• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

Pasko Kuzman promoting "Macedonian-Hellenistic period" - anti-Macedonian propaganda?

indigen

New member
Pasko Kuzman promoting "Macedonian-Hellenistic period" - anti-Macedonian propaganda?

samoilova-(4).jpg

Relief (megharic) ceramic cups with representation of the solar
symbol of the ancient Macedonians (2nd century BC), discovered
in the same cistern.

Samuil’s Fortress (Pasko Kuzman)

samoilova-(1).jpg


Portrait of a man (cavalier), dated in
the 1st century BC, discovered in a
cistern from the Macedonian-Hellenistic
period
, later used as a deposit. It is a
bronze find with realistic features of
the expression.

Samuil’s Fortress (Pasko Kuzman)

http://www.mav.mk/index.php?lang=&issue=2009-09
--------------

Pasko has same mindset as Maknews (L.U.)! For clarification, www.makedonika.org (run by Slavko Mangovski and Co.) had/has a history section termed Macedonistic and same content was also hosted on the former www.macedon.org website (together with J.G.'s Ancient Macedonians site) where it was renamed "Hellenistic"!

Now, Lubi is a good Macedonian (he does, and continues to do, a lot of good work) at heart but ideologically is not always my "cup of tea"!

Macedonians need MACEDONIAN IDEOLOGY!


Alex_in_Babylon.gif

Alexander enters Babylon
a coin found in Afghanistan

--------------------
Further info that came to light subsequently to posting this post and the discussions that ensued in this topic thread:
If not now, when? Is Pasko Kuzman another tool for Gruevski?

Pasko Kuzman seems to have led (or enjoyed) a very "evolving" and varied political past in his career.

I have been doing some Google research on him and the following are part of my discoveries:

ОПОЗИЦИЈА
ВМРО-ДПМНЕ формира "влада во сенка"

Извршниот комитет на ВМРО-ДПМНЕ назначил претседатели на повеќе партиски
комисии, со што, практично, формира партиска "влада во сенка".

За претседател на комисијата за надворешни работи е назначен Слободан Чашуле, за
меѓународна соработка Сашко Кедев, за урбанизам, градежништво и транспорт Спасен
Ѓорѓевски, за здравство Чедомир Димитровски, а за европска интеграција Елизабета
Канческа-Милевска. Партискиот ресор за култура му е доделен на археологот Паско
Кузман,
за образование на Марија Ташева, за животна средина на Методија
Мирчевски, за информатика и телекомуникации на Зоран Трајчевски, за социјални
прашања, работни односи и вработеност на Кирил Тодоровски. Секторот за физичка
култура му е доделен на кошаркарот Петар Наумовски, а за мали и средни
претпријатија - Митко Кржовски.

Претседател на Форумот за урбанизам е архитектот Јован Стефановски-Жан, а
копретседатели на комисии за социјални прашања и за здравство се Светлана
Јакимовска и Борче Георгиевски. (Б.Ѓ.)

Број 2335 (сабота, 20 декември 2003)

http://star.dnevnik.com.mk/?pBroj=2335&stID=26878

http://star.dnevnik.com.mk/default.aspx?pbroj=2335&stID=26878

http://star.dnevnik.com.mk/rssGenerator/rss.aspx?pbroj=2335

http://star.dnevnik.com.mk/?section=arc&pbroj=2335&pyear=2003

„.....Таквите тврдења на Кузман се паушални и теденциозни и злонамерни од причина што
граганите на Охрид ја знаат политичката определеност на Петрески, иако во
секојдневниот живот не го чувствуваат Петрески како човек кој ги застапува
интересите само на членството на својата партија. Но до ден денес не е дефинирана
политичката определеност на Кузман од причина што своевремено комунист, до 1997
год, член на СДСМ и одборник од СДСМ-ПДП во општина Охрид па член на ВМРО-ДПМНЕ
од 1998 год. па од 2003 год. член на ВМРО-НП.


Ај сега најдиго политичкиот крај на припадност на политичките пратии на Паско
Кузман.
Недај боже да се формира некоја нова политичка опција која ке биде на
власт и дедај боже таја политичка опција да пропагира некоја друга теза за
постанокот на Македонците што тогаш ке постане нашиот Индиана
Џонс?....“


Денесовски Сашо - Новинар

http://www.megastar.com.mk/stara/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=1226&Itemid=37

ВМРО НП ќе бара интерпелација на Стефановски
Александра Бубевска
21.04.2005


По кривичната пријава против Паско Кузман, поранешен директор на Завод и музеи Охрид за злоупотреба на службената положба, ВМРО-НП ќе достави предлог во собранието за интерпелација на министерот за култура Благој Стефановски.

Познатиот археолог Кузман се сомничи дека без тендер, со непосредна спогодба, спротивно на законот за јавни набавки потрошил околу 2 милиони и 300.000 евра државни пари, склучувајќи договор со фирмата „Митан пром“ за реставрација на споменици на културата. Во ВМРО-НП сметаат дека тој не го прекршил законот.


„Според законот за заштита на културното наследство ние немаме потреба од тендер. Единствено запазена е формата кај г-дин Паско Кузман. Имено кога се копа во Самоилова тврдина или на Плаошник вие не знаете што ќе најдете таму и веднаш за 2 дена да направите тендер“, вели Валентина Божиновска ВМРО-НП.

Паско Кузман, кој учествуваше во првите редови на мирните протести против, како што тврдеше ВМРО-НП, изборната измама во Охрид, не се огласува во јавноста за кривичната пријава против него. Веста за кривичната пријава против него предизвика жестоки реакции во јавноста.

Во петицијата, вработените во заводот од Охрид, тврдат дека неколку пати се вршела ревизија на документацијата и не биле пронајдени неправилности во работењето. Од петицијата се огради сегашниот директор на заводот Јован Трца кој во мандатот на Кузман бил правник во Заводот.

Во одбрана на Паско Кузман застанаа познати интелектуалци како Венко Андоновски и професорката Вера Битракова. Македонското археолошко друштво смета дека тој е неправедно понижен и недокажано осуден.

Во времето кога Паско Кузман беше директор на охридскиот завод возобновена е Светиклиментовата црква на Плаошник и античкиот театар, реставрирана е охридската тврдина, отворен е лапидариумот и галеријата на икони.

http://www.a1.com.mk/vesti/default.asp?VestID=45649


Last but no least is the following poem dedicated to TITO:

КОЛКУ ПАТИ ВО СЛОБОДАТА ТИТО СЕ СОДРЖИ

Колку пати во изгревот сонот се содржи
Толку пати посилно Денот ќе засвети
Нашиот ден. И овде во нас се всели
Центарот на светот од оган румен излезен.
Во него сме. И гледаме гордо на сите страни
Качувајќи се нагоре слегувајќи од планините
Од историјата кон Стожерот со поглед напред
Од иднината кон Обелискот со песна одзади
В гранит збрани но' во една голема Душа
Големата прегратка на љубовта во вселената
Во песната содржани сме. Твојата песна
Меѓу двата пола северниот и јужниот
Во сржта на патот меѓу истокот и западот
Одејќи ко' алки сврзани во долг синџир од пеења
Од исконот и легендата кон Изворот и Звездата.
Во сите знаења влезена е вистинската визија на светот.
Влезено е името Твое
И наше и сечие кој Човек се вика
Колку пати во изгревот сонот се содржи
Толку пати посилно Денот ќе засвети
Нашиот ден.
Колку пати во слободата ТИТО се содржи
Толку пати посилно Неговото име зрачи
Нашето име.

Zaebancii na negova smetka tuka.

БИОГРАФИЈА: http://mk.wikipedia.org/wiki/Паско_Кузман
 
Last edited:
this is not anti macedonian propaganda, this is nit picking, and what kuzman does is all for macedonia, its culture and its history
 
Althout I would prefer if he used just Macedonistic era I don't see this as anti-macedonian propaganda.

Anyway I also have some reserve about the glorification of Kuzman personality :)
 
hellenistic is the term academics use, simply replacing it with Makedonistic makes us seam extremist can give credibility that we are trying to steal 'greek' history. This is simply a face that we have to live with, although I dont see internally why we can let go of everything 'helenistic'
 
Hellenistic is EXTREMELY different from Hellenic.
If the foolish modern Greeks heard Macedonian or Macedonistic, they would argue how Greek it is. But the academics call it Hellenistic which clearly means it was not Hellenic. It is one the best proofs about the nature of the era.
 
Gandeto: Macedonian history must be freed from the absurd Greek attachments

Gandeto: Macedonian history must be freed from the absurd Greek attachments

Macedonian history must be freed from the absurd Greek attachments

Gandeto
April 06, 2009

Recorded history, unlike any other discipline, suffers from intrusive erosion in objectivity. Due to its ingrained proclivity to allow intimate personal feelings to seep into its content, the final version thus produced is almost always colored by various degrees of subjective anomalies. The extent to which these external tendencies compromise the historical veracity of the content and contaminate the truth, will depend largely upon the employed degree of subjectivity.

To rectify these situations and avoid promulgation of residual historical inaccuracies—the sources for future potential troubles—periodic "truth-checks", like controlled forest fires, ought to be performed; the found misconceptions need to be redefined and recommended changes must be implemented.
But coming closer to that elusive creature called truth, is neither easy nor without sacrifices. Admittedly, it is a proven fact that it takes a lot more courage to acknowledge the errors of our ways than to continue to promote them. But start we must; somehow, somewhere—even with a few feeble kernels of hope at hand—we must, because not starting is not only unwise and dangerous with lasting calamitous consequences for our future generations who will inherit the mass, but it is also a sure sign of deliberate shortsightedness and an admission of cowardice.

And thus, I call upon the western intellectuals in general and the western philhellenes in particular to separate their personal sentimental attachments to Greek history, to do the only honorary thing left and treat Macedonia and Macedonian history as a separate and comprehensive study that it is, and that it certainly deserves to be. The conflicting statements left strewn in the literature in the past hundred or so years—are the result of biased and subjective influences—and have not only caused political discourse and confusion, but bring about contradictions, fuel tensions and cause unnecessary hateful speculations.

[....]

http://www.americanchronicle.com/articles/view/97381
 
The Samnitian Empire spread Romanism throughout Europe?

In my issue it is a political period (Macedonian rule, in MACEDONIA!) we are talking about and there are probably very few (if any) comparable situations we could find to effectively compare with today. Mongolia might be one such case (?).

The Romans waged three "MACEDONIAN WARS" to "LIBERATE" the "GREEKS" from the "MACEDONIAN YOKE"! I do NOT see any case for "Macedonian-Hellenistic" anything in the structure of the Macedonian state of the Antigonid Dynasty - IT WAS SIMPLY MACEDONIAN!

Cheers
 
Althout I would prefer if he used just Macedonistic era I don't see this as anti-macedonian propaganda.

Anyway I also have some reserve about the glorification of Kuzman personality :)

Brate, you should not just prefer "Macedonistic era" (Macedonian Era/Period might be even a better designation when talking about the Antigonid Dynasty ruling in Macedonia) but should INSIST - UNCOMPROMISINGLY!

Was it not this same Pasko who was in a TV duel a few months ago with Ljubche bugarcheto supposedly defending the position of Macedonian/Macedonistic era for the same period? From what I saw on A1 video clip excerpts, they were both more than pathetic. It would seem that L.G. "convinced" him to back off?! :-)

If memory serves me correctly, Pasko Kuzamn used to use the "Hellenistic" designation some 8 years ago (and most likely before and after that time) and turned off many right-thinking Macedonian patriots from ever considering him anything special or competent to represent/promote effectively our rich Macedonian heritage.

Cheers
 
Hellenistic is EXTREMELY different from Hellenic.
If the foolish modern Greeks heard Macedonian or Macedonistic, they would argue how Greek it is. But the academics call it Hellenistic which clearly means it was not Hellenic. It is one the best proofs about the nature of the era.

RTG, I am a bit disappointed to hear this position coming from a Macedonian living in Australia!!! I would be even more disappointed if you were living here, as an adult, for the last 20 years or so and experienced the trials and tribulations of our community in that time!

Cheers
 
Indigen, there is nothing to be disappointed about. You appear to be making the fundamental mistake that mentioning something like "Hellenistic" means it has something to do with modern Greeks. This is not the case and I certainly don't want to defend a stance like that. In other words, we could both be arguing over something even though we both agree with each other completely.

For 20 years before your 20 years of trial and tribulation, I have been suffering further attacks on my identity. I understand your anger.
 
Indigen, there is nothing to be disappointed about. You appear to be making the fundamental mistake that mentioning something like "Hellenistic" means it has something to do with modern Greeks. This is not the case and I certainly don't want to defend a stance like that. In other words, we could both be arguing over something even though we both agree with each other completely.
I will again quote Gandeto: "...Macedonian history must be freed from the absurd Greek attachments..." in order to clarify my point.

For those who posted for the benefit of my education about the meaning of "Hellenistic", I know what it means and encompasses and I reject its use in regards to anything relating to Macedonian/Macedonistic era/period - always!

As for the philosophical approach that "Hellenistic" (or anything relating to ancient "Greeks") does not mean it has something to do with modern Greeks, it is an old tactic of the "Slav" school of thought (SDS/Gligorov era argument) that did the rounds in the early 1990's and its worth is limited, IMO. It can be used to undermine Greek arrogance but it should never substitute Macedonian assertive action.

For 20 years before your 20 years of trial and tribulation, I have been suffering further attacks on my identity. I understand your anger.

I take my hat off to your long "stazh"/service for the community and I never said that I personally had 20 years of trials and tribulations (the Macedonian community certainly did, and I was able to observe and sometimes participate in its activities -1992-95). I am sorry for the anguish those personal attacks are causing you!

FYI: The book Among the barbarians / Paul Sheehan (1998) has a section detailing the proceedings of an anti discrimination court case lodged by a "Hellenic" Council (perhaps NSW?) against the "Macedonian Youth Organisation of Sydney" and may be worth a read. The case was lost but I don't think costs were awarded to the M.Y.O.S. and it dragged through the courts for many years.

Cheers

----------


Gandeto: “....There is no denying that the period from Alexander the Great until well into the Roman time deals with Macedonian Dynasties, their rule, succession and their eventual interaction, or lack there of, with the indigenous local populations throughout the Balkan Peninsula, Asia and Egypt. Here, the term "Hellenism" can hardly do any justice to historical scholarship since its coverage/ domain leaves a huge section of history barely touched. Hellenism, the term Johan Gustaf Droysen gave to this era, is such a narrow cultural belt of history that its usage is not only misleading and inappropriate but it also distorts and minimizes the greatness of the ancient Macedonians. Even though the Greek contribution, from a cultural point of view, may be argued to have occupied a place of pivotal importance in the administrative sector of the empire, the organizational, the military and the structural components of this Macedonian Empire must have been obtained, delivered and maintained strictly from Macedonian resources and for Macedonian interests. The concept of an empire, an esoteric notion for the Greeks, was born with the first few initial successes of Alexander, and its meaning, magnitude, scope and structure grew as the string of victories and the success on the battlefields allowed Alexander to enlarge, coordinate and control huge land areas in Asia and Egypt. For almost 3 centuries after Alexander, it was his successors that carried the symbols and the name of the Macedonian Empire. Thus, the very narrow strip of "Hellenism" that comes, as a residue, attached to the period in question, cannot, in any meaningful way, embrace and encompass the scope and the magnitude of an empire that was built, organized and maintained on the strength and the efficiency of the Macedonian army....”

gandeto.gif

Ancient Macedonians - Differences Between The
Ancient Macedonians and The Ancient Greeks
by J.S.G. Gandeto.
 
macedonia

macedonia

Macedonistic era.

It's good to be nationalist.

Don't concern yourself about what Greeks think of us, they are inferrior.
 
UnitedForJohan said:
Don't concern yourself about what Greeks think of us, they are inferrior.
What do you mean by 'inferior'?

Indigen, I don't think Pasko Kuzman has a deliberate intent to spread anti-Macedonian propaganda, if he wrote 'Macedonian-Hellenistic period' he may have intended to highlight the significance of both components. He could have phrased it a little differently, but your thread title can be perceived as misleading.

As there are no 'periods' popularly referred to as 'Romanistic' or 'Latinistic' in Europe, despite the widespread use of Latin in a similar manner and capacity as Koine, 'Hellenistic' is invalid if referred to as a 'period'. I therefore would agree that the 'Macedonian period' is a sufficient description on par with the 'Roman period', as the successor kingdoms (including Macedonia itself) that formed after the break-up of the Macedonian Empire were generally run by Macedonians in any case.

However, the 'Hellenistic' element that existed during that 'Macedonian period' cannot be disregarded altogether, which had, as Gandeto said:
.......a place of pivotal importance in the administrative sector of the empire......
Coins, documents and other such examples are precisely 'Hellenistic' rather than 'Hellenic' because Macedonians and other non-Hellenes were the majority of people that produced such evidence in Koine within the scope of administration, commerce and education. Such examples could then be argued to have predated and followed the Macedonian Empire, as Thracians, Romans and others also used elements of the Hellenes for the same reasons in many cases.
 
Macedonistic era.

It's good to be nationalist.

Nationalist = Patriot!

Definition of Nationalist:
n.
1. One who advocates national unity and independence; -- as, for example, one of a party favoring Irish independence before 1918.
[1913 Webster +PJC]

Definition of Patriot:
n.
One who loves, supports, and defends one's country.

Antonyms: patriot
Home > Library > Literature & Language > Antonyms
n
Definition: person who loves his country
Antonyms: traitor

Don't concern yourself about what Greeks think of us, they are inferrior.

Yes, OUR REAL PREDCI (ancestors) were the CONQUERORS (YOKE AROUND THE NECK) of the perceived ancestors of the Roman leftovers in modern "Elliniki Dimokratia", thus superior in military and state craft, amongst other achievements!
 
Last edited:
Here is the origin of Hellenistic - http://www.macedoniantruth.org/forum/showthread.php?t=1088

It's meaning was something totally different in the 17th century from what some today think or feels that it is. I don't understand why we feel a need to label things today using mis-leading terminology? Scholars have really created a confusing picture to some and created a utopia (our southern neighbors) for others concerning terminologies like this. It's baseless and leads to dis-information. I know where both RTG and Indigen are coming from. I personally feel that "Alexander Era" would suffice.
 
Indigen, I don't think Pasko Kuzman has a deliberate intent to spread anti-Macedonian propaganda, if he wrote 'Macedonian-Hellenistic period' he may have intended to highlight the significance of both components. He could have phrased it a little differently, but your thread title can be perceived as misleading.

There can be NO EXCUSE for any Macedonian (especially for someone "perceived" as a Macedonian patriot) to present Ancient Macedonian heritage as anything but Macedonian - NO IFS, NO BUTS!

The Macedonian state was based on predominantly native stock (native population), very different to the other Macedonian successor kingdoms/states, and it is anti-Macedonian to deny its Macedonian essence in naming designations/classifications! Furthermore, it has been argued that the Romans spread and assimilated more "Hellenic" culture than anyone else before and yet their classification remains intact - Roman Empire/Roman Era/Roman Period!


As there are no 'periods' popularly referred to as 'Romanistic' or 'Latinistic' in Europe, despite the widespread use of Latin in a similar manner and capacity as Koine, 'Hellenistic' is invalid if referred to as a 'period'. I therefore would agree that the 'Macedonian period' is a sufficient description on par with the 'Roman period', as the successor kingdoms (including Macedonia itself) that formed after the break-up of the Macedonian Empire were generally run by Macedonians in any case.

I HOPE ALL THE REST ON THIS FORUM CAN UNDERSTAND AND LEARN FROM YOUR DEDUCTION! :-)

However, the 'Hellenistic' element that existed during that 'Macedonian period' cannot be disregarded altogether, which had, as Gandeto said:

I think "Gandeto" was talking to a different audience in saying what he says. There is no doubt in my mind that he would be talking in a different language had his audience been Macedonians only!

Lets move on!

Cheers
 
Here is the origin of Hellenistic - http://www.macedoniantruth.org/forum/showthread.php?t=1088

It's meaning was something totally different in the 17th century from what some today think or feels that it is. I don't understand why we feel a need to label things today using mis-leading terminology? Scholars have really created a confusing picture to some and created a utopia (our southern neighbors) for others concerning terminologies like this. It's baseless and leads to dis-information. I know where both RTG and Indigen are coming from. I personally feel that "Alexander Era" would suffice.

TM, I now think that the labelling that Pasko uses is politically directed! He seems to be a typical bureaucrat and will follow directions in order to keep working in his post (probably what most (would) do in his position in RM) and in prior cases he used to use only the "Hellenistic" designation.

If you remember, around June 2009 there was a great deal political dissention regarding the "New History" subject following the publication of "History Of The Macedonian People" by Mitko Panov and this might be a temporary compromise political decision.

kniga-istorija.jpg


Новата историја е објавено на македонски и англиски јазик. Не е наменета за образовниот систем, туку за надворешна промоција на Македонија. Ја издаде Институтот за национална историја со пари на Владата.

Some Links (in Macedonian):

Историско откритие или обид за манипулација


mitko-panov.jpg

Mitko Panov (author).

Нова историја на Македонија


aleksandar-makedonski.jpg

Епохата на Александар Трети Македонски треба да се нарекува „александризам“ или „македонизам“

Ристовски: Ние сме доминантно словенски народ


17.06.2009 16:40
Веќе нашата маса како да се цепи
Во денешните Македонци сигурно има и некоја капка античка крв, но ние сме доминантно словенски народ, вели за А1, академик Блаже Ристовски.

СВЕТСКИ МАКЕДОНСКИ КОНГРЕС
ПРОМЕМОРИЈА ЗА (НЕО)ВРХОВИЗМОТ И МАКЕДОНСКИОТ ИДЕНТИТЕТ

11 октомври 2009 година, Скопје, Mакедонија - Светскиот Македонски Конгрес објави Промеморија за (нео)врховизмот и македонскиот идентитет којашто ја објавуваме во целост.

(1) Врховизмот во Македонија како феномен од крајот на деветнаесеттиот и почетокот на дваесеттиот век претставува сервилност на определена номенклатура која во отсуство на доверба од сопствениот електорат, мандат за власт бара од некоја од соседните метрополи на Македонија.

(2) Историјата на Македонија ниту започнува ниту завршува со ВМРО. ВМРО е само дел од најновата историја на Македонија. И затоа, иднината и судбината на Македонија не зависат од пројавите на врховизмот во ВМРО и неоврховизмот во ВМРО-ДПМНЕ и СДСМ. Секако дека ќе има и епизодни реакции по инерција, но без влијание на државноста на Македонија како милениумски процес, а не како дневна манифестација.

[...]

(8) Оттука и не случајно, актуализацијата на јавната полемика за „Словените и античките Македонци“ и „неологизмот антиквизација политички мотивиран заради десловенизација на македонскиот идентитет“, кој Светскиот Македонски Конгрес го отфрла како анахронизам. Напротив, распаѓањето на СФР Југославија ја ослободи македонската археологија и историја од изолацијата во сопствената држава заради туѓи интереси кон Македонија и Македонците. Археолошките ископини и историографијата не претставуваат антиквизација, ниту нивното истражување претставува романтизам, туку објективизација промоција и афирмација на македонскиот идентитет.

(9) За Светскиот Македонски Конгрес е неприфатлива поделбата на антички Македонци и Словени. За Светскиот Македонски Конгрес постојат само Македонци кои имаат непрекинат континуитет од пред новата ера до денес, независно како туѓи и други за свои интереси во разни периоди ги нарекувале. Сепарацијата на „Словени зад Карпатите“ и на антички Македонци е производ на заговорот за трајна промена на историското и државното име Македонија! Македонското културно наследство е интегрално и единствено со континуитет во време и простор и тоа им припаѓа на македонската историја и наука. Обвинувањата за таканаречена „антиквизација“ се дел од тој заговор! Впрочем, народ без историја, културно наследство и традиции нема минато, а народ без минато нема своја иднина!

[...]

----------


Коренита реформа во системот на МАНУ
Авторот е државен советник во Владата

Македонска енциклопедија би требало да биде највисокиот дострел на македонскиот гениј низ вековите. Посебно кога станува збор за прво дело од таков вид и калибар

[...]

Македонија е „света земја“ според еден угледен професор на еден престижен американски универзитет кој за Македонија и за Македонците научил првенствено од Библијата. Човек кој е воодушевен од земјата во која стапнал и чекорел апостол Павле, од земјата која прва на тлото во Европа се охрабрила да оформи Христијанска црковна заедница во Филипи (Драма), од народот кој прв се осмелил храбро да истапи од многубоштвото и да ја прими христијанската вера, преку примерот на Лидија. Името Лидија е типично македонско, и е најчесто застапено токму во Македонија, а не во Грција, Бугарија или Србија. Таа „света земја“ и тие „свети луѓе“ тој ги препознава во денешната Република Македонија, во денешниот македонски народ.

Ако нашите академици, користејќи историски извори и факти само од руска провениенција, без притоа задлабочено и научно издржано да навлезат во историските архиви на Рим и Ватикан, на Истанбул, на Вашингтон, Лондон, и каде уште не на тлото на западната христијанска цивилизација, не дозволат свеж ветар во Академијата, тогаш времето кое доаѓа ќе ги прегази и едноставно ќе служат за наш срам, а не за наше гордеење. Коренита реформа треба во системот на МАНУ.

Да тврдите денес дека Македонците се чисто словенска нација и народ, дека словенството успеало за само два века, или за само три генерации (дедо, татко, син) да претопи цел еден народ кој де факто живеел и творел и имал сериозни достигнувања на овие простори, треба да сте дебело политички индоктринирани од српското и руското влијание на овие простори. Замислете, варвари и диви племиња, кои не знаеле што е писменост, кои биле пагани, многубошци и не знаеле за Бога, истите тие да претопат докажан македонски гениј, да го збришат од земјината топка, да го претворат во невидлива материја по примерот на Коперфилд... И згора на тоа, да не знаете дека вие сте првите христијани на тлото на Европа, дека сте првата црква на тоа исто тло...
Ајде здраворазумски некој да ми каже дали е ова можно?..

[...]

----------
 
For those who posted for the benefit of my education about the meaning of "Hellenistic", I know what it means and encompasses and I reject its use in regards to anything relating to Macedonian/Macedonistic era/period - always!
Indigen, do you believe Koine spread further as a result of Alexander's conquests?
 
Back
Top