• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

Risto Stefov - Articles, Translations & Collaborations

Hellenism comes from Europe; it wasn't a grass roots or native movement. It came from Europe, it was imposed from above, and the consequence of it was that the demographic needed to change radically, if the idea that "ancient Greece lives" was to be sustained in any way.

Here is what one historian, E.H Carr has to say about taking some kind of ideal.

Nothing is more radically false than to set up some supposedly abstract standard of the desirable (i.e., European Hellenism) and condemn the past in the light of it
Source, Carr, E.H., What is History? p.128

O.K so what is wrong with applying the values of Modern Hellenism, historically? What does it mean for historians? What does it mean for various ethnic groups in Modern Greece, because this instrument is essentially targetted at them? Well, for the native people of Modern Greece it means they lose their identity now (it may take several generations), but they also lose their identity historically.(Just as Risto Stefov pointed out in the above article). If the Greek States' representation of history is deceptive and false, and if that history is being used as a basis to deny human rights presently (the rights of ethnic Macedoinans, Vlachs, Turks and Albanians), don't historians (and politicians) have a moral obligation to address it? To address the State, its colonizing practices, its historical record, and in this context shouldn't Greece's political opinions about its neighbours identity, i.e., Macedonians, be taken to be highly suspect?

It is probably impossible for Europe to accept that Greece should change, from its current form, regardless of how abusive it is toward its minorities. The idea of Modern Hellenism, is a European idea. Europeans attribute the “triumphs” of civilization, progress and the like to the ancient Greeks. Constructing a Modern Greek State with this ideal in mind – and then changing its historical demographics radically, is a European enterprise. So Greece is unlikely to change form, unless Europe can accept its civilization has a lot less to do with ancient Greece, than it has to do with other things. The origins of Protestantism, are found in the Bogomil movement of Macedonia, not Greece. Protestantism, was acknowledged in Germany, because of the threatening presence of the Ottoman Turks at the gates of Western Europe. they need to acknowledge that Greece (ancient), has less to do with European civilization, or indeed the enlightenment than believed. Rennassaince Art found its form in the early Macedonian Christian School of the middle ages. For a thousand years the language of Christianity in South East Europe, was in Macedonian, not Greek. Some of the rarist and earliest liturgical manuscripts found on Sveta Gora (Mt.Athos) are in Macedonian, not Greek. The policy of denying the ethnic Macedonian, is also mirrored in the denial of the traditional presence of Macedonian cultural infrastructure, on Mt. Athos and elsewhere in Eastern Europe. Many of the Monasteries there were converted from Macedonian, to Greek, post 1913. Others were “handed over” by the Sultan to the Greek Patriarch in earlier times.

Europe can't accept that European Christianity, has a strong Macedonian tradition, not a Greek one.
 
Last edited:
Modern Greece and the Macedonian Heritage – Part 15

Modern Greece and the Macedonian Heritage – Part 15

http://www.americanchronicle.com/articles/view/98095


Modern Greece and the Macedonian Heritage – Part 15 – More questions
Risto Stefov
April 11, 2009

As much as I don´t want to turn this series into a "Dear Risto" column, a couple of you have asked some very important, worthwhile and valid questions that I would like to answer.

1. As Macedonians should we be abandoning our "Slavic" culture in favour of the Ancient Macedonian one?

2. What is your personal, and not a dictionary quote, definition of a Hellene? In your opinion who and what is a Hellene?

I will begin answering the first question by saying that the Macedonians of today are a product of all that has happened in Macedonia. We are the descendents of all the people who set foot on those lands and therefore are the inheritors of everything that was left for us. Since man set foot on Macedonian soil our culture has been evolving, growing and adding to our being; culminating in what it is today.

We are Macedonians because we have lived in Macedonia for many generations and have experienced what is Macedonian and that which we have experienced has made us into who and what we are, Macedonians. If we seek the truth about who we are then we have no choice but to accept and embrace everything that makes us who we are. We are Macedonians, one of the deepest rooted people in the world and inheritors of everything that was Macedonian since before history was recorded.

In an ethnic sense we are Macedonians but linguistically we speak a Slavic language, a language that today is described as belonging to the family of Slavic languages. Ethnically we are not Slavs, we can´t all be Slavs from the Balkans to Siberia. We are Slavic speakers who over the years have evolved into a unique entity which can only be described as Macedonian. We have, however, contributed immensely to what we today call "Slav culture" more than any other ethnic nation in the Slavic speaking world. We know for a fact that Slav culture, particularly the written form of the language, was spread from Macedonia by the Solun brothers Kiril and Metodi and that is undeniably part of our Macedonian heritage.

Are the modern Macedonians the descendants of the ancient Macedonians?

My answer to that question is why stop with the ancient Macedonians? Why not go even further back and ask "are we the descendants of all the people that occupied Macedonian lands since the melt of the last ice age"? We cannot say with certainty that we are and neither can we say that we are not. All we can say is that Macedonia, the land and all that has taken place on it over the ages has made us into who we are today, Macedonians. One thing we need to refrain from is allowing others, particularly our enemies to define us.

Our neighbours to the south, the Greeks, have made the mistake of defining themselves as the "descendants of the ancient Greeks" ignoring many years of evolution, population movements, invasions, conquests and so on. The Greeks followed the "Western European" blueprint for nation building and falsely linked themselves to the ancients and only the ancients, leaving a wide gap in their culture. However they only did this to make political gains and take advantage of their neighbours, particularly the Macedonians. In fact most of Western Europe has used mythical historiography to build its modern nations. Macedonia does not need to resort to myths because Macedonians have historically existed since pre-history.

If there is the question of who the Modern Macedonians are then there must also be a question of "who the Ancient Macedonians were".

As far as we know the Ancient Macedonians began as a small tribal nation somewhere in today´s Kostur Region sometime in the 9th century BC. They only occupied today´s geographical Macedonia in the 4th century BC after Philip II became king. From what we know, Philip II defeated the various tribal kingdoms in the vicinity of today´s geographic Macedonia and incorporated the people and their lands into his Macedonian kingdom. These tribes were not all Macedonian before Philip conquered them. So what were they?

From what we know from history, Ancient Macedonia, before it became a nation state, was the land of the Pelasgians, Illyrians, Thracians, Phrygians, Paeonians and others. Hardly anything is known about these great ancient and prehistoric tribes except that they were very numerous "like leaves in a forest". So what happened to these people? Naturally modern mainstream history would have us believe that they all disappeared, but did they? Or could these people be the ancestors of today´s modern Slav speakers?

There are some well educated and prominent scientists today who believe that large groups of people who moved into the Balkans and Europe after the last ice age are still living there to this day. Could one of those large groups be the modern day Slav speakers? There are some who believe they are! How else does one explain the Slav language being spoken over such a large expanse and by so many different people in Eastern Europe?

Now if we put two and two together we come to the realization that there is a high probability that today´s Slav speaking Eastern Europeans are the descendents of any or all of the prehistoric Illyrians, Thracians, Phrygians, Dardanians, etc.; the very same groups of people mainstream history claims have disappeared.

If the people incorporated in Ancient Macedonia by Philip II indeed came from these same tribes, and we know they did, then they too must have been the ancestors of the modern day Slav speakers. This raises the possibility that the Ancient Macedonians may also have been "Slav speakers". We know that the most prominent Ancient Macedonians including Alexander the Great were bilingual and we have many historic examples to prove it. We also know Alexander´s Macedonian soldiers spoke an "unknown" language unique to the Macedonians. The only thing, as of yet, is that we don´t know if that language was Slavic. But with time, that problem too will be solved.

So, without knowing all the facts, why would we opt for "accepting" the Ancient Macedonian heritage while rejecting our "Slav" culture when there is a possibility that one is a progression of the other?

If I had to guess, I would guess that the "Slav culture" of the 9th century AD is the revival of the Ancient Macedonian Culture of the 4th century BC but with a Christian twist.

And now to answer the second question, "my definition" of what is a Hellene?

I believe I answered this question before but I guess not to the satisfaction of at least one reader. A Hellene is a 19th century mythological being that encompasses all the desired qualities that the 19th century Western European culture craved.

Trying to define what a Hellene is is like trying to define who Santa Claus is. The word "Santa Claus" conjures up an image of a white bearded man dressed up in a red suit who gives away presents; an image of happiness. But is Santa Claus real? It depends who you ask? Most children will say that he is! But does Santa Clause exist? Yes he does, you can find him in practically every mall around Christmas time.


A Hellene is like Santa Claus in many ways. Conditioned over the years many people believe he or she exists. Any ordinary person properly dressed in red and white attire can unmistakably be Santa Claus, similarly any person who speaks and feels Greek can qualify to be a Hellene. The story of the Hellene is something like the story of Santa Claus. They both started somewhere back in Ancient times and borrowed something from this culture and something from that. The case of Santa Claus, evolved into what we know today as "the white bearded man in the red suit, living in the North Pole, making toys for little girls and boys and delivering them to all the children in the world on Christmas Eve on his sled pulled by his flying reindeer". The case of the Hellene also evolved in a similar fashion borrowing from the ancients what was attractive then mixing it with Christianity and what was desirable we then have "a Hellene who is a Christian Orthodox, speaks a bastardized ancient Language and claims to be a descendent of a race of people that died 2,000 years ago".

Will the "Santa Claus" of modern times survive the scrutiny of science if so examined? Will we find that he is real, exists and flies a sled pulled by reindeer? No! We believe in Santa Claus because he is a powerful symbol of our traditional values which today is exploited and utilized by merchants to sell their wares and make money. Similarly Hellenism (for some) is a symbol of a "perfect culture". It does not really exist and will not survive scientific scrutiny but is tolerated by people because it benefits a certain and powerful segment of our society.

Like ordinary people who put on cheap red suits and fake white beards, pretending to be Santa Claus in order to sell merchandise, ordinary people who speak Greek can also be Hellenes in order to improve their social status in society.

Does a Hellene exist? Does Santa Claus exist? It all depends on who you ask! Is a Hellene real? Is Santa Claus real? No, because they both exist only in the imagination of those who believe in them!

"To be a Modern "Hellene" one must be a liar. One has to lie about their ethnic heritage. One has to lie about their mother tongue. And one has to lie about their history. And so it goes, a Hellene is a person who is faking their ethnicity, mother tongue and history." (Maknews from www.maknews.com )

"The British, French and Russians demanded that the modern Greek identity be Hellenic and respond to the Europeans´ nostalgia…" ("Blood Lines from Ethnic Pride to Ethnic Terrorism", by Vamik Volkan, page 121)

"Thus, the recourse to the new image of Hellas (both as cultural construct and as social system) began immediately upon the brief rule of governor Kapodistrias and became efficiently implemented with the takeover of the Bavarian monarchy and its explicit desire for centralization and Hellenization. In fact, the cultural image of Greece was put into production with much greater urgency than was a political-economic infrastructure, despite the obvious importance of the latter in a newly constructed state." ("Dream Nation Enlightenment, Colonization and the institution of Modern Greece", Stathis Gourgouris, page 87)

"It should be strongly emphasized, however, that this image of classical Greece was constructed in Europe and was imported to the newborn Greek state (Tsoukalas, 2002)." ("Entangled Identities Nations and Europe", edited by Atsuko Ichijo and Willfried Spohn, page 109)

"The adjective ´Hellenistic´ not, significantly, existing in any Greek original – was first coined in its French form ´hellenistiques´ by J.B. Bossuer, in 1681 as a term for the Greek of the Septuagint, the ´Hellenized´ version of the old Testament." ("The Hellenic Age a Short History", Peter Green, page xvi introduction)

And now I leave you with this;

"And thus, I call upon the western intellectuals in general and the western philhellenes in particular to separate their personal sentimental attachments to Greek history, to do the only honorary thing left and treat Macedonia and Macedonian history as a separate and comprehensive study that it is, and that it certainly deserves to be. The conflicting statements left strewn in the literature in the past hundred or so years—are the result of biased and subjective influences—and have not only caused political discourse and confusion, but bring about contradictions, fuel tensions and cause unnecessary hateful speculations.

For instance, when some nineteenth century unsuspecting authors depict events in antiquity and describe the ancient Macedonians as Greeks, it was done not because the evidence left from the ancient biographers would support such an act but because the western media and the western academia in particular, would allow dissemination of historically inaccurate information. Such supposedly "harmless" omissions—read desirable proliferation of myths—would seep easily into the readers´ consciousness for whom the built up historiography of the artificially created Greek nation, lay in tandem with the envisioned fundamental grand scheme of things in the regional geography designed for Balkans.

It is morally wrong, ethically inadmissible and scientifically incorrect to lump the ancient Macedonians under Greek umbrella, simply, because today´s Greece—the creation of the western powers—enjoys sentimental support of many western intellectuals. Truth does not need lobbyists. Truth is not a tradable commodity and cannot be conditionally used and selectively applied. Appropriation of Macedonian history is not an acceptable act; portraying ancient Macedonians as Greeks is an outright fabrication." (Gandeto - http://www.americanchronicle.com/articles/view/97381)

For those who are still not convinced that the Modern Greek identity is an artificial creation, please continue to read this series of articles.

Author´s note:

Dear Macedonians, one way to defend ourselves from the Greek onslaught and gain back our identity and dignity is to fight back to the level to which the Greeks have reduced us; that is to attack their identity as they have attacked ours. We need prove nothing to them except to expose them as the artificial identity they truly are and to uncover their design to wipe us out in order to usurp our Macedonian heritage.

To be Continued.

Many thanks to TrueMacedonian from www.maknews.com for his contribution to this article.

You can contact the author at rstefov@hotmail.com
 
Risto has the courage to communicate and preserve our history, culture and heritage - but I think it is a burden more of us should help him with.

I can only think of my poor ancestors, illiterate for the most part, who were witnessing, but had no power to communicate, their extinction, as I said somewhere else.

I love this paragraph he wrote:

My answer to that question is why stop with the ancient Macedonians? Why not go even further back and ask "are we the descendants of all the people that occupied Macedonian lands since the melt of the last ice age"? We cannot say with certainty that we are and neither can we say that we are not. All we can say is that Macedonia, the land and all that has taken place on it over the ages has made us into who we are today, Macedonians. One thing we need to refrain from is allowing others, particularly our enemies to define us.

Thanks Risto.
 
This is absolutely brilliant.

There needs to be more historians supporting J.S Gandeto; no historian has given such a logical, and erudite exposition of Greek historiography. Its a damning indictment, not only of the New Greeks, but of Western intellectuals as well, who support this bullshit.

It is morally wrong, ethically inadmissible and scientifically incorrect to lump the ancient Macedonians under Greek umbrella, simply, because today´s Greece—the creation of the western powers—enjoys sentimental support of many western intellectuals. Truth does not need lobbyists. Truth is not a tradable commodity and cannot be conditionally used and selectively applied. Appropriation of Macedonian history is not an acceptable act; portraying ancient Macedonians as Greeks is an outright fabrication."

I'm writing an introductory paper on false impressions of Macedonia (and Greece) in the British parliament, and how the misinformation and misrepresentations of Macedonia, 100 years ago, found its way into popular attitudes, and popular culture in Europe, and more generally the West. How, these modern myths, despite their distortions, continue today, and continue to be entertained, despite all the evidence to the contrary. For as long as there has been modern myths of the Macedonians (and, Greece), pushed by Europe, there have been people there to debunk them, and tell it like it really is. The disrepenency between European attitudes, and what was "on the ground" will be brought to light through the observations of travellers, soliders, politicians ...etc, who brought these prejudices and misrpresentations with them, and left with an entirely different impression.
 
Last edited:
Modern Greece and the Macedonian Heritage – Part 16

Modern Greece and the Macedonian Heritage – Part 16

Modern Greeks, who were educated through the Greek educational system, seem to think that Macedonians did not exist prior to the 1940´s. In fact some are so sure that they are willing to stake their own reputation on it, so they say.

One Greek, who claimed to be a Professor of History, not long ago wrote and told me that there is absolutely no evidence to support the existence of Macedonians prior to Tito´s "alleged" creation of Macedonia. In fact, he said that he was so sure that Macedonians did not exist he was willing to accept everything I said at face value if I could only show him a single piece of evidence that proved Macedonians existed before 1940.

Believing he was sincere, I had no reason to doubt him, I took up his challenge and put together a document which can be found at this link; http://www.oshchima.com/Historical Documents/hdoc1.pdf

After reviewing the document the good professor was kind enough to write back to me but it wasn´t what I expected. The only thing he wrote was "Macedonia is Greek"! Nothing else! I never heard from him again.

I used to believe that Greeks were sincere in their quest for the truth but experience has taught me differently. I used to believe if one laid the facts on the table all arguments could be resolved through reasoning and logic but unfortunately I was wrong! As I have found out over the years, Modern Greeks, at least the ones I have dealt with, are not interested in finding "the truth" unless the truth serves their purpose. The only thing these Greeks are interested in, as I have found, is covering up all evidence that might challenge their claims on Macedonia and expose their lies. Facts, evidence, or logic do not matter and no Greek can be convinced of the truth unless it serves his or her purpose or supports his or her claims on Macedonia. Therefore it would be a waste of time to try and prove anything to a Greek who is convinced that his or her truth is the only truth.

If I were to classify the Greeks into categories I would classify them into three types. The first type which includes the vast majority of Greeks is the silent type which steers away from "anomalies" or information that is not explained by their indoctrination. These Greeks have found that curiosity can be painful, as Anastasia Karakasidou discovered when she wrote her book "Fields of Wheat, Hills of Blood".

The second type of Greek is a patriotic and devoted type who believes that everything the Greek government tells him or her, particularly about Macedonia, is true. This Greek is taught to believe the indigenous Macedonians, the ones who lived in Macedonia for many generations, the ones whose lands Greece stole, are his or her enemies. They are convinced that these Macedonians are preoccupied with "stealing" their Macedonia from them and therefore should not be trusted and should be punished at every opportunity.

The third and most dangerous type of Greek is the one who knows the truth but is entrusted with protecting Greek interests at any cost. This is the Greek that seeks out evidence in order to destroy it.

So the next time a Greek asks you to produce evidence that proves Macedonians exist remember that by providing this evidence you are helping him or her to cover it up.

The problem these Greeks have is not only with evidence but with the people who are bent on digging it up. Remember Karakasidou´s case? The Greeks threatened to "blow up" the publishing house in London if it published her book. Greeks often use this kind of "intimidation" to prevent what they deem "damaging" information from coming out. But more often than not, they publish "their own" versions of "the facts" to create confusion and bury the truth. For example Greeks, for years, maintained that Macedonians did not exist. But when stories started surfacing that Macedonians do indeed exist, they invented the idea that these people were not really "ethnic Macedonians" but "geographic Macedonians". In other words they are called "Macedonians" not because they are ethnic Macedonians but because they are "Greeks" who just happened to live in Macedonia!

Until a couple of decades ago, according to these Greeks, Macedonians did not exist; today, according to the same Greeks, we have all kinds of Macedonians. In fact the Greek Prime Minister himself just announced to the Greek Parliament that he too is a "Macedonian"! This is how Greeks logic works. If you can´t outright eradicate "the information" then you bury it in a huge tangle of lies. Greeks are experts at this!

Fortunately Macedonians and even foreigners are slowly coming on to these "Greek tricks" and the Greek lies are gradually being exposed.

Today there is an overwhelming amount of evidence uncovered all over the world not just from books but also from newspapers and journals. Greeks however are trying very hard to bury it by side tracking the reader with personal attacks on the messenger instead of dealing with the message. In place of responding to the questions posed, Greeks tend to attack the credibility of the messenger calling him or her "anti-Greek" having an "axe to grind" or not possessing "the right credentials" to be an authority. It seems that when facts are presented that contradict the "Greek view", Greeks tend to dismiss them by accusing the presenter of not having the "right credentials".

Recently old newspaper stories from the late 1800´s and early 1900´s have also been surfacing from various library archives. These newspapers, it appears, have been carrying all sorts of stories from the Balkan conflicts, including many from the Macedonian 1903 Uprising against the Ottoman Empire. These stories exist and are real and can be found in the archives of practically every major library in the world. Some of these documents are now being digitized and will soon be available online everywhere on the internet. Here are some examples;

http://www.maknews.com/forum/archive/here-are-som-articles-from-the-new-york-times-t5689.html

http://www.maknews.com/forum/archiv...bout-the-macedonians-in-the-1800-s-t5734.html

http://www.maknews.com/forum/general-discussions/reference-list-1-newspaper-articles-t14740.html

http://www.macedoniantruth.org/forum/showthread.php?t=1139

These stories talk about Macedonians fighting for their freedom, Macedonians who according to the Greeks did not exist prior to the 1940´s. With stories like these coming out no one in the world is going to believe the Greeks and their false claims. No one is going to believe that the references "Macedonian" and "Macedonians" are "geographic" and not "ethnic". Who in the world, except Greeks, uses "geographic" references when referring to people´s "ethnic" or "national" identities?

"Since the declaration of the Republic of Macedonia the Greek government has asserted that it has exclusive copyright to the use of the Star of Vergina. But is has been argued that since modern day Greeks are not descended from the ancient Greeks: ´The Star of Vergina is not a Greek symbol, except in the sense that it happens to have been found in the territory of the present-day Greek state. The modern day Greeks appropriate ancient Greek cultural symbols because they happen to live in more or less the same part of the world as the ancient Greeks did" ("Experimenting with Democracy Regime Change in the Balkans", Edited by Geoffrey Pridham and Tom Gallagher, page 271)



"It is widely recognized that national symbols are often a modern creation which do not reflect the reality of the circumstances they purport to represent. Tradition can be invented. Modern Greece, for example, is a relatively new creation and bears little resemblance to the ancient Greece which is the source of much of its symbolism." ("Experimenting with Democracy Regime Change in the Balkans", Edited by Geoffrey Pridham and Tom Gallagher, page 271)

So let us dispense with the niceties and tell it the way it is. Greeks who know the truth know very well that Macedonians have as much right to the Macedonian heritage as Greeks do to the Greek heritage. Even though the Modern Greeks are not the descendents of the so-called ancient Greeks they consciously laid claim to the ancient Greek heritage. Why are they then protesting against the Macedonians laying claim to the Macedonian heritage, even though the Macedonians have been living in Macedonia a lot longer then the Modern Greeks have lived in Greece? Looking at the problem another way, why is the world not challenging these imposters for usurping the Greek heritage? If Macedonians have no right to the Macedonian heritage then surely the Modern Greeks have no right to the Greek heritage?

We know that the Greeks acquired Greece and Greek occupied Macedonia under false pretences so why are we not putting all this on the table and making it part of the so-called "name negotiations" with Greece?

"And, once again, we came to this often visited intersection; there are some very progressive Greeks who do not subscribe to this middle-age Greek thinking and who see the people in the Balkans living in peace and harmony—these are the true Greeks and then, there are newly created Greeks, those whose heritage has been wiped out and replaced with the newly "morphed" ethnicity "Greek-Macedonian". Since they—in this Greek created problem—stand to lose the most, they are the "true" Greek soldiers in the forefront fighting the battle. I am sure they wouldn´t dare dig deeper into their past because they will inevitably find "skeletons" which have another story to tell: their grandfathers did not even speak Greek nor did they share in these "megali" Greek dream. What they dreamed the most and with a heavy heart longed for, were their abandoned homes, forsaken culture and their way of life in their Asia Minor communities.

Sooner than later all these Greek lies and fabrications will run their course and Europe will have no choice but to put an end to this Greek farce." (Gandeto, http://www.americanchronicle.com/articles/view/98213

"Those who espouse extreme nationalist positions, claiming (as they invoke Alexander, Philip, and Aristotle) that the name of Macedonia is exclusively Greek and that there is no such thing as a Macedonian minority, are reacting to the exigencies of a perhaps genuine dangerous local situation in which their country faces potentially hostile neighbours on several fronts; but they are also resuscitating the very logic that has always compromised their supposed independence to begin with – the logic according to which all the country´s modern claims must be evaluated by the yardstick of ancient history." (Michael Herzfeld, "Anthropology - Theoretical Practice in Culture and Society", pages 67 and 68).

"It is a myth that the population exchange ensured an uncontested and harmonious national homogeneity or that the refugees became integrated into Greek society in an unproblematic way. The criterion used for the population exchange was that of religion, in line with the tradition of the millet system. In many instances the refugees could hardly speak Greek and many had been reluctant to leave their lands and home where they had lived for generations.

Although the refugees from Asia Minor are collectively referred to as a single group, in fact they came from various cultural, linguistic, social and regional backgrounds." ("Mediating the Nation - News, Audiences and the Politics of Identity" by Mirca Madianou, page 31)

And now I leave you with this;

THIS MACEDONIAN SUN

The National flag]

By Spero Thompson

Patriots rose and fell in the Ilinden uprising

Turks holocaust villages, hope flees the land

Greeks, Serbs, and Bulgars drive out the Ottomans

Partitioning of Macedonia, their Balkan war prize demand

Europe´s power struggles bring a darkness of night

Ilinden, Balkan, World wars; repeatedly Macedonia is overrun

Sunrise overcomes night, announcing a new day

In 1991 history records the rising of the Macedonian Sun

Macedonia´s twentieth century featured bloodshed and hope

Began in bloodshed, ending in independence, hope realized

A standard is raised to represent and identify themselves

By symbol and colour, their nationhood is visualized

For so long a people oppressed and suppressed

Now masters of their own house and land

A century of, sultanate, monarchy, communism then autonomy

Today under their own flag they stand

The Macedonian Sun, a boldly emblazoned flag

On a field of red, a golden risen sun

The sun signifies a new day of self-rule

Red, for a history written in blood, a memorandum

A banner derived from their ancient heraldic emblem

Eyes see… 'we are a people' its proclamation

Proud emigrant sons and daughters see it fly

World acknowledged, flag of their mother nation

Historically, countries play leading or supportive roles

Now Macedonia is cast in a modern part

Ally to all who pursue peace and democracy

The Macedonian Sun, their pledge of national heart

Reader, listener, understand the meaning of this flag

With both prospect and retrospect you will see

The sun looks ahead, to a new era begun

Red, looks back on blood, sacrificed for country

This century, as nations strive, ideology against ideology

Fly in honour and freedom, oh Macedonian Sun

Until all flags are lowered, required no more

When His kingdom come, Gods will be done

For those who are still not convinced that the Modern Greek identity is an artificial creation, please continue to read this series of articles.

Author´s note:

Dear Macedonians, one way to defend ourselves from the Greek onslaught and gain back our identity and dignity is to fight back to the level to which the Greeks have reduced us; that is to attack their identity as they have attacked ours. We need prove nothing to them except to expose them as the artificial identity they truly are and to uncover their design to wipe us out in order to usurp our Macedonian heritage.

To be Continued.

Many thanks to TrueMacedonian from www.maknews.com for his contribution to this article.

You can contact the author at rstefov@hotmail.com
http://www.americanchronicle.com/articles/view/98986
 
Risto Stefov does it again, this is as clear as daylight but somehow or Greeks friends will not see anything at all........ the ostrich maneuver is commencing......

Thank you Risto for noticing our little hamlet on the internet. ;)
 
That is a good compendium, Risto has transcribed it from this book "Documents on the Struggle of the Macedonian People for Independence and a Nation-State, Volume I", there is also a volume II of this very eminent collection of documents, these two volumes refute everything that is "Greek" in Macedonia.
 
This is excellent.

I would Orbini's observations in this from 1601, which is very relevent. Orbini makes three points

1. Macedonians in 1601 are not Greeks
2. The Macedonians speak a Slavic language
3. The Slavic language they speak is the same language used by the ancient Macedonians
 
Sarafe, that is not true, it is all made in photoshop by the "skopiani", you know they are masters of photoshop and time travelling with druzhe Tita..... ;)
 
Modern Greece and the Macedonian Heritage – Part 20 – The Macedonian Party?

Modern Greece and the Macedonian Heritage – Part 20 – The Macedonian Party?

http://www.americanchronicle.com/articles/view/102681

Modern Greece and the Macedonian Heritage – Part 20 – The Macedonian Party?

Risto Stefov

May 17, 2009

Forty years ago we were told that Macedonians simply did not exist; "there was no such thing as a Macedonian". Thirty years ago we were told that a "Greek" cannot be made; he or she had to be born from Greeks to be Greek. Twenty years ago we were told that "Greek" is the most "solid" ethnic identity on this earth with 4,000 years of continuous and uninterrupted lineage. Now we are told that Macedonians do exist and there are 3,500,000 of them spread all over the world.

Well for people who believe they are pure Greeks, direct descendents from the ancient Greeks, even though they are not Greeks at all, anything is possible. For people who descended from Slavs, Albanians and Vlachs and still believe they are Greeks, descendants of the ancient Greeks, anything is possible. For people who believe that Alexander the Great, the same Alexander the Great who conquered and brutally suppressed their so-called "ancient Greek ancestors", is their national hero, then anything is possible.

When I first read the story that a new political party was formed in Greece, calling itself the "Macedonian Party", I thought "how wonderful", for a split second. Then reality hit. How is it possible for Greece to have a political party that represents the non-existent Macedonian minority? I knew there had to be a catch. A political party is being formed that wants to elect members to the European Parliament in the June elections. The catch however is that this is NOT a "Macedonian Party" at all but rather a "fake" Macedonian party created by Greeks for the purpose of usurping the name "Macedonia". This time the Greeks are using a different angle to approach the same old problem. They want to hold onto Macedonia and the Macedonian heritage the best way they know how; by lying and cheating.

As we know the Modern Greeks are not Greeks at all. We know they were created by the Philhellenes from the Slav, Albanian and Vlach immigrants who migrated to Greece during the 11th to the 14th century AD. We also know that the Greek people living in Greek occupied Macedonia today are not Greeks at all. Of the total people living in Greek occupied Macedonia the majority are not even Macedonians. Greece has been importing people into Macedonia since it invaded, occupied, partitioned and annexed Macedonian lands in 1912, 1913. Greece has imported Albanians and Vlachs from Albania, 1,100,000 Christian Turks from Asia Minor, the Caucasus, Russia, Armenia, etc. In fact Greece is importing people from all over the world today as we speak and is still calling them Greeks. So the Modern Greeks, being neither Macedonians nor Greeks, in essence have no "real" claim to Macedonia or to the Macedonian heritage so they have no choice but to resort to lying and cheating.

The new Greek Party founded by the so-called "World committee for the Protection of Macedonia" is another ploy to lay claim to the name "Macedonia", through the European Parliament. The Party´s aim is to block the Republic of Macedonia from entering the European Union with the name "Macedonia".

"It is of great importance for Macedonian Hellenism to join the European Parliament with the name ´Macedonia´, ´Macedonian´, ´Macedonians´, in order to guarantee that Macedonia belongs only to Greece, before Skopje has a chance to do this for itself. If the Greeks, who are the real Macedonians, enter the European Parliament with this name then the fake Macedonians will not be able to do so", said Konstantinos Kalfa committee member of the "World committee for the Protection of Macedonia", as quoted by Kanal 5.

(Note how the fake Greeks refer to the real Macedonians as fakes).

According to its founders, "the party will fight to protect the name, history and rights of the large Macedonian minority [of the Greek kind], estimated to number 3,500,000 and is spread all over the world".

So if I understand this correctly, the non-existent Macedonian minority that Greece has denied ever existed, now exists, suddenly overnight. It exists somewhat as "Macedonian" but not really because the Greek types of Macedonians are really "ethnic Greeks" who happened to live in Macedonia. We know however that there is no such thing as "ethnic Greeks" because the Modern Greek identity is not real but a Philhellene artificial creation! So if ethnic Greeks don´t really exist then these Macedonians who supposedly are "ethnic Greeks" in reality don´t exist either. But wait a minute aren´t the Greeks now telling us that they do exist, and that there are 3.5 million of them all over the world? Confused? Perhaps now you can appreciate the expression "it´s all Greek to me"! In other words "it´s too complicated for us non-Greeks to understand!"

Forget what the Greeks are telling you and focus on what they are trying to do. This is not about "ethnicities", "languages", "cultures" or histories it´s about the expropriation of Macedonian lands and robbing the Macedonian people of their heritage. Lying and cheating is a "Greek specialty", this is how they built their fake identity and artificial country. They have lied to the world from the day the Philhellenes brought them into their artificial existence. But no matter how hard they try to suppress the truth it will eventually resurface.

What I don´t understand however is why do they have to lie? Everyone knows they are lying; why not admit to the truth? Why not say that in this world "might is right" and as long we they have the "might" we will do whatever we want. They suppress the Macedonian people because they can and will hold onto their lands as long as they can.

I don´t know why they have to lie about their fake identity either? They are Greeks because they want to be Greeks, it´s as simple as that. Better still why not admit that they are the descendents of Slav, Albanian and Vlach immigrants? What is wrong with that? We are all immigrants here is Canada, with the exception of the indigenous people we found here when we colonized their lands, and we are not ashamed of it and no Canadian needs to lie about it.

We know Greece suffers from anxiety, we have known this for many years. The whole world knows that Greece and Greeks are artificially created entities and that they suffer from anxiety. The only cure for their anxiety is for them to accept the truth. No more lies and pretending will lead to no more anxiety! Anxiety makes Greeks panic and panic causes them to behave irrationally. Behaving irrationally towards their neighbours causes their neighbours to behave irrationally right back. The Republic of Macedonia is forced to behave this way because Greece behaves this way. Most of Europe, catering to Greece´s anxiety, also behaves this way. How else do you explain the "name game"? Is it rational for one country to "demand" of another to change its name? Is it rational for European Union countries to demand the Republic of Macedonia change its name? No! Why then are they behaving this way if not because of Greece´s anxiety?

The European Union it seems will accept fake countries like Greece but will not accept the Republic of Macedonia, that is until it changes its name and it too becomes a fake country. This makes one wonder if the European Union itself is a club for fakes. Again, I will ask the reader to look at the European Union for what it does and not for what it says. The EU has many rules and regulations that support minority and human rights in its member states but at the same time it allows its member states to practice racism and discrimination against their minorities. It seems that EU rules and regulations apply to "others" and not to its own members! All those human rights laws in its books and none of them can help the Macedonians in Greece or in Bulgaria.

If the European Union will allow racist organizations like the fake "Macedonian Party" in its Parliament whose only aim is to rob the Macedonian people of their lands and heritage, then what does that say about the European Union? Some people think that members of the European Parliament are ignorant of the Macedonian people´s real issues with Greece and Bulgaria. Others say they are indifferent. If that were true then those who are ignorant should by now have learned something after 17 years of playing the "name game". And those who are indifferent should have remained indifferent. Why have European Union countries sided with Greece demanding that Macedonia change its name?



"Greece´s movement to build a national identity, however, contained a unique element not shared by others: external support and even pressure, for a specific kind of new identity. The British, French and Russians demanded that the modern Greek identity be Hellenic and respond to the Europeans´ nostalgia for the restoration of a pre-Christian Hellenic civilization that has been in eclipse for some two thousand years. Europeans confidently expected to see the characteristic of Homer in post liberation Greeks, in spite of the ebb and flow of history over such a great span of time. The neoclassicism that rose in seventeenth – and eighteenth-century Europe as an aesthetic and philosophical idea was to be physically embodied in modern-day Greece. The idealistic and hopeful attitudes of neoclassicism that would later be imposed on the Greeks was succinctly expressed in 1822 when American President James Monroe declared: ´The mention of Greece fills the mind with the utmost exalted sentiments and arouses in our bosoms the best feelings of which our nature is susceptible´.

In reality, however, just before the Greek war of independence, most Greeks still referred to themselves as Romans. Vlachavas, the priest rebel leader who rose against the Ottomans, declared, ´A Romneos I was born, a Romneos I will die´.

Some Europeans and the few Americans who came to help Greece start a new nation-state, were disappointed even indignant, to discover among Greece´s peasants there were no warrior-heroes like Achilles or Ajax, no statesmen like Pericles, no philosophers like Socrates or Plato and no poets of the caliber of Aeschylus or Sophocles. There was, in fact, little likeness between nineteenth century Greeks and the idealized Greeks from ancient history that had such hold on the imagination of European liberators." ("Blood Lines form Ethnic Pride to Ethnic Terrorism", by Vamik Volkan pages 121 and 122).

"In Eastern Europe since 1990, the treatment of minorities seems quite contrary to the recent development in Western Europe, which reversed the earlier positions in both parts of Europe. If there have been any results from the High Commissioner´s mission in the three serious cases of the Russians (and other minorities) in the Baltic, the Roma and the Sinti throughout Europe, and the Macedonians in Greece, nothing substantial has so far emerged about them. The High Commissioner has been in existence since the beginning of 1993, and Max ven der Stoel has been exclusively active in Eastern Europe throughout the period until retirement mid-2001 when the new Commissioner Ralf Ekeus took over. After the first period of four years there was an analysis of Ven der Stoel´s efforts; due to the OSCE´s discrete policy, assuring effected states of ´absolute´ confidentiality, the relevant information is still lacking. The age of secret diplomacy in minority matters is not over in Europe." ("Ethnicity Nationalism and Violence", by Christian P. Scherrer, page 253)

"Because of Greece´s almost hysterical reaction, the state [Republic of Macedonia] was not admitted to the UN until the end of 1992 under the absurd appellation ´former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia´. The successive Greek governments allegedly took offense at the symbolism of the name (the Macedonia of Philip II, the native land of Alexander the Great) and at the flag (a sun with sixteen rays on a red background) although Macedonia had born this name as a Yugoslavian Republic since 1948." ("Ethnicity Nationalism and Violence", by Christian P. Scherrer, page 283)

"The key premise in Humboldt´s idea is that Hellenic civilization assumed a transcendental significance because it testified to a cultural and linguistic purity. This claim was historically absurd and even antithetical to the paradigm of comparative linguistics, which was the core of philological inquiry.

In practical terms, however, the historical absurdity of declaring Hellenic civilization the expression of a culture uncontaminated by foreign elements can be explained by a simple fact that usually tends to be disregarded – namely, that Hellenic civilizations as we know it was in effect the invention of the ´Science of Antiquity´ of Classics. As such, it could have been (and was) endowed with whatever signification the discipline found useful.

The invention of Hellenic civilization shows the profound power of philology as a method to cultural knowledge – indeed, as knowledge." ("Dream Nation" by Stathis Gourgouris, pages 133 and 134)

"…for more than a century, Greek schoolbooks have stressed the unbroken continuity and diachronic and homogeneity of Greek civilization and culture, with the results that Greeks tend to believe without question in this construction of Romantic nationalist historiography. According to this ideology, what is labeled with the timeless and semantically vague abstract term ´Hellenism´ – together with its language – is a healthy organism that for 4,000 years has either resisted or assimilated foreign influences; alteration is viewed as adulteration, while outside influences are viewed as threats." ("Hellenisms Culture, Identity and Ethnicity from Antiquity to Modernity", edited by Katerina Zacharia, page 303)

"According to the narrative of Philhellenism, after nearly two millennium of imperial rule – first under the Byzantines and then under the Ottomans – a newly defined Greek nation could reunite with its glorified ancient heritage and, lead by monarchs of German and Danish ancestry, revive the traditions that had inspired western Europe to greatness. Yet Hellenism had to be invented in Europe as the cornerstone of Western Civilization before it could be imported to Greece as a nationalist movement. A combination of the real and imagined culture of the ancient Greeks became, in various guises, a heritage to which all could lay claim.

Hellenism became a pan-European endeavour that spanned the course of many centuries and found varied forms of expression in different countries.

Germans came to conflate modern Germany with the ancient Greek world. By the end of the nineteenth century for example, the archeologist Ernst Curtious could justify large scale archeological expeditions to Greece by simply explaining that ´Germany herself has inwardly appropriated Greek culture´.

Similarly, in England ancient Greece became a model for nineteenth century citizens.

It stood as proof of the superiority of the West over the barbaric East; as such it presented one more reason for the civilization of the East through European colonization." ("Possessors and Possessed" by Wendy M. K. Shaw, pages 62 to 64)

After reading the above perhaps the reader will come to appreciate why Europe is so fond of Greece.

For those who are still not convinced that the Modern Greek identity is an artificial creation, please continue to read this series of articles.

Author´s note:

Dear Macedonians, one way to defend ourselves from the Greek onslaught and gain back our identity and dignity is to fight back to the level to which the Greeks have reduced us; that is to attack their identity as they have attacked ours. We need prove nothing to them except to expose them as the artificial identity they truly are and to uncover their design to wipe us out in order to usurp our Macedonian heritage.

To be Continued.

Many thanks to TrueMacedonian from www.maknews.com for his contribution to this article.

You can contact the author at rstefov@hotmail.com

Risto has again written a very good article. As usual the Greeks will just claim this as propaganda or even better, they will resort to sticking their heads in the sand like the ostriches do. :6:
 
Sarafe, that is not true, it is all made in photoshop by the "skopiani", you know they are masters of photoshop and time travelling with druzhe Tita..... ;)

:6:, Oh yes i forgot that, sory,probebly it was this guy :batman: helping tito.:14: Bravo for them
 
Dear Macedonians, one way to defend ourselves from the Greek onslaught and gain back our identity and dignity is to fight back to the level to which the Greeks have reduced us; that is to attack their identity as they have attacked ours. We need prove nothing to them except to expose them as the artificial identity they truly are and to uncover their design to wipe us out in order to usurp our Macedonian heritage.

This means researching all available newspapers, and press reports, at the time of Greece's CREATION, namely statistics on ethnic make up of the territory at that time, also a GOOD place to research would be TURKISH archives.
This fake trash has to be exposed to the masses.
 
Back
Top