonians from the Solun region completely, or just politically? That's a question which can not be solved.
Macedonians waged many wars with the surrounding states and kingdoms after the establishment of the Macedonian kingdom. They did it mostly with the Thracians, so the borders were frequently changing. Does that mean that the local Macedonian/Paeonian/Thracian population disappeared ? I do think NO.
As u see in the map...


Pierians were kicked eastwards (Pieria and Pieris) ...the same for Edones expelled from Mygdonia ,Bottiaioi were kicked from Pella region to north Chalkidike ,Paionians from the lower bank of Axios to the upper.
#3
Yup and it is true. I, DO believe that he was speaking about the inhabitants of the thema Bulgaria (south Larisa, upwards Belgrade). It could not be possible that all those people there be the descendants of Kubrat's 100.000 horseman horde. Alas, the center of Bulgaria was the thema Paristrion, were those Paristrians ethnically, or just politically.
Am i correct?![]()
Hm ..not exactly..
Tzetzes (1110-1180) wrote his history when "themata" were replaced by other divisions.
Also he is speaking about the Bulgarian nation in his quote ,not about thema.
http://http://books.google.com/books?id=dG0GAAAAQAAJ&printsec=frontcover&dq=Tzetzou&lr=&as_brr=3&hl=el#PRA2-PA516,M1
#4
Will be my wishful thinking if i say Philip conquered the hellenic states, and you state your "historical" facts that Philip united the hellenes at Heronea?
Neither of them is true.
Philip of Macedonia together with his allies from Epirus ,Thessaly ,Phocis ,Aetolia and Epicnemedian Locris defeated Athenians and Thebans.
That's all.
Even inside Athens there was a pro and an anti-macedonian party.
No it is NOT the same.If you are speaking about the later independence of the Paeonians, why not to speak about the Orestians(Core Macedonian tribe), which also gained independence for their war contributions against the Macedonian state from the Romans? Orestians lived in the area around Kostur. Were they too, separate from the Macedonians?
For example the army of Alexander was made up of the core-the Macedonians ,formed in "Taxeis" of Phalangites pezetairoi and "Ilai" of companions (Etairoi).
The phalangites -infantry that followed Alexander deep in Asia was made up exclusively of men from Upper Macedonia (thats modern Greek West Macedonia and Bitola region)-Orestis, Lyncestis, Elimiotis ,Tymphaia.
The infantry from Lower Macedonia remained in the kingdom.
On the other hand Paionians ,as well as Agrianes,Thracians and Greek Hoplites ,formed their own contingents within the army ,fighting in their traditional way.
Paionians were light cavalry.But different from the Macedonian.
These regions of Upper Macedonia (Orestis,Lyncestis,Eordaia,Elimiotis,Derriopos,Tymphaia)didn't have a king-even semi-autonomous ,some after Alexander I ,and other after Philip II reign.
Also Argos in Orestis ,was probably the birthplace of the Macedonian royal house.(and not Argos of southern Greece)
Paionia was part of Macedonia after Philip took over it.
I already wrote ...this was only after the Roman conquest.
Even during Philip's rule ,Paionians had their own king -Lycaeios (a coin was presented in "macedonian archaeology"
....
Lycaeios (359-340 BC),
Patraios (340-315 BC),
Audoleon (315 -286 BC),
Ariston (286 BC),
Leon (278-250 BC) and Dropion (250-230 BC) ..last mentioned Paionian king.
Last edited: