This guys article stands out the most for me :14: :macedonia
Modern Hellenism and Traditions of Intolerance
By Ivan Hristovski
In the decades following its foundation in the 19th century, modern Greece developed extreme notions of ethno-nationalism that have attempted to ensure the multi-cultural masses adhere to the myth that the modern Greek citizen is indeed the descendent of the dead ancient of Hellenes. While many commentators are at present discussing Greece’s catastrophic economic situation; we are going to focus here on identity problems that stem from the early 19th century when fundamentalist national myths were invented for Greece by European philhellenes, especially the German enthusiasts.
We shall begin by stating the obvious: extreme forms of nationalism are breeding grounds for racism. Hellenism, by definition of one of its German creators, Johan Gustav Droysen, represents an intolerant assimilatory culture that has not experienced any ruptures, from ancient to modern times (1). This Hellenism theory that Droysen concocted was taken by the chief historical revisionist of Greece in the mid-nineteenth century, Konstantinos Paparrigopoulos and was carved into separate eras which he dubbed as - Ancient Hellenism, Macedonian Hellenism, Byzantine/Medieval Hellenism, and Modern Hellenism(2). Droysen offered to the Greek national historians and politicians of the mid-late nineteenth century, to the Greek nation as a whole, not simply the imaginary vision of a ‘Hellenic’ Macedonia, but more importantly, an ideological justification for many other current politically motivated revisionist projects: the idealization of an imperial and expansionist political model; the invention of a ‘Hellenic’ Byzantium and Middle Ages in general; the adoption of Hegelian concepts of spiritual continuity, which was not necessarily linear but was based on the ability of the Hellenic spirit in its various forms to absorb ‘inferior’ elements(3). According to Panayote Dimitras, spokesman of the anti-racism campaign group the Greek Helsinki Monitor, racism in Greece is deep-rooted:"Greek national culture is one that believes there is a superiority of the Greek nation which is a continuous descendent of the ancient Greeks, and when you think like this about yourself it is very easy to think that the others are inferior," he says(4).
However, racism in Greece as everywhere else is an ideology that lacks real coherence (5). Detailed analysis reveals a smoke screen of propaganda which enshrouds a past very different from the one presented by Greek ultra-nationalist pseudo-history. According to one scholar “Greeks were taught to reject everything familiar in their vernacular culture as ‘foreign’ to the Classical Hellenism invented by the eighteenth-century German scholars who had sired both the ‘autochthonous’ theory that Greek ethno genesis and, in the lineage of ‘Aryan’ linguistics, the so-called racial science of the Nazis”(6). Indeed the philhellenic laboratory experiment in Greece was certainly not about fostering, preserving and integrating the existing multi-cultural landscape. The formulae in this experiment were put into production before Greece existed. One Greek scholar points out “The force of this cultural pre-construction of Greece cannot be underestimated, considering especially that the sociopolitical conditions prevailing at the end of the War of Independence point to an irreducible social and cultural discontinuity, to a zero point in the operation of those significations that were conceivably to propel and uphold the images of a new national identity” (7). All of this is relevant today because of its affects on Macedonia and the Macedonians, especially the Macedonian minority in Greece, who are faced with prejudice on a grand scale. Moreover, it is pertinent to note that this xenophobic ideology continues without serious challenge from the European Union (8).
Human rights groups say Greece has one of the worst records in the European Union for racism against ethnic minorities (9). Greece today does not recognize any ethnic minority within its boundaries. The reason is because this would upset the deeply entrenched philhellenic myths and Greece would have to admit that they are not a homogenous society with the oldest unruptured culture etc. Before the independence of Greece a number of languages were juxtaposed, including Greek, Albanian, Slavic, Vlach, Turkish and Italian, suggesting that the Greek nation was composed ‘by a sum of minorities’ and by no account a purely Greek phenomenon(10). A nineteenth century foreign visitor like Edmond About, writing in 1855, stated that “Athens, twenty five years ago, was only an Albanian village” and that “The Albanians formed, and still form, almost the whole of the population of Attica ; and within three leagues of the capital, villages are to be found where Greek is hardly understood. Athens has been rapidly peopled with men of all kinds and nations” (11). About also describes a Turkish village that surrounded the base of the acropolis which formed a quarter of the town as well the Albanian majority of that quarter (12). The fact that the Parthenon was used as a mosque during the Ottoman conquests(13) and before that was a church that went between Orthodox and Latin rites(14) is testament to the simple absurdity of Droysenian Hellenism.
George Finlay, a 19th century philhellene who was in Greece during the war for independence, described an early President, George Koundoriotis and Botases the Vice President of the Greek government in 1824 as “Albanian ship owners from Hydra and Spetzas”(15). Finlay added that: “It is necessary to record the sad truth that two more ignorant and incapable persons were never entrusted with the direction of a nation's affairs. The Greeks are the most prejudiced of all Europeans when there is a question of the purity of the Hellenic race, and no people regards education with more favour; yet with all this nationality and pedantry they entrusted their public affairs, in a period of great difficulty, to two men who could not address them in the Greek language, and whose intellectual deficiencies prevented them from expressing their thoughts with clearness even in the corrupt Tosk dialect which they habitually used.”(16)
Unadulterated facts, like these, about the multi-cultural origins of modern Greeks are often necessarily ignored in modern Greek nationalist narratives. In this regard, striking is the general lack of reflection upon the fact that the national dress of Greece is of Albanian origin (17), or the fact that Kolokotronis, the infamous klepht (bandit) leader, was a Major in an English General’s Albanian regiment (18) and performed an Albanian dance with other ‘Greek’ Revolutionaries for the Bavarian queen of Greece (19). Yet these ‘problems’ for the Greek nationalist narrative have still likely been lodged in the collective unconscious and this creates an insecurity that seems to make itself abhorrently evident via the often vicious manner in which Greek bigotry attempts to deny another nation’s right to an identity.
Some have estimated that during the 15th century when the Ottomans conquered the whole of what became modern Greece in 1830, some 45% of it was populated by Albanians (20). Their descendants played a leading role in the war for independence which helped win freedom from the Turks in 1821(21). The Vlachs were recorded in medieval times as having settled in what became modern Greece in very significant numbers (22). The Vlach intelligentsia paved the way for revolution in Greece during Ottoman times and, according to one Greek historian, “... contributed enormously to the development of a cultural network across national cultures and its members had acted as carriers of Greek language and culture due to their continuous migrations”(23). The Vlachs not only contributed to building up the new Hellenism which they imported from Western Europe, they also contributed to fighting the Turks as well being prominent Armatoles (police under Ottoman authority who betrayed the Sultan) and Klephts (bandit rebels). Yet their obvious Latin cultural origins are often ignored (24). However, during the early 19th century, the average person in what became Greece, according to the Historian William St. Claire, possessed feelings that were out of step with prominent philhellenes like Lord Byron:
“Most Greeks did not share Byron’s views and would not have understood his allusions. They did not think of themselves as Greeks at all - and certainly not as Hellenes (a word incidentally which always makes me uncomfortable) but as Christians or Orthodox. They had little sense of nationality in the Western European sense of a nation state like England or France with distinct geographical boundaries, a single language, and uniform culture. They thought of themselves rather as Orthodox Christian inhabitants of a large multi-racial empire. They were not, for the most part, in the least interested in their ancient ancestors, and they knew very little about them. When travelers found the locals at Marathon or Salamis with stories about ancient times, they were delighted, for they thought they had found a genuine tradition from ancient times. But the locals were usually repeating stories they had heard from earlier travellers.”(25)
When philhellenic infiltration took place after the formation of the modern Greek state, the multi-cultural inhabitants of Greece were to become ‘Hellenized’ (26). Moreover, this state began to spread the new doctrine outward into neighbouring lands. In particular, racist Hellenistic notions were directed towards all the Macedonians, Vlachs, Albanians and Turks in Macedonia and the Megali Idea, which reverberates even today, would attempt to forcefully impose itself on them and wreak terror on the people. Serious practical cultural (especially linguistic) gaps between the Macedonians and modern Greeks, in part explain the use of terror and as one scholar has noted, “...the Greeks, who could not compete on this terrain, compensated by stressing an imaginary ethnicity”. (27)
The Greek myths in regard to Macedonia are significantly connected to the intolerant seeds contained in the origins of modern Hellenism and the Megali Idea (a 19th and 20th century expansionist plan for a Greater Greece). During the 19th century, Greek as a language was a mercantile, ecclesiastical lingua franca among the bi-lingual (sometimes tri-lingual) inhabitants of the Balkans, including Macedonia. One scholar estimated “The Greek - speaking population in the three provinces that made up Ottoman Macedonia was approximately 10% of the total population”. (28)
Undaunted by this practical cultural divide Greeks attempted to Hellenize all and any in their path. Ironically a segment of the Vlachs formed the “backbone of Hellenism” in Macedonia during the early years of the 20th century. (29) Numerous foreign observers like the Englishman Brailsford, noted that “The average Greek or Hellenised Vlach in Macedonia, who professes to believe that the whole population is Greek, is doubtless to a great extent the victim of his daily impressions. He lives in a town which is for the most part Hellenised. He never goes into the country. He does not know the villages or the village folk. But even the more educated and moderate Greek ... will add a claim on behalf of Greece to more territory than her sons inhabit, "in recognition of the civilising mission of Hellenism.” I confess to some difficulty in deciding what Hellenism means in this connection. What is the specific attitude of mind which it denotes?”(30)
The observations of foreigners not only demonstrate the claim that Hellenism has a dominant cultural continuity in Macedonia extending back “4000 years”, to be an absurd myth; they also make it clear that it is ridiculous to try to claim this for the lands upon which the modern Greek state was first formed. The contradictions between the available evidence and the myth are simply insurmountable. They do however; assist in illustrating something else about the modern Greeks and their attempts to deny the existence of Macedonians: “all that these contradictions really prove is that after nearly two centuries of independence, Greek nationalists remain insecure and self-doubting behind their boastful and touchy facades” (31). Extreme nationalists, on the surface always seem to find a way to ignore the realities of the more recent past in order to maintain the rather childish “logic according to which all the country’s modern claims must be evaluated by the yardstick of ancient history” (32). When Anastasia Karakasidou wrote her book Fields of wheat, hills of blood, about the forced Hellenization of Macedonia that was annexed by Greece, it set off a fire storm that reveals the difficulties below the surface of ultra-nationalist rhetoric and “exhibits both the nervousness of the Greek establishment and the persistence of stereotypes of Greeks as irrational, hysterical Balkan lunatics among supposedly sober commentators in the West. It also demonstrates the neuralgia that anthropology can induce in those who are committed to unitary myths of national origin, as it also does the sometimes unavoidable entailment of anthropology in its object study”.(33)
This myth of Hellenism, which has significant racist traditions, is a denier of human rights to the Macedonian minority in Greece. Loring Danforth, an Anthropologist, describes an ultranationalist weekly newspaper that is distributed throughout Greece and its Diaspora, that “is testament to the evils of militarism, irredentism, xenophobia, and racism which are often fostered by extreme nationalism” and that “Calls for the reclamation of Asia Minor, Northern Macedonia (the Republic of Macedonia), and Northern Ipiros (Southern Albania) are standard themes of most issues, as are attacks on ethnic minorities in Greece such as the Jews, the ‘Mongols of Thrace’(the Turks), and the ‘Gypsy-Skopians’ (the Macedonians)” and this newspaper “even offered large sums of money and free trips to Greece as rewards for the ‘elimination’ of Macedonian activists who are regarded as particularly dangerous enemies of Hellenism”(34). This is but a more virulent example of what Macedonians in Greece are generally up against. How else is one to explain the fact that Greece refuses to recognise their existence!? Moreover, the Republic of Macedonia’s name, identity and culture are being challenged by this neighbourhood bully that is neurotically bent on maintaining an untenable national narrative. Goce Delchev, an early 20th century Macedonian liberation leader, once wrote “The moral revolution - the revolution of the mind, heart and soul of an enslaved people, is our greatest task”. He said this for the Macedonians under Ottoman rule, however Delchev’s assertion is also applicable to those Greeks who have been enslaved by the intolerant traditions within modern Hellenism and we need to remind them of their past, their diverse cultural origins and aid them to construct a history that does not require the denial of the existence of others.
Sources:
1 European historiographical influences upon the young Konstantinos Paparrigopoulos, Ioannis Koubourlis -The Making of Modern Greece; Edited by Roderick Beaton and David Ricks (2009; 60).
2 The Nation and its ruins: Antiquity, Archaeology, and National Imagination in Greece, Yannis Hamilakis (2007; 117-118)
3 Ibid (2007; 117)
4 Greek Albanians' woes fester, BBC News/Europe
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/4101469.stm (Thursday, 16 December 2004)
5 Blood and oranges: European markets and immigrant labor in rural Greece, Christopher M. Lawrence (2007; 79)
6 Anthropology; Theoretical Practice in Culture and Society, Michael Herzfeld (2001; 67)
7 Dream Nation: Enlightenment, Colonization and the Institution of Modern Greece, Stathis Gourgouris (1996; 86). Gourgouris further states; “the recourse to the new image of Hellas (both as cultural construct and as social system) began immediately upon the brief rule of Governor Kapodistrias and became efficiently implemented with the takeover of the Bavarian monarchy and its explicit desire for centralization and Hellenization. In fact, the cultural image of a modern Greece was put into production with much greater urgency than was a political-economic infrastructure, despite the obvious importance of the latter in a newly constituted State.” (1996; 87)
8 Greece is an Unworthy EU Member, Gunnar Nissen Danish newspaper Morgaenavisen Jyllands-Posten 2/26/1999. Nissen condemns Greece and the EU by stating "National oppression is taking place in many countries outside the EU. But Greece is an EU member and is thus a "part of the family". But do we intervene, we, the closest people? No, we shut up. Of ignorance or misunderstood solidarity with the Greek leaders, who as the Serbs, consider themselves "superbalkanian". Other people know more about the oppression than I, but I know a great many and every year more ignored and oppressed Slavic Macedonians in the Greek part of Macedonia. Can we justify our silence? I'm sure that Greece's unwillingness to accept the Republic of Macedonia is due to their black conscience over the oppression of Macedonians in Greece. Greece is (yet another) unworthy member of the EU." We need to here point out that while we admire the essence of Nissen‟s statement, that Nissen was probably unaware that Macedonians do reject the term “Slavic Macedonians” as offensive.
9 Greek Albanians' woes fester, BBC News/Europe
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/4101469.stm (Thursday, 16 December 2004)
10 Mediating the Nation: News, audiences and the politics of identity, Mirca Madianou (2005; 30). Madianou quotes Konstantinos Tsoukalas’ ‘by a sum of minorities’ from Dependency and reproduction: The social role of educational mechanisms in Greece (1830-1922), (1977; 50)
11 Greece and the Greeks of the present day, Edmond About (1855; 32)
12 Ibid (1855; 160)
13 National Identity in Modern Greece, Peter Mackridge (2008; 305) Hellenisms: culture, identity, and ethnicity from antiquity to modernity edited by Katerina Zacharia.
14 Athens: a cultural and literary history, Michael Llewellyn Smith (2004; 55). Smith describes the archaeological destruction of the Acropolis where the Bavarian overlords of Greece removed any Byzantine or Ottoman remnants in order to re-create a false perverted image of antiquity (2004; 56).
15 History of the Greek Revolution Volume II, George Finlay (1861; 30)
16 Ibid (1861; 30)
17 That Greece Might Still Be Free; The Philhellenes in the War of Independence, William St. Clair (1972; 232). St. Claire further describes the functioning government as “being largely Albanians themselves” (1972; 232).
18 History of the War of Independence in Greece Volume I, Thomas Keightley ( 1830; 260)
19 Sketches of Modern Greece: Athens in 1837, Anon. (1838; 476) Blackwoods Edinburgh Magazine Vol. XLIII (January-June 1838)
20 A Social Linguistic Study of Albanian Dialects Spoken in the Attica and Biotia Areas of Greece, P.Trudgill/G.Tzavaras (1975; 6)
21 Migrations and Invasions in Greece and Adjacent Areas, NGL Hammond (1976; 63)
22 Southeastern Europe in the Middle Ages, 500-1250, Florin Curta (2006; 281). Curta uses text from the Byzantine Keukamenos to describe the Vlachs and their migrations and settlements.
23 Greece and the Balkans: Identities, Perceptions and Cultural Encounters since the Enlightenment, Dimitrios Tziovas (2003; 6). See also Victor Roudometof’s Nationalism, Globalization, and Orthodoxy; The social origins of ethnic conflict in the Balkans (2001; 57) where he illustrates the “Greek Orthodox Balkan intelligentsia was a stratum crossing ethnic frontiers”.
24 Greeks and Romans, Tom Winifrith (1983; 92) Greece Old and New edited by Tom Winnifrith and Penelope Murray
25 Byron and Greece, William St. Clair (1983;161-162 ) Greece Old and New edited by Tom Winnifrith and Penelope Murray
26 Hellenism and the making of Modern Greece, Antonis Liakos (2008; 229) Hellenisms: culture, identity, and ethnicity from antiquity to modernity edited by Katerina Zacharia.
27 Nations and Nationalism since 1780: Programme, Myth, Reality, Eric Hobsbawm ( 1992; 107). Hobsbawm describes the Macedonians after the Balkan Wars as one of a few “nationalities without states” (1992; 139).
28 Collective Memory, National Identity, and Ethnic Conflict: Greece, Bulgaria, and the Macedonian Question, Victor Roudometof (2002; 111)
29 Culture, Civilization, And Demarcation at the Northwest Borders of Greece, Laurie Kain Hart (1999; 202) American Ethnologist 26, No. 1
30 Macedonia; its races and their future, Henry Noel Brailsford (1906; 201)
31 The Balkans: Of what is past, or Passing, or to Come, Brian Sullivan (1999; 18) The Emerging Strategic Environment; Challenges of the twenty first century Edited by Williamson Murray. Sullivan disputes the claims that the ancient Macedonians were ever Greek and the theory of their language being Greek, as many Greeks claim, as “the undisputed fact that Philip and Alexander admired Greek culture and that Greek was spoken at their court hardly made their subjects Greek, any more than the fact that the court of Catherine the Great and Alexander I spoke French made the Russian serfs of the late eighteenth or early nineteenth century part of French culture” (1999; 17).
32 Anthropology; Theoretical Practice in Culture and Society, Michael Herzfeld (2001; 68)
33 Ibid (2001; 68)
34 The Macedonian Conflict; Ethnic Nationalism in a Transnational World, Loring Danforth (1995; 130-131)