• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

Stephen Miller and his anti-Macedonian activities

http://www.americanchronicle.com/articles/view/109816



Alexandra, BRAVO! :thumbup1:

And to Professor Miller :double fuck:

On your request my reaction:

Much of what she writes is the same rhetoric as always. I could have spared myself that. Not much new. Greeks are invented and so on. New is the 'update' where Miller no longer calls on Obama to review the US acknowledgement of the name 'ROM'.

I presume that Miller understood himself that that reference makes the letter too politically motivated in stead of being historically motivated. By doing so he is stepping out of the world of history into the world of politics and he shouldn't do that.
 
On your request my reaction:

Much of what she writes is the same rhetoric as always. I could have spared myself that. Not much new. Greeks are invented and so on. New is the 'update' where Miller no longer calls on Obama to review the US acknowledgement of the name 'ROM'.

I presume that Miller understood himself that that reference makes the letter too politically motivated in stead of being historically motivated. By doing so he is stepping out of the world of history into the world of politics and he shouldn't do that.

So if the letter is not politically motivated why do you send a request to a political entity to be the judge in a purely historical issue with no predetermined outcome?

Quite strange dont you think Giorikas?
 
Of course its strange, but strange is no stranger to Giorikas, who only a few days ago could not stop repeating his garbage over this collection of signatures, yet now he is making excuses for people distancing themselves from it, the ever-changing just like his Hellenic identity, they would manufacture a canine lineage for themselves if it served their racist and idiotic purpose.
 
So if the letter is not politically motivated why do you send a request to a political entity to be the judge in a purely historical issue with no predetermined outcome?

Quite strange dont you think Giorikas?

I believe Miller says that ROM is using 'Macedonianism' politically and he objects to that apparently on just about the highest political platform. I believe that he plus the odd >300 PHD's object to that polical use. I also believe that he disagrees (apart from the policical use) with just about anything that the ROM Macedonianists are claiming (not the polical use but the contents); they find it historically inaccurate.

I can also only presume that attacking the incorrect information that is being spread now by the ROM and the polical use of that is one thing. But calling on the president of the US to reverse a decision is another, that would be something a politician should do, not a historian.

In any case, that shouldn't be a point that he should focus on. That decision was clearly a temporary one (that is what was said) and the expiry date is the date that a new name will be negotiated. That should happen soon now.

But really, we're speculating here why he did what. Don't know the guy and can't speak on his behalf.
 
I believe Miller says that ROM is using 'Macedonianism' politically and he objects to that apparently on just about the highest political platform. I believe that he plus the odd >300 PHD's object to that polical use. I also believe that he disagrees (apart from the policical use) with just about anything that the ROM Macedonianists are claiming (not the polical use but the contents); they find it historically inaccurate.

I can also only presume that attacking the incorrect information that is being spread now by the ROM and the polical use of that is one thing. But calling on the president of the US to reverse a decision is another, that would be something a politician should do, not a historian.

In any case, that shouldn't be a point that he should focus on. That decision was clearly a temporary one (that is what was said) and the expiry date is the date that a new name will be negotiated. That should happen soon now.

But really, we're speculating here why he did what. Don't know the guy and can't speak on his behalf.

Would you care to enlighten us in which form the government of the Republic of Macedonia is using "Macedonianism" politically, is it the mere fact that they refer to themselves as ethnic Macedonians? Because no one nation can own any historical events thus Greece claiming Ancient history as theirs is an abnomination towards mankind. And a history Professor should be quite aware that historical events are not set in stone, there are at least one more side to the story. Thus all history that we are thaught today is in one way or another POLITICALLY MOTIVATED and not always HISTORICALLY CORRECT.

Thus a history Professor is in fact jeopardizing his very own profession. Stupid to say the least.

This is why there most likely will be no letter from the Macedonian side, because entering in such a stupid game is futile.
 
I will post the quote from the second Miller letter, dated 22nd of June 2009, where he so to say "clarifies" himself:

A point of clarification about our intentions is perhaps in order since they have been misinterpreted in some quarters. We do not ask that the United States withdraw its recognition of the "Republic of Macedonia". We do ask that the weight of US diplomacy be used to stop the theft of history and historic figures, starting with Alexander the Great.

So if he has no problem with our constitutional name do you think he has a problem with our National/Citizen/Ethnic name as well?

Or is it just Alexander he is trying to safeguard?
Can you steal history?
 
That second letter Daskalot. Did I miss the link to that? It sounds like he might have been persuaded by some "letters" to professors ... if you know what I mean. ;)
 
That second letter Daskalot. Did I miss the link to that? It sounds like he might have been persuaded by some "letters" to professors ... if you know what I mean. ;)

Here is the link, I will put in code:
Code:
http://macedonia-evidence.org/obama-letter2.html

He has littered it whit other garbage, like "fyrom-slavic", what the heck is that?
 
Alexander was not Slavic, but Macedonian!

Alexander was not Slavic, but Macedonian!

http://www.australianmacedonianweekly.com/edition/1083_21072009/070_english.html

MORE THAN THE NAME - A RESPONSE TO THE ATTEMPT TO RECALL AMERICAN RECOGNITION OF THE REPUBLIC OF MACEDONIA (3)

Alexander was not Slavic, but Macedonian

We shall here quote from Professor John Fine of the University of Michigan: "It is evident that in this period a great deal of ethnic mixture between Slavs and Greeks occurred; probably few pure-blooded Greeks – if such existed prior to the Slavic invasions - were left. A few centuries later many Albanians migrated into these regions and further increased the ethnic mixtures. Thus there is no reason to believe that the Greeks now are any purer blooded than any other Balkan peoples. But, of course, it is culture rather than blood-lines that matters." (John V.A. Fine; The Early Medieval Balkans, University of Michigan Press, 1991, p.64)
In any case, it is clear that serious alterations had occurred by early medieval times, in the cultures, economies and politics of all social groupings in the Balkans.
The fact that the Orthodox church and the modern Greek state, relatively recently, succeeded in introducing, on a mass national level, a form of Greek language based on the ancient Hellenic language, does not alter the fact that modern day Greeks, possess a culture, economy and political system, that have little in common with that of the ancient city states. However, if we followed Miller's "logic", we would have to go further than pointing this out; we would have to demand that today's Greeks renounce their claim to Greekness and admit their Slavo-Albanian roots; or at the very least, refer to themselves as "Slavo-Albanian Greeks".
However, Fine is quite right to stress that culture takes precedence, and culture is a social construction, a human invention. And what we have here been demonstrating is that social constructions can vary over time.
For this context, it is pertinent to point out that words like "Macedonian" and "Greek", are symbols, and the meaning of symbols, what they represent, can vary enormously, over even short periods – let alone 2,000 years!
This variation was a normal result of the changes that took place in the Balkans in the periods under discussion. In ancient times, the words "Macedonian" and "Hellene," undoubtedly referred to socio-cultural groupings that are very different from the ones that these symbols represent today. However, this is not a problem, for these ancient social configurations, disappeared long ago.
Modern day Macedonians and Greeks, were socially constructed during the last four centuries – like most European nations and ethnicities. This was done in the context of Modernity and involved, among other things, the rise of capitalist economies; the rise of a culture dominated by a dialectic possessing, a pursuit of rational mastery on one hand, and romance on the other (and this is where one in particular, should look for the ways in which modern Macedonians and Greeks revived the ancient symbols that came to form part of the basis of their identities); and a centralised state based more or less on mass representative democracy (unlike the democracy of Ancient Athens!).
The social configuration thus produced, is quite unique/new; and so are the modern European nations that inhabit and form an important part of it. (Western academic texts discussing this process are numerous, perhaps two relatively older ones are among the most useful for beginners, (and Miller undoubtedly is!): Ernest Gellner's Nations and Nationalism, Blackwell, Oxford 1983 and Benedict Anderson's Imagined Communities, Verso, London 1983).
[...while we may consider it inappropriate and the height of kitsch to erect statues in the main square of Skopje at a time of severe economic crisis, the decision of the Macedonian government to do so was taken well before the onset of the current global financial crisis...] If the basis upon which modern day Macedonians have come into existence is false, as Miller claims, it is no more false than the way in which all other modern nations and ethnicities have come into existence, including the modern Greeks.
Thus, to quote the American anthropologist, Loring Danforth, from an "anthropological perspective, the relatively recent date of the creation of a Macedonian state and the construction of a Macedonian nation, in comparison to other Balkan cases, does not mean, as Greek nationalists claim, that the Macedonian nation is 'artificial', while the Greek nation is 'genuine'. ... Both Macedonian national identity and Greek national identity are equally constructed." (Loring M. Danforth, The Macedonian Conflict, Princeton University Press, 1995, p.108; and for more on the construction of the Modern Greek nation during the 19th century, see the work of the Historian, John Breuilly, Nationalism and the State, The University of Chicago Press, 1994, especially pp.137-148.)
Social constructing and reconstructing; defining and redefining; valuing and revaluing, appear to be an ontological aspect of the human condition – they create culture; existential meaning, and Professor Miller serves nobody well when trying to claim that the cultural creativity of one group, is superior to that of other groups.
Modern day Macedonians and Greeks, both have a right to share these ancient symbols, that is the names "Macedonian" and "Greek", that emerged from the lands they presently occupy and neither has the right to forbid the other from using them. Ethnic identity is of basic existential significance in the modern world and that is one of the reasons why it is a human right and protected by international law.
Notably, even though Greece only began to officially refer to its northern province as "Macedonia" (from 1955 till the mid 80's the official name of the region in Greece was "Northern Greece", administered by the "Ministry of Northern Greece", Law 3200, 23 April 1955) as a result of laws and directives passed in 1986 (Law 1622 of 1986) and 1988 (Prime Ministerial decision no.704, 19 August 1988); the Republic of Macedonia (which has been using the name since it was formed in 1944) has not made any request for Greece to drop its usage.
Such sharing does not create confusion as the different meanings (provincial/regional as opposed to ethnic or national) are very clear and easily explainable. Such sharing is well within the bounds of reason, though it is curious that Miller should claim for modern Greece, ownership of a word that Greece itself was long reluctant to officially utilise. Professor Miller's distress at the "misappropriation by the government in Skopje of the most famous of Macedonians, Alexander the Great" and his contention that Alexander has become Slavic is not borne out by an objective review of the facts.
The current government in the Republic of Macedonia does not claim that Alexander was Slavic, but Macedonian.
Prime Minister Nikola Gruevski has recently stated that he neither knows nor cares whether he or the Macedonians are descendants of "Slavs" or the Ancient Macedonians, but that he considers he and his people to be Macedonians with a right to their own language, culture and identity like all other peoples.
It should be pointed out that while we may consider it inappropriate and the height of kitsch to erect statues in the main square of Skopje at a time of severe economic crisis, the decision of the Macedonian government to do so was taken well before the onset of the current global financial crisis.
And lest Professor Miller go into paroxysms of rage over the "misappropriation of Alexander by the Slav Paionians", he should be reminded that of the statues to be erected, only one is of Alexander. Three are of Macedonian revolutionaries from the turn of the 20th century, one is of Tsar Samoil and a further one, is of Cento, the Republic of Macedonia's first post-war President.

(To be continued)
 
Greeks called Macedonians - "barbarians"

Greeks called Macedonians - "barbarians"

http://www.australianmacedonianweekly.com/edition/1082_14072009/070_english.html

MORE THAN THE NAME - RESPONSE TO THE ATTEMPT TO RECALL AMERICAN RECOGNITION OF THE REPUBLIC OF MACEDONIA (2)

Greeks called Macedonians - "barbarians"

That this was no mere political rhetoric directed at a political opponent who was a fellow "Hellene" is shown by the Austrian-American historian Ernst Badian who speaks of another occasion when Demosthenes called Philip a barbarian:
"Above all, however, this helps to explain how, half a generation after Philip's revival of the Macedonian king's claim to eminent Greek descent had been accepted at Olympia and his efforts to integrate his court had been bearing fruit, Greek opponents could still call not only the Macedonian people, but the king himself, "barbarian."
In this respect, nothing had changed since the days of Archelaus. The term is in fact more than once used of Philip by Demosthenes, most notably in two passages.
In one, in the Third Olynthiac (3.24), he claims that a century ago "the king then in power in the country was the subject [of our ancestors], as a barbarian ought to be to Greeks." In the second, a long tirade in the Third Philippic (9.30 f.), he claims that suffering inflicted on Greeks by Greeks is at least easier to bear than that now inflicted by Philip, "who is not only not a Greek and has nothing to do with Greeks, but is not even a barbarian from a place it would be honorable to name - a cursed Macedonian, who comes from where it used to be impossible even to buy a decent slave."
This, of course, is simple abuse. It may have nothing to do with historical fact, any more than the orators' tirades against their personal enemies usually have. But as I have tried to make clear, we are not concerned with historical fact as such; we are concerned only with sentiment, which is itself historical fact and must be taken seriously as such. In these tirades we find not only the Hellenic descent of the Macedonian people (which few seriously accepted) totally denied, but even that of the king. It is not even mentioned merely in order to be rejected: the rejection is taken as a matter of course.
Now, the orator clearly could not do this, if his audience was likely to regard his claim as plain nonsense: it could not be said of a Theban, or even of a Thessalian.
The polite acceptance of the Macedonian kings as Hellenes ruling a barbarian nation was still not totally secure: one would presumably divide over it on irrational grounds, according to party and personal sentiment - as so many of us still divide, over issues that are inherently more amen*able to rational treatment. (68)" (Ernst Badian, "Greeks and Macedonians" in Macedonia and Greece in Late Classical and Early Hellenistic Times, Studies in The History Of Art Vol 10: (The National Gallery Of Art, Washington, 1980)). The Classics professor, Peter Green, has written many books and articles about the Ancient Greeks and Macedonians in which he provides valuable information about how the Greeks and Macedonians saw themselves. For example on Page 50 of his book Alexander of Macedon 356-323 B.C, Professor Green states as follows:
[...Philip did not give a fig for Panhellenism...] "And though Philip did not give a fig for Panhellenism as an idea, he at once saw how it could be turned into highly effective camouflage (a notion which his son subsequently took over ready-made). Isocrates had, unwittingly, supplied him with the propaganda-line he needed. From now on he merely had to clothe his Macedonian ambitions in a suitable Panhellenic dress." (Peter Green, Alexander of Macedon 356-323 B.C: A Historical Biography, University of California Press, Berkeley and Los Angeles 1991).
On page 7 of the book Alexander to Actium he states:
"But then, Eumenes was a Greek, and Macedonian troops, especially the old sweats who had served under Philip II, were never really comfortable being led by non-Macedonians." (Alexander to Actium: The Historical Evolution of the Hellenistic Age, University of California Press, 19 October 1993)
We may summarise by again quoting from Eugene Borza, Professor of Ancient History at Pennsylvania State University:
"No single argument is conclusive, but the case builds in quality as it grows in quantity of evidence, and, in the end, is persuasive. Despite the efforts of Phillip II and Alexander the Great to bridge the gap between the two cultures, Greeks and Macedonians remained steadfastly antipathetic toward one another (with dislike of a different quality than the mutual long term hostility shared by some Greek city-states) until well into the Hellenistic period, when both the culmination of Hellenic acculturation in the north and the rise of Rome made it clear that what these peoples shared took precedence over their historical enmities." (Borza,1990:96)
Borza moves on to ask:
"Who were the Macedonians? As an ethnic question it is best avoided, since the mainly modern political overtones tend to obscure the fact that it really is not a very important issue. That they may or may not have been Greek in whole or part - while an interesting anthropological sidelight - is really not crucial to our understanding of their history. They made their mark not as a tribe of Greeks or other Balkan peoples, but as Macedonians. This was understood by foreign protagonists from the time of Darius and Xerxes to the age of Roman generals." (Borza, 1990:96)
So we can conclude that Miller is on very slippery ground, at best, when claiming that Ancient Macedonians and Hellenes were absolutely one and the same thing and that such an assertion is simply an incontestable fact.
Clearly, it is still a matter for debate, to say the least. Worse still though, is the ridiculous attempt to claim that modern day Greeks have a right to own the word, "Macedonia".
This is simply because of all the change that has occurred in the Balkans over the last 2,500 years! The region has been invaded and re-invaded and conquered numerous times - by the Romans, various Germanic and Tatar tribes and most notably, by Slavic tribes. Therefore it is absurd for anyone to try to claim some kind of continuous unbroken blood or cultural link.
The Slavs that invaded and settled the Balkans in the 5th Century AD did not just stop, as is often claimed by Greek propagandists, at "southern Yugoslavia". They settled the whole of the Balkans, including almost the entirety of what is today Greece, in what is reputed to have been one of the largest mass migrations in early medieval history. (Fine, 1991:30-36, 60-64; it is also worth noting that over the last decade, new discussions in the academic world have begun about the nature of the early Slavs and their appearance in the Balkans in the 6th century AD – see the work of the Historian, Professor Florin Curta, The Making of the Slavs, Cambridge University Press, 2001.)

(To be continued)
 
Macedonia was never a part of the ancient Hellenic city-states.

Macedonia was never a part of the ancient Hellenic city-states.

http://www.americanchronicle.com/articles/view/115377

Macedonia was never a part of the ancient Hellenic city-states.

Gandeto

August 21, 2009


One of the steps in the Scientific Method of Investigation is the publication of your obtained results. This is done, so that others by repeating the same experiment using same methodology may independently arrive to the same conclusion and verify whether it is true what you have accomplished with your own hypothesis. Once many independent laboratories—through their scientific research—confirm your results, then, the hypothesis that you have proposed becomes accepted and your findings acknowledged.

I have said before, and I stand by my assertions that: (a) Macedonia was never a part of any ancient Greek city-state, nor were the ancient Macedonians ever considered by the ancient Greeks or by themselves, to be Greek. (b) Macedonia was never a member of any Hellenic League. Macedonia was not a member of the Greek Amphictyonic League either. Fact is that membership into these leagues was reserved for Hellenes only. And since Macedonians were not considered Hellenes, they were not admitted into these leagues. There is no record of either side voicing displeasure regarding this rule. And (c) in antiquity people knew that the boundary between Macedonia and Greece was the river Peneus and mount Olympus; to the south were the Greek tribes and to the north was Macedonia.

I challenge all of you lecturers of history, including Professor Stephan Miller and his like-minded historians, to dispute my assertions and prove me wrong. When you claim or support a claim that "Macedonia was always Greek", it is incumbent upon you—academic standards compel—to find at least one shred of evidence from the ancient chroniclers and bring it forward. Find other authors from antiquity who will agree with your own assertion. And please, instead of shielding yourself with ambiguous interpretations from the 18th and the 19th century philhellenic writers, convince the readers with valid, persuasive arguments. Bring to the table solid, irrefutable evidence from the ancient Greeks themselves or their contemporary Greek or Roman biographers and chroniclers.

I will go on the limb and reiterate my opinion regarding the ethnicity of the ancient Macedonians: Anyone who claims that ancient Macedonia was a Greek land and that ancient Macedonians were Greeks or that Macedonians are stealing Greek heritage, is nothing less and nothing more than a corrupt, deceitful fabricator of history whose (scientific) thinking—devoid of substance—is based on personal beliefs and mythical constructs.

Facts are not derived from beliefs or mythology. Scientific knowledge does not rest on feelings, nor is it supported by bad-time stories and mythology. Science needs concrete, verifiable evidence.

I can safely state that I stand on the shoulders of others;

I stand convinced that

(1) you will be unable to prove Strabo, Scylax, Dichaerchus, Scymnus, and Dionysius wrong. These biographers have stated that Greece commences at the Ambracian Gulf, and terminates at the river Peneus.

I am convinced that

(2) you will be unable to prove Aeschines, Theopompus and Pausanias wrong, for not including Macedonia on their lists of the Amphictyonic people of Greece.

I stand convinced that

(3) you will have no answer as to why Thucydides found no room for Macedonia on his list of states on either side of the warring parties in the Peloponnesian War. Macedonia is found neither on the Athenian, nor on the Lacedaemonian side.

These are hard facts that cannot be dismissed with lame excuses and manipulation of text. One cannot disregard evidence of this magnitude and bring forward a pitiful assertion like ´Macedonians spread Hellenic culture in the East´, instead. One cannot substitute and equate the words of a king (Philip V) "My ancestors Philip II and Alexander the Great conquered Greece", with "but Macedonians had same names as Greeks", nonsense.

You can saturate the media with slogans and cry "thieves" as long as you want, but you will be unable to subvert and change the evidence left from the ancient authors. Fact is that you have bought some professors to put their whimsical shoulder on your "Greek" wheel, but fact is also that you are stuck in the mud of lies up to your knees and cannot move.

The following piece of evidence reaffirms my position and demonstrates, once again, that truth is not a manipulative currency and cannot be suppressed for long. The following passages were taken from the Canadian Macedonian Historical Society Review written by Alexander Nitsis:

"As one of the powers which had guaranteed the independence of the Greek Kingdom in 1828, Great Britain held the position that the Greek claims to extension of their territories were greater (as of 1880) than the boundaries which the Greek city-states held in antiquity. This position was brought forward by Major J.C. Ardagh, (later became Sir Major-General). He was part of the British delegation that was attached to the Special Embassy during the Congress at Berlin on June 3rd, 1878. He was also appointed as her Majesty´s Commissioner for the delineation of the frontier of Bulgaria (September 7th, 1878); and was employed during the conference at Constantinople in 1881. Sir J.C. Ardagh was born on August 9, 1840, and died on September 30th, 1907.

Before the Conference at Constantinople, Major Ardagh communicated with the British Foreign Office on the issue of the new Greek frontier with his "Memorandum on the Ancient Boundaries of Greece", which was received at the Foreign Office on February 24th, 1881. The information which Major Ardagh presented in his memorandum (quoting sources from antiquity) reaffirms claims made by Macedonians today that, Macedonia was never part of any Greek (Hellenic) state during ancient times. If ancient Greek sources did not see Macedonia as part of the "Ancient Greek World", how can the modern Greek state see Macedonia and its people as Greek?

What Major Ardagh´s memorandum does raise is questions not only to the issue of the true Greek frontier, but also to the true identity of the people of Macedonia. Since 1913, the end of the Second Balkan War when Greece, Bulgaria and Serbia and Montenegro divided up Macedonia amongst themselves, Greece has been claiming that Macedonia was always Greek. Major Ardagh discredits this claims by quoting ancient Greeks themselves and shows that not only was Macedonia not Greek or part of ancient Greece and neither was Epirus or Thessaly.

Doc. 41 Memorandum on the Ancient Boundaries of Greece

By Major J.C. Ardagh, C.B., R.E. – (Received at the Foreign Office,


February 24th, 1881.)

The Ancient Boundaries of Greece

As the claims of the Greeks to an extension of territories are in some degree based upon the limits of the ancient Greece, I conceived that an examination of the early Greek geographers would throw some light upon them, and I have been able to procure, and annex extracts from them in Greek with translations.

Strabo, Scylax, Dichaerchus, Scymnus, and Dionysius all concur in making Greece commence at the Ambracian Gulf, and terminate at the river Peneus.

The catalogue of the ships in the Iliad, the various lists of the Amphictyonic tribes, the states engaged in the Peloponnesian war, the travels of Anacharsis , the description of Greece by Pausanias, and the natural history of Pliny—all give proof of the same fact, by positive or negative evidence; nor have I found anywhere a suggestion that Epirus was Greek, except that Dodona, the great oracle, though situated amid barbarians, was a Greek institution, and the legend that the Molossian Kings were of the house of Aeacidae. When Epirus first became powerful, 280 B.C., Greece had long been under the complete ascendency of the Macedonians, and after the fall of the Empire at the battle of Pydna, 168 B.C., it became a Roman province in 148 B.C. The establishment of Greek independence in 1832 was exactly 2,000 years after the battle of Pydna.

Strabo:

(1) The tribes extending beyond the Ambracian Gulf to the eastward, and contiguous with the Peloponnesus, are Greek.

(2) The tribes from the Strymon to the Pontic passes and Haemus are all Thracian, except on the coast which is inhabited by Greeks.

(3) On the right of the entrance (of the Ambracian Gulf) dwell the Acarnanians, a Greek tribe. On the left is Nicopolis and the Kassopaeans, an Epirote tribe.

(4) The Peneus divides Lower and Maritime Macedonia from Thessaly and Magnesia, and Haliacmon Upper Macedonia.

(5) But the Peneus bounds Macedonia towards the north, and Thessaly towards the south.

Scylax: Periplus:--

(1) From Ambracia Greece is continuous (along the coast) as far as the river Peneus.

(2) Up to this point (the country of the Magnesians) Greece is continuous from Ambracia.

Dicaearchus:

(1) I therefore draw the limits of Hellas at the country of the Magnesians, i.e., to the Vale of Tempe.

Scymnus:

(1) Obove Tempe towards Olympus is the region of the Macedonians. (The writer describes the Thesprotians, Chaonians, Molossians and the inhabitants of the interior of Epirus, as barbarian. 430-460.)

(2) Greece is continuous from Ambracia to the Peneus.

Homer:

In the catalogue of the ships in the second book of the Iliad, Acarnania, Aetolia and Thessaly are the most northern districts mentioned. The others are Boetia, Phocis, Locris, Euboea, Athens, Salamis, Argos, Mycinae, Laconia, Messenia, Arcadia, Crete, Rhodes, and Isles.

The amphictyonic people. The names are given by Aeschines, Theopompus and Pausanias:

Aeschines: Thessalians, Boeotians, Dorians, Perrhaebeans, Magnetes, Locrians, Aeteans, Phthiotes, Maleans, Phocians.

Theopmpus: Ionians, Dorians, Perrhaebeans, Magnetes, Achaeans, Maleans, Dolopes, Aeneans, Delphians, Phocians, Phthiotes

Pausanias: Ionians, Diopes, Thessalians, Magnetes, Maleans, Phthiotes, Dorians,

Of these, none belong to Epirus; indeed there are neither Aetolians nor Acarnanians.

Thermopylae:

The next catalogue which throws light on the subject is that of forces under the command of Leonidas at Thermopylae.

They are enumerated by Herodotus, Pausanias, and Deodorus as follows:

Peloponnesians, Thespians, Thebans, Phocians, and Locrians (or Milesians).

Forming in fact, something less than the present limits of Greece.

Thucydides:

In book II of the Peloponnesian War, Thucydides gives a catalogue of the states ranged on either side as follows:

With the Lacedaemonians: All the Peloponnesians except the Argives and Achaeans, the Megareans, Locrians, Boeotians, Phocians, Ambraciots, Leucadians, and Anactoreans

With the Athenians: Chians, Lesbians, Plataeans, Messenians of Neopactus, most of the Acarnanians, the Corcyraeans, Zacynthians, with certain islands and colonies.

Anacharsis: Travels in Greece, 357 B.C. There are 14 other nations in Epirus.

Pausanias does not even mention Epirus

Pliny: Natural History, book IV: He places mount Olympus in Thessaly, but does not precisely define the boundary of Macedonia, which he describes as extending to the Adriatic."

With this illustration by Ardagh, the Greek cries of "Macedonia is Greece", is shown once again to be nothing more than a fabrication. The ancient boundaries of Greece do not coincide with the modern Greek borders. These ancient frontiers of Greece are the basis which the present Greek state is using for the claims on Macedonia.

This is certainly another piece of evidence that reaffirms the inadmissibility of the Greeks´ claims that "Macedonia was always Greek". Time and again, this blatant lie is being exposed for what it really represents—a flagrant and shamelessly executed subversion of historical truth—heist of unparallel historical proportions never before seen in the history of mankind. What is so arrogantly flaunted as Greek heritage is nothing but a stolen property from the Macedonians. Between these rampant Greek lies and deceptions and the silence of the European academicians, who, certainly, know the truth, runs the menacing current of the biased and the hypocritical attitude of Europe itself. Human rights issues in Greece are of paramount importance and Europe remains silent.

By not addressing these obvious violations of its own constitution, Europe undermines its own reputation. By not attending to these flames of hatred and racism exhibited by the Greek government, Europe diminishes its own stature and weakens its own institutions.

Europe must find courage to tell Greece, simply to "grow up", as said by former US Secretary of State Lawrence Eagleburger in the interview for the Macedonian Television. And in the words of the former German ambassador to the Republic of Macedonia, Hans Lothar Schteppan, Europe must recognize that "Greece's strong objection to the name was laid on a foundation of lies".

Until next time…
Bravo Gandeto, you seem to be getting on the nerves of the Greeks!
 
AMHRC runs on the board

AMHRC runs on the board

The Australian Macedonian Human Rights Committee has been very under-marketed in relation to the fine work they have done over the years. The following analysis of a protracted legal dispute in relation to the naming of the Macedonian language is an excellent case in point.

Make no mistake, the Greek lobbyists have little fear for internet warriors who merely offer opinions. In this case, the AMHRC (along with the MTA) showed some teeth and made a statement to the world in relation to basic human rights that should be afforded to all people.


In 1994 the State of Victoria became the only state in the world to issue a directive to change the name of an internationally recognised standard language (without consultation with the speakers) and then engage in a protracted legal process to uphold the directive.

On 25 July 1995 a complaint was indeed lodged against the State of Victoria in the Equal Opportunity Commission of Victoria, as agent for the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission (HREOC), signed by the Secretary of the Australian Macedonian Human Rights Committee (AMHRC) and the Macedonian Community Council of Melbourne and Victoria (MCCMV). However, by letter dated 15 July 1997, it was the AMHRC alone that exercised its right under the Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth) to instigate legal proceedings. The case is cited as Australian Macedonian Human Rights Committee (Inc) v Victoria [1998] HREOCA 1 (8 January 1998) (Sir Ronald Wilson).

In 1998 the Macedonian Teacher’s Association of Victoria (MTAV), sought a review of the unfavourable decision of Sir Ronald Wilson in (HREOC) in the Federal Court of Australia. Weinberg J of the Federal Court of Australia overturned the earlier HREOC determination and ruled in favour of the MTAV. The case is cited as Macedonian Teachers Association of Victoria Inc v Human Rights & Equal Opportunity Commission & Anor [1998] FCA 1650 (21 December 1998) (Weinberg J).

In 1999, the State of Victoria appealed the decision by Weinberg J in (the Federal Court of Australia) in the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia. O’Connor, Sundberg and North JJ dismissed the appeal by the State of Victoria and ruled in favour of the MTAV. The case is cited as Victoria v Macedonian Teachers Association of Victoria [1999] FCA 1287 (16 September 1999) (O’Connor, Sundberg and North JJ).

In 2000, the State of Victoria sought leave to appeal to the High Court of Australia before Gleeson CJ, Hayne and Callinan JJ. The High Court refused the special leave to appeal. In other words, there was no hearing.

In 2000, the matter was referred to the HREOC for final determination, where only the original complainant is able to pursue proceedings – this meant the AMHRC. On 8 September 2000, Alexander Street SC delivered his determination in favour of the AMHRC and declared the actions of the Victorian Government in imposing the “Slavonic” suffix to be unlawful. In his final determination the Commissioner made the following comments, “I declare that the Respondent (Victorian Government) has engaged in conduct rendered unlawful by section 9 (1) of the Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth) by the act of issuing the directive in the terms of the memorandum dated 21 July 1994 which involved a distinction based on ethnic origin in re-naming the language Macedonian and had the effect of impairing the recognition on an equal footing of a human right in the cultural life of users of the Macedonian language and I declare that the Respondent not continue such unlawful conduct.”

The wording adopted in Section 9(1) of the Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth) was modelled on Article 1.1 of the International Human Rights Convention on the Elimination of all Forms of Racial Discrimination as ratified by Australia. As a consequence the Victorian Government was in direct contravention of the Racial Discrimination Act and of the Convention itself.

Thus, in summary there were four legal hearings in relation to the “Slavonic” suffix case, two of them were led by the Macedonian Teacher’s Association and two by the Australian Macedonian Human Rights Committee.

However, this was not the end of the matter. In order to persuade the Victorian Government to remove the “Slavonic” suffix and to abide by the HREOC decision, a further 14 months of intensive lobbying needed to be carried out by the Australian Macedonian Human Rights Committee. This involved numerous meetings and considerable correspondence with Government Ministers, independent consultation with each (!!) Victorian Government Department and Agency and undertakings of further legal action by the AMHRC.

All Victorian government departments have now declared the language to be Macedonian. Notably though it took an enormous effort on the part of the AMHRC and the MTA to finally reach this end.

(The complete transcript of the Commissioner’s findings can be found on the AMHRC website in the “major campaigns” section.)

I found the Judge's determination clear and a strong warning to all Governments:
In my opinion, it is clear from the opening paragraph to the Convention which refers to “respect for and observance of human rights and fundamental freedoms for all, without distinction as to race, sex, language or religion”, as well as the reference to “ethnic origin” in Article 1, that linguistic minorities are intended to benefit from the protection of the Convention. As a matter of construction “cultural rights” in Article 5 of the Convention must include a cultural language. Languages develop so as to express the needs of their users and provide an ever changing kaleidoscope as means of understanding ourselves and our society. No people or their language are better than another. A cultural language includes in my opinion what may be described as a dialect or patois which is taught, learnt and used in cultural and social activities and is identified with by the users of the language. Whether speech is recognised as a language by international linguists is not, in my view, determinative of the question of fact as to whether there is a cultural language used by persons of ethnic origin. If the cultural language is identified with, in description or name, by the cultural language users this is, in my opinion, part of the cultural right. Identification with a cultural language in cultural and social activities may involve more than mere expression of the language. Mere expression is a freedom specifically recognised by Article 5 paragraph 1(d)(viii) of the Convention but this does not exhaust the protection given to a linguistic minority specifically in relation to cultural rights within paragraph 1(e). The identification by the users with the cultural language may include the description or name of the cultural language which in cultural and social activities is used by the people speaking, reading or writing the cultural language. The badge of personal identity, value and belonging of persons of ethnic origin with each other in cultural and social activities may comprise their identification in the description or name with, and use of, the cultural language. Identification in the description or name of the cultural language by the users of the cultural language may be of material significance in maintaining the identity of the persons of ethnic origin and their use of the cultural language. If the name of the language no longer exists the identity, value and belonging in learning, teaching or using the language may be diminished or destroyed. If, in the context of social and cultural activities, the language of a linguistic minority is not taught, learnt and used, this would lead to the demise of the cultural language. Where the cultural language is the cornerstone of the identity of an ethnic community a demise of the cultural language would be destructive of the ethnic community.

I find that there are people of ethnic origin who in social and cultural activities teach, learn and use the language Macedonian. I find that immediately prior to the directive the language Macedonian was used by people of ethnic origin in Australia. I find that the Macedonian language is a cultural language and identified with in the name Macedonian by the cultural language users. I find that the language Macedonian is the cornerstone of the identity of the ethnic community who speak Macedonian. I find that the badge of personal identity, value and belonging of this ethnic community in cultural and social activities comprises their identification with the name and use of the cultural language Macedonian. In my opinion, it accords with the principles of dignity and equality for a linguistic minority to have recognised, to enjoy and to exercise the human right in social and cultural activities to teach, learn and use a cultural language as identified with, in description or name, by the cultural language users. In my opinion, one of the moral rights protected by the Convention is the right in social and cultural activities to teach, learn and use the cultural language Macedonian as identified with in the name Macedonian by the cultural language users. In my opinion, this right is a human right in the cultural life of the users of the Macedonian language.

Accordingly, I am of the opinion that the human right in social and cultural activities to teach, learn and use the cultural language Macedonian, as identified with in the name Macedonian by the cultural language users, exists and is of a kind within Article 5 of the Convention and, in any event, is a human right within the meaning of section 9(1). I find in the present case that there is involved and established a right in social and cultural activities to teach, learn and use the language Macedonian as identified in the name Macedonian by the language users. I find this right is a cultural right of persons of ethnic origin in Australia who speak Macedonian.

The recognition focused upon by the protection in section 9(1) is acknowledgment of the human rights and freedoms of people by all persons including Government bodies, emanations or departments as valid or entitled to consideration. In the present case, re-naming of the language provides a new pigeonhole label whereby the former name of the language ceases to exist for Government administrative purposes. I find that Mr Honeywood’s evidence that the language Macedonian does not now exist was an admission by the respondent as to the effect of the distinction involved in the act of issuing the directive in terms of the memorandum dated 21 July 1994. I find that the effect of the directive is that Government bodies, emanations and departments of the respondent do not recognize that the language Macedonian exists. I find that the human right as established above is not recognized as valid or entitled to consideration by Government bodies, emanations and departments of the respondent. I find that this effect of the distinction impairs recognition of the cultural rights of users of the Macedonian language in social and cultural activities. The fact that the distinction does not impair expression of the cultural language is not an answer to this want of recognition. I find that the distinction does have the effect of adversely affecting and diminishing the recognition of the said right by individuals and within the Government bodies, emanations or departments of the respondent. I find that Macedonian (Slavonic) is not a description or name used by persons who learn, teach or use the Macedonian language in cultural or social activities and is not identified with the cultural language by users of the cultural language. I find that the distinction has had the effect of diminishing the recognition of cultural rights by users of the cultural language in cultural and social activities. I find that issuing the directive has had the effect of impairing recognition of cultural rights of the users of the Macedonian language in cultural and social activities. I find that other users of cultural languages have recognition, enjoyment and exercise of their cultural rights without Government directives re-naming the cultural language and accordingly have recognition and enjoyment of their cultural right on a different and unequal footing to users of the Macedonian language.
 
RTG
A seriously noteworthy step in the right to self determination and an invaluable lesson to all who try to oppose it. Outstanding work by the AMHRC and MTA, they have my congratulations, respect and gratitude. We should use this example to achieve more recognised rights in every state and internationally!
 
Thanks

Thanks

Thank you Risto for pointing this out - it was a historic moment. The AMHRC together with the MTA defeated the State of Victoria - had it found guilty of racial discrimination.

We feel that our defeat of Professor Miller and the Greek State propaganda machine last year was also a major victory and we shall update that thread which is already on this forum.

Regards,

AMHRC.
 
Update

Update

The AMHRC would like to report that since this thread was last active, new support for Professor Miller, as a result of our intervention, has virtually 'dried up'. Together with MHRMI, we are proud to say that we inflicted a major defeat upon Greek anti-Macedonian propaganda.

We would also like to report that we have been able to use the material from the response we wrote to Miller, in other productive ways. For example, at a forum that was held in Canberra late last year, between representatives of the Macedonian community from across Australia and federal politicians; the AMHRC handed out to many politicians, numerous copies of a booklet it had prepared on Macedonian matters.

Thus a process of re-education was begun and it began to have an effect almost immediately - as one politician confessed to the AMHRC, he was "stunned" to discover that Greece only began to officially utilise the name Macedonia, in the 1980's and this went a long way to discrediting the Greek position.

This grew out of our response to Miller and the original response can still be found on the front page of our website.


Regards,

AMHRC.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top