• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

Risto Stefov - Articles, Translations & Collaborations

RTG From greece's point of view Slavophone,Bulgarophone,serbophone these are terminologies to apply to macedonians whom they considered to be less than they thought.When it talked about macedonians that's how they spoke of them,

Here is Report 1
Balkan States – Report 1
December 11, 1944

Mr. Leeper to Mr. Eden
Athens 24th November, 1944

Sir,

I HAVE the honour to submit the following comments on Research Department paper of the 26th August, 1944, on the subject of Macedonia. (1)

2. The two formidable Macedonian problems in which Greece is concerned are: (a) that of Greek relations with the Slav world as represented by Serbia and Bulgaria, both of whom must be expected in the immediate future to be under strong Russian influence and to have Russian sympathy for their aspirations; and b) that of the surviving Bulgarophone minority in Western Macedonia.

3. The former problem turns chiefly on that of Serbian and Bulgarian access to the Aegean, the subject discussed in paragraphs 35-40 and 41-43 of the paper under reference. There is clearly no case (or handing over to Slav Powers any part of the North Aegean coast, which in 1940 had nowhere anything but an infinitesimal minority of Slav inhabitants. On the other hand, the strategic position of Greece here, even with Turkish backing, is very weak, vis-à-vis the Slav world, so that even in her own interests it behooves Greece to come to terms with her northern neighbours. The only possible solution-however difficult in practice under present conditions-seems to be that referred to in paragraph 51, namely, a return to, and preferably an extension of, the system of free zones. A Serbian free zone at Salonica is not difficult, but a Bulgarian zone at Kavala, or even at the outlying Alexandrupolis, would probably be out of the question for a considerable period to come, in view of the passions aroused by the atrocious conduct of the Bulgarians in Northern Greece since 1941. It remains, nevertheless, a Greek no less than a Bulgarian interest that Bulgaria's desire for access to an Aegean port should be satisfied so far as possible; since otherwise Bulgaria's southward political aspiration, which are now largely artificial, will be kept alive by the real and continual irritation of an unsatisfied economic need. (How far this need might be met by the alternative of a free zone at Durazzo is a matter for separate study.) It may further be pointed out that the grant of free zones at her northern ports would, in fact, be of direct financial benefit to Greece herself through the revivifying influence of increased trade on the life of those ports in general and through the restoration of a natural degree of intercourse between these Greek ports and their Slav hinterland.

4. The problem of the Western Macedonian Bulgarophones, who are briefly mentioned in paragraph 7 of the paper, also remains serious and formidable, in spite of its limited dimensions. This minority, which extends through the region from Florina and Kastoria through Siatista to the plain of Yannitsa, has proved exceedingly unreliable during the war. Satisfactory data are not available, but it appears from events during the occupation that the dissatisfied minority must be considerably larger than is suggested by Greek census figures; and it is certain that successive Greek Governments have shirked facing the problem and have preferred to persuade even themselves that it did not exist. On the assumptions (1) that the policy of His Majesty’s Government is to treat Greece as the most important Balkan country from the point of view of British interests, and to support those elements in Greece which are most stably pro-British and (2) that Greece does not wish to belong to a Balkan Federation in which there would be a large Slav majority, it would appear to follow that Greece had better not contain any Slav minorities at all. And since the amputation of the Slav areas in Western Macedonia and their annexation to a Slav Federation is a practical impossibility and would also be economically disastrous for Greece. It would follow that, difficult as it may be, a home must be found for perhaps 120,000 Slav Macedonians north of the Greek frontiers of 1941.

5. I have sent copies of this dispatch to the Resident Minister at Caserta, to Mr. Houstoun-Boswall at Sofia and to Mr. Broad at Bari.

I have, &c. R. A. Leeper.

(1) See “Balkan States” print section, 26th August, Section 6.

A Statement of the Bulgarian Idea of Unification as the Motive of Bulgarian Foreign and Internal Policy

April 5, 1944

No. 2782 (R-2585)
American Consulate General, Istanbul, Turkey

SUBJECT: A Statement of the Bulgarian Idea of Unification as the Motive of Bulgarian Foreign and Internal Policy

Sir:

I have the honor to present below a leading article from the Bulgarian newspaper ZORA of March 28, 1944, in which Mr. N. Kolarov, Editor of the Macedonian newspaper TSELOKUPNA BULGARIA, gives his view of the fundamental significance of the idea of unification in relation to Bulgarian foreign and internal policy.

The writer reviews the development of the movement in Bulgaria inspired by the idea of national unification in the nineteenth century, especially as it came to a head in the church settlement of 1870--which achieved the setting up of the Bulgarian Exarchate in Constantinople- and the Treaties of San Stefano and Berlin in 1878. He also refers to the long continued struggle that has been carried on in Bulgaria since the Treaty of San Stefano. Ethnographically the writer lays primary emphasis upon the areas of Bulgarian habitation as indicated in the delimitation of the territorial limits of the exarchate and the limits of the Treaty of San Stefano.

The writer sets forth no new ideas on this subject. The article merely emphasizes the fact that the idea of unification has been a powerful force working through the whole period of Bulgarian modern history and never more powerfully than today.

For the student of Balkan affairs the article is important in that it is another reminder of the fact that this powerful well organized movement and this profound sentiment must be taken fully into account in the settlement of the Balkan problem at the close of this war. As long as great numbers of Bulgarians live outside the frontiers of their country this struggle unification will go on, -for the Bulgarians are a determined and resourceful people in waging this kind of struggle. The aspiration for national self-determination and unification was in thorough accord with democratic sentiment in the nineteenth century, when it was born. The idea of unification was quite natural and commendable. The heroism of the people primarily concerned in carrying on the struggle, especially in Macedonia, for relief from the terrible conditions under which they lived was heroic. The literature which originated in the struggle is a fundamental part of Bulgarian literature and a part of the education of all the youth of country. Hence the ideal will not die.

The fatal element in connection with the whole movement, and that which has caused it to be wrecked in the twentieth century, was the unwise political methods adopted for its achievement, and the uncompromising attitude of those leaders in charge of national interests at critical moments, primarily in the spring and summer of 1913. In the bitter enmities and struggles between the Balkan states Bulgaria gave her enemies the opportunity of getting the drop on her, an opportunity which they were not slow to take advantage of; and so by her own lack of wisdom and political skill she wrecked the edifice which had been built up by so much suffering and bloodshed. The continuation in 1941 and since of this policy of political short-sightedness seems again destined to leave Bulgaria naked to her enemies; and to her natural enemies she has deliberately added Great Britain and the United states.

The writer of the article presented below, Mr. Kolarev, does not seem to be aware of the critical conditions which his country faces at this moment, for he writes of successful resistance to enemies without seeming to know that the forces gradually being built against his country are irresistible. He would do better, therefore, to devote his energies to devising by political skill some new alignment for his country that might save something from impending wreckage of Bulgaria's long cherished hopes.

The article shows how the most intransigent Bulgarians are still thinking and writing in this the eleventh of hour of the war in the Balkans. In free translation this article reads as follows:

In the Spirit of the Idea of Unification

By N. Kolarov

"Even for the first leaders of our renaissance, for whom the frontiers of Bulgaria were clearly defined, the unification idea, that is, the idea of the national unification of the Bulgarian nation was the fundamental and sacred aim of their efforts and of their epochal struggles. Later on in the political program of the revolutionary committee in Bucharest, the frontiers of the desired Bulgarian state were described with an accuracy which represents a true and understanding political view, especially when one bears in mind conditions at that time, conditions not only of patriotism crystal clear, but also showing an amazing ethnographical and historical knowledge.

Against all attempts to attack or deliver a deadly blow to the idea of unification the Bulgarian nation as reacted with iron determination, on which these attempts have ingloriously failed. The greatness of our church struggle rested precisely in the fact that it was an uncompromising struggle insofar as the territorial demarcation of the projected Bulgarian church (exarchate) was concerned. The southern frontiers proposed by the Patriarch of Constantinople and located on the crest of Stara Planina was turned down with an indication which made it clear, once for all, that the Bulgarian nation would no longer admit of its being challenged and insulted by such proposals. The further attempts
of Russian diplomacy and of the Sultan's government to satisfy the demands of our church further increased its territorial limits over which the jurisdiction of the Bulgarian church would extend, but which did not find favorable consideration in the Bulgarian nation. Our church leaders considered themselves satisfied only after the publication of the Sultan's decree, the tenth article of which opened for them the possibility, though under difficult conditions, of gathering all the territories with a Bulgarian population within the pale of the Bulgarian exarchate.

The peace treaty of San Stefano found the Bulgarian nation with an enhanced national and political consciousness and a fully crystallized idea of the meaning of unification. This is why this treaty, which was considered to be the crown of Bulgarian aspirations and the just reward of Bulgarian suffering and sacrifices, since it brought to life a just settlement which bad long been buried for five centuries, awakened an indescribable enthusiasm in the grateful nation from the Danube to the Aegean Sea and from the Black Sea to the Albanian Mountains. This is why the unfortunate news, which came a few months later with reference to the Congress of Berlin, found not only a painful echo but also the firm determination to take up a new struggle in the name of the idea of unification. This struggle in our then enslaves provinces is well known to all. It is known to us by its powerful romanticism, its sacred victims and its legendary heroism. In this struggle the indomitable sons of the provinces and the noble sons of the free fatherland took part side by side dying in a fraternal embrace. It was Bulgarian in spirit, in ideology and in aims.

The political elasticity with which the juridical principles, expressed in article twenty-three of the Treaty of Berlin, and then of the Treaty for the minorities, allowed and compelled the struggle to grow, because of the stipulations of the treaty and the international conditions at the time, from small to great achievements and gradually to attain the final Bulgarian solution of the Macedonian question, a fact which is used in vain today by some enemy countries, by ethnographical nihilists, for anti-Bulgarian purposes, for ideological combinations directed against them.

The final and great aim of the Macedonian liberation movement has been the union of Macedonia with the free kingdom. Similarly the underlying motive of Bulgarian foreign policy from the date of the Congress of Berlin until today, as well as the fundamental impulse which induced the Bulgarian soldier to die at the four corners of the Peninsula in the wars of liberation, has been the unification of all Bulgarian provinces in one Bulgarian state.

The idea of unification has also been the fundamental motive force of our national and political life. To the Balkan problem, insofar as we are concerned in it, we desire to give and shall give the solution which is in the spirit of our history, our wars of liberation, our national ideology. Any ideas which carry even the smallest sign or germ of separation or of particularism are equally alien to Bulgarians on both sides of the Osogovska Mountains. This is especially true today when we are living in a time of national and unitary states. We shall not seek our place in international life and establish the form of our state in accordance with the prescriptions of foreigners, the more so that these foreigners are known as our inexorable enemies. We shall build up our all Bulgarian state exclusively in the spirit of our idea of unification and Bulgaria will be a member of the international community ... a fully national and independent political entity." (ZORA -March 28, 1944.)

Respectfully yours, Burton M, Berry, American Consul General
To Department in original and hectograph
 
Last edited:
Where did we lose our country? - Mistaken beliefs

Where did we lose our country? - Mistaken beliefs

Where did we lose our country? - Mistaken beliefs



By Risto Stefov

rstefov@hotmail.com

February 20, 2011



In all the interviews that I conducted and stories I heard, Macedonians were great at relating their accounts the way they experienced them but very few could explain why these things happened to them and who and what was responsible for these life changing experiences. Unfortunately we also have a tendency to write things down the way we see, hear and experience them without analyzing or giving much thought as to why things happen the way they do.



Another problem that I want to discuss with you is the tendency we have to react to things. We tend to react to external driven events more than we follow our own plans or designed strategies, if these even exist, regarding real or perceived issues that concern our national interests.



In this article I will look into why things are done the way they are done and what can we do to improve them.



One of the things that we should have done since Macedonia was illegally invaded, occupied and partitioned by Greece, Serbia and Bulgaria in 1912, 1913, and later by Albania, was to call the four partitioned parts of Macedonia “occupied” because from a Macedonian perspective that is exactly what they were. For example we should have called all of Macedonia “occupied Macedonian territories”. We should have called “Aegean Macedonia”, “Greek occupied Macedonian territories”, “Vardar Macedonia”, “Serbian occupied Macedonian territories”, “Pirin Macedonia”, “Bulgarian occupied Macedonian territories” and “Mala Prespa” and “Golo Brdo” “Albanian occupied Macedonian territories”. After it was freed, the “Serbian occupied part of Macedonia” became “a free part of Macedonia” which we named the Republic of Macedonia. This reflects more accurately our situation and the status of our fatherland.



It is not too late however to do all this now because it still not only accurately reflects the reality of how we see our Macedonia but it will serve to inform the world that we as a people are not content with the situation in which we find ourselves. After 500 years of Ottoman rule the Balkans of the 19th century were still considered “occupied territories”, surely then after 100 years of Greek and Bulgarian occupation do we not have the right to call our fatherland occupied?



Since there never was a proper or satisfactory census done to count how many Macedonians live in Greece we should not be referring to them as “the Macedonian minority living in Greece” (Greek occupied Macedonia). We can’t make that assumption because in reality we don’t know how many Macedonians live there.



Clearly the vast majority of the population in Macedonia was Macedonian before Greece annexed these territories and clearly Greece willfully created the conditions that changed the demographics so why should we accept a fate imposed on us? If people invaded and occupied your home and they happened to be a larger number than your family would you accept the situation and surrender or would you fight to drive the intruders out? Would you call it their home because they were greater in number or your home because you are the owner?



Regardless of whether we are a majority or a minority in our own homeland, the fact is that land which belonged to the Macedonian people was forcibly taken away from them. In other words the Greeks stole those lands from the Macedonians. This is the picture Macedonians need to see, not only for themselves but for the rest of the world. Because this is the reality of the situation in which we find ourselves today; a reality which has existed since 1913!



We all know how Greece, Serbia and Bulgaria obtained those Macedonian lands and we know the lands do not belong to them. The part of Macedonia that was occupied by Serbia is now free and belongs to the Macedonian people. So should it not logically follow then that the parts occupied by Greece and Bulgaria should also be freed and should revert back to the Macedonian people? There are two ways we can look at this; complete independence just the way the Republic of Macedonia was freed, which is unlikely to happen anytime soon, but then no one knows how the future will turn out so shouldn’t we at least be thinking in that direction?



The other way we can free ourselves is for the Macedonian people to be given autonomy in Greece, Bulgaria and Albania so that they can govern themselves within the countries in which they live today. If there is will on the part of Greece, Bulgaria and Albania this option can be easily attained and will cost Greece, Bulgaria and Albania nothing. But just to be clear, I personally prefer the “independence” option because frankly I have had enough of the Greeks to last me several lifetimes!



Another issue that I have with Macedonians, concerns our mutual Macedonian national and ethnic identity. We tend to divide, isolate, separate and exclude parts of our genuine heritage, which I believe is not only wrong but we will some day come to regret.



I have always maintained a realistic view of who we are and that is we are the product of all the people that have ventured in Macedonia since the melt of the last ice age. There are also those who believe, and rightly so, that we as Macedonians are even older than that.



Regardless of our beliefs however, we are who we are but what we are not are “exclusively” the descendents of the ancient Macedonians, “exclusively” “Slavs”, or “exclusively” any single group that ventured into Macedonia over the years. I repeat, we are the product of all the people that set foot and settled in Macedonia and as such we have the right to their heritage, all of it.



So please let us not think that we are “only this or we are only that” and rob ourselves of our own heritage. Also let us not allow our enemies to dictate to us who and what we are and who and what we are not. Let us not allow our enemies to intimidate us into hating any part of our heritage because they made us believe it to be demeaning! We are who we are and there is nothing we can do to change that except to accept and embrace it because that is our heritage! It is us, all of it. So please before you begin criticizing me for what I have said, think about it!



I would go as far as saying that the Ancient Macedonian heritage is equally ours as is the so-called “Slav” heritage, whatever that might be. Also know that there are some things that are certain, for example when Christianity took hold in Europe Macedonia led the enlightenment. Along with the spreading of Christianity there was a revival of the Macedonian civilization, which not only brought Christianity to the Eastern European masses but gave them a written language which originated in Macedonia and was exclusively Macedonian. So why in the world should we not accept credit for these worldly deeds? Why should we exclude ourselves from the deeds of any of our Macedonian predecessors? Is this because we are intimidated by the Greeks calling us “Slavs” or “slavophones” or “Slavo-Macedonians”? We are all those things and more!



As a people I believe we need to rise above our definition by others; we only need to look into history to find who we are and believe me what we will find will surprise us!



If I may be so bold I would even venture to claim that the “Koine” language, which the modern Greeks today call “Greek”, and the “Thracian” language, which the Bulgarians today call “Bulgarian”, also fall into the category of Macedonian heritage. Why not? Think about it, the original Bulgarians were Tatars and spoke a Turkic language. Only later they adopted the Thracian language, parts of which the Macedonians were already speaking. The Bulgarians adopted the Thracian language after they settled in Thrace and were assimilated by the Thracian masses.



The Koine language is much more Alexander the Greats’ language than it is an Athenian language and was it not Alexander the Great, a Macedonian, who made it the international language of commerce throughout his empire? Where would this language have been today if it were not for Alexander the Great and his Macedonians who took this language out of the Balkans and carried it to all the corners of their vast empires? So why should Macedonians be robbed of yet another heritage to satisfy the Bulgarians who are not even indigenous to the Balkans or the Modern Greeks who only a couple of centuries ago were not even Greeks at all but Albanians and Vlachs whose ancestors immigrated to Greece during the 11th to the 13th centuries?



So realistically to whom do the “Koine” and “Thracian” languages belong, to the “Albanian-Vlach pretend Greeks”, to the “Turkic Tatars”, or to the indigenous Macedonians? What I am saying here could be proven with historical facts, all of it, which brings me to my next question! If all this can be proven, why hasn’t it been done by now? Why do we continuously take the defensive and react to issues being led by outsiders, like the “name negotiations”? Why haven’t we taken the offensive, formed a strategy, built cases and exposed the Greeks and Bulgarians for who they truly are?



Please indulge me to let you know of a rumour I heard in my travels. When the Peoples’ Republic of Macedonia was about to gain its autonomy in Yugoslavia there was great concern in Great Britain as to what language the Macedonian people would adopt as their national language. Was it going to be the Koine language written on ancient relics all over Macedonia? After all Koine was Alexander’s language and Alexander was Macedonian so it would only have been appropriate if the Macedonians picked the Koine language as their Macedonian national language! The Greeks did it so why wouldn’t the Macedonians have done it too?



Why were the Brits worried about Macedonia adopting the Koine language? I can tell you what I think and I think if Macedonians adopted the Koine language it would have meant that the Macedonians would have laid claim to the entire Macedonian heritage from ancient times to today. This would have “exposed” the fake Greeks and Bulgarians and would have left them out in the cold with no heritage! This is why I believe Britain was worried.



Well am I the only one here who thinks we made a mistake for not choosing the Koine language as our national language? And this is precisely what I mean when I say we allow our enemies to intimidate us and then we willingly “give things up” that are rightfully ours!



If you have doubts about what I said above then let me ask you this! Does Koine, Alexander’s language, belong to the indigenous Macedonians who have lived in Macedonia for many millenniums or to the Modern Greeks who in reality are Albanians and Vlachs whose ancestors migrated to present day Greece during the 11th to the 13th century AD?



If you said “to the Macedonians” then ask yourself this question. Why then did we give up the Koine language and allow the Greeks to have it? So that today they can say “look we can speak ‘Greek’ therefore we are the descendents of the ancient Greeks?” Anyone can learn to speak “Greek”, even Alexander’s Koine in its purest form, but does that make them Alexander’s great, great grandchildren?



If we take a look at the conditions under which countries such as Greece and Bulgaria were formed, I picked those two countries because I am familiar with them, we will discover that we have a better foundation than they do. When it comes to our modern Macedonian state, our modern Macedonian ethnic and national identity and our modern Macedonian language we can say that they are all natural evolutions indigenous to Macedonia. They all have long historic roots and belong to the Macedonian people.



So not only do we have a right to defend our heritage, all of it, we have the right to stop others from expropriating it and from interfering in our affairs. In simple words, Greece has no grounds whatsoever to stand on when it comes to Macedonia, never mind interfere in Macedonian’s affairs and dictate conditions to the Macedonian people. This is something we all need to recognize!



If we took some time to look into our history and compare it to theirs we would not only validate what I am saying here to be true but we would discover that as an identity we stand on firmer ground than the Greeks. For example the Greeks as an identity are a modern, 19th century construct which has nothing to do with “ancient” or “Modern” Macedonia”! History can easily prove this! Having said that then what right does Greece have to make claims to Macedonia?



Macedonians on the other hand are indigenous to Macedonia and as such have historical claims to Macedonia. Again having said that then why are we allowing the Greeks to continue to interfere in our affairs?



If it were up to me I would even go a few steps further and publicly uncover “everything” the Greeks have done against the Macedonian people, including the many atrocities they committed and then demand justice be served!



Our long term strategy should be to “sort out history” and work towards recovering all that we have lost since 1913. We should be doing this regardless of whether we are capable today or not. I repeat, this should be our long term strategy!



Also let us not forget that Greece will never cease to torment us until it achieves its own goals and that is to bring us to our demise! This has been Greece’s plan all along ever since it robbed us of our territories and of our heritage in1912, 1913!



Before I end this part of the series I would like to see one more thing done and soon if possible. One of the mistakes, I believe as Macedonians, we made in the past was our inability or unwillingness to repatriate the Macedonian people driven out of their homeland because of war, torment and belligerence. We had the opportunity for repatriation after 1945 when the Peoples’ Republic of Macedonia became an autonomous state inside the Yugoslav federation. At that time we had an opportunity to “bring everyone home” but for various reasons it did not work out. Had the Republic of Macedonia opened the doors to all Macedonians and invited them to come and live in Macedonia instead of migrating everywhere in the world, the Republic of Macedonia today would have had a lot more Macedonians, some estimate more than four million Macedonians. This however did not happen then but it is not too late for it to happen now!



The Republic of Macedonia even today has the potential and the capacity to bring together all Macedonians who would like to return to Macedonia. The Republic of Macedonia can do this by creating the right conditions for people to return; be it retired people who wish to spend the last years of their lives in their own homeland or young people who wish to settle there and have families and careers. For this to take place however, Macedonian authorities need to create the conditions, as well as promote the idea wherever Macedonians live.



To be continued.
 
If I may be so bold I would even venture to claim that the “Koine” language, which the modern Greeks today call “Greek”, and the “Thracian” language, which the Bulgarians today call “Bulgarian”, also fall into the category of Macedonian heritage. Why not? Think about it,

You should think about it...mmm...theta.

The Koine language is much more Alexander the Greats’ language than it is an Athenian language and was it not Alexander the Great, a Macedonian, who made it the international language of commerce throughout his empire? Where would this language have been today if it were not for Alexander the Great and his Macedonians who took this language out of the Balkans and carried it to all the corners of their vast empires?

How wide spread was it prior to him spreading it.

So realistically to whom do the “Koine” and “Thracian” languages belong, to the “Albanian-Vlach pretend Greeks”, to the “Turkic Tatars”, or to the indigenous Macedonians?

Is there another part to this equation…are there not posts on this site that say supposedly only the Macedonian nobility and upper class learned Greek while the common Macedonian didn’t understand Greek then if the common Macedonian spoke koin what language did the nobility learn.

What I am saying here could be proven with historical facts, all of it, which brings me to my next question! If all this can be proven, why hasn’t it been done by now?

Excellent question. Do you have an equally excellent answer. I would like it to be proven too…I think it would go a long way towards the name negotiations.

Please indulge me to let you know of a rumour I heard in my travels. When the Peoples’ Republic of Macedonia was about to gain its autonomy in Yugoslavia there was great concern in Great Britain as to what language the Macedonian people would adopt as their national language. Was it going to be the Koine language written on ancient relics all over Macedonia? After all Koine was Alexander’s language and Alexander was Macedonian so it would only have been appropriate if the Macedonians picked the Koine language as their Macedonian national language!

Well am I the only one here who thinks we made a mistake for not choosing the Koine language as our national language?

You should stick to reality and common knowledge and not indulge in rumors that could not have merit as it diminishes your credibility. Bar the Aegean Macedonian refugees who decided to live in titos Macedonia and their children whom they continued to teach Greek privately and the odd other person knew Greek. The majority of Macedonians do not understand Greek so why would they choose it as their official state language…so they don’t know how to fill out any government form. Besides not knowing koin most Macedonians would revolt at such a proposition seeing it as a forced conversion so the chances of this even being considered and seriously enough that the British would be nervous is nonsensical and hence unbelievable.

If you have doubts about what I said above then let me ask you this! Does Koine, Alexander’s language, belong to the indigenous Macedonians who have lived in Macedonia for many millenniums or to the Modern Greeks who in reality are Albanians and Vlachs whose ancestors migrated to present day Greece during the 11th to the 13th century AD?

We know the modern Greeks as Albanian Vlachs Roma ect acquired the koin language but if the Macedonians used the koin language because as far back as anyone in family can remember no one knew how to speak koin nor did they know anyone who did so are we not really Macedonians. I have heard in the past some Aegean Macedonians say that there is some border somewhere where Macedonia proper ends and that northern tip in Serbia Macedonians speak funny so should I buy a Sajkaca or my great grandfather knew some Turkish because of the Ottoman empire so should I buy a Fez or maybe I should just make one out of a newspaper.

Our long term strategy should be to “sort out history” and work towards recovering all that we have lost since 1913. We should be doing this regardless of whether we are capable today or not. I repeat, this should be our long term strategy!

I’ve been saying for a long time that we should sort out our history and recovering all that Macedonians have lost but I thought Macedonian history went beyond 1913 or is this the only history that concerns you.

Also let us not forget that Greece will never cease to torment us until it achieves its own goals and that is to bring us to our demise!

Hence my point in sorting out our history but as a matter of urgency as it goes a long way towards the name dispute or do you think the name negotiation will go on for another 100 years or more so it can sit on the backburner while those who live through our history and have something to tell pass away and any document they may have had to share become lost.

One of the mistakes, I believe as Macedonians, we made in the past was our inability or unwillingness to repatriate the Macedonian people driven out of their homeland because of war, torment and belligerence.

A mistake is only when you have a say in a decision. Tito is no friend of the Macedonians tito never
wanted too many Macedonians in Yugoslavia…maybe because of the skeletons in the closet.

We had the opportunity for repatriation after 1945 when the Peoples’ Republic of Macedonia became an autonomous state inside the Yugoslav federation.

It was not as autonomous as you might think. It was created at the execution of Macedonian officers who refused to be subject to tito and wanted an independent Macedonia as to their original arrangement with tito and then the force battle of attrition for the Macedonian troops at the battle of Sren. Tito was no friend of the Macedonians.

Had the Republic of Macedonia opened the doors to all Macedonians and invited them to come and live in Macedonia instead of migrating everywhere in the world, the Republic of Macedonia today would have had a lot more Macedonians,

Tito in keeping good with the west and Greece initially shut the border with orders to shoot anyone trying to cross. Helpless Macedonians caught on the other side of the border were massacred. Only when the mass murdering in Aegean Macedonia became too great and would be an absolute embarrassment for all concerned did tito open the border and accepted the refugees who were mainly women and children. To sanitize history he then aided the Aegean Macedonian refugees by building free apartment blocks which to this day bare the unofficial label the Aegean buildings or Aegean apartments and gave them jobs in preference to other Macedonians.

Tito is no friend of the Macedonians tito never wanted too many Macedonians in Yugoslavia…maybe because of the skeletons in the closet…that’s why few businesses were opened in Macedonia resulting in most of the population earning a living as poor farmers with the state buying their produce and feeding much of Yugoslavia and those few industries that were opened in Macedonia were the likes of metal sheltering and poisoning the city air or munitions factories like 11th October. Having created unfavorable conditions at home he made it easy for Macedonians to emigrate into the west where they dutifully sent back hard foreign currency which never made it past Belgrade as foreign currency to support poor relatives. A…foreign…cash cow is better then a bunch of peasants all turning to you looking for work.

This however did not happen then but it is not too late for it to happen now!

Yes it is.

The Republic of Macedonia even today has the potential and the capacity to bring together all Macedonians who would like to return to Macedonia. The Republic of Macedonia can do this by creating the right conditions for people to return;

With over thirty something percent unemployment rate and poor infrastructure Macedonia does not have the means to do this.

be it retired people who wish to spend the last years of their lives in their own homeland

Most don’t. People of pension age went through the heartache of leaving mothers fathers and siblings and friends behind to start new lives in the west and don’t want to go through that again leaving children and grandchildren behind in the diaspora. Macedonians are not the cool type of grans who skype and would video conference to keep in touch with their children or grandchildren and even if they could learn the internet they wouldn’t want to.

Lets not just consider what they would be leaving behind but also what they would be going to. Many have not only lost their parents but also outlived most if not all of their siblings and nephews and nieces are not to thrilled in attending to their needs…kako majka sto se raduva so dete so izdrskani peleni…particularly realizing they will be progressively be able to do less for themselves. Struggling with upkeep and preparations for winter and bothering with freezing mornings ect. Like the saying goes people go south to Florida never north for their retirement.

young people who wish to settle there and have families and careers.

With 30 something percent unemployment Macedonia already has a lot of young people doing just that. I don’t think the local Macedonians would be too thrilled at more young people from outside joining their queues as would the outsider looking at diving into a vast pool of ready unemployed.

Further with the lack of infrastructure many services are substandard…eg health education as well as other difficulties.

Those with young children to teenagers often find their kids don’t want to stay too long.

A little more realism would go a long way towards believability.
 
Last edited:
Without going into some of the other issues, I agree with OziMak in this instance in that these theories about the Koine language that Stefov puts forward are completely baseless. I'm not sure how someone like Stefov could have come to such a conclusion that the Koine language was 'Macedonian'.
 
Last edited:
I think the Koine language was amplified by the Macedonians. It was a written language that preceded the Macedonians' arrival in the East.

To call it Macedonian is misleading.

It certainly would not have been the language the ancient Macedonians used when they did not want Hellenes to understand them.
 
Koine is a language based on Attic Greek with several foreign admixtures (mostly relevant to nouns), and it was developed during the Macedonian invasion of Asia and afterwards, not before. To call the Koine language 'Macedonian' is completely inaccurate. I don't know why Stefov is doing this, or where he is heading with it.
 
Here's the answer guys:"
Zdravo George,



I am glad you asked this question. I received a lot of feedback from many Macedonians on the “Koine” issue and they deserve to know why I did this.



In my younger days a Macedonian activist living in Greece, who by the way is still active to this day, told me that “to beat the Greeks you will have to think like a Greek”.
Risto Stefov



The article in question, as are many of my “editorial” or “rant” articles, is not only about “facts” and “truth”, it is about how far I can push the envelope and get away with it.



In researching our history through the eyes of diplomats and Governments I discovered a different view of the world which has mostly has “little” to do with “facts” and “truth” but a lot to do with holding power and getting re-elected.



Governments do what is “popular” with the majority of the people, and, at the diplomatic lever, they very rarely care about people’s “feelings”.



We Macedonians know that Greeks, who are not really Greeks, claim a lot of things that don’t belong to them and yet today they are still popular in the world, have a country, a glowing heritage and a history that stretches back to ancient times. What do we have? With all the “right” things we have done and the right steps we have taken, what dowe have?



Two thirds of our country is still occupied, after 100 years, and we can’t seem to even recognize that. Our enemies bad mouth our heritage and because of it, we reject it.



The “Koine” language, as I have said hundreds of times in my history articles, was the language of trade and commerce in the entire Mediterranean region which the Macedonians extended to Asia and Africa. At least this is what history tells us. It was used as a common language by the educated, business people and governments.



The question I attempted to pose, as I do in many of my “editorial articles”, given the current situation and the fact that Greece has laid claim to a lot of things that don’t belong to it, in contract, can we do the same thing? Obviously, judging from the criticism I received, we can’t!



Again than I must ask! What is it that we “CAN” do to get us moving in the right direction which is acceptable to Macedonians?



If you don’t ask, you will never know!



Say hi to the guys at MacedonianTruth for me. I would love to join the forum and debate but where am I going to find the time? My heart is with you.
 
Risto Stefov said:
The question I attempted to pose, as I do in many of my “editorial articles”, given the current situation and the fact that Greece has laid claim to a lot of things that don’t belong to it, in contract, can we do the same thing? Obviously, judging from the criticism I received, we can’t!
We don't need to lower ourselves by replicating the behaviour of our enemies.
Again than I must ask! What is it that we “CAN” do to get us moving in the right direction which is acceptable to Macedonians?
There is still much work to be done, and I think it is more beneficial if we focus on claiming things that are actually significant from a Macedonian standpoint (in the context of Macedonian history), rather than claiming things we shouldn't, just because our neighbours have done the same.
 
Stefov makes a point.
Macedonians have never been good at "one upmanship". So this cannot be argued as something that has been done poorly before. I do agree that we need to be arguing from a righteous perspective, but let us not forget we are dealing with Greek peasants who throw Zeus or some other myth up at the most opportune of times to justify modern problems.
 
And that is why those Greeks that claim such things are peanuts. Macedonians already have enough peanuts amongst their ranks, and, as I don't consider Stefov to be one of them, my only advice would be to cease writing this sort of thing. It isn't worthy of all the other great work he has done.
 
Suggesting we adopt a language not spoken by our people is very strange and exactly what the arvanovlachs did and not something I could agree with
 
And that is why those Greeks that claim such things are peanuts. Macedonians already have enough peanuts amongst their ranks, and, as I don't consider Stefov to be one of them, my only advice would be to cease writing this sort of thing. It isn't worthy of all the other great work he has done.

I agree - using bad arguments and essentially lying doesn't make ones work accepted, it just makes it look plain bad. Besides, wouldn't claiming Koine as 'Macedonian' be effectively claiming ordinary Macedonians, not just Macedonian officials, spoke Greek? Isn't there an inherent contradiction there?
 
I have to agree with you guys if the greeks lie people beleive their lies if we lie then we are not going to be believed.If our enemies are lying why should we lie i know we are just fighting fire with fire & replicating it.
 
rom the Once Classified Files - Part 2‏

rom the Once Classified Files - Part 2‏

Here is Report 2
Balkan States - Report 2
February 1, 1945

Brigadier Maclean to Sir Orme Sargent

(No. 4)

With reference to my dispatch No.1 of the 6th of January regarding Macedonia, it may be of interest to recall the following sequence of events indicative of trends in Yugoslav, Bulgar, and Greek Macedonia in favour of incorporation in the new Macedonian federal unit of Yugoslavia.

2. On the 18th November the Greek Macedonian Brigade held its foundation ceremony at Bitolj to cries of “Give us the right to live within the framework of federal Yugoslavia.” Yugoslav partisan leaders appear to have attempted to moderate popular enthusiasm and Pasanko, representative of the Macedonian National Liberation Front, reminded his listeners that “this is a delicate diplomatic question in which the co-operation of our allies England, Russia, and America is essential.

3. The Greek Macedonian Brigade appears to have been formed partly of refugees resident in Bulgaria and partly from former adherents of E.A.M. who disagreed with E.A.M.’s minority policy. Keremediciev, Political Commissar of the new brigade, accused E.A.M. of harbouring certain elements who refused to accord the Greek Macedonians their cultural rights and own military formations. E.A.M. he added, finally issued instructions for the Macedonians to be disarmed and it was to avoid this that they crossed the border to Yugoslavia.

4. There they were probably joined by volunteers recruited from amongst Macedonian refugees previously living in Bulgaria. Yugoslav sources claim that there are some 700,000 of these refugees in Bulgaria, most of them having been transferred there as a result of agreements made after the last war for the exchange of population in the Balkans. The Yugoslav partisan newspaper Nova Makedonija for the 14th November, 1944, gave the following account of their present attitude: “These Macedonian refugees realize that the independence and liberation of the Greek part of Macedonia depends not a little on its direct participation in the operations against the German Fascists. Committees are therefore being formed in every village and town in Bulgaria where Macedonians are living. It is to be expected that the response to volunteering will assume very large proportions and will include all those able to bear arms, and that whole units will be formed from the refugees alone.”

5. On the 3rd December another meeting was held in Bitolj to elect “a Political Commission to lead the fight of the Macedonian people in Greek Macedonia.” The commission appointed Filip Velkov as its representative to the Presidium of A.S.N.O.M. (i.e. the Anti-Fascist Assembly for the National Liberation of Macedonia) and J.A.N.L., H.Q., for Macedonia. At the second session of A.S.N.O.M. held at the end of December Velkov stated: “We Macedonians from Aegean Macedonia have a grim struggle before us to realize the age-old ideal of our people, the liberation of our part of Macedonia which is still beneath a foreign yoke.” At the same session of A.S.N.O.M., Atanas Atanasovski spoke in the name of the Bulgarian Macedonians. “The entire population of Pirin Macedonia,” he asserted, “is waiting for the happy hour when we shall be included with our brothers in Macedonia in Tito’s democratic, federal Yugoslavia.”

6. These claims for union between the Macedonian population of Yugoslavia, Bulgaria and Greece had already been advanced some weeks previously by authoritative Yugoslav partisan leaders, such as General Dzilas, General Tempo and Dimitar Vlahov. Though some of the more categorical of these claims may have been made in a burst of momentary exuberance, it is worth while examining the career of the most experienced of these politicians, Vlahov, for indications as to the more permanent aims and principles determining their policy.

7. Dimitar Vlahov was born in Kilkis in Greek Macedonia in 1878, and joined the original I.M.R.O. as early as 1903, collaborating closely with the famous Macedonian leader Goce Delcev. In 1908 he was elected to the Turkish Parliament as a deputy of the Popular Federal party, whose object was to work constitutionally for an autonomous Macedonia. In 1907, after Macedonia had been annexed by Bulgaria, Vlahov became Governor of the Pristina district and after the Great War, served as Bulgarian Consul-General first in Odessa and then in Vienna. In 1924 he signed the Aleksandrov-Protogerov manifesto which attempted to patch up a truce between the rival I.M.R.O. leaders and he was repudiated by the Bulgarian Government. Disapproving of the terrorist methods of I.M.R.O. which was now falling increasingly under the domination of Ivan Mihajlov and degenerating into the tool of Bulgarian and Italian designs of disruption in the Balkans, Vlahov founded his own organization, the United (Obidinena) I.M.R.O., in 1925, and expounded his ideas in his well known book “Balkan Federation”. Vlahov looked neither to Bulgaria nor to Yugoslavia (which was then pursuing a policy of rigid centralism) but to the Soviet Union, with whose support he hoped to achieve a union of the South Slav peoples in which Macedonia would form a separate, autonomous federal unit. Though Vlahov still continued to lay great stress on non-violent methods for the achievement of his aims, his organization was broken up by the Government of the Military League in Bulgarian in 1934, and its members sentenced to long terms of imprisonment on a charge of Communist conspiracy and planning of an armed revolt. Vlahov himself settled in Moscow in 1936 and appears to have remained there until returning to Yugoslavia at some point to join the partisans. Observant readers have been able to secure an interesting side light on his activity in Moscow from an article in a recent partisan newspaper which wrote that Vlahov had “liven in Moscow, where he worked tirelessly in the International Agrarian Institute” – the latter phrase being substituted for the blocked-out but still legible word “Comintern”.

8. Although the energy with which the authorities appear to have quelled the anxiety of certain of their troops to march on Salonica (see my telegram No.63 of the 16th January) bears out Tito’s repented assurances that he intends to take no premature action over the Macedonia problem, there is every reason to suppose that it is his intention to unite in due course the Macedonian provinces of Greece and Bulgaria to Yugoslav Macedonia, and that this project has the approval of the Soviet Union. Dr. Smodlaka has stated that the Bulgarian Government (no doubt under pressure from Moscow) have already agreed to cede Bulgarian Macedonia (see my telegram No.88 of the 21st January). The Greek attitude towards this problem must be regarded as less assured and will doubtless depend on the eventual complexion of the Greek Government, although, as will be seen by my telegram No.2 of the 7th December, even E.A.M. do not appear to have proved quite as amenable on this question as Tito would have wished. It is however, difficult to see how Greece, whatever her attitude, would be able successfully to resist the wishes in this matter of an overwhelmingly strong South Slav bloc under Soviet tutelage.

F. H. R. MACLEAN, Brigadier, British Military Mission. Belgrade, 21st, January, 1945.
 
declassified files are very interesting things to read

Balkan States – Report 3
January 29th, 1945

Brigadier Maclean to Sir Orme Sargent

I TRANSMIT herewith a report on Macedonia. F. MACLEAN

British Military Mission, Belgrade, 7th January, 1945.

Enclosure. Report No. 1.

1. Now that some time has elapsed since enemy forces evacuated Macedonia, an attempt can be made to asses the extent to which the Partisans have been able to implement their policy of creating a Macedonian federal unit. Although the Partisans are somewhat prone to discuss the problem as “solved” by the mere proclamation of Macedonia’s autonomy, it is clear that a real solution can only be achieved through a long process of educational, administrative and economic reconstruction.

2. It will be recalled that provision was made for full Macedonian autonomy by a decree passed at the Second Session of A.V.N.O.J. at Jaice in November 1943. By this decree Macedonia was accorded a status equal in all respects to that of Serbia, Montenegro, Croatia and Slovenia in the new federal Yugoslavia. The first step towards carrying this autonomy into effect was taken by the formation of the Anti-Fascist Assembly for the Liberation of Macedonia (A.S.N.O.M.) as the acting federal authority.

3. It appears, however, that there is to be a considerable difference in the degree of autonomy which the Partisans intend to allow in the various spheres of Macedonian national life. In cultural matters Macedonia is to be accorded immediate and complete autonomy; in political and administrative matters as much autonomy as can be digested; in economic life there are so far few signs of autonomy and, indeed, in opposite policy of centralized state control may well be introduced.

4. Macedonia’s cultural autonomy is finding its immediate expression in the official stimulus given to the “Macedonian language.” The later has hitherto been generally denied existence and has been claimed as a Serb or a Bulgar dialect according to the national prejudices of rival philosophies. Nova Makedonija and other papers are now regularly published in the Macedonian language and a place of special honour given to Macedonian poems and songs.

5. Special efforts are also been made to educate and develop the most backward sections of the population. The Anti-Fascist Women’s Front is reported to be receiving a special response from amongst the Macedonian women, and the backward Turkish minority is being courted by solemn celebration of the Feast of Bajram, by Moslem rallies held in Skopje and by frequent favourable publicity in the press.

6. The right to political and administrative autonomy is being more differently applied. In the first place, this right is by no means universally recognized by the other Yugoslav peoples, especially the Serbs in who the old great Serb conviction that there is no Macedonia but only a “southern Serbia” is still strong. Significant confirmation of this was recently afforded by an article published in Borba criticizing a meeting of educationalists at Nis who acquiesced in a statement made by one speaker to the effect that Macedonia was “just a part of Greater Serbia.” The article went on to complain that at another meeting of the Women’s Anti-Fascist Front, also held at Nis, a delegate from Macedonia was denied the much publicized right of making a speech in her own language.

7. If the Serbs are slow to admit the right of the Macedonians to equal partnership in the Yugoslav State, the Macedonians for their part, are not quick to forgive the Serbs for exploiting their former hegemony. Macedonia was generally regarded in pre-war Yugoslavia as a colony – a sort of south Slav Siberia to which corrupt, inefficient or recalcitrant civil servants were relegated. Their task in Macedonia was less to promote the well-being of the population than to propagate the Great Serb creed. The Macedonians are now to provide their own administrators. Although local government by the committee or “odbor” system reduces the number of officials required, it would seem that a shortage of experienced Macedonian civil servants must be felt for some time to come.

8. Perhaps more resented by the Macedonian people than the old Serbian officials were the Serbian colonists settled by Government grant on Macedonian soil. The great Serbian outlook of these colonists, together with the economic privileges they enjoyed, led to considerable ill-feeling among the Macedonian population. That this ill-feeling has not yet been wholly dissipated has been confidentially admitted by Father Vlada Zecevic, Commissar for the Interior in the National Committee, who has recently returned from a visit to Macedonia. Father Zecevic states that a redistribution of land, by which it is hoped to satisfy the needs of the poorer Macedonian peasantry without entirely dispossessing the Serb settlers, is being now carried through and is inevitably giving rise to some cases of personal resentment.

9. In the meantime economic conditions in Macedonia remain confused, as has been reported by my No. 791 of the 29th December quoting a report received from my mission there; “the economic situation here is bad largely through lack of transport and inefficiency. There is sufficient food in Macedonia but distribution problems are acute. The foregoing is probably the reason for the re-election of a new ministerial council of A.S.N.O.M., which is to take place on the 28th December.” The immediate implications of autonomy in the economic field cannot therefore be regarded as an unmixed blessing, and apart from this adjustment of claims between Serb settlers and poor Macedonian peasants it seems doubtful whether the Partisans will attempt a more extensive application of the principle. Indeed, the special character of Macedonian economy suggests an opposite tendency towards State centralism. In addition to opium and cotton cultivation, both of great potential value if wisely fostered by the State, the chief Macedonian crop is tobacco. This furnishes a valuable source of income to the State, who bought it through a monopoly from the peasant cultivators at fixed low prices. The State, however, played no part in organizing or improving cultivation, though the peasant could have been greatly assisted through expert advice in methods of cultivation, model plantations, financial help, co-operatives, &c. State assistance along these lines maybe expected to yield considerable economic results, and if Partisan controlled Yugoslavia is to attempt any promising experiment in agricultural collectivization it may well be in the tobacco fields in Macedonia.

10. That the path of Macedonian autonomy is still beset with thorny problems, both in the sphere of external and internal affairs, is suggested by Marshal Tito’s decision, already reported by telegram, to send his right-hand man Kardelj to attend the Second Session of A.S.N.O.M. held on the 28th of December, 1944. In his speech to the Assembly Kardelj congratulated the Macedonians on their newly won autonomy, but went on to warn them against becoming “giddy with success.” Their enemies, he asserted, were still active and the independence of small Powers was constantly threatened. “Vigilance was all the more necessary as, unfortunately, every-day experience showed that solemn undertakings not to interfere in the internal affairs of other countries” – and here Kardelj made a veil reference to events in Greece – “were in practice only treated as scraps of paper.” Macedonia’s enemies, he continued, were “the Great Bulgarian, Great Albanian, Great Serbian and Greek chauvinists” and their supporters abroad. Equally pernicious were the opposite tendencies towards separatism. Macedonia could only flourish, Kardelj concluded, within the framework of the new federal democratic Yugoslavia.

11. A similar creed was expressed by other speakers at the Assembly, notably by General Tempo-Vukmanovic, who asserted: “We have gained a victory in the field of battle and must now gain it on the field of politics. The danger which threatens to destroy the achievements of our great struggle lies in the efforts made to stir up chauvinism and separatism.” Tempo went on to stress the need for free and democratic elections by secret ballot and affirmed: “We did not fear to give arms to the people – still less shall we fear to give the people the vote.” Thus the official line taken by the Partisan speakers was the avoidance of any territorial claims or suggestion of any eventual South Slav federation and affirmation of a conciliatory and moderate policy of full democracy. These discrete utterances were in contrast with the wild polemics and even wilder territorial claims advanced by General Tempo and Dr. Vlahov in November on the subject which, under instructions from the foreign office, I made strong representations to Marshal Tito.

12. From this and from the various conversations which I have had with him on the subject of Macedonia, there can be little doubt that Tito fully realizes the delicate nature of the internal and external problems involved, and there is every indication that, for the present at any rate, he intends to tread cautiously. What future plans he (or possibly Moscow) has for this traditionally explosive region remains to be seen. He has always told me that he does not intend to prosecute any territorial claims he may have in this region before the Peace Conference, and that in the case of any disputed region he would be prepared to be guided by the results of a plebiscite. In the case of the ethnological patchwork of the Kosovo Polje he has on occasion mentioned the possibility of moving what is left of the Arnaut population, whose loyalty to the Germans was unshaken to the end, to Albania on bloc. The first speeches made by Tempo and Vlahov after the liberation of Macedonia referred to above show that at any rate some leading Macedonians would like to see the present frontiers of Macedonia extended at the expense of Greece and Bulgaria.

13. A possible solution to these problems would, of course, be the creation of a Federal State comprising Yugoslavia and Bulgaria, and even possibly Greece and Albania, with which the frontier of the ideal Macedonia could be firmly established, if not by mutual agreements, then by an over-ruling decision of the Central Federal Authority. On the other hand, even if no Balkan or South Slav Federation should be created it seems likely that, in view of the similarity of outlook of the regimes which either have or eventually will be set up in all these countries, the task of reaching, or if necessary imposing, settlement will present little difficulty.

F. MACLEAN., 6th January, 1945.
 
Balkan States – Report 4

Balkan States – Report 4

Here is Balkan States – Report 4

Balkan States – Report 4
April 27th, 1945

Mr. Stevenson to Mr. Eden
Belgrade, 13th April, 1945.

(No. 44.)

Sir,

I HAVE the honour to report that two members of my staff recently had a long conversation with M. Emanuel Cuckov, the Minister for Macedonia. Mr. Cuckov was very friendly and appeared anxious to give all possible information.

2. He opened the conversation by saying how important it was that Allies should understand the situation in Macedonia and should realise that the Macedonians regard themselves as a separate people. What he meant by that statement was not clear, but he later said that Macedonia was very satisfied with her federal status inside the Yugoslav State and explained that the federal idea was not a new one to Macedonians, who had previously envisaged obtaining a measure of autonomy as a federal unit in a South Slav federation. From everything he said it emerged that the Macedonians have very concrete ideas on the measure of autonomy offered by their present federal status. In internal matters they seem to regard themselves as being entitled to operate almost entirely independently of the rest of the Yugoslav State. From other remarks which I have heard from prominent Yugoslavs recently, it seems possible that this tendency towards excessive independence on the part of Macedonia is causing the Central Government a certain amount of concern.

3. On being asked about the new administrative districts which have recently been set up in Macedonia, M. Cuckov said that he was not expert on this question but that he understood that these new divisions were essentially the same as they had been before 1941. They had, however, been somewhat improved and under one administrative centre were now included all villages and districts which were bound geographically to that centre. Before 1941 the divisions bad been Some what- arbitrary and areas whose market produce naturally went to one town had been often included in the administrative district of another. This had led to much inefficiency and had caused the peasants great difficulty. The frontier between Macedonia and Serbia was the historical one, i.e., a line running east to west just north of Kumanovo and south of Kacanik. I enclose as an appendix 1.0 the dispatch a list and a map (map not printed) of the new administrative areas in Macedonia.

4. M. Cuckov then spoke about agriculture. He said that attempts had been made before 1941 to encourage wheat growing in Macedonia. The son, however, had not lent itself to this and the intention of the Macedonian Government was henceforward to concentrate on the cultivation of rice, sesame, opium and tobacco, all or which could easily be grown. Macedonia had never had many factories, but it was the intention of the Macedonian Government to remedy this and to encourage industrial enterprise for the processing of commodities grown inside the Macedonian frontiers. The main industrial enterprises before the war such as the Allatini and Radusa chrome and lead mines near Stip, had not suffered much damage and were more or less ready to resume work.

5. As regards reconstruction, the Federal Government of Macedonia had- immediately after the evacuation of the Germans on their own initiative set to work to repair runways and roads. This reconstruction had been financed by the Macedonian Government itself without assistance from the Central Government. This was due mainly to the fact that the dinar had no value in Macedonia and though the Central Government had set money aside for Macedonian reconstruction it still remained in Belgrade. He believed that all roads were already repaired and the runway from Belgrade to Veles was open. From Veles to Djevdjelija the Germans had completely destroyed the runway during their withdrawal and it would take some time to repair. The runway to the Greek frontier through Bitolj was, he thought, however, very nearly fit for traffic.

6. On being asked whether the Serb colonists would be free to return to Macedonia he said, somewhat platitudiuously, that all Yugoslavs would naturally be free to come to Macedonia if they wished. As regards officials, he said, however, that the question of whether they return to their old jobs depended entirely on the Macedonian Government and not on the Central Government. The Macedonian Government were anxious that as far as possible the official positions should be fled by Macedonians and, provided that there were men to fill the posts, it was, therefore, unlikely that the Macedonian authorities would be ready to take back the old officials. For example, before 1943 the police had been almost entirely Serbian and the police chiefs had been Serbs. Now the militia who had taken their place were Macedonians and it was natural that the head of the militia should be Macedonian as well.

7. As regards the redistribution of land, he pointed out that before 1941 it had been easy for the Serbs to buy land in Macedonia, and as a result the Macedonians, for whom the purchase of land had not been easy, had been driven out of the more fertile parts of the country. He indicated that there would be as far as possible a redistribution in favour of the Macedonians and that Serbian colonists would if possible be sent back Serbia: Thirty per cent of the Banat had been owned and cultivated by Germans and here the population had been only ninety to every square kilometer of cultivable land, whereas in Macedonia it was 350. He thought that the Serbs from Macedonia could be moved to take the place of the Germans in the Banat.

8. He then spoke about the Church and Stated that before the war one of the main attempts to Serbianise Macedonia had been made through that medium. Nearly all the priests had been Serbs and this had been very unpopular with the Macedonians, who were extremely Nationalistic and would only recognise a Church run by themselves with Macedonian priests. He believed that the solution lay in a federal Yugoslav Church. Whereas previously the Orthodox Church had been a Serbian Church with tentacles in Macedonia, Bosnia and other parts of Yugoslavia, he hoped to see separate Orthodox Churches in each of the federal units which each in turn owed allegiance to a central Yugoslav Patriarchate. If such an arrangement could not be sanctioned by the Orthodox Church he felt that the Macedonian Church would be forced to carry on schismatically as the Bulgarian Church had previously done for some seventy years. He then attacked the Metropolitan Joseph of Skopje, who, he said, had during the war been associated with Trbic, the Cetnik leader in Macedonia, and had continuously been opposed to the partisans. He considered him a time-server who was unfit to stand as deputy for the Metropolitan Gavrilo whom everyone admired. The Metropolitan Joseph was also a Serb and though it might only be an internal affair of the Orthodox Church that he should call himself the Metropolitan of Skopje, it had aroused the anger of all Macedonians when he recently went to Moscow in that capacity and apparently representing the Macedonian Church. He pointed out that the Macedonian Church Assembly had sent greetings to the Holy Synod, whose authority they recognised, but not to the Metropolitan Joseph. It seems possible that the recent visit of the Metropolitan to Moscow may have been the reason for bringing to a head the Macedonian demand for a separate Church.

9. The recent elections had been a great success and had aroused widespread interest. In nearly all districts over 90 per cent of the electorate had polled. He believed that everyone over 21, except those accused of collaboration, had been allowed to vote and, in addition to this, those under that age who had fought in the Yugoslav army of National Liberation. Candidates had been chosen freely by the people and he gave an example a town of 10,000 inhabitants. This might be divided into four districts, each of five streets. Each street would at a public meeting choose two members, and a district meeting would then be held and those of the candidates who had anything against them would then be ruled out. All those who were approved as candidates would then stand for election and election was by secret ballot. No suasions had been used either by the police or by the army during the elections.

10. Opposition to the present regime in Macedonia was very slight. The Cetnik problem had never been serious and the few who had fought in the Macedonia had a long time ago gone north into Serbia. The Albanian bands who had at one point been a fairly serious menace had only been bandits, whose object was to profit from the general disorder, and at the time of the German withdrawal had impartially attacked both Germans and Partisans. These had nearly all departed – some going north with the Germans and others taking refuge in the mountains of the Kosovo.

11. A Court of National Honour was now in operation in Macedonia, but he did not know any details. He said that the number of Macedonian civilians executed for crimes under the occupation and after the liberation had been small, and gave the figure of seventy. The main crimes had been material and cultural collaboration, spying, informing, &c., and he also mentioned that four men had recently been condemned to death for speculation. Naturally after the collapse of the Germans a number of opponents had been caught under arms and had been shot out of hand, and he mentioned a group of some forty Albanians captured near Skopje.

12. Macedonia had no problems with Albania and he thought there was no question of any change in frontiers.

13. As regards the Bulgarians, he was non-committal. At the time of Yugoslavia's collapse in 1941, however, the Macedonian people, who had been striving for autonomy for a long time, had felt that the chances were remote without outside help. They therefore welcomed the Bulgarians and thought they intended to set up an independent Macedonia. Few Macedonians, however, desired to be under Bulgarian domination, and when their hopes of independence were deceived the Bulgarians became more and more unpopular and many Macedonian patriots like himself took to the woods.

14. When questioned about Greece he said that Macedonia, being a part of the Yugoslav federation, had no separate foreign relations. The Macedonians realised that the main task for the moment was to beat the enemy and to allow no other considerations to come between them and that end. They therefore did not desire to embarrass in any way the Allies, and were determined not to create any trouble by meddling in Greek affairs. He added, however, that 70 per cent of the population of Greek Macedonia was Macedonian and they were being badly treated. He felt there were many problems to be settled with Greece, but these could wait until alter the war.

15. I am sending copies of this dispatch to the Resident Minister at Caserta, to His Majesty's Ambassador in Athens and to His Majesty's political representatives at Sofia and Debrecen.

I have, &c. R. C. SKRINE STEVENSON.

Enclosure

The Administrative Divisions of Macedonia

By a decree of the Anti-Fascist Skupstina of National Liberation of Macedonia, published on the 13th February, 1945, Macedonia was divided for administrative purposes into eight Okrugs as follows:-

(1) Skoplje, consisting of the areas of Tetovo, Gostivar and Rostusa.
(2) Kumanovo, consisting of the area of Kumanovo, Kratovo and Kriva Palanka.
(3) Stip, consisting of the area of Stip, Kocane, Carevo Selo and Radovis.
(4) Strumica, consisting of the area of Strumica, Berovo, Valandovo and Djevdjelija.
(5) Veles, consisting of the area of Veles, St. Nikola, Negotin and Kavadar.
(6) Prilep, consisting of the area of Prilep, Brod, Krusevo and Kicevo.
(7) Bitolj, consisting of the area of Bitolj, Resen and Morihovo.
(8) Ohrid, consisting of the area of Ohrid, Struga and Debar.
 
Not another BIG Greek Lie?

Not another BIG Greek Lie?

Not another BIG Greek Lie?



Risto the Great from the well known Macedonian website www.macedoniantruth.org wrote:



Most of these provocations are based on the rights that Greeks feel they have after Macedonian politicians decided negotiations were necessary. Since then, Macedonian politicians have been encouraging this kind of persecution of Macedonians due to their continued desire to negotiate the Macedonian identity.



Risto The Great





Mactruth wrote:



A name change by the past NATO summit or veto was forceful blackmail into changing Republic of Macedonia's name and Macedonians' ethnicity. After Greece's NATO veto on Macedonia, Greece still tries to force Macedonia into a name change through economic means and intimidation. The following point out Greece's "good neighborly relations" with Macedonia;

More found here:http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=2204957887&v=info

56) Greek protest the use of Macedonia's constitutional name in Eurovision, hosted by Germany http://macedoniaonline.eu/content/view/17435/45/
============================================
55) Greek government states they have drawn a "red line" on the name issue and again confirm they have and will continue to "veto" Macedonia until the Republic submits to its demands
http://macedoniaonline.eu/content/view/17448/2/
============================================
54) Macedonian historians find a document from 1954 where Greek government urges officials from Lerin to replace the word: "Macedonian" with "Greek"... 50 years later they state their were/is no Macedonian minority
http://guru.mk/vesti-mk/vest/makedon...donskiot-jazik
============================================
53) Greece pressures Slovenia into banning Macedonian wine because it states "Macedonia"
http://sitel.com.mk/video/biznis/slo...anje-na-grcija
============================================
52) Macedonian tourists in Greece are terrorized simply because of their identity
http://www.vest.com.mk/?ItemID=A9FBB...09426BA80F2CFB
Note: This is done by a political group called "Golden Dawn", which has done racist Nazi acts towards the Macedonians in the past. The Greek government does nothing to make sure it doesn't happen again.
============================================
51) Greek government campaign to prevent Macedonian gatherings in Northern Greece
http://www.kanal5.com.mk/default.asp...&eventId=63133
============================================
50) Greece blocks Macedonian media from entering Greece to film Ilinden celebrations in Northern Greece
http://macedoniaonline.eu/content/view/16094/2/
============================================
49) Greek-American organizations condemn recent State Department article on Macedonia entitled "Skopje Ancient Macedonia builds modern democracy"
The Article: http://www.state.gov/documents/organization/138927.pdf
Greek response: http://ahepa.org/dotnetnuke/News/New...blication.aspx
============================================
48) Greek Tour Operators have sent a demand to their Serbian counterparts that they would be able to sell Greece only if they are not selling Ohrid.
http://macedoniaonline.eu/content/view/13582/1/
============================================
47) Greek political party L.A.O.S. puts up posters stating: "NO to SKOPJANS & TURKS"
http://on.net.mk/WBStorage/Articles/...45C009D5EF.jpg
============================================
46) Greek bishop denies Macedonians while talking about Easter
http://sitel.com.mk/video/makedonija...-i-na-veligden
============================================
45) Greek ambassador lies stating the Greek Army chant was an isolated incident
http://www.mia.com.mk/default.aspx?v...lId=2&pmId=501
Note: keep in mind Greek politicians attended the service and applauded the Greek Army, also the Greek crowd applauded the Army
============================================
44) The Greek Army chants "The skin of people of Skopje will make new clothes and blood will flow from Albanian pigs"


http://translate.google.com/translat...2DD06063CB81F7
Ironic considering Albanians and Macedonians helped Greece during their independence
============================================
43) Greek Helsinki Monitor is again attacked by the Greek government
http://cm.greekhelsinki.gr/uploads/2...hm_english.doc
============================================
42) Greece states the Macedonian language should be called "Makedonski" only
http://translate.googleusercontent.c...H8SXFgl9z-AtgQ
============================================
41) Greece tries to remove Macedonian wines from Germany, simply because of its name
http://translate.google.com/translat...F6&sl=mk&tl=en
============================================
40) Greeks threaten Macedonian activists


============================================
39) President Ivanov states Greece is trying to blackmail Macedonia by using force
http://www.mia.com.mk/default.aspx?m...S+-+NEWSLETTER
============================================
38) Ex-Bulgarian President states the "name issue" is created by Greece and is shameful
http://macedoniaonline.eu/content/view/11903/2/
============================================
37) Greece Expropriating Land in Lerin, an area within Greece with a large Macedonian minority
http://micnews.com.mk/node/20626
============================================
36) Documents are found showing Greece has been paying Macedonian politicians and journalists, as well as newspapers and Greek journalists to promote anti-Macedonian agenda
http://macedoniaonline.eu/content/view/10962/2/
http://macedoniaonline.eu/content/view/11083/45/
============================================
35) Greece forces EU to "defer" the decision to begin membership talks with Macedonia
http://www.mia.com.mk/default.aspx?vId=69768741&lId=2
============================================
34) Secret documents of discussions between Dora the Explorer and Milososki before the NATO veto reveal Greece wants the name of the identity and language of Macedonian changed to ''Makedonski'' in Cyrillic only, states the history of Macedonia is problematic and should not be a focus of negotiations, and does NOT want Macedonia to change its constitutional name
http://www.ethnos.gr/article.asp?cat...&pubid=8742863
http://translate.google.com/translat...63&sl=el&tl=en
NOTE: THE ISSUE IS OUR IDENTITY, WAKE UP!
============================================
33) Greece holding the Macedonian water polo team because it has "MKD" and Macedonia on its outfits
http://macedoniaonline.eu/content/view/10557/1/
============================================
32) Greece trying to force the Macedonian water polo team to wear different robes
http://novamakedonija.com.mk/NewsDet...tIzdanie=21853
============================================
31) Papoulias of Greece states Macedonia will pay for the "monopolization" of "Macedonian" as a peoples' nationality and language, and of "Macedonia" as their country
http://www.a1.com.mk/vesti/default.aspx?VestID=116716
============================================
30) Greece threatens Iceland's EU entry due to the Macedonia documentary "A name is a name"
http://www.mhrmi.org/news/2009/november23_e.asp
http://kanal5.com.mk/default.aspx?mI...&eventId=55364
============================================
29) Greece deepens criteria, trying to force the inclusion to change the Macedonian nationality to "Northern Macedonian"
http://turkeymacedonia.wordpress.com...olution-sours/ ============================================
28) Greece threatens EU veto if Macedonia does not change its name, after Macedonia was allowed to start EU membership negotiations
http://english.cri.cn/6966/2009/10/15/2001s522837.htm#
============================================
27) Human rights defender refused entry into Greece, with no apparent reason
http://cm.greekhelsinki.gr/index.php?sec=194&cid=3459
============================================
26) Hellenic Post, owned by the Greek government, sabotage Macedonian minority election campaign by purposely failing to mail promotional materials across Northern Greece
http://www.makfax.com.mk/en-us/Details.aspx?itemID=5982
============================================
25) Greek Professor under attack for accepting 'Macedonia' dissertation
http://macedoniaonline.eu/content/view/6400/1/
============================================
24) Greece rejects creating a Macedonian and Greek "Joint Education and History committee", which would be responsible for ending the name issue
http://balkaninsight.com/en/main/news/17473/
============================================
23) Dora the Explorer states there is no Macedonian minority in Greece after a UN report exposes discrimination of Greece's Macedonian minority
http://www.skopjediem.com/index.php?...news&Itemid=81
============================================
22) Greek FM Dora the Explorer admits the decision to veto at Bucharest had been passed prior to the summer of 2007
http://www.mia.com.mk/default.aspx?v...Id=2&pageNum=2
Note: Dora the Explorer states to not focus on the past and look towards the future, yet the "name issue" itself focuses on the past
============================================
21) Greek bloggers come to Macedonia to accuse the Macedonian government of silencing a pro-Greek citizen, only to have the police called on them by "Vasko"s mother, who states the family enrolled him into a mental institution
http://balkaninsight.com/en/main/news/16818/
============================================
20) Macedonian man jailed for 4 months because he recorded a cousins Macedonian wedding in Greece
http://a1.com.mk/vesti/default.aspx?VestID=104376
============================================
19) Greek lobby causes EuroControl to pressure Macedonian Airlines to change name of Company
http://macedoniaonline.eu/content/view/5512/1/
Note: What does ethnicity have to do with the name issue?
============================================
18) Greece threatens Croatia with a EU veto because it has recognized the Macedonian minority and church as "Macedonian"
http://www.mia.com.mk/default.aspx?vId=61320877&lId=2
Note: What does ethnicity have to do with the name issue? ============================================
17) Greek Helsinki Monitor member faces "high treason" for discussing the Macedonian minority in Greece
http://macedoniaonline.eu/content/view/3525/46/
============================================
16) Greece continues to harass Greek Helsinki Monitor, which is conducting studies of the Macedonian minority in Greece
http://cm.greekhelsinki.gr/index.php?sec=194&cid=3336
============================================
15) Greek objections after Indiana Jones calls Republic of Macedonia as "Macedonia" http://www.balkantravellers.com/en/read/article/590
============================================
14) Greece wiretaps a conversation between Rainbow party and USA
http://macedoniaonline.eu/content/view/1990/1/
============================================
13) Greek journalist labels Macedonia as a "cancer" which must be exterminated
http://www.europeus.org/archive/2008...in-europe.html
============================================
11) Greece lies to their people again by stating DR Congo has reverted its recognition back to "FYROM," DR Congo officials rebuffed these claims.
http://balkaninsight.com/en/main/news/14279/
============================================
10) Greece arrests Macedonian journalists reporting the Macedonian minority incident, nullifying freedom of press
http://www.ifj.org/en/articles/ifj-c...-journalists-2
http://www.balkanalysis.com/2008/10/...new-questions/
============================================
9) Greece tries intimidating the Macedonian minority of Greece by conducting "military exercises" in Macedonian villages and arresting those who resist
http://www.eurolang.net/index.php?op...emid=1&lang=en
http://www.florina.org/news/2008/october14_e.asp
============================================
8) Greek Olympic committee protests over Macedonia name entry: The Beijing Olympic committee recognized Macedonia's Olympic entry simply as "Macedonia"
http://www.reuters.com/article/GCA-O...63721220080808
============================================
7) Greek media propagates to its citizens that Panama has reverted its recognition of Macedonia back to "FYROM", only to be negated by the Panama officials
http://macedoniaonline.eu/content/view/2657/45/
============================================
6) Greece pressures EU to ERASE "Macedonian" from EU documents
http://www.focus-fen.net/index.php?id=n139992
Note: What does ethnicity have to do with the name issue?
============================================
5) Macedonians attacked numerous times in Greece in the process forced to do embarrassing acts such as removal of "MK" from their cars, and cleaning the roads of the Greek boarder
http://macedoniaonline.eu/content/view/1348/45/
http://macedoniaonline.eu/content/view/1747/45/
Note: Greek officials (police) were involved in some abuses
============================================
4) Greece bans financial transfers from, and to Macedonia because Western Union clients worldwide fill in "Macedonia" on the "country" portion of forms needed to send or receive funds. This bothered Greece so the financial transactions were cut
http://macedoniaonline.eu/content/view/1192/45/
============================================
3) Discovery of Macedonian swastika in Greek media circulation parallel to the time of Greek swastika occurred in Skopje billboards
http://macedoniaonline.eu/content/view/1412/45/
============================================
2) Greece bans Macedonia's national flag carrier airline because flights are under the name "MAT- Macedonian Airline Transit"
http://www.balkaninsight.com/en/main/news/9464/
Note: Macedonian does not equate to the name issue.
============================================
1) Greece bans Macedonian lamb because the source of the meat is labeled "Republic of Macedonia."
http://www.sofiaecho.com/article/gre...28781/catid_68



By Mactruth posted at: http://www.macedoniantruth.org/forum/showthread.php?t=5118
 
My Thoughts on Macedonian Matters

My Thoughts on Macedonian Matters

My Thoughts on Macedonian Matters



By Kocho Sterjovski



Dear friends, the so-called “Macedonian Question” between Greece and the Republic of Macedonia, one way or another, affects the everyday life of every Macedonian from Greece. It brings tension between us and makes us argue and busy ourselves over it.



I wrote this letter, not to convince anyone, but simply to express my thoughts and give you my point of view on a question which I believe is not well understood.



In the context of things first it needs to be known that the word “KOMITA” (insurgent) comes from the Greek word “KOMA” (party), or as we say in Macedonian “KOMITET” (committee). The participants of the Internal Macedonian Revolutionary Organization (IMRO) committee, which organized the August 2nd, 1903 Ilinden Macedonian Uprising to free Macedonia from the Ottoman yoke were called “KOMITI” (insurgents).



The word “MAKEDONOMAHOS” (Macedonian fighter) can be explained in a couple of ways:



- First, if these Greek units (Greek illegal armed bands), made up of volunteers, were helping the Macedonian insurgents during the Ilinden Uprising, then they would have been friends of the Macedonian people because they would have fought together with the insurgents for Macedonia.



- Second, which for me is the correct explanation, is that these Greek units, made up of volunteers, entered Macedonian territories in 1904 and took the side of the Ottoman army and together with the Ottomans hunted down the Macedonian insurgents and tortured the Macedonian people. For me they were the “Macedono-crushers” of Macedonia, who did not want Macedonia to be an independent state and had foresight that the Ottomans would leave the Balkans and the occupied territories would be divided between Serbia, Bulgaria and Greece.



The fact that the “Makedonomahi”, the likes of “Pavlos Melas, Captain Fufas or Captain Agras”, were killed by Macedonian insurgents reveals to me that they were the enemy of Macedonia and of the Macedonian people.



And as was expected, the Ottomans left the Balkans and in 1913, in Bucharest, Romania, the agreement to partition Macedonia was signed and with that borders were erected between Serbia, Bulgaria and Greece.



Greece’s “Megali idea” to grab more territory from the Ottomans, where “supposed” Greek minorities lived, led to the “Greco-Turkish” war in the 1920’s, which the Greeks lost and were obliged to sign an agreement for population exchanges with Turkey. This arrangement contributed to the arrival of the “Prosfigi” (Christian Turkish settlers from Asia Minor) in the Aegean part of Macedonia (Greek occupied Macedonia), who today make up the majority of the population there and, supported by Greek authority, administer most of our Macedonian territory.



It needs to be mentioned that, during that period of change, many Macedonian families who would not accept the Greek occupation were driven out of their homeland.



On a different but related subject we have the deluded terms “Bulgarian state” and “Bulgarian language” in Bulgaria, which puts the Macedonian people living in Bulgaria in a similar situation as the Macedonians living in Greece.



With just a few short words the Bulgarians can be described as being a Tatar (Asian) people close to the Turks, who as horsemen, numbering a few thousand soldiers, managed to create a state inside the Byzantine territory, or more accurately, inside the territory of Northern Thrace, around the 8th century AD and who, according to Greek historians, adopted the language of the indigenous Thracians, whose language belonged to the group of Slavic languages closest or similar to the Macedonian language.



I also want to add that there is no Slavic language that exists on its own. Slavic languages are characterized by the country in which they are spoken, like Russian being spoken in Russia, Polish in Poland, Serbian in Serbia, and Macedonian in Macedonia and so on.



Slavic speaking countries cover the largest territory in Europe, starting from the Balkans in the south all the way to the Baltic in the north.



Similarities between the Macedonian and Thracian languages, which today the Bulgarians call “Bulgarian”, contributed greatly to Bulgarian propaganda in Macedonia in attempting to influence the Macedonian Uprising, convincing a select group of Macedonians to seek Bulgarian help which never materialized.



The Bulgarians had similar ideas as the Greeks and Serbians about Macedonia which led to Macedonia’s partition, results of which we all have to live with to this day. Today Macedonia is in pieces and depending on to which it belongs we hear a variety of stories.



The most interesting story for me is the one told by the Greek state, which says that the use of the name Macedonia is exclusively a Greek right which is tied to ancient Greek history and culture.



The world today wants to learn more about this ancient Greek culture and civilization. The number of tourists visiting ancient Greece, or as the advertisements claim “Glorious Greece”, is large.



There are even advertisements compelling people to fly to Turkish territories where they say it is possible to see the presence of this ancient Greek culture and civilization. Sadly however there is not even a single trip organized to Northern Greece, to Macedonia. I guess the world does not want to learn that apart from the Greek civilization, a Macedonian civilization also existed. The world does not want to hear that the Macedonian language is spoken in Macedonia; a language that is characteristic to all of Macedonia. I guess the world does not want to know that Macedonians are indigenous to Macedonia. That is why the Greeks call them “endopie” (local, indigenous).



If we Macedonians shared a common history with the Greeks in the past, why then is it that we do not share a common history today? Why do we not share our heritage as two people and why is the Republic of Macedonia not Greece’s best neighbour?



It appears that nothing in this world remains the same and everything is changed to fit the politics of the day.



Think about it, if those ancient Greeks with their high culture and civilization lived in Greece today, Greece would have been one of the most enlightened and richest countries in the world. The Acropolis is an ancient story and it appears that it is only used as Greek propaganda to brainwash people into believing in an everlasting Greece.



Maybe someone will ask me what I personally think of the so-called “Macedonian Question” being argued nowadays between Greece and the Republic of Macedonia.



For me this question does not exist. The problem is simple and singular and stems from Greece’s refusal to recognize a Macedonian minority.



This is a problem that only we the Macedonians in Greece can solve. One of the solutions, but not my solution, is for all of us to accept the Greek state’s program of assimilating the entire population of Greece into the “new Greek” nation, with a single Greek language.



My latest visit to the old country made me believe that the process of denationalizing the Macedonian nation and assimilating it into a Greek one is in full swing. A large part of the Macedonian population has already accepted the conditions of life which the Greek state forced upon it, and it would not be a lie if I told you that today the Macedonian language is on its deathbed, especially with the younger generations.



Very often I felt I was walking on delicate ground like an “unwanted” guest visiting strange people. But the people with whom I visited were not strangers, I grew up with many of them and experienced good and bad times. I even spoke with them in the Macedonian language. Let me say however that I do understand their problems and it is clear to me that they need to do what is right and best for them.



At the same time I cannot help myself but recall the words of my grandmother “Slavka” who begged me to speak to her in our Macedonian language, not only because she did not speak Greek but because Macedonian was our mother tongue. She even scolded my grandfather when he did not call her by her Macedonian name telling him, “Don’t call me “Evdoksia” that is not my name. My name is Slavka so call me by the name my godfather christened me.”



Visiting my village felt like I was watching myself on a film with my recollection of the old timers who looked after us when we were growing up. I remember old Kalina our neighbour, old Angia the soothsayer, old Naum the fisherman, old Mitre the miller, old Stojna, old Kata and old man Tasi with his interesting stories he told and re-told. All these people spoke only Macedonian and left us richer with their experience. Their lives were routed in Macedonian tradition full of beautiful stories, songs and dances which sadly today are being assimilated into the exaggerated new Greek culture.



Many say that this is done to create some kind of multiculture but how can this be called “multiculture” when it is presented as Greek and only in the Greek language.



Many of us Macedonians fail to understand that when “the pushteno” (Macedonian) dance is danced like the “levendiko” (Greek) that dance is no longer a Macedonian dance; it is now a Greek dance from Macedonia.



I believe that living with a mask on one’s face today is a great injustice. The discriminatory politics that go on between the various segments of the population in a country brings hate and mistrust between them.



In the beginning of this write-up I said that I had no aim of convincing anyone of anything but only to express my thoughts. I have no expectations that the KOMITI (Macedonian insurgents) from a bygone era will be resurrected and will free Macedonia.



It is my wish however that the Macedonian population in Greece have a good life, good “understanding and mutual respect” with the Prosfigi (colonists from Asia minor), who became citizens of Macedonia in the assembly of the Greek state.



Recognition of the Republic of Macedonia would be the right decision for Greece if it wants the needless and fanaticized problem solved which will be a relief for us and we will not have to bother one another. The Republic of Macedonia has shown that it can live with all its ethnic groups. It simply wants to exist and live in peace and understanding with all the countries in the Balkans.



Kocho Sterjovski – Kostas Stergiou



A Macedonian, citizen of Greece born in the village Ajtos, Lerin Region (Aetos Florinis) in Greece and now a citizen of Canada, living in Hamilton, Ontario.

Reference taken from Private email from Risto Stefov
 
Last edited:
Back
Top