• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

Macedonian Church Dispute in Australia

ive read the Bill & it is totally correct that the real analysis is nothing more than a land grab & gives Petar wide powers to do what he likes & can do anything such as sell the property & transfer the money anywhere.
 
Aleksandrov, cheers for that information. I have some issues
1/ It disgusts me that Reverend Nile is supporting and assisting in passing the Act, its a farce, from someone that instigated the DEMISE and death of the Presbyterian church in the SAME manner this is happening with the Macedonian Church in Australia. The Presbyterian church was swallowed by the Uniting Church. Goodbye Charlie.

2/ The Hellenic Association submission to drop the name , Macedonian. Perhaps they should reject the Act altogether

3/ The NSW Government with their pathetic comments on not acknowledging Macedonia, period, but DEMANDING FYROM or SKOPJE
why is AUSTRALIA continuing to NEGATE MACEDONIANS

4/ the original submission was passed over primarily because the Macedonian Communities in Australia were not privy to open meetings in regard to this whole farce.
Petar, to my knowledge, has not openly done this , yet again

If there are any supporters for the demise of the Macedonian church out there, they are the Petar sheep and his soldiers.
Wake up. Whay happened to the Presbyterian church is now commencing with the Macedonian church. Wake up you bunch of moronic imbeciles.
 
Last edited:
Apart from the Bill having an adverse effect does church cannon law have any influence
on Australian Law.Can the motherchurch from macedonia because of cannon law say this is mine & take it.Or is there some sort of protection that cannon law is not recognised here?
Also .I agree with Julie that the Hellenic Council should BUTT out this is not their dispute.They should not be allowed to muddy the waters.It's not about the name issue.
Who are these MORONS to dictate how a country etc should be called.How about a name for them "Hellenic Morons Council"".
 
Last edited:
Среда, 18 Август 2010
Цепачи на националното единство

cepaci-na-nacionalnoto-edinstvo-1.jpg


cepaci-na-nacionalnoto-edinstvo-2.jpg


http://www.mn.mk/istorija/2415-Cepaci-na-nacionalnoto-edinstvo

"Makedonska Nacija" - broj 12:
"..."Makedonska Nacija" gi pozdravuva site borci za makedonskoto
nacionalno edinstvo vo Avstralija im pozheluva uspeh vo nivnata
pravedna borba, a za svoite chitateli gi objavuva vo ovoj broj
spomenatite dve pisma na Makedonskata crkovna opshtina vo Melburn.
Na istava tema objavuvame i drugi materijal shto ni beshe ispraten
od nashi sorabotnici od Avstralija. So toa sakame da gi pomogneme
nashite brakja vo Avstralija vo nivnata borba za zachuvuvanje na
makedonskoto nacionalno edinstvo


Brakja Makedonci vo Avstralija!
Ne ostavajte razni agenti i razni neprijatelski snagi da go razbijat
vasheto nacionalno edinstvo, branete ja nezavisnosta na vashite
crkovni opshtini, so toa kje dokazhete deka ste verni sinovi na
Ilindenska Makedonija!.
..."


"MAKEDONSKA NACIJA"


For fair use only.

------

A relevant message from MN that, IMO, should be heeded and taken into account today in regard to resisting Jole (aka Petar) K.'s dirty deeds campaign against the patriotic Macedonian community of Australia!
 
Last edited:
Guy's, don't be too concerned with what the Hellenic council has to say on the matter. They have their own problems with their own Bishop, Stellianos, who was Petar's mentor in creating the Macedonian Church Dispute. This crap has been going on within the Greek community for much longer.

@ Prolet, sorry to push your buttons pal, but you are way too much of a fence sitter on way too many issues. Thanks for clearing that up.

Sorry Alexendrov, I was unaware you are a Barrister.
 
Mikail, You and i go back a long way surly by now you've been able to see that i view this church dispute very highly and i dont want to see this destroying our community.

What i want to know is and im not sure if people do know, Bishop Petar in the Sitel Interview said that he wants to register these 4 churches exactly the same way as the other orthodox churches are registered in Australia. Are the Serbian,Greek,Russian churches registered in a similar way?

The fact that Bishop Petar refuses to discuss his intentions without discussing what he is actually doing to his committee members in the churches i cant fully back his initiative. He needs to be upfront and honest with his dealings because our community is deeply involved in his decisions.
 
Sorry Alexendrov, I was unaware you are a Barrister.

Mikhail,

I am not a barrister or a practicing solicitor. I was admitted as a lawyer by the Supreme Court of NSW in 1998. This entitles me to work as a solicitor for a firm (if I pay for a practicing certificate), but I have not yet commenced practice as a solicitor and have not commenced the program that I have to complete to become a barrister. My current professional commitment is to establish and temporarily perform the role of Chief Executive Officer of the Macedonian Orthodox Community of Sydney. Once we find somebody suitable to continue that task, I hope to complete the program that is a prerequisite for working as a barrister.
 
Last edited:
Среда, 18 Август 2010
Цепачи на националното единство

cepaci-na-nacionalnoto-edinstvo-1.jpg


cepaci-na-nacionalnoto-edinstvo-2.jpg


http://www.mn.mk/istorija/2415-cepaci-na-nacionalnoto-edinstvo

"makedonska nacija" - broj 12:
"..."makedonska nacija" gi pozdravuva site borci za makedonskoto
nacionalno edinstvo vo avstralija im pozheluva uspeh vo nivnata
pravedna borba, a za svoite chitateli gi objavuva vo ovoj broj
spomenatite dve pisma na makedonskata crkovna opshtina vo melburn.
Na istava tema objavuvame i drugi materijal shto ni beshe ispraten
od nashi sorabotnici od avstralija. So toa sakame da gi pomogneme
nashite brakja vo avstralija vo nivnata borba za zachuvuvanje na
makedonskoto nacionalno edinstvo


brakja makedonci vo avstralija!
ne ostavajte razni agenti i razni neprijatelski snagi da go razbijat
vasheto nacionalno edinstvo, branete ja nezavisnosta na vashite
crkovni opshtini, so toa kje dokazhete deka ste verni sinovi na
ilindenska makedonija!.
..."


"makedonska nacija"


for fair use only.

---!

Суштината на расколништвото на МПЦ во Австралија. Многу малку е сменето, освен што поранешните југословенски вазали станаа или беа наследени од вазали на Српската православна црква и други странски хегемони со "вмровска" кожа.
 
Mikhail,

I am not a barrister or a practicing solicitor. I was admitted as a lawyer by the Supreme Court of NSW in 1998. This entitles me to work as a solicitor for a firm (if I pay for a practicing certificate), but I have not yet commenced practice as a solicitor and have not commenced the program that I have to complete to become a barrister. My current professional commitment is to establish and temporarily perform the role of Chief Executive Officer of the Macedonian Orthodox Community of Sydney. Once we find somebody suitable to continue that task, I hope to complete the program that is a prerequisite for working as a barrister.

OK. A Barrister here in Melbourne told me not so long go that the term Lawyer was an Amercanism and we don't officially have lawyers in Australia, hence why I assumed you were a Barrister.
 
Mikail, You and i go back a long way surly by now you've been able to see that i view this church dispute very highly and i dont want to see this destroying our community.

What i want to know is and im not sure if people do know, Bishop Petar in the Sitel Interview said that he wants to register these 4 churches exactly the same way as the other orthodox churches are registered in Australia. Are the Serbian,Greek,Russian churches registered in a similar way?

The fact that Bishop Petar refuses to discuss his intentions without discussing what he is actually doing to his committee members in the churches i cant fully back his initiative. He needs to be upfront and honest with his dealings because our community is deeply involved in his decisions.

Prolet, we do go a long way back hence my confusion by your actions here.

Prolet our community hasn't been destroyed by Petar, not at all, it's much worse than that. Petar has ripped the very heart out of what took a long time to establish.

As you would well be aware, Petar would have been a young boy, learning how to salute to Tato Tito and how to be a good Yugoslav, when Macedonians fought to establish the very first Macedonian Orthodox Church in the Diaspora and every consecutive Macedonian Orthodox Church thereafter.

Petar has been nothing short of an opportunist spilling out of the breakup of a Communist regime. Petar is as corrupt as every other sellout who has come from the top of the Former Yugslav fallout.

The only way to fix this is by the removal of Petar. Petar can never bring about harmony within our within community.
 
Aleksandrov said:
There is nothing in the Bill about registering the Macedonian Orthodox Church as a legal person. The Bill seeks to create a new statutory corporation made up of Bishop Petar and a handful of his appointees, under the name "Macedonian Orthodox Church Property Trust", to be the legal owner of property which it would hold on trust for the Australian Diocese of the Macedonian Orthodox Church. If the Australian Diocese or the MOC as a whole were to become a legal person in Australia, which they could do by incorporating as an association or company limited by guarantee, they wouldn't need Petar's trustee corporation to hold property for them. In fact, an ASIC database search indicates that the Macedonian Orthodox Archdiocese of Australia & New Zealand is already incorporated as an Association. But Petar wouldn't want it to be the holder of properties, as that would require him to be much more accountable to the constituents of the Diocese and to the relevant Australian regulatory agency.

These observations are indisputable. What confounds me is that Petar's supporters cannot see any alternative agendas transpiring right under their noses.

I am trying to understand the mindset of these people and think they must exist in the following fashion:

1. Blindly faithful. They would do or believe anything a man in a robe tells them. &/or
2. Blindly spiteful. They typically did not contribute anything to the building or ongoing maintenance of our churches. They believe they have nothing to lose and perhaps may even gain some influence should a wholesale change in ownership transfer from community to Petar occur. &/or
3. Jilted former community members who seek to destroy the community they used to be associated with. &/or
4. Children of any of the above who are yet to develop independent thought.

All of the above are dangerous for Macedonian communities in Australia.
 
These observations are indisputable. What confounds me is that Petar's supporters cannot see any alternative agendas transpiring right under their noses.

I am trying to understand the mindset of these people and think they must exist in the following fashion:

1. Blindly faithful. They would do or believe anything a man in a robe tells them. &/or
2. Blindly spiteful. They typically did not contribute anything to the building or ongoing maintenance of our churches. They believe they have nothing to lose and perhaps may even gain some influence should a wholesale change in ownership transfer from community to Petar occur. &/or
3. Jilted former community members who seek to destroy the community they used to be associated with. &/or
4. Children of any of the above who are yet to develop independent thought.

All of the above are dangerous for Macedonian communities in Australia.

At a most fundamental level, the danger is an abominable lack of education, prudence, free thought, moral enlightenment and the courage to stand up for the truth in the face of adversity, among a large part of our community and the Macedonian nation. That is what has kept Petar's engine of moral and material destruction running for so long.

It is easier to find a score of men wise enough to discover the truth than to find one intrepid enough, in the face of opposition, to stand up for it. A.A. Hodge

“Moralnata revolucija – revolucijata vo umot, srceto i dushata na eden ropski narod, e najgolemata zadacha.” Goce Delchev
 
Igor:Is there any solution to the church dispute?can there be a lasting one???Why & why not?(I'm on the neutral side.)
 
Igor:Is there any solution to the church dispute?can there be a lasting one???Why & why not?(I'm on the neutral side.)

Yes, there is. The solution is that the Synod appoint a worthy bishop to head the Australian Diocese, in place of Petar, who has been a 'temporary' administrator since about 2004. There will always be disagreements where power-sharing is concerned, but a person who is fit to be a true bishop and respects the Macedonian Orthodox people in Australia would never let things get anywhere near as bad as Petar has.

I refer you to interview with bishop Naum, conducted on 3 January 2008, posted on the official MOC-OA website, in which he was asked: What do you think, when will the situation with the property of the MOC in Australia be solved?

He answered:

"First peace must reign between the faithful in the Australia and New Zealand Diocese of the MOC, and that will occur when one or perhaps even two new bishops are appointed as the authorized prelates, behind whose work will stand a united Holy Synod of the Macedonian Orthodox Church.

For us, in Australia, there occurred a failure of the stages of solving the problems. The problems must first be solved on a spiritual level, and only after that on the material level. The problems must first be solved by prayer, in our heart, and only then outside of us. The church above all is its people, only after come its buildings."

See the full interview, in Macedonian, here:

http://www.mpc.org.mk/MPC/SE/vest.asp?id=2604
 
Екслузивно интервју на Митрополитот Преспанско -пелагониски и администратор австралиско-новозеландски Г-дин Петар

Законот се однесува само на оние имоти кои се епархиски и кои моментно гласат на мое име, на Отец Јовица Симоновски, на Отец Тоне Гулев. Ние имаме поднесено изјава, декларација пред адвокати , дека тој имот не е наш туку со одлука на епархиски Управен одбор е купен за овие цели за црквата и кога ќе се донесе овој Закон за старател на црквата, ние го предаваме, значи не станува збор за наш личен имот туку за имот кој е на МПЦ. На оние луѓе кои прават пропаганди ќе им пропаднат пропагандите ако овој Закон се донесе бидејќи не ќе можат да им велат на луѓето дека имаме цркви на наш имот. Со ова нема да стојат имотите на наше име туку името на старателот е МПЦ. И после нас, старател ќе биде МПЦ. Откако ќе се расчистат сите овие работи и кога не секој да се претставува како МПЦ и кога ќе престанат пропагандите, ние ќе обрнеме внимание повќе на отворање на старски домови,детски градинки, и други објекти за згрижување на лица – зависници од дрога, од алкохол и за тие посебно ќе се грижиме.

Нашата цел е да се создаде еднаш засекогаш старател на имотот на македонската црква во Австралија по примерот на првите верници во црквата како што бил случајот со верниците запишани во делата на светите апостоли .Овие регистрации за кои станува збор, овој Закон за старател значи регистрација на МПЦ. Ако МПЦ не биде регистрирана со свој имот не може ни да постои како правно лице.


http://www.radioilinden.com.au/inde...10-08-15-09-40-46&catid=37:zaednica&Itemid=57


Could you please give your comment on this Aleksandrov?
 
Екслузивно интервју на Митрополитот Преспанско -пелагониски и администратор австралиско-новозеландски Г-дин Петар

Законот се однесува само на оние имоти кои се епархиски и кои моментно гласат на мое име, на Отец Јовица Симоновски, на Отец Тоне Гулев. Ние имаме поднесено изјава, декларација пред адвокати , дека тој имот не е наш туку со одлука на епархиски Управен одбор е купен за овие цели за црквата и кога ќе се донесе овој Закон за старател на црквата, ние го предаваме, значи не станува збор за наш личен имот туку за имот кој е на МПЦ. На оние луѓе кои прават пропаганди ќе им пропаднат пропагандите ако овој Закон се донесе бидејќи не ќе можат да им велат на луѓето дека имаме цркви на наш имот. Со ова нема да стојат имотите на наше име туку името на старателот е МПЦ. И после нас, старател ќе биде МПЦ. Откако ќе се расчистат сите овие работи и кога не секој да се претставува како МПЦ и кога ќе престанат пропагандите, ние ќе обрнеме внимание повќе на отворање на старски домови,детски градинки, и други објекти за згрижување на лица – зависници од дрога, од алкохол и за тие посебно ќе се грижиме.

Нашата цел е да се создаде еднаш засекогаш старател на имотот на македонската црква во Австралија по примерот на првите верници во црквата како што бил случајот со верниците запишани во делата на светите апостоли .Овие регистрации за кои станува збор, овој Закон за старател значи регистрација на МПЦ. Ако МПЦ не биде регистрирана со свој имот не може ни да постои како правно лице.


http://www.radioilinden.com.au/inde...10-08-15-09-40-46&catid=37:zaednica&Itemid=57


Could you please give your comment on this Aleksandrov?

Already have, Bratot. It's another act of deception by Petar to get people to support something that has little if anything to do with what they think they are supporting. Just check the link to the Bill and the submissions regarding the Bill, which I posted above.

I will post my own submission here soon, but I am not sure how, as it is about 33 pages long.
 
Already have, Bratot. It's another act of deception by Petar to get people to support something that has little if anything to do with what they think they are supporting. Just check the link to the Bill and the submissions regarding the Bill, which I posted above.

I will post my own submission here soon, but I am not sure how, as it is about 33 pages long.

If I may suggest, either post all of the document on a separate thread and, with the approval of MTO Admins, have it locked and made a sticky and then link to it here or send it to RTG/SOM and have one of them do the same. Another option would be to use a document hosting service such as Google, which Chris Stefou (aka Risto Stefov) uses for his "Macedonian Digest" monthly and post a link to it.
 
I will not be able to post a copy of my submission to the NSW Parliament's Inquiry into the Macedonian Orthodox Church Property Trust Bill 2010 until the Standing Committee has had time to consider it. However, I will start post aspects of our objections to the Bill.

The Bill represents an attack on the founding principles by which Macedonian Orthodox communities in Australia have been established, and have operated and accumulated assets since 1956. Those principles include freedom of religion, freedom of association, democratic, independent, and accountable self-government in the interest of the local Australian Macedonian Orthodox community, respect for general Australian law governing the registration and operation of non-profit and charitable organisations, and the right to preserve and promulgate the Macedonian ethnic heritage free of the repressive assimilation that Macedonians have been subjected to by state and church regimes in different parts of the Macedonian homeland for centuries.

Historical structure and political context of the Macedonian Orthodox Church

1.1 The Bill is based on a misguided presumption that the Macedonian Orthodox Church is historically hierarchical in its management and control of property.

1.2 The Macedonian Orthodox churches in Australia, America and Canada, as well as the modern Macedonian Orthodox Church in the Republic of Macedonia, were established as self-governing, legally decentralized institutions by a grass-roots movement of the Macedonian Orthodox people. Their establishment was led by the Macedonian national independence movement, with the objective of freeing the Macedonian people from oppressive state and church regimes. The clerics who provided spiritual leadership in the establishment of self-governing Macedonian Orthodox churches did so in defiance of the clerical hierarchies by which they were ordained and under which they served until they broke away.

1.3 Prior to 1913, the Macedonian homeland was under the religiously and politically oppressive rule of the Ottoman Empire for five centuries. In the course of the 19th century, the Ottoman Empire, under international pressure, allowed the national Orthodox churches of neighbouring Bulgaria, Greece and Serbia to operate in various parts of Macedonia. The desire of indigenous Macedonians to have their own Macedonian Orthodox Church was not respected. Macedonians, most of whom were historically Orthodox Christians, could only choose between the Serbian, Greek or Bulgarian Orthodox church. The clerical hierarchies of these churches used their resources and influence to indoctrinate and assimilate the Macedonian people into the new Serbian, Greek or Bulgarian and national identities, as defined by their nation-states.

1.4 In the Balkan Wars of 1912/13, Macedonia was occupied and divided by Serbia, Greece and Bulgaria. All of these states denied the Macedonian people the right to self-determination and the right to preserve and promulgate their autochthonous Macedonian identity, culture, language and historical heritage. Serbia insisted that the Macedonian people are Serbs. Greece insisted that the Macedonians are Greeks. Bulgaria insisted that the Macedonians are Bulgarians. The national Orthodox Church of each of these states used its religious influence to promote these politically, culturally and ethnically oppressive policies.

1.5 The “Macedonian Orthodox Church – Ohrid Archdiocese” (MOC-OA) operates only in the part of Macedonia that was under Serbian rule between the Balkan Wars and WWII, and subsequently achieved the status of a federal Republic in the Yugoslav Federation of nations, before declaring independence in 1991. Macedonians currently living within the borders of neighbouring Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia and Albania are not offered the opportunity to establish their own Macedonian Orthodox churches. They continue to be subjected to systematic national assimilation by the Serbian, Greek and Bulgarian Orthodox churches. The hierarchy of the MOC-OA is doing very little, if anything, to support them in achieving respect for their basic human rights. This is a key point of distinction between the MOC-OA in Macedonia and Macedonian Orthodox communities abroad, which are made up of Macedonian migrants from all parts of Macedonia.

1.6 The process of the establishment of the modern Macedonian Orthodox Church has been traced to a resolution by the Supreme Headquarters of the Macedonian People’s Liberation Army and Partisan Divisions to appoint father Veljo Manchevski (a rebel priest originally ordained by the Serbian Orthodox Church) as its Religious Head, dated 15 October 1943.

1.7 The earliest recorded meetings of a Holy Synod and Church-people’s Assembly of the Macedonian Orthodox Church occurred on 17-19 July 1943, without the presence or blessing of any bishop.

1.8 The first Macedonian Church-people’s Assembly acknowledged in the preamble to the current Constitution of the MOC-OA, held on 4 March 1945, was also held without the presence or blessing of any bishop. Among the resolutions of that Assembly were the following:

“1. That the (medieval) Ohrid Archdiocese be renewed as a Macedonian independent church that will not be subservient to any other Church;
2. That it shall have its own national bishops and its own national clergy as a guarantee of the preservation of its distinct national characteristics.”

1.9 A subsequent Assembly of Macedonian Priests, held in May 1946, resolved:

“1. That the Church in the People’s Republic of Macedonia have national bishops, national clergy and self-government in the resolution of all internal church-people’s matters.
2. That bishops be elected by the people and the priests.”

1.10The Macedonian Orthodox Church in the Republic of Macedonia operated without any bishops and without recognition by any other Orthodox Church hierarchy from at least 1943 to 1958. During that time, its legitimacy as an Orthodox Church was disputed by the hierarchy of the Serbian Orthodox Church within Yugoslavia, as well as by other Orthodox Church hierarchies.

1.11 On 4-6 October 1958, a Macedonian Church-people’s Assembly held in Ohrid Macedonia adopted a Constitution for the establishment of an autonomous Macedonian Orthodox Church, which would be in canonical unity with the Serbian Orthodox Church, and have bishops approved by the Serbian Orthodox Patriarch. On 17 July 1967, an Archiepiscopal Church-people’s Assembly of the Macedonian Orthodox Church declared autocephaly, that is, complete independence from the Serbian Orthodox Church.

1.12 Article 4 of the foundational constitution of the Macedonian Orthodox Church makes it clear that it was conceived as a decentralised affiliation of various legal entities, each of which was to be independent in the legal ownership and control of its property:

“The Macedonian Orthodox Church consists of the following legal persons:

1. Macedonian Orthodox Church;
2. The Metropolitan residency;
3. The Dioceses;
4. The bishops’ regencies;
5. The church communities;
6. The monasteries;
7. Charitable foundations;
8. The independent institutions and funds, legacies and individual parishes, according to their properties;
These legal persons are entitled, in accordance with the existing state laws, to accumulate and hold real property and any other property, to use and manage it, and to exercise all rights and obligations arising from its ownership.”

1.13 The definition of local church communities as separate legal persons remains a part of the Constitution of the MOC-OA to this day. However, Article 172 of the current version of the Constitution, which was passed in 1994, ambiguously attempts to subvert the right of individual church communities to independently determine how they will use their properties, by providing that they accumulate their properties “for the Church” and manage them “in accordance with this Constitution and church regulations, which are passed on the basis of this Constitution.” This provision was introduced in Macedonia without the free and democratic consent of the members of individual Macedonian Orthodox church communities in Australia, America, Canada and Western Europe. Most of those communities continue to rely on the democratic constitutions and legislation and regulations by which they are incorporated in their new homelands.

1.14 The establishment of a self-governing Macedonian Orthodox Church in Australia dates back to 1956, that is even before the official declaration of an autonomous Macedonian Orthodox Church in 1958, when the Macedonian Orthodox Community of Melbourne and Victoria democratically elected its first church committee and bought the property on which it built the church of St. George. A majority of the members and leaders of that Community were and still are Macedonians originating from the part of Macedonia under Greek state rule. There was no Macedonian Episcopal hierarchy operating in any part of the Macedonian homeland in 1956. The only Episcopal hierarchies operating in parts of Macedonia were the Greek Orthodox Church (in the parts of Macedonia under Greek and Albanian state rule), and the Bulgarian Orthodox Church (in the part of Macedonia under Bulgarian state rule). Both of those Church hierarchies, along with the Serbian and other non-Macedonian Orthodox Church hierarchies, had branches in Australia. A key motivation of the Macedonian Orthodox Community of Melbourne and Victoria was not to be under their jurisdiction and to remain legally independent.

1.15 Article 75 of the Community’s foundational constitution provided that “The Community shall from time to time employ a priest who shall perform all such religious rites, ceremonies and duties as are ordinarily performed by priests of the Eastern Orthodox Church.” There was no reference at all in the constitution to any specific Orthodox Church’s hierarchy.

1.16 When an administratively autonomous Macedonian Orthodox Church was subsequently established in the Republic of Macedonia, under the canonical jurisdiction of the Serbian Orthodox Patriarch, in 1958, its bishops accepted the St. George church as the first Macedonian Orthodox parish outside of Macedonia. However, the Macedonian Orthodox Community of Melbourne and Victoria, with its parish, retained its self-governing status. It did not make any amendments to its constitution that would legally bind it to the autonomous Macedonian Orthodox Church in the Macedonian Republic.

1.17 The foundation stone for the St. George church was laid on 2nd August 1959, blessed by a priest of the Syrian Orthodox Church, father George Haydar. The church was consecrated on 1st August 1960, by a bishop and priest from Macedonia. Its first parish priest was also from Macedonia, but it never accepted the jurisdiction of the Serbian Patriarch, even though the Church in Macedonia was under his canonical jurisdiction until 1967.

1.18 All other Macedonian Orthodox communities and churches established in Australia prior to bishop Petar’s arrival in 1996 followed the independent self-governing model of the Macedonian Orthodox Community of Melbourne of Victoria, with respect to property ownership and control. Hoewever, some of them, like the Macedonian Orthodox Church Community “St. Petka” Inc and Macedonian Orthodox Church Community “St. Nikola” in Preston Victoria adopted constitutions that put them under the canonical jurisdiction of the Macedonian Orthodox Church in Macedonia for what the founders thought would be only spiritual, rather than material purposes. Communities that accepted such provisions, without an understanding of the potential implications under trust law, ultimately became the targets of extremely costly and complex legal proceedings by bishop Petar, in his attempt to put their properties under the absolute and unaccountable control of himself or his appointees.

1.19 In 1996, having been freshly appointed by the Synod of the MOC-OA in the Republic of Macedonia to head its Australian Diocese, bishop Petar tried and failed to persuade existing Macedonian Orthodox communities in Australia to accept a new Diocesan Statute and By-Laws that would give him absolute and unchecked control over their funds, assets and appointment of office-bearers and delegates to his Diocesan Assembly. He then resorted to legal action, which led to claims of property having been held on trust for the MOC-OA that were previously unheard of.

1.20 The founders of the St. Nikola Community in Preston Victoria were the first to be sued. They promptly lost the proceedings due to inability to afford effective legal representation. They lost much of their own property, including homes, on legal costs. That is what they remember as the bishop’s and the MOC-OA’s show of appreciation for their countless voluntary hours in the establishment of the St. Nikola church.

1.20 The court victory against the St. Nikola Community emboldened the bishop to sue the MOCC St. Petka Inc in Rockdale NSW. Those proceedings have been on foot for 14 years now and the Community is severely struggling to afford effective legal representation. Bishop Petar’s source of funds for his legal expenses in the ongoing proceedings remains undisclosed.


Contemporary political hostility surrounding the Macedonian Orthodox Church

2.1 The Serbian Orthodox Church disputes the autocephalous status of the Macedonian Orthodox Church on the basis that it broke away without approval from the Serbian Patriarchy and that it is a non-canonical, ‘communist’ creation. The hierarchy of the Serbian Church has also maintained the hostile nationalist position that the Macedonian people are historically Serbs. Other Orthodox Church hierarchies have either actively supported or otherwise appeased the position taken by the Serbian Orthodox Church. Orthodox Macedonians worldwide find this position to be a violation of their right to freedom of religion, freedom of association and freedom to preserve and promulgate their distinct ethnic, cultural and linguistic heritage and identity.

2.2 Bishop Petar is one of several modern bishops in Macedonia who have a history of supporting the Serbian position on the independence of the Macedonian Orthodox Church. On 7 May 2002, he led a delegation of three Macedonian bishops who signed an agreement with the Serbian Orthodox Church to the effect that the “Church in Macedonia” would relinquish its Macedonian national identity, adopt the name Ohrid Archdiocese and come under jurisdiction of the Serbian Patriarch. Numerous sources suggest that a majority of bishops in the Holy Synod of the MOC were prepared to ratify that agreement, but backed off due to vehement opposition by bishop Kiril, bishop Agatangel, some lower ranking clerics, and overwhelming public revolt and political pressure within the Republic of Macedonia. Given the political volatility in the Republic of Macedonia, this position could easily change, against the will of Macedonian Orthodox Australians.

2.3 Despite the positions taken by bishop Petar and other Orthodox Church hierarchies, most Orthodox Macedonians are proud of the self-determination and the commitment to democratic, decentralised and transparent self-government that led to the establishment of independent Macedonian Orthodox churches in the Republic of Macedonia and Australia, as well as in America, Canada and Western Europe.
 
It must be disappointing to recant such detailed and thoughtful information only to be met with stupid and thoughtless replies based on innuendo, misinformation and hearsay.

I fear we will never see an equally intelligent reply.

It should be said that the Macedonian Orthodox Church has never tried to be a church for its Macedonians in Greece or Bulgaria. In which case, it has never tried to be a church for Macedonians outside of the Republic of Macedonia ...... except for instances where there is property up for grabs.
 
... It should be said that the Macedonian Orthodox Church has never tried to be a church for its Macedonians in Greece or Bulgaria. In which case, it has never tried to be a church for Macedonians outside of the Republic of Macedonia ...... except for instances where there is property up for grabs.

Did you notice point 1.5 in my previous post?
 
Back
Top