Vangelovski
New member
What I have said is self explanatory.
In your own mind.
I perfectly understand you OziMak.
Turks in Germany don't have the natural right of self governing, cause they are not in their indegous theritory, they are not the natural inheritors of the given theritory. Period.
To be more precise, the Turks in Germany can have it two ways:
- Be on working Visum, which allows them to work and stay as long as they want in Germany, but they don't have the right to vote. If they break the law, the Visum is no more valid and they will be thrown away from Germany.
- To take German citizenship and take whole part into the German society underlieing on German laws and regulations. If breaking the law, they will be judged as any other German according to the German law. That can't be counted as self governing. All they can do is join to one of the existing German parties or create own, as they did in 2008, but it is still under German law, and if they get the votes, will have representatives in the German Bundestag, speak German and obay German laws.
So, they don't have the right to self govern them in Germany, which is absolutely reasonable and acceptable. If anyone else says something else, so he should go to the German chancellor Merkel and tell her about it, and than post her reply here. I know exactly what kind of reply that will be.
That should have been the case with Kosovo, but that does not apply on the Balkan, as we can see from the beginning post on this thread.
Got bewahre, dass hier die Balkanregelung angewandt werden soll. Dann haben wir gleich den dritten Weltkrieg.
By denying one people the right to self-government you are denying everyone's right to self-government including the right of Macedonians in Greece, Bulgaria and Albania. Self-government or self-determination is not based on ethnicity, civil law or location - it is a natural right.
Rather, you should make the argument that we have a natural right to self-defence. Even Israel does not question the Palestinian's right to self-determination - because that would be idiotic and undermine their own right to self-determination. Rather, they use the argument of self-defence to maintain the integrity of their state.
At the end of the day, this is the only mechanism that will ensure Macedonian sovereignty over western Macedonia - not some contradictory argument about natural rights not applying to Albanians, but at the same time applying to Macedonians. Neither is this argument of natural rights not applying to Albanians going to physically stop any future declaration of independence or the current disintegration of the Macedonian state.
Why argue against our own right to self-determination when we should be arguing in favour of a competing right that supports and does not undermine our own self-government?