• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

The Greek colonization of Macedonia since 1913!

Mastika said:
I'm not here to push any Greek propaganda however It's very inaccurate to say that Vlachs were more numerous then Greeks. I feel that by trying to be objective here I automaticallly assume the role of "devils advocate", so to speak.
Inaccurate are your assertions that these Patriarchist Vlachs were really 'ethnic Greeks'. Inaccurate, and unproven. You haven't provided a single reference to corroborate what you have claimed. There are several sources that speak of the Vlachs as being the main component of the so-called 'Greeks' in Macedonia, Brailsford is one among many. He even goes so far as to suggest that the (ethnic) Greeks are not a Macedonian race. But here you are, convinced and uncompromising in the distorted narrative you have chosen to adopt. Do you have the linguistic records I asked for earlier, on which you base your assertions, or not?
SoM, What do you believe the majority population was south of the Bistrica river, on the Chalcidice and around the mouth of the Struma river?, if not Greek.
Much of the Chalcidice was not densely populated as it was largely church property. Although as a trading language Romaic was spoken by town and coastal populations such as those around the mouth of the Struma, most of these people (including those south of the Bistrica) were either native Macedonians or possibly Vlach, who, since the 1700's have undergone a repressive campaign of propaganda from the Patriarchate that was trying to turn the all into good little 'Rumlari' who could only speak Romaic.

Wrap them in whatever 'Greek' clothing you want, it will remain thin and weak until you start considering other factors, such as Macedonian, Serbian, etc traders who were in Austria-Hungary and referred to as 'Greeks', such as Serbian and Bulgarian townsfolk referring to themselves as 'Greek', etc. You seem to disregard all other parallel matters that are critical for gaining the true and overall picture of what was happening during that era, and concern yourself only with Macedonia and the associated propagandas that were spewed up by Macedonia's enemies. Funnily enough, you don't dare delve into the same matters where it concerns Greece, Serbia, Bulgaria or Albania.

You can't just pick and choose which era you want to work with and dismiss all events prior. You let yourself and your research down when you do this.
 
Inaccurate are your assertions that these Patriarchist Vlachs were really 'ethnic Greeks'. Inaccurate, and unproven. You haven't provided a single reference to corroborate what you have claimed. There are several sources that speak of the Vlachs as being the main component of the so-called 'Greeks' in Macedonia, Brailsford is one among many. He even goes so far as to suggest that the (ethnic) Greeks are not a Macedonian race. But here you are, convinced and uncompromising in the distorted narrative you have chosen to adopt. Do you have the linguistic records I asked for earlier, on which you base your assertions, or not?

The statistics I have used here are taken directly from Vasil Kanchov's 1900 Macedonia - Ethnography and Statistics survey. It gives village by village descriptions on the demographics of Macedonia. His classification of the peoples of Macedonia is done by mother language, which in my honest opinion is the best descriptor of one's ethnic identity. His sources give generally accurate descriptions of each village, the city population however is more disputable. It is however Bulgarian propaganda, and thus lists the Macedonians as being Bulgarians which is obviously incorrect. This is the downfall, however if you merely swap the word bulgarians with Macedonians then I see no major issue in using the data from the work to give detailed descriptions of the demography of a certain village or town.

You can give me some quotes from people claiming that there were Vlachs posing as Greeks, etc. etc., I agree this happened. But where did these Vlachs live? Give me more detail rather then summative and innacurate statements. I know that some Vlachs posed as Greeks, Vasil Kanchov for example still counts them as Vlachs, because that was their mother language. Show me proof that Vlachs settled the regions which are marked upon demographic maps as being "greek".

Much of the Chalcidice was not densely populated as it was largely church property.

That is true, however figures such as Vasil Kanchov still managed to include 34,442 people living in the Kasandra kaza, of whom according to him 30,359 were ethnically Greek. These people were not traders but villlages and fisherman who had been speaking Greek for hundreds of years. You cannot claim them to be anythign but Greek, historically the Chalcidice has been predominantly Greek speaking for hundreds if not more years. Vlachs and other people have had not historic presence, nor were there any Vlach villages to be found on the Chalcidice 100 years ago. The only other groups to be found were Turks, who had a considerable presence in the inland and a few Macedonian villages to the South of Solun. However the bulk of the population was Greek speaking and this is depicted on every single ethnographic map of the time. I will not be posting them here however there is a considerable range presented at Wikipedia, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographic_history_of_Macedonia. (I am not endorsing the depictions of Macedonians as Bulgarians or Serbs, which is found on most maps, this is WRONG). If everyone notices the areas around the Chalcidice, the Struma delta, Thasos island and south of the Bistrica river are consistently shown to be ethnically Greek. I wonder why?! Is it possible that these people were in fact Greeks?


Although as a trading language Romaic was spoken by town and coastal populations such as those around the mouth of the Struma, most of these people (including those south of the Bistrica) were either native Macedonians or possibly Vlach, who, since the 1700's have undergone a repressive campaign of propaganda from the Patriarchate that was trying to turn the all into good little 'Rumlari' who could only speak Romaic.

Again all ethnographic maps present this population as Greek speaking, and that these people were not ethnically Macedonian or ethnically Vlach. I am talking about 1900 not in the 1700s, assimilation happens. What ever some of our ancestors were at the begginging of the 18th century is irrelevant, a persons ethnicity is defined by the ethnicity of their parents/grandparents as well as the environment in which they were raised. Please give me details, which are the assimilated villages? Which villages were once ethnically Macedonian and became 'Greek'? Where is the documented presence of Vlachs at the mouth of the Struma who assimilated into Greeks?

You are making speculations about a hypothetical demography of a region and then trying to relate it to a group which lived 200 years later. Again, please show me evidence that at the turn of the 20th Century in places such as Lokvica/Mesolakia (at the mouth of the Struma) the population was Macedonian or Vlach, ie. non-Greek.

Wrap them in whatever 'Greek' clothing you want, it will remain thin and weak until you start considering other factors, such as Macedonian, Serbian, etc traders who were in Austria-Hungary and referred to as 'Greeks', such as Serbian and Bulgarian townsfolk referring to themselves as 'Greek', etc. You seem to disregard all other parallel matters that are critical for gaining the true and overall picture of what was happening during that era, and concern yourself only with Macedonia and the associated propagandas that were spewed up by Macedonia's enemies. Funnily enough, you don't dare delve into the same matters where it concerns Greece, Serbia, Bulgaria or Albania.

It is not about wrapping them in Greek clothing, if a family has been speaking Greek for as long as their family is aware, is that family not-Greek? 'No, they must be Macedonian or Vlach.' Why? What business do people like this who have been speaking Greek for hundreds of years have with Macedonian or Vlach people?! It is ridiculous to claim that a group of people is not what they have been for hundreds of years, because of some theory that 500 years ago their ancestors may have been speaking a language other then Greek.

You are accusing me of not delving in the matters of Greece. Well, Aegean Macedonia is in Greece, I have posted many times in support of the Macedonians in Greece and of those working against racial intolerance. What you call "delving" seems to be an effort to disprove the existance of any other neighbouring ethnicity. This is ridiculous. I am not going to join in the actions of other people whose only intention is to believe that there exist no Bulgarians, no Greeks, no Albanians and no Serbs, and that us Macedonians are the only real ethnic group. This is nonsense.

You can't just pick and choose which era you want to work with and dismiss all events prior. You let yourself and your research down when you do this.

In this converstaion, I am dealing with the era around 1900. I am concerned with what people believed themselves to be and what languages people spoke at that time. What language one ancestor spoke in the 1700s is not a concern of mine, that does not define ethnicity.

I do not know how to make this any clearer, you are confusing the real Greeks with the fake Greeks found in places such as Lerin and Voden. The difference is that in the North these "greeks" were indeed Hellenised Macedonians or Hellenised Vlachs. However in the south a Greek popuation did exist. There is a reason why we never hear of Macedonians from Grevena or Satista or the Chalcidice, for the simple reason that there were no ethnic-Macedonians living there at the time. The Vlachs, as I have already mentioned were located in a select number of villages and in some colonies across a few towns.

It seems that you are not happy with the actual demographic landscape of Macedonia 100 years ago, the same one recorded in ethnographic maps, in reports and in surveys, so to counter-act this you have devised your own view of history which apparently believes that all Greeks are infact not Greeks, rather brainwashed Arvanites or Vlachs or Turks or Macedonians etc.

If these people were not Greeks, then please show me some hard evidence which documented the majority population in the Chacidice, Lapcista, Satista, Grevena, Katerini and Nigrita regions as being ethnically non-Greek, ie. ethnically Vlach or ethnically Macedonian. If you can present direct demographic information disproving my assertions about the demography of these regions then the conversation will be able to move forward.

I'm not here to support the Greek point of view/propaganda, however I disagree completely with a number of people here who believe that their own alternative version of history is the true version of history, and who dismiss methodologies/research with no good reason. Dismissing the existence of an entire ethnicity, as is frequently expressed by many contributors here, is a fanatical and historically innacurate view.
 
Mastika said;
In this converstaion, I am dealing with the era around 1900. I am concerned with what people believed themselves to be and what languages people spoke at that time. What language one ancestor spoke in the 1700s is not a concern of mine, that does not define ethnicity.

Define Ethnicity for us Mastika.
 
Mastika said;


Define Ethnicity for us Mastika.

In my opinion, ones ethnicity is defined by both ones past and ones present. It is the act of belonging to a certain ethnic group through ancestral heritage, language, culture, religion, customs, traditions, dress, kinship and often physical appearance. It arises due to a combination of nature and nurture. Upon birth, we are born into a certain ethnic group, however nurturing of this ethnic consciousness is needed for the certain ethnic identity to be perpetuated within the individual.

Can one change one's own ethnicity? I don't believe so, ethnicity is not a buffet for one to choose what they want to be, I despise people such as the Grkomans, they are kidding themselves, they will never be truly Greek. However, one can change their descendant's ethnicity through the process of assimilation, if that is the desired form of nurture. Over several generations it is possible for a family through altering of customs, language, clothing, religion, traditions, etc. to change their ethnicity, by undergoing assimilation. Personally I see race as being the only obvious barrier preventing this complete assimilation, however as society changes this too may also disapear.

Do I believe that genetics are the most important thing in defining ethnicity? Definately not. How can one define a pure Macedonian or a pure Russian?, for example. What are Macedonian genetics?, what are not? Genetics do not define ethnicity, example. If a Macedonian wakes up tomorrow and recieves a call that his father was from Sweden, should he feel Swedish? What does this person have to do with the Swedish ethnicity? Culturally nothing. Should they feel less Macedonian?, No definately not. Nurture, in my opinion, is much more important, had they not recieved that phone call they would have no idea they "weren't really" Macedonian. If people are to hold genetics in such high esteem they must realise that it is more likely to work to their detriment then their benefit.

I will give an extreme example which is close to home for many, in the aftermath of Ilinden, a large number of Macedonian women and girls were raped by Turkish soldiers. Many of these women would have been impregnated, later giving birth to children, who "genetically" would have been half-Turkish. These children grew up in Macedonia as Macedonians, imagine questioning the 'Macedonian-ness' of these people because the of the non-ethnic Macedonian origin of their biological fathers. This is ludricrous and insulting! The fact that such occurances have happened over thousands of years, coupled with consenting inter-ethnic relations and the fact that ethnicity was determined by customs, language, religion etc. and not the amount of a certain strand of genetic material in one's blood stream further exemplifies the fallacy which is determination of ethnicity by ones genes.

Although I feel that one cannot truly change their own ethnic identity during their own lifetime, over a number of generations it can and often does happen. Inter-marriage, loss of customs, loss of language and assimilation into the wider culture may mean that in 3 generations a person and their family may be no different to the "true" members of that ethnic group. Although genetically they may be "impure", they are culturally and physically (if they are of the same race) a member of the ethnic group which the family/persons assimilated into. Nurture in this case trumps nature.

That is my opinion. No doubt people will disagree. I am not a fan of those people who chose to assimilate, I hate assimilation with a passion, which I believe to be the destroyer of cultures, languages and practises. I am also against those people who voluntarily choose to leave their own culture and join another culture.
 
Mastika said:
The statistics I have used here are taken directly from Vasil Kanchov's 1900 Macedonia - Ethnography and Statistics survey.
Where does Kanchov obtain his figures from, or was it independent research on the ground level that led him to believe he knows the linguistic affiliation of each village in Macedonia? Here is what Verkovich wrote in the mid 1800's:
........Slavs are the most numerous compared to all the other people, and after them are Vlachs. The numbers of the Greeks and Turks are very small................Generaly, Greeks are located where there were once old Hellenic colonies, like : Amphipolis, Eion, Neopolis, etc, however everywhere in very small number. (S. Verkovich, 1860.)
Here is what Brailsford wrote in the early 1900's:
They are not a very numerous stock, though without their aid the Greeks would cut a poor figure among the statistics of the Macedonian races. The so-called "Greeks" of Monastir are Vlachs to a man. They form a considerable and continuous group along the Pindus range, wedged between Thessaly and Epirus. They are numerous once more between Olympus and Kara-Veria (the ancient Beroea). Elsewhere they have scattered villages, all built like Pisodéri among the rocks. Kruchevo, Neveska, and Klissoura are the most notable of these mountain-nests. (H. N. Brailsford, 1906)
The 'Greeks' in Macedonia during 1900 were essentially nothing without Vlachs. The area between Olympus and Beroea where these Vlachs live is south of the Bistrica. I will grant you some Greeks south of this river in Macedonia, but I won't be blind as you are, and accept everybody there as 'Greeks' for the sake of conclusion.
Mastika said:
That is true, however figures such as Vasil Kanchov still managed to include 34,442 people living in the Kasandra kaza, of whom according to him 30,359 were ethnically Greek. These people were not traders but villlages and fisherman who had been speaking Greek for hundreds of years. You cannot claim them to be anythign but Greek, historically the Chalcidice has been predominantly Greek speaking for hundreds if not more years.
For all you know your 'ethnically Greek' fishing villages were in that particular area for only a generation prior as descendants of refugees from elsewhere. Or are you suggesting that such a small group of people survived in the same area unscathed since the ancient Hellenic colonies in Macedonia were destroyed by Phillip II during the 4th century BC?
I will not be posting them here however there is a considerable range presented at Wikipedia, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demogra...y_of_Macedonia.......If everyone notices the areas around the Chalcidice, the Struma delta, Thasos island and south of the Bistrica river are consistently shown to be ethnically Greek. I wonder why?! Is it possible that these people were in fact Greeks?
Don't get too excited, all of your maps are either from the 19th or 20th centuries, none of them correspond to each other exactly, some differ significantly, and others still will exclude groups that existed by placing them under 'umbrella' terms such as Greeks and Bulgars. Although Verkovich refers to the Macedonian population as 'Bulgarian' (side note: he gives an explanation why he does this), see what he writes about the 'Greeks' at the mouth of the Struma:
From Demir-Hisar, where begins the big Serezian lowland, on both sides of the river Struma, till the ruins of Amphipolis by the sea, and east from Amphipolis towards Kavala, on both sides of mountain Pangea, which is today called Pernar by locals, there are more than 100 Bulgarian villages, the same number of Vlach villages, whereas there are barely 20 Greek villages. (S. Verkovich, 1860)
Should he be dismissed because you only wish to look at a narrow window of time or prefer to trust misinformed propagandist maps from the 19th and 20th century?
What ever some of our ancestors were at the begginging of the 18th century is irrelevant, a persons ethnicity is defined by the ethnicity of their parents/grandparents as well as the environment in which they were raised.
It's not irrelevant, except to people like you who readily accept over-simplified narratives which just so happen to be at the expense of your 'own' people's existence. Some of my grandparents were born in the early 1900's, they were Macedonians, their grandparents were born in the 1800's, a few generations earlier, 1700's, etc, etc, and it keeps going back. True ethnic identity doesn't just change with each century, and can endure even in the harshest of environments. There are also those of weak mind or questionable integrity.
What business do people like this who have been speaking Greek for hundreds of years have with Macedonian or Vlach people?!
What evidence do you have to indicate 'hundreds of years' of Greek-speakers in Macedonia in any given area except for some of the main towns?
Which villages were once ethnically Macedonian and became 'Greek'? Where is the documented presence of Vlachs at the mouth of the Struma who assimilated into Greeks?
I showed you Verkovich. He too considers Bistrica as a natural border but south of Macedonia is Thessaly, and there the Vlachs were even more numerous.
You are making speculations about a hypothetical demography of a region and then trying to relate it to a group which lived 200 years later.
It's not a speculation or hypothetical, prior to the 1760's 'native' Greek-speakers were basically nowhere in Macedonia. There are no census' based on language or ethnicity in those earlier years, historical accounts vary but they do also speak of Macedonians.
This is ridiculous. I am not going to join in the actions of other people whose only intention is to believe that there exist no Bulgarians, no Greeks, no Albanians and no Serbs, and that us Macedonians are the only real ethnic group.
Where have I said that no Bulgars, Greeks, Albanians or Serbs exist? I will tell you where, nowhere. So what was the point of that rant? Nothing. Have another drink of your namesake.
I'm not here to support the Greek point of view/propaganda, however I disagree completely with a number of people here who believe that their own alternative version of history is the true version of history, and who dismiss methodologies/research with no good reason.
Some of your 'methodologies' have no good reason, because you haven't properly researched all of the necessary sources. You don't sound stupid so I don't think you're ignorant, which probably means that you're still the same self-loathing and self-negating 'Macedonian' that you were the first time you arrived here.
 
Response to Soldier of Macedon.

Response to Soldier of Macedon.

Where does Kanchov obtain his figures from, or was it independent research on the ground level that led him to believe he knows the linguistic affiliation of each village in Macedonia. Here is what Verkovich wrote in the mid 1800's: "........Slavs are the most numerous compared to all the other people, and after them are Vlachs. The numbers of the Greeks and Turks are very small................Generaly, Greeks are located where there were once old Hellenic colonies, like : Amphipolis, Eion, Neopolis, etc, however everywhere in very small number. (S. Verkovich, 1860.)"

I find it hard to take such an expert seriously if he is claiming that the number of Turks is very small, given that in 1900, according to Kanchov, they were the second most numerous group at c.500,000. Interestingly Verkovich in 1889 puts the number of Greeks at 222,740 whilst claiming that there were 240,264 Turks. 200,000+ does not seem like a “small” number to me at all. Regardless, I seriously question data put forward by a man who believes that there were more Vlachs then Turks. Simply by comparing the 40 or so Vlach settlements with the hundreds and hundreds of Turkish speaking villages, one can see that his assertion is incorrect. He doesn’t even mention where this Vlach population is populated, if the Vlachs can outnumber the Turks who comprised c. 500,000 people you would assume that they occupied a large part of Macedonia.


Here is what Brailsford wrote in the early 1900's: “They are not a very numerous stock, though without their aid the Greeks would cut a poor figure among the statistics of the Macedonian races. The so-called "Greeks" of Monastir are Vlachs to a man. They form a considerable and continuous group along the Pindus range, wedged between Thessaly and Epirus. They are numerous once more between Olympus and Kara-Veria (the ancient Beroea). Elsewhere they have scattered villages, all built like Pisodéri among the rocks. Kruchevo, Neveska, and Klissoura are the most notable of these mountain-nests. (H. N. Brailsford, 1906)”

Brailsford is right in labelling the “Greeks” of Bitola as Vlachs, in essence that is what they were. So too, were the “Greeks” of Lerin or of Voden, however I am not talking about sell-out Vlachs, rather real Greeks who lived 100 kilometres to the South. A number of people, not specifically you, have confused their experiences with Grkoman “Greeks” with those of real ethnic-Greeks from Southern Macedonia.

Brailsford is wrong in claiming that the Vlachs lived between Olympus and Kara-Veria/Ber. The only Vlach villages of the region, were a compact group comprising of Gorno Šel, Dolno Šel, Crkovchan, Maruša, Doljani, Valoda, Kserolivadon and Kastanja with c. 10,000 inhabitants (1900AD) and were to the East of Negus and Ber, and to the north of the Bistrica river.

If one happens to draw direct line from Olympus to Ber, the only villages within the proximity will be Greek villages. Apart from the listed 8, there are no more Vlach villages in the region (except for some on the Southern slopes of Olympus, thus falling outside of Macedonia).

The 'Greeks' in Macedonia during 1900 were essentially nothing without Vlachs. The area between Olympus and Beroea where these Vlachs live is south of the Bistrica. I will grant you some Greeks south of this river in Macedonia, but I won't be blind as you are, and accept everybody there as 'Greeks' for the sake of conclusion.

Its not about being blind for the sake of conclusion, its about making a conclusion based on the evidence presented. The Vlachs had a limited presence in Macedonia confined to 40-50 mountains villages (through all parts of Macedonia) along with some small colonies established in the local towns.

“The area between Olympus and Beroea where these Vlachs live is south of the Bistrica.”

This is not true, please consult a topographic/accurate ethnographic map. You will notice that all of the Vlach villages of the region were located to the West of Ber/Negush and to the North of the Bistrica river. The three Vlach villages around Olympus are located outside the geographical limits of Macedonia.


For all you know your 'ethnically Greek' fishing villages were in that particular area for only a generation prior as descendants of refugees from elsewhere. Or are you suggesting that such a small group of people survived in the same area unscathed since the ancient Hellenic colonies in Macedonia were destroyed by Phillip II during the 4th century BC?

Some may have been newly founded villages (30 years or so), however it is more likely that many were founded much earlier then that. Both our comments (where I have quoted you, and my own comments in this paragraph) are speculation however. I’m not suggesting that they are the descendants of people from 400BC, however many towns such as Poligeros on the Chalcidice have around for hundreds of years, during which time the population has been recorded as being Greek speaking. There is no evidence of Vlach’s populating the Chalcidice, yet the population emerged as Greek speaking, I can only see one plausible explanation.

Don't get too excited, all of your maps are either from the 19th or 20th centuries, none of them correspond to each other exactly, some differ significantly, and others still will exclude groups that existed by placing them under 'umbrella' terms such as Greeks and Bulgars.

All the maps vary, this is 100%. However the later maps tended to get more accurate, as better studies were organised, and more homogenous. The maps over and over again show Macedonians as the majority group around Lerin, Kostur, Negush, Voden, Kukush, Demir Hisar/Valovista, north of Ser and north of Drama. Turks are consistenly shown around Kavala, Pravista, Sari Shaban, around Bogdanska Planina/Suho village near Solun, between Kukush and Ser, South of Ostrovsko Ezero, Kajlar and north of Kozani. Greeks are consistently shown around Grebena, Satista, Lapcista, Katerini, Serfidze, the Chalcidice and the mouth of the Struma. The Megleno-Romanians and the Vlachs near Ber/Negush are also generally shown.

Although individual maps have flaws (generally minor ones), the general distribution of the ethnicities are continuously corroborated by consecutive maps. As of yet I have not seen a map which placed people under umbrella terms such as Greeks (generally due to affiliation with the Patriachate) and as Bulgarians (due to affiliation with the Exarchate). All maps seems to correctly classify the Greeks as those being ethnically Greek, not as hellenised Macedonian or as Macedonians who were affiliated to the Patriachate.

You haven’t been able to discredit the maps which seem to back up the point I am trying to make.

Although Verkovich refers to the Macedonian population as 'Bulgarian' (side note: he gives an explanation why he does this), see what he writes about the 'Greeks' at the mouth of the Struma: “From Demir-Hisar, where begins the big Serezian lowland, on both sides of the river Struma, till the ruins of Amphipolis by the sea, and east from Amphipolis towards Kavala, on both sides of mountain Pangea, which is today called Pernar by locals, there are more than 100 Bulgarian villages, the same number of Vlach villages, whereas there are barely 20 Greek villages. (S. Verkovich, 1860)”

Not only does Verkovich ‘forget’ about the large Turkish presence in this region, however he claims that there were around 100 Vlach villages in the region. Which villages exactly were populated by Vlachs? From my understanding the only considerable presence of Vlachs in this region was in Serska Dzumaja and Karli Kyoy (20% Vlasi), Oravishte with 100 Vlachs (44% of the village), Boren near Drama with 18% Vlasi and Prosochen with 16% Vlasi. In the region described by Verkovich out of a total population of 296,339 (Ser/Demir Hisar/Z’hna/Drama/Kavala/Pravista kaza’s) it seems that there are only 4,802 Vlachs in total (1.6%). Although there were probably more then is counted by Kanchov, especially in the Urban centres, by no means does this support Verkovich’s claim of c. 100 Vlach villages compared to only c. 20 Greek ones.

I’m not going to use this data as the “be all and end all”, I acknowledge that it too, is has its flaws. However I have never heard of such a large group of Vlach’s living in this area of East Macedonia, nor have I come across the demographic data to back it up. Given Verkovich’s track record about underestimating the number of Turks, it seems that here he has confused Turks with Vlachs. If not, please tell me which villages were the Vlach villages? Where did they live? Why is it that in 1860 there were 100 Vlach villages whilst in 1900 there was not one ethnically Vlach village?

Should he be dismissed because you only wish to look at a narrow window of time or prefer to trust misinformed propagandist maps from the 19th and 20th century?

He should not be dismissed, but rather if his work is to be taken more seriously it needs to be backed up with facts supporting his view. His claims of ‘one hundred Vlach villages’ and of ‘the number of Turks being small’, are very easily disputed, as I have done here, and are borderline ludricrous.

Interesting you bring up the issue of the propagandist maps, sure they show propaganda by depicting Macedonians as Serbs and Bulgarians, but what benefit would a Serbian/Bulgarian/Pan-Slavist get out of showing ‘Hellenised Vlachs’ or ‘Hellenised Macedonians’ as Greeks? You would assume that in order to discredit the Greek propaganda at the time the ethnographers would show the Greek population as being either Vlach or Macedonian, ie. Non-Greek. It is interesting that none of these ethnographers, many of whom were anti-Greek, chose to represent this ‘non-Greek’ population as a Greek-speaking one. One would assume that the anti-Greek propagandists would have made the link that you have made here about these people’s “true” ethnicity.

It's not irrelevant, except to people like you who readily accept over-simplified narratives which just so happen to be at the expense of your 'own' people's existence. Some of my grandparents were born in the early 1900's, they were Macedonians, their grandparents were born in the 1800's, a few generations earlier, 1700's, etc, etc, and it keeps going back. True ethnic identity doesn't just change with each century, and can endure even in the harshest of environments. There are also those of weak mind or questionable integrity.

We don’t know what ethnic identity our great-great-great-grandparents really were, especially in a time of virtually no record keeping. If people didn’t want their past to be known they would simply not pass that information on to their children. I agree with you, true ethnic identity can endure the harshest environments, however no ethnic identity has existed from the beginning of time. That means in everyone’s ancestry there was a period where the ancestors had an identity which doesn’t correspond with the identity of their descendants in the 21st century. No doubt these ancestors had a different form of identity, whether it was tribal, or religious, or cultural, no ethnic identity is static.

What I am saying is not at the detriment of my own people’s existence, rather they are two separate matters. The existence of Greeks in Macedonia 100 years ago does not reduce our right to be known as Macedonians nor does it reduces our ‘Macedonian-ness’. What will affect us negatively however is the creation of a national myth which does not correctly reflect historical actualities.

What evidence do you have to indicate 'hundreds of years' of Greek-speakers in Macedonia in any given area except for some of the main towns?

Some of the earliest maps such as Ami Boué 1847 and Pavel Jozef Šafárik 1842 depiction’s of the Balkans display this indication of the Greek presence in the 3 zones which I keep talking about. I am not a fan of the religious based affiliations which existed before this time which unfairly classified people as being Greek merely based on affiliation to the Patriarchate.

I showed you Verkovich. He too considers Bistrica as a natural border but south of Macedonia is Thessaly, and there the Vlachs were even more numerous.

This doesn’t answer my question. Verkovich possibly chooses to use the Bistrica as a border because it broke up the Macedonian-Turkish speaking population of the North with the Greek speaking population to the south of the river. Later academic developments however chose to include the area south of the Bistrica as apart of Macedonia, even if the demography was completely different to the Northern region.

It's not a speculation or hypothetical, prior to the 1760's 'native' Greek-speakers were basically nowhere in Macedonia. There are no census' based on language or ethnicity in those earlier years, historical accounts vary but they do also speak of Macedonians.

Once again, I am looking at the period around the turn of the 20th century. In the 1700s the area known as ‘Macedonia’ had not yet been established, ie. It did not take the shape of the Macedonia we know today. Historical accounts do differ, however again your statement is very broad. The 1700s is very under documented and therefore any conclusions made from that period a potentially affected by the bias of the author. If by “basically nowhere” you mean no-where except the Chalcidice, mouth of the Struma and south of the Bistrica, then you are probably right in your conclusion. The line between Macedonian-Turkish and Greek speakers may indeed have been 10 or 20 kilometres to the south of the established positions by 1900, however after 140 or roughly 7 generations it is hard to claim these people as being anything but Greek. SoM if you found out that in 1860 your family decided to stop being Albanians (for example) and began to assimilate into Macedonians, would you suddenly stop feeling Macedonian? Would you feel Albanian all of a sudden? Should you feel Albanian all of a sudden?

Where have I said that no Bulgars, Greeks, Albanians or Serbs exist? I will tell you where, nowhere. So what was the point of that rant? Nothing. Have another drink of your namesake.

This comment was not directed at you, you are smarter than this, but at others who truly believe in the non-existence of neighbouring ethnicities.

Some of your 'methodologies' have no good reason, because you haven't properly researched all of the necessary sources. You don't sound stupid so I don't think you're ignorant, which probably means that you're still the same self-loathing and self-negating 'Macedonian' that you were the first time you arrived here.

I am interested in this “self-loathing and self-negating 'Macedonian'” statement. I am proud to be Macedonian. I have no hesitations in saying this, I do not loath my ethnicity, nor the Macedonian heritage which my ancestors were apart of. Such a statement should be reserved for a Grkoman, who is truly ashamed of their heritage and seeks solice in the ethnicity of a foreign group. This is not appropriate for someone who simply chooses to question the exaggerations which have arisen.

You have acknowledged that there were in fact Greeks living to the south of the Bistrica and posted a source in support of the Greek presence around the Struma (I am assuming that you agree with Brailsford assertion that Greek villages were in existence there). Now if you add to these groups the population of Greeks on the Chalcidice, is not possible for them to have outnumbered the Vlachs?, who after all lived only in a small number of settlements.
 
You can give me some quotes from people claiming that there were Vlachs posing as Greeks, etc. etc., I agree this happened. But where did these Vlachs live? Give me more detail rather then summative and innacurate statements. I know that some Vlachs posed as Greeks, Vasil Kanchov for example still counts them as Vlachs, because that was their mother language. Show me proof that Vlachs settled the regions which are marked upon demographic maps as being "greek".



It`s not only claims of "some people" as you said. It`a fact since there are 100s of incidents reported by Vlachs to Turkish authorities between 1850s to 1913.

I already translated some of the government archive records at this message;

http://www.macedoniantruth.org/forum/showthread.php?p=51391#post51391




All of these are facts. There are names, dates and detailed reports of the incidents with the signed testimony of the eyewitnesses.

Yesterday`s poor Vlachs but today`s proud Hellenes in Greece should read all of these. They can even find the testimonies of their own grandparents since it`s "that" many.

Especially in the last 10 years of Turkish reign in Aegean Macedonia, there was no public order or security outside Salonika city center and there was lots of armed Greek bandit groups who terrorized in Vlach and Macedonian villages. They were forcibly trying to convert them to accept Greek identity by kidnapping, raping and murdering their priests and teachers.

In one archival record, it was saying that Greek bandits gathered all Vlachs to their church in some village and orders them to not speak in Vlach language anymore. They murder their priest, burns every bible and documents written in Vlach language. Then they kidnap 2 men by telling them that if they don't speak and pray in Greek language when they return to the village again, they will kill the kidnapped villagers.


Now Mastika, while the situation was like that in Aegean Macedonia, do you think that it was possible to gather correct data about who is Macedonian, who is Vlach, who is Greek from there? These poor victims had to accept Greek identity or die, especially after 1890s.
 
Last edited:
It`s not only claims of "some people" as you said. It`a fact since there are 100s of incidents reported by Vlachs to Turkish authorities between 1850s to 1913.

I already translated some of the government archive records at this message;

All of these are facts. There are names, dates and detailed reports of the incidents with the signed testimony of the eyewitnesses.

Yesterday`s poor Vlachs but today`s proud Hellenes in Greece should read all of these. They can even find the testimonies of their own grandparents since it`s "that" many.

Especially in the last 10 years of Turkish reign in Aegean Macedonia, there was no public order or security outside Salonika city center and there was lots of armed Greek bandit groups who terrorized in Vlach and Macedonian villages. They were forcibly trying to convert them to accept Greek identity by kidnapping, raping and murdering their priests and teachers.

In one archival record, it was saying that Greek bandits gathered all Vlachs to their church in some village and orders them to not speak in Vlach language anymore. They murder their priest, burns every bible and documents written in Vlach language. Then they kidnap 2 men by telling them that if they don't speak and pray in Greek language when they return to the village again, they will kill the kidnapped villagers.

Now Mastika, while the situation was like that in Aegean Macedonia, do you think that it was possible to gather correct data about who is Macedonian, who is Vlach, who is Greek from there? These poor victims had to accept Greek identity or die, especially after 1890s.

Very true, incidents against Vlachs did happen, sadly. However I am not talking about Hellenised Vlachs, regardless of whether they were forced or not. Sadly many Vlachs were indeed subject to discrimination due to their ethnic identity. However, I am talking about those Greeks who at the turn of the 20th century were not Hellenised Vlachs or Hellenised Macedonians, but people who knew only how to speak Greek and only of themselves having a Greek-speaking heritage, mainly found in the three regions I have been talking about.

Do I think it is possible to gather correct data? "Correct" is not the right word, as "accurate as is possible" is better wording. Yes I do believe that this is possible. It is well documented which villages were Vlach at the turn of the century, I have already listed them here a number of times. Whether or not some villages were forced to adopt Hellenism, the inhabitants are still counted as Vlachs, which is what they truly were. Even if some were Grkoman's or Romanian-leaning, Kanchov still counts them as Vlachs. Dimitar Mishev in 1905 again counts them as Vlachs, with those who were either Romanian or Greek leaning. Greek statistics from 1904 count them as "Vlachophones", either as "Greeks" or "Romanians". Despite assimilative preassures placed against many, there are still numerous records of the existence of both Hellenised and non-Hellenised Vlachs. By using the population of the villages we can arrive at good estimates, it is the cities/towns where a larger discrepancy can be caused. However by using village-by-village data one can attain more accurate ethnographic maps etc.

Of course we will not arrive at the exact number of any group, we can get a rough idea of the size of the population and the distribution of the group. The limited number of Vlachs and Vlach settlements puts them way out of reach of overtaking Greeks as the third most populous group, which is the point I have been trying to make here. However the upside, this makes accounting for the entire Vlach population easier due to the limited number of settlements.

Now, If you did a survey of the "Greeks" in Aegean Macedonia in 1955 you will find that many of them were 'second-generation Greeks' with their grand-parents in fact being Aromanians or Macedonians, who had been Hellenised.
 
Last edited:
Very true, incidents against Vlachs did happen, sadly. However I am not talking about Hellenised Vlachs, regardless of whether they were forced or not. Sadly many Vlachs were indeed subject to discrimination due to their ethnic identity. However, I am talking about those Greeks who at the turn of the 20th century were not Hellenised Vlachs or Hellenised Macedonians,
Then you must mean Hellenised Albanians.


but people who knew only how to speak Greek and only of themselves having a Greek-speaking heritage, mainly found in the three regions I have been talking about.
So the language used by people by itself identifies their ethnicity?
Do you know for sure these people that have a greek speaking heritage actualy inherited Greek from there papoo and yaya? Its a long time between turn of the 19th century (when the west inserted the idea that they actually are sons, grandchildren and relatives of Pericles, Demostenisa and sons of Socrates.) and the turn of the 20th century.
 
Mastika,
Would it be possible for you to provide the sources you studied that led you to the conclusion that there were real Greeks living in Macedonia prior to the 19th Century? Also, what about Vaillant’s and Giannelli’s work regarding the Macedonian language as it existed during the 16th Century? You mentioned that Macedonia wasn’t truly thought of as Macedonia (or Macedonian) prior to a certain point in time and, yet, languages are typically classified according to the regions and/or ethnicities of the people who speak them. What sources did you read to form such a belief? If the Macedonian language existed during the 16th Century (as a living language), what about the 15th Century? At what point in time was what is considered today to be Macedonian not Macedonian and what was this language and ethnicity classified as?
 
The problem is that non-Greek estimates of the number of 'Greeks' in Macedonia have them at below 10% or thereabouts of the total population consistently.

Now if any part of this 10% includes ethnic Vlachs, partially Hellenized Macedonians and others - just how many 'Greeks' should we expect find in Macedonia around 1900 ?

Very, very few.
 
The Kozani area apparently was almost exclusively Turks from Konya, while the inhabitants of Kozani itself who were mostly of Vlach origin.

"and in Shatishta and Kozhani in which two latter towns the hellenized Vlachs form the strongest part of the Greek population" - Wace. A

The area around Olympus was also settled by Vlachs, many vlachs migrated from Livadi (a center which was the biggest in the area) to Katerini.
 
Mastika, you failed to answer my question with regard to Kanchov. Where does he obtain his figures from? Or was it independent research on the ground level that led him to believe he knows the linguistic affiliation of each village in Macedonia?
Mastika said:
I find it hard to take such an expert seriously if he is claiming that the number of Turks is very small, given that in 1900, according to Kanchov, they were the second most numerous group at c.500,000.
Verkovich may well have given a higher figure for both Turks and Greeks decades later, but he travelled through Macedonia in the years prior to 1860 in the citations I provided, are you aware of the events that took place between then and 1900? If so, do you know what the consequences were for Macedonia? I will give you a hint, the answer is in your sentence quoted above.
Brailsford is wrong in claiming that the Vlachs lived between Olympus and Kara-Veria/Ber.
Is he also wrong when says his:
The Greeks are not a Macedonian race, though they have a powerful Church and a considerable party in Macedonia. If one takes the linguistic test there are practically no villages in European Turkey whose mother-tongue is Greek, save along the coasts of the Aegean and the Black Sea, in the peninsulas of Chalcidice, and the Thracian Chersonnese, and in the extreme south of Macedonia near the Thessalian frontier.
Brailsford himself admits that the Vlachs were not a very numerous stock, but also states that "without their aid the Greeks would cut a poor figure among the statistics of the Macedonian races". He was in a better position to know this than either of us.
Some may have been newly founded villages (30 years or so), however it is more likely that many were founded much earlier then that. Both our comments (where I have quoted you, and my own comments in this paragraph) are speculation however. I’m not suggesting that they are the descendants of people from 400BC, however many towns such as Poligeros on the Chalcidice have around for hundreds of years, during which time the population has been recorded as being Greek speaking.
I suspect there would have more than a mere 'some', aside from Poligeros which other town in Chalcidice has been around for centuries? Also, can you show me a record from centuries ago indicating that people from Poligeros spoke Greek as a mother-tongue?
All the maps vary, this is 100%. However the later maps tended to get more accurate, as better studies were organised, and more homogenous..........As of yet I have not seen a map which placed people under umbrella terms such as Greeks (generally due to affiliation with the Patriachate) and as Bulgarians (due to affiliation with the Exarchate)........
Later maps also received a flood of information that emanated from refined and rampant propaganda machines in the service of Greece, Serbia and Bulgaria. Their accuracy is immediately compromised. Who do you think these foreign cartographers got their sources from, if not those representing their respective millets in the empire and of course the Ottoman census' which were based on religious affiliation? Few of them travelled all or most of the villages and towns in Macedonia to draw such 'accurate' statistics which you so blindly subscribe to.
You haven’t been able to discredit the maps which seem to back up the point I am trying to make.
The point you're trying to make is based on misconceptions, and that renders your point inaccurate. Can you show me some equivalent maps that date from the 18th century and prior?
Not only does Verkovich ‘forget’ about the large Turkish presence in this region, however he claims that there were around 100 Vlach villages in the region.
He doesn't 'forget' the Turks, they simply weren't there in such numbers during the mid 19th century. The Vlach villages, on the other hand, which were there (according to Verkovich who travelled through Macedonia during the same period), are all 'Greek' villages by the beginning of the 20th century. And you still can't see what is going on.
However I have never heard of such a large group of Vlach’s living in this area of East Macedonia, nor have I come across the demographic data to back it up.
Have you went through all records and documentation since the Roman invason of Macedonia to confirm there have been no settlements in the area?
Interesting you bring up the issue of the propagandist maps, sure they show propaganda by depicting Macedonians as Serbs and Bulgarians, but what benefit would a Serbian/Bulgarian/Pan-Slavist get out of showing ‘Hellenised Vlachs’ or ‘Hellenised Macedonians’ as Greeks? You would assume that in order to discredit the Greek propaganda at the time the ethnographers would show the Greek population as being either Vlach or Macedonian, ie. Non-Greek.
For a Serb or Bulgar to accept the existence of Macedonians would go against their own propaganda. It was in their greater interest to carve Macedonia between themselves and Greece rather than support the Macedonians, because the latter option would leave them with no prize of additional territory. I can certainly see the (stupid) reasons they had and indeed used in their cunning efforts to justify 'their' places in Macedonia.
We don’t know what ethnic identity our great-great-great-grandparents really were, especially in a time of virtually no record keeping.
To each his own Mastika, as far as my inquiries have went with some relatives using the names of ancestors to build a family tree, I can (at the moment) go back to my great-great-great grandparents, about the mid to late 1800's, my family (on both sides) has resided in the same area since memory and there is nothing about settling the area. The chances that the people that came before them were anything other than Macedonians are slim.
The existence of Greeks in Macedonia 100 years ago does not reduce our right to be known as Macedonians nor does it reduces our ‘Macedonian-ness’. What will affect us negatively however is the creation of a national myth which does not correctly reflect historical actualities.
The 'Greeks' in Macedonia 100 years ago were overwhelmingly non-Greek by mother-tongue. What affects us negatively is the element in our society today that buys into outdated anti-Macedonian garbage while ignoring all of the facts and set precedences that expose the flaws in their 'estimations' and, more importantly, paints the picture of disunity among Macedonians.
In the 1700s the area known as ‘Macedonia’ had not yet been established, ie. It did not take the shape of the Macedonia we know today.
The frontiers of Macedonia have altered over the years, I don't see your point.
SoM if you found out that in 1860 your family decided to stop being Albanians (for example) and began to assimilate into Macedonians, would you suddenly stop feeling Macedonian? Would you feel Albanian all of a sudden? Should you feel Albanian all of a sudden?
Give me a scenario of when an Albanian in the 1860's would start being a Macedonian, and by what reason and incentive? It was the Macedonians who were being forced to assimilate into other groups.
I am interested in this “self-loathing and self-negating 'Macedonian'” statement. I am proud to be Macedonian. I have no hesitations in saying this, I do not loath my ethnicity, nor the Macedonian heritage which my ancestors were apart of. Such a statement should be reserved for a Grkoman, who is truly ashamed of their heritage and seeks solice in the ethnicity of a foreign group. This is not appropriate for someone who simply chooses to question the exaggerations which have arisen.
You don't see any collective history prior to the 19th century for the nation you're apparently so 'proud' to call yourself a part of, yet you have bought many of the lies that deny Macedonian existence and the accurate reflection of that existence.
 
Despite all this posted in this thread, we still have the Greeks using that old "territorial aspirations" chestnut.

Of course, they quite easily forget their own "territorial aspirations", including even those against the Republic of Macedonia.

Here's a paid advertisement by the Greek community in Australia going back some 15 years or so...

greek_territorial_ambition_90s.jpg
 
Thanks Rogi,
I never knew "Slavs" existed in Macedonia.
Does anyone know what they look like? They are obviously not Bulgarians or Serbians if we are to accept that seemingly brilliant advertisement from theo Chris.

Is it too late to send them my name to win a trip to Greek Macedonia?
 
They have their perspective that they want to promote, but this ad was factually innacurate. They've become a little more sophisticated in their deviousness these days, and in the absence of Macedonians to provide counter-arguments, are getting away with murder... literally.
 
You have eys but you cannot see.:sleeping:

Take those 65 years then go back only a further 45 years....where's your Greece??

At 1890 or 1900 Greece was, you know where. What’s interesting is that all my ancestors were Greeks, yet they were outside Greece. It’s not hard to guess what would come next, since Ottoman Empire was collapsing.

No different to how the Bulgrian State was created in the 1800s it goes on record that people wanted and faught for an autonomous Macedonian State. This is around the time when the other Balkan states were created.

The only difference is we had no allies to see it through.

Actually, in your case the difference is that it is not so much on record. Also, you shouldn’t confuse the idea of an autonomous multi-national Macedonia, with the idea of an ethnic-Macedonia (imagined as a national country, populated by ethnic-Macedonians, i.e. your people). Muslim (Turks), Bulgarians, Greeks, Jews were the main entities who had to live together. Back then, your people were considered a key-factor population who was in-between, was illiterate, had no leaders or clear identity and would easily be either Hellenized or Burglarized. (I omit Serbia, because I don’t know much about the Northern areas).

Bulgarian, Greek or Serbian feeling was only created in Macedonia by propaganda. You are part of that propaganda. Congratulations and bravo for upholding that. You must feel proud of that 100 or so years of history of deep concern and propaganda.

Yes, but ethnic-Macedonian consciousness is also a propaganda (that came too late).

Macedonians have wanted to live as free men and women for thousands of years. Free from any oppression. The oppression came from the Greek city states as well not only Persians. That is the Macedonian History.

I don’t know if Phillip oppressed Thebes or vice versa. Who cares now? Actually, the most glorified moment of Macedonians was a conquest beyond belief, so you have to be kidding.

If Macedonia had a true Greek history your Athenian government wouldn't have had to change so many names of people places and things in a short time. :no:
Some names were correctly changed back to their initial names (e.g. Thessaloniki or Edessa). In case of villages etc. you are right. In case of people names you are more than right. They should change it only if they wanted to. Even today, they should be let, to change their names back, if they want.
__________________________________
Odysseas Elytis - Our name is our soul
 
Here is what is interesting.

Thessaloniki on Macedonians: ethnic-Macedonia, ethnic-Macedonians, i.e. your people, ethnic-Macedonian consciousness.

Thessaloniki on Greeks: Greece, Greeks, Greece, Greeks.

---------------------

Personally, I have had enough. You've continued to behave like an idiot ad infinitum, and have show a complete lack of respect for Macedonians by constantly including prefixes to our Macedonian name when not required or out of context. You have never applied the same idiotic standards to Greeks. You have had ample time and notification to stop this, but you haven't. Consequently, I can only consider you one of two things, an idiot, or a racist (possible a hybrid of both).

You have been relieved of your membership from the MTO for a week, take note of what I have just written. The next time you enter the MTO and start talking in the following manner: Greeks, Bulgarians, ethnic-Macedonians, Serbs, Albanians, etc - Will be your last. I have had it with people like you who deliberately pretend to be stupid and waste my time with such miniscule matters that a primary school child would have grasped by now.
 
I think that this can be added here.

It is a record of a conversation between the Greek Prime Minister, Venizelos and Mr. Harold Nicolson of the British foreign office. The letter is dated January 22, 1925.


“He (Veniselos) did not think that any federation between Bulgaria and Serbia was practical politics for the moment, although he admitted that it might come one day and that when it came the position of Greek Macedonia would become precarious. If, however, Greece could have ten, or even five years of peace in which to populate the district (with Greeks) and to introduce British and American capital...then she would be able to look with less anxiety towards the north”.

Source: National Archives of Australia; A 981/4, ‘Record of Conversation between N. Veniselos and Mr. Nicolson’, Item, 176601
 
Last edited:
Personally, I have had enough.
No, you haven’t. Neither have I.
You've continued to behave like an idiot ad infinium, and have show a complete lack of respect for Macedonians by constantly including prefixes to our Macedonian name when not required or out of context.
It was certainly NOT out of context, you can see that if you exclude prefixes, then read again my second paragraph and try to see if it makes sense. I didn’t know that after Slav-Macedonian, now the term ethnic-Macedonian has become derogatory. The Rainbow Party doesn’t know it either, because they give a fierce fight to establish it in Greece. I never accepted the term (and never bought the arguments behind it); funnily, I used it because YOU asked me to. So, I don’t have a problem, I won’t use it again.
You have never applied the same idiotic standards to Greeks. You have had ample time and notification to stop this, but you haven't.
Actually, the same questions could be applied in the case of Greece or Bulgaria, but their national identity was not questionable by 1900, for various reasons. If someone was Christian and Bulgarian speaker and had joined the Bulgarian Exarche, then I guess he was Bulgarian.
Consequently, I can only consider you one of two things, an idiot, or a racist (possible a hybrid of both).
For you, every Greek is a combination of racism and stupidity, so it doesn’t really matter.
_________________________________
Odysseas Elytis - Our name is our soul
 
Back
Top