• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

Australian position on Macedonia

Australian position on Macedonia

  • ........

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • ......

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    0
In, order to answer the above truthfully he must make a premeditated choice to lie for the UMD. In, his reckless attempt to assist the UMD he has brought more shame (honesty) and a reason why people must think twice about anything they have to offer .. he, can't bail on them now he's in way over his head and feels some sense of responsibility.

I'm ready to hear that reply - it's showtime

MK
I don't expect him to reply or even attempt to answer the questions, my guess is he will deflect, ignore or flippantly skip over the issue at hand, despite laying it out in front of him, he will more than likely come back with another question in order to avoid having to answer. Ka sho ti reche ponapre - tenake!
 
Pension Agreement between Macedonia and Australia

Pension Agreement between Macedonia and Australia

I've just recently been informed by a number of Macedonian pensioners living in Australia that Centrelink has sent them forms and told them that they have to fill them in outlining work they have done in Macedonia otherwise they will have their Australian pensions cut.

Does this mean that their Australian pensions will be reduced proportionally to the amount of time worked in Macedonia and that they will then have to claim Macedonian pensions for the time worked there?

Denars are not the local currency. I'm starting to suspect that we have been given a dud deal.
 
MK
I don't expect him to reply or even attempt to answer the questions, my guess is he will deflect, ignore or flippantly skip over the issue at hand, despite laying it out in front of him, he will more than likely come back with another question in order to avoid having to answer. Ka sho ti reche ponapre - tenake!
He, was here earlier and made a choice to read and make no public comment (fled) at that time. He, tends to return after midnight Toronto time so he's still at the library looking up many words and definitions.

Does he think we're playing some sort of ethnic game here? Well, he will come to learn that the games ended 20 years ago.
 
Last edited:
He, was here earlier and made a choice to read and make no public comment (fled) at that time. He, tends to return after midnight Toronto time so he's still at the library looking up many words and definitions.

Does he think we're playing some sort of ethnic game here? Well, he will come to learn that the games ended 20 years ago.

MK
Pretty easy to come and go, chuck a few comments here and there, duck and weave, dodge and avoid, shit...reminds of some overseas politicians!
 
MK
Pretty easy to come and go, chuck a few comments here and there, duck and weave, dodge and avoid, shit...reminds of some overseas politicians!
At, some point in time he'll wake up (hopefully) to find an empty house where he can do what he wishes; however, until that time he will continue to get a major beating in the name of the UMD.

God, gave him two hands and it's time for him to use them - switch!
 
Last edited:
rujnovino
I'll narrow it down for you since you are having comprehension difficulties, here you go:-

Since we are having a discussion it's your turn to show me how the 3 above points can be accurately attributed to UMD and their use of the title.

rujnovino
:waiting:waiting

What happened to the discussion we were having? Here's a clue, it's your turn to respond now! Try and answer some of the questions that have been put to you, they remain unaddressed to date!
 
rujnovino
:waiting:waiting

What happened to the discussion we were having? Here's a clue, it's your turn to respond now! Try and answer some of the questions that have been put to you, they remain unaddressed to date!
nema mundi, skopen e sto po sto >>>>>>>> walk-in-closet filled with dresses and makeup aka user names
 
Last edited:
Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal

Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal

http://www.austlii.edu.au/au/cases/vic/VCAT/2011/1647.html

Australian Macedonian Advisory Council Inc. v LIVV Pty Limited trading as Australian Macedonian Weekly (Anti-Discrimination) [2011] VCAT 1647 (30 August 2011)

Last Updated: 6 September 2011

VICTORIAN CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

HUMAN RIGHTS DIVISION
ANTI-DISCRIMINATION LIST

VCAT REFERENCE NO. A41/2011
CATCHWORDS
Racial and Religious Tolerance Act 2001, section 7, whether article in ethnic weekly newspaper incited hatred or other relevant emotion on the ground of race



APPLICANT

Australian Macedonian Advisory Council Inc. (“AMAC”) on behalf of James Papadopoulos, Con Kouremenos, Christine Stavropoulos and Ian Pelekanakis
RESPONDENT

LIVV Pty Limited trading as Australian Macedonian Weekly
WHERE HELD

Melbourne
BEFORE

Noreen Megay, Senior Member
HEARING TYPE

Hearing
DATE OF HEARING

3 and 4 August 2011
DATE OF ORDER

30 August 2011
CITATION

Australian Macedonian Advisory Council Inc. v LIVV Pty Limited trading as Australian Macedonian Weekly (Anti-Discrimination) [2011] VCAT 1647

ORDER


The complaint is dismissed.
Noreen Megay
Senior Member






APPEARANCES:

For Applicant

Mr T Hurley of counsel
For Respondents

Mr J W Rapke QC, senior counsel

REASONS

Background

The complainant AMAC is an incorporated association and the other complainants are, or were, office bearers of the association. According to its website, AMAC is an “Hellenic-Australian non-profit political synergy, established in 2008 for the welfare and advancement of the Greek-Australian community. The chief concern of the AMAC is to edify, preserve and promote Hellenic civilisation in Australia with specific emphasis on the origin, history and culture of Macedonia. Where possible, it clarifies distortions of events aimed towards the falsification of Macedonian history through the illumination of historical truth, thereby safeguarding the kernel of Hellenic heritage for the sake of posterity.”
The respondent company publishes a weekly newspaper entitled Australian Macedonian Weekly. The newspaper is published mostly in the Macedonian language with the occasional article in English. It is produced in paper form and is sold by newsagents and other retailers. The hard copy version uses the Cyrillic alphabet. An electronic version appears on a website and its readers can choose between Cyrillic and Latin alphabets. Its editor (and sole director and shareholder) is Mr Ljupco Stankovski. He prints 5,000 copies each week with approximately 2,400 copies being distributed throughout Victoria, the balance throughout Australia where there are large Macedonian communities.
The 19 May 2009 edition (at page 27 of 60) carried an article headed “Who in this celestial world gave the Greeks the right to take away the Macedonian language?”
Apart from page 26 (which included four English language articles on a related subject matter), a small article on page 60 about a Melbourne Victory result and various advertisements, it was the only other English-language article in the entire 60-page edition.
The article in question is said to be written by someone who calls himself “Gandeto” and is date-lined 14 May 2009. The editor was sent a copy of this article from overseas. He received it on 16 May 2009 and having read it, decided to publish it. On 17 May he suffered a stroke which left him in a coma for two months and in hospital until the end of the year.
Following publication of the article Mr Kiritsis, the executive director of the complainant, wrote a series of letters to the respondent. Those letters were dated 29 July 2009, 12 August 2009, 15 August 2009, 25 August 2009, 9 September 2009, 16 September 2009 and 1 September 2010. Only two of them referred specifically to the article in question; the balance took the form of complaints about the publication of some“geographical maps” and an earlier article entitled “Sex, Alexander the Great and a dog called Dora” the content of which is unknown to the Tribunal. There is no doubt that the major cause for concern expressed in those letters was the latter article, not the Gandeto one.
On 14 August 2009 AMAC was informed of Mr Stankovski’s stroke and on 14 September 2009 his son sought further particulars of the complaints. Notwithstanding the grave illness of the publisher, the complainants took their grievance to the Press Council on 30 September 2009 but as the Tribunal understands matters, their complaint was not able to be dealt with. On 24 September 2010 they filed a complaint with the Victorian Equal Opportunity and Human Rights Commission. Attempts to conciliate the dispute were unsuccessful and on 27 January 2011 the matter was referred to this Tribunal pursuant to s.117(3) of the Equal Opportunity Act 1995.
Because it will be necessary consider the article in its historical and social context, some explanation is required. The article commences with a statement attributed to the Greek Prime Minister Harilaos Trikoupis who led Greece from 1882 to 1895. The quote is as follows:

“When the Great War comes, Macedonia will become Greek or Bulgarian, according to who wins. If it is taken by the Bulgarians, they will make the population Slavs. If we take it, we will make all of them Greeks.”

One gains the flavour of the article from the following paragraphs headed “Does it make any sense?”

Harilaos’ prophecy came true and in the Great War of 1912-13, Greeks – with the support of the western nations who reeked with chauvinism and hypocrisy – took Macedonia for the first time in their history. Ever since then, this thieving nation meticulously engaged its fascist army in destroying anything Macedonian and replacing it with Greek. To put a permanent imprint on a land they never owned before, they uprooted the ethnic Macedonians from their ancestral lands; burned and defaced any Macedonian artefact found connected to the past, transplanted refugees from Asia Minor and spread their gruesome poisonous propaganda throughout the Macedonian land. By erasing the Macedonian legacy, these fascist Greeks felt that they can eliminate and wipe out all potential witnesses from ever challenging the newly established status quo.

While with time, I think, we can forgive their zealousness for replacing the Macedonian toponyms. We can also overlook their crime in ethnically cleansing people from their homes. We can ignore the fact that they have burned our books written in the old Macedonian language. We can, perhaps, disregard the atrocities committed during the war; we’ll even discount the murders perpetrated in the name of Hellenism; we can forgive the delusional Greek zealots from erasing the Macedonian written language from the Macedonian churches and monasteries. Furthermore, we can close our eyes to the everyday torments inflicted on those ethnic Macedonians who elected to stay in their ancestral homes and take a chance under the hated Greek occupation.

I think we can, somehow, manage to convince ourselves to let everything stay in the past

The article continues:

But what we cannot overlook, what we cannot ignore, what we cannot disregard, cannot forgive, cannot close our eyes to, and we cannot ever remain silent about is the fact that these Greek zealots, these Greek deranged bastardly monsters took the Macedonian language away from our Macedonian children. That is what we’ll never, in a million years, be able to overcome and put behind us. That we cannot do.

How can a stinking Greek teacher and spy-for-a priest religious person denigrate, disparage, malign and ridicule the language of a child spoken by his mother and grandmother. How can a first grader be made to feel inferior because he does not speak Greek? How can a butcher-for-a-priest refuse to baptize a child with a name given by his parents?

.......

Who gave a right to these freaks of nature to impose their ugly nature on other populations

....

What evil alien abstraction possessed your dark soul to deprive a child from learning its mother’s songs? What barbaric wickedness obliterated your senses to deprive the children from learning their traditional cherished bedtime stories and songs, saved and propagated for generations on hand? Just what morbid urge, what dark indomitable fear prompted you to act with such horrible ferocity against defenceless population entrusted under your care?

Fast forward from the 19th century to 1913 and then to 1945 which saw the commencement of the communist Republic of Yugoslavia under Prime Minister Tito comprising Serbia, Croatia, Bosnia and Herzogovina, Macedonia, Slovenia and Montenegro. Tito died in 1980 and without his influence, ethnic and nationalist differences began to flare and the disintegration of the union began. Slovenia and Croatia were first to declare independence followed shortly thereafter (in January 1991) by Macedonia. It became a parliamentary democracy.
In an article annexed to Mr Stankovski’s statement, Professor Loring Danforth (the Professor of Anthropology at Bates College Maine USA) set out the background to what is now colloquially known as “the naming dispute.”

As Yugoslavia finally began to collapse in the early 1990s, the citizens of the Republic of Macedonia, in a referendum held on September 8, 1991, voted overwhelmingly in favour of initiating the process of establishing a completely sovereign and independent Macedonian state.

The fledgling state of Macedonia, however, faced a difficult struggle for international recognition because of the fierce opposition mounted by Greece to what Greeks claim to be a misappropriation by a Slavic people of the name Macedonia, a name that “was, is, and always will be Greek.”

In December 1992 the Republic of Macedonia applied for membership of the United Nations. On 8 April 1993 the General Assembly decided to “admit as a Member of the United Nations the State being provisionally referred to for all purposes within the United Nations as ‘The former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia’ pending settlement of the difference that had arisen over its name.”
The “naming dispute” persists and remains unresolved. According to Professor Danforth’s article the Greek nationalist position is that “because Alexander the Great and the ancient Macedonians were Greeks, and because ancient and modern Greece are bound in an unbroken line of racial and cultural continuity, it is only Greeks who have the right to identify themselves as Macedonian, not the Slavs of southern Yugloslavia, who settled in Macedonia in the sixth century AD and who called themselves “Bulgarians” until 1944.”
Two reviews serve to inform the ongoing discussion of the competing parties. Human Rights Watch (formerly Helsinki Watch) published a review of information gathered by a fact-finding mission in the Macedonian region in northern Greece in July 1993. Human Rights Watch is a body established in 1978 to monitor and promote domestic and international compliance with the human rights provisions of the 1975 Helsinki accords.
In February 2009 a report by an Independent Expert on Minority Issues (Mission to Greece) was presented to the Human Rights Council of the United Nations General Assembly.
The Tribunal is not required to express any view on the conclusions contained in these reports save to note that they indicate incidents which, if correct, would serve to authenticate many of the claims that underpin the denunciations in the article in question.

The legislation

The purposes of the Racial and Religious Tolerance Act 2001 (“the Act”) are set out in section 1.

The purposes of this Act are—

(a) to promote racial and religious tolerance by prohibiting certain conduct involving the vilification of persons on the ground of race or religious belief or activity;

(b) to provide a means of redress for the victims of racial or religious vilification

Section 4 sets out the objects and provides –

(1)The objects of this Act are—

(a) to promote the full and equal participation of every person in a society that values freedom of expression and is an open and multicultural democracy;

(b) to maintain the right of all Victorians to engage in robust discussion of any matter of public interest or to engage in, or comment on, any form of artistic expression, discussion of religious issues or academic debate where such discussion, expression, debate or comment does not vilify or marginalise any person or class of persons;

(c) to promote dispute resolution and resolve tensions between persons who (as a result of their ignorance of the attributes of others and the effect that their conduct may have on others) vilify others on the ground of race or religious belief or activity and those who are vilified.

Section 7 makes racial vilification unlawful and provides that-

(1) A person must not, on the ground of the race of another person or class of persons, engage in conduct that incites hatred against, serious contempt for, or revulsion or severe ridicule of, that other person or class of persons.

(2) For the purposes of subsection (1), conduct—

(a) may be constituted by a single occasion or by a number of occasions over a period of time; and

(b) may occur in or outside Victoria.

“Race” is defined in the Act to include “(a) colour; (b) descent or ancestry;(c) nationality or national origin”.
Section 9 deals with the irrelevancy of motive and dominant ground and provides -

(1) In determining whether a person has contravened section 7 or 8, the person's motive in engaging in any conduct is irrelevant.

(2) In determining whether a person has contravened section 7 or 8, it is irrelevant whether or not the race or religious belief or activity of another person or class of persons is the only or dominant ground for the conduct, so long as it is a substantial ground.

Section 11 sets out some exceptions and provides –

(1) A person does not contravene section 7 or 8 if the person establishes that the person's conduct was engaged in reasonably and in good faith—

(a) in the performance, exhibition or distribution of an artistic work; or

(b) in the course of any statement, publication, discussion or debate made or held, or any other conduct engaged in, for—

(i) any genuine academic, artistic, religious or scientific purpose; or

(ii) any purpose that is in the public interest; or

(2) For the purpose of subsection (1)(b)(i), a religious purpose includes, but is not limited to, conveying or teaching a religion or proselytising.

The complainants’ case

The complainants contend the respondent has breached section 7 of the Act, They say that the article constitutes racial vilification at three levels, namely-
The article as a whole;
The structure of parts of the article; and
Some specific words and phrases in the article.
They contend that the article describes the beliefs of “modern/contemporary Greeks” and is not expressing views of antiquity. They conclude this is so by virtue of reference to “modern Greeks, “Greek zealots” and references to Greece being undemocratic and “run by a government composed of zealots that only the brave few resist”.
They contend that the paragraphs repeated in paragraph 9 herein contain a peroration or exhortation leading to the denunciations set out in paragraph 10 herein (after the section in bold type) and the dramatic effect of the writing makes the words more effective in inciting hatred against, serious contempt for, or revulsion or severe ridicule of the Greek race. Further, other paragraphs contain statements that criticise the Greek race as one which is unable to maintain a real democracy, that endangers and oppresses ethnic minorities and can only produce a government that is run by hot headed brainwashed nationalists who dwell in the middle ages. They maintain that the concluding paragraphs of the article constitute a patronising statement that the Greek race is only capable of creating a country deficient in human rights, poor and on a downward spiral.
Their other contentions relate to various phrases which the complainants contend hold the Greek race up to hatred, serious contempt, or revulsion or severe ridicule because they portray members of the Greek race as having a capacity to perform and accept things that civilised persons do not. Such phrases are :
“a thieving nation”
“these Greek deranged bastardly monsters”
“stinking Greek teacher and a spy-for-a-priest”
“a butcher-for-a-priest”
“freaks of nature”
“deranged monsters”
“evil alien abstraction”
“what evil spirits possessed your moronic conscience
“predisposed to such ghastly monstrosity”
The Tribunal heard viva voce evidence from Mr Ian Pelekanakis who is a member of the complainant body and also its treasurer. In addition the Tribunal accepted into evidence three statements in support of the complainants’ case. One was from Leyshon Betts and the other from Professor Melville-Jones. Neither is of Greek descent and both stated that in their view the article breached the Act because of its offensive and abusive language. A third statement was received from Peter Jasonides who is of Greek extraction; in his view the impassioned tone of the article and its disparaging characteristics were malign and stimulated racial hatred.
Mr Pelekanakis told the Tribunal that the article’s author had used alleged historical events to abuse today’s Greeks and to portray them as racially inferior, evil and wicked. He said the article had been brought to his attention and he had then purchased a copy of the paper. He neither reads nor speaks Macedonian. The article was discussed at length at board level resulting in a decision that “something had to be done” about it.
In cross-examination he agreed that the naming issue was a “running sore” and that it had remained so since 1991. He insisted that the article had a dehumanising intent and was an attempt to portray Greeks as racially inferior, evil and wicked.

The respondent’s case

Mr Stankovski gave evidence as to how the article came to be published and why he thought it suitable for publication. It is clear that he is still unwell but his explanation is best summarised by some paragraphs from his written statement. He stated –

....because of the small overall population, the [Macedonian] community, whether at home or abroad, is very cohesive with a strong sense of ethnic identity. It is united by the Macedonian language, by its own church, the Macedonian Orthodox Church. There is a high level of inter-marriage between Macedonians. Extended family groups are common. In Melbourne the community is highly organised around the churches, cultural groups, sporting clubs and social activities.

In Melbourne, two newspapers as well as ethnic radio and television programs reinforce community cohesion and identity. The internet is used by many groups of Macedonians, and facilitates contact internationally. A Macedonian resident in Canada emailed the article complained of to the newspaper. The article that was forwarded to us was published in Canada a few weeks before we received it. We published it in the same format in which it was forwarded to us. As editor I considered it appropriate for publication as in my view, its content was a matter of public interest for the Macedonian community. The issues raised were topical and current and of concern to Macedonians in Australia and worldwide. In addition, the article coincides generally with Macedonian’s ongoing attempts to join the European Union, NATO and the United Nations under its constitutional name (the “naming dispute”)

.......

The article was published in the honest belief that it would be of interest to Macedonian readers, and that it was a matter of political significance and as such was worthy of discussion. There was no ulterior motive in publishing it. I believed in the truth of the statements made in the article, even though the language may have been extravagant in parts. It was my view that the public interest in the publication lay in educating and acquainting Macedonians in Australia of the history, heritage and nuances in dispute. I also felt the publication was able to remind Macedonians of the importance of these issues.

In cross-examination he was asked the following:

Q. If someone said of Slavic Macedonians that they were evil abstractions or freaks of nature, you would agree with me that is something that would hold Slavic Macedonians up to ridicule or contempt”

A Yes

Do you agree with me that if an article is written in Hobart which said something of American Indians that they were freaks of nature or evil alien abstractions would not those America Indians be entitled to say that they had been ridiculed?

Yes

In re-examination it became clear that Mr Stankovski’s grasp of English was less than fluent and that his ability to explain the meaning of various words was less than adequate. It was also apparent to me that he was unwell.
There were other witnesses for the respondent. The Tribunal heard from Aneta Kotevski and received various statements. Predictably each of the witnesses was either born in Macedonia or one or both of their parents were. The thrust of their evidence was that the article was to be read within its historical context and pointed out that the article assumes a certain knowledge of history and in particular of the annexation by Greece of Macedonia in 1913 and the subsequent and long-running naming dispute.

Discussion

The evidence before the Tribunal is predictably partisan and frankly of little assistance. The Greeks say the article vilifies them and incites hatred; the Macedonian Slavs (if I can call them that without being accused of using a pejorative term) say it is an article of interest to Macedonians and its utility is to educate and inform Macedonians living in Australia.
The first matter for me to decide is that of the right of the complainants to bring this action. As I understand the claim, it is brought pursuant to the representative provisions of the Act. Section 19 sets out who may take a complaint to the Commission. The relevant sub-sections provide as follows:

(3) A representative body may complain to the Commission on behalf of a named person or persons if the Commission is satisfied that—

(a) each person named in the complaint—

(i) is entitled to complain under subsection (1)(a); and

(ii) has consented to the complaint being made by the body on the person's behalf; and

(b) the representative body has a sufficient interest in the complaint; and

(c) the alleged contravention arises out of the same conduct.

(4) A representative body has sufficient interest in a complaint if the conduct that constitutes the alleged contravention is a matter of genuine concern to the body because of the way conduct of that nature adversely affects or has the potential adversely to affect the interests of the body or the interests or welfare of the persons it represents.

(5) An authorisation under sub-section (1)(b)(i) may be given—

(a) in writing; or

(b) in any other manner approved by the Commission.

I accept the evidence given by Mr Pelekanakis as to the genesis of the complaint, the reason for it and his explanation of how the subject matter of the complaint is viewed as a matter of genuine concern to the organisation of which he is a member and office bearer. This is so notwithstanding that the emphasis in most of the “pre-complaint” communications related to other matters.
The starting point for any analysis of matters arising under the Act is the Preamble to it, an unusual addition to the legislation in itself. The opening words of the Preamble are-

The Parliament recognises that freedom of expression is an essential component of a democratic society and that his freedom should be limited only to the extent that can be justified in an open and democratic society.

This makes it crystal clear that Parliament intended this Act to be interpreted with care and a degree of rectitude. Indeed, Neave JA, in Catch the Fire highlighted that approach at paragraph 173 where she stated –

The legislation aims to strike a balance between protecting freedom of speech and protecting people from vilification on the grounds of their race and religious belief. It would inconsistent with this aim to interpret the legislation so as to make it impossible for people to proselytise for their own faith or to criticise the religious beliefs of others.

That line of argument was considered in some detail in Walsh v Hanson [2000] HREOCA 8 and the sentiments expressed by the Commissioner bear repeating. The case involved Pauline Hanson and her One Nation party and the publication entitled “Pauline Hanson The Truth”. In the publication there were claims that aboriginals practised cannibalism and that they ate babies. Complaints were made about parts of the book although many aboriginals objected to it in its entirety. Ms Hanson defended the book (although she was not the author, she owned copyright) saying people needed an alternative to the noble savage picture of aborigines being taught in schools and universities. Having concluded that the nature of the publication was political, the Commissioner had this to say –

It is without doubt a grave matter to restrict or control the free expression of political thought. Such restrictions have frequently been imposed in the name of some good said to be so important that its promotion or preservation justifies the restrictions. I think care has to be taken not to suppress genuine political expression, even when that expression, either in form or content or both, may be repulsive to the majority of the community.

It is a concomitant of political freedom that political activists, especially those at the extreme ends of the political spectrum of ideas, will from time to time, even frequently, hurt and offend other members of society. It seems to me that we must be mature enough to accept that as a price that we must pay for the privilege of living in a society where political expression is to remain free and unfettered. This is so no matter how odious to the majority some of the fringe manifestations of that freedom may be.

The leading case in this jurisdiction is Catch the Fire Ministries Inc & Ors v Islamic Council of Victoria Inc & Anor [2006] VSCA 284. This was an appeal from a decision of this Tribunal that two Pentecostal pastors, and their evangelical organisation Catch the Fire Ministries, had engaged in religious vilification of Muslims in statements made at a public seminar held in 2002 and in articles published in 2001.
In his comprehensive judgment Nettle JA traversed the terms of the Act and made a number of salient points which have resonance in the case before me although I am not persuaded that I should just replace the word “religion” with “race” and assume that Catch the Fire contains a complete dossier of answers for matters arising where “race” is the sole element. This is because there are some necessary differences. For instance, in most cases, religion is a choice whereas race is not and one might ponder whether standards should be applied differently when considering whether racial laws (in circumstances where the person being racially vilified has no ability to choose) have been breached. That said, his Honour’s instructive judgment provides comprehensive guidance on a number of facets of the matters before me.
Under the heading “The meaning of ‘incites” his Honour dealt with the prevailing view that had arisen from the a decision of the NSW Administrative Appeals Tribunal in Kazak v John Fairfax Publications Ltd [2000] NSWADT 77. In that case, the Tribunal was considering the effect of s.20C of the Anti-Discrimination Act 1977 (NSW) which provides –

“It is unlawful for a person, by public act, to incite hatred towards, serious contempt for, or severe ridicule of, a person or group of persons on the ground of the race of the person or member of the group.”

At paragraph 13 his Honour stated:

The New South Wales Tribunal took the view that the word “incites” in s.20C should be given its ordinary meaning “urge, spur on, stir up, animate, stimulate to do something.” It also held that the operation of s.20C was not limited to what it called “actual incitement” and thus that it was sufficient to engage the operation of s.20C that conduct appear as likely to stimulate hatred, serious contempt or serious ridicule. That meant, it was said that one was to ignore any special characteristics or proclivities to which the audience or potential audience might be subject and to assess the matter by reference to the standard of the ‘ordinary reasonable reader”. In other words, one was to assume a “person of fair average intelligence who is not perverse, morbid, suspicious of mind or avid for scandal.”

In my view, however, that reasoning is not altogether apposite in relation to s.8 of the Act. That accords with the plain and ordinary meaning of the word and also with the criminal law’s conception of incitement, upon which s.8 appears loosely to be based. I also allow that incitive conduct is capable of contravening s.8 without necessarily causing hatred or serious contempt or revulsion or serious ridicule. As with the common law criminal offence of incitement, I view s.8 as directed to inchoate or preliminary conduct, whether or not it causes the kind of third party response it is calculated to encourage. In that sense, the section is prophylactic. But that said, I do not accept that one should exclude from consideration the nature of the audience to whom the conduct is directed.

It strikes me that even if the reasoning of the NSW tribunal remains entirely apposite in the case of race, in the circumstances of this matter, in its particular factual context and the Court of Appeal’s commentary about audience, I should not deal with incitement on the basis of whether or not the article is likely to stimulate the relevant emotion absent any consideration of the potential audience.
His Honour went on to state that the idea of the ‘ordinary reasonable reader’ arises from defamation law which has as its object the protection of individuals against false allegations calculated to lower them in the esteem of others. He continued –

Contrastingly, s.8 does not prohibit statements about religious beliefs per se or even statements which are critical or destructive of religious beliefs. Nor does it prohibit statements concerning the religious beliefs of a person or group of persons simply because they may offend or insult the person or group of persons. The proscription is limited to that which incites hatred or other relevant emotion and s.8 must be applied so as to give it that effect.

Neave JA took a slightly different view and concluded that because of publication on the web site and because anyone could have read the material on the website, the Tribunal was required to consider whether its effect was likely to incite hatred and other relevant responses among “a broad audience.”
Nettle JA went on to consider the nature of the audience to whom the conduct is directed. At paragraph 16 he continued:

If conduct is to incite a reaction, it must reach the mind of the audience. And if conduct is to be perceived as inciting a particular reaction, it must reach the mind of an audience as something which encourages that reaction. So, for conduct to incite hatred or other relevant emotion it must reach the mind of an audience as something which encourages those emotions. So, therefore, the question of whether it has that effect will depend upon the perception of the audience.

17. Of course, where statements are published generally as they might be in a book or newspaper or by posting on a web site, one may need to have regard to all manner of persons who are likely to see them and absorb them. But it is otherwise where the audience is select.

18......Parity of reasoning with the law relating to misleading and deceptive conduct suggests that s.8 has in view the effect of conduct on a reasonable members of the class of persons to whom the conduct is directed. But for the reasons already expressed, the perception of a reasonable member of the class of persons to whom conduct is directed will not always be the same as the perception of the so-called ordinary reasonable reader. ....

19. So to say does not deny “the ordinary reasonable reader” a role in the assessment of religious vilification. As will be seen, he or she or at least something very like them has a large role to play in the application of s.11. But for the purposes of s.8 I think the test is different. It is a question of whether the natural and ordinary effect of the conduct is to incite hatred or other relevant emotion in the circumstances of the case.

It is abundantly clear that it is necessary to construe the article as a whole and not to take individual phrases in a piecemeal fashion and construe the effect of each individual phrase. The cases are ad idem on this point and it follows that I reject the submission of counsel for the applicants that I should consider the individual slurs one by one.
It is necessary to view the entire article against the backdrop of historical context and the dispute which has arisen between the two communities and the antipathy generated by that dispute. The question to be asked is whether the article, as whole, in its historical and social context, amounts to incitement to hatred of the Greeks as a race? Not the ultra-nationalist Greeks who may have perpetrated the acts complained of, but the Greeks as a nation, as a race of people. And of course in answering the question, one must consider the nature of the audience which is likely to see and absorb the statements in question.
In so doing , I must also consider whether there are parts of the article which contain what is referred to in the cases as an ameliorating effect. The writer states that “he solutes [sic] all the progressive Greeks, who today, at their own peril – bravely support the ethnic minorities in Greece. I solute [sic] their courage to stand up to the hot-headed, brain-washed nationalists”. One might draw a variety of inferences from the text of the article that the writer does not seek to brand all modern Greeks with attributes equivalent to their forbears but in the main I viewed those inferences to be of little moment.
The Australian Macedonian Weekly is, as mentioned before, printed in the Macedonian language. A perusal of its website indicates copies from 2006 onwards are available on archive. A random search of several editions over the time reveals that English language articles are a rarity. Indeed the majority of editions are entirely in Macedonian. So even though the editions are on the website, they are not likely to be accessed by the public at large or indeed by folk who do not read the language. In my view that limits the extent of the potential audience. Furthermore, as Dr Kotevski said, without a knowledge and understanding of the history, a casual reader would not in any event comprehend the nuances contained in the article. Dr Kotevski, whose evidence I accepted on that point, is a daughter of a mixed Macedonian/Greek parentage.
Neave JA contemplated whether s.8 required consideration of whether the ordinary reasonable reader would be incited to hatred or other relevant response and referred to the finding in the Kazak case that s.20C of the Anti-Discrimination Act 1977 required consideration of whether

“the ordinary reasonable reader [could] understand from the....act that he/she is being incited to hatred towards or serious contempt for, or severe ridicule of a person or persons on the ground of race.”

At paragraph 157 she had this to say ;

Section 8 is not directed at religious vilification in the abstract but is concerned with the effect of the alleged inciter’s words or conduct on those exposed to that behaviour. If that were not the case, a person could deliberately inflame the emotions of people known to have prejudiced views towards a particular religious group and then avoid the application of s.8 by saying that the behaviour would not have incited an ordinary reasonable audience. With one minor qualification, I therefore agree with Nettle, J.A.’s view that s.8 requires consideration of the effect of the conduct on a member of the class to which it is directed. The minor qualification relates to Nettle, J.A.’s reference to a ‘reasonable” member of the class to which that conduct is directed. Despite the common use of the concept of reasonableness, both in the common law and in legislation, I have avoided that formulation because the concept of “a reasonable member of the class” may be inappropriate in the context of racial or religious vilification......it may be more appropriate to consider the effect of the words or conduct on an “ordinary” member of the class to which it is directed, taking account of the circumstances in which the conduct occurs. I would therefore agree....that the test for the purposes of s.8 is “whether the natural or ordinary effect of the conduct is to incite hatred or other relevant emotion in the circumstances of the case.”

For his part Ashley JA (dealing with the differences between his other two colleagues) at paragraph 132 stated:

First, concerning the question of incitement, I prefer the formulation that it should be decided by reference to an “ordinary” rather than a “reasonable” member of the audience class.....

......I agree with Neave J.A. that the import of a publication, so far as incitement is concerned, may be disclosed from consideration of its entirety rather than by discrete examination of its component parts.

All three of the judges in appeal spent some time considering the applicability of the test formulated in Bropho v Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission [2004] FCAFC 16. That case involved the publication of a cartoon that lampooned the dispute about the return of the head of an aboriginal leader from a museum in England. The ensuing complaint alleged a breach of s.18C of the Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth) which provided –

18C(1) It is unlawful for a person to do an act, otherwise than in private, if:

(a) the act is reasonably likely, in all the circumstances, to offend, insult, humiliate or intimidate another person or a group of people; and
(b) the act is done because of the race, colour or national or ethnic origin of the other person or some or all of the people in the group.

At first instance in Catch the Fire, the late Judge Higgins, then of this Tribunal, without expressly stating the source of his view, appeared to rely on the decision of French J in Bropho that the words “done because of” in s.18C of the Racial Discrimination Act, required a “causal connection”.
The Commonwealth Act contains exemptions in like vein to those found in s.11 of the Victorian Act. So, although the exemption sections are almost identical, the sections dealing with the actual breach are not so similar and that very difference makes the application of Bropho to the interpretation of s.7 somewhat fraught. What the case does highlight however is that the Court approved the formulation of Kiefel J in Creek v Cairns Post Pty Ltd [2001] FCA 1007 and that her Honour in turn relied on Waters v Public Ttransport Corporation [1991] HCA 49; (1991) 173 C.L.R. 349,401.
In considering the meaning of the words “on the ground of religious belief” as they appear in s.8, Nettle J.A. noted the construction placed on the words by the judge at first instance that the meaning of the words “on the ground of” was not dissimilar to “because” as it appeared in s.18C of the Commonwealth Act. He thought there were problems with this interpretation. In particular, at paragraph 23, his Honour stated:

..... it appears to me that s.9(1) of the Act, by expressly providing that a person’s motive in engaging in any conduct is irrelevant, confirms that "on the ground of" in s.8(1) is to be interpreted as the majority interpreted those words in the Equal Opportunity Act in Waters. In effect, it gives statutory force to the view first expressed by the House of Lords in R. v. Birmingham City Council and later adopted by Deane and Gaudron, JJ. in Australian Iron & Steel Pty Ltd v. Banovic and then by Mason, C.J. and Deane and Gaudron, JJ. in Waters, that intention or motive to discriminate (or in this case to engage in conduct which incites hatred), though it may be relevant so far as remedies are concerned, is not a necessary condition of liability.

Again, at paragraph 30 his Honour referred the problem of adopting the Bropho test and summarised as follows:

With respect, there are several aspects of that reasoning [the Tribunal at first instance] which I take leave to doubt. The first of them arises out of the adoption of the Bropho test and, consequently, the Tribunal’s conclusion that the words "on the ground of [religious beliefs]" imply a causal connection between religious beliefs and impugned conduct. In effect the Tribunal decided that the Seminar contravened s.8 because the Tribunal was satisfied that Pastor Scot was moved or caused by the religious beliefs of Muslims to make the statements which he did at the Seminar, and that an ordinary reasonable person who was not malevolently inclined or free from susceptibility to prejudice would be inclined by Pastor Scot’s statements to hate Muslims. But, for the reasons which I have given, I do not consider that that was the question which needed to be decided. In my view the question was whether, having regard to the content of the statements in the context of the whole of the Seminar, and to the nature of the audience in the sense that I have described, the natural and ordinary effect of what was stated was to encourage the hatred [or other stipulated emotion] of Muslims based on their religious beliefs..

It seems all three Justices of Appeal concluded that the approach taken by the majority in Waters was correct in relation to s.8 of the Victorian Act; i.e that the meaning of “on the ground of” in s.8 referred to the basis of the feelings likely to be incited in the audience and not to anything that motivated the vilifying conduct. This test is identical in respect of the element of “on the ground of” adopted in Kazak.
The language used in the article in question was described by Mr Stankovski as “extravagant”. That strikes me as an understatement. Frankly it is more properly viewed as an intemperate and (in many parts) hyperbolical rant aimed at the acts of past participants and present ultra-nationalists. But the test is not whether the article could have been written better, could have been expressed in less pejorative terms, or as counsel put it, in a more felicitous tone.
It is not for this Tribunal to determine whether the acts complained of in the article are an accurate recounting of history; the truth or otherwise of what might be seen as extreme allegations is of little relevance. It is not material whether the following extracts are or are not be a correct version of history although it is fair to say that against the “nuances of history” such allegations might appear perfectly appropriate but do not necessarily incite hatred.
..destroying anything Macedonian and replacing it with Greek;
to put a permanent imprint on a land they never owned before, the uprooted the ethnic Macedonians from their ancestral lands:
Burned and defaced any Macedonian artefact found connected to the past;
transplanted refugees from Asia Minor and spread their gruesome, poisonous propaganda through the Macedonian land;
By erasing the Macedonian legacy, these fascist Greeks felt they could eliminate and wipe out all potential witnesses from ever challenging the newly established status quo.
The complaints made in the article are not, in any event, complaints against Greeks per se; they are complaints about the actions of some Greeks perpetrated in the past and denunciations about perceived past wrongful acts.. “How can a stinking Greek teacher...?” whilst offensive is not made against all Greeks although made in relation to a teacher who refuses to let a child speak its mother tongue; “How can a butcher for a priest?” refers to an un-named individual, not to all Greeks; it is not a statement that all Greeks are butchers. And so on. What is being criticised here is the conduct of the priest, the conduct of the teacher.
Paraphrasing in accordance with section 7 what Neave J.A. stated as the correct construction of s.8, the following applies:
The phrase “on the ground of race” does not refer to the ground which caused the alleged inciter to act, but to the ground on which people exposed to the alleged inciter’s words were incited to hatred or other relevant emotion against another person or group.
It is not necessary to show that the audience was actually incited to hatred, serious contempt for, or revulsion or severe ridicule of a person or class or persons on the ground of their race.
A breach of s.7 occurs if the words or conduct have the tendency to incite that response.
In considering whether s.7 has been breached, it is necessary to take account of the effect of the words on an ordinary member of the audience to which they were directed.
The cases agree that the ordinary meaning of the words “incite” is to “urge, spur on, stir up, animate, stimulate to do something.” So in the context of s.7 the question that must be asked is whether, having regard to the content of the article as a whole set in its historical and social context, to the nature of an ordinary member of the audience it might reach, whether the natural and ordinary effect of what was stated in the article is to stir up, etc or stimulate and encourage the hatred of, serious contempt for, or revulsion or severe ridicule of Greeks on the ground of their race. I am not persuaded he complainants have made out their case; by that I mean that I am not persuaded that the offending article, when read by a person (within the limitations of the contemplated audience) of ‘fair intelligence who is not perverse, morbid, suspicious of mind or avid for scandal’ is likely to stimulate hatred or the other emotions contemplated by s.7.
I am mindful of the comments of Neave J.A. that when information is transferred to the internet, it reaches a broad general audience. But such is not the case here. I can say this with some confidence for the following reasons. Mr Stankovski told the tribunal that the article was aimed at Macedonians living in Australia. His evidence by itself might not be enough but there are other factors bearing on the subject. On its face, this is a Macedonian newspaper, published essentially in the Macedonian language in Cyrillic script and aimed at the Macedonian community. Certainly when published on the website it can be accessed by people who do not read Macedonian but such a reader would be limited to finding and reading the isolated English language articles appearing amid the myriad pages of Macedonian text.
Counsel for the respondent contended that because so much of background to the dispute which was the genesis of the article was not dealt with in the article and that knowledge of the history of the dispute was assumed, serves to confirm that the intended audience was not the world at large but a rather more select audience, Macedonians, and I think there is much force to that submission. For the average Macedonian reader, this article is probably just “preaching to the converted”and is not likely to stir up such raw emotion as to breach the Act. I suspect that the average non-Macedonian reader who might stumble across the article on the website or who might flick through it at the local shop would just wonder what it was all about without being incited to any extreme emotion about Greeks.
It is true that in modern multicultural Australia people might wonder why it was necessary consistently to re-open old ethnic wounds and to do so in such forceful terms. Although I would not wish to be taken as approving the tenor of the article I am not persuaded it breaches s.7 of the Act. In my view the words of the article do not have any tendency to incite hatred against Greeks or to incite serious contempt for, or revulsion or severe ridicule of Greeks on the ground of their race.
A commitment to free speech is an essential concept of all liberal democracies of which Australia is one. In this country we do not have a version of the USA’s first amendment which protects the most rabid ideology in the name of free speech but the legislation under review here (and its federal and other state counterparts) serves to place some restriction on racist and other extreme expressions. That said I am firmly of the view that restrictions should only be placed on discourse in the most egregious of cases. I can do no better than to echo and adopt the sentiments of the Hon J A Nader QC , the Commissioner who presided over the Hanson case. His comments on political discourse and its place in our society and the need for political expression to remain free and unfettered are set out in paragraph 40 herein.
It has not been necessary for me to consider the effect of section 11 because I have not found a breach of s.7. However without wishing to be taken as having considered the matter with any particularity, and assuming one were to be satisfied that the respondent had acted reasonably and in good faith, I would have some difficulty in deciding that the article was “a publication,
discussion or debate” for “any purpose that is in the public interest.” My instinct is that the section requires a consideration of whether the subject matter is in the interest of the public as a whole, as distinct from one that excites the interest of two ethnic groups of the public. But I am not required to decide the point.
The complaint is dismissed.

Noreen Megay
Senior Member
 
Apart from 'case dismissed'.. What stands out is Noreen Megay recognised that 'Macedonian Slav' is a pejorative term and discontinued its use throughout the discussion.

I would have termed it an ethnic slur!
 
Letter to Stefan Fule - Macedonian Literary Association "Grigor Prlichev" of Australi

Letter to Stefan Fule - Macedonian Literary Association "Grigor Prlichev" of Australi

Letter to Stefan Fule - Macedonian Literary Association "Grigor Prlichev" of Australia Inc.‏

7:29 AM
Reply ▼
risto stefov
To ;
Macedonian Literary Association “Grigor Prlichev” of Australia Inc.


P.O. Box 227 Rockdale (Sydney) NSW 2216

ABN: 64751353521 INC: 9885424



7.11.2011



To: Štefan Füle, Enlargement and European Neighbourhood Policy

Subject: Stop European genocide against the Macedonian people

We the Macedonians in Australia, live in a democratic multicultural society where we can freely cherish our Macedonian language and culture. The Macedonian language is taught in primary and secondary schools as well as at university level. Meaning democracy in Australia is based on principles which recognize language, ethnicity and national identity.


There are twenty Macedonian churches and monasteries, ten sports clubs, many cultural and arts organizations, theatres, literary associations and social clubs in Australia. Our Macedonian Literary Association “Grigor Prlicev” has existed for 33 years and, to this date, has published over 65 literary titles by Macedonian-Australian authors. The Association represents more than 300 members. Meaning, that in addition to Macedonians living in the Republic of Macedonia, there are Macedonians also living in Australia, New Zealand, Canada, the United States of America, Northern Europe and other places in the world as well as in the partitioned parts of Macedonia now existing under Greece, Bulgaria, Albania and Serbia.


History has shown very well that Europe has always had problems with Macedonia. It had problems during the Balkan wars, the First and Second World Wars and during the Yugoslav conflict when Europe stood behind the Albanian terrorists.


Why do you commit psychological torture against the Macedonian people?
Why do you blackmail the Macedonian people?
Why do you propagate the kind of democracy that hides behind Nazi ideology?


Your failure to recognize the Macedonian language, nation and state clearly tell us that there is no room for Macedonians in the European Community. When we are invisible, some non-existent nation, why do you blackmail us like the Athenians blackmail us? Or do you think we are simpletons and we will destroy ourselves only to please you.


It is time to stop the policy of genocide towards the Macedonian people. If you are not willing to accept us for who we are, then please stop mistreating us because we are Macedonians. Macedonia does not need membership in a European Community if people must be disfigured and stripped of their language and ethnicity in order to fit in.

Respectfully,

Dusan Ristevski
(President)






Македонско Литературно Друштво „Григор Прличев“



P.O. Box 227 Rockdale (Sydney) NSW 2216

ABN: 64751353521 INC: 9885424



7.11.2011



До Еврокомесарот Штефан Фуле



Повод: Да се запре европскиот геноцид врз македонскиот народ



Ние, Македонците во Австралија, живееме во едно демократско мултикултурно општество каде слободно го негуваме македонскиот јазик и култура. Македонскиот јазик се изучува во основните и средните училишта како и на универзитетско ниво. Значи во Австралија демократијата е заснована врз принципи на признавање на јазикот, етничкиот и националниот идентитет.



Во Австралија постојат дваесеттина македонски цркви и манастири, десетина спортски клубови, повеќе културно уметнички друштва, театри, литератуни друштва и социјални клубови. Нашето Македонското литературно друштво „Григор Прличев“ постои 33 години и досега има издадено над 65 книжевни наслови од македонско-австралиски автори. Во Друштвото членуваат повеќе од 300 членови. Значи, Македонците постојат во Австралија, Нов Зеланд, Канада, Америка, северна Европа, постојат и во нашата распарчена помеѓу Грција, Бугарија, Албанија и Србија, Македонија, постојат и во Република Македонија.



Историјата многу добро покажува дека на Европа од секогаш Македонија им пречела. Тоа се покажа со Балканските војни, со Првата и Втората светска војна како и со конфликтот при поделбата на Југославија кога Европа застана зад албанските терористи.



Зошто вршите психичка тортура врз македонскиот народ?

Зошто го уценувате македонскиот народ?

Зошто пропагирате демократија зад која тежнее нацистичка идеологија?



Со непризнавањето на македонскиот јазик, нација и држава вие јасно ни кажувате дека нема место за Македонците во европската заедница. Кога сме невидливи, некоја непостоечка нација, зошто не уценувате како што не уценуваат Атињаните? Или мислите дека ние сме слабоумни и ќе се самоуништиме само вас да ви угодиме.



Време е да се запре геноцидната политика спрема македонскиот народ. Доколку не сте спремни да не прифатите онакви какви што сме, тогаш ве молиме, престанете да не малтретирате поради тоа што сме Македонци. Верувајте, на Македонија не и` е потребно членство во некаква Европска заедница доколку влегуваме во истата обезличени, без јазик и етничност.



Со особено почитување,



Душан Ристевски

(претседател)


BOOKS PUBLISHED

BY THE “GRIGOR PRLICHEV” MACEDONIAN LITERARY ASSOCIATION OF AUSTRALIA



P.O.Box 227 Rockdale NSW 2216 Library: 5 Belmore Street Arncliffe NSW 2205 Ph./Fax. 9597 7362

E-mail: dushan@macedon.com; itrposki@hotmail.com Working hours: Fridays 6.30 – 8.30 pm



No. ISBN Year Author Title Page No. Price $



1. 0959132201 1984 Dr G. Stalev Vistas-Anthology (Poetry – Macedonian) 184 10.00

2. 095913221X 1984 D. Ristevski Fragments (Poetry-Macedonian) O.F.P. 42 10.00

3. 0959132236 1985 I. Trposki Shallow Roots (Poetry-Macedonian) 46 10.00

4. 0959132228 1985 B. Naumovski Keeper of Childhood Memories

(Stories for Children-Macedonian) 116 10.00

5. 0959132244 1986 B. Naumovski Time for Reminiscence (Poetry-Macedonian) 42 10.00

6. 0959132252 1987 G. Maslinkoski Farewell (Poetry-Macedonian) 56 10.00

7. 0959132260 1987 J. Kokalovski Atomic Protest (Poetry-Macedonian) 78 10.00

8. 0959132279 1988 L. Toseska Lyrical Echo (Poetry-Macedonian) 42 10.00

9. 0959132287 1988 I. Trposki Chained Sea (Poetry-Macedonian) 62 10.00

10. 0958745404 1989 J. Thomev Fragments of a History (Poetry-Bilingual) 104 10.00

11. 0959132295 1989 D. Ristevski Fragments (Poetry-Bilingual) 84 10.00

12. 0958745420 1990 B. Neskovski Three Plays: Full House; Say Goodbye to the Past;

Conqueror Cole (Plays – English) 244 20.00

13. 0958745412 1990 I. Trposki Heading West (Poetry-Macedonian) 70 10.00

14. 0958745463 1992 D. Ristevski Dream-Agony (Poetry-Macedonian) 98 10.00

15. 0958745455 1992 G. Maslinkoski Wedding in the Woods

(Poetry for Children-Macedonian) 60 10.00

16. 095874548X 1995 O. Nikolovska Voluntary Prisons (Play-Macedonian) 62 10.00

17. 0646036777 1995 D. Dzajkoski The Flow of Time (Poetry-Macedonian) 32 10.00

18. 0958745471 1995 I. Trposki Todorka (Poem-Macedonian) 32 10.00

19. 0958745498 1996 Anthology Macedonian Poetry in Australia (English) 170 20.00

20. 0958657912 1997 P. Damcevski-Kocin Future Never to Be (Poetry-Macedonian) 84 10.00

21. 0958657920 1998 P. Damcevski-Kocin Sinister Night (Play-Bilingual) 58 10.00

22. 0958657947 1999 I. Trposki Svitilo (Poetry-Macedonian) 80 10.00

23. 0958657963 1999 I. Trposki Between two Homelands

(Poetry for Children-Macedonian) 64 10.00

24. 0958657955 2000 V. Doneva-Varkoly: Houses for Sale and Prayer (Poetry-Macedonian) 70 10.00

25. 0958657963 2000 I. Trposki Following the Sun-Journey to Macedonia (Macedonian) 164 10.00

26. 0958657998 2001 V. Doneva-Varkoly: A Glass of Water for the Ocean (Poetry-Macedonian) 54 10.00

27. 095865798X 2001 D. Ristevski Clasp (Poetry-Macedonian) 68 10.00

28. 0958116222 2002 I. Trposki Macedonia-My Homeland (Journals - Macedonian) 186 10.00

29. 0958657971 2002 V. Doneva-Varkoly : Dream Message (Poetry – Macedonian) 54 10.00

30. 0958116237 2003 K.Naumovski Tears, Curses and Hopes (Poetry-Macedonian) 86 10.00

31. 0958116245 2003 V.Doneva-Varkoly: A branch in the wind no more (Poetry-Macedonian) 64 10.00

32. 0958116210 2003 D. Ristevski Flower – Woman (Poetry – Macedonian) 48 10.00

33. 0958116229 2003 Anthology Anthology of Love Poetry (Macedonian) 170 15.00

34. 0958116253 2004 A. Donski The Descendants of Alexander the Great of Macedon

(History-English) 250 20.00

35. 095811627X 2004 I.Trposki Love Imagination (Poetry-Macedonian) 60 10.00

36. 0958116288 2004 I. Trposki Restless Winds (Poetry-Macedonian) 82 10.00

37. 0958116296 2004 I. Trposki The Macedonian Demonstrations in Australia

(Community History – Macedonian) 342 25.00

38. 0958116261 2004 M. Seraphinoff Macedonian Gold (Novel-English) 182 15.00

39. 0975733206 2005 A. Donski The Genealogical Lineage between Queen Elizabeth II

and the Medieval Macedonian Tsar Samuel (History–English) 110 15.00

40. 0975733214 2005 S. Popov Kalesh Angja (Novel – English) 200 15.00

41. 0975733230 2006 M. Seraphinoff Some Great Old Stories from the Old Country Macedonia

(Folk Stories for Children-English) 32 10.00

42. 0975733249 2006 A. Donski The Genealogical Lineage between Certain American Presidents and

the Dynasty of Alexander the Great and other Macedonian Dynasties

(History-English) 196 15.00

43. 0975733257 2006 A. Donski The Language of Ancient Macedonians

(History-Macedonian) 242 15.00

44. 0975733222 2006 D. Ristevski Fear and Shame (Play – Macedonian) 120 15.00

45. 0975733265 2007 P. Damcevski-Kocin Macedonia Altar (Poetry-Macedonian) 78 10.00

46. 0975733273 2007 A. Donski The Byzantine Tsars of Macedonian Ethnicity

(History–Macedonian) 196 15.00

47. 0975733281 2007 A. Donski Descendants of the Ancient Macedonian Dynasty

(History–Macedonian) 110 15.00

48. 097573329X 2008 Risto Stefov Short History of Macedonia (History-English) 306 20.00

49. 9780980481334 2008 Ivan Trposki Behind the Blue Wave (Poetry-Macedonian) 118 10.00

50. 9780980481327 2008 Ivan Trposki Spase Trposki-Spasko (Biography-Macedonian) 154 10.00

51. 9780980481358 2008 Viktor Gaber Recognition and Denial (History-English) 184 20.00

52. 9780980481310 2009 A. Donski The Mystery of the Copper Book (History-English) 256 20.00



…..2/



No. ISBN Year Author Title Page No. Price $



53. 9780980481303 2009 P.Damcevski-Kocin Mother’s Footprints (Poetry-Bilingual) 182 10.00

54. 9780980481341 2009 D. Ristevski Fear and Shame (Play – English) 104 10.00



55. 9780980481365 2009 D. Ristevski Stolen Thoughts (Poetry-Macedonian) 88 10.00

56. 9780980481372 2009 D.Ristevski Forbidden Love (Poetry-Macedonian) 56 10.00

57. 9780980481389 2010 A. Donski The Ancient Macedonians Were No Greeks

(History-Macedonian) 76 10.00

58. 9780980481396 2010 A. Donski The Ancient Macedonians Were Not Greeks

(History-English) 72 10.00

59. 9780980847901 2011 G. Jovanovski The Joy of Youth (Poetry for children-Macedonian) 76 10.00

60. 9780980847918 2011 Risto Stefov The Little Book of Big Greek Lies (Politics-English) 120 15.00

61. 9780980847949 2011 V.Doneva-Varkoly Making a Rug (Poetry/Essays-Macedonian) 84 10.00

62. 9780980847963 2011 D.Ristevski Stolen Thoughts (Poetry-Bilingual) 158 10.00

63. 9780980847925 2011 A. Donski Ancient Greek and other Ancient Testimonies of the

Distinction of the Ancient Macedonians (History-Macedonian) 15.00

64. 9780980847932 2011 A. Donski Ancient Greek and other Ancient Testimonies of the

Distinction of the Ancient Macedonians (History-English) 15.00







To place an order: Cheque/MO payable to:

Macedonian Literary Association

PO Box 227 Rockdale NSW 2216



For further information: dushan@macedon.com Tel. 0425231335

itrposki@hotmail.com
 
The Hon. PETER BREEN on the "MACEDONIAN ETHNIC IDENTITY"

The Hon. PETER BREEN on the "MACEDONIAN ETHNIC IDENTITY"

PARLIAMENT OF NEW SOUTH WALES
The Hon. PETER BREEN [6.25 p.m.]: I bring to the Parliament's attention the plight of Macedonians who have been denied the right to ethnic self-identification by the States of Greece, Bulgaria and Albania, as well as by Australian governments, under pressure from a lobby of the Greek state. Following the Balkan wars of 1912 and 1913 Macedonia, which was until then part of the Ottoman Empire, was divided between Greece, Serbia, Bulgaria and Albania. In a bid to create an ethnically homogenous nation, each of those states adopted the policy of denying indigenous Macedonians the right to maintain their own ethnic identity.

After World War II, following struggles by the Macedonian Liberation Movement, the Serb-occupied part of Macedonia was established as a Macedonian republic within the Yugoslav Federation. In 1991 the Republic of Macedonia became a sovereign and democratic state, recognised by the international community. But Greece, Bulgaria and, to a lesser extent Albania, continue to deny the existence of a Macedonian ethnic identity. Greece has extended this policy to denying the Republic of Macedonia the right to call itself Macedonia. To appease the Greek Government and its international lobby, some members of the international community, including Australia, have refused to recognise Macedonia under its proper name, and refer to it by the absurd name "Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia".

When Macedonian Australians declare their country of origin as Macedonia, Australian government departments record their country of origin as "Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia". This is despite the fact that over 120 countries, including the United States of America, Russia and China, have now recognised the Republic of Macedonia under its proper name. In 1994 the Australian Government further appeased the Greek Government's lobby by adopting a policy that all Australian government departments and agencies should refer to Australian Macedonians as "Slav Macedonians", with the official excuse that it was necessary to distinguish Macedonians from the Republic of Macedonia from Greek Macedonians.

Australian Macedonians are an ethnic community originating not only from the Republic of Macedonia, but also from parts of Macedonia under Greece, Bulgaria and Albania. They find it discriminatory and oppressive that the Australian Government should impose on them any identity other than the identity they have determined for themselves. I am not aware of any other ethnic community towards which Australia has adopted such a policy. In a report entitled "Denying Ethnic Identity: The Macedonians of Greece", Human Rights Watch-Helsinki found:

The Greek Government denies that a Macedonian minority exists in Greece. It refers to ethnic Macedonians as "Slavophones" or "Slav-Speakers". The official Greek position is that the Greek state is ethnically homogenous, the only exception being the Muslim minority in western Thrace—which is in reality a Turkish minority—whose existence was confirmed in 1923 by the Lausanne Treaty …

The Greek Government's denial of the existence of the Macedonian minority violates international human rights agreements to which the Greek Government is a party. [Under international law], minority identity is a matter to be determined by the individual, and not by the state.

In May 2004 the United Nations Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights urged Greece to reconsider its position with regard to the recognition of ethnic, religious or linguistic minorities, and invited it to ratify the Council of Europe Framework Convention for the Protection of National Minorities 1995.

In June 2004 the European Commission against Racism and Intolerance noted that "persons wishing to express their Macedonian, Turkish or other identity incur the hostility of the population". The commission encouraged the Greek authorities to take further steps toward the recognition of the freedom of association and expression of members of the Macedonian and Turkish communities. The United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Persons Belonging to National or Religious and Linguistic Minorities requires that:

… States shall protect the existence and the national or ethnic, cultural, religious and linguistic identity of minorities within their respective territories and shall encourage conditions for the promotion of that identity. (Article 1 (1))

Greece's denial of the existence of the Macedonian minority clearly contravenes its obligations under international law and agreements. A multicultural country like Australia should be strongly discouraging such an oppressive policy, rather than reinforcing it with its own denial of the Macedonian ethnic identity. If Australia had a bill of rights to give domestic force to international human rights law, the Government's refusal to respect the right of Macedonians to self-identification would likely be declared by a court as a breach of human rights. Australian Macedonians reject being identified as Slav-Macedonians or Former Yugoslav Macedonians. Australia should respect the right of Australian Macedonians to self-identification and should urge other countries to do likewise.
http://www.parliament.nsw.gov.au/Prod/parlment/hansart.nsf/V3Key/LC20060329039

I dont know if that was posted before, if yes feel free to erase this.
 
Australian government announces policy shift and recognises macedonian community

Australian government announces policy shift and recognises macedonian community

AUSTRALIAN GOVERNMENT ANNOUNCES POLICY SHIFT
AND RECOGNISES MACEDONIAN COMMUNITY

13 February 2012

The Australian Macedonian Human Rights Committee (AMHRC) is pleased to announce that after a sustained lobbying campaign, the Australian Government has finally withdrawn its discriminatory and racist “Slav Macedonian” Directive which renamed the Macedonian community in 1994.

In a letter dated 9 January 2012, the Acting Chief of Staff to the Minister for Foreign Affairs wrote:

“I can reaffirm that the ‘Slav Macedonian’ Administrative Circular is no longer operative in the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (DFAT). As is standard practice with inoperative Administrative Circulars, it has been cancelled and the document archived. Similarly, DFAT has advised me that the ‘Slav Macedonian Directive’ is not in use in other agencies, including the Department of Immigration and Citizenship and the Australian Bureau of Statistics.”

The Department of Immigration and Citizenship also confirmed this position in a subsequent letter to the AMHRC on 11 January 2012:

“As stated by...[the] acting Chief of Staff to the Minister of Foreign Affairs, I can confirm that this department does not actively use the term ‘Slav-Macedonian’. For example, the Translating and Interpreting Service National now only uses the term ‘Macedonian’. We acknowledge the concerns of the Macedonian Australian community in relation to this matter.”

This victory marks the end of a significant and long-running campaign by the AMHRC to gain governmental acceptance of the Macedonian community’s right to self-identification. The campaign began in 1994, and saw hearings before the High Court of Australia, the Human Rights & Equal Opportunity Commission and the Parliamentary Committee on Foreign Affairs and Trade. Its culmination was recently reached after an intensive series of exchanges, involving meetings and correspondence, with senior Cabinet Minsters (including the Prime Minister), members of parliament from all political parties and various Government Departments.

The Australian Government’s announcement of the official end to its offensive nomenclature policy marks a return to the long successful policy of Multiculturalism, a position the AMHRC has long advocated. This is a victory that will be beneficial to the maintenance of the human rights of all Australians.

Whilst the AMHRC is pleased with the Australian Government’s current shift in policy toward the Macedonian Community, it now reiterates its call upon the Government to take the next logical step and recognise the Republic of Macedonia under its official and democratically chosen name.

Established in 1984, the Australian Macedonian Human Rights Committee (AMHRC) is a non-governmental organisation that informs and advocates before international institutions, governments and broader communities about combating racism and promoting human rights. Our aspiration is to ensure that Macedonian communities and other excluded groups throughout the world, are recognised, respected and afforded equitable treatment. For more information please visit www.macedonianhr.org.au, email info@macedonianhr.org.au or via +61 3 9329 8960 .
 
АВСТРАЛИСКАТА ВЛАДА НАЈАВУВА ПРОМЕНА НА
ПОЛИТИКАТА И ЈА ПРИЗНАВА МАКЕДОНСКАТА ЗАЕДНИЦА

13 февруари 2012 г.

Австралиско-македонскиот комитет за човекови права (АМКЧП) со задоволство изјавува дека после една долготрајна кампања на лобирање, австралиската влада конечно ја има повлечено својата дискриминаторска и расистичка „Славо-македонска“ директива со која што македонската заедница беше преименувана во 1994 г.

Во писмо до АМКЧП датирано 9 јануари 2012 г., вршителот на должноста шеф на кабинетот на Министерот за надворешни работи напиша:

„Јас можам да потврдам дека „Славо-македонското“ Административно циркуларно писмо повеќе не е на сила во Министерството за надворешни pаботи и трговија (ДФАТ). Како што е вообичајната пратика што се однесува до неважечки Аднминистративни циркуларни писма, тоа е поништено и докуметот е ставен во архива. Исто така, ДФАТ ми има ставено до знаење дека „Славо-македонската Директива” не се применува во други владини служби, влучувајки ги и Министреството за имиграција и државјанство и Австралискиот завод за статистика.”

Министерството за имиграција и државјанство исто така го потврди овој став во друго писмо до АМКЧП на 11 јануари 2012 г.:

„Како што изјавил вршителот на должноста шеф на кабинетот на министерот за надворешни работи, јас можам да потврдам дека ова министерство активно не го употребува терминот „Славо-македонски.” На пример, Националната служба за преведување и толкување сега само го употребува терминот „македонски”. Ние ја признаваме загриженоста на Македонско-австралиската заедница во врска со ова прашање.”

Со ова победа се одбележува крајот на една значајна и долготрајна кампања водена од Австралиско-македонскиот комитет за човекови права, чија цел беше владата да се согласи да го прифати правото на македонската заедница на самоидентификација. Кампањата започна во 1994 г. и вкулучуваше сослушувања во Високиот суд на Австралија, Комисијата за човекови права и еднакви можности и Парламентарниот комитет за надворешни работи и трговија. Кампањата го достигна својот врв неодамна како последица на интензивна серија од размени на мислења која вклучуваше средби и допишувања со водечки министри на владиниот кабинет (вклучувајки ја и премиерката), парламентарни претставници од сите политички партии и разни владини министерства.

Соопштението на австралиската влада дека официално става крај на својата навредлива политика на преименување значи враќање кон долготрајна и успешната политика на мултикултурата, која АМКЧП оддамна ја поддржува. Ова е победа која ќе биде корисна за зачувување на човековите права на сите Австралици.

Иако АМКЧП е среќен што австралиската влада ја промени политиката кон македонската заедница, тој го повторува своето барање владата на Австралија логично да постапува и да ја признае Република Македонија под нејзиното официаллно и демократско избрано име.
 
CHRONOLOGY: HOW THE “SLAV MACEDONAN” POLICY CAME TO AN END


1994 – Macedonian Community in Australia officially renamed

In February 1994, Australia recognised the Republic of Macedonia under the provisional reference “the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia”.

In March 1994 the Australian Federal Government issued a Directive officially requiring all government agencies to re-name Macedonians residing in Australia, to “Slav Macedonians”. This applied to all those people whose ancestry was linked to the Republic of Macedonia. While all other members of the Macedonian ethnic community of Australia who had come to this country from the parts of Macedonia located outside the borders of the Republic of Macedonia (e.g.: in Greece) were required by the Directive to be referred to as “individuals associated with Slav-Macedonians”. The Australian government had effectively taken away their right to possess an ethnic identity.


1994–2000 Victorian Government officially renames Macedonian language to “Macedonian (Slavonic)”
In July 1994 sighting the Federal Government’s renaming of the Macedonian Community, a Directive was issued by the former Premier of Victoria, Mr Jeff Kennett. The “Language Directive” as it became known, required any official Victorian State Government reference to the Macedonian language to take the form of “Macedonian (Slavonic)”.
In response to the language directive, the AMHRC lodged a claim with the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission (HREOC) which challenged the Victorian Government's directive on the grounds that it was discriminatory and racially based. After subsequent hearings before the Federal Court, Full Federal Court and High Court of Australia, the matter returned to HREOC.
Commissioner Street of HREOC handed down his decision on 8 September 2000 declaring that the Victorian Government had engaged in conduct rendered unlawful by section 9 (1) of the Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth) by the act of issuing the directive in the terms of the memorandum dated 21 July 1994 which involved a distinction based on ethnic origin in re-naming the language Macedonian and had the effect of impairing the recognition on an equal footing of a human right in the cultural life of users of the Macedonian language and I declare that the Victorian Government not continue such unlawful conduct.

1995-2010: Implementation of policy

Despite repeated protests and objections by the AMHRC and other members of the Macedonian community, successive federal governments maintain the “Slav Macedonian” policy.




February 2011: AMHRC reiterates demand for official withdrawal

The Australian Macedonian Human Rights Committee (AMHRC) writes to the Minister for Foreign Affairs and the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship seeking a formal withdrawal of the discriminatory and offensive “Slav Macedonian” policy.


11 May 2011: Minister shifts responsibility

In return correspondence to the AMHRC, the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship claimed that, the Directive “is a matter that falls within the portfolio responsibilities of the Minister for Foreign Affairs”.


6 June 2011: Foreign Affairs Department avoids answering questions on policy

In correspondence to the AMHRC on behalf of the Minister for Foreign Affairs, the Director of the Southern Europe branch of the Department of Foreign Affairs affirms the maintenance of the Government’s “Slav Macedonian” policy, but claims that he is “unaware of the extent and nature of its use across Commonwealth agencies.”


23 June 2011: AMHRC makes FOI Request for Documents

Frustrated by the lack of government transparency on this issue, the AMHRC submits a Freedom of Information Request under the Freedom of Information Act 1982 to demand documents evidencing the implementation of the “Slav Macedonian” Directive. Upon obtaining such documentation the intention of the AMHRC was to launch a legal racial discrimination claim against the government, as it had already successfully done against the Victorian government for renaming the Macedonian language.


10 July 2011: Foreign Affairs Minister shifts responsibility

In response to previous correspondence from a fellow government Minister, the Minister for Foreign Affairs claims that, “the 1994 “Slav Macedonian directive” was issued by then then-Department of Immigration and Ethnic Affairs and that accordingly, we may wish to contact his colleague, the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship, on this matter.


12 July 2011: Immigration Department shifts responsibility...again

A Government Minister receives correspondence from the Parliamentary Secretary for Immigration and Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs shifting responsibility for the Directive back to the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade by claiming that, “The 1994 Directive in relation to the term ‘Slav-Macedonian’ cannot be rescinded, as it is subordinate to the Australian Government’s foreign policy relating to the country name.”


18 August 2011: AMHRC appears before Parliamentary Sub-Committee

Representatives of the AMHRC appear before the Joint Parliamentary Sub-Committee on Human Rights in Parliament House Canberra, discussing a range of human rights issues including the “Slav Macedonian” Directive.


22 September 2011: FOI Request outcome exposes government’s policy

Under the Freedom of Information Act, dozens of documents are released to the AMHRC. While parts of the released documents were redacted, what was disclosed was quite revealing. For example, according to the Department’s own advice, “[a]though the 1994 directive has not been suspended, in practice Commonwealth agencies have moved away from using the term “Slav-Macedonian” (Ministerial Submission 09-1054, 26/05/2009).

The Department noted that “[because] it is not being implemented consistently and because it causes offence to the Macedonian community there is a case for reviewing the directive” (Ministerial Submission 09-1054, 26/05/2009). DFAT officials also concede that “Slav Macedonian” is a “horrible piece of terminology” and that it “could easily be incorrect (and consequently considered offensive)” (email from Southern Europe Section 10/01/2006).

Furthermore the documents revealed that in addition to the Macedonian ethnic group, the directive is also offensive to other ethnic groups from the Republic of Macedonia. In fact the advice noted that “eyond taking offence, these other groups would consider it inaccurate to be called ‘Slav-Macedonian’ for nationality purposes” (Ministerial Submission 09-1054, 26/05/2009).

On several occasions the Government has claimed that “the term ‘Slav Macedonian’ is in no way meant to be considered an ethnic identifier”. However in 2006, a DFAT official from the Southern Europe Section admitted that the “term ‘Slav Macedonian’ is essentially an ethnic indicator” (Attachment B – Email from Southern Europe Section 10/01/2006).


6 October 2011: AMHRC demands official withdrawal of policy

The AMHRC writes to the Prime Minister, the Minister for Foreign Affairs and the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship presenting the evidence from the Freedom of Information Request and demands a formal withdrawal of the “Slav Macedonian” Directive and an acceptance of the right to self-identification of the Macedonian Community in Australia.


9 November 2011: AMHRC meets with Prime Minister and government ministers

Representatives of the AMHRC continue their lobbying efforts and meet with the Prime Minister of Australia and other government Ministers in the context of the Community Cabinet day held in Werribee, Melbourne.



9 January 2012: Australian Government finally announces withdrawal “Slav Macedonian policy”

On behalf of the Minister for Foreign Affairs, the Acting Chief of Staff to the Minister for Foreign Affairs wrote to the AMHRC:

“I can reaffirm that the ‘Slav Macedonian’ Administrative Circular is no longer operative in the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (DFAT). As is standard practice with inoperative Administrative Circulars, it has been cancelled and the document archived. Similarly, DFAT has advised me that the ‘Slav Macedonian Directive’ is not in use in other agencies, including the Department of Immigration and Citizenship and the Australian Bureau of Statistics.”


11 January 2012: Government confirms official use of ‘Macedonian’ for the Macedonian community in Australia

The Department of Immigration of Immigration and Citizenship also confirmed the above position in a subsequent letter to the AMHRC:

“As stated by...[the] acting Chief of Staff to the Minister of Foreign Affairs, I can confirm that this department does not actively use the term ‘Slav-Macedonian’. For example, the Translating and Interpreting Service National now only uses the term ‘Macedonian’. We acknowledge the concerns of the Macedonian Australian community in relation to this matter.”

ХРОНОЛОГИЈА: КАКО СЕ СТАВИ КРАЈ НА „СЛАВО-MАКЕДОНСКАТА” ПОЛИТИКА

1994 г. - Македонската заедница во Австралија официјално преименувана

Во февруари 1994 год. Австралија ja призна Република Македонија под привремената референца „Поранешната Југословенска Република Македонија”.

Вo март 1994 год., федералната влада на Австралија издаде Директива, која што официално ги обврза сите владини служби и агенции да ги преименуваат сите Македонци кои живеат во Австралија во „Славо-Македонци”. Ова се оденесуваше на сите тие лица кои потекнуваа од Република Македонија. Сите други припадници на етничката македонска заедница кои што имаа пристигнато во оваа земја од оние делови на Македонија надвор од границите на Република Македонија (на пример: од Грција) требаше, според директивата, да се ословуваат како „лица поврзани со Славо-Македонци”. Со оваа директива, австралиската влада фактички им го одзеде правото да имаат свој етнички идентитет.


1994 г. до 2000 г. - Викториската влада официално го преименува македонскиот јазик во „македонски (словенски)”

Во 1994 г, цитирајки го преименувањето на македонската заедница од страна на федералнта влада, поранешниот премиер на Викторија, г. Џеф Кенет, издаде директива. „Јазичната директива”, како што почна да се нарекува, ги обврза викториските државни инситуции и служби да го ословуваат македонскиот јазиик официално како „македонски (словенски).”

АМКЧП поднесе жалба во Комисијата за човекови права и еднакви можности (ХРЕОК) со која што се оспоруваше директивата на викторската влада поради тоа што е дискриминаторска и заснована на расистички побуди. После серија сослушувања во Федералниот суд, во Федералниот суд (во полн состав) и во Високиот суд на Австралија, предметот беше вратен во ХРЕОК на повторно разгледување.

Комесарот Стрит од ХРЕОК ја објави својата одлука на 8 септември 2000 г.. Во неа тој изјави дека викториската влада постапи незаконски според членот 9(1) од Законот за расна дискриминација од 1975 г., за тоа што издала директива, односно меморадум во кој што „се направи разлика заснована на етничкото потекло при преименување на македонскиот јазик и на тој начин се нарушило признавањето на рамноправна основа на едно човеково право во културниот живот на говортелите на македонскиот јазик”. Со оваа одлука тој изјави дека викториската влада треба да престане да постапува незаконски.


1995 г. до 2010 г. - Спроведување на директивата

Наспроти бројните протести и приговори од страна на АМКЧП и други членови на македонската заеднца, низа федерални влади продолжуваат да ја спроведуваат „Славо-македонската” директивата и политиката.


Февруари 2011 г. - АМКЧП го повторува своето барање директивата официјално да се укине

Австралиско-македонскиот комитет за човекови права (АМКЧП) им испраќа писма на Министерот за надворешни работи и Министерот за имиграција и државјанство во кои што бара формално да се укине дискриманторска и навредливата „Славо-македонска” директива и политика.


11 мај 2011 г. - Министерот трвди дека не е надлежен

Министерот за имиграција и државјанство, во својот одговор на писмото на АМКЧП трвди дека „директивата е нешто што потпаѓа под ресорните ингеренции на министерот за надворешни работи.”


6 јуни 2011 г. - Министерсвото за надворешни работи избегнува да одговори на прашањата поставени во врска со директивата

Во својот писмен одговор до АМКЧП, директорот на одделението за Јужна Европа на Министерството за надворешни работи, во име на Министерот за надворешни работи, го потврдува задржувањето на владината политика во врска со користењето на терминот „Славо-македонски”, но трвди дека тој „не знае до коj степен и како таа се применува во службите на Комонвелтот.”


23 јуни 2011 г. - АМКЧП поднесува барање за достап до документација во рамките на Законот за слободен пристап кон информациите (FOI)

Фрустриран од недостатокот на транспарентност од страна на владата во врска со оваа тема, АМКЧП поднесува барање под Законот за слободен пристап кон информациите од 1982 год. (FOI) и бара да му се достават тие документи кои го евидентираат спроведувањето на „Славо-македонската” директива. Штом ги добиеше потребните документи, намерата на АМКЧП беше да поведе правна постапка против владата за кршење на Законот за расна дискриминација, како што веќе имаше направено успешно во случајот со викториската влада и преименувањето на македонскиот јазик.


10 јули 2011 г. - Министерот за надворешни работи бега од одговорност

Министерот за надворешни работи, на одговор на допсиката со друг владин министер, негов колега, трвди дека „Славо-македонската директива“ беше издадена од тогашното Министерство за имиграција и етнички работи и спрема тоа, ние би можеле да стапиме во контакт со неговиот колега, Министерот за имиграција и државјанство, во врска со ова прашање.


12 јули 2011 г. - Министерството за имиграција пак бега од одговорност...

Владин министер добива писмо од Парламентарниот секретар за имиграција, државјанство и мултикутурни работи кој ја префрлува одговорноста за директивата на Министерството за надворешни работи и трговија, трвдејки дека „Директивата од 1994 г. во врска со терминот „Славо-македонски” неможе да се укине бидејки таа зависи од надворешната политика на австралиската влада во врска со името на земјата.”


18 август 2011 г. - АМКЧП се појавува пред Парламентарниот поткомитет за човекови права

Претставници на АМКЧП се појавуваат пред Мешовитиот парламентарен поткомитет за човекови права во Парламентот во Канбера каде што дискутираа за низа прашања поврзани со човековите права, влучувајки ја и „Славо-македонската” директива.




22 септември 2011 г. - Исходот од барањето под Законот за слободен пристап кон информациите ја открива владината политика

Многу дузини документи беа предадени на АМКЧП како резултат на барањето поднесено под Законот за слободен пристап кон информациите. Иако делови од предадените документи беа редактирани, она што беше предадено резултираше со разоткривање на доста информации за владината политика по оваа тема. На пример, според милсењето што го доби Министерството за надворешни работи од самите свои советници “иако директивата од 1994 г. не била суспендирана, во пракса Комонвелтските служби се отдалечиле од употребата на терминот „Славо-македонски“ “ (Министерски поднесок 09-1054, 26/05/2009).

Министерството забележа дека „(поради) тоа што тоа не се спроведува доследно и поради тоа што е навредлива за македонската заедница, постои причина за пресипитување на директивата„ (Министерски поднесок 09-1054, 26/05/2009). Службени лица од ДФАТ исто така признаваат дека „Славо-македонски” е одвратен термин” и дека „многу лесно може да се смета за погрешен (и како резултат на тоа може да се смета за навредлив)” (електронска порака од Одделението за Јужна Европа, 10/1/2006).

Згора на тоа, документите обелоденија дека освен за македонската етничка група, директивата исто така е навредлива за други етнички групи од Република Македонија. Всушност, во мислењето се забележува дека „освен тоа што се осеќаат навредени, овие други групи би сметале дека е неточно тие да бидат ословени како „Славо-македонци”, што се однесува дo опишување на нивната националност” (Министерски поднесок 09-1054, 26/05/2009).

Во неколку наврати владата трвдеше дека „терминот „Славо-македонски“ не треба воопшто да се свати како етничка одредница”. Меѓутоа, во 2006 г., службено лице на ДФАТ од Одделението за Јужна Европа призна дека „терминот „Славо-македонски е всушност етнички показател” (електронска пошта од Одделението за Јужна Европа, 10/1/2006).


6 октомври 2011 г. - АМКЧП бара официално де се укине директивата

АМКЧП им испраќа писма на австралиската премиерка, министерот за надворешни работи и министерот за имиграција и државјанство во кои што ги приложува информациите добиени како резултат на барањето под Законот за слободен пристап кон информациите и побарува формално да се укине „Славо-македонската“ директива” и да се прифати правото на македонската заедница во Австралија на самоидентификување.


9 ноември 2011 г. - АМКЧП се среќава со премиерката на Австралија и владини министри

Претставници н АМКЧП продолжуваат со своето лобирање и се среќаваат со премиерката на Австралија и други владини министри во рамките на денот посветен на средби на владиниот кабинет со заенцицата што се одржа во Вериби, Мелбурн.









9 јануари 2012 г. - Австралиската влада конечно го соопштува укинувањето на „Славо-Македонската директива и политика”

Во име на министерот за надворешни работи, шеф на кабинетот на министерот за надворешни работи испраќа писмо до АМКЧП со следната содржина:

„Јас можам да потврдам дека „Славо-македонското“ Административно циркуларно писмо повеќе не е на сила во Министерството за надворешни паботи и трговија (ДФАТ). Како што е вообичајната пратика што се однесува до Аднминистративни циркуларни писма, тоа е поништено и докуметот е ставен во архива. Исто така ДФАТ ми има ставено до знаење дека „Славо-македонската” Директива не се применува во други владини служби, влучувајки ги и Министреството за имиграција и државјанство и Австралискиот завод за статистика.”


11 јануари 2012 г. - Владата ја потврдува официалната употреба на терминот „македонски” за македонската заедница во Австралија

Министерството за имиграција и државјанство исто така го потврди горенаведниот став во писмо испрaтено подоцна до АМКЧП:

„Како што изјавил шеф на кабинетот на министерот за надворешни работи, јас можам да потврдам дека ова министерство активно не го употребува терминот „Славо-македонски”. На пример, Националната служба за преведување и толкување сега само го употребува терминот „македонски”. Ние ја признаваме загриженоста на Македонско-австралиската заедница во врска со ова прашање.”
 
This victory marks the end of a significant and long-running campaign by the AMHRC to gain governmental acceptance of the Macedonian community’s right to self-identification. The campaign began in 1994, and saw hearings before the High Court of Australia, the Human Rights & Equal Opportunity Commission and the Parliamentary Committee on Foreign Affairs and Trade. Its culmination was recently reached after an intensive series of exchanges, involving meetings and correspondence, with senior Cabinet Minsters (including the Prime Minister), members of parliament from all political parties and various Government Departments.
Great news and a highly logical outcome for Australian Macedonians. Well done AMHRC


Whilst the AMHRC is pleased with the Australian Government’s current shift in policy toward the Macedonian Community, it now reiterates its call upon the Government to take the next logical step and recognise the Republic of Macedonia under its official and democratically chosen name.
I don't think it is a logical step.
Macedonia wants to be called FYROM by the UN (it went to court to insist on it!) and Australia has said it will look to the UN in relation to this matter. Australia (in its own mind) is being logical about this. Macedonia needs to tell the world that it is Macedonia (not FYROM). It needs to do THAT instead of indicating a willingness to compromise its name. I apportion 0.1% of blame to Australia and 99.9% to Macedonia.
 
Fantastic news!

Let's hope they recognise RoM this year to coincide with 100 years since partition - not that we should have waited that long anyway.
 
Back
Top