• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

Stephen Miller and his anti-Macedonian activities

So once again... Was there a country, your country to be precise, with the name Macedonia that we attacked? Just clarify that point once and for all since a lot of people here seem to have difficulties to understand that.
Was there not a possibility that Greece already at the time considered Macedonia (Greek Macedonia and even more) simply Greek?

First, I would agree with Risto, there was no country named Greece when the French and Brits came to liberate "Greece" but rather attacked the Ottoman Empire.

Was there any Greek state back than??? Why did they come to save Greece when there was no Greek state or Greek country !? What ever your answer is, it apply to Macedonia as well.

You have been very careful about choosing your words by specifying
already at the time considered

maybe cause you know very well that this was not the case before the time.

There are a number of accounts telling us that Macedonia and Macedonians were not seen as Greek until the Megali Idea came to exist.

As recently as the 19th century the official view of Greek history was that "the Greek Peninsula had been struggling for independence from foreign domination ever since the ancient Greeks had been conquered by the Macedonian armies in 338 BC"

Taken from:
Anna Triandafyllidou, "National identity and the Other", Ethnic and racial studies, Vol 21, No 4, July 1998, p. 605

You are good in dodging but you ain't fooling anybody here.
 
Last edited:
Hatred ? Why should I ? I just see a lot of things very differently. As far as your statement about Macedonians fighting for Macedonia, I'd better not enter that discussion. Last time that got me banned so we'd better not speak here on this forum about ehmm, your leaders 'contradictory statements' ....


You seem so very anal about us Macedonians and Macedonia, could you please tell us what kind of a Greek you are? :blink:
 
To the students of Ancient Macedonian History - part 2

To the students of Ancient Macedonian History - part 2

http://www.americanchronicle.com/articles/view/104325

To the students of Ancient Macedonian History - part 2

Gandeto

May 30, 2009

Students, as per your request, I have provided adequate citations for the quotes published in the previous article ("To the students of Ancient Macedonian History" 5/29/2009). Bloggers should have a field day; there is enough ammo to last you for a long, long time. Use it as you see it fit. On this note, I would like to remind you also that under my RSS Feed at the American Chronicle under "Inappropriate Comments by a Distinguished Professor" you will find my answer to Professor Miller´s invectives against Macedonia and the Macedonian people. (http://www.americanchronicle.com/articles/view/93881 Mon, 09 Mar 2009)

Moreover, one of his signatories of the petition, Richard Stoneman—who obviously supports his position—in his book "Alexander the Great" published by Routledge in 1997, on page 81 contradicts himself; he writes:

"The most problematic point about this decree is the interpretation of its legal basis. Alexander was not king of Greece; the free cities were not part of his empire."

(Recall that Professor Miller referred to Alexander the Great as a "Greek hero").

I wonder how many of these signatories are unaware of what they have signed or that they, themselves, have fallen into Mr. Miller´s trap?

Let us continue…

If your professor is one of the signatories of Professor Miller´s petition, sent to our president Obama to "clean up the debris" left from the previous administration—as Mr. Miller puts it—then, you ought to confront them and demand a full explanation for their position. Namely, after reviewing the content of these 130 quotes, one is compelled to ask how and under what conditions can anyone—with clear conscience and cogent argument—place the ancient Macedonians under the same racial card as the ancient Greeks.

It is a proven fact that good educators have moral obligations to explain to their students why they have taken certain positions on specific issues. Good educators provide their students with scholarly evidence in support of their decisions and certainly, good educators disclose all the overriding issues that underpin and prompt their stand. A good educator is like a good coach; he tells his pupils/players what should be done in a particular situation, how it should be done and finally, why it should be done that way. To simply say that it was his belief or that it was his personal conviction, is surely not enough.

Taking a stand on politically very sensitive matters with profound human rights consequences requires both a thorough background research of the issue at hand and an even greater analysis of the potential risks that may precipitate from such an act. Historical issues with political connotations and overtones are the most controversial; the fallout from such an explosive mixture may not only be catastrophic for one party but at the same time it may have ruinous self trepidations for the other. Seeking self aggrandizement at someone else´s expense is a sign of a desperate state of affairs; either your arguments do not hold any water or the water from your arguments had promptly evaporated.

Reading the posted quotes below, one comes away convinced that a great omission and an even greater injustice has been perpetrated against the ancient Macedonians by placing them under Greek history or Greek anything. They can, and they should stand alone in the cusps of history as people who significantly influenced and shaped the destiny of the ancient world through clearly Macedonian flavor. Politics and personal sentiments should be divorced from historical truth. It is a high noon for all scholars, educators and publishers to reverse the outdated—and the trend for unsupported evidence—that ancient Macedonians were Greeks. The time for this fallacy to be thrown into the hip of discarded and no-longer-viable truths is long overdue.

There is not an Indian sophist, not a polished debater, not a slick lawyer, not a common man nor a professional liar that will be able—under any circumstances—to squeeze "greekness" for the ancient Macedonians out of any of these passages listed below without corrupting the text. Our adversaries can slip and slide their way around them—till the cows come home—but they will be unable to change an iota from this irrefutable truth. Even the Gods will yield in front of such formidable obstacle.

The quotes updated:

1. "Here there is a relative abundance of information from Arrian, Plutarch (Alexander, Eumenes), Diodorus 17-20, Justin, Curtius Rufus, and Nepos (Eumenes), based upon Greek and Greek-derived Latin sources. It is clear that over a five-century span of writing in two languages representing a variety of historiographical and philosophical positions the ancient writers regarded the Greeks and Macedonians as two separate and distinct peoples whose relationship was marked by considerable antipathy, if not outright hostility." (Eugene Borza ´Who Were (and Are) the Macedonians?"

(Abstract from a paper presented at the 1996 Annual meeting of the American Philological Association http://www.apaclassics.org/AnnualMeeting/96program.html)

2. "The conclusion is inescapable: there was a largely ethnic Macedonian imperial administration from beginning to end. Alexander used Greeks in court for cultural reasons, Greek troops (often under Macedonian commanders) for limited tasks and with some discomfort, and Greek commanders and officials for limited duties. Typically, a Greek will enter Alexander's service from an Aegean or Asian city through the practice of some special activity: he could read and write, keep figures or sail, all of which skills the Macedonians required. Some Greeks may have moved on to military service as well. In other words, the role of Greeks in Alexander's service was not much different from what their role had been in the services of Xerxes and the third Darius." (Makedonika, Essays by Eugene Borza p.156. Published by Regina Books, California 1995)

3. "What ever the ethnic origins and identity of the Macedonians, they were generally perceived in their own time by Greeks and themselves not to be Greek." ( Borza ´In the Shadow of Olympus´ p.96 n.38)

4. On Alexander's I attempt to enter the Olympic games: "There were outraged protests from the other competitors, who rejected Alexander I as a barbarian -- which proves at the least, that the Teminid descent and the royal genealogy had hitherto been an esoteric knowledge." (Badian "Greeks and Macedonians" in Macedonia and Greece in Late Classical and Early Hellenistic Times. Studies in the History of Art vol. 10)

5. On Alexander the Great: "Characteristically for Alexander despite his thorough Greek education and obviously genuine interest in Greek literature, was nevertheless a Macedonian king." ( Badian Greeks and Macedonians in Macedonia and Greece in Late Classical and Early Hellenistic Times. Studies in the History of Art vol. 10)

6. On Demosthenes' tirades about Macedonians: "... we are concerned only with sentiment, which is itself historical fact and must be taken seriously as such. In these tirades we find not only the Hellenic descent of Macedonian people (which few seriously accepted) totally denied, but even that of the king." (Badian Greeks and Macedonians in Macedonia and Greece in Late Classical and Early Hellenistic Times. Studies in the History of Art vol. 10)

7. "Philip had not tried to pass of his Macedonians as Greeks" (Ibid)

8. Alexander never tried to impose Greek on his Macedonian infantry, or to integrate it with Greek 'foreign' individuals". (Ibid)

9 "As Callisthenes was a Greek, there was no question of trying him by the Macedonian army." (Wilcken, Alexander the Great p. 170).

10. "Even in Philip's day the Greeks saw in the Macedonians a non-Greek foreign people, and we must remember this if we are to understand the history of Philip and Alexander, and especially the resistance and obstacles which met them from the Greeks. The point is much more important than our modern conviction that Greeks and Macedonians were brethren, this was equally unknown to both, and therefore could have no political effect." (Ibid p. 22-3).

11. "The dislike was reciprocal, for the Macedonians have grown into a proud masterful nation, which with highly developed national consciousness looked down upon the Hellenes with contempt. This fact too is of prime importance for the understanding of later history." (Ibid p. 26).

12. "In my view there is nothing at all surprising in the use of Macedonian. Alexander was calling his hypaspists, who were Macedonians, and he addressed them in their native language/dialect." (A.B. Bosworth Ancient History Bulletin 10.1 (1996) 19-30).

13. "Alexander's invitation to speak (Curt. 6. 9. 34) presupposes that the entire army spoke Macedonian." (Ibid)

14. "Alexander's challenge presupposes that all the army would understand an address in Macedonian." (Ibid)

15. "He used Macedonian because the troops would instantly understand and (he expected) would react immediately. There is no need for more complicated explanation." (Ibid)

16. "The turning-point in the evolution of Alexander's army appears to have been the year 330. Until then the Macedonian component was progressively reinforced, reaching peaks before Issus and after the arrival of Amyntas' great contingent late in 331. Alexander then thought it safe to divest himself of non-Macedonian troops". (Bosworth "Conquest and Empire - The Reign of Alexander the Great" p. 271).

17. "The forces from the Corinthian League, infantry and cavalry, were demobilised from Ecbetana in the spring of 330; [Arr. III.19.6-7; Plut. Al. 42.5; Diod. XVII.74.3-4; Curt. VI.2.17] even the Thessalian cavalry who re-enlisted were dismissed at the Oxus less than a year later (Arr. III.29.5) Alexander now relied on the Macedonian nucleus for front-line work and the mercenaries for support function." (Ibid 271).

18. "The structure of command seems to have been parallel to that of the Macedonian cavalry, with regionally based ilai, but at the head was a Macedonian commander. The rest of the allied cavalry, predominantly from central Greece and the Peloponnese, was much less important and effective, fewer in number and less prominent in action. Like the Thessalian they were divided into ilai (Tod. GHI no 197.3) under the command of a Macedonian officer." (Ibid p. 264).

19. "The infantry from the allied Greek states is more problematic. They formed a contingent numerically strong, 7,000 of them crossing the Hellespont in 334, and they were predominantly heavy-armed hoplites. But once in Asia they are mainly notable for their absence. There is no explicit record of them in any of the major battles." (Ibid p.264)

20. "There was also the question of loyalty. Alexander might well have been reluctant to rely on men recently vanquished at Chaeronea to face the Hellenic mercenaries in Persian service. It was too much kin against kin, and his Greek allies naturally had less stomach for the task than his native Macedonians." (Ibid p. 264)

21. "The mythical imagination was always fertile in Greece, and it would have found Greek ancestors for the Macedonian people as easily as it had done for the royal line" ("Alexander the Great and the Hellenistic World" Pierre Jouguet p. 70)

22. "He knew from experience that in the eyes of the Macedonians he was still a Greek, a foreigner. Plutarch praised his charming and refined manners, which were very unlike the haughty airs of the noble Macedonian officer." (Ibid p.142).

23. "But he was not a Macedonian, and the Macedonians did not look upon him as an equal. This may have been one reason for his tenacious loyalty to the cause of the Kings; his fortune was bound up with the Empire, and in the case of a partition he would not have received the support of the Macedonian troops in securing a portion for himself." (Ibid p.129).

24. "To endure and maintain a royal garrison must have been, for a city, one of the most certain signs of servitude. As a rule, except in the cases of strategical necessity, Alexander seems to have abstained as much as possible from inflicting the presence of his soldiers and the duty of maintaining them on Greek cities." (Ibid .p 87).

25. "So Greece was in a peculiar situation. It was not properly incorporated in the Empire. It was attached to it by a treaty of alliance which consecrated the hegemony of one ally, without injuring the autonomy of the states. It was directed rather than ruled. But it did not resign itself readily to this secondary role, or to the menace which was always suspended over its liberties. And, indeed, while it was to be feared that Alexander could not be content with this hazardous limited authority, it might also be foreseen that the most serious obstacles to the accomplishments of his designs would come from Greece." (Ibid p.71).

"But there were more serious difficulties- the resentment of those defeated at Chaeronea, the political selfishness of each city, the historical past, binding the great states to their traditions, and an invincible repugnance for accepting national unity imposed by a foreign sovereign." (Ibid p. 70).

27. On Macedonian ethnicity] "So little do the Macedonians seem to have belonged to the Hellenic community at the beginning, that they did not take part in the great Games of Greece, and when the Kings of Macedon were admitted to them, it was not as Macedonians, but as Heraclids. Isocrates, in the 'Philip' praises them for not having imposed their kingship on the Hellenes, to whom the kingship is always oppressive, and for having gone among foreigners to establish it. He, therefore, did not regard the Macedonians as Greeks." (Ibid p.68).

28. "It is sufficient for our purposes to note that the Hellenes and the Macedonians regarded themselves as different nations, and this feeling did not ceased to be the source of great difficulties for the union of Greece under Macedonian rule. When the union was achieved, it was only by policy of force." (Ibid p. 68).

29. "The architect was a King of Macedon, and he never forgot his origin, even when, after he had accumulated many crowns, his suspicious comrades accused him of denying it. Alexander always wore the insignias of his national kingship -- the purple cloak, the Kausia, or great hat adorned with purple, and the Macedonian boots. With the insignia, he retained to the end of his life the simple, free manners of his forbears." (Ibid p.62).

30. "It was quite certain that Alexander would not be content. He had called himself the avenger of Greece, and had begun the war in the capacity of Strategos of all the Hellenes, but he meant the war chiefly to serve the greatness of Macedonia. That is why there were so few Greeks in the army, which was mainly Macedonian; the Macedonians alone were sufficiently attached to the royal house of their country to follow Alexander in an undertaking for which Asia Minor was already too small a prize." (Ibid p. 20).

31. "Alexander had left Antipatros 12,000 foot and 1,500 horse, to protect Macedonia and to watch Greece." (Ibid p. 9).

32. "The Colonels, as it happened, promoted Alexander as a great Greek hero, especially to army recruits: the Greeks of the fourth century BC, to whom Alexander was a half-Macedonian, half-Epirote barbarian conqueror, would have found this metamorphosis as ironic as I did." (Peter Green "Alexander of Macedon 356-323 B.C. A Historical Biography" xv).

33. "Macedonia was the first large territorial state with an effective centralized political, military and administrative structure to come into being on the continent of Europe." (Ibid p.1).

"No one had forgotten that Alexander I, known ironically as the philhellene, had been debarred from the Olympic Games until he manufactured a pedigree connecting the Argeads with the ancient Argive kings." (Ibid p.7).

34. "Isocrates' letter to Philip II where he, Isocrates refers to Philip as one who has been blessed with untrammeled freedom to consider Hellas your fatherland Green calls this a rhetorical hyperbole. Indeed, taken as a whole the Address to Philip must have caused its recipient considerable sardonic amusement." (Ibid p.49).

35. "And though Philip did not give a fig for Panhellenism as an idea, he at once saw how it could be turned into highly effective camouflage (a notion which his son subsequently took over ready-made). Isocrates had, unwittingly, supplied him with the propaganda-line he needed. From now on he merely had to clothe his Macedonian ambitions in a suitable Panhellenic dress." (Ibid p. 50).

36. "The Greeks had done a deal with Artaxerxes, (Persian commander), and if Philip did not move fast it would be they who invaded his territory, not he theirs. In the event, he moved faster than anyone could have predicted". (Ibid p.69).

37. "The Greek states retained no more than a pale shadow of their former freedom". (Ibid p.80).

38. "The dedication of the Philipeum was a salutary reminder that from now on, whatever democratic forms might be employed as a salve to the Greeks' self-respect, it was Philip who led and they who followed." (Ibid p. 86).

39. "Philip's Panhellenism was no more than a convenient placebo to keep his allies quiet, a cloak for further Macedonian aggrandizement." (Ibid p.87).

40. "Most Greek statesmen recognized this only too well. To them, their self-styled hegemon was still a semi-barbarian autocrat, whose wishes had been imposed on them by right of conquest; and when Alexander succeeded Philip, he inherited the same bitter legacy of hatred and resentment - which his own policies did little to dispel." (Ibid p.87).

41. "The military contingent they supplied were, in reality, so many hostages for their good behavior. As we shall see, whenever they saw the slightest chance of throwing off the Macedonian yoke, they took it." (Ibid p. 87).

42. "Some 15,000 Greek mercenaries, not to mention numerous doctors, technicians and professional diplomats, were already on the Persian payroll; twice as many men, in fact, as the league ultimately contributed for the supposedly Panhellenic crusade against Darius." (Ibid p. 95).

43. "In the early spring of 336, an advance force of 10,000 men, including a thousand cavalry, crossed over to Asia Minor. Its task was to secure the Hellespont, to stockpile supplies, and in Philip's pleasantly cynical phrase, to 'liberate the Greek cities'." (Ibid p. 98).

44. "Only the Spartans held aloof. The traditions of their country, they informed the king, did not allow them to serve under a foreign leader. (So much for Macedonia's pretensions to Hellenism.) Alexander did not press the point....." (Ibid p.121).

45. "Darius reversed his earlier policy of non-intervention, and began to channel gold into Greece wherever he thought it would do most good. He did not, as yet, commit himself to anything more definite: clearly he hoped that the Greek revolt would solve his problem for him. But the mere thought of a Greeko-Persian coalition must have turned Alexander's blood cold." (Ibid p.138).

46. "This was the Panhellenic crusade preached by Isocrates, and as such the king's propaganda section continued - for the time being - to present it. No one, so far as we know, was tactless enough to ask the obvious question: if this was a Panhellenic crusade, where were the Greek troops?" (Ibid p. 157).

47. "Indeed, despite the league's official veto, far more Greeks fought for the Great King - and remained loyal to the bitter end - than were ever conscripted by Alexander." (Ibid p. 157).

48. "What is more, the league's troops were never used in crucial battles (another significant pointer) but kept on garrison and line-of-communication duties. The sole reason for their presence, apart from propaganda purposes, was to serve as hostages for the good behavior of their friends and relatives in Greece. Alexander found them more of an embarrassment than an asset, and the moment he was in a position to do so, he got rid of them." (Ibid p. 158).

49. "Alexander lost no time in getting rid of the league's forces which accompanied him - another ironic gloss on his role as a leader of a Panhellenic crusade." (Ibid p. 183).

50. "Their own crews, he pointed out, were still half-trained (the cities of the league must have been scraping the bottom of the barrel when they chose them); and - a revealing admission - a defeat at this point might well trigger off a general revolt of the Greek states. So much for the Panhellenic crusade. Alexander's main fear, we need scarcely doubt, was that the league's fleet might actually desert him if the chance presented itself." (Ibid p. 190).

51. "The truth of the matter seems to have been that Alexander distrusted his Greek allies so profoundly - and with good reason - that he preferred to risk the collapse of his campaign in a spate of rebellion rather than entrust its safety to a Greek fleet." (Ibid p. 192).

52. "The burning of Persopolis had written finis to the Hellenic crusade as such, and he used this excuse to pay off all his league's troops, Parmenio's Thessalians included. The crisis in Greece was over: he no longer needed these potential trouble makers as hostages." (Ibid p. 322).

53. "But Greek public opinion was something of which Alexander took notice only when it suited him; and the league served him as a blanket excuse for various questionable or underhand actions, the destruction of Thebes being merely the most notorious." (Ibid p. 506-7).

54. "It is significant that two native uprisings occurred on the news of Alexander's death, and both of these, as we shall see in a moment, involved Greeks; there were otherwise no inigenous revolts against the colonial government." (Peter Green "Alexander to Actium" p. 6).

55. "Alexander meanwhile dealt swiftly with the unrest in Greece - not only did the Athenians rejoice at Philip's death, but the Aetolians, the Thebans, as well as Spartans and the Peloponnesians, were ready to throw off the Macedonian yoke. (Diod. 17.3.3-5) - and he marched south into Thessaly, demanding the loyalty of its people in the name of their common ancestors, Achilles (Justin 11.3.1-2; cf. Diod. 17.4.1). And with speed and diplomacy Alexander brought the Thebans and Athenians into submission (Diod. 17.4.4-6) Quintus Curtius Rufus "The History of Alexander" p. 20. Penguin Classics).

56. "It was decided to raze the city to the ground as a lesson to all Greek states which contemplated rebellion." (Ibid p.21).

57. "Alexander also referred to his father, Philip, conqueror of Athenians, and recalled to their minds the recent conquest of Boeotia and the annihilation of its best known city." (Ibid p.41).

58. "Your Majesty", said Patron, 'we few are all that remain of 50,000 Greeks. We were all with you in your more fortunate days, and in your present situation we remain as we were when you were prospering, ready to make for and to accept as our country and our home any lands you choose. We and you have been drawn together both by your prosperity and your adversity. By this inviolable loyalty of ours I beg and beseech you: pitch your tent in our area of the camp and let us be your bodyguards. We have left Greece behind; for us there is no Bactria; our hopes rest entirely in you - I wish that were true of the others also! Further talk serves no purpose. As a foreigner born of another race I should not be asking for the responsibility of guarding your person if I thought anyone else could do it." (Ibid p. 112-13).

59. "Men! If you consider the scale of our achievements, your longing for peace and your weariness of brilliant campaigns are not at all surprising. Let me pass over the Illyrians, the Triballians, Boeotia, Thrace, Sparta, the Aecheans, the Peloponnese - all of them subdued under my direct leadership or by campaigns conducted under my orders of instructions." (Ibid p. 121-22).

60. "Besides the Macedonians, there are many present who, I think, will find what I am going to say easier to understand if I use the language you yourself have been using, your purpose, I believe, being only to enable more people to understand you." (Ibid p. 123).

61. "Starting with Macedonia, I now have power over Greece; I have brought Thrace and the Illyrians under my control; rule the Triballi and the Maedi. I have Asia in my possession from the Hellespont to the Red Sea." (Ibid p. 277).

62. " Hitherto the resentment of the Athenian community against Philip had been kept in check by fear; but now, with the hope of assistance ready at hand, they gave free rein to their anger. There is never any lack at Athenian tongues ready and willing to stir up the passion of the common people; this kind of oratory is nurtured by the applause of the mob in all free communities; but this is especially true of Athens, where eloquence has the greatest influence. The popular assembly immediately carried a proposal that all statues of Philip and all portraits of him, with their inscriptions, and also those of his ancestors of either sex, should be removed and destroyed; that all feast-days, rites, and priesthoods instituted in honour of Philip or his ancestors should be deprived of sanctity; that even the sites of any memorials or inscriptions in his honour should be held accursed, and that it should not be lawful thereafter to decide to set up or dedicate on those sites any of those things which might lawfully be set up or dedicated on an undefiled site; that whenever the priests of the people offered prayer on behalf of the Athenian people and their allies, their armies and navies, they should on every occasion heap curses and execrations on Philip, his family and his realm, his forces on land and sea, and the whole race and name of the Macedonians" (Livy's book XXXI.44).

63. "There was appended to this decree a provision that if anyone afterwards should bring forward a proposal tending to bring on Philip disgrace or dishonour then the Athenian people would pass it in its entirety; whereas if anyone should by word or deed seek to counter his disgrace, or to enhance his honour, the killing of such a person would be lawful homicide. A final clause provided that all the decrees formerly passed against the Pisistratidae should be observed in regard to Philip. This was the Athenians' war against Philip, a war of words, written or spoken, for that is where their only strength lies." Livy XXXI.44).

64. "It is not until Demosthenes is fighting the "tyranny" of the Macedonian conqueror that the idea of liberty takes on its true color for him and becomes significant as a great national good. Even then this watchword of "liberty" serves solely to promote his (Demosthenes' foreign policy; but by that time it has really become an essential factor in his envisagement of the world about him, in which Greece and Macedonia are polar opposites, irreconcilable morally, spiritually, intellectually." Werner Jaeger "Demosthenes" p. 93).

65. "In the Panegyricus he [Isocrates] had urged an understanding between Sparta and Athens, so that the Greeks might unite in a common expedition against the Persian Empire. Nothing of that sort was any longer thinkable. But the policy of which he now had such high hopes offered a surprisingly simple solution for the distressing problem that lay heavily on all minds the problem of what was to be the ultimate relationship between Greece and the new power in the north." (Ibid p. 152).

66. "If Philip was not to remain a permanent menace to the Greek world from outside, it was necessary to get him positively involved in the fate of Hellas; for he could not be eluded. Of course in the view of any of the Greek states of the period, this problem was comparable to that of squaring the circle." (Ibid p.152).

67. "But for Isocrates that was no obstacle. He had long since come to recognize the impossibility of resisting Macedonia, and he was only trying to find the least humiliating way to express the unavoidable submission of all the Greeks to the will of Philip. Here again he found the solution in a scheme for Macedonian hegemony over Greece. For it seems as if Philip's appearance in this role would be most effective way to mitigate his becoming so dominant a factor in Greek history; moreover, it ought to silence all Greek prejudices against the culturally and ethnically alien character of the Macedonians." (Ibid p. 153).

68. "With the help of the role that Isocrates had assigned to him, he had the astuteness to let his cold-blooded policy for the extension of Macedonian power take on the eyes of the Greeks the appearance of a work of liberation for Hellas. What he most needed at this moment was not force but shrewd propaganda; and nobody lent himself to this purpose so effectively as the old Isocrates, venerable and disinterested, who offered his services of his own free will." (Ibid p. 155).

69. "When Demosthenes draws up his list of Philip's transgressions, it includes his offense against the whole of Greece, not merely those against Athens; and Demosthenes' charge of unbecoming remissness is aimed at all the Greeks equally- their irresolution, and their failure to perceive their common cause." (Ibid 171).



70. "Quite apart, however, from any theoretical doubts whether the nationalistic movement of modern times, which seeks to combine in a single state all the individuals of a single folk, can properly be compared with the Greek idea of Panhellenism, scholars have failed to notice that after the unfortunate Peace of Philocrates Demosthenes' whole policy was an unparalleled fight for national unification. In this period he deliberately threw off the constrains of the politician concerned exclusively with Athenian interests, and devoted himself to a task more lofty than any Greek statesman before him had ever projected or indeed could have projected. In this respect he is quite comparable to Isocrates; but an important point of contrast still remains. The difference is simply that Demosthenes did not think of this "unification" as a more or less voluntary submission to the will of the conqueror; on the contrary, he demanded a unanimous uprising of all the Greeks against the Macedonian foe." (Ibid 172)

71. "If the Persian leaves us in the lurch and anything should happen to us, nothing will hinder Philip from attacking the Persian king." (Fourth Philippic) Ibid p. 181.

72. "For historians of the old school, Greek history ended when the Greek states lost their political liberty; they looked upon it as a closed story, mounting to a heroic finish at Chaeronea." (Ibid p. 188).

73. "For if any non-Greek power, whether Persian or Macedonian, were to achieve world dominion, the typical form of the Greek state would suffer death and destruction." (Ibid p. 188).

74. "The first resolution passed by Synedrion at Corinth was the declaration of war against Persia. "The difference was that this war of conquest, which was passionately described as a war of vengeance, was not looked upon as a means of uniting the Greeks, as Isocrates would have had it, but was merely an instrument of Macedonian imperialism." (Ibid 192).

75. "Outwardly, the "autonomous" city-states kept their relations with Macedonia on a fairly strict level of rectitude. Inwardly, the time was one of dull pressure and smoldering distrust, flaring up to a bright flame at the least sign of any tremor or weakness in Macedonia's alien rule - for that is how her surveillance was generally regarded. This excruciating state of affairs continued as long as any hope remained. Only when the last ray of hope was extinguished and the last uprising had met disaster, did quiet finally settle down upon Greece -- the quiet of the graveyard." (Ibid p. 192).

76. "Then when Alexander suddenly died in the flower of his age, and Greece rose again for the last time, Demosthenes offered his services and returned to Athens. But after winning a few brilliant successes, the Greeks lost their admirable commander Leosthenes on the field of battle; and his successors was slain at Crannon on the anniversary of Chaeronea; the Athenians then capitulated, and, under pressure of threats from Macedonia, suffered themselves to condemn to death the leader of the "revolt." (Ibid p. 196).

77. "The dispute of modern scholars over the racial stock of the Macedonians have led to many interesting suggestions. This is especially true of the philological analysis of the remains of the Macedonian language by O. Hoffmann in his Makedonen etc. Cf. the latest general survey of the controversy in F. Geyer and his chapter on prehistory. But even if the Macedonians did have some Greek blood- as well as Illyrian- in their veins, whether originally or by later admixture, this would not justify us in considering them on a par with the Greeks in point of race or in using this as historical excuse for legitimizing the claims of this bellicose peasant folk to lord it over cousins in the south of the Balkan peninsula so far ahead of them in culture. It is likewise incorrect to assert that this is the only way in which we can understand the role of the Macedonian conquest in Hellenizing the Orient. But we can neglect this problem here, as our chief interest lies in discovering what the Greeks themselves felt and thought. And here we need not cite Demosthenes' well-known statements; for Isocrates himself, the very man who heralds the idea of Macedonian leadership in Hellas, designates the people of Macedonia as members of an alien race in Phil.108. He purposely avoids the word barbaroi but this word is one that inevitably finds a place for itself in the Greek struggle for national independence and expresses the views of every true Hellene. Even Isocrates would not care to have the Greeks ruled by the Macedonian people: it is only the king of Macedonia, Philip, who is to be the new leader; and the orator tries to give ethnological proof of Philip's qualifications for this task by the device of showing that he is no son of his people but, like the rest of his dynasty, a scion of Heracles, and therefore of Greek blood." (Ibid p. 249).

78. "So far as we can tell, the belief that the "Macedonians" of the coast-planes and the men of the hills were distinct people with distinct traditions and claims was held not only in Greece but in Macedonia as well." David G. Hogarth "Philip and Alexander of Macedon" (p. 7).

79. "Philip demanded that the Lyncestian towns be surrendered at discretion and the Illyrian allies be sent away. The armies met, and Philip experimented for the first time in the new tactics, which were to crush Greece and conquer Asia." (Ibid p. 50).

80. "Philip began enrolling his subjects according to their local and tribal divisions and assigned them to standing territorial regiments. These standing regiments were known each by its colonel's name and quoted thus by Arrian. "All were called 'Macedonians'; the only general distinction, made thereafter, is between Macedonians and Greeks, Thracians and Illyrians." (Ibid p. 54).

81. "As Philip had extended the honourable title of 'King's Followers' to all his native cavalry, so he took the corresponding term 'pezshatairoi', and applied it to all the Macedonian infantry, whether of his clan or no: thus distinguishing the new nation from the Greeks, as the clan had once distinguished itself from the feudatories." (Ibid p. 56).

82. "During the winter he pressed the Thessalians to supply better support, and when he came south again in the spring of 352 he was able to take the field with more than twenty thousand foot and three thousand horse. A host of knights and mercenaries, superior to his own, was awaiting him, and in the plain of Volo Philip fought his first great battle on Greek soil." (Ibid p. 70).

83. "While Philip was conquering (342) the western shores of the Black Sea, and the northern coast of the sea of Marmora, and all inland up to the Danube, the Greek states conspire against him forming a kind of anti-Macedonian League. "They sent envoys up to the Great King in Susa, to warn him of Philip's panhellenic project, and induce him to assist Philip's enemies." (Ibid p. 108).

84. "The interest of the modern world in Philip, and his place in universal history, depend after all most on his relation to Greek civilization. Therefore, we must examine, in conclusion, the indictment so often repeated, that the Macedonian destroyed Hellenic liberty, and the measure of the wrong he did to civilization, if that indictment be true." (Ibid p. 145).

85. "Alexander came, then, in this April of 334, to the shore of Dardanelles, with an ambition to possess all Persia as already he possessed all Greece." (Ibid p.177).

86. "It is a small matter, but a straw on the stream of events. What had happened since the 'Cavalry Battle', to ease the conscience of the Captain--General? In effect enough to make Miletus a point clearly marked in the passing of the enthusiastic boy into the calculating man of affairs. For those two months had proved to demonstration nothing less than that the maritime states of Hellas, those that alone greatly mattered, were in their hearts not for Alexander, but for his enemies. The larger islands, Rhodes, Chios, and Lesbos, and nearly all the lesser, kept open ports to the Persian admirals, and the city of Athens had been at no pains to disguise her sympathies. Her continental position and twenty of her ships, held as hostages by the Macedonian, made her warn Pharnabazus off the Piraeus; but openly she sat within her walls watching for the first Macedonian reverse, and indeed had sent already, or was about to send soon, an envoy direct to Darius." (Ibid p. 179).

87. "Therefore, at Miletus, the first sanguine hour of Alexander's life has closed, and on the wreck of his exuberant illusions begins his rise a sterner purpose. Greece must be coerced if she will not be courted. Her command of the seas shall be broken by the capture of the coasts of the Levant, and her people be bent willy nilly to the panhellenic work." (Ibid p. 180).

89. "In the face of present hostility, however, it was no longer worth while to maintain an offensive fleet; and, accordingly, he issued now his much canvassed decision to 'burn his boats' and leave himself stranded in Asia." (Ibid p. 180).

90. "This early disillusionment, though it cooled the boy's spirit all too soon, and when pressed home by much future trouble with Greeks, embittered him not a little, and forced him in the end to adapt a policy alien to modern sympathy, was in certain ways salutary." (Ibid p. 180-81).

91. "Certain consequence of Issus, however, is of more importance to Alexander's individual history than the battle itself; for through it, in two ways, illumination come to him, and a distinct change in his personal attitude ensues. In the first place, not only had he been placed by the capture of Darius' baggage in possession of much correspondence between the Great King and Hellenic states, but also, for the first time, he had seized in flagrant fault the persons of Hellenic envoys sent up to the Persians." (Ibid p. 185).

92. "He was officially both King of Macedon, and Federal Captain-General of the Hellenes; but neither the habitual attitude of his Macedonians towards his Greeks, nor of his Greeks towards his Macedonians, was consistent with the relation in which each stood to the general." (Ibid p. 207).

93. "The attitude of the Hellenes in Greece had raised, as we have seen, a first difficulty; the attitude of the older Macedonians was now raising a second. The party which Parmenio led had no panhellenic ideals. They would have had Alexander even as Philip and his forefathers had been--feudal king of the Macedonians, conqueror of the Greeks if he would, and of the Persians if he could." (Ibid p. 207).

94. "The Roman general replied that his duty dictated an answer which was both simple and clear. He demanded that Philip should withdraw from the whole of Greece, restore to each of the states the prisoners and deserters he was holding, hand over to the Romans the region of Illyria which he had seized after the treaty that had been made in Epirus, and so on...." Book XVIII, I. (Penguin Classics) Polybius "The Rise of the Roman Empire" p. 495).

95. "But what is most outrageous of all is that they should attempt to put themselves on the same footing as the Romans and demand that the Macedonians should withdraw from the whole of Greece. To use such language is arrogant enough in the first place, but while we may endure this from the Romans, it is quite intolerable coming from the Aetolians. In any case,' he continued, 'what is this Greece which you demand that I should evacuate, and how do you define Greece? Certainly most of the Aetolians themselves are not Greeks! The countries of the Agraae, the Apodotea, and the Aphilochians cannot be regarded as Greek. So do you allow me to remain in those territories?"( Polyb. XVIII, 5).

96. "When he received the report that Alexander was moving forward to the attack, he sent some 30,000 mounted troops and 20,000 light infantry across the river Pinarus, to give himself a chance of getting the main body of his army into position without molestation. His dispositions were as follows: in the van of his heavy infantry were his 30,000 Greek mercenaries, facing the Macedonian infantry, with some 60,000 Persian heavy infantry- known as Kardakes."

97. "Darius' Greeks fought to thrust the Macedonians back into the water and save the day for their left wing, already in retreat, while the Macedonians, in their turn, with Alexander's triumph plain before their eyes, were determined to equal his success and not forfeit the proud title of invincible, hitherto universally bestowed upon them. The fight was further embittered by the old racial rivalry of Greek and Macedonian." (Arrian "The Campaigns of Alexander" Penguin Classics p. 114).

98. "In the spring of 334 Alexander set out from Macedonia, leaving Antipater with 12,000 infantry and 1,500 cavalry to defend the homeland and to keep watch on the Greek states." (Ibid p. 34).

99. "In the first place, it was to rush blindly into a naval engagement against greatly superior forces, and with an untrained fleet against highly trained Cyprian and Phoenician crews; the sea, moreover, was a tricky thing - one could not trust it, and he was not going to risk making a present to the Persians of all the skill and courage of his men; as to defeat, it would be very serious indeed and would affect profoundly the general attitude to the war in its early stages, above all by encouraging the Greeks to revolt the moment they got news of a Persian success at sea." (Ibid p. 80).

100. "...But let me remind you: Through your courage and endurance you have gained possession of Ionia, the Hellespont, both Phrygias, Cappadocia, Paphlagonia, Lydia, Caria, Lycia, Pamphylia, Phoenicia and Egypt; the Greek part of Libya is now yours, together with much of Arabia, lowland Syria, Mesopotamia, Babylon, and Susia;........."(Ibid p. 292).

101. "Come, then; add the rest of Asia to what you already possess - a small addition to the great sum of your conquests. What great or noble work could we ourselves have achieved had we thought it enough, living at ease in Macedon, merely to guard our homes, excepting no burden beyond checking the encroachment of the Thracians on our borders, or the Illyrians and Triballians, or perhaps such Greeks as might prove a menace to our comfort." (Arrian, Book 5 p. 294).

102. "We have already inferred from the incident at the Olympic Games c.500 that the Macedonians themselves, as opposed to their kings, were considered not to be Greeks. Herodotus said this clearly in four words, introducing Amyntas, who was king c.500, as 'a Greek ruling over Macedonians' (5.20. 4), and Thucydides described the Macedonians and other northern tribes as 'barbarians' in the sense of 'non-Greeks', despite the fact that they were Greek-speaking. (Thuc. 2. 80. 5-7; 2. 81. 6; 4. 124.1) (NGL Hammond "The Macedonian State" p. ?).

103. "These instances show us that even Philip II and Alexander III introduced very few Greeks into the Assembly of Macedones. They wanted the 'Macedones' to have their own esprit de corps; and those of them who came from Lower Macedonia continued to speak the Macedonian dialect among themselves and to address the king or a commander in that dialect as a sign of affection." An ordinary soldier is represented as speaking in the Macedonian dialect to the dying Alexander in Ps-Callisthenes B 32. 14 (ed. Kroll), and the Macedonian soldiers greeted Eumenes in the Macedonian dialect when he came to command them (Plu. Eum. 14. 11). Ibid p. 64.

104. "Alexander's Macedonian advisers feared that a crisis was at hand and urged the young king to leave the Greek states to their own devices and refrain from using any force against them." (Plutarch "The Age of Alexander" Penguin Classics (p. 263).

105. "Thebans countered by demanding the surrender of Philotas and Antipater and appealing to all who wished to liberate Greece to range themselves on their side, and at this Alexander ordered his troops to prepare for battle." (Ibid p. 264).

106. '"It was Asclepiades, the son of Hipparchus, who first brought the news of Alexander's death to Athens. When it was made public, Demades urged the people not to believe it: If Alexander were really dead, he declared, the stench of the corpse would have filled the whole world long before." (Ibid p. 237).

107. 'If only your strength had been equal, Demosthenes, to your wisdom. Never would Greece have been ruled by a Macedonian Ares' (Ibid p. 216).

108. "While Demosthenes was still in exile, Alexander died in Babylon, and the Greek states combined yet again to form a league against Macedon. Demosthenes attached himself to the Athenian convoys, and threw all his energies into helping them incite the various states to attack the Macedonians and drive them out of Greece." (Ibid p. 212).

109. "The news of Philip's death reached Athens. Demosthenes appeared in public dressed in magnificent attire and wearing a garland on his head, although his daughter had died only six days before. Aeshines states: "For my part I cannot say that the Athenians did themselves any credit in putting on garlands and offering sacrifices to celebrate the death of a king who, when he was the conqueror and they the conquered had treated them with such tolerance and humanity. Far apart from provoking the anger of the gods, it was a contemptible action to make Philip a citizen of Athens and pay him honours while he was alive, and then, as soon as he has fallen by another's hand, to be besides themselves with joy, trample on his body, and sing paeans of victory, as though they themselves have accomplished some great feat of arms." (Ibid p. 207).

110. "The maladies and defects in the Greek scene of the fourth century BC were not hard to find. But its great and overriding merit is summed up in the word 'freedom.' With allowance made for the infinite variety promoted by so many independent governments, Greece was still broadly speaking a free country. This freedom was threatened and in the end extinguished by the coming of the Great Macedonians." (Ibid p. 8).

111. "All Herodotus in fact says is that Alexander himself demonstrated his Argive ancestry (in itself a highly dubious genealogical claim), and was thus adjudged a Greek---against angry opposition, be it noted, from the stewards of the Games. Even if, with professor N.G.L. Hammond, we accept this ethnic certification at face value, it tells us, as he makes plain, nothing whatsoever about Macedonians generally. Alexander's dynasty, if Greek, he writes, regarded itself as Macedonian only by right of rule, as a branch of the Hanoverian house has come to 'regard itself as English'. On top of which, Philip II's son Alexander had an Epirote mother, which compounds the problem from yet another ethnic angle." (Peter Green "Classical Bearings" p. 157).

112. "We have no way of judging the authenticity of either the claim or the evidence that went with it, but it is clear that at the time the decision was not easy. There were outraged protests from the other competitors, who rejected Alexander I as a barbarian -- which proves, at least, that the Temenid descent and the royal genealogy had hitherto been an isoteric item of knowledge. However, the Hellanodikai decided to accept it -- whether moved by the evidence or by political considerations, we again cannot tell. In view of the time and circumstances in which the claim first appears and the objections it encountered, modern scholars have often suspected that it was largely spun out of fortuitous resemblance of the name of the Argead clan to city of Argos; with this given, the descent (of course) could not be less than royal, i.e., Temenid." (Ernst Badian - "Studies in the History of Art Vol. 10: Macedonia and Greece in Late Classical Early Hellenistic Times").

113. "As a matter of fact, there is reason to think that at least some even among Alexander I's friends and supporters had regarded the Olympic decision as political rather than factual -- as a reward for services to the Hellenic cause rather than as prompted by genuine belief in the evidence he had adduced. We find him described in the lexicographers, who go back to fourth-century sources, as "Philhellene" -- surely not an appellation that could be given to an actual Greek." (Ibid)

114. "The loyalist of all the successors was Eumenes of Cardia, not a Macedonian but a Greek, which meant that even his first-rate generalship could not gain him the continued support of Macedonian soldiery." (Michael Grant "From Alexander to Cleopatra - the Hellenistic world" p. 101).

115. "Alexander's various successors, to whom Greece was still the most coveted prize, held two conflicting opinions of the city-states (with many nuances in between): that they were still free allies (a view upheld ostensibly, and perhaps genuinely, by the philhellenic Antigonus I Monophtholmos), and, conversely, that they were little better than subjects (the attitude of Antipater and Cassander." (Ibid p. 105).

116. "...the appropriation of Greek Kulturgescichte, and the use by non-Greeks for political purposes against Greeks, is less common, and even less well documented. Here I offer an example of highly effective Macedonian use of Greek cultural history to advance the propaganda aims of Philip II which had the double aim of blunting Greek criticism of his state-building while at the same time cloaking his work in the legitimizing terminology devised by Greeks for their own, often violent, colonizing and city founding activities." (D.Brenden Nagle " Macedonian Appropriation of Greek Kulturgechichte" APA Ancient History Bulletin Vol 10, 1996).

117. "That it has continued to confuse interpreters is testament to the hegemonic power of Greek cultural history and the adroitness of the Macedonians in using this powerful tool of self-identification against its devisers." (Ibid)

118. "The designation of Macedonia as part of Greece has intrigued modern critics. This, according to Schachermeyr, is enough to 'take one's breath away'. He went so far as to suggest that, however brief, it encapsulates a whole and bold strategy: to counter the Great King's strategy of attempting to exploit the age-old distinction between Macedonians and Hellenes. The reason for including Macedonia as part of a larger Hellas was designed to justify Macedonian participation in the so-called war of revenge. Whatever the truth on this point, on the basis of what we know happened in Macedonia in 480, Alexander had no more grounds for carrying out a war of revenge on behalf of Macedonia than he had on behalf of Athens or Sparta. Of course, Macedonians never regarded their territory as forming part of Greece, and certainly the Greek poleis did not regard Macedonia as being another Greek polis. The reason why Alexander here includes Macedonia as being part of Greece may be an attempt to paper over the glaring anomaly between what Philip and he had just done to 'the rest of Greece' and what he is in the process of doing to the Persian empire. The Persians had never done anything significant against the Macedonians. It is noteworthy that Herodotus, although he provides considerable information on Xerxes' activities when he passed through Macedonia in 480, does not record any acts of destruction--- scarcely surprising if Xerxes was instrumental in Macedonia gaining control of Upper Macedonia." (Edmund F. Bloedow "Diplomatic Negotiations between Darius and Alexander: Historical Implications of the First Phase at Marathus in Phoenicia 333/332 BC" APA Ancient History Bulletin Vol. 10, number 1, 1996).

119. "What is more important is the that Chaeronea, Thebes, and Agis make a complete mockery of attempting in this context to suggest that the Greeks in Hellas regarded themselves as willing subjects under legitimate Macedonian kings (Philip and Alexander) or- that the inhabitants of the regions he had just conquered did so entirely of their own will." (Ibid)

120. "In a speech delivered at Sparta in 210 BC the Aetolian Claeneas, appealing for Spartan collaboration in the Roman alliance against Macedonia, is said by Polybius (ix, 28, ) to have opened with the truism: 'Men of Sparta, I am quite certain that nobody would venture to deny that the slavery of Greece owes its origin to the kings of Macedonia'.....He goes on to describe in detail the outrages which Philip, Alexander and their third-century successors have inflicted on the Greek cities." p.92-3 from "The Hellenistic World" by F.W. Walbank.

121. "Relationship with Macedonia was as loaded a question in the third and second centuries BC as it had been in the fourth. The Macedonian policy of controlling Greece was up against the Greek passion for freedom and autonomy". (Ibid p. 92).

122. "The war ended in disaster for the Greeks, and in 261 BC Athens had to surrender. Areus of Sparta was killed fighting near Corinth, and for about ten years Antigonus' control of Greece was unchallenged". (Ibid p.95).

123. "I deliberately refrain from adopting any position on the linguistic status of ancient Macedonians. It has little significance outside the nationalistic propaganda of the contemporary Balkan states, in which prejudice and dogma do duty for rational thought. What matters for the present argument is the fact, explicit in Curtius, that Macedonian was largely unintelligible to non-Macedonians. Macedonians might understand Greek, and some Greeks (like Eumenes) with experience of Macedon might speak Macedonian. However, even Eumenes took care that a vital message was conveyed to the phalangites of Neoptholemus by a man fluent in Macedonian." (Bosworth "The Tumult and the Shouting: Two Interpretations of the Cleitus Episode" Ancient History Bulletin Vol 10, 1, 1996).

124. "There is nothing at all surprising in the use of Macedonian. Alexander was calling his hypaspists, who were Macedonians, and he addressed them in their native language/dialect." (Ibid)

125. "He used Macedonian because the troops would instantly understand and (he expected) would react immediately. There is no need for more complicated explanation."

(Ibid).

126. "Of the nearly 850 persons listed by Berve, 275 are either certainly or probably ethnic Greeks. Of this number, 126 persons are not associated with Alexander's train, and thus outside present concerns. Of the 149 which remain, 69-- nearly half-- are court figures not associated with administration. They include sophists, physicians, actors, athletes, musicians, jugglers, and other entertainers, and a variety of hangers-on. 89 names remain. Of these three are of uncertain ethnic origin. 24 Greeks serve the king in variety of administrative tasks: some are envoys, some are clerks, some financial officers, and some act as the king's agents in local places. They pop in and out of the historical record as Alexander sees the need to employ them. The remaining 53 Greeks serve specific military functions. (Borza, "Makedonika" p.153).

127. "Out of these 53 persons, 22 names are attached to a single unit (the allies from Orchomenos), who, by the way, are dismissed along with the other Greek allies in 330 BC (Only a few short years into the expedition). Fourteen other Greeks hold naval appointments, either as ship commanders in the Hydaspes fleet, or in conjunction with Nearchus' ocean voyage. Four Greeks are in charge of mercenary units, and 9 others have unspecified, low-level military assignments. Seven have duties that did not take them beyond Egypt. In summary, of the 149 known Greeks with official connections to the king, only 35 to 40 held positions of rank- some as officers, some as administrators, but only a handful in top positions." (Ibid p. 154).

128. "It is necessary, in any assessment of the role of Macedonia in the Hellenistic world to bear in mind that although our sources naturally, being Greek or based on Greek writers, lay their emphasis on Macedonian policy towards Greece, Macedonia was in fact equally a Balkan power for which the northern, western and north-eastern frontiers were always vital and for which strong defenses and periodic punitive expeditions over the border were fundamental policy." ".... Macedonians were an essential bulwark to the north of Greece." (F.W Walbank "Hellenistic World" p. 91).

129. "As for you Callisthenes, the only person to think you a man (because you are an assassin), I know why you want him brought forward. It is so that the insult which sometimes uttered against me and sometimes heard from him can be repeated by his lips before this gathering. Were he a Macedonian I would have introduced him here along with you - a teacher truly worth of his pupil. As it is, he is an Olynthian [Greek] and does not enjoy the same rights." (Quintus C. Rufus The History of Alexander p.195)

130. "We then come upon Eumenes' second observation that, being a foreigner, he has no right to exercise command over Macedonians. At no point, however, in Diodoros' prior narrative does Eumenes' Greek origin excite animosity among the Macedonians. More important, Eumenes does not see his foreign origin as an impediment to accepting the dynasty' offer of a supreme command in 18.58.4 and he proceeds to exercise that authority in 19.13.7 and 15.5 without any qualms on his part that he is not a Macedonian. Eumenes' foreign origin does become an issue at one point among the commanders of the Silver Shields." (Robert A. Hudley in his paper "Diodoros 18.60.1-3: "A Case of Remodeled Source Materials.")

Until next time…

Another solid article from Gandeto! :14:
 
Greece Hey Bro! Will you sign my petition? We're trying to erase Macedonian ethnicity

Greece Hey Bro! Will you sign my petition? We're trying to erase Macedonian ethnicity

http://www.americanchronicle.com/articles/view/104453

Greece: Hey Bro! Will you sign my petition? We're trying to erase Macedonian ethnicity!

Alexandra Aleksovska

June 01, 2009

If you are a Greek historian in a well known university, well actually no, if you are an academic with a Greek surname, or you are a Greek historian from the Droysen tradition (say from a German school), it is likely you received an email on behalf of Stephen Miller in the past few weeks.

Metaxas.jpg


He wanted you to sign a petition that was sent to Obama. This petition states that Ancient Macedonians don´t have anything to do with the Modern Macedonians, and therefore the United States should not recognize Macedonia by the name ´Republic of Macedonia´ – its constitutional name. This is the name that America has recognized Macedonia by for the last 5 years, and the name by which 125 countries around the world, including 4 of the 5 permanent UN Security Council members, use. Greece wants the US to use the name "Former Yugoslav" Republic of Macedonia. Greece has about 14 other countries that use that formula, like Cyprus which is a predominantly Greek nation, Australia which has a vocal Greek lobby and the Democratic Republic of Congo – which sided with Greece, it has been reported, because Greece gave them a fleet of old tanks. Despite the Greek nationalism of citizens of other countries, and some politicians who, while elected to represent the country they were elected in, are actually busy working for the Greek foreign ministry, about 90% of countries that have made an official statement in relation to the Macedonian name issue have sided with Macedonia.

Why is this? Why do only 10% of countries that have chosen a side, side with Greece? Because unless we are pandering to our own ethnic Greek voters (who can also vote in Greek elections) or unless we have a new fleet of ex-Greek tanks to commit war crimes with (some DRC leaders are being investigated by the International Criminal Court for using rape as weapon of war, amongst other crimes), why would we care what anybody other than the actual citizens of Macedonia decide to call their own country? Which leads me to another question: If 90% of the world doesn´t seem to have an issue with it, why does Stephen Miller?

First of all, who is Miller? He is a retired archaeology professor from UCLA who spent his life digging up soil in Greece. He is married to a Greek woman and while some may say that in relation to Greece, "you marry the girl, you marry the country" that is not exactly fair. Miller´s position doesn´t stem, as people would like to portray, from a great knowledge of Ancient Macedonia. Miller has only written about the Ancient Greek Olympic Games – not about Macedonia. Many of the names on the list of scholars have not written about Macedonia either – but are minor academics with Greek surnames or Greek historians from the German tradition (who believe that Alexander was a pro-Greek super-hero rather than a political realist who used equal measures of propaganda and massacre to control his empire). Where on the list are respected scholars like Eugene Borza, Ernst Badian or Peter Green, who have written the most respected books on Ancient Macedonia?

The only real names on the list are Paul Cartledge, and of course the celebrity historian himself, Robin Lane Fox. Fox has taken up NGL Hammond´s old position as the Greek Orthodox Patron Saint of ´Ancient Macedonia Was Greece, Despite What Everybody Else Says´. If you aren´t aware, Fox was recently on a Greek TV show ´Great Greeks´ – where Alexander was voted the ´Greatest Greek of All Time´ by a Modern Greek audience. The Ancient Greeks, who hated Alexander, probably wouldn´t have voted the same way. It is the latest in a series of public statements by Fox to the Greek domestic media in relation to Alexander or the Macedonian issue. He is a celebrity in Greece. Of course if you look at Fox´s first book on Macedonia ´The Search for Alexander´ you will see that it was published with the help of the Greek Ministry of Culture. Fox is deemed to be a politically reliable academic by Greece.

You see, you can´t do archaeological work in Greece unless you receive permission from the State Archaeological Service – a Greek government body. If you draw conclusions that the Greek government doesn´t agree with, you can´t do archaeological work in Greece. It is as simple as that! It reminds me of a famous scholar (who will remain nameless – although those that know him will identify him) who had to be ambiguous as to Alexander´s ethnicity in his writing until he left Greece. Now he has left all ambiguity behind in his more recent books.

Given that the petition is written by one of Greece´s ´accepted´ scholars, and recognizing the bias that that entails, what is the reasoning behind the request to change the US policy on Macedonia´s name? Is there anything that he states in his letter that any of Barack Obama´s advisors don´t already know?

Well, unfortunately, there is nothing new there. It is the same old collection of official Greek statements that have been floating around since the early 1990s when the Greek government paid for full page advertisements calling on people not to recognize Macedonia as a state. Many of those points (long refuted) still float around the internet on places like Topix, YouTube and various propaganda sites. The one thing, however, that did surprise me was the tone of the letter. The language of the letter is so vitriolic it is almost cute! It is like he has been hanging out too long on the Australian Macedonian Advisory Council message board. Let me share with you some of the highlights.

Stephen always refers to "the government in Skopje" Why the reluctance to state the name of the country? Most of the world says Macedonia. His preferred term is most commonly used by the Greek media. It kind of reminds me how many Arab governments can´t say the name ´Israel´ – and how places like Iran use "the government in Tel Aviv". Surely a US academic doesn´t need to act like an Iranian state journalist?

Stephen also stated that "(Macedonia) cannot build a national identity at the expense of historic truth." What stopped Greece doing exactly that? While we are on the subject of historic truth, why don´t we ask about the Macedonians who lived there before the Greek invasion of Macedonia in 1912? Historic ´truth´ is always subject to the perspective of the academic who is evaluating the history. Why does Stephen Miller´s ´historic truth´ mean more than Ernst Badian´s ´historic truth´ (a Harvard Greek Historian who wrote on Macedonia). Given that Badian wasn´t dependent on keeping the Greek government happy to perform his work, I think his ´historic truth´ may be more reliable.

In relation to the Republic of Macedonia looking into the past of its people and recognizing the connection between the ancient and modern Macedonians, Stephen states: "Why would a poor land-locked new state attempt such historical nonsense?" – Gloating about the relative poverty of Macedonia and the fact that it is land locked? How very academic! I guess if we had received EEC/EU aid for the last 30 years and still had the world´s 8th highest debt/GDP ratio like Greece, we might be in a better position to attempt ´historical nonsense´. Greece has really led the way in that respect; just ask any of its minorities.



Because the USA has recognized Macedonia, Stephen feels "It is sad that the United States of America has abetted and encouraged such behavior." Or maybe it is that the United States, like the rest of the world, just recognizes that a nation´s citizenship decides it constitution – not its neighbor´s foreign ministry. The USA recognizing modern Macedonia is a rather odd bone for an Ancient Greek Olympic scholar like Miller to pick. The tone of the letter also seems as if Greece (through Miller) is ´talking down´ to the United States.

In relation to the US policy on Macedonia, let me explain why Macedonia has been recognized. Macedonia has been a keen supporter of the United States, despite its small size – and despite the criticism that the rest of the world throws at the United States. In comparison, Greek media has been a vocal critic of the United States for at least the last decade. The US flag that Macedonian soldiers have fought alongside Americans to protect in places like Afghanistan is regularly burnt on the streets of Athens. In their respect for their own and other people´s freedoms, the Macedonian people are a lot more like the Americans. The Greek government, in its attempts to bully and isolate its neighbors and deny ethnicities is acting much more like the Peoples Republic of China than the United States. Maybe we should lobby countries to force Greece to have its name changed to the People´s Republic of Greece?

America does not owe Greece any favors. Remember according to Eleftherotipia´s poll of the 16th September 2001, 25% of Greeks believed that ´justice was done´ on September 11 2001. A few days after September 11, during a football match between Scotland and Greece, when the Scots held a minute of silence for the victims of 9/11 – the Greek fans jeered and booed and tried to burn a US flag. The most popular book about September 11 in Greece, written by Manolis Vasilakis, if translated into English, would be titled ´They had it coming´. Does Greece really expect the United States to bend to their will on this issue, given the hostility Greece has towards America?

Stephen Miller repeated the old ´Republic of Macedonia is only a small part of Ancient Macedonia´ argument that Hammond used to state in the 1990s. That is somewhat true; however it does neglect one very important detail. The ´elephant in the room´ in this argument has always been the fact that Modern Greece stole Macedonia from the Macedonians in 1913. It is more correct to say rather than "the Republic of Macedonia is only a small part of Ancient Macedonia", that "the Republic of Macedonia is only a small part of Macedonia prior to it being divided up by its neighbors in 1913". Prior to this there was not a single part of Macedonia that was Greek – ever. In stating that they have almost all of Ancient Macedonia, Greece is trying to assert ownership over the identity of Macedonians – all Macedonians.

Of course whatever label you choose to use for the land, there is one thing that cannot be argued – parentage as defined by genetic research. One third of Macedonians, according to the worlds biggest gene lab, have genetic links to the Ancient Macedonians, but only 5% of Greeks (mainly the ethnic Macedonian minority) have these genetic links. Greek pressure on academics or abuse of procedure in NATO or EU cannot change genetic reality. The fact that somebody steals your land and evicts you from it, as Greece did to many Macedonians, doesn´t mean that they also steal your ancestors. I have a house that was previously owned by a Melanesian Australian. His ancestors came from the Solomon Islands in the 19th century as sugar cane slaves. When I bought the house two years ago, he didn´t transfer his ancestors; although I might check the contract – if I got his ancestors too, I might be able to get free accommodation on some beautiful Pacific island.

No matter what Greece likes to think, and no matter what it states through its captive academic mouthpieces like Miller, Macedonia is not something that was frozen in time in the 4th century BC and then defrosted by the Greeks in the 20th century. Macedonians had children and continued to live in Macedonia from the time of Alexander to the present day. This may be inconvenient to Greek nationalists – but with such a bizarre view of the world as they hold – truth never is convenient.

The thing I find most offensive about the whole petition isn´t the tone and the language, it´s the fact that these few academics are prostituting academic position for what is obviously the bidding of the Greek government. The act they are seeking is the de-recognition of the Macedonian´s own name for their own country – something the Greek government has been seeking for 17 years. Why can every other country on the planet choose their name, but Macedonia can´t? Don´t Macedonians have the same human right to self-determination that everybody else has? Greece has sought to attack the Ethnic Macedonians in Macedonia and their own Ethnic Macedonians´ identity. The two are linked – Greece has always argued that calling Macedonia ´Macedonia´ will legitimize the Ethnic Macedonians in Greece. Attacks against the Macedonian name are part of an ongoing campaign by Greece to erase the Macedonian ethnicity. If Miller states that the "US has no business in supporting the subversion of history", we can equally ask what business an Ancient history professor has in trying to help a foreign government erase an ethnicity?

You know what the petition is? It is a list of academics that are prepared to put political ends before academic integrity and human rights. An academic is free to state their opinion – but when an academic tries to use their position to push for political ends at the behest of a state, they are no longer acting as academics. These people, by trying to isolate Macedonia, are aiding the Greek government´s attack on Macedonian ethnicity – a violation of human rights. They are smart enough to know that this is what Greece is doing. If I were a university's board, I would be embarrassed to have these people putting the name of my university on something that is attacking the human rights of a people.

How do we as a society with a conscience that respects human rights, show an academic that such conduct is inappropriate? The list is online with their names attached. Boycott the books of the academics on the list, do not enroll in their classes, and refuse to work or perform research for or with them. If you are on a selection committee for an academic position, disqualify anybody who appears on this list. No student deserves to be taught by someone who condones the abuse of human rights.

So, no Stephen, I will not sign your petition.

Thank you Alexandra for shedding some light on who our dear Professor Miller is. :flowers:
 
First, I would agree with Risto, there was no country named Greece when the French and Brits came to liberate "Greece" but rather attacked the Ottoman Empire.

Was there any Greek state back than??? Why did they come to save Greece when there was no Greek state or Greek country !? What ever your answer is, it apply to Macedonia as well.

You have been very careful about choosing your words by specifying

maybe cause you know very well that this was not the case before the time.

There are a number of accounts telling us that Macedonia and Macedonians were not seen as Greek until the Megali Idea came to exist.



You are good in dodging but you ain't fooling anybody here.

Unfortunately, I have to be very precise in the way I formulate. I prefer to be a bit more outspoken but I can't here. If you want to call it dodging, well, you may.

And yes, there was a Greek state when Macedonia was liberated. Obviously Macedonia was not part of it before, so Greece corrected that. Ideally it would have included more territory from Greece's point of view. In particular in what is today Turkey. These are not opinions. I think they accurately describe what happened.

There's a lot to say about who was seen as Macedonian or not. There's a lot to say about nationalities or the lack of national identity in those days in those places. I believe if you asked Ataturk if he was a Macedonian, he would have answered with 'yes'. But a Turk too. Just to give you an idea. I have seen lists from all different sides where the populations were described. Some based upon language, some based upon 'ethnicity', others based upon religion. I have seen Serbian-Macedonians mentioned there, Bulgarian-Macedonians, Greek-Macedonians, Albanians, Turks, Vlachs, but no Macedonian-Macedonians. Now that might be a mistake, but that mistake has been made consistantly from different sides. Think of it what you will.

Important is that there is a country, the ROM, of which a large number today identifies as Macedonians (and also beyond those borders). The only question that needs to be answered is in what permanent name the 'F' name will be changed. There is no other discussion. Certainly, Greece will not enter into a fascistoide discussion with Mr. Gruevski about how race pure Greeks are or are not.
 
And yes, there was a Greek state when Macedonia was liberated.

Read my question again!?


Follow up good Giorikas, here is how the chat developed:

1) You ask if there was Macedonian state (1913) when Macedonia got partitioned by Greece, Serbia and Bulgaria.

1.1) You ask this question for justifying what all three states did. You say: "There was no State, so we did grab the land's from the Ottomans, not from the Macedonian state and the Macedonians"

2) We asked you if there was a Greek State when Greece got supposedly liberated by France and Britain. Or did they just grab the land from the Ottoman.

2.1) There was no Greek state during Ottoman times, and still French and Brits have liberated Greece, it is your point
2.2) The same goes for Macedonia, with one difference, Macedonia was among the last under Ottoman rule, and was not liberated but partitioned.

3) So if we accept that even though there was no Greek state, but the French and Brits have liberated Greece, which according to you means Greece and Greeks did existed, the same goes for the Macedonia and Macedonians, even you don't want to agree upon.

With the above said, your question is a way of justifying a land grab and denying of the existence of Macedonia and the Macedonians.

You apply a logic to justify Greek existence, but don't apply the same logic for the Macedonians.

You know it, I know it, everyone knows it, that you do it on purpose.
 
There's a lot to say about who was seen as Macedonian or not. There's a lot to say about nationalities or the lack of national identity in those days in those places. I believe if you asked Ataturk if he was a Macedonian, he would have answered with 'yes'. But a Turk too. Just to give you an idea. I have seen lists from all different sides where the populations were described. Some based upon language, some based upon 'ethnicity', others based upon religion. I have seen Serbian-Macedonians mentioned there, Bulgarian-Macedonians, Greek-Macedonians, Albanians, Turks, Vlachs, but no Macedonian-Macedonians. Now that might be a mistake, but that mistake has been made consistantly from different sides. Think of it what you will.

What you say is so easy to apply to any nation on the Balkan, Greeks not excluded, wouldn't you agree!?

By the way, I guess you have skipped many list that are evident to apply to ethnic Macedonian, and you certainly don't think that Macedonian will declare as Macedonian-Macedonians !? :6:

Important is that there is a country, the ROM, of which a large number today identifies as Macedonians (and also beyond those borders). The only question that needs to be answered is in what permanent name the 'F' name will be changed. There is no other discussion. Certainly, Greece will not enter into a fascistoide discussion with Mr. Gruevski about how race pure Greeks are or are not.

The discussion is artificially imposed by you.

And in this discussion there is a big question, what is the compromise on the Greek side !?

My father say's : "If the Greeks insist on the name North Macedonia, than for the sake of the argument, they should name their Province South Macedonia, than we can talk about changing".

Would you agree on such settlement of the issue !? For me it is not acceptable, but what my father say's is logical.

If there is a north there is a south, think of North and South Korea :cool1:

And about Gruevski. Exactly as you started the name change issue, you started the racial bullshit.

You said that we should prove a ethnic and genetic link to the Ancient Macedonians. You are the ones running around and crying out you are Slavs you are Slavs, Alexandro Megali was not Slav. How pathetic, wouldn't you agree.

You hoped it would be one sided. But if this criteria should be applied to us so that we have the right to call us Macedonians, than it is only fair to be applied to you as well so if you have the right to call your self Greeks.

I know you won't agree, but hey, I don't agree with you too, see life is a bitch.
 
Somebody threw the French and Brits into the discussion even if it really does't bear any relevance to the question whether there was a Macedonian state at the time. I did not. Besides, I did not ask a question to justify anything. The reason being: there is no need to justify anything.

We fought for Macedonia and captured it. We did not fight a Macedonian army and we did not annex a Macedonian country. No Macedonian army, government, country or etnicity was recorded in the relevant treaties at all. Just as if they never existed.

I understand the point you guys have been making all along. First of all, let's just destroy this 'Macedonian truth' that Greece exists today because Greece was liberated by France and Britain. While France and Britain certainly supported and were sympathetic to the cause for many reasons, it was sure enough Greeks that liberated themselves. Let's not compare it with how France was liberated in WW II for example.

Now knowing full well that many here are very good in building theory upon theory, I don't want to speculate how that struggle would have evolved without that support of those countries. Would Greece have unsuccessfully revolted, and would a Greek state not have been created, then I suppose that Greece did care enough about it's indepence to fight untill the last man.

Fact of the matter is that Greece liberated itself and had been attempting many times before. Greece was willing to pay a heavy price for that. So did Bulgarians, same with Serbians. We fought Ottomans, and fought between us and declared our independance.

Cutting a long story short. Apparently Macedonia did not fight for it's independence. Think of that what you want but no Philhellene Brit or Frenchmen is responsible for that.
I rest my case.
 
Cutting a long story short. Apparently Macedonia did not fight for it's independence. Think of that what you want but no Philhellene Brit or Frenchmen is responsible for that.
I rest my case.

I rest my case as well, seeing that you turn the blind eye.

Macedonians did fight for it's independence, and there is an amount of documentation about it. You can think of it what ever you like, but you a wrong about that.

I see, you have been ignoring everything that was ever published about this.


YouTube - Ηλιας Î*ετροπουλος-Η Μακεδονια Ilias Petropoulos-Macedonia 1/2

YouTube - Ηλιας Î*ετροπουλος-Η Μακεδονια Ilias Petropoulos-Macedonia 2/2

Discussion with Ilias Petropoulos regarding Macedonian and Greek Issues

Nice interview.....
 
Last edited:
What you say is so easy to apply to any nation on the Balkan, Greeks not excluded, wouldn't you agree!?

By the way, I guess you have skipped many list that are evident to apply to ethnic Macedonian, and you certainly don't think that Macedonian will declare as Macedonian-Macedonians !? :6:



The discussion is artificially imposed by you.

And in this discussion there is a big question, what is the compromise on the Greek side !?

My father say's : "If the Greeks insist on the name North Macedonia, than for the sake of the argument, they should name their Province South Macedonia, than we can talk about changing".

Would you agree on such settlement of the issue !? For me it is not acceptable, but what my father say's is logical.

If there is a north there is a south, think of North and South Korea :cool1:

And about Gruevski. Exactly as you started the name change issue, you started the racial bullshit.

You said that we should prove a ethnic and genetic link to the Ancient Macedonians. You are the ones running around and crying out you are Slavs you are Slavs, Alexandro Megali was not Slav. How pathetic, wouldn't you agree.

You hoped it would be one sided. But if this criteria should be applied to us so that we have the right to call us Macedonians, than it is only fair to be applied to you as well so if you have the right to call your self Greeks.

I know you won't agree, but hey, I don't agree with you too, see life is a bitch.

Hello Makedonin,

No, I don't agree that that could apply to Greeks. And I have not seen any credible proof of a population consensus that mentioned Macedonians as such, right next to Greeks, Bulgarians, Serbians, Vlachs, and so on. Now I would not say here that there were no Macedonians, just I did not see that overwhelming proof.

I understand that that question (the 'F' word) has been imposed by us, but nevertheless, it is there. And you agreed to find a 'mutual acceptable' solution. Let's not bicker about details whether this is right or wrong, it's a fact.
Now all these years many have asked and hoped Greece to forget about that. Greece did not, and in 2009, it's still on the agenda. And it doesn't look likely to go away. Even in Skopje (meant as capital and center of politics dear mederaters) they seem to understand that.

Now again, there seems to be a misunderstanding about what this 'open question' is about. It is not about minorities and neither about Greece renaming anything. Just about the name, though I suspect that there will be an appendix that will clearly demand ROM to not make claims on Greek territory. In other words, you well get whatever permanent official name, and that's it. No freebies from Greece.

The 'ethnically pure' discussion, -contrary to what you think I said- is not something that Greece is putting forward as argument. Greece believes that nearly no country can be ethnically pure. (especially in the Balkans) It does not believe you in ROM have to or can prove your pure bloodline connection to Macedonians. It was never about blood. We base our link with Macedonia upon other things like language (even if evolved in a natural way after thousends of years) for one, but also geographically we are more connected with Macedonians. There is proof that Macedonians identified themselves as fellow Greeks (or Hellenes more correctly). This is on paper.
You practically do not live on Macedonian soil as it was. You speak a Slavic language. So far you have not convinced the world that Macedonians for example spoke another language then Greek, before they jumped to Greek, and then again to a Slavic language. I don't think you will either.

Can't we move away from these discussions. Honestly, it's not that important if you believe me, or I believe you. What matters is the next step.
 
I rest my case as well, seeing that you turn the blind eye.

Macedonians did fight for it's independence, and there is an amount of documentation about it. You can think of it what ever you like, but you a wrong about that.

I see, you have been ignoring everything that was ever published about this.


YouTube - Ηλιας Î*ετροπουλος-Η Μακεδονια Ilias Petropoulos-Macedonia 1/2

YouTube - Ηλιας Î*ετροπουλος-Η Μακεδονια Ilias Petropoulos-Macedonia 2/2

Discussion with Ilias Petropoulos regarding Macedonian and Greek Issues

Nice interview.....

I'll check the youtube proof you provide later.
Honestly, what do you expect me to believe. Many of those you claim to be your Macedonian revolutionary leaders have been making very mixed statements in relation to Bulgaria. That's on record too. (This is just about where I got banned got time .. )
And I don't understand that. I learned here from another poster / moderator that that's what they were made to identify themselves as for years....
Now if you finally start your revolution, your uprising, you risk to get captured and and put to death by Ottomans, now why would you hold back ? Why would you still incorrectly identify yourself as anything else then Macedonian if that's how you feel? That doesn't make sense. Please clarify that.
 
I'll check the youtube proof you provide later.
Honestly, what do you expect me to believe. Many of those you claim to be your Macedonian revolutionary leaders have been making very mixed statements in relation to Bulgaria. That's on record too. (This is just about where I got banned got time .. )
And I don't understand that. I learned here from another poster / moderator that that's what they were made to identify themselves as for years....
Now if you finally start your revolution, your uprising, you risk to get captured and and put to death by Ottomans, now why would you hold back ? Why would you still incorrectly identify yourself as anything else then Macedonian if that's how you feel? That doesn't make sense. Please clarify that.

those revolutionary leaders who were making mixed statements with Bulgaria were called македонски врховен комитет but mro(tmro,tmoro.vmro) were pure and fought for our freedom
 
I'll check the youtube proof you provide later.
Honestly, what do you expect me to believe. Many of those you claim to be your Macedonian revolutionary leaders have been making very mixed statements in relation to Bulgaria. That's on record too. (This is just about where I got banned got time .. )
And I don't understand that. I learned here from another poster / moderator that that's what they were made to identify themselves as for years....
Now if you finally start your revolution, your uprising, you risk to get captured and and put to death by Ottomans, now why would you hold back ? Why would you still incorrectly identify yourself as anything else then Macedonian if that's how you feel? That doesn't make sense. Please clarify that.

The revolutionary have made their stance: they declared Macedonians, such as the people of the Razlovci and Kreshna uprising. That Macedonians were considering them as Macedonian descendants of the Ancients was even a problem for the Bulgarian propagandist Slaveykov who was calling them Makedonists. See more Slaveykov. There are many more instance for this.

Thus you're either misinformed or just spining the ball.

But, since the Revolutionary had to prepare the revolution somewhere where the Ottomans had no juristiction, they chose Bulgaria and partially Serbia as their base for preparation.

But hey, the Bulgarians have doing the same i.e. prepared the revolution in Romania, and than with guerilla attack over the border fought the Ottomans. See more on BRCK

But this misfortunate circumstance of placing their base for preparation have lead to misunderstanding, as Sarafov have said it:

We Macedonians consider ourselves to be an entirely separate national element, and we are not in the least disposed to allow our country to be seized by Bulgaria, Servia, or Greece. We will, in fact, oppose any such incorporation with all our might. Macedonia must belong to the Macedonians. The misunderstanding has arisen through our residing in Bulgaria.

Source

Bulgarians were persecuting the Macedonian revolutionary for that matter all the time.

Sometimes, the label Bulgarian was used by the Macedonian revoutionary to conceal in Bulgaria.

On the other hand, the label Bulgarian was something similar to the label Nigger. It was derogatory term used by the Patriarchists, you sure know it, Hondrokefalos Bulgaris, thickheaded Bulgarian i.e. Stupid peasant. That is why the Pasyi Hilendarski asked:

Why are you ashamed to call yourself Bulgarian?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paisius_of_Hilendar

And many were stupid peasants, and as the Negro population in US uses the term Nigger between them self, so did the Macedonian peasants from time to time, until they did not understand that they were asked about their ethnic name. Many were interchanging designation with their church affiliation, but this was at later stage.

On the derogative meaning of the Bulgarian name you can even read from the bulgarians them self from here, just translate it with Google translate.

I know you won't agree again, but who cares.

so I am really off now.
 
Giorikas, your hatred of Macedonians really amuses me.
I am positive if you took off your souvlaki tinted glasses you may have learned something from the preceding posts.
You have said you would much prefer us Macedonians (albeit with a different name) as your neighbours than Albanians or Serbs. That almost sounds nice.
If you would prefer us there, is it ok if we have the same rights as any other sovereign nation? Or would you prefer us there in a different kind of way?
 

Daniel Tompkins
Dept. of Greek & Roman Classics
Temple University
pericles@temple.edu

June 1, 2009



Responding to Professor Miller


To Colleagues:


[Note: in what follows, I follow the lead of 125 nations, including four of the five permanent UN Security Council members, and use “Macedonian” as the appropriate adjective for the Republic of Macedonia. Note that it was the usage of the Journal of Modern Greek Studies as early as 1996. Use of a “politically correct” term would have required, as Chase and Phillips put it, “laborious periphrasis.”]

[I'm updating this letter regularly, redating it each time, partly because I've received interesting and important criticisms.]

Stephen Miller, an American archaeologist, has circulated a number of versions of a statement about Balkan politics, with the expressed intent of influencing the Obama administration. I append the version to which I respond below. It differs somewhat from the online versions posted May 20, 2009 at:


http://modern-macedonian-history.blogspot.com/2009/05/letter-to-president-barack-obama-as.html

and updated to May 26 at:


http://macedonia-evidence.org/obama-letter.html

Although the ostensive topic is Alexander the Great, the statement commits the author and the many scholars who’ve co-signed to two extreme positions: that President Bush’s 2004 recognition of the Republic of Macedonia by that name “was clearly the catalyst for the fantasies of a Slavic Alexander" or “unleashed a dangerous epidemic of historical revisionism,” and that the inhabitants of the Republic have no right to call themselves “Macedonians.” The first of these claims is easily disproved: the Republic of Macedonia had sought to appropriate, or share, Alexander long before 2004. As to the second, the Republic occupies land that has long been called “Macedonia,” and is, to boot, a sovereign state.

In other words, Prof. Miller takes extreme positions that are not required in a scholarly discussion of ancient ethnicity. Doing so, he converts the thicket of Balkan politics into a lawn. In particular, the challenge to the sovereignty and name of a neighboring state puts Prof. Miller and his co-signers in a position to the right of the Greek government. That’s quite an achievement.

The form of the letter –its seemingly dispassionate appeal to scholars, its assurance in one draft that “many of us would prefer to avoid politics” – should not blind readers to its tendentious and inaccurate historical claims, or to its extreme conclusions.

Let’s start at the beginning. This spring, Professor Miller circulated a draft ( dated January 22, 2009) of the letter we now have. He criticized an article in the January / February 2009 Archaeology Magazine by Matthew Brunwasser: “Letter from Macedonia. Modern Macedonia Lays its Claim to the Ancient Conqueror's Legacy.” Professor Miller complains that the magazine would not print his response (which ran to 1500 words, almost as long as Brunwasser's original). Professor Miller has not shared his correspondence with the magazine. In his short piece, Brunwasser interviews some archaeologists and visits some sites, and says, "Greece insists that Macedonia should change its name, claiming that it implies ambitions over Greek territory -- the northern province of Greece is also called Macedonia -- and opposes the name as an appropriation of Alexander III of Macedon (Alexander the Great), whom the country claims as Greek." A bit later he adds: "But the subtle relations between the ancient Macedonians and Greeks are sometimes lost in today's acrimonious debate over who has the exclusive claim to Alexander's homeland."

If I, or I think most of the co-signers, were intent on ridiculing Greek claims, we’d be somewhat more assertive and vicious. Brunwasser does mention a Macedonian kitchen utility salesman who likes Alexander as a countryman, but then quotes workmen with the opposite opinion:

"If we had to choose between Alexander and joining the EU and NATO, we’d choose Europe," says Goran Nikolovski. "History is in the past," says his colleague Zlatko Petreski. "We want the name of the country to remain Macedonia because we are Macedonians," says Nikolovski. "But we want to move forward."

“Sick of Alexander”? “History is in the past”? That is not the way people talk when they’re out to undermine “the scientific basis for our professional lives,” as Prof. Miller puts it, perhaps a tad portentously.

In the body of his letter, Professor Miller comments problematically on both ancient and modern history:


a) The ancients: Professor Miller spends considerable space reciting literalist claims about early Macedonia that can be found on many Greek disapora websites, including a very selective presentation of Alexander I in Herodotus. The goal is to demonstrate a linear and unbroken sequence of Greekness from Alexander I to Alexander the Great and up to today.

Linearity, however, is the stuff of propaganda, not of history. Discussing the Macedonia issue a decade ago, some very prominent Greek social scientists mentioned “the strategic manipulation of nationalist ideology by the Greek government” in its presentation “of political and cultural myths.” They noted that “The historical trajectory of the nation has been traced in a linear form and without ruptures or discontinuities from antiquity to modernity…. Thus, any questioning of the 'Hellenicity' of Alexander the Great is perceived as a threat to the very essence of the nation because it casts doubt on the continuity of the national community through history. The nationalist feelings of the population have … been manipulated by political parties as a campaigning device….” (Triandafyllidou, Calloni & Mikrakis [1997])

Any country seeking to map itself onto ancient history confronts a host of problems. Herodotus illustrates these clearly in his portrayal of Alexander I, who is sometimes a satrap engaged in lucrative dynastic marriage-relations with Persian royalty, and sometimes a "Hellene." He is one of only two people in Herodotus accused of athemista, “lawlessness.” Other Greeks challenge his standing as a “Hellene.” Much of this is well discussed by David Fearn, in a fine recent essay, "Narrating Ambiguity: Murder and Macedonian Allegiance (5.17-22)," which I recommended to Professor Miller two months ago, when he floated his letter. There is no sign that he has read Fearn or is disturbed by the paradox of this sole “Greek” satrap.

The claim to be a “Hellene” is one, but only one, of several cards this Alexander plays. He protects himself and his people by cannily playing the odds (and using the talent of silver his mines produced daily). That’s why Spartans and Athenians treat him with such contempt at the end of Book 8. Scholars of ethnicity and acculturation in antiquity won’t be surprised at his ambiguous status, especially given Jonathan Hall's warning against a "transhistorically static definition of Greekness." (Hall, p. 166) Prof. Miller's letter shows no awareness of the anthropologically sophisticated work on ancient ethnicity now being produced in our field.

Now, it is true that both the Greek and Macedonian governments, as well as their diaspora supporters, have gone to absurd lengths to claim ancient ties. The list of examples is endless. A textbook claims that Alexander I, far from being a wily and self-serving border king, "is the founder of the unbroken unity and acme of the Macedonian state. Having full consciousness of his Hellenicity, he tried, where possible, to help the southern Greeks i the fight against the Persians." (Hamilakis, "Learn History," 55) Classicists seeking the ancient “Via Egnatia” may be surprised to observe that it now begins in Igoumenitsa not Durres, and lies wholly within Greek borders. The Greek-American Pan Macedonian Union urged not only denial of its northern neighbor's right to name itself and the return of the Marbles, but US intervention on behalf of the "Kalash of the northern Himalayan region of the Hindu Kush Mountains of Pakistan [who] are Hellenic descendants of the armies of Alexander the Great." Skopje claims its own Nepalese "relations" – an initiative the supposed propagandist Mathew Brunwasser has reported many Macedonians find “funny or pathetic.” (International Herald Tribune, October 2, 2008)

For an even-handed comment on the “name” issue, consider Roudometof in the Journal of Modern Greek Studies:

In the case of the controversy between Greece and FYROM, two identifications have been developed with respect to one homeland (that of Macedonia). Consequently, two narratives have formed, each of which seeks to establish a genealogical tie between a people and the land which that people inhabits…. The affirmation of minorities is interpreted, according to the nineteenth-century Balkan mentality, as representing the first step toward irredentist activity.

Both sides operate with the assumption that nationhood provides the essential component for nation-building. Both view national narratives as providing an essential ingredient for their national identity. The two national narratives, however, encroach upon one another, tending to claim Macedonia … exclusively for their particular side. For Greeks, Macedonia is a name and a territory that is an indispensable part of the modern Greek identity. For Macedonians, it provides the single most important component that has historically differentiated them from Bulgarians.

Elsewhere, Roudometof says, “Greeks rallied to defend their national narrative--in effect, denying the claim of the Macedonians to stand for an independent nation.” (1999: 459)

b) Turning to the modern world, what is noticeable is Prof. Miller’s insistence that the Republic of Macedonia has shown deplorable manners: "Why would a poor land-locked new state attempt such historical nonsense? Why would it brazenly mock and provoke its neighbor?"

Prof. Miller treats the question as a rhetorical one. But it’s not rhetorical. State-building often relies on archaeology and history, especially if there is pressure from neighbors. Greek scholars have noticed abuses within Greece, and similar patterns have emerged elsewhere, especially in new states. The pressures from Greece in the '90s certainly did nothing to ameliorate this tendency: It’s not only Cavafy’s narrators who celebrate an oppressor’s frustration: “To ousiodes ine pou eskase” (“The important thing is, he blew up”). Monteagle Stearns and Susan Woodward both discussed the danger that Greek actions would have a negative outcome in 1997. As Woodward said, these actions "not only made it more difficult for Macedonian leaders to accept a compromise, but also created a more serious threat to the long-term stability of the region."

What do I mean by “oppression”? Most notably, the threats of Serbia and the Mitsotakis government in the early 90s to carve up the new Republic between them. Milosevic seems to have proposed the idea. See the discussion of this topic, of the “Samaras Pincer,” and of Virginia Tsouderou’s convenient 1992 discovery of Hellenized Vlachs in need of rescue in Macedonia, in Michas, pp. 53ff. Michas provides some testimony about initial Greek willingness to invade, though he has no documentary proof. Prof. Miller’s little joke (“Greece should annex Paionia”) may betray unawareness that annexation was seriously considered. Macedonians don’t see the humor.

Then came the "economic blockades" (as Le Monde, the Wall St. Journal, and BBC among others called them) from the Greek side. I use the plural because Michas mentions “unofficial” blockades as well as the official one. For 20 months in 1994-95, Greece imposed a crippling embargo that cut off two-thirds of the new state's oil. One Greek official proclaimed, "We will choke Skopje into submission." Export earnings for the Republic of Macedonia fell by 85%, imports of food by 40%, of crude oil by two thirds. Inflation soared. (As Michas points out, Foreign Minister Antonis Samaras was a major promoter of these and other destabilizing measures, sometimes in partnership with Serbia's Slobodan Milosevic. Coincidentally, Samaras is now Minister of Culture, in charge of Greek antiquities.)

How many classicists co-signed complaints about that?

Unembarrassed by such cruelty and seemingly blind to irony, Prof. Miller pours on the self-pity: “The USA can effect just about anything it wants with smaller countries,” he complains. But it was Greece, not the USA, that tried to “choke” a far smaller and weaker neighbor into submission -- and boasted about it. Short of gunfire, blockades are the closest a state can come to an act of war.

Officially sanctioned indignities have continued, on a smaller scale, up to the present day. And all Macedonians are conscious that by keeping Macedonia out of NATO and the European Union, Greece is keeping Macedonia poor. Macedonians I met in January marveled at the reports of Athenian youth rioting because they earned “only” 750 euros / month.

The brutal 1994-95 blockade backfired, cementing a sense of national unity in much of the Republic. As Mark Mazower, a real historian, remarked in the Journal of Modern Greek Studies:

[T]he development of modern Macedonian nationalism, and its extension from small groups of intellectuals to a more popular base, depended upon the combined idiocies of three nation-states--Greece, Bulgaria, and Yugoslavia / Serbia….

Mazower, p. 233

Macedonians call their neighbors "the wolves." This term is said to date from the Treaty of Bucharest (1913), one of several treaties in which what is now a state was divided anew; but it retains its currency.

The serious problems to be settled in this region trump the name-calling about Alexander. These include the personal and property rights of those who were forced out of the country in the civil war of the '40s. Since the 1980s some former fighters were allowed to return in 1982 -- but only those who were “Greeks by genos” or who renounced a more complex ethnic identity. (The precise meaning of "Greek by genos" is a topic of discussion: the law has recently been interpreted to refer not to "ethnic identity" but "national consciousness." Konstaninos Tsitselikis, after reviewing the complexities of all this as regards citizenship, states that the law singles out: "persons coming from a different nation and who, by their actions and general behaviour have expressed sentiments testifying to the lack of a Greek national consciousness, in a way that [shows that] they cannot be considered as having assimilated into the Greek nation.” After commenting on older laws that denied a "right to regain or acquire Greek citizenship" to Muslims and Jews after World War II, he mentions the commission established to determine the citizenship status of Civil War veterans from the USSR, which must judge "evidence of ... Greek national consciousness." "Greek law," Tsitselikis concludes, "has invented exclusive categories for those who accept the respective norms on the basis of an objective racial relationship, a concept, which is a priori incompatible with the fundamental principal of non-discrimination, as it has been established in the Constitution and in the international conventions for the protection of human rights."[155])

Cases are pending in the European Court of Human Rights and The Hague about some of these issues. Greece also faces a blizzard of negative human rights reports, including one from the US State Department; Athenian human rights expert Alexis Heraclides has been quoted as warning that current court cases may blow up in Greece’s face, but he appears to be in a minority.
The area the Republic occupies has been called "Macedonia" on maps for many years, though the borders have long been disputed or “unrectified.” Livanios, while showing that the Great Powers and surrounding nations have been more opportunistic than dispassionate in defining Macedonian ethnicity, says that it is “widely accepted” that Macedonia comprised the Ottoman vilayets of Salonica, Monastir and Kosovo. (4, 46, 67, 77) Note his reference to the “monumental paternalism” of the British. (113) Greek sources sometimes claim that the name of the Republic will spark “irredentism,” but irredentism requires not pictures on t-shirts but military or political action. Greece has a military budget 50x that of the Republic, and a per capita GDP of $8,000 versus Greece’s $29,000. This may explain why Greek sources never specify exactly what danger really looms: the behavior they brand “irredentist” barely merits mention in Myron Weiner’s scholarly analysis of irredentism in the Balkans and elsewhere. (On the other hand, It is important to add that despite the rhetorical noise, Greece and Macedonia now have important trade relations.)

Attempts to prove Macedonian "irredentism" make frequent use of maps and documents from the north. Prof. Miller provides a map and a "bank note":

http://macedonia-evidence.org/documentation.html



These have previously appeared on multiple anti-Macedonian websites. Though Professor Miller titles the page "Documentation," documentation is precisely what is lacking here. The "bank note" with the White Tower is dated to 1991, but we need to know where and when it circulated, and why. Kiro Velkovski tells us (in a comment at http://archaeoastronomy.wordpress.com/2009/05/29/macedonia-from-bad-to-worse/ ) that this was "a mockup by some individuals while we still had the Yugoslav dinars. It is in no way connected to the government or National Bank." A political scientist in Macedonia adds, "It was made as a proposal by a nationalist group and printed on normal paper ... it was never accepted." (Personal communication.) Velkovski does the great service of showing that the "bank note" is wholly missing from the current inventory of Macedonian bank notes.



Likewise, Prof. Miller provides no translation of the language surrounding the map he parades. What does the text say? Macedonians certainly are entitled to recall the days -- before the Treaty of Bucharest in 1913 and the demographic changes consequent upon the Asia Minor disaster in 1922, and Civil War in the 1940s -- when they were more numerous in the area around Thessalonki. To show that this automatically implies a current territorial claim requires more argument.



So, what Prof. Miller gives the reader here is the rawest kind of raw data, like some unexamined find from the earth. The data may be meaningful, but it does not speak for itself.



In short, it is hard not to be dismayed at this letter, which rejects modern scholarship on ethnic formation, reads the text of Herodotus as if it was a newspaper, complains about imagined verbal slights in a bland magazine article – and ignores the immense material damage Greece has done to its neighbor.



There remains ample room to argue about Alexander the Great, and about the supposed “linear trajectory … without ruptures or discontinuities from Alexander to the present.” We ought to be able to do this without endorsing violation of sovereignty or applauding or ignoring efforts to impoverish others.



Prof. Miller hopes to influence the Obama administration, which has acted with cool realism in the Balkans. He says he prefers the goal of right-wing Greek nationalism: a blanket prohibition on use of “the name Macedonia.” But he acknowledges that that is unachievable. (Two Greek diplomats have publicly recommended dropping the name issue.) He doesn’t mention NATO or the European Union, though they are an important part of the picture. Should Obama, then, force Macedonia to drop its claims to “Alexander”? It is hard to see why, and even harder to see how this issue can be separated from other matters, including NATO, the EU, and the rights of ethnic Macedonians in Greece.



Interestingly, many of the sources I’ve cited above are Greek. There are plenty of fine academics, human rights attorneys, and others in Greece who do not follow the company line (one Athenian friend who does not found a swastika painted on his house). I’ve not consulted with anyone I’ve quoted, but hope I’ve represented them fairly. I also recognize that I’ve passed over some issues.



I’ve worked on Greek causes since 1969. But I happen to believe that the current nationalist policy toward Macedonia is disastrous and has brought no gain.



Dan Tompkins
Department of Greek and Roman Classics
Temple University
mailto:pericles@temple.edu



Bibliography



Graham T. Allison, editor. The Greek Paradox. Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press 1997.

K. S. Brown, and Yannis Hamilakis, editors. The Usable Past. Greek Metahistories. Lanham, Md.: Lexington Books, 2003.

Mathew Brunwasser, “Macedonia Dispute has Asia Flavor; Claiming Alexander's Heritage, Pakistanis Enter the Fray.” International Herald Tribune (October 2, 2008).

David Fearn. "Narrating Ambiguity: Murder and Macedonian Allegiance (5.17-22)." In Elizabeth Irwin and Emily Greenwood, editors, Reading Herodotus. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press, 2007.

Jonathan Hall. "Contested Ethnicities: Perceptions of Macedonia within Evolving Definitions of Greek Identity." In Irad Malkin, ed., Ancient Perceptions of Ethnicity, Washington DC: Center for Hellenic Studies, 2001.

Yannis Hamilakis . "Learn History! Antiquity, National Narrative and History in Greek Educational Textbooks". In Brown and Hamilakis, 39-68.

D. Kalekin-Fishman and P. Pitkanen, editors. Multiple Citizenship as a Challenge to European Nation-States. Rotterdam: Sense Publishers. 2006

Dimitris Livanios. The Macedonian Question: Britain and the Southern Balkans 1939-1949. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2008.

Mark Mazower, “Introduction to the Study of Macedonia.” Journal of Modern Greek Studies 14.2 (1996), 229-235.

Takis Michas. Unholy Alliance: Greece and Milosevic's Serbia in the Nineties. College Station: Texas A&M University Press, 2002.

Victor Roudometof. “Nationalism and Identity Politics in the Balkans: Greece and the Macedonian Question.” Journal of Modern Greek Studies 14.2 (1996) 253-301.

Victor Roudometof. “Invented Traditions, Symbolic Boundaries, and National Identity in Southeastern Europe: Greece and Serbia in Comparative Historical Perspective (1830-1880).” East European Quarterly 32.4 (1999) 429 – 468.

Stearns, Monteagle, “Greek Security Issues,” in Allison, 61-72

Anna Triandafyllidou and Andonis Mikrakis, “Greece. ‘A Ghost Wanders Through the Capital.’ In The New Xenophobia in Europe edited by Bernd Baumgartl and Adrian Favell (Leiden: Brill, 1995)

Anna Triandafyllidou, Marina Calloni & Andonis Mikrakis. 
”New Greek Nationalism.” Sociological Research Online 2.1 (1997)

http://www.socresonline.org.uk/2/1/7.html

Anna Triandafyllidou. “National identity and the `other.’” Ethnic and Racial Studies 21.4 (1998) 593 – 612.

Anna Triandafyllidou and Anna Paraskevopoulou. “When is the Greek Nation? The Role of Enemies and Minorities.” Geopolitics 7.2 (2002) 75 – 98.

Konstantinos Tsitselikis, "Citizenship in Greece." In Kalekin-Fishman and Pitkanen, 145-170.

Myron Weiner. “The Macedonian Syndrome: An Historical model of International Relations and Political development“ World Politics 23.4 (1971) 665-683.
Voutira, Eftihia A. " Post-Soviet Diaspora Politics: The Case of the Soviet Greek." Journal of Modern Greek Studies 24.2(2006), 379-414.

Woodward, Susan L. “Rethinking Security in the Post-Yugoslav Era.” In Allison, 113-122.

Dan Tompkins



Addendum


Just as Jonathan Hall and others have opened up the study of race in antiquity, scholars like Anna Triandafyllidou have enriched our understanding of ethnicity in modern Greece. This is particularly urgent since the government continues to insist that there are no ethnic minorities there. Though her current scholarship concerns immigration -- a pressing problem in Greece -- she's written well on ethnicity too. Her overall perspective is one that classicists would do well to consider when they try to discuss modern ethnicity.

Triandafyllidou has shown, for instance, the problems of the current policy of treating "Turks" not as an ethnic but as a religious minority, noting "the changing character of civic, ethnic and religious identities of the Muslim minority in relation to the Christian Greek Orthodox majority." This concept of "change" permeates her discourse: history is dynamic not static, Greece has changed and is changing. The "dynamic nature of national identity" led to a moment (around 1922) in which "Greek national identity abandoned its irredentist character and shifted towards an ethnic but also territorial and civic definition of the nation in the early twentieth century, through interaction and conflict with neighbouring countries as well as internal social and political changes." Many of these "conflict dynamics ... developed between the nation and the ... other," and the other, too, must constantly be reinvented.

I would recommend any of the essays listed below, especially the most recent. As long ago as 1998, Triandafyllidou was noting that "the claim of FYROM over the ‘Macedonian’ cultural heritage has led Greeks to incorporate Alexander the Great into the classical Greek tradition and emphasize his centrality to the Greeks.'" This was, she says, a shift from nineteenth-century resistance toward all "foreign (including Macedonian) domination.” It began long before President Bush became president and supposedly "catalyzed" the Alexander craze in Macedonia, as Prof. Miller claims. After the disappointments of Andreas Papandreou's final term, she notes, it was convenient to restore "national pride ... in a political discourse which concentrated on the ‘injustice’ caused by ‘foreigners.'"

Triandafyllidou is bolder than many of her colleagues in asserting that "the Greek government and most Greek intellectuals ... tacitly ignored the fact that the indigenous Slavic speaking population of the Greek region of Macedonia was subjected to forceful Hellenization during the first half of this century." She adds that "National consciousness makes sense only in contrast to some other nation," and that Macedonia's displacement of Turkey in the demonization derby has given new prominence to the perceived or imagined virtues of Alexander and Philip.



__________



Note: Many other good Greek social scientists write about related issues. The Journal of Modern Greek Studies is one worthwhile source.



Anna Triandafyllidou and Andonis Mikrakis. “Greece. ‘A Ghost Wanders Through the Capital.’ In The New Xenophobia in Europe edited by Bernd Baumgartl and Adrian Favell (Leiden: Brill, 1995)



Anna Triandafyllidou, Marina Calloni & Andonis Mikrakis. ”New Greek Nationalism.” Sociological Research Online 2.1 (1997)

http://www.socresonline.org.uk/2/1/7.html



Anna Triandafyllidou. “National identity and the `other.’” Ethnic and Racial Studies 21.4 (1998) 593 – 612.



Anna Triandafyllidou and Mariangela Veikou. “Greek immigration policy. The Hierarchy of Greekness: Ethnic and national identity considerations in Greek immigration policy.” Ethnicities 2 (2002); 189-208



Anna Triandafyllidou and Anna Paraskevopoulou. “When is the Greek Nation? The Role of Enemies and Minorities.” Geopolitics 7.2 (2002) 75 – 98.

Do any Greeks care to dispute what Professor Tompkins has written here?
 
The revolutionary have made their stance: they declared Macedonians, such as the people of the Razlovci and Kreshna uprising. That Macedonians were considering them as Macedonian descendants of the Ancients was even a problem for the Bulgarian propagandist Slaveykov who was calling them Makedonists. See more Slaveykov. There are many more instance for this.

Thus you're either misinformed or just spining the ball.

But, since the Revolutionary had to prepare the revolution somewhere where the Ottomans had no juristiction, they chose Bulgaria and partially Serbia as their base for preparation.

But hey, the Bulgarians have doing the same i.e. prepared the revolution in Romania, and than with guerilla attack over the border fought the Ottomans. See more on BRCK

But this misfortunate circumstance of placing their base for preparation have lead to misunderstanding, as Sarafov have said it:



Bulgarians were persecuting the Macedonian revolutionary for that matter all the time.

Sometimes, the label Bulgarian was used by the Macedonian revoutionary to conceal in Bulgaria.

On the other hand, the label Bulgarian was something similar to the label Nigger. It was derogatory term used by the Patriarchists, you sure know it, Hondrokefalos Bulgaris, thickheaded Bulgarian i.e. Stupid peasant. That is why the Pasyi Hilendarski asked:



And many were stupid peasants, and as the Negro population in US uses the term Nigger between them self, so did the Macedonian peasants from time to time, until they did not understand that they were asked about their ethnic name. Many were interchanging designation with their church affiliation, but this was at later stage.

On the derogative meaning of the Bulgarian name you can even read from the bulgarians them self from here, just translate it with Google translate.

I know you won't agree again, but who cares.

so I am really off now.

Ok thanks. I think that's a bit thin but it's a position at least.

So when Dame Gruev wrote below he was really lying through his teeth if I understand it correctly ? He was considering himself to be a decendant of ancient Macedonians, not a Bulgarian and was trying to play along with Bulgarians ... Hmm.

"Macedonia. Documents and materials", Sofia, 1978, part III, No.92: To the Esteemed Government of the Principality of Bulgaria. In view of the critical and terrible situation of the Bulgarian population of the Monastir vilayet following the devastations and cruelties perpetrated by the Turkish troops and bashibazouks, in view of the fact that these devastations and cruelties continue systematically, and that one cannot foresee how far they will reach; in view, furthermore, of the fact that here everything Bulgarian is running the risk of perishing and being obliterated without a trace by violence, hunger and by approaching poverty, the General Staff considers it its duty to draw the attention of the Esteemed Bulgarian Government to the fatal con*sequences for the Bulgarian nation, if it fails to discharge its duty to its own brothers here in an impressive and energetic manner, made imperative by force of circumstances and by the danger threatening the common Bulgarian homeland at the present moment...
 
Giorikas, your hatred of Macedonians really amuses me.
I am positive if you took off your souvlaki tinted glasses you may have learned something from the preceding posts.
You have said you would much prefer us Macedonians (albeit with a different name) as your neighbours than Albanians or Serbs. That almost sounds nice.
If you would prefer us there, is it ok if we have the same rights as any other sovereign nation? Or would you prefer us there in a different kind of way?

Glad to be of your Greatness' service. Correction: I don't hate anybody and I actually don't remember saying that I prefer you over Albanians or Serbs, but certainly I don't mind having you as neigbours either.

In fact, I even believe that a country like Albania for example will some time soon become a reliable neighbour and the relations will improve a lot. Serbs are my favourites though. But and I wish all my neighbours well. That includes your country, Albania, Bulgaria and Turkey. The better they are doing economically, the better Greece will do. In time this dispute between our countries will mean nothing.
 
Giorikas, beneath your exceedingly thin veneer of niceness, you failed to answer my question. I am pretty sure it was you (or many painfully like you) who go on about how nice it is to have the Republic where it is. Certainly in preference to the Albanians. If it was not you who said that, please forgive me. I find it difficult to distinguish many of you sometimes.

Notwithstanding this, I am pleased to read that this dispute will mean nothing in time. The sooner the better I say. A silly argument for sovereign nations indeed!
 
Do any Greeks care to dispute what Professor Tompkins has written here?

Not really. He's entitled to his opinion. 253 scholars so far disagree with that. (minus the Greeks if you insist to exclude them). That's enough proof for me that there must be some truth in our side of the story.

It's not that relevant anyway, apart from the theoretical possibility that this will influence the US policy on this matter. And I'm not sure that that's the case, or not in in an overwhelming way. But sure, it can't harm either.
 
Giorikas, I have had more direct correspondence with these Professors than you might care to imagine. It has been more than illuminating. All of my correspondence reveals the support has been less than wholehearted. I hope you recover from this revelation.
 
Back
Top