• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

Australian position on Macedonia

Australian position on Macedonia

  • ........

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • ......

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    0
I can understand if the Australian Government has friendly relations with Greece for whatever reason however why would they tarnish relations with Macedonia and Turkey??

Simple question to answer.

It`s some kind of necessity to tarnish relations with Turkey and Macedonia if you wanna have friendly relations with Greece because Greek policy requires this. They are so obsessive to us, so they expect everyone to be negative to us, just to satisfy their national ego. Also, because of their inferiority complex, they feel better as much as support they get from outside of Greece.

So, as you can win the hearts of Greek public in Greece with anti-Turkish and Macedonia stance. You should do the same for Greek diaspora too. It`s the key to get their votes, just like the people in Greece.
 
Anti-Macedonian 'University of Western Australia' Professor strikes again! some people never learn

Re: The Importance of Historical Truth and The Macedonian Issue
Australian Macedonian Advisory Council
February 03, 2011
Following the publication of the edited version of the after-dinner talk that I gave in October, a formal complaint was made to my employer (to which a polite reply was made, stressing the importance of academic freedom), and I received an e-mailed message from the United Macedonian Diaspora (which I thought, because of its name, must be a Greek organisation until I read what it had to say), together with a number of other e-mails. Many of these were merely abusive, but this didn´t surprise me, because I know from experience that when people hold strong beliefs that are based on faith not fact, and they are shown that these beliefs cannot be true, this is distressing to them, and they will very often become agitated, as they cling to their beliefs even more vigorously. None of the messages that I received addressed the issue that I raised in my talk in Melbourne, the proposed erection of the statue of Alexander the Great in Skopje. Two of them were, however, more thoughtful, and I have had some mild and civilised exchanges with their authors, as we define our positions.

Some of the points that were made were what I would call 'diversionary', such as the statement that the present population of the Greek province of Macedonia has nothing in common with its population in ancient times, being 'colonisers', referring to the fact that many of them were brought there from Turkey in the 1920s during the exchange of populations which led to Muslims being removed from some areas of the Balkans, and Christians from some parts of Asia Minor. I have pointed out to the persons who made this point that this is not an accurate way to describe what happened; and it is certainly not relevant to the issue that brought me into this debate (see below). Similarly, I know that in northern Greece some of the things that have been done to the Slav minority who live there, such as discouraging them from using their own language, cannot be defended (and I wonder what has happened to any Greek speakers who still live in the FYROM, but no one has told me anything about them). But I am a specialist in the ancient world, not in modern history, and again this is not relevant to the point that I am trying to make.

Anyway, I composed a reply, and sent it to everyone who had contacted me, answering some of the points that had been made, and emphasising that I was not well informed on the details of what had happened in the period of Ottoman domination or the twentieth century, although I am in fact learning more. For example, I have been looking at a book called The Contest for Macedonian Identity 1870-1912 by Nick Anastasovski, which is very scholarly and better documented, particularly in relation to Ottoman sources, than anything else that I have previously read. But it fails in its promise to show how a 'Macedonian Identity' began to be constructed in the 19th century. And one of the problems is that the word ´Macedonian´ can be interpreted in different ways (I am reminded of the character Humpty Dumpty in Lewis Carroll´s Alice through the Looking Glass, who said ´When I use a word, it means just what I choose it to mean …´).

One delightful experience was my being directed, apparently seriously, to a web site produced by two scientists in Skopje, who claimed to have shown that the middle section of the Rosetta Stone (196 B.C.), the section occupying the space between the text that was presented in hieroglyphics and the text that was presented in Greek, was not, as has been generally supposed, written in Middle or Ptolemaic Demotic Egyptian (close to Coptic), but in the original 'Macedonian' language, which the Ptolemies, being Macedonians, were supposed to have used. This was combined with the suggestion that these original 'Macedonians' had been driven out of Macedonia by the Romans, but returned some seven centuries later to their homeland. Thus we would have a connection between the Macedonians of antiquity and the present inhabitants of the FYROM.

It is amazing that this world-shattering theory has not made the front pages of the international newspapers, even though, to judge from the comments that I have found on the web, some people in the FYROM are convinced by it. There are, however, obvious weaknesses that anyone, not necessarily a specialist in linguistics, can spot easily. In the first place, the web site dismisses the perfectly credible translation from Demotic which is provided by the British Museum. Also, the number of 'Macedonian' words that have been 'identified' by this 'scholarly' study is small (the authors do not offer a translation of the complete text, just a selection of supposed 'Macedonian' words). I discussed this with a linguist of my acquaintance, who said that if he studied the text in the same way, he would be able before too long to prove that some words in it were Finnish, Chinese or (Heaven forbid!) Bulgarian.

The nature of the language spoken by the ancient Makedónes is hard to evaluate, because so little of it remains (I will ignore the claim concerning the Rosetta Stone, and the suggestion that there are inscriptions of an early date in one or more non-Greek languages which have been discovered, but are locked up in Greek museums and kept secret). We have about a hundred and fifty words that are specifically described as ´Macedonian´, most of them from the Lexicon of Hesychius (5th century A.D., but incorporating earlier work). The material is insufficient for a firm judgement to be made (and it should be remembered that Hesychius and his predecessors were collecting rare or unusual words, rather than listing ones that were the same everywhere), but it is clear even from this limited sample that the Macedonian language was no further from Attic Greek (which became the standard form) than the Cretan or Spartan languages, which would certainly be called Greek.
Having said this, I can restate my position and develop it a bit. The origin of the Makedónes is unclear, but they seem to have arrived in the area around Aigai (Edessa & Vergina) by the eighth century B.C. They pushed out or absorbed the Bottiaioi who lived in that region or to the south of it, and other groups such as the Pierians and Mygdonians. Over the next two centuries they settled there and expanded their territory, and although they still had a number of separate tribes, a firm succession of kings was established, and this made them stronger than other more divided groups. Some of the names of early kings that we have may be legendary, but with Perdikkas I (7th century) we seem to be on firmer ground. The territory under the control of the Makedónes continued to expand, and by the beginning of the 5th century one of their kings, Alexander I, had begun to issue coins with his own name written on them in Greek.

Several passages that survive in Greek authors of the fifth and fourth centuries suggest that the Macedonians were regarded by the southern Greeks as ´different´. This is not surprising, since they had arrived on the scene much later than the groups that had entered the peninsula during the Bronze Age and moved southward, but it is clear from the evidence that they were, although perhaps grudgingly, accepted as being Hellenes. The situation is less clear with regard to their neighbours on the north, in an area that cannot be exactly defined, but is approximately equivalent to the territory of the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia. These were called the Paionians, and there were frequent conflicts as they tried to expand into Macedonian territory. At the accession of Philip II to the throne of Macedonia the Paionians joined with the Illyrians in an attempt to take advantage of the inexperience of the new king, but Philip drove them back, defeating them on more than one occasion.

When I spoke of this in my after-dinner speech, I described this event as a ´conquest´, which was completed by Philip´s son Alexander III. This was an overstatement. The Paionians were defeated, but their territory did not become a part of Macedonia. This is shown by the fact that the Paionian kings began issuing coins bearing their own names (written in Greek of course) during the reign of Philip II, and when Alexander started making his conquests, they provided a separate contingent of cavalry in his army. They certainly remained separate from Macedonia until the Roman conquest, as their continued issuing of coinage, first in the name of their kings, and finally in the name of the Paionians themselves in the early second century B.C., shows. And in the immediate aftermath of that conquest they were still regarded as separate, if we can believe the Roman historian Livy, who tells us (XLV, 29) that the Dardanians were not allowed by the Romans to take control of Paionia, although, as they claimed, it had once been theirs, because it had belonged to the last Macedonian king Perseus (sub regno Persei), and all Perseus´s subjects had now been granted political freedom (libertas).

In later years the name 'Macedonia' was applied to a much larger area. It included some land to the north (Paionia), to the west and to the south (even including southern Greece for a while until a separate Roman province of Achaia was created). And in the centuries before the Ottoman conquest the geographical extent of ´Macedonia´ (by now a purely administrative district, with no separate ethnic identity), varied considerably at different times. But now we are moving away from the issue that brought me into this naming dispute. This is that the territory of the FYROM was not, either in the fourth century B.C. or for many centuries after that, a part of Macedonia (except perhaps for a very narrow strip along its southern border), and that the erection of a statue of Alexander the Great in Skopje can never be justified, because it is based on a distortion of history by a people who, I am sorry to say, are trying to create a false identity for themselves.
http://www.americanchronicle.com/articles/view/216105

This guy has lost the plot.....
Had anyone wrote any letters to this propagandist..and was there a reply from him..?

This is his E-mail john.melville-jones@uwa.edu.au
 
Last edited:
Australian Macedonian Advisory Council is the Greeks at it with their constant attacks on our identity, they have stolen our name and this issue of paying professors to side with utter rubbish and bullshit, should be investigated by the appropriate boards and he should be stripped of his phd doctorate for propogating false information and propoganda
 
Anti-Macedonian 'University of Western Australia' Professor strikes again! some people never learn

Re: The Importance of Historical Truth and The Macedonian Issue
Australian Macedonian Advisory Council
February 03, 2011
Following the publication of the edited version of the after-dinner talk that I gave in October, a formal complaint was made to my employer (to which a polite reply was made, stressing the importance of academic freedom), and I received an e-mailed message from the United Macedonian Diaspora (which I thought, because of its name, must be a Greek organisation until I read what it had to say), together with a number of other e-mails. Many of these were merely abusive, but this didn´t surprise me, because I know from experience that when people hold strong beliefs that are based on faith not fact, and they are shown that these beliefs cannot be true, this is distressing to them, and they will very often become agitated, as they cling to their beliefs even more vigorously. None of the messages that I received addressed the issue that I raised in my talk in Melbourne, the proposed erection of the statue of Alexander the Great in Skopje. Two of them were, however, more thoughtful, and I have had some mild and civilised exchanges with their authors, as we define our positions.

Some of the points that were made were what I would call 'diversionary', such as the statement that the present population of the Greek province of Macedonia has nothing in common with its population in ancient times, being 'colonisers', referring to the fact that many of them were brought there from Turkey in the 1920s during the exchange of populations which led to Muslims being removed from some areas of the Balkans, and Christians from some parts of Asia Minor. I have pointed out to the persons who made this point that this is not an accurate way to describe what happened; and it is certainly not relevant to the issue that brought me into this debate (see below). Similarly, I know that in northern Greece some of the things that have been done to the Slav minority who live there, such as discouraging them from using their own language, cannot be defended (and I wonder what has happened to any Greek speakers who still live in the FYROM, but no one has told me anything about them). But I am a specialist in the ancient world, not in modern history, and again this is not relevant to the point that I am trying to make.

Anyway, I composed a reply, and sent it to everyone who had contacted me, answering some of the points that had been made, and emphasising that I was not well informed on the details of what had happened in the period of Ottoman domination or the twentieth century, although I am in fact learning more. For example, I have been looking at a book called The Contest for Macedonian Identity 1870-1912 by Nick Anastasovski, which is very scholarly and better documented, particularly in relation to Ottoman sources, than anything else that I have previously read. But it fails in its promise to show how a 'Macedonian Identity' began to be constructed in the 19th century. And one of the problems is that the word ´Macedonian´ can be interpreted in different ways (I am reminded of the character Humpty Dumpty in Lewis Carroll´s Alice through the Looking Glass, who said ´When I use a word, it means just what I choose it to mean …´).

One delightful experience was my being directed, apparently seriously, to a web site produced by two scientists in Skopje, who claimed to have shown that the middle section of the Rosetta Stone (196 B.C.), the section occupying the space between the text that was presented in hieroglyphics and the text that was presented in Greek, was not, as has been generally supposed, written in Middle or Ptolemaic Demotic Egyptian (close to Coptic), but in the original 'Macedonian' language, which the Ptolemies, being Macedonians, were supposed to have used. This was combined with the suggestion that these original 'Macedonians' had been driven out of Macedonia by the Romans, but returned some seven centuries later to their homeland. Thus we would have a connection between the Macedonians of antiquity and the present inhabitants of the FYROM.

It is amazing that this world-shattering theory has not made the front pages of the international newspapers, even though, to judge from the comments that I have found on the web, some people in the FYROM are convinced by it. There are, however, obvious weaknesses that anyone, not necessarily a specialist in linguistics, can spot easily. In the first place, the web site dismisses the perfectly credible translation from Demotic which is provided by the British Museum. Also, the number of 'Macedonian' words that have been 'identified' by this 'scholarly' study is small (the authors do not offer a translation of the complete text, just a selection of supposed 'Macedonian' words). I discussed this with a linguist of my acquaintance, who said that if he studied the text in the same way, he would be able before too long to prove that some words in it were Finnish, Chinese or (Heaven forbid!) Bulgarian.

The nature of the language spoken by the ancient Makedónes is hard to evaluate, because so little of it remains (I will ignore the claim concerning the Rosetta Stone, and the suggestion that there are inscriptions of an early date in one or more non-Greek languages which have been discovered, but are locked up in Greek museums and kept secret). We have about a hundred and fifty words that are specifically described as ´Macedonian´, most of them from the Lexicon of Hesychius (5th century A.D., but incorporating earlier work). The material is insufficient for a firm judgement to be made (and it should be remembered that Hesychius and his predecessors were collecting rare or unusual words, rather than listing ones that were the same everywhere), but it is clear even from this limited sample that the Macedonian language was no further from Attic Greek (which became the standard form) than the Cretan or Spartan languages, which would certainly be called Greek.
Having said this, I can restate my position and develop it a bit. The origin of the Makedónes is unclear, but they seem to have arrived in the area around Aigai (Edessa & Vergina) by the eighth century B.C. They pushed out or absorbed the Bottiaioi who lived in that region or to the south of it, and other groups such as the Pierians and Mygdonians. Over the next two centuries they settled there and expanded their territory, and although they still had a number of separate tribes, a firm succession of kings was established, and this made them stronger than other more divided groups. Some of the names of early kings that we have may be legendary, but with Perdikkas I (7th century) we seem to be on firmer ground. The territory under the control of the Makedónes continued to expand, and by the beginning of the 5th century one of their kings, Alexander I, had begun to issue coins with his own name written on them in Greek.

Several passages that survive in Greek authors of the fifth and fourth centuries suggest that the Macedonians were regarded by the southern Greeks as ´different´. This is not surprising, since they had arrived on the scene much later than the groups that had entered the peninsula during the Bronze Age and moved southward, but it is clear from the evidence that they were, although perhaps grudgingly, accepted as being Hellenes. The situation is less clear with regard to their neighbours on the north, in an area that cannot be exactly defined, but is approximately equivalent to the territory of the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia. These were called the Paionians, and there were frequent conflicts as they tried to expand into Macedonian territory. At the accession of Philip II to the throne of Macedonia the Paionians joined with the Illyrians in an attempt to take advantage of the inexperience of the new king, but Philip drove them back, defeating them on more than one occasion.

When I spoke of this in my after-dinner speech, I described this event as a ´conquest´, which was completed by Philip´s son Alexander III. This was an overstatement. The Paionians were defeated, but their territory did not become a part of Macedonia. This is shown by the fact that the Paionian kings began issuing coins bearing their own names (written in Greek of course) during the reign of Philip II, and when Alexander started making his conquests, they provided a separate contingent of cavalry in his army. They certainly remained separate from Macedonia until the Roman conquest, as their continued issuing of coinage, first in the name of their kings, and finally in the name of the Paionians themselves in the early second century B.C., shows. And in the immediate aftermath of that conquest they were still regarded as separate, if we can believe the Roman historian Livy, who tells us (XLV, 29) that the Dardanians were not allowed by the Romans to take control of Paionia, although, as they claimed, it had once been theirs, because it had belonged to the last Macedonian king Perseus (sub regno Persei), and all Perseus´s subjects had now been granted political freedom (libertas).

In later years the name 'Macedonia' was applied to a much larger area. It included some land to the north (Paionia), to the west and to the south (even including southern Greece for a while until a separate Roman province of Achaia was created). And in the centuries before the Ottoman conquest the geographical extent of ´Macedonia´ (by now a purely administrative district, with no separate ethnic identity), varied considerably at different times. But now we are moving away from the issue that brought me into this naming dispute. This is that the territory of the FYROM was not, either in the fourth century B.C. or for many centuries after that, a part of Macedonia (except perhaps for a very narrow strip along its southern border), and that the erection of a statue of Alexander the Great in Skopje can never be justified, because it is based on a distortion of history by a people who, I am sorry to say, are trying to create a false identity for themselves.
http://www.americanchronicle.com/articles/view/216105

This guy has lost the plot.....
Had anyone wrote any letters to this propagandist..and was there a reply from him..?

This is his E-mail john.melville-jones@uwa.edu.au

heh, was about to post this but you beat me to it :)

It makes you wonder why this "academic" would stoop to such low levels. I can understand if he has a opinion but he goes further and speaks down on Macedonians and belittles them.

Ironically he claims that he is a "expert" only on ancient history, not modern, and yet has the arrogance to downplay the macedonian movement in ottoman times and has the nerve to bring up some sort of phantom "greek" minority in rep of macedonia that has some how vanished.

Finally, for a supposed expert on ancient macedonian history he made the false claim that only a "small strip" of land in rep of macedonia belonged in the ancient macedonian kingdom. I have seen maps of the macedonian empire in its peak reaching as far as struga and maybe kicevo. I wouldnt call it a small strip but perhaps 35% of the republic.

I wonder what a "respected academic" would put in so much effort to push the greek agenda and put down macedonians on public sites like American chronicle...
 
A paid propagandist funded by maggots representing a racist nation that is yet to reach the 21st century.

If they find the UMD offensive, they should come here more often.
 
Does anyone think we would have a chance to say something before we a thrown out?

I was overseas when they did their "tour" a few months ago and could not attend their performance in Adelaide. But it would appear no Macedonians went to any of their performances anywhere.

Yet 2 Greeks went to the Adelaide premiere of Next Year in Lerin. As clueless as they are, they are fighting for an agenda.
 
....Finally, for a supposed expert on ancient macedonian history he made the false claim that only a "small strip" of land in rep of macedonia belonged in the ancient macedonian kingdom. I have seen maps of the macedonian empire in its peak reaching as far as struga and maybe kicevo. I wouldnt call it a small strip but perhaps 35% of the republic.....
BBS, I am very, very disappointed in you (or any other Macedonian ignorant of the historical facts) making such unfounded and anti-Macedonian claims (supposedly to shore up the Macedonian Cause) about the extent of the Macedonian EMPIRE in Europe at its peak expansion under the rule of Filip II and Aleksandar III Makedonski!

The info has been floating around for years and there is NO excuse why Macedonians should be undermining their own (Macedonian) cause by their own ignorance or laziness, IMHO!

FYI:
Polybius says northern border of (ancient) Macedonia was the Danube!

Polybius: "...The rule of the Macedonians in Europe extended...from the lands bordering the Adriatic to the Danube...." Book I (Page 42 of Penguin Classics Edition).


MACEDONIANS, A SEPARATE PEOPLE SINCE ANCIENT TIMES.

The Ancient Kingdom of Macedonia was situated to the north of Greece.
Unlike Macedonia, Greece was not a unified country, it consisted of City States which were independent political entities. City States did not exist in Macedonia, Macedonia was vastly different in that a national patriarchal monarchy existed, political and social conditions were unique and basic Macedonian life was characteristically different to the Greek.

Culturally and linguistically the two peoples differed, and historical evidence confirms that the Ancient Macedonians considered the Greeks as neighbours, not as kinsmen. On the other hand the Greeks considered the Macedonians as foreigners.

Generally Ancient Greek writers use the term “barbarians” when referring to the Macedonians. This term was used by the Ancient Greek people when referring to non-Greek people. Today an abundance of ancient literature is available which supports the fact that the Macedonians were a distinct and separate group of people who were labelled as “barbarians” by the ancient Greeks. All who spoke a foreign language to Greek were considered “barbarian”, Macedonians were placed into this category because their language was incomprehensible to the Greeks. Ancient writers clearly spoke of the Macedonians as a separate people with a separate language to the Greeks, these include such famous writers as Herodotus, Thucydides, Curtius Rufus, Plutarch, Hesiod, Abel, Arrian and others.

The famous Athenian orator Demosthenes (384-322 BC) provides a clear indication of Greek opinion towards the Macedonians in his Third Oration against King Phillip II of Macedonia:

“Truly, Phillip calls himself a Hellenophile, that is a friend to the Greeks. Phillip cannot be a friend to the Greeks because of his barbarian origin. He is not a Hellene and is not in any way connected by kin with the Hellenes. He is not even a foreigner of respectable descent. He is only a miserable Macedonian, and in Macedon as is well known, one cannot even buy a descent slave”

Soon after this famous speech against the Macedonian King, an alliance was formed between the City States at Chaeronea in August 338 BC. The City State soldiers were overwhelmingly defeated by the Macedonian army under the leadership of King Phillip and his son Alexander the Great. Having conquered the City States, King Phillip II of Macedonia reorganised them under the League of Corinth and placed himself commander in chief of their forces. He then forced the League members to form a separate alliance with Macedonia. Macedonia itself was not a League member, the League was under Macedonian domination. The City States despised this state of affairs, as it was unthinkable that they should be dominated by the “Macedonian barbarians”.

The French historian Pierre Jouguet comments on how the Macedonians and Greeks viewed each other in his book “Alexander the Great and the Hellenistic World”’:

“When that union (between Macedonian and Greece) was achieved, it was only by policy and force... the Hellenes and the Macedonians regarded themselves as different nations, and this feeling did not cease to be the source of great difficulties for the union of Greece under Macedonian rule”.

Clearly, the Ancient Macedonians thought of themselves as a separate people to the Greeks, and the development of both the Macedonian and Greek people have taken separate paths through the natural processes of nation building.

It is interesting to note that Ancient maps present Greece under the name of Achaia. The Ancient Greeks called themselves Hellenes, they were divided amongst City States until the Romans wiped out the last City State (Corinth)in 146 AD, and for nearly two thousand years there was no such thing as a national Greek state until 1830.

The Macedonian name which existed over three thousand years ago is still used today by the Macedonian people. The Macedonian people consider themselves to be the natural heirs of Ancient Macedonia, and are outraged as modern Greek nationalists conduct an obsessive campaign involving gross manipulations and distortions to connect Twentieth Century politics to Ancient History. By claiming the Ancient Macedonians as Greek they believe they can justify the Greek occupation of Southern Macedonia (1912-1913) and their territorial ambitions.

Despite the historical facts confirming the differences between the Macedonian and Greek people, Greek “scholars” have embarked on an obsessive campaign involving gross manipulation and falsification of every aspect of Macedonian history, identity, culture, language, politics, customs, etc. At the same time modern Greek academics and historians maintain a direct lineage of “unbroken descent” between the modern Greeks and the Ancient Hellenes. The manipulation of their own history has reached absurd dimensions, it is also claimed that the modern Greek state is ethnically homogenous. This notion contains a distinct political connotation rather than a historical one.

1Ares Publishing Inc 1985.

4

Macedonians condemn Greek attempts at the falsification of the Macedonian identity and history, and suggest that they examine their own background. Recent historical evidence suggests that the racial origin of the modern Greeks is Turkic-Slavic. The purpose of this pamphlet is not to analyse the racial origin of the Greek people, the best people to do that are the Greeks themselves (objectively), unfortunately any serious discussion on this topic by Greek academics and historians is actively discouraged in Greece. There are brave historians such as Ioannis Kordatos (”A History of Later Greece – Turkish Rule” Athens 1957) who have expressed differing views to the official version embraced by the Greek government, Kordatos is of the opinion that K. Paparigopulous and Karolidis, leading historians of the second half of the 19th and early years of the 20th Century and founders of modern Greek historiography, used false arguments to support their claim that the modern Greek nation was in direct descent from the ancient Hellenes.

There are a number of non-Greek sources which question the historical continuity of Hellenism. Robert Browning in Greece Old and New, (edited by Tom Winnifrith and Penelope Murray, Macmillan Press, London 1963) states:

“In 1830 the Bavarian Johann Philipp Fallmereyer proposed that “the Slav invasions and settlements of the late sixth and seventh centuries resulted in the expulsion or extirpation of the original population of peninsula Greece. Consequently the medieval and modern Greeks.. . Are not the descendants of the Greeks of antiquity, and their Hellenism is “artificiaI” R.M. Henkins (1963 “Byzantium and Byzantinism” Cincinnati) revived the idea”.

“By the middle of the fourteenth and early fifteenth century the majority of people in the Peloponnese were Albanian speakers... the Albanian incursions into Greece continued under the Turkish system and went on right into the eighteenth century... the descendants of these people were still talking Albanian when I was in Greece in the 1930’s”

Regardless of how Greek academics, historians, nationalist organisations and the Greek government portray the Macedonians, it is an indisputable reality that Greece is desperately attempting to conceal the fact that approximately 1,500,000 – 1,800,000 Macedonians live in Aegean Macedonia today, and have been subject to brutal oppression and persecution in Aegean Macedonian for over 80 years by the Greek state.

5

ETHNO-GEOGRAPHICAL MAP OF MACEDONIA

Ethnographic Macedonia covers an area of 67,712.2 square kilometers on the central region of the Balkan Peninsula. It is geographically bounded on the east by the River Mesta and the Rhodope Mountains, the Shar mountains in the north, Albania and the Prespa-Ohrid Lakes define the western frontier, and the southern boundary is defined by the River Bistrica, the Aegean Sea and Mt Olympus.

Ancient Macedonia covered an area roughly equal in size to ethnographic Macedonia today.[2]

n2 The territory of Ancient Macedonia is accurately designated as almost equal with today’s ethnographical map of Macedonia by ancient cartographers Strabo and Ptolemy.
The same borders are accepted by various Serbian and Bulgarian scholars. A Greek publication “Macedonia” (General Editor M.B. Sakellariou, Ekdotike Athenon S.A., Athens 1983. Page 118) presents a map of Ancient Macedonia incorporating today’s ethnographical borders, including the modern capital of the Republic of Macedonia, Skopje.

6

-----------------

The Division Of Macedonia And The Oppression Of The
Macedonians Under Greek Occupation

Nick Anastasovski
On behalf of Macedonian Youth Alliance (Melbourne, Australia),1995

CONTENTS
1. Introduction
2. Macedonians, a Separate People Since Ancient times
3. Ethnographical Map of Macedonia
4. Ottoman Empire in Macedonia
5. Balkan Wars
6. Greek Method of Oppressing and Assimilating the Macedonians

7. Macedonians from Aegean Macedonia participate in World War Two and Greek Civil War

8. Greek Persecution of Macedonians 1950's - 1990's

9. Greek Policy and the Australian Government

10. Macedonian Demands in Aegean Macedonia

11. Appendices

----------

For fair use only.
 
BBS, I am very, very disappointed in you (or any other Macedonian ignorant of the historical facts) making such unfounded and anti-Macedonian claims (supposedly to shore up the Macedonian Cause) about the extent of the Macedonian EMPIRE in Europe at its peak expansion under the rule of Filip II and Aleksandar III Makedonski!

The info has been floating around for years and there is NO excuse why Macedonians should be undermining their own (Macedonian) cause by their own ignorance or laziness, IMHO!

FYI:

Hey Indigen,

Cheers for refreshing my mind and clearing my head :)

I had a funny feeling that alexanders empire was bigger then then the images i could find in google, because in the past i used to argue over idiots who kept on saying that the empire only contained a "small strip" of rep of macedonia. I just wasnt sure by how much as the map that i reference was taken down by wikipedia :)

I used the few quick google images i could find of alexanders empire because the map that i always have used in these disputes, that pretty much shows alexanders empire contained most, if not all of rep of macedonia, was taken down by wikepedia. Im guessing it is the work of internet grks again.

I get this when i try to go to the wikepdia page and access the map:
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/1/14/Map-alexander-empire.png


Anyway, thankfully after spending a bit of time searching on the internet i was able to find the map again, but unfortunately it is much smaller then the map i used to be able to access on wikipedia.

For all those interested here is the map of alexanders Empire that contains pretty much all of rep of macedonia:

http://www.artline.ro/Alexander-the-Great-King-of-Macedonia-24095-2-n.html

http://www.artline.ro/files/gItems/image/5/Map-alexander-empire.jpg
 
BBS don't listen to the BS coming from our enemies Macedonia is much bigger than they think.The propaganda is to belittle us for example skoje accorfing to bs is not meant to be part of the ancient macedonia.That's BS skopje was part of the ancient macedonia.
 
ABC officially calls ancient Macedonians & Alexander Greek

ABC officially calls ancient Macedonians & Alexander Greek

This is the response received for an official complaint about an Alexander the Great documentary aired on the Australian Broadcasting corporation, claiming Alexander, his empire and the Macedonian people greek::



---------------------

Thank you for your email regarding the documentary Alexander's Greatest Battle, broadcast on ABC1 on 17 January. I am sorry for the delay in responding to you.

I understand you considered that this program contained false historical information; specifically, the assertion that Alexander the Great was Greek. In accordance with the ABC's complaints process, your concerns have been investigated by Audience & Consumer Affairs, a unit which is separate to and independent of program making areas within the ABC.


In light of your concerns, Audience & Consumer Affairs has reviewed the program and assessed the references to Alexander being Greek against the relevant editorial standard for accuracy, which requires that every reasonable effort be made to ensure that factual content is accurate and in context.

The presenter and narrator of the program, Michael Wood, made two references to Alexander as a "Greek conqueror" and six references to Alexander and his army as "the Greeks". He also had the following exchange with Syrian historian Professor Mohammad Mohfel:

PROFESSOR MOHAMMAD MOHFEL: Alexander is more than the Greek.
MICHAEL WOOD: Alexander is more than Greek?
PROFESSOR MOHAMMAD MOHFEL: Yes, more than Greek. He's something universal.

However, Mr Wood also referred several times to the fact that Alexander and his army were Macedonian; for example, he described Alexander as "the young Macedonian" and referred to "the Macedonians" and "the Macedonian army". Early in the program he also stated as follows: "His route north leads first to the great caravan city of Aleppo, which the Greeks renamed Veria after their home town in Macedonia".

Having regard to all of these instances, it is apparent that Mr Wood's references to Alexander being Greek did not constitute assertions that he was Greek only and not Macedonian; rather, Mr Wood asserted that Alexander was both Greek and Macedonian.

I understand there is considerable disagreement about whether Alexander was Macedonian, Greek or both. In considering this issue, it is important to ensure that modern notions of nationhood and nationality are not anachronistically applied to the ancient world. For example, it is not the case that 'Macedonia' and 'Greece' existed as nations - in the modern sense of the word - at the time of Alexander, and the ancient Macedonian kingdom and Greek city-states do not equate to the modern nations of Macedonia and Greece.

It is clear that you believe Alexander was Macedonian and not Greek. Mr Wood, on the other hand, asserted that he was both. The implication of this assertion was that Alexander was from Macedonia but was ethnically Greek. Mr Wood's position is supported by numerous modern historians; for example, in his book 'The Ancient Greeks: A Critical History', Professor John Fine stated as follows: "Since so little is known about the early Macedonians, it is hardly strange that in both ancient and modern times there has been much disagreement on their ethnic identity. The Greeks in general and Demosthenes in particular looked upon them as barbarians, that is, not Greek. Modern scholarship, after many generations of argument, now almost unanimously recognizes them as Greeks, a branch of the Dorians and "Northwest Greeks" who, after long residence in the north Pindus region, migrated eastward" (p. 607).

On review, taking into account the context in which the references to Alexander being Greek were made, and the fact that Mr Wood also referred to Alexander as Macedonian, Audience & Consumer Affairs is satisfied that the references were consistent with the editorial standard for accuracy.

Nonetheless, we do acknowledge your strong views about this issue. Please be assured, your comments have been noted and conveyed to ABC Television management so that relevant staff are aware of your concerns and feedback about the program.

For your reference, the ABC's editorial standards, including the Code of Practice, are available here: http://abc.net.au/corp/pubs/edpols.htm. Should you be dissatisfied with this response to your complaint, the avenues of review which may be available to you are outlined at section 7 of the Code of Practice. Please note that the ABC is making changes to its self-regulatory arrangements in 2011 and the Complaints Review Executive and Independent Complaints Review Panel will be discontinued on a date to be announced. Should you wish to pursue your complaint with either of these bodies, please do so within 14 days. Your opportunity to seek review from the Australian Communications and Media Authority will be unaffected by these changes.

For more information about the changes the ABC is making to its self-regulatory framework, please refer to the report available here: http://abc.net.au/corp/pubs/documents/review_of_the_abc_self_regulation_framework_1009.pdf.

Thank you for taking the time to write.

Yours sincerely

Simon Melkman
ABC Audience & Consumer Affairs


------------------------
Lets see what response people can muster up to another step form of oppression of the Macedonian people in Australia.

I sincerely hope people here can put time in to actually defend our nation and make a real difference.

Volk :2guns:
 
Last edited:
Volk,

Did you write to him originally? You could tell him not to lecture us on "notions of modern nationhood and nationality" and focus on the topic at hand. Further, he may want to read a little more widely, including the ancient authors who make it clear, in my view, that the Macedonians were not Greek according to "ancient notions of belonging to cultural/political communities".
 
Tom, I did write to him and know exactly how to respond.

I was hoping for some other people to respond also, since we are all such passionate Macedonians we should all act as such, don't you think?
 
Modern scholarship, after many generations of argument, now almost unanimously recognizes them as Greeks,
:confused1:

This is a review on the Michael Woods tv series by Eugene N. Borza


Multimedia: Alexander's Epic March
by Eugene N. Borza
Volume 51 Number 3, May/June 1998

A PBS series offers stunning images of the conqueror's route through Egypt, the Near East, and Asia.

"To this day no one has traced the whole of Alexander's great journey on the ground--that was my plan." Despite Michael Wood's enormous effort, modern politics prevented him from realizing his goal. Yet this British historian and creator of more than 60 documentaries has come closer to doing so than any of his illustrious predecessors, including the great early twentieth-century British explorer Sir Aurel Stein and the indefatigable mid-century traveler Freya Stark, both of whom intensively explored portions of Alexander's route. We are grateful to have the record of Wood's journey across Greece, Turkey, Syria, Lebanon, Israel, Egypt, Iraq, Iran, Afghanistan, Uzbekistan, Tajikistan, Pakistan, and India. It is to his credit that only in Iraq was he prevented by the authorities from following the ground trod by Alexander's army. There were also political difficulties in Greece, Israel, and Egypt, but Wood managed to overcome them.


(I’m curious to find what difficulties he had in Greece, and what he did to over come them :whistling:.)

Except for suggesting some alternate routes, the film does not contribute much to traditional scholarship on Alexander. On an artistic level, however, it is a major achievement that will enrich both scholars and the general public. With stunning images of parts of the world rarely seen by Western eyes, Wood conveys a sense of the extraordinary distances and dramatic campaigns in the difficult country through which Alexander led his army. No book or film has ever before so persuasively conveyed this message.

The effect is cumulative over the four one-hour episodes. The first two segments are a military and cultural travelog involving the ancient itinerary and the modern peoples who inhabit the Turkish and Near Eastern regions conquered by Alexander. Wood has a keen eye for contemporary life, and, as in his previous series, Legacy: Origins of Civilization and The Sacred Way (see "The Charm of Michael Wood," July/August 1994), he interacts effectively with the locals. His itinerary is occasionally enlivened by on-site interviews with specialists, such as one at the location of the Battle of Issus, the scene of Alexander's victory over the Persian king Darius in 333 B.C., during their first head-to-head encounter. On this famous coastal plain, amid the intrusions of a steel factory, electric power lines, and highway construction, Tulane University professor Kenneth Harl offers an energetic reconstruction of the battle. Later on, the journey into Egypt's Western Desert to retrace Alexander's route to the Siwa Oasis provides, perhaps for the first time, a comprehensive visual record of that dramatic landscape. These film images remind one of Lawrence of Arabia, with the addition of Wood's running historical commentary.
Although the political situation in Iraq prevented him from doing ground-level examination there, Wood, innovative as always, managed to hitch a ride on a U.S. Air Force AWACS flight that was monitoring the northern "no-fly zone." Within this sensitive military zone is the site of the Battle of Gaugamela, where, in 331 B.C., Alexander's army finally defeated Darius' forces in one of the largest and most decisive engagements of antiquity. Wood's discussion of that battle is illustrated from aloft, with a description of the ancient armies' movements through the terrain as seen on the AWACS's radar screens. The itinerary resumes in Iran with Wood's discovery of the route used by a detachment of Alexander's forces to circumvent the Persians' blockade of the pass leading to Persepolis, where the imperial palace complex provides, even in its ruined form, a dramatic backdrop for Wood's account of Alexander's destruction of this symbol of ancient authority in Asia in the spring of 330 B.C.

But it is in the third episode, covering the journey through Afghanistan and the central Asian republics, that the film's power becomes evident. With Wood, we are stunned by the present-day devastation of Kabul and the loss through looting of the treasures in the great museum there (see "Museum Under Siege", March/April 1996). The museum director's comment is touching: "It was as if our mother and father had died. Our whole history was here." From the ruins of Kabul, Wood follows Alexander's route across the towering Hindu Kush through the formidable Khawak Pass. He travels by Land Rover, then horse, and finally on foot, all the while recounting the ancient writers' descriptions of the suffering endured by Alexander's army from starvation, cold, exhaustion, and altitude sickness. At the head of the 12,000-foot pass, from which the land stretches away into central Asia, Wood notes that after "following Alexander's footsteps up here with this wind you can really feel, whatever you think about him, what an amazing achievement it was to drive an army over these mountains."

In episodes three and four, Wood experiences the push to Samarkand, the return to Afghanistan and the crossing of the Khyber Pass into the northwest frontier, the journey down the Indus, and finally the return trek across the Makran Desert toward Persia. The cinematography is so potent that, even after decades of studying Alexander's career, I understood for the first time the topography of the heretofore impregnable mountain fortress called in antiquity the Rock of Aornos, the modern Pir Sar. Using techniques known today mainly to mountaineers, Alexander's army climbed those steep heights to engage and defeat Indian enemies who had taken refuge there. By seizing Aornos, Alexander accomplished what is said to have thwarted Herakles during his wanderings across the earth. In the long run it was an insignificant military engagement, but the difficulty of the heights, plus the association with Herakles, certainly contributed to the enhancement of Alexander's legendary reputation. Of equal drama is the conqueror's return from the Indus Valley to Persia across the utter desolation of the Makran Desert in southern Pakistan. This journey was so devastating to Alexander's army that it has justifiably been compared to Napoleon's retreat from Moscow. These remote areas are brought to life by Wood's film, enabling those who read and write about Alexander to have a geographical stage on which to place historical characters.

One major theme that emerges is the enormous impact of Alexander's life and legend on local people, in coffee houses in northern Greece, in bazaars and tents in central Asia, and along the Indus frontier. The memories exist, deeply embedded in the folk traditions of a vast segment of Earth's peoples. No matter that many of the memories are hostile. Alexander's passing is still regarded as a disaster among the Zoroastrians of central Iran, who believe that his destruction of the ancient Persian Empire was an act of evil. To this day they call him "Alexander the Accursed." I hope the film will provoke cultural anthropologists to conduct a comprehensive study of the Alexander legends recalled by the people who live today along the conqueror's path.

The viewer is overwhelmed by the scale of the geographical obstacles encountered and overcome, albeit with huge losses, by Alexander's army. We are astounded that the young Macedonian king could have led an army through this alien wilderness while retaining the loyalty of his men through much of it. There are few historical parallels for Alexander's qualities of leadership. Yet, one wonders, what was the point? With Wood as our competent guide we begin to ask, "What was Alexander doing in this part of the world? What did his men think? Why did they follow him?" The viewer must conclude with Wood, lacking evidence to the contrary, that this was a highly personal undertaking without further meaning.

Wood's commentary is for the most part intelligent and dramatic, and occasionally moving. Specialists will find a few matters with which to quarrel. There is, for example, an enigmatic reference to Alexander's "far-sighted thinking," which not only contradicts Wood's thesis that there was little point to this expedition, but also flies in the face of the conqueror's well-known lack of interest in administration and planning beyond the most immediate military needs. Wood adheres to an outmoded idea that Alexander was a founder of many cities; the most recent scholarship suggests that he was actually responsible for only six: Alexandria in Egypt, plus five others, long gone, in central Asia. There is ambiguity about the distinction between Greek and Macedonian, terms that Wood uses indiscriminately even though the ancient sources are clear to distinguish between the Greeks and the Macedonians in Alexander's entourage. As time went on, most Greeks were dropped, and the expedition became almost solely a Macedonian operation. There is also a failure to reflect upon the savage campaign of slaughter inflicted upon the native peoples encountered during his campaigns, particularly those of the Indus Valley. The wholesale killing of civilian populations when there was no military necessity for it transcended even the rather loose wartime conventions of that era. It was a campaign of terror. And there is a curiously indecisive final evaluation of Alexander's career, despite powerful evidence that Wood himself offers of Alexander's amazing qualities of leadership.

As is often the practice with these productions, a book has been issued to accompany the film. Written by Wood and published by the BBC and the University of California Press, it lacks the grace of the television production, and its intended audience is not clear. It is not very interesting as a piece of travel literature until it gets to north Afghanistan, where, coincidentally, the film comes alive. Most people will find it an uneven and occasionally inaccurate account of Alexander's career. Some lapses in historical accuracy, while perhaps acceptable in the film where they do not diminish the visual impact, have no place on a printed page. At one point the date of the deaths of Alexander's wife Roxanne and son Alexander IV is given as 314 B.C., at another 313 (the correct date is 311/310). There is a slightly garbled account of Alexander's long-range plans, which, according to the first-century B.C. writer Diodorus Siculus, did not include the conquest of Arabia, as Wood alleges. (Another ancient writer, Arrian, reports that Alexander planned a circumnavigation of the Arabian peninsula, a natural extension of his exploration of the coastlines from India to Africa.)

As in the film, there is confusion between Greeks and Macedonians. During the earlier part of Alexander's campaigns, the army contained important contingents of Greek allies and mercenaries, but in time most of these were replaced with Macedonian and Asian troops. It is simply incorrect to call Alexander's army Greek. In one place, Wood refers to the army's "Greek high command," though there were only a handful of important Greek commanders, and a few pages later it is the "Macedonian high command" that draws our attention. Many American readers would be startled to learn that "50 degrees" is a "ferocious" temperature in northern Iraq, unless told that the measurement is Celsius, not Fahrenheit. One wishes that the author and his editor had brought to the book the same careful attention to detail that they brought to the film.

There are dozens of color illustrations, but many are stock photos drawn from the usual archival and museum sources, and too few are of the interesting places and peoples encountered by Wood in his journey. I often longed for a photograph to accompany the description of some distant place. The most interesting images were taken by Wood himself, for example, in the Makran Desert, at the Khawak Pass, among the people of Iran and Afghanistan, and from the heights of Pir Sar.

Wood has some creative ideas that will test traditional scholarship. He knows the ancient sources on Alexander, has read and understood much of the best modern scholarly literature, and has the enormous advantage of having walked the ground, a modern disciple of the ancient historian Polybius who advised historians to abandon their libraries and study in the field. There are several fresh interpretations of Alexander's route. If Wood is correct about the conqueror's path from the Siwa Oasis to the Nile Valley, I will have to rethink my own arguments concerning it, published nearly 30 years ago. Wood's exploration of the highland route taken by the conqueror's elite troops around the enemy forces blocking the Persian Gates leading to Persepolis may have finally resolved the outstanding questions concerning that event. And, as mentioned earlier, his exploration of the Macedonian army's campaign at the formidable Rock of Aornos not only confirms Sir Aurel Stein's earlier survey of the area, but gives us a remarkable photographic record of the investigation. One hopes that Wood will address these problems in more detail in print, thereby making an important contribution to scholarship concerning Alexander's journey.

Eugene N. Borza is professor emeritus of ancient history at Pennsylvania State University.

http://www.archaeology.org/9805/etc/multimedia.html
 
I have a few suggestions Volk:

1) As ABC admitted, the ancient authors viewed Macedonians and Greeks as separate nations, make sure you stress the authors and stress they stated it themselves:
http://www.macedoniantruth.org/forum/showthread.php?t=1706

2) Show them the Greek authors (before Megali Idea) that admitted Macedonians were separate from Greeks and oppressed Greeks, I believe it can be found there:
http://www.macedoniantruth.org/forum/showthread.php?t=1316

3) Remind ABC that even though Wood may view Alexander as BOTH Greek and Macedonians, Greeks use this as an excuse to state Macedonians = Greeks

4) Show him some present authors who disregard Alexander as being Greek, so show there is still disagreement (and always will be)
 
I sincerely hope people here can put time in to actually defend our nation and make a real difference.
Volk, well done on the effort.
But can't you see how futile it is when the Macedonian Government is denying the connection of modern Macedonians to Alexander by removing symbols that connect us to them. Why is your voice more important than the actions of the country called Macedonia (or FYROM depending on which flag you salute under)?
 
Back
Top