• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

Who are the Slavs? - Citations and Sources

Lavce, I have read this before. It does not really deal with the discussion. It deals with the consequences of a modern linguistic familiarity being used to re-badge the Macedonian people and their ethnicity.
I agree.
I am well aware of the danger that some Macedonians seek to avoid by avoiding the "S" word. The elephant in the room is the simple observation that some linguistic similarities exist between various languages described as Slavic languages today.
The elephant in the room shows us that many linguistic similarities exist, not just some. Furthermore, in the literature of those who spoke/speak the languages at least, they have been collectively regarded as Slavic languages from the 9th century. The 'danger' of the so-called "S" word today is a recent creation by the West (supported by sections of Greek, Romanian and Albanian societies, and by some Slavic-speaking societies such as those in Bulgaria and Russia) and unwittingly perpetuated by Macedonian ignorance. Rather than confronting this issue and defeating it with facts and logic, some of us are choosing to hide from it and throw up smoke, in the hope it will disappear into insignificance. It won't. Macedonians shouldn't be ignoring this issue, they should be trying to understand it and confront it, so that they are in a comfortable position to explain what it means to us and why it doesn't have a place in our ethnic identity.
I don't see Romanians questioning their identity when they are included in the Latin language list. I think some Macedonians must have an identity crisis if they are pre-occupied with the "elephant in the room".
I agree, completely.
If there were a nation called Slavs EVER in history ... I would understand the potential for confusion. Luckily, we are Macedonians.
RtG, can you elaborate on that point a little more? The peoples of Slovenia (Slovenija) and Slovakia (Slovensko), for example, took this identity based on linguistic commonality and, as compact Danubian groups, they developed it into an ethnicity at some point.
 
Bratot said:
The appearance of "K" in the term SLAV, comes as a consequence of the rule in Greek language that between "S" and "L" there must be placed "K" in order to read the "L".

As I mentioned before, the reason for the inclusion of K or C in the name Sclavi, Sklavenoi, Sklaveni, is due to the nature of the Dark L or Ł before a back vowel. In Old Church Slavonic this sound still existed. I posted about it before:

Delodephius said:
I wrote about this earlier somewhere, not sure. Anyhow, the reason why Romans wrote Sklavenoi or Sclavi, i.e. why include k or c, or even th as in Greek Sthlavenoi, is due to Slavic pronunciation of their name itself. The L in Sloväni is the velarized alveolar lateral approximant or "Dark L". In pronunciation it sounds like KL or THL, and that is how the Romans and Greeks heard it the first time. It changed to a regular L, alveolar lateral approximant, somewhere past the 9th century AD, since in OCS it is still velarized, which means it was so in the Macedonian dialect it was based upon. Only Slavic dialects that still have the Dark L are in eastern Poland and west Belarus, and they use the letter Łł to write it down. The Dark L is pronounced exclusively only in front of back vowels: o, u, a, just like in Sloväni.
In the IPA (International Phonetic Alphabet] it would be written [sɫɔwæni]. I most modern pronunciations it is either [slɔveni] or in East Slavic [slɑvʲɑni]. This too is due to the evolution of sounds in Slavic phonology.

There is no logical linguistic reason for what you are stating. I do remember when this theory was first postulated, at least on the old Maknews forum, some 5 years ago. Come to think of it, it could have been me who came up with it; that is, in the days before I knew much about Slavic linguistics. For some reason, while I was making such bullshit theories back then people were more inclined to believe me.:lol:
 
Last edited:
RtG, can you elaborate on that point a little more? The peoples of Slovenia (Slovenija) and Slovakia (Slovensko), for example, took this identity based on linguistic commonality and, as compact Danubian groups, they developed it into an ethnicity at some point.
There is a place called "Macedonia" and there are "Macedonians".
There has never been a place called Slav and there have never been "Slavs" from an ethnic and/or national sense. I struggle with the "Slav" nomenclature as a consequence. At best IMO it represents a linguistic grouping in a similar vein to Latin.

Nobody has ever really tried to call Macedonians as Slovenians or Slovakians. This is a tired little Greek game that is boring the hell out of me. It is nothing more than an attempt to undermine the Macedonian identity by our antagonists.

The language commonality is unable to be refuted even though Macedonians (in isolation) would struggle to understand any other slavic language. The etymology of volumes of slavic words are undeniably related. I've met enough Russians or (insert supposed Slavic brother race here) to know being Macedonian has nothing ethnically to do with them other than varying degrees of slavic lingual connections. I can live with myself (as a Macedonian) in knowing this.

My Italian (Calabrian) friend used his knowledge of dialectal Italian to great advantage in Spain recently and was quite pleased that he could be understood. He does not feel the least bit Spanish. I fear some Macedonians are scared they might start feeling Slav if they are understood by other ethnicities. If they do feel Slav, can they please tell me how it feels.
 
I have registered about 10 variances of the term supposedly defining the "Slavs", as following:

1. Sclavania
2. ΣκλαβηνΙβι
3. Σκλαυινία
4. Sdavinian
5. ΣκλαβινΙας
6. Σχλαυηυο
7. Σκλανία
8. ΣχλαυηνΙα
9. Σκλαυινία
10. Σκλαβηνίαι

I do not know about 10 name versions in which the Macedonians have appeared or Macedonia, and frankly, taking into account just these 10 examples(I believe can be found more), I do wonder why this term is not unique if it's the name of same people or country?

Not all of these are correct:
SLA- has appeared as SLA, SKLA/SCLA and even STHLA. So SHLA (No 6, 8) may not be totally wrong.

By 6th Century and later B would sound as V in Greek, but the standard transliteration from Greek to Latin would turn Greek B(=V) to a Latin B(=MP)
No 3, 6, 8, 9 is an alternate Greek spelling where αυ sounds like AV. Both αυ and αβ sound as AV.
This means that you have it wrong in the previous page. They first met Greeks who would call them Slavs (with a V) and then Latin Romans turned this to Slabs (with a B) and so did Arabs later.

No 6 seems to be wrong. Probably wanted to write: Σχλαυηνο (Shlavino)
I don't believe No 4 either. It seems like someone misinterpreted cl for d.
I’ve no idea what No 2 is. Did they mean Σκλαβηνιοι (Sclavenioi)? (it refers to people: Sclavenians)
No 5 is probably Σκλαβινιάς-Sclavinias (genitive: Σκλαβινιάδος-Sclaviniados) a proper Hellenized name of a country/land, which is about the same as No 8 and 9. No 10 is a plural of the same term (Sclavenian Lands).
Alternatively, No 5 could be Σκλαβινίας, i.e. simply the genitive case of Sclavinia/Sclavenia.

No 7 also seems to be wrong. Probably meant Σκλαυία (Sclavia, not Sclania)
 
Last edited:
There has never been a place called Slav and there have never been "Slavs" from an ethnic and/or national sense.
Actually, in Slovak the very word Slovak means Slav and the country Slovakia - Slovensko - means Slav land. The same thing with the Slovenians, their country and language. We for instance had to invent a different pronunciation for the word Slav to distinguish it from our own ethnic name, so today we say Slovania for Slavs. Other names like the province of Slavonia in Croatia, or the Slovincian language in Pomerian, or the extinct people Sloveni in Novgorod all mean Slav. So the names Slovak, Slovenian, Slavonian all mean Slav as both a nation and place.

I don't deny your ethnicity, country or language as being anything but Macedonian, so don't deny me being a Slav, or my country and language being Slavic, because that is what we are. Now, if the language group to which both of our languages belong is also called Slavic, i.e. if we take Slav in a pan-linguistic sense, then I can see the confusion, but that is merely in terminology, not in facts. A member of a group having the same name as the group as well as the same name as some other members of the group, while the rest of the members don't have the same name as the group, that is a bit confusing.
 
Last edited:
That is not necessarily true, because the transitional period of the Greek letter β from /b/ to /v/ has not been sufficiently determined. The only thing that is certain is that it took place during the Roman Empire, and it is likely that this process was gradual. What supports the notion that the term 'sklavenoi' was indeed pronounced with a /v/ is the fact that in Latin the word is only ever rendered with a /v/ and not a /b/.

It's still likely enough, because as you pointed out, we know the direction of this change - from /b/ to /v/ and we are able to date the first record of the term which appeared with letter β.


Many languages interchange the /b/ and /v/, even dialects within a common language. Spanish is a good example, where one could hear 'vamos' or 'bamos' depending on the speaker. In Hebrew the name of their capital in Tel Aviv, yet in some other Semitic languages like Arabic the name is pronounced as Tel Abib. Another example can be seen with the devoiced /p/ and /f/ - if you've ever communicated with somebody that speaks an oriental language like Vietnamese, you will notice that quite often they can hear the name 'Frank' yet when they pronounce it, it sounds more like 'Prank'. The same also applies to the /r/ and /l/, which are also quite often interchanged in both European and Asian languages.

Every later interchange between /b/ and /v/ can not discard the previous linguistic desingation.

For us, it is important to focus on the surrounding languages that coexisted or have had direct contact with the "Slavic".

It has more to do with the way (Latin or Greek-speaking) Romans interpreted the name rather than the person telling them the name.

This isn't just a case of interpretation, because we even do have written evidence of slavic form in Latin or Greek scripts.

What does it mean to you? Do you think the Paleo-Balkan languages underwent a change after the 6th century invasions?


I don't believe there have been some "Common Slavic" language.

I am not convinced that some significant invasions took place but I do think some changes could have happen as result of the continual language evolution and the later reforms introduced by Cyril and Methody.

I think the Paleo-Balkan languages formed a separate natural language basin that gave the primary input for development of North Slavic languages.

As a identity concept, in my opinion the "Slavic" conscience have always been supranational one.
 
Actually, in Slovak the very word Slovak means Slav and the country Slovakia - Slovensko - means Slav land. The same thing with the Slovenians, their country and language. We for instance had to invent a different pronunciation for the word Slav to distinguish it from our own ethnic name, so today we say Slovania for Slavs. Other names like the province of Slavonia in Croatia, or the Slovincian language in Pomerian, or the extinct people Sloveni in Novgorod all mean Slav. So the names Slovak, Slovenian, Slavonian all mean Slav as both a nation and place.

I don't deny your ethnicity, country or language as being anything but Macedonian, so don't deny me being a Slav, or my country and language being Slavic, because that is what we are. Now, if the language group to which both of our languages belong is also called Slavic, i.e. if we take Slav in a pan-linguistic sense, then I can see the confusion, but that is merely in terminology, not in facts. A member of a group having the same name as the group as well as the same name as some other members of the group, while the rest of the members don't have the same name as the group, that is a bit confusing.
I think you are getting confused about this.
I see Slovakia and Slovenia. When I see a country called Slav I will take your message on board. Your distorted logic suggests Slovakians and Slovenians are the same people. Which is ridiculous.

I see no reason to read any more into the word Slav and I think you are reaching for something that makes no sense.
 
I think you are getting confused about this.
I see Slovakia and Slovenia. When I see a country called Slav I will take your message on board. Your distorted logic suggests Slovakians and Slovenians are the same people. Which is ridiculous.

I see no reason to read any more into the word Slav and I think you are reaching for something that makes no sense.
I'm not saying nor suggesting that Slovaks or Slovenians are the same people. I'm telling you that in their languages their names mean Slav (when translated into English). In ENGLISH the word is Slav, in Slovak it is Slovak, in Slovenian it is Slovenian.

If you ask a Slovak what is the name of his language, he will tell you "Slovenský jazyk". If you ask him what is the name of the Slavic languages, which belong to the Indo-European group of languages, he will say "Slovanské jazyky" (plural of Slovanský jazyk). The WORD is the same, but it stands for two completely different things in different contexts.

I think you just don't understand, because it is very simple.

WORD Slovak = WORD Slav
Slovak is a nation, language, country
Slav is a language group

In ENGLISH they are different for the sake of avoiding confusion. In Slovak itself the confusion was solved in the late 19th century by changing the E in Slovenský to A, hence Slovanský. But the words are still of the same origin.

An example in English would be of German language and Germanic languages. German is one of the languages of the Germanic family of languages.

So, if we were to translate the word Slovenský (sk) or Slovenski (sl) into English in a literal manner, we would get: Slovak or Slovenian, i.e. Slav is one of the languages of the Slavic family of languages.
 
Last edited:
I'm not saying nor suggesting that Slovaks or Slovenians are the same people. I'm telling you that in their languages their names mean Slav (when translated into English). In ENGLISH the word is Slav, in Slovak it is Slovak, in Slovenian it is Slovenian.

If you ask a Slovak what is the name of his language, he will tell you "Slovenský jazyk". If you ask him what is the name of the Slavic languages, which belong to the Indo-European group of languages, he will say "Slovanské jazyky" (plural of Slovanský jazyk). The WORD is the same, but it stands for two completely different things in different contexts.

I think you just don't understand, because it is very simple.

WORD Slovak = WORD Slav
Slovak is a nation, language, country
Slav is a language group

In ENGLISH they are different for the sake of avoiding confusion. In Slovak itself the confusion was solved in the late 19th century by changing the E in Slovenský to A, hence Slovanský. But the words are still of the same origin.

An example in English would be of German language and Germanic languages. German is one of the languages of the Germanic family of languages.

So, if we were to translate the word Slovenský (sk) or Slovenski (sl) into English in a literal manner, we would get: Slovak or Slovenian, i.e. Slav is one of the languages of the Slavic family of languages.


OK, but still we can see overlaping of certain forms for expressing Slav/Slavic, Slovenian or Slovak when we speak about terms used in different Slavic languages.

There's an old hypothesis that Slovaks and Slovenians once have been same nation but after they have developed language differencies (slovakian is product of influence by czech, and slovenian of influence by serbo-croatian). According to this understanding Slovak language is intermediate between southern and western group of slavic languages.

The names of both nations in their own language means simple Slavs. They are possibly offsrings of Carinthia (Carantania - Caran??) and after that the Grand Moravian state (situted on the place connecting today territories of Slovaks and Slovenians)??
 
There has never been a place called Slav and there have never been "Slavs" from an ethnic and/or national sense. I struggle with the "Slav" nomenclature as a consequence.
The Slavic name was first recorded in reference to a group of peoples that lived north of the Danube and were raiding across Roman borders. It is likely that at least some peoples north of the Danube expanded on their linguistic commonality by consolidating into a more specific identity, especially after the establishment of the Samo Empire. In the 7th century, the contemporary historiographer Theophylact Simocatta wrote that a Roman "emperor enquired what was their nation, where was their allotted abode, and the cause of their presence in the Roman lands. They replied that they were Sclavenes by nation and that they lived at the boundary of the western ocean…...…." The reference to the western ocean seems to suggest that they lived near the Adriatic and thus quite possibly the Danube. The same author refers to them as "Getae...the older name" - the Getae were a Thracian tribe also known as Dacians, and in antiquity they lived around the Danube area - just like the 'Sclavenes' did at the time of writing.

This situation differs to the autonomous enclaves in the Balkans known as Sclavinias, which the Roman named after the peoples that established them. Although retaining periodical independence, this often interchanged with either Roman subjugation or political influence, which consequently resulted in the assimilation of the invaders into the indigenous populations. However, so long as the enclaves existed, their language - which had long before developed as a lingua franca in the Danube area - was able to remain relatively conservative and spread out within their vast confines. The enclaves consumed practically all of the Balkans all the way down to the Peloponnese, yet their language held out definitively only in Macedonia, Illyria and Thrace, precisely because it was related to the indigenous languages of those regions.

It was a Macedonian (Saint Clement) that first recorded (in a Slavic language) the language as 'Slovjanski', in relation to the people of Solun in Macedonia. But he also cites the Moravian ruler making reference to his own population as 'Slovjani', and how they were a simple people without any Christian teachers to educate them in their own language, in the way Latins (Vlah'), Greeks (Gr’k’) and Germans (Njam’c‘) had. Great Moravia (which included parts of today's Slovakia and Slovenia) occupied a similar albeit larger area than the Samo Empire, and can be considered as an example where the Slavic identity has evolved from a linguistic nature to one of a more specific nature. Whether or not this identity was national, ethnic and/or cultural can be argued, but they were definetly in a political union which probably stemmed from a loose tribal confederacy, and they were linguistically related.
The language commonality is unable to be refuted even though Macedonians (in isolation) would struggle to understand any other slavic language. The etymology of volumes of slavic words are undeniably related. I've met enough Russians or (insert supposed Slavic brother race here) to know being Macedonian has nothing ethnically to do with them other than varying degrees of slavic lingual connections. I can live with myself (as a Macedonian) in knowing this.
Exactly.
Bratot said:
This isn't just a case of interpretation, because we even do have written evidence of slavic form in Latin or Greek scripts.
Aside from the Freising works in the 9th century, when was a Slavic language written in Latin or Greek characters during that era?
For us, it is important to focus on the surrounding languages that coexisted or have had direct contact with the "Slavic".
Not if you're talking about the Arabic pronounciation of the word. And given that Arabs convert /v/ to /b/ even with words from among their own Semitic cousins, it isn't unlikely that they did the same when they first heard of the word 'Sklavenoi'.
I am not convinced that some significant invasions took place but I do think some changes could have happen as result of the continual language evolution and the later reforms introduced by Cyril and Methody.
Don't you think that 'language evolution' was impacted by the language of the Slavic invaders?
I think the Paleo-Balkan languages formed a separate natural language basin that gave the primary input for development of North Slavic languages.
When do you think Paleo-Balkan languages contributed to this development?
cultea said:
They first met Greeks who would call them Slavs (with a V) and then Latin Romans turned this to Slabs (with a B) and so did Arabs later.
Which Latin texts write "Slabs"?
 
I'm not saying nor suggesting that Slovaks or Slovenians are the same people. I'm telling you that in their languages their names mean Slav (when translated into English). In ENGLISH the word is Slav, in Slovak it is Slovak, in Slovenian it is Slovenian.

If you ask a Slovak what is the name of his language, he will tell you "Slovenský jazyk". If you ask him what is the name of the Slavic languages, which belong to the Indo-European group of languages, he will say "Slovanské jazyky" (plural of Slovanský jazyk). The WORD is the same, but it stands for two completely different things in different contexts.

I think you just don't understand, because it is very simple.

WORD Slovak = WORD Slav
Slovak is a nation, language, country
Slav is a language group

In ENGLISH they are different for the sake of avoiding confusion. In Slovak itself the confusion was solved in the late 19th century by changing the E in Slovenský to A, hence Slovanský. But the words are still of the same origin.

An example in English would be of German language and Germanic languages. German is one of the languages of the Germanic family of languages.

So, if we were to translate the word Slovenský (sk) or Slovenski (sl) into English in a literal manner, we would get: Slovak or Slovenian, i.e. Slav is one of the languages of the Slavic family of languages.
The danger of thinking about translations of words such as Slovak, Slovene into English is that there is simply increased room for confusion. Your interpretation of the meaning & translation of self-described words may be useful to Slovaks & Slovenes. It obviously has no place for Macedonians as they relate to nothing more than a lingual connection.

Your example about Germans is a compromised one. By using the word "Slav" (if this is indeed the English translation) instead of Slovak and/or Slovene in order to be consistent in your approach, it renders the statement more confusing.

Such that:
- German is one of the languages of the Germanic family of languages.
- Slav is one of the languages of the Slavic family of languages. (Except now we don't know whether we are talking about Slovaks or Slovenes. It simply does not make sense without qualifiers.)

I am still unable to determine what a Slav is.
 
Can anyone name me a country that has preserved it's language & culture right through the ages.Can you look me in the eye & because you have read your crap slav theories you are going to say that we are nothing but slavs.Because that's what you are slowly doing.You are slowly developing a chink in the macedonian armour that we are not macedonian but slavs.Do people know part of the smear campaign was to destroy the macedonian consciousness of the people.How by telling them that they are slavs.Both greece /serbia/bulgaria practised this propaganda.They were all out to destroy the people's consciousness for being a macedonian.You aren't any different you are doing it for them today you great internet warriors.You should all be ashamed of yourselves referring to each other as slavs & beleiving crap slav theories.
 
Can you look me in the eye & because you have read your crap slav theories you are going to say that we are nothing but slavs.
George, who here has said "we are nothing but slavs"? Can you quote them? The answer is no. Stop beating your chest and start using your brain. That would be better than making baseless allegations against people you can't even name.
You are slowly developing a chink in the macedonian armour that we are not macedonian but slavs.
Did Cyril, Methodius and other Macedonian saints and scholars also develop a 'chink' in the Macedonian armour by calling their language Slovjanski?
You aren't any different you are doing it for them today you great internet warriors.
That is utter rubbish.
You should all be ashamed of yourselves referring to each other as slavs & beleiving crap slav theories.
No, you should be ashamed of yourself for presenting our people as a bunch of ignorant clowns who aren't aware of their own history. You should be ashamed of yourself for promoting idiotic fictions like 70,000 year old rock theories. You should be ashamed of yourself for wanting to keep Macedonians in the dark about their history and not allowing them to gain a true understanding and appreciation of how they evolved as a people and what it was throughout history that impacted them on different levels.

Some of you really appear to live in a world of delusion where any and everything is Macedonian. I can't believe how you're unable to critically assess our own history and accept facts for what they are. You seriously must have an inferiority complex if you bitch about every contextual reference to 'Slavs' where it concerns Macedonia. I didn't know it was that easy for some of you super-patriots to have your identity shaken, you give the impression that the Macedonian identity is merely a pack of cards, ready to crumble at the mere whisper of the word 'Slavs'. Don't you think it is better for our people to be able to confront the word and be able to logically explain it? Or is sticking your head in a paper bag when you hear the word the way to go these days?

The Macedonian identity, culture and people are indigenous to Macedonia. Those are the facts. Here is another fact. All three components underwent certain changes as a result of invasions and influences over centuries of evolution. Who here denies this? While some of you like to criticise logic, none of you are prepared to come forth with your own suggestions as to how half of Europe speaks related languages. Let me know when one of you brave chaps is prepared to actually put the money where their mouth is and come up with a credible explanation.
 
SOM i would like to disagree with you.First & foremost we are macedonian.The slav name is a smear campaign by our enemies.The greeks,bulgarians & serbians.Name me one theory today that is accepted as truth today in a coherent way.You said you were looking for that special language what is it?? Paleo??What i'm saying is that our enemies are saying we are slavs.They are just theories & who knows who is right.?I will not capitulate to anyone on our so called slav heritage.We may have had some kind of influence but not to the extent of the annihilation of our macedonian identity.Just like the ventilator or the name change people are free to beleive what they want i prefer to be MACEDONIAN & not something concocted by the slav theorists.Lets agree to disagree.That is my 2 cents worth.I don;t usually subscribe to these so called slav theories but when isaw everyone going for open slather on each other.(if you want you can delete my comments as you may feel they have no relevance)
:21::14:
 
Last edited:
SOM i would like to disagree with you.First & foremost we are macedonian.
We are Macedonians first and foremost. Who here has said that we aren't? Why are you creating arguments out of thin air? It's not that you disagree with what I am writing, you simply just don't understand it.
The slav name is a smear campaign by our enemies.
Are you going to answer my previous question? What did Cyril and Methodius and the other Macedonian saints and scholars call our language in the 9th and 10th centuries?
You said you were looking for that special language what is it?? Paleo??
Further evidence of how utterly ignorant you are where it concerns historical linguistics.
What i'm saying is that our enemies are saying we are slavs.
I know, and don't worry about trying to understand what 'Slavs' are so we can argue convincingly against such assertions, just put your head in a paper bag and pray for the term to disappear.
I will not capitulate to anyone on our so called slav heritage.
What Slav heritage?
We may have had some kind of influence but not to the extent of the annihilation of our macedonian identity.
That's what I am saying too. But you can't see this because you have your blinkers on and are misconstruing my words.
That is my 2 cents worth.
That's about all it is worth. George, I have always considered you a good guy, but when it comes to historical linguistics you don't have a clue, and it is sad that you have formed an opinion without actually reading into the matter in more detail. But, to each his own.
 
Yes they erroneously seemed to claim that we are slavs.Slavjani.If it was said long enough & convincing enough to make it we were slavs by their assesment.But the facts speak otherwise we did have influnces from many people,did they change our identity no,did they have some kind of influence yes.The slavs went through other countries as well labelling them as slavs might not be right because they were influnced in the same way.Som i think we seem to agree on something then.
 
Ok then sOM you were going to announce that what some language you have found.
Also maybe you could write in a summary fashion what you have found out about the slavs.I can tell you that i get easily upset that the truth might out that we are not macedonian but slavs.This innate fear.
As i said why don't you put in a summary fashion what you have found out about the slavs
& i won't criticise anything (not a threat).
I think deep down wed all like to know the truth heres your opportunity I'm all ears!
 
Sorry som didn't they call it slavjanski.??
Ok the thing that set me off is all that arguing you guys were going on.Also speaking for myself i don't want to be in the dark if you can enlighten us on the slavs like a page summary nice & simple for my benefit i'll shut up & eat humble pie.In the past i have allways taken your word & beleived what you said coz yyou are the best of the best.
Also it's not easy trying to follow what you & slovak were upto.
 
Last edited:
Ok then sOM you were going to announce that what some language you have found.
George, why are you refusing to answer the question I asked with regard to the Macedonian saints? I will give you the answer anyway, and if you've been reading this thread you should already know - they called it Slovjanski. Don't hide from it, instead, confront it, understand it, then challenge it when it is raised in an inappropriate manner. That is the way to go, and not this approach of sweeping it under the rug that some of you seem to be proposing.
As i said why don't you put in a summary fashion what you have found out about the slavs & i won't criticise anything (not a threat).
I already have, in several threads. I don't care if you criticise what I am writing George, I just want your criticism to be based on logic. Surely that isn't too much to ask.
I can tell you that i get easily upset that the truth might out that we are not macedonian but slavs.This innate fear.
That is an unfounded fear based on an inferiority complex. We have nothing to be fearful of, because we are Macedonians, and that is what we have always been. Shake off your fear and confront the issue with courage, you will see that the truth isn't anywhere near as dangerous for us as you may currently think.
 
Back
Top