• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

Stephen Miller and his anti-Macedonian activities

Hello Makedonin,

I am not really interested to sit down here and discuss point by point with each of you why the contents of this letter are wrong or right, even if I'm tempted. No offense intended here.

Many 'professional Macedonians' on this and other forums have been doing that for years and will probably still doing that for many years to come. May the force be with them.
I am interested to see the reactions on this. Calling a proffessor fascist because he looks a at things differently then the 'real' experts here, don't you think that's a bit over the top?

Just a few points in your message that i can comment on: I still disagree with you that this is a clear call for war. I would sign the petition if I held the appropriate PHD. I think this letter helps us so regardless whether I would 100% agree with each single word, I would sign if I was in that position.
I agree that history is not always impartial, at times speculative, even if if any independant academic will try to take a neutral stance.

I like your last remarks, you do have a point here. In the Balkans we all have a great deal stubbornness and need for discussions and dialogue. I like this quote by an old Israeli guy I met once saying: '2 Jews, 3 opinions' haha. That would apply for all of us. Do you live in the Balkans by the way?
 
Hallo Giorikas

Hello Makedonin,

I am not really interested to sit down here and discuss point by point with each of you why the contents of this letter are wrong or right, even if I'm tempted. No offense intended here.

Neither am I interested in discussing this with you, but you asked me polite to help you out, so I did.

Many 'professional Macedonians' on this and other forums have been doing that for years and will probably still doing that for many years to come. May the force be with them.
I am interested to see the reactions on this. Calling a proffessor fascist because he looks a at things differently then the 'real' experts here, don't you think that's a bit over the top?

You are missing the point, should I say as usual. This Professor you are defending,

is called fascist cause he suggest war and annexation of R. of Macedonia by the Greek state, not cause he has different views with us.

Or did you change your mind and support his call on war now?

We won't get to talk about the "Greek experts online" who only babble bull about the Macedonians, aren't we?

Just a few points in your message that i can comment on: I still disagree with you that this is a clear call for war. I would sign the petition if I held the appropriate PHD.

I didn't ask you to sing that particular petition to support the Prof, but rather an Anti War petition, since you said openly you won't support a war.

What does the word annex means to you!?

A bit of help for you:
http://www.thefreedictionary.com/annex
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Annex

How will Greece append the territory of Macedonia in it's territory. Will it ask us politely!? What do you think!?

I think this letter helps us so regardless whether I would 100% agree with each single word, I would sign if I was in that position.
I agree that history is not always impartial, at times speculative, even if if any independant academic will try to take a neutral stance.
We can agree that we disagree on the letter. It is nothing new. But it actually helps only your zeal and nothing else.

I like your last remarks, you do have a point here. In the Balkans we all have a great deal stubbornness and need for discussions and dialogue. I like this quote by an old Israeli guy I met once saying: '2 Jews, 3 opinions' haha. That would apply for all of us.

It is a common human characteristics, not only for the Balkans.

It is the fear behind. Some do it with the religion, other with nationalism, but both are seeking kind of immortality in Ideals.

Nationalism tells us, "My nation have persisted the time, so I will find my immortality in it's Continium". Ironically, we are all ready to die defending this Idea.

A Singer once said: "For Ideals are dieing the stupid". That is really true.
Do you live in the Balkans by the way?
By the way, I do, but am pending. Do you live in the Balkan!?
 
Hello again Makedonin,

I asked your help to show me this practical declaration of war. Not your help to discuss like so many before us the same topics. Didn't see it in the letter, and quickly looking at the documentation, I didn't see it either. Maybe I missed it. Can you show me the quotes?

If he suggests an act of war, then I would oppose that. Both would lose, even if I believe that Greece will militarily win because of the numerical and technological superiority. (not intended to sound superior here, we just happen to have a bigger country with more military)

To be honest I never heard of this guy before, but I can not believe that so many would be associated with a letter to Obama where it is suggested that another country should be annexed. If that causes you to call him fascist, then that's more understandable. If it is because his or their views are different, then I would call that over the top. But I can't find it, can't judge the context, and I can't judge how seriously he meant that.

Let's put that behind us a bit. You know very well that Greece does not intend to annex you fortunately.

As far as the letter: Yes it helps. I believe it's more effective then raising a monument of Alexander the great. I do believe that the fact that so many non-Greeks academics support it, gives it some level of authority, even if it is in the end just their professional opinion. I would be very interested to see how many independant academics support your view.

I like your comments about nationalism. Again, you have a point, and I thought many times of this. It is indeed a form of vanity too.

I don't live in the Balkans, but bit North, still in Europe. I'm often in Greece, and have been twice in the last month to Thessaloniki for example even if I don't have relatives there.
 
Last edited:
Hi Giorikas,

To be honest I never heard of this guy before, but I can not believe that so many would be associated with a letter to Obama where it is suggested that another country should be annexed.

Are you playing games with me Giorikas?

Go to the first page of this thread or read it for your self:

Allow me to end this exegesis by making a suggestion to resolve the question of the modern use of
the name "Macedonia." Greece should annex Paionia - that is what Philip II did in 359 B.C. And that
would appear to be acceptable to the modern residents of that area since they claim to be Greek by
appropriating the name Macedonia and its most famous man. Then the modern people of this new Greek
province could work on learning to speak and read and write Greek, hopefully even as well as Alexander
did.
http://www.hellenicleaders.com/Content/Documents/Document.ashx?DocId=43199

He is saying that R. of Macedonia or in his eyes Paionia should be annexed by the Greek state!!!!

Or is that hot air for you?

As for the Nationalism, it is my view, if we share it, it is good, there is hope, at least a spark.
 
Hmm, I started reading this thread in between somewhere at random where I picked up on the conspiracy theories, I see it now. My bad.

I think it's obvious that he doesn't really want or expect an annexation. He's playing with words a bit trying to make a point. Point being that the core of ROM did not belong to ancient Macedonia while ancient Macedonia lies in Greece. You're all a bit overreacting, though I will admit that he should probably not have said that. Also it's not connected to this Obama letter as I thought you implied.

As for nationalism, I do see myself as a nationalist in the sense that I care for Greece and hope that Greece has a good, prosperous, and safe future. That does not mean that I wish the opposite for Greece's neighbours. In fact, Greece will prosper more by having wealthy and stable neigbours, and on a personal level I don't see why there should be any anymosity from us to you.
Now I also believe that the effect of these discussions on these forums is practically non-existant. Neither Greeks will influence a neutral reader, nor will you. There are very few neutral readers reading these forums anyway. The difference is that I'm aware of this of this while others I suspect have lost touch with reality a bit. I suspect that it is some sort of therapy for those far away from our countries. I helps them to feel more of a patriot even if realistically they can not change anything. And also realistically they are not as Greek or Macedonian as they think they are anymore.
 
Point being that the core of ROM did not belong to ancient Macedonia while ancient Macedonia lies in Greece.

Lets talk about terminology now.

When you say "ancient"... you mean what period exactly?

Is it.. 800-600 B.C., 600-400 B.C. , 400-200 B.C., 200-100 B.C.... ???

Select the most "ancient" period that wil suit for you.
 
Very pertinent question Bratot.
Each period has its own nuance and only a blind nationalist fool would attempt to look at one in isolation.
 
Originally Posted by Giorikas

Point being that the core of ROM did not belong to ancient Macedonia while ancient Macedonia lies in Greece.

It only is part of modern "greece" by default. Let's not get carried away here. Brailsford was there and he even states that there was barely any so-called ethnic "greeks" there. However he does mention Hellenized Vlachs and Albanians. Historically you have nothing to do with Aegean Macedonia. Only recently due to occupation.
 
It only is part of modern "greece" by default. Let's not get carried away here. Brailsford was there and he even states that there was barely any so-called ethnic "greeks" there. However he does mention Hellenized Vlachs and Albanians. Historically you have nothing to do with Aegean Macedonia. Only recently due to occupation.

Lets do lil mathematics.

Source: "Linguistic Composition of the Nations of the World: Europe and the U S S R" By Heinz Kloss, Grant D. McConnell, International Center for Research on Bilingualism, Published by Presses Université Laval, 1984, pages 281, 283-292.



linguistic-compostition-000.png

linguistic-compostition-281.png


You can find the topic with full report on our forum.

Macedonian language:


- Year 1978

- 165.060 Macedonian speakers

- Region of Macedonia: cities of Florina,Kastoria,Kilkis,Serrai,Drama and Kavala and the regions of the rivers Vardar,Struma and Mesta

Other figures:

Year - Language - Total Speakers

1978 - Albanian - 450.000 ( Northern Epirus-Chameria)

1977 - Turkish - 101.000 (W.Thrace)

1981 - 7.400 Bulgarien + 35.000 Pomacs(moslems) = 42.400 Bulgarian speakers (Thrace)

Total* non-Greek speakers in Northern Greece in 1981 (Chameria-Macedonia-Thrace) = 760.000 population.



*
without Vlachs and gypsies etc
 
Last edited:
Daniel Tompkins
Dept. of Greek & Roman Classics
Temple University
pericles@temple.edu
May 28, 2009

http://astro.temple.edu/~pericles/Letter.htm

Responding to Professor Miller

To Colleagues:

[Note: in what follows, I follow the lead of 125 nations, including four of the five permanent UN Security Council members, and use “Macedonian” as the appropriate adjective for the Republic of Macedonia. Note that it was the usage of the Journal of Modern Greek Studies as early as 1996. Use of a “politically correct” term would have required, as Chase and Phillips put it, “laborious periphrasis.”]

Stephen Miller, an American archaeologist, has circulated a number of versions of a statement about Balkan politics, with the expressed intent of influencing the Obama administration. I append the version to which I respond below. It differs somewhat from the online versions posted May 20, 2009 at:

http://modern-macedonian-history.blogsp ... ma-as.html

and updated to May 26 at:

http://macedonia-evidence.org/obama-letter.html

Although the ostensive topic is Alexander the Great, the statement commits the author and the many scholars who’ve co-signed to two extreme positions: that President Bush’s 2004 recognition of the Republic of Macedonia by that name “was clearly the catalyst for the fantasies of a Slavic Alexander" or “unleashed a dangerous epidemic of historical revisionism,” and that the inhabitants of the Republic have no right to call themselves “Macedonians.” The first of these claims is easily disproved: the Republic of Macedonia had sought to appropriate, or share, Alexander long before 2004. As to the second, the Republic occupies land that has long been called “Macedonia,” and is, to boot, a sovereign state.

In other words, Prof. Miller takes extreme positions that are not required in a scholarly discussion of ancient ethnicity. Doing so, he converts the thicket of Balkan politics into a lawn. In particular, the challenge to the sovereignty and name of a neighboring state puts Prof. Miller and his co-signers in a position to the right of the Greek government. That’s quite an achievement.

The form of the letter –its seemingly dispassionate appeal to scholars, its assurance in one draft that “many of us would prefer to avoid politics” – should not blind readers to its tendentious and inaccurate historical claims, or to its extreme conclusions.

Let’s start at the beginning. This spring, Professor Miller circulated a draft ( dated January 22, 2009) of the letter we now have. He criticized an article in the January / February 2009 Archaeology Magazine by Matthew Brunwasser: “Letter from Macedonia. Modern Macedonia Lays its Claim to the Ancient Conqueror's Legacy.” Professor Miller complains that the magazine would not print his response (which ran to 1500 words, almost as long as Brunwasser's original). Professor Miller has not shared his correspondence with the magazine. In his short piece, Brunwasser interviews some archaeologists and visits some sites, and says, "Greece insists that Macedonia should change its name, claiming that it implies ambitions over Greek territory -- the northern province of Greece is also called Macedonia -- and opposes the name as an appropriation of Alexander III of Macedon (Alexander the Great), whom the country claims as Greek." A bit later he adds: "But the subtle relations between the ancient Macedonians and Greeks are sometimes lost in today's acrimonious debate over who has the exclusive claim to Alexander's homeland."
That’s it. If I, or I think most of the co-signers, were intent on ridiculing Greek claims, we’d be somewhat more assertive and vicious. Brunwasser does mention a Macedonian kitchen utility salesman who likes Alexander as a countryman, but then quotes workmen with the opposite opinion:

"If we had to choose between Alexander and joining the EU and NATO, we’d choose Europe," says Goran Nikolovski. "History is in the past," says his colleague Zlatko Petreski. "We want the name of the country to remain Macedonia because we are Macedonians," says Nikolovski. "But we want to move forward."

“Sick of Alexander”? “History is in the past”? That is not the way people talk when they’re out to undermine “the scientific basis for our professional lives,” as Prof. Miller puts it, perhaps a tad portentously.

In the body of his letter, Professor Miller comments problematically on both ancient and modern history:

a) The ancients: Professor Miller spends considerable space reciting literalist claims about early Macedonia that can be found on many Greek disapora websites, including a very selective presentation of Alexander I in Herodotus. The goal is to demonstrate a linear and unbroken sequence of Greekness from Alexander I to Alexander the Great and up to today.

Linearity, however, is the stuff of propaganda, not of history. Discussing the Macedonia issue a decade ago, some very prominent Greek social scientists mentioned “the strategic manipulation of nationalist ideology by the Greek government” in its presentation “of political and cultural myths.” They noted that “The historical trajectory of the nation has been traced in a linear form and without ruptures or discontinuities from antiquity to modernity…. Thus, any questioning of the 'Hellenicity' of Alexander the Great is perceived as a threat to the very essence of the nation because it casts doubt on the continuity of the national community through history. The nationalist feelings of the population have … been manipulated by political parties as a campaigning device….” (Triandafyllidou, Calloni & Mikrakis [1997])

Any country seeking to map itself onto ancient history confronts a host of problems. Herodotus illustrates these clearly in his portrayal of Alexander I, who is sometimes a satrap engaged in lucrative dynastic marriage-relations with Persian royalty, and sometimes a "Hellene." He is one of only two people in Herodotus accused of athemista, “lawlessness.” Other Greeks challenge his standing as a “Hellene.” Much of this is well discussed by David Fearn, in a fine recent essay, "Narrating Ambiguity: Murder and Macedonian Allegiance (5.17-22)." Two months ago, when Prof. Miller floated his essay, I recommended the Fearn piece, but there is no sign that Prof. Miller has read Fearn or senses any scholarly obligation to do so. He remains undisturbed by the paradox of this single “Greek” satrap in all of Herodotus.

The claim to be a “Hellene” is one, but only one, of several cards this Alexander plays. He protects himself and his people by cannily playing the odds (and using the talent of silver his mines produced daily). That’s why Spartans and Athenians treat him with such contempt at the end of Book 8. Scholars of ethnicity and acculturation in antiquity won’t be surprised at his ambiguous status, especially given Jonathan Hall's warning against a "transhistorically static definition of Greekness." (Hall, p. 166) Prof. Miller's letter shows no awareness of the anthropologically sophisticated work on ancient ethnicity now being produced in our field.

Now, it is true that both the Greek and Macedonian governments, as well as their diaspora supporters, have gone to absurd lengths to claim ancient ties. The list of examples is endless. Classicists seeking the ancient “Via Egnatia” may be surprised to observe that it now begins in Igoumenitsa not Durres, and lies wholly within Greek borders. The Greek-American Pan Macedonian Union urged not only denial of its northern neighbor's right to name itself and the return of the Marbles, but US intervention on behalf of the "Kalash of the northern Himalayan region of the Hindu Kush Mountains of Pakistan [who] are Hellenic descendants of the armies of Alexander the Great." Skopje claims its own Nepalese "relations" – an initiative the supposed propagandist Mathew Brunwasser has reported many Macedonians find “funny or pathetic.” (International Herald Tribune, October 2, 2008)
For an even-handed comment on the “name” issue, consider Roudometoff in the Journal of Modern Greek Studies:
In the case of the controversy between Greece and FYROM, two identifications have been developed with respect to one homeland (that of Macedonia). Consequently, two narratives have formed, each of which seeks to establish a genealogical tie between a people and the land which that people inhabits…. The affirmation of minorities is interpreted, according to the nineteenth-century Balkan mentality, as representing the first step toward irredentist activity.
Both sides operate with the assumption that nationhood provides the essential component for nation-building. Both view national narratives as providing an essential ingredient for their national identity. The two national narratives, however, encroach upon one another, tending to claim Macedonia … exclusively for their particular side. For Greeks, Macedonia is a name and a territory that is an indispensable part of the modern Greek identity. For Macedonians, it provides the single most important component that has historically differentiated them from Bulgarians.

Elsewhere, Roudometoff says, “Greeks rallied to defend their national narrative--in effect, denying the claim of the Macedonians to stand for an independent nation.” (1999: 459)

b) Turning to the modern world, what is noticeable is Prof. Miller’s insistence that the Republic of Macedonia has shown deplorable manners: "Why would a poor land-locked new state attempt such historical nonsense? Why would it brazenly mock and provoke its neighbor?"

Prof. Miller treats the question as a rhetorical one. But it’s not rhetorical. While I’ve no inside information, the current nationalist tendency of Macedonian history seems in part to be a response to seventeen years of interference and economic oppression by the large neighbor to the south. It’s not only Cavafy’s narrators who celebrate an oppressor’s frustration: “To ousiodes ine pou eskase” (“The important thing is, he blew up”). Monteagle Stearns and Susan Woodward both discussed the danger that Greek actions would have a negative outcome in 1997.

What do I mean by “oppression”? Most notably, the threats of Serbia and the Mitsotakis government in the early 90s to carve up the new Republic between them. Milosevic seems to have proposed the idea. See the discussion of this topic, of the “Samaras Pincer,” and of Virginia Tsouderou’s convenient 1992 discovery of Hellenized Vlachs in need of rescue in Macedonia, in Michas, pp. 53ff. Michas provides some testimony about initial Greek willingness to invade, though he has no documentary proof. Prof. Miller’s little joke (“Greece should annex Paionia”) may betray unawareness that annexation was seriously considered. Macedonians don’t see the humor.

Then came the blockades (I use the plural because Michas mentions several “unofficial” blockades as well as the official one). For 20 months in 1994-95, Greece imposed a crippling embargo that cut off two-thirds of the new state's oil. One Greek official proclaimed, "We will choke Skopje into submission." Export earnings for the Republic of Macedonia fell by 85%, imports of food by 40%, of crude oil by two thirds. Inflation soared. (As Michas points out, Foreign Minister Antonis Samaras was a major promoter of these and other destabilizing measures, in partnership with Serbia's Slobodan Milosevic. Coincidentally, Samaras is now Minister of Culture, in charge of Greek antiquities.)

How many classicists co-signed complaints about that?

Unembarrassed by such cruelty, Prof. Miller pours on the self-pity -- even when he is blind to the irony: “The USA can effect just about anything it wants with smaller countries,” he complains. But it was Greece, not the USA, that tried to “choke” a far smaller and weaker neighbor into submission -- and boasted about it. Blockades are the closest a state can come to an act of war without gunfire.

Officially sanctioned indignities have continued, on a smaller scale, up to the present day. And all Macedonians are conscious that by keeping Macedonia out of NATO and the European Union, Greece is keeping Macedonia poor. Macedonians I met in January marveled at the reports of Athenian youth rioting because they earned “only” 750 euros / month.

The brutal 1994-95 blockade backfired, cementing a sense of national unity in much of the Republic. As Mark Mazower, a real historian, remarked in the Journal of Modern Greek Studies:

[T]he development of modern Macedonian nationalism, and its extension from small groups of intellectuals to a more popular base, depended upon the combined idiocies of three nation-states--Greece, Bulgaria, and Yugoslavia / Serbia….
Mazower, p. 233

That's why Macedonians call their neighbors "the wolves."

The serious problems to be settled in this region trump the name-calling about Alexander. These include the personal and property rights of those who were forced out of the country in the civil war of the '40s (some former fighters were allowed to return in 1982 -- but only those who were “Greeks by genos” or who renounced a more complex ethnic identity). Cases are pending in the European Court of Human Rights and The Hague about both the blockade and property rights. Greece also faces a blizzard of negative human rights reports, including one from the US State Department; Athenian human rights expert Alexis Heraclides has been quoted as warning that current court cases may blow up in Greece’s face.
The area the Republic occupies has been called "Macedonia" on maps for many years, though the borders have long been disputed or “unrectified.” Livanios, while showing that the Great Powers and surrounding nations have been more opportunistic than dispassionate in defining Macedonian ethnicity, says that it is “widely accepted” that Macedonia comprised the Ottoman vilayets of Salonica, Monastir and Kosovo. (4, 46, 67, 77) Note his reference to the “monumental paternalism” of the British. (113) Greek sources sometimes claim that the name of the Republic will spark “irredentism,” but irredentism requires not pictures on t-shirts but military or political action. Greece has a military budget 50x that of the Republic, and a per capita GDP of $8,000 versus Greece’s $29,000. This may explain why Greek sources never specify exactly what danger really looms: the behavior they brand “irredentist” barely merits mention in Myron Weiner’s scholarly analysis of irredentism in the Balkans and elsewhere.

In short, it is hard not to be dismayed at this letter, which rejects modern scholarship on ethnic formation, reads the text of Herodotus as if it was a newspaper, complains about imagined verbal slights in a bland magazine article – and ignores the immense material damage Greece has done to its neighbor – though we must acknowledge that despite the rhetorical noise, Greece and Macedonia now have important trade relations.

There remains ample room to argue about Alexander the Great, and about the supposed “linear trajectory … without ruptures or discontinuities from Alexander to the present.” We ought to be able to do this without endorsing violation of sovereignty or applauding or ignoring efforts to impoverish others.

Prof. Miller hopes to influence the Obama administration, which has acted with cool realism in the Balkans. He says he prefers the goal of right-wing Greek nationalism: a blanket prohibition on use of “the name Macedonia.” But he acknowledges that that is unachievable. (Two Greek diplomats have publicly recommended dropping the name issue. They lost their positions.) He doesn’t mention NATO or the European Union, though they are an important part of the picture. Should Obama, then, force Macedonia to drop its claims to “Alexander”? It is hard to see why, and even harder to see how this issue can be separated from other matters, including NATO, the EU, and the rights of ethnic Macedonians in Greece. (It is Greek policy not to acknowledge the existence of ethnic minorities within Greece.)

Interestingly, many of the sources I’ve cited above are Greek. There are plenty of fine academics, human rights attorneys, and others in Greece who do not follow the company line (one Athenian friend who does not found a swastika painted on his house). I’ve not consulted with anyone I’ve quoted, but hope I’ve represented them fairly. I also recognize that I’ve passed over some issues, including Macedonian sentimentality toward land they recently inhabited. This is just as profound as Greek feelings about Constantinople, “I Poli,” or about lands in Turkey or homes in Alexandria they themselves have lost. My Macedonian friends would love to go to Greece – but to get much-needed work, not to “reclaim” the White Tower.

I’ve worked on Greek causes since 1969, sometimes actively, sometimes dangerously. But I happen to believe that the current nationalist policy toward Macedonia is disastrous and has brought no gain.

Dan Tompkins
Department of Greek and Roman Classics
Temple University
mailto:pericles@temple.edu

Bibliography

Graham T. Allison, editor. The Greek Paradox. Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press 1997.

Mathew Brunwasser, “Macedonia Dispute has Asia Flavor; Claiming Alexander's Heritage, Pakistanis Enter the Fray.” International Herald Tribune (October 2, 2008).

David Fearn. "Narrating Ambiguity: Murder and Macedonian Allegiance (5.17-22)." In Elizabeth Irwin and Emily Greenwood, editors, Reading Herodotus. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press, 2007.

Jonathan Hall. "Contested Ethnicities: Perceptions of Macedonia within Evolving Definitions of Greek Identity." In Irad Malkin, ed., Ancient Perceptions of Ethnicity, Washington DC: Center for Hellenic Studies, 2001.

Dimitris Livanios. The Macedonian Question: Britain and the Southern Balkans 1939-1949. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2008.

Mark Mazower, “Introduction to the Study of Macedonia.” Journal of Modern Greek Studies 14.2 (1996), 229-235.

Takis Michas. Unholy Alliance: Greece and Milosevic's Serbia in the Nineties. College Station: Texas A&M University Press, 2002.

Victor Roudometof. “Nationalism and Identity Politics in the Balkans: Greece and the Macedonian Question.” Journal of Modern Greek Studies 14.2 (1996) 253-301.
Victor Roudometof. “Invented Traditions, Symbolic Boundaries, and National Identity in Southeastern Europe: Greece and Serbia in Comparative Historical Perspective (1830-1880).” East European Quarterly 32.4 (1999) 429 – 468.

Stearns, Monteagle, “Greek Security Issues,” in Allison, 61-72

Anna Triandafyllidou and Andonis Mikrakis, “Greece. ‘A Ghost Wanders Through the Capital.’ In The New Xenophobia in Europe edited by Bernd Baumgartl and Adrian Favell (Leiden: Brill, 1995)

Anna Triandafyllidou, Marina Calloni & Andonis Mikrakis. 
”New Greek Nationalism.” Sociological Research Online 2.1 (1997)
http://www.socresonline.org.uk/2/1/7.html

Anna Triandafyllidou. “National identity and the `other.’” Ethnic and Racial Studies 21.4 (1998) 593 – 612.

Anna Triandafyllidou and Anna Paraskevopoulou. “When is the Greek Nation? The Role of Enemies and Minorities.” Geopolitics 7.2 (2002) 75 – 98.

Myron Weiner. “The Macedonian Syndrome: An Historical model of International Relations and Political development“ World Politics 23.4 (1971) 665-683.

Woodward, Susan L. “Rethinking Security in the Post-Yugoslav Era.” In Allison, 113-122.

Dan Tompkins
5/26/09

Addendum

Just as Jonathan Hall and others have opened up the study of race in antiquity, scholars like Anna Triandafyllidou have enriched our understanding of ethnicity in modern Greece. This is particularly urgent since the government continues to insist that there are no ethnic minorities there. Though her current scholarship concerns immigration -- a pressing problem in Greece -- she's written well on ethnicity too. Her overall perspective is one that classicists would do well to consider when they try to discuss modern ethnicity.

Triandafyllidou has shown, for instance, the problems of the current policy of treating "Turks" not as an ethnic but as a religious minority, noting "the changing character of civic, ethnic and religious identities of the Muslim minority in relation to the Christian Greek Orthodox majority." This concept of "change" permeates her discourse: history is dynamic not static, Greece has changed and is changing. The "dynamic nature of national identity" led to a moment (around 1922) in which "Greek national identity abandoned its irredentist character and shifted towards an ethnic but also territorial and civic definition of the nation in the early twentieth century, through interaction and conflict with neighbouring countries as well as internal social and political changes." Many of these "conflict dynamics ... developed between the nation and the ... other," and the other, too, must constantly be reinvented.

I would recommend any of the essays listed below, especially the most recent. As long ago as 1998, Triandafyllidou was noting that "the claim of FYROM over the ‘Macedonian’ cultural heritage has led Greeks to incorporate Alexander the Great into the classical Greek tradition and emphasize his centrality to the Greeks.'" This was, she says, a shift from nineteenth-century resistance toward all "foreign (including Macedonian) domination.” It began long before President Bush became president and supposedly "catalyzed" the Alexander craze in Macedonia, as Prof. Miller claims. After the disappointments of Andreas Papandreou's final term, she notes, it was convenient to restore "national pride ... in a political discourse which concentrated on the ‘injustice’ caused by ‘foreigners.'"

Triandafyllidou is bolder than many of her colleagues in asserting that "the Greek government and most Greek intellectuals ... tacitly ignored the fact that the indigenous Slavic speaking population of the Greek region of Macedonia was subjected to forceful Hellenization during the first half of this century." She adds that "National consciousness makes sense only in contrast to some other nation," and that Macedonia's displacement of Turkey in the demonization derby has given new prominence to the perceived or imagined virtues of Alexander and Philip.

__________

Note: Many other good Greek social scientists write about related issues. The Journal of Modern Greek Studies is one worthwhile source.

Anna Triandafyllidou and Andonis Mikrakis. “Greece. ‘A Ghost Wanders Through the Capital.’ In The New Xenophobia in Europe edited by Bernd Baumgartl and Adrian Favell (Leiden: Brill, 1995)

Anna Triandafyllidou, Marina Calloni & Andonis Mikrakis. ”New Greek Nationalism.” Sociological Research Online 2.1 (1997)
http://www.socresonline.org.uk/2/1/7.html

Anna Triandafyllidou. “National identity and the `other.’” Ethnic and Racial Studies 21.4 (1998) 593 – 612.

Anna Triandafyllidou and Mariangela Veikou. “Greek immigration policy. The Hierarchy of Greekness: Ethnic and national identity considerations in Greek immigration policy.” Ethnicities 2 (2002); 189-208

Anna Triandafyllidou and Anna Paraskevopoulou. “When is the Greek Nation? The Role of Enemies and Minorities.” Geopolitics 7.2 (2002) 75 – 98.

Taken from Temple Edu
 
Last edited:
I think Obama has much more serious problems than to deal with the greeks.
USA is as far as I can see at the edge of an economical collapse.
 
Lets talk about terminology now.

When you say "ancient"... you mean what period exactly?

Is it.. 800-600 B.C., 600-400 B.C. , 400-200 B.C., 200-100 B.C.... ???

Select the most "ancient" period that wil suit for you.

Why ? It's irrelevant. I hope you're not disputing the fact that the core of Macedonia lies in Greece or do you ? Regardless which era and whether we consider Philip's extension of territory.
 
Why ? It's irrelevant. I hope you're not disputing the fact that the core of Macedonia lies in Greece or do you ? Regardless which era and whether we consider Philip's extension of territory.
This core you speak of has been in Greece for about 96 years. What on Earth makes you believe your statement has any significance?
 
It only is part of modern "greece" by default. Let's not get carried away here. Brailsford was there and he even states that there was barely any so-called ethnic "greeks" there. However he does mention Hellenized Vlachs and Albanians. Historically you have nothing to do with Aegean Macedonia. Only recently due to occupation.

I have heard this story so often...you sound like a broken record. There are no Greeks but Arvanitovlachs etc, etc,....Think of it what you want, it doesn't really matter to me that there is someone in Australia spending a lot of hours behind his PC that calls himself 'True Macedonian' who can not accept that. I feel comfortable enough to laugh at that, knowing full well that NO country can claim 'pure blood', including Greece.

It's obvious that you have difficulties understanding that there is a Greek state, and within it's boundries lies the core of Macedonia. If you can not accept that simple fact, then I understand your bitterness and frustration. You know, talking about this occupation (as if Greece invaded a country with a government called Macedonia ......) makes you bitter my friend. Focus on the future because Greece is here to stay. No inch of it's soil will be given up. I assure you that. You know, good and friendly neigbourly relations....., things that help countries to join NATO and the EU. I forgot, the ROM does not need the NATO and EU and will forge alliances with strong other countries who are begging to get in favour with the new regional superpower called the ROM.

Now if we can cut all the crap about who pisses further, who is more ethnic pure and so on, we could just look at things a bit more pragmatically. So the only question that is on the agenda as far as I see it is 'What needs to be done to move forward'. The answer must be, Greece and the ROM need to find an accord. All other topics you want to include are not on the agenda and will not be either as far as I see it.
 
This core you speak of has been in Greece for about 96 years. What on Earth makes you believe your statement has any significance?

Do you dispute that statement? Do you believe that there is any relevance in saying that it has been in Greece about 96 years? Will the worldcommunity stand up and shout: 'Enough is enough' we need to redraw this border ... it's not fair, we need the REAL Macedonians to take possesion of those historic lands. You know that taht will never happen. So it's irrelevant. It has been in Greece for the last 96 years, and before that a long time in the Ottoman empire.
 
It's obvious that you have difficulties understanding that there is a Greek state, and within it's boundries lies the core of Macedonia.

Greece persists in calling itself Greece or Ellada or whatever.
When it starts calling itself Macedonia, a problem will exist.
But for now ... this is all fluff ... and your pursuits in relation to this matter is evidence of your futility.
 
Why ? It's irrelevant. I hope you're not disputing the fact that the core of Macedonia lies in Greece or do you ? Regardless which era and whether we consider Philip's extension of territory.

It's crucial, since we are talking about the kingdom, not the empire.

If you are interesteed in the starting point only where should we mark the core of Ellas?

Again you will come to two very simple conclussions and two completelly different things. Only in ur narrow-minded thinking the core of Macedonian kingdom belongs to the core of Ellas.
 
Last edited:
Greece persists in calling itself Greece or Ellada or whatever.
When it starts calling itself Macedonia, a problem will exist.
But for now ... this is all fluff ... and your pursuits in relation to this matter is evidence of your futility.

Obviously I'm not a pro like you, even if self proclaimed :detective:. Spending so many hours behind the PC fighting for the cause I guess makes you lose the perspecive a bit. The agenda is much shorter then what you believe.
Now, what you want to call Greece is really your problem. I don't take it seriously, and apart from a handfull of fellow extremists, I can't see too many people taking it seriously.
The only discussion that exists is what the definate name will be of your country, since in parallel to the name you use there is the 'F' word too.
 
It's crucial, since we are talking about the kingdom, not the empire.

If you are interesteed in the starting point only where should we mark the core of Ellas?

Again you will come to two very simple conclussions and two completelly different things. Only in ur narrow-minded thinking the core of Macedonian kingdom belongs to the core of Ellas.

From whicever way you look at it, the starting point is in a country called Greece. Not in a republic North of Greece.
 
Back
Top