Pelister
New member
Pelister Wrote...
I think this is the most important question that has never been satisfactorily answered by the proponents of the 6th century 'migration' theory. Without conclusive proof of the wholscale extinction of not only the Thracians, but also the Illyrians and numerous other indigenous peoples, the 6th century 'migration' theory simply cannot be sustained. The fact that the 6th century 'migration' theory was propagated so widely during the 19th century obviously has more to do with German, Austrian and English politics than an honest view of history.
If the 6th century 'migration' theory were fact, and wholescale extinction of the Thracians and Illyrians took place as a result of an 'invasion' by 'migrating' Slavs, one would expect to find numerous archaeological evidence of this just about everywhere in the Balkans. One would also expect to find a clear break in the material culture (art, burial styles, type of dwellings etc) of the region where the Thracian and Illyrian ceases and the 'Slavic' begins...yet there is none.
In fact when considering material culture, there is a high degree of continuity from the ancient right up until modern times in the Balkan region in general (except for Albania and Greece where the opposite is true).
The New Greeks are pushing the idea that the 5th century constitutes a clean break, in respect to the Macedonians and Macedonia, only so they can open specifically the region of ancient Macedonia to any number of possible historical revisions, that suites its modern political objectives.
It certainly constitutes a clean break, for ancient Greece (We know this because of the presence of Slavic speaking tribes there, and Albanians, among others), but in lands traditionally inhabited, or occupied from some dark and distant past, by Thracians (Slavic speakers), and related tribes (the two oldest tombs on Mt Olumpus,, are Thracian), which include ancient Macedonia, can we say such a break exists?
The only logical reason why were can't "see" the Thracians and the Illyrians, among others, perhaps even the ancient Macedonians, is because they are indistinguishable from the cultures of the various Slavic speaking ethnic groups, inhabiting those lands today.
There is no evidence of a mass migration, and there is no evidence of a clean break in the material culture, as you say.
It is a very cunning trick, to call us "Slavs" which immediately and automatically associates us, with the 5th century. This has most of us fooled, including myself, because the brain automatically, draws conclusions; if we arrived in the 5th century, who was there before Us ?...etc.
Last edited: