Bill77
New member
I think you have a short memory. i could have sworn you said Barbarian meant something diferant.hey Bill...first off you dont have to tell me what barbaros mean. I know..thanks anyway.
and lastly macedonians also competed in the olympics. which is a FACT
That being said, i never said you guys werent macedonians either.
take care man...and chill out
Regarding Macedonians competing, lets talk about that and clear facts.
following Herodotus--the stade- race competitors at Olympia thought the Macedonian was a foreigner (Hdt. 5.22: barbaros) Second, for his effort on behalf of the Greek cause against the Persians Alexander is known as "Philhellene". Now this is kind of odd to call a Greek a "friend of the Greeks". "This title is normally reserved for non-Greeks".
Peter Green - Classical Bearings p.157
Alexander was thus adjudged a Greek---against angry opposition, be it noted, from the stewards of the Games
Ernst Badian - Studies in the History of Art Vol 10: Macedonia and Greece in Late Classical Early Hellenistic Times:
"We have no way of judging the authenticity of either the claim or the evidence that went with it, but it is clear that at the time the decision was not easy. There were outraged protests from the other competitors, who rejected Alexander I as a barbarian--which proves, at least, that the Temenid descent and the royal genealogy had hitherto been an isoteric item of knowledge
Badian sums it up:"As a matter of fact, there is reason to think that at least some even among Alexander I's friends and supporters had regarded the Olympic decision as political rather than factual--as a reward for services to the Hellenic cause rather than as prompted by genuine belief in the evidence he had adduced. We find him described in the lexicographers, who go back to fourth-century sources, as "Philhellene",--surely not an appellation that could be given to an actual Greek."
fact that even when they were finally permitted to compete in the Olympic games, they could so only as ‘Heraklides’, ie; descendants of Herakles, and not as Macedonians. It would only be several years later that the Macedonian nobility were allowed to partake in the Olympic games, after which the Romans, another non-Greek people, also joined in participation.
http://www.macedoniantruth.org/2009/05/05/pausanias-description-of-greece-2nd-century-ad/
i supose you got to leave now.
Last edited: