Soldier of Macedon
Senior Member
Afterhours, I really cannot see any reason for you to respond with 7 posts to each 1 of mine, other than trying to gain a higher post count on this forum. Can you explain to me why you do this, because your three-liners can all be consolidated into one post to make it easier to address. At the moment, I view this as suspect spamming, but I will allow you to correct this behaviour going forward, should you be willing. Filling up a page with 7 out 10 posts (most of which consist of only a few words) is a waste of space as far as I am concernced, and is a contributing factor to this thread blowing up to 14 pages within a matter of days.
Clearly some of what I wrote earlier is too difficult to comprehend and keep up with (for you), your arguments going forward do not consider what has been contested, and henceforth lose their significance each time. To be quite honest, I thought you were a little better than that, but now you are slowly beginning to exhibit the same mannerisms that led to your eventual expulsion by TM at maknews. Start producing the goods mate, or stop wasting our time, it's that simple.
I advise you to stop playing words, other than going back 6 pages to look for your rapid three-liners, your cyclic attitude is becoming annoying. Athenian colonists are HELLENIC colonists. How many other Hellenes colonised lands of fellow Hellenes, in the manner that Hellenes from Athens colonised Macedonia? Failure to answer this question after this last repeat attempt will indicate to me that you are unable to.afterhours said:Athenian colonists. I'm not saying it, but the sources I've posted in this thread clearly do! Don't just take it up with me!
What exactly do you want me to address? I'm sorry, in your abundance of posts on this thread I am afraid it is lost in the sea of nothingness. Refer me to exactly what statement they have made? Are they saying that there are people in Macedonia who could speak and write Hellenic (If so, you win no medals), are they calling the original inhabitants of Macedonia as Hellenes, or are they linking these people to modern ethnic Hellenes of the 19th century and post-type?can you at least address what the Louvre, the British Museum, the Metropolitan Museum of Art, and the State Hermitage Museum thought of them?
No, not probaby, definetly. There is not a shred of evidence to prove otherwise, especially not in the manner that you are suggesting.Probably, but we don't know for sure!So who was Hellenized as early as, or prior to, the 8th century BC? I’ll give you a hint, nobody. The oracle at Dodona is pre-Hellenic and dates much earlier than any record of Hellenes.
Fantastic. I don't need a plethora of information, you can save that for your Albanian friends who seemed convinced that the Molossians are an ancestor tribe of theirs and that Pyrrhus is their ancestral king. Here is something that caught my interest in the link you posted:
Tharrhypas reigned beteen 430 - 390 BC - That is the 5th century BC. Before this it appears that Hellenic learning and manners was non-existent, and all prior is a myth. Even the mythical kings became 'barbarous', and the language of the country was as different to Hellenic as is Aspetus to Achilles. The above says to me that the people of Epirus (including Molossians or those who came to be known as such) are not Hellenic by origin and receive actual Hellenic influence only from the 5th century BC onwards, like Macedonia and the other surrounding non-Hellenic regions.Neoptolemus, Achilles's son, planting a colony, possessed these parts himself, and left a succession of kings, who, after him, was named Pyrrhidae, as he in his youth was called Pyrrhus, and of his legitimate children, one was born of Lanassa, daughter of Cleodaeus, Hyllus's son, had also that name. From him Achilles came to have divine honours in Epirus, under the name of Aspetus, in the language of the country. After these first kings, those of the following intervening times becoming barbarous, and insignificant both in their power and their lives, Tharrhypas is said to have been the first who, by introducing Greek manners and learning, and humane laws into his cities, left any fame of himself.
That is not specific enough, because if that is all you have to say then in general terms it is false. Thrace, Illyria, Macedonia, Italy, Asia, etc received Hellenic influence via colonists much earlier that Alexander or even the rise of Macedon as a power. Are you denying this?I think you know very well what I'm trying to say here, and that is that the Greek language became a lingua franca after the exploits of Alexander.
Have I ever referred to you as such in the past, present, in this forum or any other? If not, then why have you written such a description for yourself? Is this what you want me to call you?Ok, then by all means, give this "Arvanitovlahoslavotorko" the low down!
Hang on a second, I have shown you genuine examples of how they DID use the Hellenic language (Geta). Or are the items in your selected museums the only one's that count for you?But they didn't use the Greek language, and according to the museums that I've highlighted thus far, the ancient Maks did.
Clearly some of what I wrote earlier is too difficult to comprehend and keep up with (for you), your arguments going forward do not consider what has been contested, and henceforth lose their significance each time. To be quite honest, I thought you were a little better than that, but now you are slowly beginning to exhibit the same mannerisms that led to your eventual expulsion by TM at maknews. Start producing the goods mate, or stop wasting our time, it's that simple.