• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

Macedonian Church Dispute in Australia

Hi everyone,

I just got back from Macedonia and have some info I found out whilst there which is pertinent to this thread.

Petar is loved in Bitola.

I had a long conversation with someone I'll call GP when I was there who said he was close to Petar and could call him to a meeting at anytime. GP asked me if I wanted to meet the Vladika and I replied, call him to a meeting if you can, he won't meet with anyone who opposes his position!

Needless to say the call was not made and I didn't get to meet Petar.

I explained to GP how the church was divided in Australia and that all church and community property now belonged to Petar. Not MOC!

GP chose not to enter that discussion and went on to tell me about what a great guy Petar was as he went to Albania and personally christened 60 odd children in one sitting. In his opinion, this was a great deed and Petar could do no wrong.

Bij, I told GP about what the priest in Sydney said to your niece. About the tactics they were employing to scare the people.

GP again didn't want to respond.

GP asked me if I could arrange to get him to Australia and that he would resolve this issue.

I told him that all Macedonians in Australia were behind MOC. That those not under Petar banner are supported by Gospodin Gospodin Stefan.

Now for the good bit!

According to GP, who claims he eats & drinks with Petar whenever he wants, Gospodin Gospodin Stefan hates the Egejci and wants nothing to do with them. This is why Nikodim Tsrknjas is not in part of MOC.

Petar tells Bitolcani that GG Stefan is against Macedonian people and that he can't do anything about this. That he has put plees in to GG Stefan to get him to unite Macedonians and GG Stefan stands firm in despising Egejci and not uniting us.

I told GP I found this hard to believe as GG Stefan has sent priests to Australia to churches who don't support Petars take over bid. That Petar will not meet with anyone to discuss the issue.

He said the reason why Petar did what he did was because "the Australians" went to church in their shorts and that disrespected the church.
 
Good To Have you back Mikail

Gospodin Gospodin Stefan to me seems like an Angliska Kralica, there is no doubt that there are secret tensions between Bishops and there have been for quite a while now.

The problem with taking Nikodim Carknjas to MPC is that he is a priest and not a Bishop for starters, if we use him against the Greeks like how the Serbs are using Vraniskovski against us this will further fuel political tensions. I think its great that he is involved with the Human Rights Committee however putting too much exposure on him will only fuel further hatred from the Greek side.

Mikail, Whats the feeling like there with our people in Stari Kraj aswell as in Egejska Makedonija?? Did you cop a bit of slack about being from Australia and that you'll be forced to give $10 for our flag? LOL

They did it to me all the time.
 
Good To Have you back Mikail

Gospodin Gospodin Stefan to me seems like an Angliska Kralica, there is no doubt that there are secret tensions between Bishops and there have been for quite a while now.

The problem with taking Nikodim Carknjas to MPC is that he is a priest and not a Bishop for starters, if we use him against the Greeks like how the Serbs are using Vraniskovski against us this will further fuel political tensions. I think its great that he is involved with the Human Rights Committee however putting too much exposure on him will only fuel further hatred from the Greek side.

Mikail, Whats the feeling like there with our people in Stari Kraj aswell as in Egejska Makedonija?? Did you cop a bit of slack about being from Australia and that you'll be forced to give $10 for our flag? LOL

They did it to me all the time.

There is other reason for Tsarkanjas being left from MPC and that's the serville politics toward the Universal Patriarch Bartholomew - the head of Istambul's patriarchy.

They are afraid of the 'implications', as they would make it from harder to imposible for the recognition of MPC.
But taking into consideration that Barholomew is a Greek patriarch it's pretty obvious that untill such position will be held by Greeks, we shouldn't be expecting revelations in their policy toward MPC.

Vranishkovski is actually a Greek puppet, not Serbian. The second, is only a mask for the real interest.

Their aim is to breake the spiritual moral of Macedonians, to neutralize the MPC of carrying the 'Macedonian' augury in it's name, putting on us Serbian spiritual rule and renaming our church in - Ohrid Archbishopric(POA of Vranishkovski).


While this clown Peter is a simple matherialistic govno to sell even his own mother for a sport car.

Sometimes.. there is only a one reasonable way to end a misery, amputation.


In the letter from the Cosmic patriarch Vartolomej addressed to the president of the Government of Republic of Macedonia, d-r Vlado Buckovski, delivered on 19th of October 2005, it is said:

“Dear Excellency,
With great pain we follow the prolonged static if not retrograde, to the decision regarding to the long-term and changeful totality of the “body” of the Holy Orthodox Churches - for church’s problem of your country.
We can’t hide the impression of our Holy Mother of God the Great Church, regarding to it the country over there didn’t play the required constructive role, it saw the whole question probably under an ethnic prism and stayed on the opinions which are little bit in conformity with for ages old valid church and holy canons’ rules. Surely, you can react that that is also done by the Serbian government. But with this Patriarch letter we are specially addressing to Excellency of yours and we underline the necessaryment for urgent change of the way of managing the problem by the Government, because the God’s solution is aridly being filibustering with your last opinion, and that, as the facts point out that you’re also properly understanding it, has direct consequences to the overall governmental base of your government.
For example, the Mother Church has addressed with a requirement by an official letter to us and required mine intermediation for releasing of the Holy Bishop Mr. Jovan.
In the previous letter addressed to the Mother Church in august you mentioned him as any ordinary citizen of your country, which is not in agreement with the basic rules of cultural behavior and to the respect of the Ecumenical Patriarch.
That’s why if it’s true, as we believe, you covet the regular solving of this church problem, you should hug, in my opinion, the Church’s thinking, because there is no other except this Holy Spirit unlighted by the Holy Fathers of the church, to bring out the Holy synod rules, according to which, the overall church’s body is been polities and controlled.
With this, with Our father God’s bless, we are remaining with deep love and respect”.

http://www.makedonskosonce.com/1_1/info/info_en/br595.htm

Do you understand it better now?
 
Last edited:
...Gospodin Gospodin Stefan to me seems like an Angliska Kralica, there is no doubt that there are secret tensions between Bishops and there have been for quite a while now.

Petar's had his eyes on the Archbishop's throne for at least 20 years. He has gone to disgraceful extremes to defame and question the legitimacy of every Archbishop who has held the throne since g.g. Gavril, including Gavril himself, g.g. Mihail and g.g. Stefan. He's gone furthest in defaming and questioning the legitimacy of g. Kiril, who, as the only survivor of the three bishops who signed the declaration of independence of the Macedonian Orthodox Church, has been a front-running contender for the Archbishop's throne for decades. Petar's nasty campaigns to defame and vilify g. Kiril as somebody who is not a real Bishop, which in themselves make him unfit to wear the cloth, are the key reason why Kiril has never become Archbishop.

Petar denied the legitimacy of the election of g.g. Stefan from day one and has since juggled between discrediting and blackmailing Stefan into turning a blind eye to the non-canonical, unconstitutional and morally repugnant campaign Petar is waging against the Australian Macedonian Orthodox communities.

In being as cowardly and complacent as he is, Stefan has hardly shown himself to be a true leader and protector of the integrity of the Macedonian Orthodox Church. However, I can assure everyone that he is by no means a hater of "egejci". Any such propaganda is probably generated by Petar advocates.

If any Macedonian Bishop has shown himself to be hostile to the 'egejci', it is Petar himself. His original and most vicious attacks on the Macedonian Orthodox communities in Australia were targeted specifically at those old communities that were established by Macedonians from the Aegean part of Macedonia. Particularly in Melbourne, Adelaide and Perth, and to some degree in Sydney, he and his supporters have shamelessly and heartlessly worked to prolong and promulgate the "Egejci v. Vardarci" schism of the old Yugoslav paradigm, as part of his divide and conquer strategy.

The problem with taking Nikodim Carknjas to MPC is that he is a priest and not a Bishop for starters,..

Are you going to spread defamatory nonsense about father Nikodim too now, Prolet? For someone who plays so dumb and naive on these issues, you seem to have just about every malicious rumor generated by Petar advocates well covered covered.

Nikodim Carknjas is an Orthodox Archimandrite (the highest clerical title under Bishop), who has been purportedly defrocked by the Greek Orthodox Church due to his 'coming out' as an ethic Macedonian, his dedication to preserving and promulgating the Macedonian ethnic identity, language and culture in the part of Macedonian under Greek state rule, and his advocacy for the protection of human rights within the Greek state in general. There is no canonical obstacle to the Macedonian Orthodox Synod ordaining him as a Bishop. The key obstacle is Petar's opposition to Carknjas becoming a Bishop. Petar's collusion and signed anti-Macedonian agreement with the Serbian Orthodox Church, which is a partner of the Greek Orthodox Church in its anti-Macedonian stance, should make it pretty clear to you why he opposes Carknjas becoming a Bishop of the Macedonian Orthodox Church. Carknjas himself has been pretty clear about what he thinks of Petar's character and his collusion with the Serbian Church.

If we use him against the Greeks like how the Serbs are using Vraniskovski against us this will further fuel political tensions. I think its great that he is involved with the Human Rights Committee however putting too much exposure on him will only fuel further hatred from the Greek side.

I am sure that coming out of the closet and openly supporting the Serbian Orthodox Church decree signed by Petar, known as the "Nish Accord", will bring you a lot of love from the Greek Orthodox Church, Prolet.
 
Good The problem with taking Nikodim Carknjas to MPC is that he is a priest and not a Bishop for starters, if we use him against the Greeks like how the Serbs are using Vraniskovski against us this will further fuel political tensions. I think its great that he is involved with the Human Rights Committee however putting too much exposure on him will only fuel further hatred from the Greek side.

What is this garbage Prolet?

This is the same rubbish that has been spewed by Petar here in the past. When the rally to promote Macedonian issues was held in Canberra in 2007, Petar claimed that the rally would only harm relations with the Greeks.

Are you and your master suggesting that we should relinquish our human rights so that we don't "fuel hatred from the Greeks"?
 
Aleksandrov, Father Nikodim Carknjas to me is a great person and somebody i respect alot, i know for a fact that he is not a Bishop however he is a high ranking sveshtenik. We can all speculate the reason but only the Bishops in Stari Kraj know the real story.

I also agree that ArchBishop Stefan is not against any Egejci whats so ever, people have their own opinions.

Aleksandrov, Here is what Father Nikodim Carknjas had to say about Bishop Petar in an interview.

http://www.geocities.ws/svetikim/info.html
 
Aleksandrov, Do you know anymore about the predlog zakot for Staratelstvo which Bishop Peter is introducing before the courts in NSW?

Владиката Петар и предлог-законот за МПЦ во Австралија

Канцеларија на Македонската православна црква, Епархија за Австралија и за Нов Зеланд


Владиката Петар е во посета на Епархијата и активно го надгледува разгледувањето од страна на парламентот во Нов Јужен Велс на предлог-закон за старателство на имотите во Австралија на Македонската православна црква, Епархија за Австралија и за Нов Зеланд.

Парламентот во Нов Јужен Велс го разгледува предлог-законот за старателство на четирите епархиски црковни имоти на кои се лоцирани Соборниот храм „Раѓање на Пресвета Богородица“ во Сиднам - Викторија, црквите „Света Богородица Пречиста“ во Ливерпул - Нов Јужен Велс, „Собор на Пресвета Богородица“ во Аделаид - Јужна Австралија и манастирот „Свети Прохор Пчински“ во Донибрук, Викторија.

Овие имоти сега се чувани од страна на три лица старатели - митрополитот Петар, протoјeреј Јовица Симоновски и протoјeреј Тоне Гулев. Митрополитот Петар, кој е назначен од страна на Светиот архиерејски синод (САС) на МПЦ и свештениците од страна на Епархиското собрание, како привремени старатели на овие црковни имоти до моментот на основање законски старател. Доколку биде усвоен предлог-законот во Нов Јужен Велс, горенаведените епархиски имоти ќе бидат автоматски предадени на чување на законскиот старател. Со ова ќе се реши долгогодишниот проблем на црковни имоти чувани од страна на лица поради неможноста за основање ваков законски старател во минатото. Важно е да се напомене дека овој предлог-закон ќе ги опфати само горенаведените четири имоти и нема да се однесува на имотите на која било друга црква или црковна општина, асоцијација, компанија итн.

Законот предвидува постапка за вакви и други имоти да бидат предложени за чување од страна на законскиот старател, но само доколку има согласност од страна на релевантната црковната општина или на кој друг било дарител, асоцијација, компанија, правно или приватно лице, но и со согласност на Епархискиот управен одбор (ЕУО), односно Епархискиот одбор на доверители на црковните имоти на МПЦ.

Парламентот на Нов Јужен Велс свика комисија за го разгледа ефектот на овој предлог-закон. Епархијата подготви детална изјава во врска со важноста на законот за МПЦ во Австралија.

Владиката Петар навремено ќе ги известува свештениците и верниците во парохиите на епархијата за напредокот на овој предлог-закон, со цел верниците да бидат информирани за овој значаен подвиг на нашата МПЦ во Австралија.

http://www.utrinski.com.mk/?ItemID=FD1BE252272F3F448DAD24406FB3705D
 
Aleksandrov, Do you know anymore about the predlog zakot for Staratelstvo which Bishop Peter is introducing before the courts in NSW?

Владиката Петар и предлог-законот за МПЦ во Австралија

Канцеларија на Македонската православна црква, Епархија за Австралија и за Нов Зеланд


Владиката Петар е во посета на Епархијата и активно го надгледува разгледувањето од страна на парламентот во Нов Јужен Велс на предлог-закон за старателство на имотите во Австралија на Македонската православна црква, Епархија за Австралија и за Нов Зеланд.

Парламентот во Нов Јужен Велс го разгледува предлог-законот за старателство на четирите епархиски црковни имоти на кои се лоцирани Соборниот храм „Раѓање на Пресвета Богородица“ во Сиднам - Викторија, црквите „Света Богородица Пречиста“ во Ливерпул - Нов Јужен Велс, „Собор на Пресвета Богородица“ во Аделаид - Јужна Австралија и манастирот „Свети Прохор Пчински“ во Донибрук, Викторија.

Овие имоти сега се чувани од страна на три лица старатели - митрополитот Петар, протoјeреј Јовица Симоновски и протoјeреј Тоне Гулев. Митрополитот Петар, кој е назначен од страна на Светиот архиерејски синод (САС) на МПЦ и свештениците од страна на Епархиското собрание, како привремени старатели на овие црковни имоти до моментот на основање законски старател. Доколку биде усвоен предлог-законот во Нов Јужен Велс, горенаведените епархиски имоти ќе бидат автоматски предадени на чување на законскиот старател. Со ова ќе се реши долгогодишниот проблем на црковни имоти чувани од страна на лица поради неможноста за основање ваков законски старател во минатото. Важно е да се напомене дека овој предлог-закон ќе ги опфати само горенаведените четири имоти и нема да се однесува на имотите на која било друга црква или црковна општина, асоцијација, компанија итн.

Законот предвидува постапка за вакви и други имоти да бидат предложени за чување од страна на законскиот старател, но само доколку има согласност од страна на релевантната црковната општина или на кој друг било дарител, асоцијација, компанија, правно или приватно лице, но и со согласност на Епархискиот управен одбор (ЕУО), односно Епархискиот одбор на доверители на црковните имоти на МПЦ.

Парламентот на Нов Јужен Велс свика комисија за го разгледа ефектот на овој предлог-закон. Епархијата подготви детална изјава во врска со важноста на законот за МПЦ во Австралија.

Владиката Петар навремено ќе ги известува свештениците и верниците во парохиите на епархијата за напредокот на овој предлог-закон, со цел верниците да бидат информирани за овој значаен подвиг на нашата МПЦ во Австралија.

[url]http://www.utrinski.com.mk/?ItemID=FD1BE252272F3F448DAD24406FB3705D[/URL]

Prolet,

What do you think we have been discussing this entire time? How about you re-read this entire thread.
 
Good To Have you back Mikail

Gospodin Gospodin Stefan to me seems like an Angliska Kralica, there is no doubt that there are secret tensions between Bishops and there have been for quite a while now.

The problem with taking Nikodim Carknjas to MPC is that he is a priest and not a Bishop for starters, if we use him against the Greeks like how the Serbs are using Vraniskovski against us this will further fuel political tensions. I think its great that he is involved with the Human Rights Committee however putting too much exposure on him will only fuel further hatred from the Greek side.

Thanks for the welcome back Prolet.

Why am I not surprised you were the first to respond to what I wrote?

Adding a bit of 'spin' goes a long way to softening the impact on exposing the tactics Petar employs.

I have had a bit of a read of this thread since I got back Prolet and you certainly have a lot to say on this subject.

Your knowledge here is very large so why not come clean about who it is you are and what you know.
 
Dojchin said:
I agree with most of you that Petar is the main cause for the division among our community when our church is concerned.
No you don't, because you spent the rest of your post babbling about Aleksandrov. You're the same tikva that was here a couple of weeks ago, without the profanity. As a Macedonian that has had little to do with the church 'issue', and therefore a neutral, I can unequivocally state that I am absolutely disgusted in the lies, manipulations and behaviour of Petar's (and your) side.
 
As someone who is very far removed from this controversy, I have to wonder why the Macedonian Church hasn't pulled such a divisive force out of Australia by now? Whether there has been evidence of wrongdoing or not, the mere whiff of scandal would be enough for a reshuffling at the very least.

Some clarification would be greatly appreciated
 
Aleksandrov, Where do the Vernici fall into this?? It seems that every time somebody disagrees with you about something you accuse them of working for Bishop Petar, the way this is going Bishop Petar must be a millionare who has alot of people working for him.

Where would Bishop Petar,Jovica Simonovski and Tone Gulev be without us vernici? There is no MPC without us, thats for sure.
Prolet, I have already deleted a number of your irrelevant posts, and quite possibly will delete the one I just quoted above.

You have shown yourself to be absolutely ignorant of the key points in this issue, and your input has been of absolutely no value to this thread or discussion. Should you continue to post your irrelevance here, you will not be permitted to post on this thread again.
 
Aleksandrov,

The name of the title is not relevant, there are hundreds of Macedonians Australia wide voluntarily contributing for our community. But I don't know if any of them are receiving $75K+ for their contributions. Why is your time more valuable then theirs? That is the real issue here.

Dojcin,

Volunteerism is certainly a necessary feature of keeping a community running, particularly in terms of a democratically elected volunteer boards consisting of community members. However, in our highly complex legal and political system, there needs to be 'professional' and capable people running the day-to-day needs of the community (financial, legal, representative etc) otherwise we are doomed to suffer the incompetence of the past decades. If anything, the 'professionalisation' of our communities is overdue and MOCS is leading the way in this respect.

But, your not here to argue the merits of a 'professionalised' system, your here to attack Aleksandrov. Perhaps you can tell us why?
 
Aleksandrov, Where do the Vernici fall into this?? It seems that every time somebody disagrees with you about something you accuse them of working for Bishop Petar, the way this is going Bishop Petar must be a millionare who has alot of people working for him.

Where would Bishop Petar,Jovica Simonovski and Tone Gulev be without us vernici? There is no MPC without us, thats for sure.

Prolet,

What's your real relationship with Petar and his goons? Don't pretend to by some innocent bystander - you have done nothing but spread Petar's propaganda on this forum.
 
Lavche, we are relaxed, perhaps you should familiarise yourself with the facts a little more, Petar is not good for the Macedonian community in Australia.
 
The Macedonians in Australia
by
Peter Hill

Publisher: Hesperian Press, 1989
ISBN 0 85905 142 0

Parts of text from Chapter 8 (pp 89-98)

How Can We Pray To God In A Foreign language?

Macedonian Churches in Australia


The initiative to set up the Macedonian Orthodox Community of Melbourne and Victoria, and the church of St George, Fitzroy, dates back to the end of 1955 and the beginning of 1956. Among the activists were Risto Altin from Lagen/Lerin and Stoyan Sarbinoff from Buf/Lerin. At a public meeting on 14th May 1956, a church committee was elected, with Vasil Mojanov from Lagen/Lerin as president. It was decided to set up the church in Young Street, Fitzroy, on the site of the Yugoslav Club, where the Macedonian-Australian People’s League had its office.

A dance was held at St Luke’s Anglican Hall, North Fitzroy, on 27th May 1956 and fund-raising for the church began. Because of its national significance the church committee solicited and received donations from Macedonians throughout Australia for this project. In 1956 the Yugoslav Club was bought at a cost of £7,000 by the church committee and demolished to make way for the Macedonian Orthodox Church of St George.

The initiators of the church planned to place it under the jurisdiction of the Anglican Church, while their constitution states simply under article 75 that:
“The Community shall from time to time employ a priest who shall (...) perform all such religious rites, ceremonies and duties as are ordinarily performed by priests of the Eastern Orthodox Church”.

The initiators of the church conducted negotiations with Archdeacon Thomas of the Anglican diocese of Melbourne and with the vicar of Fitzroy North, Father James Elliott, but when the Macedonian Orthodox Church in Yugoslavia achieved administrative autonomy, the church committee in Melbourne approached the hierarchy in Skopje and in the end they were accepted as the first parish of this church outside Macedonia.

However in the meantime the Fitzroy Council had revoked the permit to erect a Macedonian Orthodox Church, apparently on the grounds that no such church organisation existed, and the church committee had to fight a battle in the Australian courts before their right to set up such a church was formally recognised by the Supreme Court of Victoria.

On 27th February 1959 the Memorandum and Articles of Association of the Macedonian Orthodox Community of Melbourne and Victoria were officially registered.

89

A building firm was commissioned on 11th May 1959 to build the church within 10 months for a cost of £24,500 the total cost of the church including preparatory work being £36,500, which was raised from donations, including interest-free loans, from Macedonians around Australia, and there was also an additional bank credit.

On Ilinden (2nd August) 1959 the foundation stone for the Macedonian Orthodox Church of St George was laid by the Mayor of Fitzroy, Alderman Blackman, and blessed by the priest of the Syrian Orthodox Church in Melbourne, Father George Haydar.

On 1st August 1960 a Macedonian church delegation, including Bishop Naum from the Zletovo-Strumica diocese, and Father Nestor Popovski, arrived from Skopje to participate in the consecration. The first parish priest of the church was to be Father Gjorgji Angelovski, who had arrived in Melbourne some 10 days earlier.

The visiting church delegation was welcomed at the airport by the secretary of the Church Committee, Vancho Nedelkovski, and a large delegation, including representatives of the Fitzroy Council and the Anglican and Syrian churches. (Cf. Andonov 1973 p. 100 et seqq.)

90
The church was consecrated on 7th August 1960. Some 5,000 people attended the consecration ceremony, which had been timed to coincide with Ilinden, and on the same day £6,000 was collected toward paying off the church.

The Macedonian Church of St George was the first community outside Yugoslavia to affiliate with the Macedonian Orthodox Church. It was only the first of many, being followed in quick succession by similar churches in Perth (1968), Adelaide (1969), Queanbeyan (1969), Sydney (1969), Newcastle (1970) and Wollongong (1972).

*


In Adelaide, chinch services began under the auspices of the Bulgarian Church Community at the Bulgarian Hall, 443 Tapleys Hill Road, Fulham Gardens, in 1968. The foundation stone for a Bulgarian church was laid in 1968, the church was completed in 1972 and consecrated in 1974. The Bulgarian church in Adelaide is a parish of the American Bulgarian Eastern Orthodox Church, Diocese of Akron/Ohio, under Bishop Andrey Velichky, and the first priest was Father Dimitâr Popov. Some Macedonians were involved with this church community, and the services also attracted local Macedonians.

In 1968, the then priest of St George’s in Melbourne, Father Metodija Gogov [The late Archbishop Mihail, died 1999.], visited the Macedonian Community of S.A. in Adelaide and convinced the leaders that they should initiate church services in Macedonian at the Macedonian Hall in Crittenden Road, Findon. Father Gjorgji Kacarski was dispatched from Skopje and began services in the back room of the Macedonian Hall in 1969.

After services began in Macedonian at the Macedonian Hall, the Macedonian Community of S.A. began to make plans to build their own church. Betty Kris’s survey revealed that, of 114 respondents, 66 felt that the community should build a church, while 40 were against, and 8 unsure.

But donations for the erection of the church were received not only from the Macedonian community in S.A., but also from the Stopanska banka in Skopje and from Yugoslavian Airlines (JAT), and, in addition, the Cultural Society Koco Racin from Skopje toured Australia in 1974 under the auspices of the Macedonian Orthodox Community of Adelaide as a fund-raising venture for the new church.

[....]

For fair use only.

NB: That is only part of the excerpt and the rest deals with the creation of the other churches as well as the ideological divide that occurred during Bishop Kiril's jurisdiction and some subsequent legal court wrangles that predate (and to some extent pave the way for) the actions Jole Karevski (aka Bishop Petar) is currently undertaking.
 
The Macedonians in Australia
by
Peter Hill

Publisher: Hesperian Press, 1989
ISBN 0 85905 142 0

Parts of text from Chapter 8 (pp 89-98)

How Can We Pray To God In A Foreign language?

Macedonian Churches in Australia

Part 2:


The foundations of the Macedonian Church of Saint Naum of Ohrid the Thaumaturge were blessed on 1st May 1982 by Bishop Cyril (Kiril), Macedonian Orthodox Metropolitan of Australia and Canada.

The church was designed by the Australian Macedonian architect Jim Petre after the famous church of St Naum on the banks of Lake Ohrid. The frescoes were carried out by the local artist Pero Buzdarovski.

The church was consecrated on 29th April 1984 by the present Metropolitan of Australia and Canada, Bishop Timothy [Timotej], in the presence of many distinguished guests from Yugoslavia, including the president of the Institute for the Emigrants from Macedonia, Boge Sotirovski, the Consul-General of Yugoslavia in Melbourne, Luka Novak, the Minister of Ethnic Affairs of S.A., Chris Sumner, and a huge congregation of Macedonians. Kosta Ka1inchev attended the ceremony as official representative of the church of St George, Fitzroy, and a cultural program was presented by the folkloric associations, Sloboda/Freedom (Adelaide), Biser/Pearl (Geelong) and 11th October (Melbourne).

[Page92] On 11th October 1984 - Macedonian Revolution Day - a bust of Goce Delchev, a gift from the Institute for the Emigrants from Macedonia in Skopje, was officially unveiled in front of the church by Kevin Hamilton, representing the Premier of S.A.

The first church to be established in Sydney and the only Macedonian Orthodox cathedral in NSW is Sts Cyril and Methodius, Rosebery, formerly St. Andrew’s Anglican Church. The site with the church was purchased in 1969 with funds collected by the Vesela Makedonzja organisation. The existing church was later rebuilt as the cathedral church of Sts Cyril and Methodius. The foundation stone was blessed by Bishop Cyril [Kiril] on 16th May 1976 and the new church opened by the Premier of NSW, Neville Wran, on 16th October 1977.

The Cathedral Church of Sts Cyril and Methodius is administered by the Macedonian Orthodox Community of Sydney Area Ltd, which was incorporated in January 1971.

In Cabramatta in 1977 the foundation stone was laid by the former Prime Minster Gough Whitlam for another church, to be dedicated to St. Nicholas. The foundations were laid in June 1983. 5 000 people attended the official opening on 20th April 1986. Among the official speakers was the Yugoslavian Consul-*General in Sydney, Bozhidar Crnjak. The consecration by Metropolitan Timothy took place on 8th February 1987 in the presence of Gough Whitlam and other distinguished guests such as the Premier of NSW Barry Unsworth.

93

Another group of Sydney Macedonians from the village of Capari (Tsapari) /Bitola established the Macedonian Orthodox Church of Sveta Petka in Rockdale in 1976 [This was then a pro Yugoslav move in opposition to the independent Macedonian Orthodox Community of Sydney and Area]. This church works under the constitution of the Macedonian Orthodox Diocese of Australia. [Worked only nominally and since then they are now outside its jurisdiction and major opponents! Though a long and very expensive legal battle is being waged by “Petar” against the Community.]

The constitution of the Macedonian Orthodox Community of Melbourne and Victoria is essentially democratic, in that power is vested in an elected church committee, which can employ and dismiss the priest of the community at will and without recourse to the bishop, who is thus only a spiritual head. This constitution was a source of dissension between the community and the Macedonian Orthodox Bishop of Australia and Canada (later Metropolitan of Australia), who resides in Skopje. When the Macedonian Orthodox Community tried to set up other churches in Melbourne, the Bishop refused to consecrate them unless they accepted the diocesan constitution, which makes the Bishop not only the spiritual head of the church community, but gives him also the title to the real estate of the church and influence over the membership of the church committee. There was a move by the Bishop to limit membership of church committees to Yugoslavian citizens. As a result of the dissension, the second Macedonian Orthodox church in Melbourne, that of St Elijah (Sveti Prorok Ilija) in Victoria Street, Footscray, which had been initiated by the Macedonian Orthodox Community of Melbourne and Victoria in 1971, was finally established in 1974 according to the diocesan constitution and in opposition to the church of St George. Plans to set up another Macedonian Orthodox Church in the northern suburbs of Melbourne failed for the same reason.

In the mid-1970s, the dispute between St George and the diocese reached the point where the latter threatened to withdraw the priest and thus effectively close down the church if the community did not accept the diocesan constitution. At this time, in most centres throughout Australia, a second church was set up with a diocesan constitution in opposition to the original Macedonian Orthodox Church. The constitutional crisis was most traumatic, however, in Perth.

The first Macedonian church in W.A. was that of St Nicholas within the Macedonian Club (Macedonian Community of W.A.) on the corners of Bourke Street, Albert Street and Kayle Place (later renamed “Macedonia Place”) in North Perth. This church was consecrated by the Metropolitan of Australia and Canada, Bishop Cyril (Kiril), on 6th April 1969. The first priest, Spase Stefanovski from Kumanovo, had arrived in Perth some months earlier from Skopje.

In October 1976 a dispute between the Community and the priest, Father Gjorgji Mitrev, came to a head. A General Meeting of the Community voted to dismiss the priest against the background of a new constitution which the diocese under Bishop Cyril [Kiril] wished the community to adopt.

The priest and a group of parishioners laid claim to the church and attempted also to have it re-registered in their names and under the diocesan constitution (cf. Vesnik, Perth, 25.12.77). After the High Court of W.A. ruled in July 1977 in favour of the Community, the priest and the group of parishioners loyal to him transferred the icons from the church on the corner of Albert Street and Kayle Place to a Methodist church which they had acquired on the corner of Angove and Albert Streets, which they renamed “Saint Nicholas”. They set up a church community of their own which they considered to be the only legitimate Macedonian Orthodox church and which was recognised as such by Bishop Cyril. The Macedonian Community of W.A. now appointed as their priest Father Kliment Dimitrov, who had served at the church of Sts Cyril and Methodius in Melbourne for some years in the mid-1960s, a priest of the Bulgarian Orthodox Church, and later Father Petre Nanevski, a Macedonian who had been ordained by the Ukrainian Orthodox Church in America.

Thus, Perth has two Macedonian churches called “St Nicholas”, with two separate church communities, but the first church of St Nicolas has now been readmitted to the diocese, and Father Petre Nanevski reconciled with the bishop in Skopje, and there are moves to build a new church at Macedonia Park in Balcatta and to re-unite the two communities.
*

In Australia today there are 18 Macedonian Orthodox church communities. The older church communities, such as St George, Fitzroy (Melbourne), St Demetrius, Wollongong, Holy Mother of God (Sveta Bogorodica), Newcastle, the first church of St Nicholas, Perth, and Sts Cyril and Methodius, Rosebery [and Sv Nikola, Cabramatta too (both under the jurisdiction of Macedonian Orthodox Community Of Sydney and Area!)] (Sydney), have independent constitutions, while the new ones work under the diocesan constitutions. However, all the church communities work together more or less harmoniously in the Diocesan Conference and some churches forward dues to the Diocesan Conference in Melbourne. From time to time the Diocesan Conference invites the Metropolitan to visit the churches in Australia.

[SO, IT MEANS THE SYNOD WAS BREACHING ITS OWN CONSTITUTION FOR DECADES BY ALREADY WORKING THE WAY THEY DID IN AUSTRALIA! IT IS HYPOCRISY TO NOW SAY OTHERS ARE NOT FOLLOWING THE CONSTITUTION!!!]

[...]

For fair use only.
 
Back
Top