• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

Risto Stefov - Articles, Translations & Collaborations

TrueMacedonian,
Orthodox Church is called epikratousa religion (i.e. prevailing, main, pre-dominant), since about 99% of Greeks are Orthodox Christians.
The President doesn’t have to be Christian, he just have to swear according to the rites of Church. If that seems crazy to you, it’s because the whole provision is silly. How can we have a non-Christian President when 99% of the Parliament Members (who elect him) are Orthodox Christians? For the same reason the phrase “Most top positions in the military, the judiciary, and public schools are de facto restricted to Orthodox candidates” is silly or invalid, especially the reference to judiciary and public schools.
Cases of unlawful proselytization are very rare so I couldn’t find an actual example. The term is supposed to refer to forceful practices, blackmail, fraud, coercion when there’s economic, professional dependence etc. Yet, even in such cases, things are never clear.

Other corrections:
The state DOES NOT subsidize the church budget, OR administers church property (if only). Religious education is NOT mandatory for Greek Orthodox children in public primary and secondary schools (they can be excepted if they ask to). The Ministry of Education and Religious Affairs, is just the relevant Ministry for… Religious issues of all Churches (the current vice-Minister is… Jewish).

The institutionalization of Greek Orthodoxy as the official state religion gives the church a powerful voice in political policy making and the organization of society. The church also has a vested interest in preventing social reform that would weaken the established social order and blur the identification of "Greekness" with Orthodoxy.
The first sentence is an interesting questionable opinion. Is the strength of the Church and its’ influence on people the result of its’ legal state or the deserving reason of it?
The Church is usually a protector of traditional ideas and status quo. Thus, it has fought against the ideas of communism, consumerism, feminism, globalisation (to name a few). Yet, as you understand these are political, philosophical expressions of religion and I guess Church would adapt in any situation. E.g. before 1821 they fought against the “heresy of Nationalism”.
 
Last edited:
The red priest started as a communist-rebel-priest (don’t ask) and then an admirer of Andreas Papandreou; he would speak for the people and against the powerful hierarchs and the official Church and was the No1 nutcase of Greek priest. I don’t know his real or pastoral name; he is known as Papa-Jackal (which is very appropriate). I also don’t know if he was eventually punished or ousted by Church (actually he’s in hospital and dying right now) but there was a time when Church tried unsuccessfully to prohibit or restrict such TV-personas.
Still, you can find legitimate, intellectual, thoughtful versions of his ideas in important figures of Church. Search for the works of Father George Metallinos.
 
but there was a time when Church tried unsuccessfully to prohibit or restrict such TV-personas.

Well from what I could tell the entire cast on that show, from the little angry red fellow to the Vlach who shyly admitted his true ethnic origins to the supposed secret service agent on the phone spreading false rumors without any facts to back up his claims, they all played right into Tsarknias' hand. That's why Tsarknias maintained his composure and played it cool. The rest of the idiots looked like the Three Stooges on the set lol

YouTube - Three Stooges Fight Over Turkey
 
the greeks are a bunch of fakes they go on as if they are as pure as the white driven snow.
They are anything but pure.
 
Last edited:
The Inform-Bureau and the Refugee Children from the Aegean part of Macedonia 1948 – 1

The Inform-Bureau and the Refugee Children from the Aegean part of Macedonia 1948 – 1

The Inform-Bureau and the Refugee Children from the Aegean part of Macedonia 1948 – 1956



By Professor Dr. Violeta Achkoska, Faculty of Philosophy, Skopje

Translated and Edited by Risto Stefov

January 2, 2011



The Macedonian exodus from Greece, as a consequence of war and repressive Greek regimes, falls in the order of the most tragic ethnic cleansings perpetrated against a people in the latest history of Europe. Because of the realization of the “Megali Idea” (greater Greece), that is Greece’s expansion in the 20th century to include Macedonian territories, the Macedonians from the Aegean part of Macedonia, a part of Macedonia that was given to Greece during the Balkan Wars (1), were exposed to physical and emotional repression. This, through various forms and through various intensities, has not changed with time and has lasted to this day. The Greek aim here has been to depersonalize and denominate the Macedonian population and its national identity through permanent Hellenization, to never allow the exiled citizens who do not have a Greek ethnic background to return to Greece and to usurp Macedonia’s history and call it Greek.



The Macedonian exodus from Greece can be studied as a historical, political, psychological and ethnic problem and as a subject, in the most obvious way, expresses the collective and individual suffering of the Macedonian people. At the same time, the problems that caused the Macedonian exodus represent the pivot around which the falsification of Greek history gravitates. (2) Greek authorities, in justifying the supposed “name dispute” with the Republic of Macedonia, are looking for some kind of historical legitimacy to explain their chauvinism and “Megali Idea” Greek politics which have played a role in this all through the end of the 19th, 20th and beginning of the 21st century. An example of this is the so-called “historical collection” of essays edited by the eminent Greek historian Kofos, which introduce the idea that there are multiple “Macedonian identities”. Kofos’s intent here is to show that there is more than one “type” of Macedonian, which is a deceitful attempt to break apart the contemporary Macedonian national identity and replace it with another sort of Macedonian identity with a Greek ethnic connection. This is done in order to give necessary historical legitimacy to the ambiguous Greek claim to Macedonia.



Over the years Greece has settled colonists from other parts of Greece, from Asia Minor, the Caucuses, etc. in the centuries long owned homes and properties of the Macedonians it had exiled. Greece has also used savage methods to erase everything that is Macedonian in order to hide the ethnic cleansing and atrocities it committed over the years against the Macedonian people.



To cover up for its wrong doing, Greece today is not only denying the rightful Macedonians the right to self-identify as Macedonians but it is promoting its most recent non-Macedonian colonists as the “real” Macedonians and descendents of the ancient Macedonians who not only “feel” like Macedonians but are “proud” of their ancient Macedonian heritage. (3)



Through its decades long ethnic cleansing, Hellenization, renaming of Macedonian personal names, toponyms and through erasing Macedonian history, Greece has made every effort to eradicate the Macedonian national and ethnic identity.



Greece has used every opportunity to rob the Macedonian people of their long heritage by not only denying their human rights inside Greek held territories but also outside. An example of this is the Greek role in the Tito-Stalin squabbles or, more precisely, the squabbles between the Communist Party of Yugoslavia (CPY) and the Inform-Bureau (IF) which began in 1948.



When Tito and Stalin started their falling out, the Communist Party of Yugoslavia (CPY) and the Peoples’ Federal Republic of Yugoslavia (PFRY) were severed from the “brotherly union of peoples’ democratic states” (the IF) and were exposed to violent attacks from the Stalinist communist parties. (4)



One of the more devastating consequences resulting from this was the closing of the borders between the Peoples’ Republic of Macedonia (PRM) and Bulgaria, Albania and Greece. As a result the PRM, in 1948, found itself encircled by the tightest borders in existence in contemporary Europe. The Macedonian people living in PRM found themselves cut off both physically and psychologically from the Macedonian people living in the other Balkan countries, which in effect stifled their ability to reunite. Isolated, they lost their chance to bring even the most minute changes (as per discussions for a Yugoslav-Bulgarian Federation), or to help the Macedonians in Bulgaria and Greece with their struggles for national emancipation, which was started thanks to the participation of the Macedonian people in the anti-Fascist struggle.



But in a turn of events as Stalin and Josip Broz Tito (2nd to Stalin) fought for dominance in the communist led world, the Macedonian people found themselves in the centre of a conflict between Yugoslavia and its neighbouring countries. (5) As a result of this, the Bulgarian and Albanian state-party leaderships began a dizzying campaign of verbal insults against Yugoslavia which resulted in breaking economic, cultural and military ties, loss of cooperation and the provocation of border incidents between Yugoslavia and these countries. (6)



Also as a result of the Yugoslav-Soviet spat, among other things, relations between the CPY and the Communist Party of Greece (CPG) began to deteriorate. Adopting the IF resolution (taking the Soviet side) the Greek Communist Party leadership, with Nikos Zahariadis in charge, began a negative campaign against the CPY and against the Macedonian people. The CPG’s first step was to politically isolate the large number of Macedonians serving in its ranks because of supposed fears that they might be working for the CPY in Yugoslavia. As a result of this the Macedonian National Liberation Movement (MNLF) in Greece suffered a serious blow.



The beginnings of the IB campaign against the CPY and the PFRY happened to correspond with the defeat of the Democratic Army of Greece (DAG) during the Greek Civil War. For DAG’s defeat the CPG leadership blamed the USA, Great Britain, Yugoslavia and the MNLF from the Aegean part of Macedonia. According to CPG allegations, the anti-fascist MNLF was an unfriendly organization operating in Greece but serving as a “spy ring” for Yugoslavia. By those allegations “it was implied that Yugoslav intelligence services organized the MNLF and turned it into a spy ring recruiting agents and spies from the ranks of the Macedonian people”. (7) Thus once again the Macedonian people were accused of “wrong doing” and without a shred of evidence were placed under scrutiny and repressive pressures. To deal with these “Tito agents”, among other things, the DAG Central Security Service created a special section.



In reality from what was evident, Tito did not at any time become involved in the internal affairs of the Greek struggles. His involvement was only superficial and done to achieve a better negotiating position for Yugoslavia in the Paris Peace Conference and again afterwards when the Macedonian question became a pawn in his ideological spats with Stalin. Tito took every measure possible to maintain good relations with the Great Powers and never seriously busied himself with the Macedonian question. Evidence of this can be found in the Second sitting of the National Anti-Fascist Liberation Council of Yugoslavia, with the formation of the Yugoslav Federation. (8)



The fate of the Macedonian people living in Greece is well tied not only to Greece’s chauvinistic politics but also to the entire constellation of International relations, particularly in regards to the redrafting of the political map of influence in the Balkans and in the entire world immediately after World War II. Introducing British influence and giving power to a monarchist government in Greece was the beginning of the end of communist influence in Greece. Unfortunately it was not going to be an easy or clean end, particularly for the Macedonians since a large number of them were engaged in this struggle. (9)



It must be made very clear at this point that Macedonians did not enter this struggle for “ideological reasons” as is frequently stated by their enemies in order to devalue their effort. They entered the struggle in order to free themselves and to gain their national and ethnic rights. (10) The communists were a small group in Greece and to increase their numbers they offered the Macedonian people national rights and equality, which the Macedonians accepted and joined their ranks en masse. So as long as the Greek Civil War existed, even as an ideological struggle for power, it existed as a national struggle for liberation for the Macedonian people. (11)



The defeat of DAG and of the democratic forces in Greece opened the way for the Monarchist Greek regime to systematically, ethnically cleanse the Macedonians from the entire Aegean part of Macedonia. This was most evident when the Greek regime formed Monarchist paramilitary units and unleashed them on the civilian population to carry out unseen terror for the purpose of cleansing the Macedonian people while openly announcing that “when the king arrives here he will not find even a single ‘Slav’ on this soil”. (12)



In view of this overhanging danger as a result of the persecutions and terror, many Macedonians feared for their lives and were prepared to leave their homeland and seek secure shelter in neighbouring countries such as Yugoslavia and Bulgaria and in countries overseas. Outside of individual families seeking shelter, there was also an organized evacuation of children which took place in the months of March and April 1948. Around 28,000 children were evacuated and sent to various Eastern European countries. The need for this evacuation was initiated and carried out by the top CPG leadership in the name of “saving the children” but behind the name hid the sinister act to secure manpower reserves for DAG in order to continue the fighting in the Greek Civil War. (13) An example of this is the CPG’s recruitment program carried out in Eastern block countries outside of Greece when underage Macedonian children were recruited and brought back to Greece to fight in the Greek Civil War. This was another blow to the Macedonian people who had to suffer one more time because of Greek and International politics and ideologies. Of all the Eastern European countries which sheltered Macedonian refugee children, only Poland refused to allow the Greeks to recruit children from their soil.



Internal party purges of Macedonians from the CPG and from DAG during the IB period created an atmosphere of fear and exposed the Macedonian population to further mass persecution and terror. The insecurities created by the terror further contributed to the Macedonian population leaving Greece, thus prompting the United Nations to form a Special Investigative Commission for the Balkans. According to a Commission report, dated May 13th, 1949, there were 552,000 refugees from Greece of whom 232,000 were Macedonians. The Commission also cited the Greek government of having reported that there were 486,925 refugees. (14) A large number of wounded partisans, especially after the conclusion of the General Papagos offensive, were sent to Albania to receive medical attention, provided for by groups of doctors from Poland and other Eastern European countries, and after that they were transported by ship to the USSR, Poland and other East European countries. (15)



The process of resettling the Macedonians from Greece intensified after the conclusion of the Greek Civil War, especially after successive Greek governments refused to take them back and continued to pass laws to discriminate against them. (16) But if taking them back was not an option, the Greeks went out of their way to make it difficult for them even outside of Greece. Greek diplomacy became very active in the affairs of the Macedonian refugees outside of Greece and used every method possible to deny their rights, even the right to call themselves “Aegean Macedonians” and their place of origin “Aegean Macedonia”. (17)



Even though the CPG was the only party in Greece to offer the Macedonians equality and human rights, its attitude and conduct towards solving the Macedonian national question varied from time to time. When it needed Macedonian support the CPG declared that Macedonians did exist and should have their rights recognized, when it didn’t it kept quiet, that is up until 1988 when it openly declared that there were no Macedonians living in Greece.



While the CPY squabbled with the IB and after DAG was defeated, the CPG openly conducted anti-Macedonian campaigns both inside and outside of Greece. During the Sixth Plenum of the CPG Central Committee held on October 9th, 1949 in Bureli, the Peoples’ Republic of Albania a resolution was passed, which among other things puts the blame for DAG’s defeat on the Macedonians. This was also evident in other CPG party documents.



The CPG claimed that the reasons for DAG’s defeat were (1) the unlimited help the Athenian regime received from the USA and Great Britain and, (2) Tito’s “betrayal” and his “circle of spies” working in Greece. According to the same documents, the CPG also called for a ruthless attack on the remnants of “Tito’s agents” in the ranks of DAG and on the Macedonian civilian population that had left Greece. This kind of appeal by the CPG not only put a price on the heads of the Macedonians inside Greece but extended its anti-Macedonian attacks against the refugees outside of Greece. This call unfortunately did not go unnoticed and as was shown in practice, in November 1949, when relations between the IB and the PFRY were at their worst, the defeated fighters from DAG and the civilian population were sent to the USSR and to other East European countries where they were exposed to unwarranted scrutiny. Besides facing pressures from Greek and pro-Greek members of the CPG, these fighters and civilian refugees were exposed to harsh scrutiny and repressive measures by the same regimes which were unfriendly towards Tito and Yugoslavia. Macedonians labelled “Tito’s agents” by the CPG became instant enemies of these regimes. The CPG and Zahariadis, its leader, initiated an aggressive campaign against the MNLF and through various publications accused a large number of Macedonians as being “counter revolutionary spies” working for Tito’s Yugoslavia. As a result of this many Macedonian fighters were court marshalled and executed. In July 1949, DAG’s security service with CPG and DAG leadership permission organized a camp to isolate Macedonians accused of collaborating with Yugoslavia. (18)



In the beginning of 1951 a special institution called the “Observation Division” was formed in Bucharest by orders of the politburo of the CPG Central Committee. This division was run by advisory instructors whose role was to repress and persecute Macedonians for alleged ideological wrong doings. The division was charged by the CPG leadership with the task of identifying and prosecuting the MNLF’s leaders who led the movement from 1941 to 1949 and who supposedly had been spying for Belgrade and its intelligence services. Although this was the outward motive for creating this organization, its real motive was to persecute Macedonians and keep them silent.



Unfortunately due to the Greek terror campaigns perpetrated by Greece’s paramilitary, many Macedonian families were forced to look for safe shelter in neighbouring countries such as Yugoslavia and Bulgaria or overseas. According to official statistics released by the CPG’s Central Committee (October 1950), the total number of refugees who fled to East European block countries and to the Soviet Union was 55,881, from which more than 20,000 were Macedonians. Refugees who fled to Yugoslavia numbered around 45,000 to 50,000. (19) If we take into consideration that another 28,000 to 30,000 children were also evicted from Greece, according to some sources, the number of refugees that left Greece is truly tragic. In addition to being displaced and exiled many families ended up being separated with little chance of re-uniting.



Due to the bloody Greek Civil War entanglement and due to the underlined complications of the IB campaign against Yugoslavia, Macedonian families were not only unearthed from their homes but had the unfortunate fate of becoming separated from their children, a greater part of whom, after six decades of exile and organized persecution, are still not allowed to return to their birthplace.



The 28,000 or so Refugee Children (Detsa Begaltsi), casualties of the Greek Civil War, were evacuated from Greece in the spring of 1948 and taken to refugee camps in various Eastern European countries. Around 11,000 were taken to the then PFRY. (20) Those who were sent to Bulkesh and who had family members in the ranks of DAG were moved to special orphanages opened just for them. But because of the soured relations between the CPY and the IB, the CPG gave orders to take the children out of Yugoslavia and place them in other Eastern European countries. Following this order more than 2,000 children were sent to Czechoslovakia. (21) Thus again Macedonians, even innocent children, became tragic pawns in the political games played by the CPY and the IB.



The Refugee Children that remained in Yugoslavia were placed under the care of the Yugoslav Red Cross and, in the period from 1948 to 1958, were settled in various children’s homes including those in Vojvodina, Croatia and Slovenia with 1,857 children (1,581 Macedonians) being settled in the beginning of 1949. (22) The Macedonian children who completed their elementary education in other Yugoslav Republics (outside of the PRM) were returned to the PRM to further their education. Here homes were especially opened to accommodate them. (23)



In the beginning of 1951, according to unofficial reports, 3,957 families and 1,681 single people (a total of 17, 699 people) were settled in the territory of the Peoples’ Republic of Macedonia. Unfortunately the PRM was under an economic blockade and had extremely meagre resources at its disposal. It found it difficult to cope with the sudden influx of refugees, for whom it truly cared, but who were an extra burden on its economy. (24)



Although they were ethnic Macedonians, the Macedonians from the Aegean part of Macedonia, after 1952, in accordance with UN conventions, held “refugee status” in the PRM. Still a large number of them wanted to live there because it felt like home. Their desire to live in the PRM was always there ever since they left their own homes in Greek held Macedonia. Unfortunately due to a series of unavoidable circumstances, many ended up sheltered in the various other Eastern European countries. And with the souring of relations between Yugoslavia and those countries in 1948, many were robbed of their desire to live in the PRM.



The East European Stalinist regimes continued their damaging campaigns against Yugoslavia and the CPY, which included Macedonian people, particularly those who were labelled “Yugoslav agents and spies” by the Greeks. So besides having to endure a war, being exiled from their homes and separated from their families, some Macedonian refugees had now become victims of the polemics between Yugoslavia and the IB; a souring relation which the Greeks took advantage of in order to continue to persecute the Macedonians even outside of their jurisdiction.



During the chaos of the refugee exodus, thousands of families were separated and sent to various countries. With the tense relations between Yugoslavia and the IB and the closing of borders, families that were separated could not be reunited and had to remain apart for a long period of time. Parents were separated from their children, wives from their husbands, mothers from sons and daughters, sisters from their brothers and so on; all were disconnected with no chance of contact or reunification. Also, as long as they found themselves in places that were hostile to them, because of Greek lies and propaganda, they were exposed to severe scrutiny and torment from the Stalinist internal security services operating in those countries. (25)



After the Yugoslav-IB conflict ended and relations between Yugoslavia and the IB countries improved, a review was conducted to determine what went wrong. As a result the CPG newspaper “Neos Kosmos”, in 1957, wrote a story absolving the Macedonians of any wrong doing by admitting that the Macedonians were labelled “Tito’s agents”, “spies”, “enemies and the like” without a shred of evidence to support those charges, for which the Macedonians were tormented, abused and jailed. (26) Because of fear of being persecuted, most Macedonian refugees sent to the East European countries kept to themselves and would not speak about their troubles, not even about their desire to go and live in the PRM.



There is however another side to this story, the side of the Macedonian refugees who were allowed to return to the PRM from the IB countries. While the ideological battles, led by the Soviet Union between Yugoslavia and the IB countries raged on from 1948 to 1956, the CPY became fearful that the “IB infection” was eventually going to be caught by the Macedonian refugees then living in the East European countries. As a result the PRM authorities became cautious and treated those who arrived in the PRM with distrust, suspecting that they might be “planted agents” from the East or from the West who were sent there to work against the PFRY. They were most suspicious of the refugees from Albania and Bulgaria who began to arrive in the PRM some months after the problems with the IB were solved. These particular refugees became victims for the third time and now were being followed by the PFRY internal security service. (27)



Besides fearing that they might be “imbedded agents”, the PRM authorities, particularly the CPY leadership, insisted that most refugees be investigated and recruited into the Party ranks en masse. This intent however was more symbolic than practical because in reality being Macedonians themselves, the “Aegeans” as they were called by the CPY and by the Communist Party of Macedonia (CPM), were cared for and much was done to accommodate them into Macedonian society. Still, many “Aegeans” were not trusted by the PRM authorities, especially those who had family ties with “Aegean” refugees in the Eastern European countries under the USSR and Stalin’s political influence. (28)



Around 1950, the Macedonian Refugees living in the PRM began to organize themselves and formed an organization called the “Organization of the Macedonians from the Aegean part of Macedonia”. Most refugees saw this Organization as an authority representing the refugees and worrying about their problems, most important of which at the time were finding places to live, jobs and “material” needs. However in dealing with the daily problems the leading committee of the Organization, from time to time, took steps outside of its jurisdiction, which came into conflict with the PRM government authorities. (29) Here again the PRM authorities on one hand expected the Organization to lobby for the refugees and get them organized but on the other it raised restrictions to satisfy Yugoslav politics. (30) But all in all the PRM government, in parallel with concerning itself with solving economic and social problems, tried to give the Macedonian Refugees political support and political status.



In addition to being abused because of supposed “IB influence”, authorities were further intimidating the refugees for wanting to obtain Greek passports so that they could return to their birthplace. Their visits to the Greek Consulate were viewed with mistrust and the refugees were suspected of having fallen under some kind of permanent “Greek influence” (1950/51).

According to some documents, there were allegations that “this influence could be cut by vigorous intervention of the authorities and by the political explanatory work of the Association of refugees…” “It was concluded that the two mentioned hostile influences could be drawn away…” (31)



Irrespective of the work that the PRM and the PFRY were doing for the refugees, there were always fundamental differences in what the refugees needed and how far the authorities were willing to go to deliver it, especially if it involved Yugoslav external politics. The need to address the question for repatriation and the properties of the refugees, a stumbling block in Greek-Yugoslav relations, was always ignored. The same is true to this day and this is another key reason for the supposed “name dispute” between Greece and the Republic of Macedonia. Greece has invented the “name dispute” in order to sidestep a vital issue and that is the repatriation of the refugees and former citizens and the return of their properties.



Many Macedonians at that time, as it is true to this day, never gave up calling for Macedonia and the Macedonian peoples’ reunification and solving the Macedonian question. Unfortunately, the call for reunification or adopting some sort of different option, other than the Yugoslav variation, fell on the arsenal of conducting “unfriendly activities against the PRFY”. Because of the New Federation’s International position, Yugoslavia and Tito were only interested in keeping the Macedonian question closed. At the same time Yugoslavia never disengaged from its obligations to protect the rights of the Yugoslavian minorities in the neighbouring countries and Yugoslavian external politics could not ignore the fact that Macedonians existed in Greece. That is why some time ago it raised the question for the recognition of the national rights of the Macedonians in Greece. (32)



In its attempt to recruit the “Aegeans” into its Party ranks, the CPY and CPM were unwilling to accept former CPG members and thus cautiously found reasons to reject them. This was because of fears on account of them being members of the CPG and could have possibly been influenced by the IB (as well as the British discretely raising the question of the state of the Macedonians in Greece). And even though waves and waves of them kept coming to the PFRY over several years, the CPM Central Committee bureau at the May 14, 1951 sitting, adopted a resolution to investigate all applicants for membership to the CPY who were former CPG members (except those for whom the authorities already had information that they could not be accepted). For the refugees and former fighters who were willing to give their lives for the Macedonian cause, this was a “very low mark” indeed, even on a “theoretical level”. A large number of them were requested to take Party courses and attend Party schools. (33) Giving these former fighters and cadres of the Macedonian struggle a strong ideological “re-education in the CPY Party line” was only a means of controlling them.



In summing up its experience of taking care of the refugees and creating conditions for them to “fit in” the Party ranks and political activities, the PRM Central Committee estimated that there were visible differences in the refugee political situation, depending on which place they came from and where they were settled. (34) It was estimated that these Macedonians from the Aegean part of Macedonia exhibited aspirations to be settled in certain regions or in certain groupings according to their birth connections. (35) Grouping the refugees in this way would unfortunately create serious economic problems for them, but in spite of that, the PRM authorities paid more attention to their own political convictions than they did to the refugee needs. Aiming to have better control of them and to prevent their eventual self-organization, authorities created special arrangements in their distribution throughout Macedonian cities and villages.



Whether the refugees themselves were influenced by the IB or not remains an open question, but the fact is that they were receiving letters loaded with propaganda from friends and relatives who still lived in IB countries. The life they lived in these IB countries was described as idyllic, a picture of harmony and prosperity. But at the same time it was well known that no letter could pass the control of the internal security organs and leave the country unless it described that country as idyllic and harmonious. (36) That is why “the attitude of the Aegeans”, as they were called in the PRM party documents, was measured and analyzed, especially the attitude of those who had contact with people from “enemy” IB countries.



Looking at the problem another way, life was not easy for the refugees living in IB countries either and if they did not toe the line, they too would be in serious trouble. Those who showed support for the CPY and Yugoslavia were “abused, persecuted and jailed. The refugee situation was particularly bad in Albania, Hungary and Romania especially with regards to their material needs.” (37)



Longing for their birthplace, displaced from their families, looking for their lost relatives and close friends in the various countries, the Macedonian refugees soberly followed the news of what was happening in Greece and in the IB countries. They were especially concerned and interested to know the situation of their relatives and friends back in Greece. They had left their birthplace, homes, properties and graves of their ancestors so naturally they were interested to know what was happening back home. Similarly, a lot of refugees who had relatives living in the IB countries also wanted to know how they were doing. It was only normal that they would care for them. Unfortunately these types of “concerns” were regarded with suspicion on both sides of the fence. The fact that a large number of refugees were taken to the Eastern European countries was also regarded with suspicion. In their zeal to clean up the “internal enemy” meaning the IB supporters inside Yugoslavia, authorities were not beyond exercising excessive control over people’s lives. Even after Stalin’s death (1953), and after the dissolution of the IB (1956), authorities continued to exercise excessive control. When a large number of Macedonians from the Eastern European countries wanted to settle in the PRM, even though they were to be placed behind a closed Greek border, the authtorities still did not trust them and feared that they might be “spies”. So when they arrived they were labelled untrustworthy to be monitored by the PFRY internal security services. (38)



The most painful question for the Macedonian refugees from the Aegean part of Macedonia has been “when will we return to our ancestral homes?” a question that has been simmering since 1949, since the end of the Greek Civil War. The Greek attitude towards this question was made most obvious in a Greek publication which strongly spoke against their return. “The Slavophones are to remain where they are”; “We don’t want them here! If they return – send them to the island concentration camps”, etc. The same words were also echoed by civil servants working in the Greek consulate in Skopje, words purposely spoken to put fear in the hearts of the “Aegeans” and to “stop them from wanting to return”. (39) Fear, Greek aggression, racist propaganda and confiscated Greek citizenships were all factors designed to keep the Macedonian refugees away from Greece. They unfortunately yearned for their abandoned and confiscated homes and lived with hope that some day soon the political situation in Greece would change and they would return to their birthplace. But with time, instead of becoming better, the situation worsened as the Greek state put into effect a number of discriminatory laws to keep the refugees out. Discriminatory laws which went contrary to European principles and which the European Union unfortunately did not challenge when Greece applied for membership to join its ranks. (40) It seems that such principles are sadly unimportant to Greece or to the European Union.



After 1956, relations between Yugoslavia and the Eastern European countries started to normalize and entered a period of de-Stalinization. During this time the Macedonian refugees, in some small way, were given some freedom from their permanent control, pressure and fear with which they had lived their daily lives. By doing so, it strengthened their resolve to settle in the PRM and adopt it as their new mother country. Realistically however, the PRM had always been their second choice as they never gave up wanting to return to their birthplace. They never gave up their natural right to return to their roots and to possess their properties and the homes of their ancestors.



The Macedonian people from the Aegean part of Macedonia in their Golgotha have endured terror and organized persecution from the Greek authorities. They have endured persecution as a result of the ideological games played by Tito and Stalin, games which the CPG took advantage of to place the Macedonian people in harms way. Instead of delivering on its promises to support the Macedonian people in their struggle to gain their human rights, the CPG exposed its true face when it committed them to further torment. The CPG’s chauvinistic attitude towards the Macedonian people, at times well hidden, showed itself time and again to finally culminate in 1988, with its leadership definitely declaring that “in northern Greece there is nothing other than Greeks”. This was also the time when the Greek state renamed the part of Macedonia it gained by an act of war after the Balkan Wars in 1913, to the “Greek province of Macedonia”. With the CPG on board with the rest of the Greek nationalist camp, one can conclude that Greek politics has achieved consensus in relation to the negation of the Macedonian question and to the negation of the existence of the Macedonian people. In spite of the tens of thousands of Macedonians being persecuted by the Greek state and in spite of the tens of thousands of Macedonian people evicted from their homes and exiled by the various undemocratic Greek regimes, Greece still maintains that Macedonians do not exist. The conclusion one may reach from all this is: Greece’s long term aim is to entirely eradicate the Macedonian identity and everything that is Macedonian. Greece is doing this with never before seen aggression and abuse of its membership status in International organizations.



(1) Vo balkanskite (1912/1913) i Prva svetska vojna (1914-1918), izvrshena e podelba na etno-geografska Makedonija koja dotogash beshe del od Turskata drzhava. Od vkupno 67.741,2 km2 na Grcija ñ pripadna najgolem del, 35 169 km2; na Kralstvoto SHS 25 774 km2; na Bugarija 6 798 km2; eden mal del od teritorijata na Makedonija ostanal vo granicite na novoformiranata drzhava Albanija (Ivan Katardzhiev, Istorija na makedonskiot narod, tom chetvrti, INI, Skopje 2000, 131).

(2) Etnichkoto chistenje na Makedoncite vo Egejskiot del na Makedonija zapochnuva vednash po balkanskite i Prvata svetska vojna. Kako posledica od navedenite vojni od Egejska Makedonija emigrirale 50.000 Makedonci. Na istiot prostor, so grchko-turskiot dogovor od 1923 godina, bile naseleni 640.000 Grci od Turcija, a 40.000 islamizirani Makedonci od Egejska Makedonija, se iselile zaedno so Turcite. Vo periodot od 1923-1928 godina od Egejska Makedonija vo sosednite drzhava se iselile okolu 43.000 Makedonci. Vo tekot na Vtorata svetska vojna i vo Grchkata gragjanska vojna, iako zastaa na stranata na antifashizmot, Makedoncite dozhivea novi pogromi i nov najsilen egzodus. So iseluvanjeto od Grcija na ushte okolu 120.000 Makedonci beshe ispolnet planot na grchkata desnica, napraven vo dekemvri 1944 godina za likvidacija, deportiranje i prisilno izgonuvanje na t.n Grci-Slavofoni (Vidi: Simovski H. T., Etnichkite promeni vo Egejska Makedonija vo XX vek, “Etnichkite promeni vo Egejska Makedonija vo XX“, Zdruzhenie na decata begalci od egejskiot del na Makedonija, Skopje 2002, 35-75). Progonetite Makedonci ne mozhat i denes da se vratat vo Grcija, a nivnite imoti se odzemeni i dadeni na grchki kolonisti. Zaradi stravot od golemi ekonomski reperkusii po drzhavata, ako se reshi begalskoto prashanje, vo Grcija se vodi shovinistichka kampanja za navodniot iredentizam na “Skopje” i se bara promena na imeto na Republika Makedonija.

(3) Вo 1988 godina, koga na grchkata politichka scena beshe postignat definitiven nacionalen kosenzuns za negiranje na postoenjeto na bilo kakvo makedonsko malcinstvo vo Grcija, severniot del od drzhavata beshe imenuvan vo grchka provincija Makedonija. Celta beshe da se minira sozdavanjeto na posebna makedonska drzhava so raspadot na SFRJ, kade egzistirashe makedonskata republika pod slednive nazivi: Demokratska Federalna Makedonija (1944-1946), Narodna Republika Makedonija (1946-1964) i Socijalistichka Republika Makedonija (1964-1991). So referendumot od 8 septemvri 1991 godina, gragjanite na SRM se izjasnija za samostojna drzhava Makedonija, koja so site ustavni akti beshe vostanovena kako Republika Makedonija.

(4) V. Achkoska, Sudirot so Informbiroto i nekoi tekovi vo makedonskoto opshtestvo (1948-1998), "Istorija”, XXXIV/XXXV, br.1-4, Skopje, 1998/1999, 81-96.

(5) DimitÍr Vlahov, Do Georgi Dimitrov, pretsedatel na MinisterskiÔa sÍvet na Narodna Republika BÍlgariÔ, SkopŸe 1948. (Napishano vo Belgrad na 27.09.1948 godina)

(6) Arhiv Republike Slovenije, f: Rodbinski fond Edvard Kardelj, 162/613, Prepiska izmegju CK SKP (b) i CK KPJ i Rezolucija Informbiroa.

(7) Risto Kirjazovski, Egejskiot del na Makedonija po Gragjanskata vojna vo Grcija, INI, Skopje 2001, 265-266.

(8) Koga vo januari 1945 godina, makedonskite artileriski brigadi od Skopje, zhtip i vojnici od drugi garnizoni vo DFM demonstriraat zhelba da se pomogne borbata na Makedoncite vo Egejska Makedonija (t.n. nastani na Skopskoto kale) Tito bara itno raschistuvanje so organizatorite na demonstraciite. Togash e daden nalog za prenasochuvanje na makedonsata vojska kon sever, odnosno XV Korpus na Narodnoosloboditelnata vojska na Makedonija e ispraten na Sremskiot front. (V. Achkoska, N. zhezhov, Represijata i represiranite vo najnovata makedonska istorija, Makavej, Skopje 2006, 147-159). Ponatamu, vo Deklaracijata na Vladata na DF Jugoslavija od mart 1945 godina, voopshto ne se spomenuva makedonskoto parashanje, tuku se bara prikluchuvanje kon Jugoslavija na "nacionalnite" teritorii na severozapad i sever koi po Prvata svetska vojna pripadnale na Italija, kako i zacvrstuvanje na ponatamoshnata sorabotka so sojuznicite i so sosednite balkanski narodi (Arhiv Jugoslavije, fond: Vlada na FNRJ ‡ Pretsednishtvo vlade, 50-30-52). Vo takviot duh, na Pariskata mirovna konferencija, Jugoslavija voopshto ne go postavi makedonskoto prashanje, i pokraj prisutnite baranja na povekje Makedonci.

(9) Povekje izvori zboruvaat za tragichniot bilans na borbata za demokratijata vo Grcija. Vo taa borba golorak, makedonskiot narod istovremeno "stana da go brani svojot opstanok i koga toj neramen boj zavrshi, zad sebe ostavi nad 10.000 ubieni, isto tolku zatvoreni i internirani (osudeni ili neosudeni od prekite grchki voeni sudovi) po grchkite zatvori i suvite ostrovi i preku 50.000 begalci i emigracija vo FNRJ i istochnite zemji" (DARM, f: Republichki Glaven Odbor na SSRNM - Skopje, k-39, Sekretarijatot na Glavniot odbor na Zdruzhenieto na Makedoncite od Egejska Makedonija, Do Izvrshniot sovet na FNRJ, 10.08.1953).

(10) Ushte vo januari 1946 godina, republikanskiot nedelen vesnik "Elefteros", br. 28, pishuva: "Slavomakedoncite treba da is~eznat ottuka, tie treba zadolzhitelno da se isteraat i neka odat vo koja bilo sosedna zemja" (T. Popovski, Makedonskoto nacionalno malcinstvo vo vo Bugarija, Grcija i Albanija, "Makedonska kniga", Skopje 1981, 196).

(11) Makedoncite, ne bile zhrtvi samo na monarho-fashistichkite sili, tuku, voopshto stanale zhrtva na grchkiot shovinizam so etnichki, a ne so ideoloshki predznak. Tumbov Gjorgji, roden na 29.09.1939 godina vo s. LJubnica (Skra), blizu Gevgelija, Egejska Makedonija se sekjava na 1946-ta na brutalnosta na grchkata neorganizirana vojska. Negoviot tatko bil vo partizanite, a isto i negovata 18-godishna tetka koja ja izgubila nogata vo borbite, a potoa migrirala za Polska. Gjorgji tukushto pochnal da odi vo prvo oddelenie, vo grchko uchilishte. Vo kukjata bile dedoto, majkata i chetiri deca. Edna nokj bil odveden dedoto so stokata, a eden grchki partizan gi proteruva od domot, majkata i chetirite deca. Najprvo go ubil kucheto, vrz koe se nafrlil rastrevozheniot Gjorgji, a potoa gi gonel vo kukjata na popot za zhivi da gi izgori. Za srekja, megju grchkite partizani imalo eden koj go poznaval negoviot tatko i toj gi spasil od uzhasnata smrt. Site zhiteli bile priterani sred selo, a mnogumina bile zaklani. Toj den, 13.11.1946 godina, raskazhuva Gjorgji "grchkite parizani ubija 33 lugje i deca i gi izgorea site kukji. Megju ubienite zheni beshe i edna majka na trojca partizani. Nè sobraa i nè oddelija vo dva dela: onie koi kje ostanat i onie koi kje bidat prefrleni vo Jugoslavija. Jas ostanav vo zbegot so parizanite, nekade nad Gevgelija. Tamu ostanavme 14 uzhasni denovi - preku den nè maltretiraa angliskite avioni, a nokje silni dozhdovi... Majka mi beshe so bebe od dve nedeli. Konechno, dobivme dozvola za evakuacija do Gevgelija, a od tamu so voz do Veles i so kamioni do s. Stepanci. Nabrzo potoa, razocharan od odnosot na grchkite partizani, pristigna i nashiot tatko. Na krajot od 1949 godina se preselivme vo Veles. Vo 1953 godina, tatko mi pochina nemozhejkji nikako da se pomiri deka sme begalci i deka go napushtivme rodnoto ognishte, kukja, stoka, tamoshniot zhivot, sè. Nie decata ostanavme sami, no, site uspeavme da se izborime i da se osamostоime vo novata sredina...”. (Beleshki od razgovorot voden so Tumbov Gjorgji, vo Topilnicata vo Veles, 1996).

(12) Samo vo periodot od fevruari 1945 do maj 1947 godina, ovie paravoeni formacii vo Kostursko, Lerinsko, Vodensko, Enidzhevardarsko, gi napravile slednite zlodela: bez sudenje ubieni 278 Makedonci, siluvani 297 zheni, zatvoreni 6.456 lica, 4.200 lica osudeni, 3.215 osudeni na povekjegodishen zatvor, 1.449 internirani, 13.449 maltretirani, 1.191 izgoreni kukji, 13.938 proterani selani od nivnite domovi i 45 iseleni sela (DAРM, fond br.996 - Egejska Makedonija vo Gragjanskata vojna, Izveshtaj od 20.05.1947).

(13) F. Martinova - Buckova, I nie sme deca na majkata zemja..., Skopje 1998, 115/116.

(14) L. Lazarov, Francuski pogledi za polozhbata na makedonskiot narod i etnichkite promeni vo Egejska Makedonija (1944-1957), “Etnichkite promeni vo Egejska Makedonija vo XX vek”, Zdruzhenie na decata begalci od egejskiot del na Makedonija, Skopje 2002, 186.

(15) Makedonskite begalci vo Polska, dokumenti, 1948-1975, 1, izbor, prevod, voved i redakcija P. Nakov, dok. br. 6, 139-147.

(16) Vo ramkite na politikata na iskorenuvanje na Makedoncite od nivnite rodni mesta, grchkite vlasti nosat niza zakonski akti za konfiskacija, nacionalizacija i za eksproprijacija na imotite na borcite na DAG. Vrz osnova na Dekretot M/48, Dekretot N/48, Zakonot 2536/53 izvrshena e konfiskacija na okolu dva milioni dekari obrabotlivo zemjishte, pasishta i shumi, glavno vo pogranichnite makedonski podrachja, od koe pred vojnata se izdrzhuvale 30.000 domakjinstva. Zaedno so zemjata bile konfiskuvani stanbenite zgradi, rabotnite prostorii, dukjanite, pokukjninata itn. Spored zakonite, konfiskacija na imotite se vrshela na uchesnicite vo DAG, shto emigriraa i na onie na koi im beshe odzemeno drzhavjanstvoto. Vo ovie ramki, na povekje od 15.000 Makedonci im beshe odzemeno drzhavjanstvoto, a povekje od 50.000 bea prinudeni da emigriraat. Najgolema konfiskacija na makedonskite imoti bila izvrshena so zakonot 2536/53, koj se primenuval so nevideno varvarstvo. Na konfiskuvanite makedonski imoti vlastite nosele Grci od drugi delovi na drzhavata, pa duri i od Kafkaz. Toa bile kolonisti na koi vlasta mozhela celosno da se potpre vo sproveduvanjeto na etnichkoto chistenje na severniot del od drzhavata. Vo ovoj period nasilstvoto vrz Makedoncite dostiga nevideni razmeri, zashto grchkiot patriotizam se dokazhuval preku brojot na ubienite i maltretiranite Makedonci, preku siluvanite i ubienite Makedonki itn. Odredbite na spomenatiot Zakon propishuvale na 60 km od granicata kon vnatreshnosta da se iselat “nelojalnite” gragjani i na nivno mesto da se naselat Grci, “zadravi“ elementi, “so jasna i so potvrdena grchka nacionalna svest“. (R. Kirjazovski, Makedonskoto nacionalno prashanje i Gragjanskata vojna vo Grcija, INI, Skopje 1998, 340-341).

(17) Taka, vo eden grchki Memorandum, ispraten do britanskata vlada, od 28.09.1950 godina, megju drugoto stoi: “‘Egejskite Makedonci‘ se izrastok na ‘balkanskata’ politika neodamna izmislena od grchkite sosedi so cel da ja dezintegriraat nea. Ova e parola protiv koja grchkata nacija trgna i pobedi so sopstvenata krv i materijalnata pomosh od sojuznicite. Grchko-jugoslovenskoto priblizhuvanje nema da bide od korist za Grcija, nitu kje bide potreben faktor vo sojuznichkata politika, dokolku prodolzhi da bide unishtuvano od ovaa gangrena”. (Makedoncite vo jugoslovensko-grchkite odnosi, Dokumenti 1950-1953, tom II, izbor, prevod i redakcija L. Panovska, T. Chepreganov, DARM, Skopje 2001, 247)

(18) R. Kirjazovski, Egejskiot del na Makedonija po Gragjanskata vojna vo Grcija, INI, Skopje 2001, 266-279; DARM, f. Grcija, k.18/19/63; k. 18/44, 144; k. 18/59, 82; k. 20/291; k. 28/28/23; k. 20/28/43.

(19) Fani Martinova - Buckova, I nie sme deca na majkata zemja..., Zdruzhenie na decata-begalci od Egejskiot del na makedonija, Skopje 1998, 32.

(20) Brojkata od 11.000 deca prifateni vo Jugoslavija se odnesuva na vkupniot broj deca, od koi nekoi bile smesteni vo detskite domovi na Crveniot krst, a drugite, pogolemiot del, bile so roditeli ili rodnini. FNRJ beshe megju prvite zemji shto prifatija najgolem broj deca-begalci so roditeli i bez roditeli. Osven toa, niz nea pominaa okolu 12.000 deca bez roditeli, upateni kon istochnoevropskite zemji, koi bea privremeno smesteni i nahraneti, a potoa regularno predadeni na nadlezhnite organi vo zemjite shto definitivno gi prifakjaa.

(21) Fani Martinova - Buckova, cit. trud, 36.

(22) Vo ramkite na FNRJ, detski domovi bea otvoreni vo: Vojvodina - Bela Crkva, Novi Sad, Hrvatska - Crkvenica, Zagreb, Osiek, Vrbas, Zrenjanin, Krani, Sailovo, Kula, Samobor, Pladishte, Vrshachka Chuka, s. Strasha - Banat; Slovenija - Dutovlje, Stara Gora, zhent Vit. Za nivnoto vospituvanje i obrazovanie bile angazhirani 90 lica, od koi 17 makedonski i 10 grchki uchiteli, a kako vospiten i drug pomoshen personal rabotele ushte 33 Makedonci i 30 Grci (DARM, f: 997, k-1.2/3-4).

(23) Taka, domovi za "Egejchinja" bea otvoreni vo povekje gradovi vo NRM. Vo Struga, na 1.03.1950 godina beshe otvoren domot "Goce Delchev" vo koj bea zgrizheni 60 deca od 7 do 16 godini. Potoa domovi imashe vo Bitola, Kumanovo, s. Petrovec - Skopsko, Demir Kapija - Kavadarsko, Valandovo. Vo Valandovo vo 1952 godina beshe otvoren detskiot dom "Aleksandar Rankovikj” vo koj bea zgrizheni 270 deca, najgolem broj deca-begalci dojdeni od domovite od drugite republiki (Vesnik "Glas na Egejcite”, od maj 1954 godina). Spored sekjavanjeto na negoviot direktor (1952/53 godina), Gligor Todorovski, "postoenjeto na Domot 1952-1958 godina ostavi silni tragi vo kulturniot zhivot vo gradot i okolijata vo nastapite na horskata, igraornata, baletskata i drugi sekcii shto postoeja vo Domot”.

(24) DARM. f: CK KPM/SKM, k-27, dok. 39, Zapisnik za sastanka Biroa CK KPM, odrzhanog 14 maja 1951 god.

(25) Za golgotata niz koja pominale mnogu semejstva, za nivnite begalski maki, za odnost na Grcite kon Makedoncite vo emigracija, potresni sekjavanja kazhuvaat makedonskite zheni (vidi: Lidija Stojanovikj-Lafazanovska, Ermis Lafazanovski, Egzodusot na Makedoncite od Grcija: zhenskite storii za Vtorata svetska vojna i nivniot egzodus, EURO BALKAN, Skopje 2002)

(26) DARM, f: CK KPM/SKM, k-101, dok. 23, Za nekoi problemi vo vrska so useluvanjeto na Makedoncite od istochno-evropskite zemji vo SR Makedonija, materijal od 64-ta sednica na IK na CK SKM, 20.2.1964.

(27) DARM, f: CK KPM/SKM, Uprava za agitacija i propaganda, Komisija za Albanija, k-49, Elaborat za albanskata politichka emigracija vo Makedonija, maj 1953; DARM, f: CK KPM/SKM, k-49, Elaborat za polit. emigrantite od Bugarija, 4.02.1953.

(28) Spored ocenkite na KPM, "pod vlijanie na IB potpadnale dobar del od kadrite na DAG...". KPM smeta deka del od borcite na DAG, glavno, go shirele informbirovskoto vlijanie "sred eden del od masite, osobeno onie koi imaa semejni vrski so begalcite od Egejska Makedonija vo istochnite zemji. No toa vlijanie... so tekot na vremeto se povekje i povekje opagjashe i toa poradi opshtata ideoloshko-politichka pobeda na Jugoslavija nad hajkata protiv nea od Sovetskiot blok i poradi teshkite uslovi vo koi se postaveni begalcite vo zemjite od sovetskiot blok....". (DARM, f: Republichki Glaven Odbor na SSRNM - Skopje, k-39, Analiza za situacijata sred begalcite od Egejska Makedonija vo FNRJ, 7.10.1953).

(29) DARM, f: Republichki Glaven Odbor na SSRNM - Skopje, k-39, Analiza za situacijata sred begalcite od Egejska Makedonija vo FNRJ, 7.10.1953.

(30) Budno sledejkji shto se sluchuva so begalcite vo NRM, grchkite diplomati vo septemvri 1950 godina gi informiraat svoite sojuznici deka “od dolgorochen aspekt“ noviot periodichen “Glas na Egejskoto more (se odnesuva na organot na Zdruzhenieto na begalcite od Egejska Makedonija Glas na Egejcite, b.m.) chii celi se zacrtani vo dodatokot 2 (del X) verojatno pretstavuvaat seriozen kamen na sopnuvanje za bilo kakvo mozhno podobruvanje na grchko-jugoslovenskite odnosi...”. (Makedoncite vo jugoslovensko-grchkite odnosi, Dokumenti..., 248)

(31) DARM, f: Republichki Glaven Odbor na SSRNM - Skopje, k-39, cit.dok.

(32) Pedantnite britanski diplomati vo Atina kje zabelezhat: “... Jugoslovenite ne se raspolozheni da go prifatat argumentot deka ‘nema makedonsko malcinstvo’ vo Grcija po pat na zamolchuvanje...Potoa, poradi nadvoreshni i vnatreshni prichini, jugoslovenskata propaganda ne saka da zadrzhi diskreten molk vo odnos na ‘grchka Makedonija’ shto bi bilo najdobro“. Vo prodolzhenie na ovoj izveshtaj, sepak se konstatira deka vo natpisite na jugoslovenska strana nema nekavi teritorijalni baranja. (Makedoncite vo jugoslovensko-grchkite odnosi, ..., 112)

(33) Pri Kontrolnata komisija na CK na KPM bila oformena posebna grupa koja vo sorabotka so rakovoditeli od Egejska Makedonija gi razgleduvala izjavite na kadrite i dostavuvala predlog do Kontrolnata komisija na CK na KPM. Partiskite komiteti na terenot dobile preporaka preku "zasilena politichka i partiska rabota pomegju Makedoncite od Egejska Makedonija da nastojuvaat shto povekje da primat za chlenovi na KPM...". (DARM. f: CK KPM/SKM, k-27, dok. 39, Zapisnik za sastanka Biroa CK KPM, odrzhanog 14 maja 1951 god.).

(34) Spored odredeni procenki, najdobra politichka polozhba megju begalcite bila konstatirana vo Bitola. Tamu, spored sostavot, tie bile od Lerinsko, Kostursko i Vodensko, od onie kraishta kade shto antifashistichkoto demokratsko dvizhenje bilo najsilno. Skoro sekoe od ovie semejstva dalo zhrtvi vo borbata. Tie, vo golema mera, bile politichki poizdignati i tochno informirani za terorot nad Makedoncite vo Grcija i za sostojbite vo SSSR i stalinistichkite logori. Zaradi takvite soznanija ne projavuvale zhelba da se vratat nazad ili da zaminat od NRM i pokraj postoenjeto odredeni problemi so nivnoto smestuvanje (stan, vrabotuvanje isl.).

(35) Taka, na primer, onie od Kostursko i Lerinsko projavuvale zhelba da se naselat vo bitolskiot reon, onie od Dramsko vo Strumichko, od Vodensko - vo Kavadarci i Gevgelija, Prilep itn. I pokraj grupiranjeto vo reoni, sepak najgolem broj Makedonci od Egejot projavile zhelba da ostanat vo Skopje. Vo 1953 godina bilo evidentirano deka edna tretina od niv zhiveat vo Skopje, a bile podneseni 717 nivni molbi, od drugite pomali mesta vo NRM, za gradenje stanovi vo Skopje. (DARM. f: CK KPM/SKM, k-49, dok. 72, Izveshtaj od ekipata koja trebashe da ja ispita polozhbata na Egejcite, 1953).

(36) DARM. f: CK KPM/SKM, k-27, dok. 39, Zapisnik za sastanka Biroa CK KPM, odrzhanog 14 maja 1951 god.

(37) DARM, f: Republichki Glaven Odbor na SSRNM - Skopje, k-39, Informacija za polozhbata na begalcite od Egejska Makedonija, 13.04.1957.

(38) Za doagjanje na negovoto semejstvo od Polska vo NRM, Stavre Dzhikov zapishal: “...Na zheleznichkata stanica vo Skopje pristignavme zimata vo dekemvri 1956 godina. Moite roditeli bea tretirani kako politichki emigranti i so policiski dzhip né odnesoa vo zatvorot Idrizovo, kade shto bevme smesteni vo dzidani prizemni dolgi zgradi ≠ prifatilishta. Golemata zhelezna vrata vo Idrizovo zasekogash kje mi ostane vo pametenje, iako bev samo dete. Tri nokji prespavme vo prifatniot logor vo zatvorot i po raspitot na moite roditeli od policiskite islednici ne odvedoa vo anot Merkez kaj Bit-Pazar. Tamu vo edno tesno odajche zaedno so dedo mi Stojche, koj se pribra od Bitola zhiveevme edna godina. Makedoncite koi doagjaa od Istochniot lager na komunistichkite drzhavi, se karakteriziraa kako somnitelni i nadgleduvani od tajnata policija ≠ Uprava za drzhavna bezbednost ≠ UDB-a”. (Stavre Dzhikov, Chetvrta emigrantska Makedonija, Az-buki, Skopje 2007, 22).

(39) Sekretarot na Konzulatot Panajotis Nikolaidis, megju drugoto, zboruval: "Egejcite ni se nam golemi neprijateli i zatoa gi mrazime. Nie kje gi ochistime site Egejci i vekje pochnavme da gi chistime, neka znaat deka sme Grci... Grcija mora da ostane sosema chista samo so Grci, a ne i so ovie Makedonci. Ednash zasekogash kje se oslobodime od Makedoncite..." (DARM, f: Republichki Glaven Odbor na SSRNM - Skopje, k-39, Narodno sobranie na NRM, Izvrshno vekje, str. pov. 6, 18.09.1953 g. Skopje, Drzhavnom sekretarijatu za inostrane poslove - Beograd). Polozhbata na Makedoncite koi ostanale vo svoeto rodno mesto vo grchkata drzhava bila mnogu teshka. Tie zhiveele vo teror i bezakonie"...Posle pet godini od zavrshuvanjeto na Gragjanskata vojna, se drzhat vo zatvorite i vo internacija neosudeni lica, ili osudeni vrz osnova na lazhni optuzhbi..." (DARM, f: Republichki Glaven Odbor na SSRNM - Skopje, k-39, Sekretarijatot na Glavniot odbor na Zdruzhenieto na Makedoncite od Egejska Makedonija, Do Izvrshniot sovet na FNRJ, 10.08.1953).

(40) Pritoa, so stapuvanjeto na sila na Zakonot za kolonizacija na severnite pokraini na Grcija od avgust 1953 godina se zgolemuvala do krajni granici neizvesnosta za vrakjanje vo nivnite imoti i rodni mesta. Vo chlen 6 od Zakonot nedvizhniot imot na onie lica koi se naselile vo stranstvo ili nedozvoleno ja napushtile zemjata bez pasosh od nadlezhnite organi, se smeta kako napushten imot. Po istekot na 3 godini od begstvoto na spomenatite lica, nivniot imot avtomatski í pripagjal na drzhavata, so polno pravo na koristenje i vladeenje. Isto taka, se odzemala vo korist na drzhavata i zemjata na onie lica koi ja napushtile vo poslednite dve godini i se naselile vo vnatreshnosta na Grcija. Konfiskuvaniot imot im se dodeluval na novonaseleni lica koi mozhele da bidat i nezemjodelci, od bilo koj kraj na drzhavata. (DARM, f: Republichki Glaven Odbor na SSRNM - Skopje, k-39, Sekretarijatot..., 10.08.1953). So ova zakonodavstvo koe mu protivrechelo na site megjunarodni odredbi za pravata na chovekot i gragjaninot, na Makedoncite im bile odzemeni ne samo nacionalnite tuku i chovekovite prava da se vratat na svojot imot i vo svojata zemja od koja bile prinudeni vremeno da pobegnat
 
Macedonian Struggle for Independence Part 37 – The Second Balkan War and Macedoni

Macedonian Struggle for Independence Part 37 – The Second Balkan War and Macedoni

Macedonian Struggle for Independence



Part 37 – The Second Balkan War and Macedonia’s Partition



By Risto Stefov

rstefov@hotmail.com

January 2011



The London Conference adjourned on August 11th, 1913, officially declaring an end to the First Balkan War. In spite of all the deals made during the conference, the resolutions left all parties dissatisfied. Serbia was dissatisfied with losing the Albanian territory. Serbia appealed to Bulgaria to grant it access to the Aegean Sea via Solun and the Vardar valley but its appeals fell on deaf ears. Greece also was not happy with Bulgaria’s invasion and annexation of Odrin. To balance her share, Greece wanted Serres, Drama and Kavala as compensation. That too fell on deaf ears.



Seeing that Bulgaria was not going to budge and the fact that neither Greece nor Serbia alone could take on Bulgaria militarily, should a conflict arise, Greece and Serbia concluded a secret pact to jointly work against Bulgaria. In short, the objective was for Greece and Serbia to take the territory west of the Vardar River away from Bulgaria and divide it and have a common frontier.



After stumbling upon the Greek-Serbian pact, despite Russian attempts to appease it by offering it Solun, Bulgaria remained bitter and in a moment of weakness was lured away by Austria. By going over to Austria, Bulgaria in effect broke off all relations with the Balkan League. Russia, disappointed with the Bulgarian shift, made it clear that Bulgaria could no longer expect any help from Russia.



In what was to be termed the “Second Balkan War”, the Bulgarian army, unprovoked, on June 30th, 1913 attacked its former allies on Macedonian soil. The conflict also drew in the Ottomans and Romania.



After a truce between the Ottomans and the allies was concluded on December 4th, 1912, besides Western Macedonia, the Serbian army had occupied part of Albania and had gained access to the Adriatic Sea. Austria-Hungary however, wanting that region to remain under its sphere of influence, strongly opposed Serbia’s plan. This unfortunately created a cascading effect threatening Russian plans to gain access to Istanbul and forcing France to take measures against Austro-Hungarian expansion by advising Serbia not to withdraw from the Albanian territories. Great Britain came in support of Greece wanting Greece to expand northward and eastward into Ottoman territory in order to block Russian influence in the Balkans and in Istanbul.



The start of the Second Balkan War sparked a crisis in the region which the Great Powers attempted to resolve by peaceful means. Russia advised Serbia to retreat from Albanian territories in order to avoid conflict with Austria – Hungary. There were also recommendations made that the allies withdraw from Macedonia and follow up on the December 1912 suggestion, made in the London Conference, that Macedonia be given autonomy under Ottoman sovereignty. But that suggestion was rejected. The one suggestion that was followed up on was that made by Austria-Hungary on December 27th, 1912, to create an autonomous Albanian state. This meant that Serbia would have to evacuate all Albanian territory. By the May 30th, 1913 Peace Treaty of London, the Albanian territory was defined as the entire territory north of the Enos-Midia line previously ceded to the Balkan allies. The Ottomans were also ordered to leave Crete and the Great Powers were to decide on Albania’s borders.



Serbia did retreat from Albania and gave up on its plans to gain access to the Adriatic Sea but now found itself landlocked, so it looked to Bulgaria to grant it access to the Aegean Sea. Serbia’s plan was to acquire a bigger chunk of Macedonia. Dissatisfied with Bulgaria’s silence on the matter, Serbia cancelled its Serbian-Bulgarian treaty regarding the current division of Macedonia. Greece in the meantime requested of its partners to recognize its share of southern Macedonian, including its rights to Solun. Bulgaria, while categorically refusing to cede Macedonian territories to its partners, was secretly hoping to occupy all of Macedonia and acquire Solun for itself.



On June 1st, 1913 Serbia and Greece signed a secret treaty by which they agreed to forcefully take more Macedonian territory away from Bulgaria. Using the tense situation to its advantage, Romania too jumped in and requested of Bulgaria to hand over southern Dobruja. Not to be outdone and in hopes of gaining back some of their lost territories the Ottomans too jumped into action.



Austria-Hungary also took advantage of the situation and to draw Bulgaria into its sphere of influence, on June 29th, 1913, began an assault on Bulgaria’s former allies thus initiating the Second Balkan War.



Caught in the middle of all this were the Macedonian people who were now being mobilized by force to fight on all sides of the conflict. Macedonians drafted in the foreign armies were well aware that they had been deceived and knew very well that the war they were about to fight was about Macedonia’s permanent occupation and imminent division. They felt deep hatred towards the Serbs, Bulgarians and Greeks and deserted their armies at every opportunity.



The Macedonian economy also suffered during this time, particularly in the rural regions where Macedonians were forced to provide for the armies and work digging trenches and fortifying their positions. Outside of those being mobilized by force by the Bulgarian army, Bulgaria also mobilized about 40,000 young Macedonians between the ages of 20 and 26 to create the Seres, Drama and Odrin Brigades. These Macedonians were forced to fight against their will and to the detriment of their own people.



Bulgaria’s entry into the Second Balkan War began with King Ferdinand's order number 234 and directive number 22 issued on June 1st, 1913, which called for an urgent transfer of the Bulgarian army from the Thrace front to the western front in Macedonia.



Bulgarian Supreme Command was planning to attack and defeat the Serbian army in two decisive strikes; first in the Morava River valley and then in Ovche Pole. The plan was to encircle the Serbian armies and force them to surrender.



Assuming Austria-Hungary was going to protect it from Romania and the Ottomans by preventing them from joining the war against Bulgaria, Bulgarian Supreme Command left its borders with these countries unprotected.



Meanwhile, on June 1st, 1913, Serbian and Greek Supreme Commands, in accordance with article 6 of their Military Convention, signed a Protocol to co-operate in case of a Bulgarian attack.



On June 3rd, 1913 Greece signed a Treaty with Bulgaria defining the demarcation line between the Bulgarian and Greek armies. On June 6th, 1913 Greek Supreme Command issued an order to strategically deploy the Greek army on the Gulf of Orfano -Besik Lake -Lagadina Lake - hills north of Solun and the village Karasuli line. By June 13th, 1913 Greece had its forces regrouped and ordered to hold back the Bulgarians.



The first battle of the Second Balkan war began in Bregalnitsa on June 30th, 1913 when the Bulgarians unexpectedly attacked the Serbians. Many Macedonians were drawn into the battle and fought on both sides. The Macedonian -Odrin Opolchenie units fought on the Bulgarian side, while the Macedonian Osogovo detachment fought on the Serbian side. As the battle entered its second day, the Serbians, in need of reinforcements, decided to mobilize 30,000 men, mostly from Macedonia, and dispatched them to the front without any training. By July 7th, 1913 more Serbian reinforcements began to arrive and as the Greek army began its advance towards the north end of the front in an effort to cut off Bulgarian retreat, the Bulgarian army disengaged and retreated.



During the Bregalnitsa battle both Serbian and Bulgarian armies experienced mass desertions on the front lines. The deserters were Macedonians who not only knew each other from before but had come to the realization that the objective of this war was to divide Macedonia.



All three armies showed no hesitation in using Macedonians to fight on their fronts, even if they had to fight each other, Macedonians against Macedonians. All three recruited young men from the Macedonian population and, with no training, forced them to fight on the front where many were killed.



If destroying Macedonia’s future generations was not enough, all three belligerents also helped themselves to the Macedonian population’s food supplies threatening the civilian population, particularly the women and children, with starvation.



By July 2nd, 1913 a second front had developed in Kukush Region and fighting between the Bulgarian and Greek armies began. But due to a strong barrage of artillery fire from the Greek side, the Bulgarians retreated without a fight disappointing the Macedonians enough to discard their weapons and walk away. Kukush is Gotse Delchev’s birthplace and the Bulgarians abandoned it without a fight. Their retreat was disgraceful. If Delchev was truly Bulgarian as they had claimed, then the Bulgarians would not have left Kukush without a fight.



Over the next few days the Greek army continued to push the Bulgarians back until they reached Belasitsa where they ended their advance.



When it became clear that the Bulgarians had lost to the Serbians and Greeks at Bregalnitsa and Kukush, the Romanians began to mobilize their armies. At that point the Romanian government informed the Bulgarian government that Romania’s armies were going to invade Bulgaria in order to recover southern Dobruja. Given the vast size of the Romanian force, Bulgaria decided to remain passive and on July 13th, 1913 allowed the Romanians to cross the Bulgarian border. The next day the Romanians crossed the Danube River and on July 20th, 1913 reached the Berkovitsa- Vratsa –Orhaniya line. By July 25th, 1913 the Romanians came to within 5 km of Sofia where they were stopped by request from Germany.



In the meantime seeing that Bulgaria was losing to the Serbians and Greeks, the Ottomans also entered the fore. On July 15th, 1913 Ottoman forces crossed the Enos –Midia border and on July 23rd, 1913 entered Odrin. But due to Great Power intervention the Ottomans were stopped before crossing the Bulgarian border.



After Romania and the Ottomans entered the Second Balkan War, Bulgaria had little choice but to capitulate and on July 30th, 1913 signed a truce and entered negotiations for the division of Macedonia.



The Peace Conference in Bucharest began on July 30th, 1913 and was attended by six Great Power representatives. The Balkan delegations, except for the Bulgarian, were led by their Prime Ministers. Chairing the Conference was Prime Minister Titu Maioresku of Romania. The conference was organized in plenary and special sessions led by military delegations. Special commissions were also established to deal with special issues.



The Conference took place in a tense atmosphere and was constantly interrupted because of the many parties involved. Military operations were ordered to cease on July 31st, 1913 and a preliminary truce was signed under the following conditions:



1. Demarcation lines marked with white flags were to be drawn where the advance guards had reached on July 31st, 1913, precisely at noon.

2. The truce was to begin on July 31st, 1913, at noon, and was to last for five days.

3. Movement of the troops and provisions were not to be interrupted.

4. In order to terminate hostilities, the “warring powers” were to inform each other of their current positions.

5. Supreme commands of the “warring powers” were to immediately inform all their forces of the truce.

6. Articles 40 and 41 of the war conventions on land were to be observed.



When the Bucharest Conference began the various parties decided to leave Bulgaria out of the plenary sessions and separately discuss Bulgarian issues between Serbia, Romania, Greece and Montenegro. The first treaty to be signed was between Bulgaria and Romania.



On August 5th, 1913 Jackson, the American representative at the Conference, read a note sent by his government which in part said that the US government was interested in putting provisions in the Treaty to protect the civil and religious rights of the population in the regions proposed to come under the sovereignty of these five states. Maioresku accepted the American proposal and some discussions took place in that regard but on Venizelos’s (Greek prime minister) suggestion this provision did not enter the Peace Treaty, thus depriving the Macedonian population of its rights.



The most difficult problem the Conference faced was reaching an agreement about Macedonia’s division. In addition to the Greeks, Serbians and Bulgarians wanting things to go their way, there were also all kinds of proposals made by the Great Powers. While the Russians wanted to divide Macedonia one way, Austria-Hungary, to placate Bulgaria, wanted to divide it a different way.



Russia suggested that the border between Serbia and Bulgaria be drawn between the Vardar and Struma rivers so that Shtip could be given to Serbia and Strumitsa and Kochani to Bulgaria. The junction between the Serbian-Greek-Bulgarian borders would be Gevgelija. The Greek-Bulgarian border would extend from Gevgelija down the Struma river valley to Drama, with Drama and Seres going to Greece. The Great Powers would then determine the border from Drama to the Aegean Sea.



Austria-Hungary suggested that the Serbian-Bulgarian border be drawn along the Vardar River so that lands west of the river would be given to Serbia and lands east of the river would be given to Bulgaria. The Greek-Bulgarian border would be drawn so that the southern part of the Struma River and the coast from Kavala to Enos would be given to Bulgaria.



The Serbian delegation disagreed and requested that the border be drawn from Gorna Dzumaja along the Struma River down past the Rupel Gorge.



On August 6th, 1913 Bulgaria and Serbia came to an agreement that Stip and Kochani should be given to Serbia and Strumitsa and Radovish to Bulgaria. While their military representatives drew up the border on topographic maps, a commission of experts from Belgium, Switzerland and the Netherlands was put together to deal with specific problems.



Drawing the Greek -Bulgarian border was a little more challenging mainly because Greece did not want to give Bulgaria access to the Aegean Sea. Greece insisted that the border be east of Belasitsa Mountain, north of Seres, Drama, Ksanthi up to Makri on the Aegean Sea. Under this scenario Bulgaria would acquire a 40 km long coast stretching from Makri to Enos. Dissatisfied Bulgaria requested of Maioresku, the Romanian Prime Minister, that it be given the Port of Kavala otherwise there would be no agreement. France and Britain however did not agree with Bulgaria’s request and Kavala was given to Greece.



Bulgaria agreed to continue with the talks under Russian, Italian, and Austro-Hungarian assurances that they would soon revise the Treaty to include this Bulgarian request.



On August 7th, 1913 Protocol number 9 was signed, drawing the Greek-Bulgarian border from the Serbian-Bulgarian border, over Belasitsa Mountain down the mouth of the Mesta River to the Aegean Sea. Then on August 10th, 1913 the Bucharest Conference adopted the text and the negotiations were over.



With the signing of this treaty Macedonia’s fate was sealed. The territories Macedonia, Kosovo, Metohija, Vasojevitsi, Sandzhak, Thrace and northern Epirus, previously occupied by the Ottomans were expropriated by the three belligerent states, Greece, Serbia and Bulgaria.



Serbia received roughly the Vardar Region of Macedonia, Kosovo, part of Metohija and part of Sandzhak, an area of 39,000 km2 inhabited by 1,290,000 people.



Montenegro received Vasojevitsi, part of Sandzhak and part of Metohija. Its territory was increased by 7,000 km2 and its population by about 260,000 people.



Greece was given northern Epirus, roughly the Aegean Region of Macedonia, part of Western Thrace, the Chalcidice Peninsula with Solun and a large number of Aegean Islands. Greece was given 51,300 km2 of land populated by 1,624,000 people.



Bulgaria was given roughly the Pirin Region of Macedonia, greater Strumitsa and parts of eastern and western Thrace. Bulgaria was given 21,000 km2 of land inhabited by about 600,000 people. Bulgaria was also given access to the Aegean Sea which extended from the mouth of the Mesta River to the mouth of the Maritsa River and the Port of Dedeagatch.



Romania received southern Dobruja, an area of 800 km2 populated by 303,000 people.



On August 11th, 1913 just after the Treaty was signed, Austria-Hungary, Russia and Bulgaria requested revisions to the Treaty. But then a couple of days later, on August 14th, 1913, Russia changed its mind and the dreaded 1913 Treaty of Bucharest to this day remains incomplete and without the signatures of some Great Powers.



No one, not even the Great Powers took any requests from the Macedonian people not even for the preservation of their identity.



On March 1st, 1913 Georgi Konstantinovikj, Dimitrija Chupovski, Natse Dimov and Aleksandar Vezenkov, representatives of the Macedonian colony in St. Petersburg, signed a memorandum demanding independence for Macedonia and sent it to Edward Grey, Foreign Minister of Great Britain, as well as to the ambassadors of the Great Powers in London. Unfortunately the Great Powers were not interested and, in the absence of the Macedonian people, sanctioned Macedonia’s division.



As has been shown in this and previous chapters, the Balkan Wars were not about liberation but about land grabs resulting in the occupation and division of Macedonia. During the two year Balkan Wars duration, Macedonia was partitioned three different times by three different divisions. The first, as agreed by the March 13th, 1912 Serbian-Bulgarian Treaty called for the Deve Bair–Ohrid line to be drawn. The second division took place after the First Balkan War when a border was proposed to coincide with the frontlines. The third division took place on August 10th, 1913 after the Treaty of Bucharest was signed.



The only standards used to determine these borders, in all three cases, were force of arms, lies and deceit.



Instead of liberating it, the 1913 Bucharest Treaty enslaved Macedonia and turned it into provinces of the belligerent Balkan states which wasted no time in forcefully denationalizing and assimilating the Macedonian population.
 
Not another big lie

Not another big lie

Not another BIG Greek Lie?



Despite what some may think, there will never be a solution to the problems with Modern Greece because the mere existence of Macedonians and an independent Macedonian state negate and contradict the very foundations on which the Modern Greek state and Modern 'Greek' ethnicity were built. Modern Greece was created from an ethnically diverse population assimilated either willingly or by force under 'Neo-Hellenism', or the false belief that they are all 'directly' descended from the ancient Hellenes.

Any recognition of a Macedonian ethnicity by Modern Greece would be de facto recognition of the Macedonians within the borders of the modern Greece state. This poses a threat to the Modern 'Greek' identity as established under 'Neo-Hellenism', as the Moderns 'Greeks' are ALL supposed to be 'directly descended' from the ancient Hellenes. If the Macedonians in Modern Greece aren't 'Greek' or 'directly' descended from the ancient Hellenes...then what other groups within Modern Greek society happen to be Non-Greek as well. These kinds of uncomfortable questions threaten to expose the policy of 'Neo-Hellenism' to be nothing more then a lie, to which Modern 'Greeks' fear would ultimately lead to the unraveling of the Modern Greek state. The Modern 'Greeks' therefore have two choices;

1 - Abandon the policy of 'Neo-Hellenism' and rediscover their true ethnic origins, or...

2 - Do everything in their power to erase the existence of a Macedonian ethnicity.

It is therefore clear what choice the Modern 'Greeks' have made. Modern 'Greeks' will NEVER recognize the existence of a Macedonian ethnicity and will do everything in their power to negate and erase the existence of Macedonia and Macedonians.

For this reason all diplomatic discussions with Modern Greece are pointless and must end NOW!!!



By Napoleon
 
Precisely anything to come out is a compromise to trick macedonia to beleive will lead to entry to nato or eu.So the discussions should end asap.
 
Hey eddie i can't read your alexander thing how do you blow it upthe TEXT?.Also you should mention
what you are discussing in the thread rather just having a link by itself.Another member tried to have a link with no explanation & admin went at them for doing it.
I have looked at the rest briefly & it looks pretty interesting keep it up.
 
Last edited:
Getting to know thy Greece

Getting to know thy Greece

Getting to know thy Greece



By Risto Stefov

rstefov@hotmail.com

January 9, 2011



One of the obstacles I was faced with in the past was convincing people that things are not right in Greece, especially when it came to human rights. Even the people who were willing to lend an ear found it difficult to believe what I had told them. How could one people be so cruel towards another in a peace loving, democratic country such as Greece? That is impossible! People in modern democratic countries don’t behave this way in this day and age? I am certain many felt that perhaps there was something wrong with me. Although no one, besides the Greeks themselves, ever told me that they didn’t believe me, I had the feeling that it was going to be a rough road to travel. Fortunately for me I didn’t have to do a lot of convincing. Greece did all that for me, first when it went out of its way to make life difficult for the Macedonians in the Republic of Macedonia by refusing to recognize them as Macedonians and their country as Macedonia and then by the way it got itself into its current economic crisis.



Just a while ago one of my readers pointed me to an eye opening article which I found both informative and enlightening regarding “Greek behaviour” but from a different angle. The twenty page article, which I sent to all my readers, was a bit lengthy but captured the essence of “Greek” very well, the way my recent ancestors had it described. Written by Michael Lewis, the article entitled “Beware of Greeks Bearing Bonds” can still be found this link:

http://www.vanityfair.com/business/features/2010/10/greeks-bearing-bonds-201010?currentPage=all



In short here are some of Michael Lewis’s highlights:



“In addition to its roughly $400 billion (and growing) of outstanding government debt, the Greek number crunchers had just figured out that their government owed another $800 billion or more in pensions. Add it all up and you got about $1.2 trillion, or more than a quarter-million dollars for every working Greek.”



“Our people went in and couldn’t believe what they found,” a senior I.M.F. official told me, not long after he’d returned from the I.M.F.’s first Greek mission. “The way they were keeping track of their finances—they knew how much they had agreed to spend, but no one was keeping track of what he had actually spent. It wasn’t even what you would call an emerging economy. It was a Third World country.”



“As it turned out, what the Greeks wanted to do, once the lights went out and they were alone in the dark with a pile of borrowed money, was turn their government into a piñata stuffed with fantastic sums and give as many citizens as possible a whack at it.”





“The average government job pays almost three times the average private-sector job. The national railroad has annual revenues of 100 million euros against an annual wage bill of 400 million, plus 300 million euros in other expenses. The average state railroad employee earns 65,000 euros a year.”



“The Greek public-school system is the site of breathtaking inefficiency: one of the lowest-ranked systems in Europe, it nonetheless employs four times as many teachers per pupil as the highest-ranked, Finland’s.”



“There are three government-owned defense companies: together they have billions of euros in debts, and mounting losses.”



“The retirement age for Greek jobs classified as “arduous” is as early as 55 for men and 50 for women. As this is also the moment when the state begins to shovel out generous pensions, more than 600 Greek professions somehow managed to get themselves classified as arduous: hairdressers, radio announcers, waiters, musicians, and on and on and on.”



“The Greek public health-care system spends far more on supplies than the European average—and it is not uncommon, several Greeks tell me, to see nurses and doctors leaving the job with their arms filled with paper towels and diapers and whatever else they can plunder from the supply closets.”



“The Greek people never learned to pay their taxes .... because no one is ever punished.”



“Where waste ends and theft begins almost doesn’t matter; the one masks and thus enables the other. It’s simply assumed, for instance, that anyone who is working for the government is meant to be bribed.”



“People who go to public health clinics assume they will need to bribe doctors to actually take care of them. Government ministers who have spent their lives in public service emerge from office able to afford multi-million-dollar mansions and two or three country homes.”



“The biggest problem the banks had was that they had lent roughly 30 billion euros to the Greek government—where it was stolen or squandered. In Greece the banks didn’t sink the country. The country sank the banks.”



“In 2001, Greece entered the European Monetary Union, swapped the drachma for the euro, and acquired for its debt an implicit European (read German) guarantee. Greeks could now borrow long-term funds at roughly the same rate as Germans—not 18 percent but 5 percent. To remain in the euro zone, they were meant, in theory, to maintain budget deficits below 3 percent of G.D.P.; in practice, all they had to do was cook the books to show that they were hitting the targets. Here, in 2001, entered Goldman Sachs, which engaged in a series of apparently legal but nonetheless repellent deals designed to hide the Greek government’s true level of indebtedness. For these trades Goldman Sachs—which, in effect, handed Greece a $1 billion loan—carved out a reported $300 million in fees. The machine that enabled Greece to borrow and spend at will was analogous to the machine created to launder the credit of the American sub-prime borrower—and the role of the American investment banker in the machine was the same. The investment bankers also taught the Greek-government officials how to securitize future receipts from the national lottery, highway tolls, airport landing fees, and even funds granted to the country by the European Union. Any future stream of income that could be identified was sold for cash up front, and spent. As anyone with a brain must have known, the Greeks would be able to disguise their true financial state for only as long as (a) lenders assumed that a loan to Greece was as good as guaranteed by the European Union (read Germany), and (b) no one outside of Greece paid very much attention. Inside Greece there was no market for whistle-blowing, as basically everyone was in on the racket.”



And there you have it. This not only verifies but validates the saying “Greek=Thief” as the Macedonian old timers back in Greek occupied Macedonian used to say!



By the fact that some European countries were willing to lend other European countries money to build their economies and improve their peoples’ lives was a genuine gesture of goodwill on the part of the lending countries. But how did the recipient countries of this goodwill deal with this gesture? Just take a look at Greece, Europe’s favourite child!



What is happening in Europe is no different from what happens to basically every person in this brave new world of ours. People borrow money from the banks to build a business, family and home knowing very well that they will have to pay it back and with interest. It is no different for countries than it is for individuals. The idea of the lending European countries was to lend the poorer countries some money for a period of say ten years where this money could be put to good use to improve the country’s ability to work in a market economy with a proper supporting structure. The idea was that now the poorer country would develop itself economically, not only to pay back the loan and interest but to be able to properly function and prosper from the ten year period forward. So where did Greece and the others go wrong?



I guess the modern Euro-eggheads forgot to include the “Greek=Thief” variable into their lending formula when they handed Greece their taxpayers’ money. It seems our great grandfathers were wise to teach us “Greek=Thief” but have we really learned anything from them? If we have we would not be negotiating, with the “Greek=Thief”, our country’s name for which many of our ancestors fought and died to protect. Even after re-learning all this about the “Greek=Thief”, are we that naïve or is there another reason for these negotiations?



Allow me to let you in on a couple of rumours. There are those who believe that the 1913 Treaty of Bucharest is about to expire in 2013 and as it was decided, when the Treaty was drafted under a secret clause, if any of the three parts of divided Macedonia becomes independent before 2013, all three parts will become independent and Macedonia will become united again. And there are those who believe that the United States had had enough of Greece, as it did of Yugoslavia, and will use the so-called “name dispute” to bring Greece down. It has been foretold (since the 1970’s by Henry Kissinger) that Greece will be cut to pieces. It’s a matter of when!



This may be wishful thinking on the part of those who have faith in others to solve our problems but be it as it may, I thing Greece will come apart on its own because of its own cleverness!



Now that we all think we know Greece a bit better, here is something more that we can learn:



AJC Calls on Greek Orthodox Church to Condemn Priest’s Anti-Semitic Libels



http://www.ajc.org/site/apps/nlnet/content2.aspx?c=ijITI2PHKoG&b=2818289&ct=8980321&notoc=1



December 22, 2010 -- New York -- AJC is calling on the head of the Greek Orthodox Church in Greece, Archbishop Ieronymos II, as well as Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew, to condemn unequivocally the blatant anti-Semitic libels expressed by Metropolitan Seraphim of Piraeus, one of the church’s highest officials.



"Metropolitan Seraphim's horrendous lies on Greek TV demonstrate that anti-Semitism is alive and well within the Greek Orthodox Church,” said Rabbi David Rosen, AJC's International Director of Inter-religious Affairs. “It is the responsibility of the church leadership to condemn and uproot anti-Semitism.”



Metropolitan Seraphim’s comments came during an interview on the morning show of the largest Greek TV station.



“Adolf Hitler was an instrument of world Zionism and was financed from the renowned Rothschild family with the sole purpose of convincing the Jews to leave the shores of Europe and go to Israel to establish the new Empire,” said Seraphim. He also charged that Jews such as "Rockefeller, Rothschild and Soros control the international banking system that controls globalization.”



Rabbi Rosen said, “Jews worldwide had hoped that this kind of outrageous bigotry, which in the past was sustained and nurtured by the Christian world, had been consigned by the Church to the dustbin of history.”



AJC, the premier global advocacy organization, has long maintained close relations with the Greek government and Jewish community, and is a pioneer worldwide in building inter-religious understanding.



And this man is God’s representative on earth?



And finally this:



6 in 10 Greeks don't pay income taxes
By Katy Byron, CNN
December 31, 2010 1:30 p.m. EST



Athens, Greece (CNN) -- More than 5 million Greeks did not pay income taxes for 2008, according to public documents released by the struggling nation's finance ministry.

More than six in 10 taxpayers earn less than 12,000 euros per year and are not required to pay income taxes under the Greek tax system, the press office of the Greek Ministry of Finance said Thursday.

However, there is wide speculation that many Greeks are not accurately reporting their income.


To read more click on this link:



http://www.cnn.com/2010/WORLD/europe/12 ... es/?hpt=T2

:6::6::tank::21::2guns:
 
Hey eddie i can't read your alexander thing how do you blow it upthe TEXT?.

Hmmm I don't know. Maybe you don't have cyrilic support on your PC. I'll check with others. Thanks for the info.

Also you should mention
what you are discussing in the thread rather just having a link by itself.Another member tried to have a link with no explanation & admin went at them for doing it.
I have looked at the rest briefly & it looks pretty interesting keep it up.

Thanks

This thread is for ebooks. The thread for patriotic art is full of pictures without much words, It is expected this to be full with links (of eBooks).

The situation is the same on every forum I am in (Kajgana, Milenko...), don't know why this would be a problem here ???
 
Who are the Greeks - a Macedonian Perspective

Who are the Greeks - a Macedonian Perspective

Who are the Greeks - a Macedonian Perspective



By Risto Stefov

rstefov@hotmail.com

January 16, 2011



Some of you have asked me to write about the Modern Greeks and what they really think of themselves and their neighbours; a subject which I have often touched on but have never fully delved into.



I would have to say that, as a general rule, it is none of my business to gossip about people unless of course they give me reason to. Believe me the Greeks have given me plenty of reasons to not only to analyze them forwards and backwards without feeling guilty, but to talk about them as I see fit. In fact I would go as far as saying, “It is imperative to know thy Greeks as seen through the eyes of at least one Macedonian!”



Like every other people in the world, typical Greeks fall into a number of categories; but the only categories of interest to me are those who interfere in the affairs of the Macedonian people. These Greeks fall into two distinct categories, the clueless and the ones leading the clueless.



I used to think that every Greek out there knew the truth, especially about themselves, and “stood their ground” because of “self interest and self preservation”. But with time I have discovered that it is not always the case. Yes it is true that there are many Greeks who know their own true narrative but because of “self interest” have chosen to defend their mythical narrative; an alternate reality which puts them at an advantage over others, but which unfortunately comes into collision with the Macedonian narrative.



In order for these Greeks to convince themselves that what they are doing is right they need to convince the rest of the Greeks to follow them in their quest. For example there are many Greeks today who know they are not Greeks of the type that are direct descendants from the ancient Greeks from 2,600 years ago, but are more like Greeks by circumstance who became Greeks by force when they were brought to Greece from Asia Minor or from the Caucasus to colonize Macedonia. Or they were Albanians or Vlachs gripped by the chokehold of 19th century nationalism which turned them into Greeks. In any case, it is irrelevant how these people became Greeks, but the fact that they are in an ideal position in Greek society today gives them ample reasons to defend their “assumed” position by defending the status quo i.e. that they are Greeks who descended from the ancient Greeks or more lately, they are Greeks who descended from the ancient Macedonians.



And of course they have their followers, the clueless Greeks who believe everything they tell them. How does one recognize a clueless Greek? By the way they react to new information.



Just recently I received the following “typical” e-mail from a Greek:





WRITING THESE ARTICLES PROVES YOU ARE INFERIOR, YOU CAN'T COME UP WITH ANYTHING ELSE YOUR JUST DOWN A BARBARION WHO IS DAMN JEALOUS LOL‏



TO RSTEFOV@GMAIL

THE WHOLE WORLD KNOWS THE TRUTH, BUT WHO EVER HATES THE GREEKS TRIES TO STEAL HISTORY OR DENIE THE TRUTH OR TRIES TO OFFEND THEM ALL ARE JUST PLAIN IGNORANT FOOLS. THE TRUTH SHALL BE REVEALED, IT CANNOT HIDE FOR LONG NO MATTER HOW ONE TRIES TO CHANGE THINGS AROUND.

WE HAVE THE PROOF ALL OVER THE WORLD. ENVIOUS PEOPLE WILL TRY TO SHUT PEOPLE'S MOUTHS, BUT THE ROCKS TALK LOUDER IF YOU DON'T UNDERSTAND THE MEANING OF THIS, THEN YOUR PROVING YOU ARE A BARBARIAN WHO CANNOT READ!!!!! SO IF YOUR PEOPLE CANNOT READ AND UNDERSTAND BETWEEN THE LINES THEY PROVE THEY ARE JUST BABBARIANS WITHOUT US GREEKS ARGUING WITH THEM!!!!!

THEY ARE SO JEALOUS, THEY HAVE TO MAKE UP THESE TYPE OF ARTICLES. THEY ARE THE LOWEST OF THE LOW THAT IS WHY THEY ENVY US. THEY KNOW THEY ARE INFERIOR


Well, where do I begin?



To some degree we are all drones and believe what we are taught or told by the authorities. Why else did we all believe at one point in time that the earth was flat? Yes it is true; the entire world at one point in time knew for a fact that the earth was flat! It knew the truth about the earth being flat just like the entire world today knows the truth about the Greeks being the descendants of the ancient Greeks!



It was okay to make such claims when there was no evidence to show different. But what about after it had been discovered that the earth was not flat? How should people have reacted? Should they have continued to believe the earth was flat in spite of the evidence showing that it wasn’t?



Similarly, when no one opposed the “Greek claim” that “Macedonians do not exist” it was believed to be true! More recently however it was proven that “Macedonians do exist”, I am a living example of that. No only do they exist all over the world but Macedonians today have their own country! So what is “the truth” in this case? Do Macedonians exist, as the evidence points out, or do they NOT exist as Greeks like to claim?



How about examining the Greek claim that the “Modern Greeks are the descendents of the ancient Greeks”. What evidence have the Modern Greeks presented to prove this claim? More importantly, what evidence have the Greeks neglected in an attempt to prove this claim? When one examines all “the facts” it is easy to find the truth. It is a far fetched claim to insist that “the Modern Greeks are the descendents of the ancient Greeks” when evidence points to “the Modern Greeks being the descendents of the 19th century Albanians, Vlachs and of the 20th century Macedonians”.



There is far more evidence that points to the modern Greeks being the descendents of the Albanians, Vlachs and Macedonians than there is that points to the Modern Greeks being the descendants of the ancient Greeks of 2,600 years ago. I am not saying this because I hate the Greeks and because I am jealous of them. I am saying this because evidence points in that direction!



But again there are many, many clueless Greeks out there who insist that “this is all wrong” and only the enemies of the Greeks would make such absurd claims and that there is some sort of “information” out there that when it comes out will prove that things are different!



Unfortunately, for the clueless Greeks, there is no “such”, “more” or “other” information out there that will justify the lies perpetrated by Greek authorities over the last 200 years. If anything does come out it will be more lies to cover up previous lies or to “disclaim” newly uncovered information. A good example of this is Greece’s stand on the Macedonian question claiming that “Macedonians do not exist”. When the Republic of Macedonia was about to emerge, all of a sudden all sorts of Macedonians were living in Greece! Even the imported Christian Turkish colonists settled in Greek occupied Macedonia in the 1920’s overnight became “Macedonians” and on top of that, they claimed to be the “descendents of the ancient Macedonians from 2,300 years ago! All this by magic no less! And after decades of saying that “Macedonians do not exist”, what reason did the Greeks have to “invent” these “new” Macedonians of the Greek kind? I will leave this one for you to figure out!



If these clueless Greeks care to open their eyes they will find the truth, not in any books or in my articles but on the very land they today call Greece. Examine the people from generations back, before Greece became a country for the first time in 1829, and see what language they spoke, what customs and traditions they followed, etc. Look at the geographical names of the land, the villages, towns, cities, lakes, rivers, regions and see what they were called before Greece changed them. If all these people were Greeks, descendants from the ancient Greeks and all these lands were Greek then what reason did the Greek authorities to have to change them? What about the people living in Greece who today speak “Arvanitika”, “Vlahika” and “Makethonika”, are they also descendents of the ancient Greeks? How did they come about to speak those languages if all Greeks of all generations were Greek since 2,600 ago? Are those languages dialects of the ancient Greeks?



I know some people will argue that language has little to do with descent but then again how did those languages appear in a region where they don’t belong, in a region, which according to Modern Greeks, has always been Greek, where the Greek language has always been spoken? If Modern Greeks are the descendents of the ancient Greeks then they must have always been Greeks and spoke the Greek language without interruption.



Aside from that it is well known that throughout history, since Philip II’s time, the entire Balkans existed borderless until the 1800’s and were invaded and occupied by at least the Ancient Macedonians, the Romans, the Byzantines and the Ottomans for no less 2,300 years. What happened to the “purity” of the Greek race during that time?



What about the number of times over the years that Greece, particularly the Peloponnesus, the heart of Greece, was settled by Slavs, Albanians, Vlachs, Latins and so on? What happened to these people? Were they “Hellenized”? And if they were, how does that make them “the descendents of the ancient Greeks”?



And then we have the 20th century 1,000,000 Christian Turkish colonists who were brought to Greece from Asia Minor and the Caucasus, where they Greeks too, descendents from the ancient Greeks?



I think there is a huge gap, the size of the Grand Canyon, between what the “truth” is and what the Greeks claim “the truth” to be. This is particularly true in the “Greek thinking” between their claim that “Macedonians do not exist” and their claim that they themselves are “the descendants from the ancient Greeks”.



Instead of thinking that there is some sort of conspiracy on my part and on the part of people like myself, why not examine the evidence for yourselves and reach your own conclusion about what is “truth” and what is “myth”! If you really think that you are the “superior” people you claim to be, surely then you should be able to separate fact from fiction and discover the truth for yourselves! And please don’t forget to tell me what it is!
 
Where did we lose our country? - Introduction

Where did we lose our country? - Introduction

Where did we lose our country? - Introduction



By Risto Stefov

rstefov@hotmail.com

January 23, 2011





Klaudija, one of my readers wrote:



Dear Risto,



I don’t want to pull you away from your current writing, you have done a lot for the Macedonian cause, but I do want to suggest to you something more. The most painful segment of Macedonia’s history has been “the loss of our country and our sovereignty, a fate which we all have to live with to this day”. “Where did we go wrong?”



I also would like you and your readers to have a look at my blog and videos found at this link:



http://forum.kajgana.com/showthread...-извори-за-Македонците!&p=4006692#post4006692



Regards, Klaudija

Dear Klaudija, I know I haven’t written much about this because it has been a struggle for me as well for several reasons. For starters, there has always been a Macedonia since ancient times, recreating it as a modern state should not have been a difficult task. So why did it not happen?



The Macedonian people were not only aware of the name Macedonia but have always had an historic connection to it. Macedonia and its past glory have always existed and will continue to exist in the narrative of the Macedonian people. Also, the Macedonian people, unlike any of the other people in the Balkans, were a nation with a large majority having a well developed Macedonian national consciousness before they had a country. Looking at this from another angle, there are many reasons why the Macedonian people should have had their own country a long time ago. Yet it did not happen! Why not? And you are right, as long as this subject remains a mystery, our history will be incomplete. And worse, as long as we are not aware of our past mistakes, we are bound to repeat them!



So as a nation of people where did we go wrong and what could we have done differently to change the outcome?



Before I get to the details of examining the historic crossroads that faced our ancestors in their quest to free themselves and to create their own country, I would like to make a few comments about where I see us standing today.



One of the mistakes we are making today is that, instead of having our own strategy, we seem to be reacting to “issues”, real or perceived, brought to us by others.



For example, we seem to be comfortable with the idea of calling some of our Macedonian territories a “Greek province” because others called it that. We know very well how Greece obtained those Macedonian territories but so far we have not made any effort to reveal that fact, either officially or publicly.



Instead of agreeing that these Macedonian territories are a “Greek province ‘also’ called Macedonia” because others call them that, we should have our own strategy and should be calling them officially and publicly “Greek occupied Macedonia” because no matter how we look at it, from our point of view, that is exactly what they are!



By not objecting to the fact that others, including Greece, recognize an illegitimate “Greek province ‘also’ called Macedonia” we give credence and support not only to Greece occupying these Macedonian territories but also the right of Greece to challenge the legitimacy of the Republic of Macedonia.



Let us take a few historic steps backwards and examine what “really” happened in the years following the dawn of the 20th century. Let us publicly and officially show the world “how and when Macedonia became Greek”.



Have we forgotten how Greece came to possess the so-called “Greek province ‘also’ called Macedonia”? Isn’t that the same Macedonian territory that was illegally invaded, occupied and partitioned by Greece, Serbia and Bulgaria during the two Balkan Wars of 1912, 1913? Isn’t that the 51% of Macedonia that was awarded to Greece by the Great Powers by the 1913 Treaty of Bucharest? Isn’t that the very same Macedonia that our Macedonian ancestors fought to liberate in 1903, only ten years before the Greeks, Serbians and Bulgarians brutally snatched it right out of our hands? Why have we not made these facts officially and publicly known?



The fact is that the so-called “Greek province ‘also’ called Macedonia” belongs to the Macedonian people and not to Greece. Greece’s legitimacy to the possession of these lands should have been challenged the moment Greece declared that “Macedonia was Greek” and when Greece officially and publicly, through every medium, announced to the world that the Republic of Macedonia had “territorial pretensions” against a Greek territory also called Macedonia. Right then and there Greece had the door wide open for things to be sorted out, with historical facts, as to whom Macedonia belongs! But instead of explaining to the world how “Macedonia became Greek”, in spite of the Ilinden 1903 Uprising, the Macedonian side decided to back down, allowing Greece to not only keep the Macedonian territories it illegally annexed in 1913 but gave Greece the go ahead to challenge the legitimacy of the Republic of Macedonia! The Macedonian government even made changes to the Macedonian constitution declaring that it does not have “territorial pretensions” towards its own peoples’ territories. And we the Macedonian people accepted all that without question and without a single note of protest! And today we wonder why Greece is interfering in our affairs and demanding that we change the God given name of our fatherland? Do we not see what is happening here?



Even if we did not have the power to do anything about reclaiming our Macedonian territories when Greece opened that door for us, we could have at least officially and publicly, for the record, told our side of the story. We owed it to those who fought, spilled their blood and died to free Macedonia so that we could have a better future! But we didn’t even do that!



Today many Macedonians stand against the so-called “name negotiations” between Macedonia and Greece with good reason. But the authorities in Skopje continue to knuckle down to Greek and external demands to continue to negotiate, risking not only what our ancestors fought for and lost in the past but what we already hold in our hands; the future of the entire Macedonian nation! This mistake can be easily remedied by the Macedonian side pulling away from these so-called “name negotiations”!



When Greeks made the claim that the “Modern Greeks are the descendents of the ancient Greeks” and at the same time made adamant claims that “Macedonians do not exist” they not only opened the door for debate but gave the Macedonian side the perfect opportunity to challenge the Greeks on both claims!



When the Greeks said “Macedonians do not exist” we should have reacted with a counter claim saying that “the Modern Greeks are not the descendents of the ancient Greeks” and here is why! Those who today call themselves “Greeks” did not exist as “Greeks” before the Greek state was artificially created by the Philhellenes in the early 1800’s. In fact it is more accurate to call these people “Albanians’, “Vlachs”, “Latins”, “Turks”, “Macedonians” and so on than to call them “Greeks, descendents of the ancient Greeks”.



Unlike the Macedonians who were a nation before they had a country, there was no “Greek nation” before there was a Greek state. In other words, the Greek nation was artificially constructed to fit the country that was created for it by the Philhellenes. The people that made up the so-called “Greek nation” were assimilated Albanians, Vlachs, Turks, Macedonians and others who happened to live in that region. Therefore it is more accurate to say that the “Modern Greeks” are the descendents of the 19th century Albanians, Vlachs, Turks and 20th century Macedonians than it is to say that they are the descendents of the ancient Greeks from 2,600 years ago!



Why haven’t we uncovered these “historical facts” with dates, names and places that prove that the majority of “Modern Greeks” today are not only the descendents of Albanians and Vlachs, but that their ancestors were not even indigenous to Greece. Why haven’t we shown the world that most of today’s Modern Greeks are the descendents of Albanian and Vlach immigrants who colonized the southern part of Greece between the 11th and 13th centuries AD. These are not myths but historical facts readily available to everyone. What has the Macedonian side done officially and publicly to prove that it is the “Greeks” who do not exist and are not who they claim to be: not the Macedonians? So far they have done nothing!



Even though it can easily be proven that the Modern Greeks of today are not the descendents of the ancient Greeks, no Macedonian in authority, to this day, has challenged that assertion. Even in view of the fact that Greeks have officially denied the existence of the Macedonians, for many decades now, the Macedonian side has done nothing to challenge the Greeks. Are we incapable or do we simply not care?



By denying our existence Greece has opened the doors and has given us a chance to challenge it once and for all about its own existence. Yet no Macedonian in authority has accepted that challenge! Why not?



I believe that all of our current problems stem from our inability to stand up to Greece and to all those who deny our name, our human rights and our right to exist!



It is our country and our identity that is at stake here and we cannot afford to enter into negotiations and accept deals that are harmful to us and to our future.



It should be obvious to everyone by now that no matter how much we “compromise”, it will never be enough to please Greece. Historically we were forced to compromise when Macedonia was invaded, occupied and partitioned against our wishes in 1912, 1913. We were forced to compromise when our new occupiers took our lands, exiled, or assimilated us and erased our identity and language. We were forced to compromise when our names were changed and we were given Greek names against our will. We were forced to compromise when colonists were settled on our lands against our wishes. We were given no choice when we were forced to accept all these compromises. But today we have a choice and our choice must be “no more compromises”.



How many people in the world do you think know of the many “compromises” Macedonians were forced to make in the past? I would bet that not many know! Why is that?



How many Macedonians do you think know of our past “compromises”, that we as a people were forced to make? Here too I would hazard to guess that not too many know! Why is that?



Many painful “compromises” have already been made and still our neighbours to the south are not “pleased”! So ask yourselves “how many more compromises must we make to satisfy the Greeks?”



Take it from me; the only thing that will satisfy the Greeks is to see us become extinct! If nothing but our extinction can satisfy the Greeks, why then are we “negotiating” with them? Why then are we giving them the time of day?



We are in the right, yet we act as if we are in the wrong! Why is that?



Perhaps it was not the right time to stand up to our enemies, as so many of you have reminded me in the past, but then when is the right time? And what will our enemies do if we truly stand up to them and officially and publicly tell our side of the story, the way we experienced it? Will they hate us any more? Can they do us any more harm than wish for our extinction? What more harm can they do to us? Start a war: like the one Milosevic waged in Yugoslavia? If that were possible Greece would have already done it!



Is it not obvious to everyone what the Greeks are doing? They want us to disappear from the face of the earth. That will solve many of their problems but they can no longer do it by force so they are attempting to do by bribes and blackmail. Why are we letting them? In fact why are we letting them lead us and run us around in circles? It is up to us to say “NO” to “negotiating” with them, especially about the name of our fatherland”! It is up to us to say “NO MORE COMPROMISES”! It is within our right to say “NO”!



In fact, it is our duty to take a step even further and bring these people to justice! The least we can do is officially and publicly let the world know what they have done to us. Let the world know of the past compromises they already forced us to make and demand an end to any further “compromises”!



To be continued.
 
In fact, it is our duty to take a step even further and bring these people to justice! The least we can do is officially and publicly let the world know what they have done to us. Let the world know of the past compromises they already forced us to make and demand an end to any further “compromises”!
I would take it even an additional step further and say that the former compromises were unjust and illegal, and that they should be overturned at the soonest possible opportunity. The Macedonian state name, flag and constitution need to be reverted to their true forms, and then, let's talk as equals.
 
Well said SOM perhaps that might be in the next installment but that just about sums it up
there are past injustices done & must be acknowledged & past wrongs need to be acknowleged not to mention restitution is needed.
 
Klaudija said:
Instead of agreeing that these Macedonian territories are a “Greek province ‘also’ called Macedonia” because others call them that, we should have our own strategy and should be calling them officially and publicly “Greek occupied Macedonia” because no matter how we look at it, from our point of view, that is exactly what they are!

Gruevski is giving the Greek lie all the international publicity it could ever hope for. I might add that Gruevski is the one meddling and interfering with our historical and political identity here, no one else. We have been badly exposed, and continue to be. There has not been a single occasion to date where the Macedonian government has taken a principled defence of our historical rights, in an official and public capacity. Gruevski's "silence" on a thousand lies and a thousand different issues has been defeaning. On that basis alone, the so called 'negotiations' must end immediately.

Great article.
 
Back
Top