• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

WTF?: North Macedonia to become bilingual state until 2020

Giorikas, what Greece is doing to Macedonia and the Macedonian people is an outright shame and disgrace. No progress will be made until your side recognizes my side by the name we identify with, just like we recognize you.

Any Greek who thinks they have the right to dictate terms to the Macedonians where it concerns their state and identity is a piece of shit, and a racist. Do you fall in this catergory mate?
Giorikas said:
I'm saying, it's impossible to ignore the very significant 'Bulgarian Macedonian' populatian that existed in Greek Makedonia (ex big cities more or less, especially Thessaloniki).
Nobody ignores the 'Bulgarian' Macedonians as they don't ignore the 'Greek' Macedonians - As they don't ignore the fact that both the 'Bulgarian' and 'Greek' labels were not ethnic, not linguistic, but distinctions of religion and/or class. That is the simple fact. A Macedonian in the Exarchate or Patriarchate is still a Macedonian, he/she still speaks the Macedonian language, he/she still has Macedonian origins, he/she still has Macedonian customs and a Macedonian culture. That is the truth. The manipulation of the Macedonian peasantry via political or religious persuasion finished about a 100 years ago. The Macedonian dialects are distinguishable from Bulgarian, 99% of the linguistic experts in the Slavic world will testify to this, therefore, if it is a Slavic dialect in Macedonia then 9/10 it is the Macedonian language.
The ones we fought identified themselves as Bulgarians and got help from Bulgaria.
You're wrong, and you know it, and we can prove it. You are trying to indicate that the sole identity of the peasantry was 'Bulgarian', which is simply not true. Macedonians fought as Macedonians, against Greeks. Some may have identified as 'Bulgarian' or 'Greek' for the reasons outlined above, but the bulk of the population only had a native Macedonian identity, which was coupled with an imposed identity at various stages. Most often, these 'Greeks' and 'Bulgarians' were simply Macedonians who fought against each other under the persuasion of opposing sides.

Have a read of the below link:

http://www.macedoniantruth.org/forum/showthread.php?t=881

Even Greeks like Delta who try and muddy the waters when speaking of the Macedonians, by claiming that they are a mix of all sorts, cannot help but admit that the native identity and language of the people was Macedonian and called Macedonian by the persons concerned.
Greeks and Bulgarians are bad guys for not accepting you identity as 'Macedonian-Macedonians', a Slavic speaking, though not Slavic population.
Greeks and Bulgarians who do not recognize the Macedonian identity are racist morons, I hope I make myself clear enough on that point. I would like you to clarify what you mean by "Slavic-speaking, though not Slavic population", is that the same as the Egyptians being "Arab-speaking, though not Arab population", or the Scottish being "English-speaking, though not English population"?? Giorikas, we will not agree on what the ancient Macedonians were and most scholars will agree that the subject is still open for debate, therefore, if you are trying to indicate what I think, then your argument on this particular point is rendered worthless.
A Greek you say is not a Greek even if he identifies himself as such, and the same goes now for Bulgarians so it seems.
Where it concerns Macedonia, that is for the most part correct. Again, read my above responses pertaining to the 'Greek' and 'Bulgarian' identities in Macedonia. Only decades earlier, there was neither the Greek or Bulgarian identity that you and your Bulgar friends would like to envision, the 19th century saw all the modern Balkan nations come to fruition. You should keep that fact clear from the propagandist lies you may have read on some racist Greek website.
I can understand the numbers that you claim a bit better now. You incorporated the complete Bulgarian-Macedonian population into yours.
Read above. I hope you had fun swinging around the misguided (and irrelevant) 'Bulgarian-Macedonian' terminology. I trust you have ceased your game now.

By the way, you can lay off Thorvald, your spiteful attacks on him are growing tiresome. The old Giorikas indeed mate......
 
You're saying: Macedonians were often counted as Bulgarians. I can accept that to a certain extent.
But same time there were for sure a significant number of Bulgarians. You have no problem to count them as Macedonian. I believe that it's incorrect. We know that there was a Bulgarian movement, because we fought them. Turkish fought them too and refered to them as Bulgarians. They considered themselves to be Bulgarian. We have that on paper. It was a movement that had been cooking for years. The Miladinov Brothers did their part writing 'Bulgarian folk songs' as did others, so do not tell me that there were no Bulgarians there.
Now if you're saying that I am racist scum for not not going along with counting all of them in retrospect as Macedonians, then so be it. I can really live with that.
You said in so many words that there were no substantial numbers of Bulgarians in Greek Macedonia, apart from the occasional one in Thraki. That is far from the truth as I see it and it doesn't make your claims credible. Again, I respectfully disagree.

To be clear I am not saying you are Bulgarians.

In fact, you expect me to respect your right of self determination if possibly by conviction rather then just obeying the formum rules, but you do not do the same to Greeks (who seem on this board to be anything but Greeks in the first place) nor do you extend the same courtecy to Bulgarians. They were simply all .... Macedonians you say. Regardless of what they identidied as.

Actually, you will this find this really offensive but here we go: Population counts recorded Bulgarians for sure in Macedonia (after the time that Christians were mentioned as group only). Turks counted them, Greeks counted them, French counted them, Bulgarians counted them, Serbs counted them, foreigners spoke of them, travellers recorded them, Greeks fought them, Serbs fought them, Turks fought them. The evidence is overwhelming and not disputed, read any book on the Balkan wars and read who participated.

I read for example letters that were found of Greek soldiers writing back home (don't remember the source). They spoke of incredible autrocities from their side. We know that Bulgarians did the same to us. It was dirty business in those days. Whichever village did not belong to your side was burned to the ground and most villagers killed. Now I find it completely understandable and credible that any Bulgarian would not identify as Bulgarian but just simply as Macedonian looking at a gun and sabre when being confronted with fierce Cretans on horses ready to burn, kill, rape and pillage. That would for me be a very logical reaction. We know that many in those places during that time identified with whichever side was in front of them for sure. All sides confirm that. Being Macedonian was more accptable, more safe, more neutral & less dangerous and might give you a chance to get away with being Bulgarian. So I find it very plausable that a Bulgarian would anser 'I am Macedonian' if he was asked what he was. If would have asked for example Kemal Ataturk in his if he were Macedonian he would also answer that with a yes. But Turk too.
I am not saying that now each Macedonian is in fact Bulgarian, to be clear. But just consider the possibility that it's completely the other way around then what you say.
You see, it depends all on which way you want to see it.

BTW, I will leave that Nazi Thorvald alone.

Giorikas
 
Giorikas said:
But same time there were for sure a significant number of Bulgarians.
Ethnic Bulgarians as opposed to ethnic Macedonians from the Exarchate or one's using the generic 'Bulgar' name applied to other Slavic-speakers in the Balkans also? Do tell....
We know that there was a Bulgarian movement, because we fought them.
It was a Macedonian movement. Unlike the foreigners from Crete and elsewhere that came to Macedonia to fight for the Greek 'cause' of usurping the region and its people, they did not enjoy the support of the Bulgarian state as did the so-called 'Makedonomachos' with Greece. I agree that there was Bulgarian influence due to the Exarchate and some extremely pro-Bulgarian members, but that is irrelevant to the sentiments of most of the members, who were locals from Macedonia and had as their aim the ultimate liberation of Macedonia as an independent state.
Turkish fought them too and refered to them as Bulgarians. They considered themselves to be Bulgarian. We have that on paper.
We have papers too. These 'Bulgarians' you cite are members of the Exarchate who are ethnic Macedonians, nothing more.
The Miladinov Brothers did their part writing 'Bulgarian folk songs' as did others, so do not tell me that there were no Bulgarians there.
The Miladinov brothers were only using the generic term used by most Slavic-speakers of the Ottoman Empire at the time, they were from the far west in Macedonia, Struga, the dialects recorded in their texts from Macedonia are clearly identified as Macedonian, there can be no doubt of that. You try and hold on to these 'Bulgarian' references desperately, would you accept that in the territory that came to be the Greek Kingdom there were only Romans and no Hellenes? That is what the locals of that land called themselves, is it not? Ethnic Romans? Do you see how utterly inaccurate your suggestions are?
..........but you do not do the same to Greeks (who seem on this board to be anything but Greeks in the first place).....
You keep repeating that, yet I see plenty of people calling you Greeks, in particular the person writing this to you now. This doesn't come close to your continual twisting of the facts about the 'Bulgarian-Macedonians', who were ethnic Macedonians from the Macedonian region and spoke the Macedonian language.
.......nor do you extend the same courtecy to Bulgarians. They were simply all .... Macedonians you say. Regardless of what they identidied as.......
Such fanatical 'identity' is cheap. In his assessment of some regions in the west of Aegean Macedonia, the Greek chief of staff in the military, Salvanos (1925), calls these Greeks and Bulgarians a group of fanatics, who are in the minority. How can I consider somebody a Greek or Bulgarian when they have the same ancestal origins as me, the same culture and customs as me, the same language as me? That is not an identity, it is the falsification of identity. Now, I know that you will tailor your answer to suit the following question, but try and be honest here, what would you think of a person who identifies as a Turk yet speaks Greek at home and among family, has Greek customs, etc? Respect his identity as an ethnic Turk? The thought wouldn't cross your mind that there is more to this person that just an 'Turk'? In anticipation of a serious response here.

We are not asking you to respect our identity just for the sake of putting on a show or to get our own way, we are asking you because that is our only native identity as a people, state and language, and it is as historically valid as any other nation on this earth. We are the Macedonians.
Actually, you will this find this really offensive but here we go: Population counts recorded Bulgarians for sure in Macedonia (after the time that Christians were mentioned as group only). Turks counted them, Greeks counted them, French counted them, Bulgarians counted them, Serbs counted them, foreigners spoke of them, travellers recorded them, Greeks fought them, Serbs fought them, Turks fought them. The evidence is overwhelming and not disputed, read any book on the Balkan wars and read who participated.
And there are reasons why they were called 'Bulgarian', as already explained. Here is something that you and the type of racist Greeks you are beginning to sound like choose to deny: Populations statistics also record a Macedonian Slavic population distinct from Serbs and Bulgars, Greeks most certainly have considered the people and language as Macedonian or Macedonian Slavic several times which is recorded in Greek records, Bulgarians and Serbs also saw the Macedonians who they tried to assimilate due to linguistic similarities, foreigners also saw them and spoke of them and considered them an independent people. Our evidence is also overwhelming which demonstrates that your evidence is delivered in a propagandist manner and is sourced from misguided information. Why is it OK for you to raise this type of 'evidence' yet the second that somebody highlights the imperialistic and racist policies of Greece and/or the significance of Albanians, Germans, Vlachs, etc in the origins of modern Greek history, you jump up and down in a tantrum and commence with baseless accusations at people? If such people are 'low' for spending some hours researching your state and people, what does that say about you and your efforts here against the Macedonians?
Now I find it completely understandable and credible that any Bulgarian would not identify as Bulgarian but just simply as Macedonian looking at a gun and sabre when being confronted with fierce Cretans on horses ready to burn, kill, rape and pillage.
Why would Macedonians identify as Macedonians to Bulgarians, Serbs and foreigners? Because they were all fierce? Your argument doesn't hold water, we know why and when we used the 'Bulgarian' name, evidently you don't, as the modern Greek memory seems to erase inconvenient contradictions in your arguments, such as your Roman identity in parallel to that of the Bulgarian one. You have only called yourselves Hellenes since the 19th century and you think you have the right to question the name of my identity?
I am not saying that now each Macedonian is in fact Bulgarian, to be clear. But just consider the possibility that it's completely the other way around then what you say.
I have considered it, and I rendered it historically incorrect.
You see, it depends all on which way you want to see it.
I see it from the pragmatic and realistic side, I see the Macedonian Truth, all you seem to see is Greek lies.
 
Going to be a long one again ....

Regarding your first remark: A Christian from Macedonia does not equal a Greek, of course. But if you dig further, it makes no sense that the overwhelming majority of Slav-speaking Christians would accept being labelled Bulgarians when they were in fact not. Unless you believe that Ottomans had a good reason to suppress your Macedonian identity at that time, and I can not think of any. The creation of the Exarchate had many reasons, and adding a Macedonian Orthodox Church would not be necessarily against their interests. But that did not happen. It would probably have strengthened the Ottoman position dividing as much as possible (between all troublemakers). We know after all that the Ottomans encouraged the Greek - Bulgarian skirmishes. It was a turbulent time indeed and Ottomans were about to resettle Macedonia with Muslims from Bosnia, just to make sure they had a population they could trust & to consolidate their position in Macedonia.

Regarding the Macedonian movement: we are going around circles. We have it on paper that many identified themselves as Bulgarians. That does not mean automatically that there could not be simulaniously a non-Bulgarian but Macedonian struggle, but it seems all evidence is against you. If for crying out loud you take the risk of rebelling & getting killed would you call yourself 'Bulgarian' in stead of Macedonian having a Macedonian identity. And on top you know that the majority around you feels Macedonian, not Bulgarian.... It just doesn't add up for me. Hey Mr. Ottoman, I want to kick you from our soil, but unfortunately the time is not there yet to call myself Macedonian...? How ridiculous is that?

You say that the exachate had Bulgarian influences. I say it was Bulgarian to the core. I can't believe you made that comment.

The Miladinov brothers; I can't properly judge if this dialect as you describe it, differs from mainstream Bulgarian at that time. I know just 1 thing, if every fibre in my core tells me that I am a Macedonian and nothing else, and if one of the reasons I write what I write (which is to preserve / promote my national Macedonian conciousness) no way would I call it 'Bulgarian folk tales' but 'Macedonian folk songs'. Those were times when revolution was in the air. Why conform, like self sensorship. It's not as if the the exarchate would excommunicate me since this was Macedonian in essence anyway, right, 'though with Bulgarian influence'.

Now, Rum: if a Greek in Turkey was (and still is to this day) called Rum, then that did not offend them. It doesn't bother me that I am a Yunan for them, but my brothers in Turkey are 'Rum', while I call myself Ellinas, and in English that would be Greek. But do not try to tell a Thessalonian that he's Bulgarian ;-) If I would meet somebody in Turkey that speaks Greek and I consider to be Greek but he or she identifies himself as Turk (and there are such cases) then it would sadden me. But I'd have to accept his right to choose his identity. I any case there is nothing else one could do. I don't believe in enforcing an identity on someone. He or she is a Turk if he or she made that choice.

As far as Greeks not being allowed to be called Greeks here on this forum, I meant it in the context that we are debating here, that you claim Greeks from Macedonia to be Macedonian of origin. I have told you my take on Macedonians in Greece. Anybody living on Greek soil who feels not Greek, but feels Macedonian has my blessing. I believe that they are there and I believe that everyone should be entitled to express their views and they should not be hindered in any way. That I do not believe those to be connected with ancient Macedonia is another matter all the same. They seem to feel connected with ROM. I also believe the numbers to be very small. It's irrelevant for this discussion. You knew my position on that.

Evidence: We can do the 'show me yours and I'll show you mine' but I challenge you to show me the overwhelming proof of recorded population census indication an indiginous Macedonian (non-Bulgarian)ethnic identity from a neutral source.

On Mr. Thorvald, I called him a Nazi before he referred to Greece as being imperialistic. It was practically the first thing I wrote him.

On the topic why Macedonians called themselves what, I disagree. You mentioned Macedonians were by far outnumbering Bulgarians and Bulgarians were in fact non-existant in Macedonia (a few in Thace aside) & Greeks were really Macedonians too. Those are controversial statements. Who did those Macedonians then have to answer to? To non-existing Bulgarians? To non-existing Bulgarian revolutionary movements who were really Macedonian? To Greek revolutionary movements who were also Macedonians? Ottomans maybe? The sick man of Europe, who was weak and wanted their enemies weaker. It would serve Ottomans just fine to add another ingredient, another ethnic group to the salade Macédoine, the more fighting between the Christians the better. What was the masterplan then by your enemies?

Anyway, I'm just thinking out loud here. I repeat, I am not stating that there were no etnic Macedonians. I am also not saying that Macedonians are Bulgarians. I just want you to consider that is wrong to absorb Greeks & Bulgarians from Macedonia in retrospect as Macedonians. It's merely that point I want to make. Please reconsider.
 
Last edited:
It also happened with the Prosfiga who came to Aegean Macedonia, where they learned the Macedonian language. Like these people below;
YouTube - Î*ολύπετρο Κιλκίς05

They learned it from people like this;
YouTube - I am NOT Greek, I AM MACEDONIAN!

Macedonian must have been widespread and influental, why wasn't it given the status discussed above?

Sorry, but the people in that first video did not learn the language when they arrived. Maybe other refugees did, but not those specific people in the video.


----
Dr AV*
 
dr av really i thought your moniker was an indication of your knowledge about these matters, mr DRVO si

Hi there,

Yes im a family doctor and those are the first four letters of my last name, as you know Greek last names can be pretty long!!

I dont have the best knowledge of these matters but i do know for sure that those people in the first video didnt learn the language after they arrived, i have seen that show in its entirety.

Thanks for the nice welcome, you must be the village idiot of the message board, i will remind myself to ignore you.


----

Dr AV*
 
if it makes you feel good about your obvious igornace about macedonia, then yeah i am the village idiot. why in the hell would i welcome a confused wannnabee hellene like you, and being an md means shit on a history and politics forum yatre mou.
ignore as much as you like thats the best way to stay ignorant like a drvo.
 
Giorikas said:
............it makes no sense that the overwhelming majority of Slav-speaking Christians would accept being labelled Bulgarians when they were in fact not.
It makes sense if you take into account the facts and all the historical circumstances prevalent during that time. You clearly don't intend to do this, therefore you will only tell lies and half-truths as a result.

Giorikas, you are not even a Bulgarian, yet you have clearly come to this forum for the purpose of denying my identity, and you, a Greek, is trying to tell me who my people are and that they were 'Bulgarians'. And then you wonder why the Macedonians on this forum place the name of your nation in "quotation" marks, you have shown yourself unworthy of their respect. While you will grudgingly accept to cease your clearly natural sense of racism by calling my people by the name they identify with, every single one of your posts is aimed at denying the identity of my people. Maybe it wasn't such a bad thing you slithered away after all then, re megale........

Regarding the activity of the Macedonian revolutionaries, it was a Macedonian movement, aimed at liberating Macedonia and the Macedonian people. That is the bottom line. You have tried, really hard, to resist your temptations at racist remarks and the denial of another people's history in which you have no clue or relation, but to not avail.
The Miladinov brothers; I can't properly judge if this dialect as you describe it.............
You can't properly judge anything you jester, just take a look at the dribble full of lies you produced in your previous posts. You perceptions about Macedonians is more akin to people thinking the world is flat, that is how off the mark you are.
Now, Rum: if a Greek in Turkey was (and still is to this day) called Rum, then that did not offend them. It doesn't bother me that I am a Yunan for them, but my brothers in Turkey are 'Rum', while I call myself Ellinas, and in English that would be Greek. But do not try to tell a Thessalonian that he's Bulgarian ;-) If I would meet somebody in Turkey that speaks Greek and I consider to be Greek but he or she identifies himself as Turk (and there are such cases) then it would sadden me. But I'd have to accept his right to choose his identity. I any case there is nothing else one could do. I don't believe in enforcing an identity on someone. He or she is a Turk if he or she made that choice.
Hahaha, now that did make me laugh. Who said anything about 'Greeks' in Turkey today? ALL of your comments are about the Macedonians, before they realised their own state. Before the state of the modern "Hellenes" was born, ALL of its inhabitants were called ROMANS - ROMANS.

Like I said before,
You have only called yourselves Hellenes since the 19th century and you think you have the right to question the name of my identity?


Anyway, I'm just thinking out loud here. I repeat, I am not stating that there were no etnic Macedonians. I am also not saying that Macedonians are Bulgarians.
You are clearly denying the identity of the Macedonians, you are clearly calling 'Bulgarian' the Macedonians of today, many of whom in the past (before they created their state) referred to themselves as 'Greeks' or 'Bulgarians' due to religious, linguistic and class distinction. You are a racist, and a cunning liar, and as such, you will provide an endless barrage of lies in response no matter what facts and truths are shown your way.

Giving somebody the opportunity to show and support the other (Bulgarians in this case) side, I have no problem with that, but when somebody that is not even from the other side (Greek), makes it his sole purpose to endlessly spew up repetitive and outdated remarks about the Macedonians, which have racist undertones full of lies, that is a problem for me.

If I wanted to read the garbage full of denial of the Macedonian identity, like the shit full of lies you wote above, I would have gone to your breeding grounds at racist websites like the maggotsontheweb.

Take a temporary (ban) holiday, we will see you in a few weeks, I think it will do you some good, as evidently your previous absence was not extensive enough.
 
Oh, and Giorikas, if you decide to slither back in a few weeks once your ban is lifted, the first racist remark of denial you make will be your last. Try and display a little sense of dignity so that the good Greek people don't look like racist pricks as you do.
 
Sorry, but the people in that first video did not learn the language when they arrived. Maybe other refugees did, but not those specific people in the video.


----
Dr AV*
Be sorry for yourself, not to me.

http://www.macedoniantruth.org/forum/showthread.php?t=706&page=2

The lady in black is doing most of the talking, she said that they were transferred there (Greek-occupied Macedonia) and lived among the locals (Macedonians), “what do you want after so many years, I was born here, of course we learned the language, Shto Pravish, Odam” (Macedonian words).

She says that all the people there get along fine, use similar words (?), the only thing different is that they count in Turkish. She can only count to six in Macedonian, "chetiri, pet, shest".

The moron with the grey hair and glasses asks if they understand Bulgarian? The people around the table say they understand it but not all of it.

One of the ladies says Serbian, Yugoslavian…….I think some may have said they understand, but I hear "no, no we don’t understand it" towards the end.

He asks something like is the language similar to Greek? They respond a resounding no.

At one point the lady in black doing most of the talking says something about the “dialect of Gevgelija”, which of course is Macedonian and is spoken in the Republic of Macedonia, see:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gevgelija

Right at the end that idiot says something like “how do you feel”, staring like some psycho at the people around the table in anticipation of a response. There was nothing but silence and stares of confusion for seconds. Finally somebody asks something like “what do you mean”, after which another says “our homeland in Greece so we are Greek”, quite unconvincingly.

Then this idiot start saying something like “there is only one Greece, bla, bla, bla” as if he is some preacher and calls over a priest, I guess he must have thought he would need spiritual back-up to convince those people that they were pure blooded Greeks.


And what about the second video ιδιοφυία?


είσαι πρόσφυγας? -- “what do you want after so many years, I was born here, of course we learned the language, Shto Pravish, Odam”

What's that?
 
Be sorry for yourself, not to me.

http://www.macedoniantruth.org/forum/showthread.php?t=706&page=2




And what about the second video ιδιοφυία?


είσαι πρόσφυγας? -- “what do you want after so many years, I was born here, of course we learned the language, Shto Pravish, Odam”

What's that?

I need to ask you a serious question. Who has translated this for you?
They did not do a great job.
The problem is that when they are talking amongst themselves you can pick up bits and pieces but i know you are struggling to understand the whole conversation.
As for your translation, nowhere does she say 'what do you want after so many years' and 'of course we learned the language'
Here is a better translation of what the lady is saying

'Sotiris asked me how many are there the TrakaTurkis, and i said half and half, endopie and.. host says- in petropouli?
'But now that we are born here we are the same, basically our language is matching, shto pravish , odam odam , what differences is that?? only in counting we dont match. host says- how do you count?
'We count in Turkish, but over there they say no , ve , tri , chitiri, thats as far as i know, (man in the back says - its bulgarian)
As for the rest of your translation its a bit better.

This is what you need to ask yourself. If they learned the language after they arrived why would they count in Turkish. Counting is probably the most fundamental and first thing you learn when speaking a new language.

The last question i have is this. In your humble opinion what are the people in the video? Are they Greeks , Turks, Bulgarians, Macedonians, Pomaks, Armenians etc etc

Remember , there are more parts to this show and i have the feeling you havent seen them, so after you answer my questions maybe i will put them up for you.

Take care

----

Dr AV*
 
I need to ask you a serious question. Who has translated this for you?
They did not do a great job.
The problem is that when they are talking amongst themselves you can pick up bits and pieces but i know you are struggling to understand the whole conversation.
As for your translation, nowhere does she say 'what do you want after so many years' and 'of course we learned the language'
Here is a better translation of what the lady is saying

'Sotiris asked me how many are there the TrakaTurkis, and i said half and half, endopie and.. host says- in petropouli?
'But now that we are born here we are the same, basically our language is matching, shto pravish , odam odam , what differences is that?? only in counting we dont match. host says- how do you count?
'We count in Turkish, but over there they say no , ve , tri , chitiri, thats as far as i know, (man in the back says - its bulgarian)
As for the rest of your translation its a bit better.

This is what you need to ask yourself. If they learned the language after they arrived why would they count in Turkish. Counting is probably the most fundamental and first thing you learn when speaking a new language.

The last question i have is this. In your humble opinion what are the people in the video? Are they Greeks , Turks, Bulgarians, Macedonians, Pomaks, Armenians etc etc

Remember , there are more parts to this show and i have the feeling you havent seen them, so after you answer my questions maybe i will put them up for you.

Take care

----

Dr AV*

just out of curiosity, what kind of Greek are you? Lets start with the easy question, are you from Greek annexed Macedonia?
 
This is what you need to ask yourself. If they learned the language after they arrived why would they count in Turkish. Counting is probably the most fundamental and first thing you learn when speaking a new language.

Sorry Dr Drvo, or is that Mr Ed? this is blatantly false. Most people revert back to their original language when adding or counting.
 
fucking hopless another greek drvo trying to twist raelity to suit their patheticaly in secure hellenic world view. why the fuck would a so called greek in greece count in turkish.
 
I was hoping Soldier who initially posted this video would respond.
From the other responses it seems that the other members feel that these people are Turks or Turkish speakers.
Here is the rest of the show, enjoy, at 5:30 we get an explanation.
YouTube - Î*ολύπετρο Κιλκίς02

Translation...
Host - They call you TrakaTurkides, why?
Priest - From the word ' taka tuka ' come here, go there, our people speak a language which is 40/100 Slavo/Russian/Bulgarian , 40/100 Persian/Turkish/Arabic , 15/100 Greek and 5/100 Arvanitic. It is the only language which was spoken in all Asia Minor. This language is not spoken anywhere else in the world.
He then talks about how they were to be settled near the Bulgarian border but because later on they would think that they were Bulgarians they did not want to go there. He then asks if they still speak it and the priest says they do but they kids unfortunately dont.

Thats all i wanted to point out, that they didnt learn it when they arrived, they actually brought the language with them.

To El Bre - If my statement is blatantly false then why dont they count in Macedonian, the original inhabitants came to Asia Minor in the 1500's from Ohrid. Thats in another part , would you like to see it ?
These people have Macedonian roots.

To Daskalot - Yes Giannitsa and Naousa , and you?
To Osiris - On ignore

----

Dr AV*
 
Divorcee said:
I need to ask you a serious question. Who has translated this for you?
I need to ask you a serious question. Were your eyes closed when you wrote what you did? Where exactly do you find the great distinction between this,
'what do you want after so many years' and 'of course we learned the language'
And this,
'But now that we are born here we are the same, basically our language is matching
That language uses words such as Shto Pravish , Odam. That is not Greek, it is the Macedonian language.
what differences is that?? only in counting we dont match. host says- how do you count?
'We count in Turkish, but over there they say no , ve , tri , chitiri, thats as far as i know
The locals would of course count in Macedonian, as dve, tri chetiri are of the same language as shto pravish and odam - the Macedonian language.
This is what you need to ask yourself. If they learned the language after they arrived why would they count in Turkish. Counting is probably the most fundamental and first thing you learn when speaking a new language.
Why would they count in Turkish then? Because they came from Turkey. Your example about the 'fundamental' things one first learns when speaking a new language is completely incoherent and flawed. Most of the Prosfiga spoke Turkish as a first language, Greek was the 'official' language of their new state which they would forever after hear in media, schools, churches, etc, but Macedonian was the language of the locals in "Northern Greece" (Greek-occupied Macedonia), that is why these Christian Turks picked up the language, and many of them quite well actually. Fancy that, a language that Greece denies exists, with absolutely no support in the media, schools, churches, etc, was still learned and spoken by Christian Turks. That is something you need to come to terms with.
he last question i have is this. In your humble opinion what are the people in the video? Are they Greeks , Turks, Bulgarians, Macedonians, Pomaks, Armenians etc etc
Mostly Prosfiga, whatever they are, nothing they say before or after can dispute the fact that Prosfiga learned MY language in a state that denies its existence. Whatever you come up with next, that fact will remain, Shto Pravish, Odam, Tri, Chetiri, etc is Macedonian.
man in the back says - its bulgarian
Really? Some 'man' in the back? What do the rest say when they are asked?

The moron with the grey hair and glasses asks if they understand Bulgarian? The people around the table say they understand it but not all of it.

One of the ladies says Serbian, Yugoslavian…….I think some may have said they understand, but I hear "no, no we don’t understand it" towards the end.

He asks something like is the language similar to Greek? They respond a resounding NO.

At one point the lady in black doing most of the talking says something about the “dialect of Gevgelija”, which of course is Macedonian and is spoken in the Republic of Macedonia, see:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gevgelija

And with regard to this video that you posted about this mystery language that nobody has ever heard of up until now, do you have anything documenting its existence? What is it called, another 'Greek' dialect? How can we confirm that the Slavic words used in this mystery language were not learned from the Macedonians, as so many, many other Prosfiga did?

By the way, do you agree with the people in the video who say that this mystery language which is 40% Slavic is "the only language which was spoken in all Asia Minor"? Are these your ancient Ionians that "came home"?
 
Back
Top