• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

Vasil Iljov and the Inscriptions in Macedonia

The writing on the cave wall

The writing on the cave wall

The writing on the cave wall
February, 24 2010

New Scientist

THE first intrepid explorers to brave the 7 metre crawl through a perilously narrow tunnel leading to the Chauvet caves in southern France were rewarded with magnificent artwork to rival any modern composition.

Time to look around the paintings
Stretching a full 3 metres in height, the paintings depict a troupe of majestic horses in deep colours, above a pair of boisterous rhinos in the midst of a fight. To the left, they found the beautiful rendering of a herd of prehistoric cows. "The horse heads just seem to leap out of the wall towards you," says Jean Clottes, former director of scientific research at the caves and one of the few people to see the paintings with his own eyes.

When faced with such spectacular beauty, who could blame the visiting anthropologists for largely ignoring the modest semicircles, lines and zigzags also marked on the walls? Yet dismissing them has proved to be something of a mistake. The latest research has shown that, far from being doodles, the marks are in fact highly symbolic, forming a written "code" that was familiar to all of the prehistoric tribes around France and possibly beyond. Indeed, these unprepossessing shapes may be just as remarkable as the paintings of trotting horses and tussling rhinos, providing a snapshot into humankind's first steps towards symbolism and writing.

Until now, the accepted view has been that our ancestors underwent a "creative explosion" around 30,000 to 40,000 years ago, when they suddenly began to think abstractly and create rock art. This idea is supported by the plethora of stunning cave paintings, like those at Chauvet, which started to proliferate across Europe around this time. Writing, on the other hand, appeared to come much later, with the earliest records of a pictographic writing system dating back to just 5000 years ago.

Few researchers, though, had given any serious thought to the relatively small and inconspicuous marks around the cave paintings. The evidence of humanity's early creativity, they thought, was clearly in the elaborate drawings.

While some scholars like Clottes had recorded the presence of cave signs at individual sites, Genevieve von Petzinger, then a student at the University of Victoria in British Columbia, Canada, was surprised to find that no one had brought all these records together to compare signs from different caves. And so, under the supervision of April Nowell, also at the University of Victoria, she devised an ambitious masters project. She compiled a comprehensive database of all recorded cave signs from 146 sites in France, covering 25,000 years of prehistory from 35,000 to 10,000 years ago.

What emerged was startling: 26 signs, all drawn in the same style, appeared again and again at numerous sites (see illustration). Admittedly, some of the symbols are pretty basic, like straight lines, circles and triangles, but the fact that many of the more complex designs also appeared in several places hinted to von Petzinger and Nowell that they were meaningful - perhaps even the seeds of written communication.

A closer look confirmed their suspicions. When von Petzinger went back to some of the records of the cave walls, she noticed other, less abstract signs that appeared to represent a single part of a larger figure - like the tusks of a mammoth without an accompanying body. This feature, known as synecdoche, is common in the known pictographic languages. To von Petzinger and Nowell, it demonstrated that our ancestors were indeed considering how to represent ideas symbolically rather than realistically, eventually leading to the abstract symbols that were the basis of the original study.

"It was a way of communicating information in a concise way," says Nowell. "For example, the mammoth tusks may have simply represented a mammoth, or a mammoth hunt, or something that has nothing to do with a literal interpretation of mammoths." Other common forms of synecdoche include two concentric circles or triangles (used as eyes in horse and bison paintings), ibex horns and the hump of a mammoth. The claviform figure - which looks somewhat like a numeral 1 - may even be a stylised form of the female figure, she says.

The real clincher came with the observation that certain signs appear repeatedly in pairs. Negative hands and dots tend to be one of the most frequent pairings, for example, especially during a warm climate period known as the Gravettian (28,000 to 22,000 years ago). One site called Les Trois-Frères in the French Pyrenees, even shows four sign types grouped together: negative hands, dots, finger fluting and thumb stencils (a rare subcategory of the negative hands).

Grouping is typically seen in early pictographic languages - the combined symbols representing a new concept - and the researchers suspect that prehistoric Europeans had established a similar system. "The consistency of the pairings indicate that they could really have had a meaning," says Nowell. "We are perhaps seeing the first glimpses of a rudimentary language system."

Von Petzinger caused quite a stir when she presented her preliminary findings last April at the Paleoanthropology Society Meeting in Chicago. She and Nowell have recently submitted a paper to the journal Antiquity and they are currently preparing another paper for the Journal of Human Evolution. The Smithsonian Institution's National Museum of Natural History in Washington DC plans to include the symbols in a forthcoming exhibition on human evolution.

"This work is really exciting," says Iain Davidson, an Australian rock art specialist at the University of New England in New South Wales. "We can see that these people had a similar convention for representing something."

Suspecting that this was just the beginning of what the symbols could tell us about prehistoric culture, von Petzinger and Nowell's next move was to track where and when they emerged. The line turned out to be the most popular, being present at 70 per cent of the sites and appearing across all time periods, from 30,000 to 10,000 years ago.

The next most prolific signs were the open angle symbol and the dots, both appearing at 42 per cent of the sites throughout this period. The vast majority of the remaining symbols are each present in around one-fifth of the French caves, the exceptions being the cordiform (roughly a love-heart shape), reniform (kidney shape), scalariform (ladder shape) and spiral, which all turned up in just a handful of sites. "The spiral only appears in two out of the 146 sites throughout the entire time period, which really surprised me as it is a common motif in many later cultures," says von Petzinger.

The Rhone valley and the Dordogne and Lot regions in the south seem to have been the original sites for the symbols in France: most signs seem to appear in these regions before spreading across the rest of the country. Notable exceptions include the zigzag, which first appeared in Provence and is a relative latecomer, debuting around 20,000 years ago.

No signs ever emerged in northern France, though. "For large periods of time the north was uninhabitable because of ice sheets coming and going, so there was less opportunity for culture to develop independently up there," says von Petzinger.

The Ice Age may have hindered the cultural revolution in the north, but elsewhere it could have been instrumental in furthering it. "People were forced to move south and congregate in 'refugia' during the last glacial maximum, 18,000 to 21,000 years ago, and it is at this time when we start to see an explosion in rock art," says Nowell. "One possibility is that they were using the signs to demarcate their territories."

Yet while long winters spent in caves might have induced people to spend time painting wonder walls, there are reasons to think the symbols originated much earlier on. One of the most intriguing facts to emerge from von Petzinger's work is that more than three-quarters of the symbols were present in the very earliest sites, from over 30,000 years ago.

"I was really surprised to discover this," says von Petzinger. If the creative explosion occurred 30,000 to 40,000 years ago, she would have expected to see evidence of symbols being invented and discarded at this early stage, with a long period of time passing before a recognisable system emerged. Instead, it appears that by 30,000 years ago a set of symbols was already well established.

Rewriting prehistory

That suggests we might need to rethink our ideas about prehistoric people, von Petzinger says. "This incredible diversity and continuity of use suggests that the symbolic revolution may have occurred before the arrival of the first modern humans in Europe." If she is right, it would push back the date of the creative explosion by tens of thousands of years.

The idea would seem to fit with a few tantalising finds that have emerged from Africa and the Middle East over recent years. At Blombos cave on South Africa's southern Cape, for example, archaeologists have recently discovered pieces of haematite (an iron oxide used to make red pigment) engraved with abstract designs that are at least 75,000 years old (Science, vol 323, p 569). Meanwhile, at the Skhul rock shelter in Israel, there are shell beads considered by some to be personal ornaments and evidence for symbolic behaviour as far back as 100,000 years ago (Science, vol 312, p 1785).

Further evidence may well come from caves elsewhere in the world, and indeed a tentative look at the existing records suggests that many of von Petzinger's symbols crop up in other places (see map). The open angle symbol, for example, can be seen on the engravings at Blombos cave.

Does this suggest that these symbols travelled with prehistoric tribes as they migrated from Africa? Von Petzinger and Nowell think so. Davidson, on the other hand, who has identified 18 of these symbols in Australia, is unconvinced that they have a common origin, maintaining that the creative explosion occurred independently in different parts of the globe around 40,000 years ago. Instead, he thinks the symbols reveal something about a change in the way people thought and viewed their world, which may have emerged around this time. "I believe that there was a cognitive change, which suddenly put art into people's heads," he says.

Clottes, however, thinks they could be on to something. "Language and abstract thought were probably practised long before 35,000 years ago, since 'modern humans' are some 200,000 years old. We shouldn't be surprised by the sophistication of these people's thinking: they were our great-great-grandparents after all," he says.

But if people really did have a symbolic culture this far back, why don't we find more evidence pre-dating 40,000 years ago? "Perhaps the earlier symbols tended to be carved into perishable things such as wood and skins, which have now disintegrated," says von Petzinger. And even if they did paint in caves many of the rock surfaces will have eroded away by now.

Whenever these symbols did emerge, the acceptance of symbolic representation would have been a turning point for these cultures. For one thing, it would have been the first time they could permanently store information. "Symbols enabled people to share information beyond an individual lifespan. It was a watershed moment," says Nowell.

One huge question remains, of course: what did the symbols actually mean? With no Rosetta Stone to act as a key for translation, the best we can do is guess at their purpose. Clottes has a hunch that they were much more than everyday jottings, and could have had spiritual significance. "They may have been a way of relating to supernatural forces. Perhaps they had special symbols for special ceremonies, or they may have been associated with the telling of special myths," he says.

One intriguing aspect is their possible use in deception. "Once symbolic utterances are recognised, communication becomes more flexible," says Davidson. "One result is that ambiguity can be introduced for concealing truths."

With no key to interpret these symbols, though, we can't know whether ancient humans were giving false directions to rival tribes or simply bragging about their hunting prowess. Our ancestor's secrets remain safe - at least for now.

Doodler or da Vinci?

When our ancestors painted beautiful works of art, were they intending them to be viewed by others, or did they just paint for their own pleasure?

The Lascaux caves, in the Dordogne region of France, may have the answer. There you can see a painting of a red cow with a black head high on one of the walls. Up close the cow appears to be stretched from head to toe, but when viewed from the ground the cow regains normal proportions. This technique, known as anamorphosis, is highly advanced, and suggests the painter was considering his audience as he painted the cow.

Our ancestors probably took the quality of their work very seriously. Recent work by Suzanne Villeneuve, from the University of Victoria in British Columbia, Canada, shows that the images painted with the most skill tend to occur in places where large numbers of people would have been able to see them, while poorer-quality images were more likely to be in smaller cubby holes. In most cases it seems that only the "Leonardos" of the day were allowed to paint the big spaces.
http://www.archaeologydaily.com/news/201002243385/The-writing-on-the-cave-wall.html

For fair use only.

Food for thought.
 
The writing's on the wall: How cave drawings may have been Man's first attempts to write
By Nicola Boden
18th February 2010

article-1251766-0857AA1F000005DC-893_233x288.jpg


http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencet...doodles-French-caves-mans-attempts-write.html
 
I don't agree with Iljov or his work

You are entitled to your opinion, just like everyone else, but it does not mean it is correct or valid.

FYI, Vasil Iljov has stood up for MACEDONIA POLITICALLY where many others either keep silent or are selling us out and you should reconsider whether you agree with him on that issue. If you are opposed, does it mean that you take the position of those that are selling us out right as we speak/write?! :-)


The more he comes out with these ludicrous theories the more I feel that he's somehow on a mission to make Macedonia and its institutions look bad.
This has to be a BAD JOKE, no? :-)

What are these "Macedonian" institutions that have a "good name" in order for someone to give them a "bad name"? Is it MANU, presidents such as Gligorov, Trajkovski, Crvenovski, the Macedonian education system, the Macedonian media, former prime ministers such Ljubcho Georgievski and Vlado Buchkovski or is it the current RAMKOVIST POLITICAL ESTABLISHMENT and its UCK CONSTITUTION?

From where I stand, it looks like the POT is calling someone else black! :-)
 
Indigen said:
Food for thought.
I'm still hungry. Indigen, there's nothing concrete that supports the suggestion that the Macedonian name existed during the Neanderthal era.
The writing's on the wall: How cave drawings may have been Man's first attempts to write
So? Do you see any Phoenician letters there, like the apparent scratches that Iljov refers to? That people scratched things into walls, made designs and patterns, carved symbols, etc, 70,000 + years ago is probable. The concept that people used an alphabet akin to the Phoenician one which most Europeans adopted after about 1000 BC is historical revisionism gone bezerk.
Vasil Iljov -----> GREAT MACEDONIAN PATRIOT!
I don't see the relevance. The average village idiot could be a patriot of the country he descends from. Being a Macedonian patriot is not enough when it concerns such matters. Why hasn't Iljov tried to gain any credibility for his suggestions in world institutions? Why hasn't he sought corroboration? He doesn't even try and go into detail to prove his theories. How can anybody take him seriously? If you want to support wild theories just because its creator is a Macedonian patriot, that is your choice, but don't insult others because they don't share your enthusiasm for this sort of lunacy. I'd love to be proved wrong, but common sense and base logic strongly suggests otherwise.

As it stands at this moment, it's complete bez veza, and unproven theories like these are counter-productive for Macedonians.
 
I'm still hungry. Indigen, there's nothing concrete that supports the suggestion that the Macedonian name existed during the Neanderthal era.
I use mobile broadband with limited download quotas and I can not download every damn video clip people post and thus I have no idea what Vasil Iljov is saying here because I have not seen the clip.

One, I posted the info because someone claimed that writing systems were only a few thousand years old and I just wanted to highlight that there are different views on that point. Two, there is also recent research published that claims Neanderthals were smarter that we thought and that they may have had some genetic input into modern man.

Lastly, Iljov is not representing any official Macedonian institution that I know of, is not an academic and thus I do not think it is warranted to direct such vitriol against him.

He is a good patriot that gets coverage in newspapers and TV shows and thus is quite a few cuts above your average Trajko or Petko patriot.


Васил Иљов

Васил Иљов е претседател на здружението на граѓани “Антички Македонци“ од Богданци, по професија архитект.

Има држено многу предавања на тема континуитет на Античките Македонци со денешните. Активноста на здружението и на Васил Иљов е насочена пред се кон преиспитување на историјата и културата на македонскиот народ од античко време до денес[1], како и целосна поддршка на сите проекти во полето на културно уметничката и научна дејност од областа на античката Македонска историја и култура[2].

Здружението е против официјалната историска наука на Република Македонија, и се бори за ревизија на историјата со поголема афирмација на тезата за директен континуитет со антиката.
mk.wikipedia.org
That is the only Bio info I could find on Vasil Iljov. It seems he is just a higher profiled political activist and not much different to the likes of Donski or Stefou, etc. and, IMO, should not be targeted so negatively and aggressively. I am sure we could find serious faults with P. Kuzman, C. Stefou, A. Donski, amongst others, but it seems some like to target Iljov more than any other activist.


If you want to support wild theories just because its creator is a Macedonian patriot, that is your choice, but don't insult others because they don't share your enthusiasm for this sort of lunacy. I'd love to be proved wrong, but common sense and base logic strongly suggests otherwise.
He has made and continues to make other contributions to the cause and thus people should not subjectively attack him whole-scale and disregard his other contributions to the struggle. This is what upsets me.

Those that deny or seriously downplay Macedonian indigenous continuity and then go on a MASSIVE character assassination of a solid Macedonian patriot such as Vasil Iljov are, IMO, being extremely hypocritical.
 
Last edited:
Indigen said:
I use mobile broadband with limited download quotas and I can not download every damn video clip people post and thus I have no idea what Vasil Iljov is saying here because I have not seen the clip.
Then perhaps next time you'd be mindful not to comment on every damn clip you haven't even watched.
Iljov is not representing any official Macedonian institution that I know of, is not an academic and thus I do not think it is warranted to direct such vitriol against him.
He is on TV and putting his 'theories' up on the internet like its gospel, like it's all been confirmed as legitimate. I asked you before, why hasn't he looked for others to corroborate and support his ideas, outside of the average Trajko and Petko on the internet?
I am sure we could find serious faults with P. Kuzman, C. Stefou, A. Donski, amongst others, but it seems some like to target Iljov more than any other activist.
Then find it and criticise it, but don't defend that which has no grounds of defence.
..........people should not attack whole-scale and disregard his other contributions to the struggle. This is what upsets me.
Where has anybody disregarded his other contributions, whatever they are? What upsets me is that people are going around posing as if they know what they're on about, making all sorts of wild claims like 77,000 year old inscriptions that write 'Macedonia', yet when the simple questions are put forth, we have people like yourself and Dimko jumping in to their defence. What Iljov is suggesting, especially without a shred of support, is counter-productive.
Those that deny or seriously downplay Macedonian indigenous continuity and then go on a MASSIVE character assassination of a solid Macedonian patriot such as Vasil Iljov are, IMO, being extremely hypocritical.
Can you explain how that is hypocritical? If anything, it is showing a measure of consistency. Personally, I wouldn't downplay the indigenous character of Macedonians, but there is no way I would agree with an extreme like Iljov's suggestion. Am I hypocritical, or am I being logical? Are you being logical, or are you allowing your logic to be clouded by patriotism?
 
You are entitled to your opinion, just like everyone else, but it does not mean it is correct or valid.

FYI, Vasil Iljov has stood up for MACEDONIA POLITICALLY where many others either keep silent or are selling us out and you should reconsider whether you agree with him on that issue. If you are opposed, does it mean that you take the position of those that are selling us out right as we speak/write?! :-)



This has to be a BAD JOKE, no? :-)

What are these "Macedonian" institutions that have a "good name" in order for someone to give them a "bad name"? Is it MANU, presidents such as Gligorov, Trajkovski, Crvenovski, the Macedonian education system, the Macedonian media, former prime ministers such Ljubcho Georgievski and Vlado Buchkovski or is it the current RAMKOVIST POLITICAL ESTABLISHMENT and its UCK CONSTITUTION?

From where I stand, it looks like the POT is calling someone else black! :-)

No one is questioning his political beliefs. What is in question are his theories that went from a 4000 year old Macedonian writing to 102,000 years old in the decade we've been posting his claims. Iljov may be the most ardent patriot for all I know but it does not excuse the lack of validity or substance behind his work.

Maybe you or someone else can provide the peer reviewed journals he's appeared in where other scientists and people in other fields conclude his work has substance?
 
Znaci tocno na taa godina pred 102010 godini se pisalo, taka? Nemoi bre, ne postoi nikakvo pismo pred 5-6,000 godini. Ako sum gresen, pokazimi, ama ne so ovie ckrtainci na kamenja, kako da znaele takva azbuka vo toa vreme.

Dimko, Neanderthals lived during that time. Did you know that?

слушај ваму...васил иљов не е тој кој ги датираше артефактике, тие се датирани од странци како франзуските научници...васил е ама тој човек, кој успеал да ги дешифрират "цртниците"...васил е на тој зегмент гениајалец, albert einstein за дешифрирање...тој се занимават со оваа тематика преку 40 години...

кажими кога ќе одиш друг пат за македониа, па ќе организирам средба меѓу тебе, васил иљов, ташко белчев и ако сакаш со ангелина маркус.
 
I ako ne e toi sho go datiral, isto taka toi e sho veli deka crtive na kamenjata pisat nesto - nesto sho ne bilo mozno vo toa vreme. Ako mois da dokazis inaku, pa aj dokazi.

Toa sho go kaza za vasil i einstein, ne e vredno za odgovor. Jas nemam nikakov problem da se sretnam so lugjevo, ama zosto mene samo da mi kazat a ne na celio svet?
 
No one is questioning his political beliefs.

As you did no clearly qualify your disagreement with Iljov when you said "I don't agree with Iljov or his work", I took it to mean literally ALL HIS WORK. Thus I apologise if I read you wrong but please be more clear in future and don't over-dramatise his importance or his official status. We need more patriots with some public profile to stand up for Macedonian national interests as a priority and we should quibble less about issues that are not so important at this time.

What is in question are his theories that went from a 4000 year old Macedonian writing to 102,000 years old in the decade we've been posting his claims. Iljov may be the most ardent patriot for all I know but it does not excuse the lack of validity or substance behind his work.
I don't have an issue with criticism of his theories but just the way you do it. There is no need to denigrate him in the way that you have done because he has made an excellent contribution to the Macedonian cause and deserves some respect and appreciation for it, IMHO.

Maybe you or someone else can provide the peer reviewed journals he's appeared in where other scientists and people in other fields conclude his work has substance?
I don't know how much these peers will objectively review his work when the international community is set on eliminating our very own identity and heritage for political reasons. I recall Ilija Chashule explaining to a few Macedonians (around 1994/5) how he was perceived as being a lunatic when he presented his research papers on Paleo-Balkan linguistics to his peers at some academic conference he attended and can only think an even worse reception would apply to Iljov. Also, when even Russian academics such as Genadij Stanistavlovich Grinevich have not received any positive reviews from peers in western circles, I should think that it would be delusional to expect such for mere Macedonians such as Vasil Iljov.
 
As you did no clearly qualify your disagreement with Iljov when you said "I don't agree with Iljov or his work", I took it to mean literally ALL HIS WORK. Thus I apologise if I read you wrong but please be more clear in future and don't over-dramatise his importance or his official status. We need more patriots with some public profile to stand up for Macedonian national interests as a priority and we should quibble less about issues that are not so important at this time.


I don't have an issue with criticism of his theories but just the way you do it. There is no need to denigrate him in the way that you have done because he has made an excellent contribution to the Macedonian cause and deserves some respect and appreciation for it, IMHO.


I don't know how much these peers will objectively review his work when the international community is set on eliminating our very own identity and heritage for political reasons. I recall Ilija Chashule explaining to a few Macedonians (around 1994/5) how he was perceived as being a lunatic when he presented his research papers on Paleo-Balkan linguistics to his peers at some academic conference he attended and can only think an even worse reception would apply to Iljov. Also, when even Russian academics such as Genadij Stanistavlovich Grinevich have not received any positive reviews from peers in western circles, I should think that it would be delusional to expect such for mere Macedonians such as Vasil Iljov.

Fair enough.
 
Then perhaps next time you'd be mindful not to comment on every damn clip you haven't even watched.
Look, I have read his earlier work and I am open to its validity or not and I did download his earlier 77k (or the like) years old writing clip and I assume it will not be much different. I am not buying into his findings one way or the other and would lean on the being sceptical of such claims.

Where has anybody disregarded his other contributions, whatever they are?
I actually did not criticise you (in your original post), so I do not see a need to get into an argument over nothing.

What upsets me is that people are going around posing as if they know what they're on about, making all sorts of wild claims like 77,000 year old inscriptions that write 'Macedonia', yet when the simple questions are put forth, we have people like yourself and Dimko jumping in to their defence. What Iljov is suggesting, especially without a shred of support, is counter-productive.

There are plenty of people making various claims about Macedonian ethnogenisis with only political bias for justification but they don't get the scrutiny, or people may even jump to their defence, that Iljov gets. Iljov's official status and the "damage" his views may have on Macedonians in comparison to the damage inflicted on ALL (ethnic) Macedonian schoolchildren via the education curricula of the state education system are incomparable. I should think we need to get some priorities right in our struggle for what is right for the Macedonian Cause.


Can you explain how that is hypocritical? If anything, it is showing a measure of consistency.
In an ideological way, yes but when that ideology is obviously very flawed, it becomes the pot calling someone else black, IMO.

Personally, I wouldn't downplay the indigenous character of Macedonians, but there is no way I would agree with an extreme like Iljov's suggestion.
I don't have many issues with your take on Macedonian indigenity, which is almost identical to mine, minus some reservation on your part about certain terminology, e.g. what constitutes a "direct" descendant and nothing I wrote was aimed at you (except the post about cave writing and its age).

Am I hypocritical, or am I being logical?
I did not have an issue with what you raised (in your original post) and it seemed logical to me.

Are you being logical, or are you allowing your logic to be clouded by patriotism?
Maybe a bit of both! As I see it, there are too few patriots to allow them to be sacrificed at the altar of political correctness (PC). Very few people in Mk with a public profile took a strong stand in opposition to the "Ramkoven dogovor" in 2001! Vasil Iljov, Todor Petrov, Slavko Mangovski, Gjorgijia Atanasovski, Blazhe Ristovski and Gjorgji Marjanovikj are among the few that did and I don't like seeing them denigrated or subjectively attacked in an unwarranted manner. It is from the ranks of these same few public profile individuals that we again see resistance being waged in opposition to the latest anti-Macedonian deconstruction agendas of external and internal enemies.
 
Last edited:
I don't know how much these peers will objectively review his work when the international community is set on eliminating our very own identity and heritage for political reasons. I recall Ilija Chashule explaining to a few Macedonians (around 1994/5) how he was perceived as being a lunatic when he presented his research papers on Paleo-Balkan linguistics to his peers at some academic conference he attended and can only think an even worse reception would apply to Iljov. Also, when even Russian academics such as Genadij Stanistavlovich Grinevich have not received any positive reviews from peers in western circles, I should think that it would be delusional to expect such for mere Macedonians such as Vasil Iljov.

That's very true, but the only way to challenge and defeat the western theories is to confront them.
We should be the first to question them instead of locking ourselves within some alternative academic circles.

Tentov personally said to me, that after his publication on deciphering the Rosseta Stone, dozens academic adresses from many well known world universities went to his website and downloaded his whole study.

And all of them remained silent!?!?!

Tentov also have said it is 100 times harder for us to prove our findings because we need to turn upside down the whole internationally accepted learning, which is very difficult to be adopted and demand more time.

But if we compare where we were 15-20 years ago and now, we can say the progress is obvious and exceeding.

Having said that, with respect to all patriots who are working on this to happen, we have to preserve cold heads, to offer productive criticism and to enforce better supported standings before we make anything officially.

Because if we fail one time, such failure will follow us all the time and it will be more difficult for us to prove anything else.
 
I ako ne e toi sho go datiral, isto taka toi e sho veli deka crtive na kamenjata pisat nesto - nesto sho ne bilo mozno vo toa vreme. Ako mois da dokazis inaku, pa aj dokazi.

Toa sho go kaza za vasil i einstein, ne e vredno za odgovor. Jas nemam nikakov problem da se sretnam so lugjevo, ama zosto mene samo da mi kazat a ne na celio svet?
pa neli mnogu ubavo vasil objasnuvat kako dostignal do deshifrirajneto...
- napravil kopija od artefaktot
- ja zgolemi kopijta za da mozhit pishanoto (tvojte crtnici) podobro da se gledat

toa e se...neli mnogu ubavo se gledat na negovite sliki deka ne se samo liniji tuku deka e rakopis.

deneska kje kacham nov video na jutjub...valda tamu kje vidish podobro.
 
Last edited:
Given this is the Macedonian Truth Organisation, the pusuit of the truth should be done in a manner which upholds certain procedures/principles, these should be applied to all claims/posts/threads equally in order to maintain the integrity of this forum.
 
That's very true, but the only way to challenge and defeat the western theories is to confront them.
We should be the first to question them instead of locking ourselves within some alternative academic circles.

Tentov personally said to me, that after his publication on deciphering the Rosseta Stone, dozens academic adresses from many well known world universities went to his website and downloaded his whole study.

And all of them remained silent!?!?!

Tentov also have said it is 100 times harder for us to prove our findings because we need to turn upside down the whole internationally accepted learning, which is very difficult to be adopted and demand more time.

But if we compare where we were 15-20 years ago and now, we can say the progress is obvious and exceeding.

Having said that, with respect to all patriots who are working on this to happen, we have to preserve cold heads, to offer productive criticism and to enforce better supported standings before we make anything officially.

You raise some good points and I mostly agree with you.

Because if we fail one time, such failure will follow us all the time and it will be more difficult for us to prove anything else.
You have a point, but it should/must apply to official state institutions and academics working from within them. Individuals such as V. Iljov, A. Donski, C. Stefou (aka R. Stefov), T. Belchev, Sime Pandevski and the like can make any claims they like as individuals without serious repercussions and you can find them mirrored in all countries, and especially in those around our Macedonian neighbourhood. In our case, they serve a purpose to publish and promote aspects of our heritage and history that has been systematically neglected or denied for anti-Macedonian political agendas.

Lastly, if you take your last point and analyse it SERIOUSLY, what should we now expect from the international community after 99.9% of what official Macedonian state institutions have been sending (or displaying) to the world since 1945 has been to present us as newcomers from behind the Carpathian Mountains? :-)

So pochit,
I.
 
Back
Top