• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

Macedonian Church Dispute in Australia

aleksandrov, Petar has been placed here in Australia, the largest Macedonia diaspora group STRATEGICALLY to cause DIVISENESS to erode vox populi , the voice of the people, he has been planted and casuing this division by the political parties in RoM to allow the smooth transition of the framework agreemnt , to allow our cultural genocide.
Petar is the anti christ to the Macedonian cause, and PROLET if I hear you one more time spout he is an effing priest, will personally place you over my knee and spank your butt. Wake up stupids, wake up, the grand plan they have put in place has gone through, with UMD full support
 
Actually, is there any agreement about whether Petar is simply a madman on his own agenda or in fact carrying out the mission of his superiors.
 
PROLET if I hear you one more time spout he is an effing priest, will personally place you over my knee and spank your butt.
Now thats a turn on. Prolet might love a bit of bondage :001_tongue:

Petar has been placed here in Australia, the largest Macedonia diaspora group STRATEGICALLY to cause DIVISENESS
I don't think this was part of the master plan. It just eventuated that way because they underestimated the diaspora in Australia.


I understand what Prolet is trying to say (i think). This saga is no good at all and it must be solved. Even if it means inviting Petar and starting some sort of dialog for the sake of our people. Negotiations can be good sometimes.


He is a madman RTG. His superiors silence on this matter suggest they do indeed support his actions.
Or suggests they fear him. He has been known to blackmail them.
 
Last edited:
Actually, is there any agreement about whether Petar is simply a madman on his own agenda or in fact carrying out the mission of his superiors.

In fact, I think the first theory is closer to the truth. However, in pursuit of his own agenda, he will ally himself with anybody he thinks can assist him, and that usually means domestic and foreign players who share his interest in suppressing, paralysing or controlling the free will of the Macedonian people. He will betray ANYONE if he deems it opportune for his own agenda, so I am not sure that you can call anyone his superior in a long-standing sense. He even did it with his own spiritual child, Zoran Vraniskovski, when he sensed that his material interests were seriously threatened by Vraniskovski's coming out of the closet for an unwavering pursuit of the agenda that Petar set for him. And if he starts feeling that those he betrayed will retaliate more potently than he expected, there is no honor to prevent him from pretending that it wasn't him and that he has nothing but infinite fatherly love and respect for them. He will play that game like a fox, always ready to profit from a fresh opportunity to stick a knife in their back.
 
... This saga is no good at all and it must be solved. Even if it means inviting Petar and starting some sort of dialog for the sake of our people. Negotiations can be good sometimes....

Given the long history of this saga, which is well documented above, what exactly would you negotiate with him about?

On what basis would you expect that he will honor any agreement that may eventuate, as distinct from using it as a tactical opportunity for another low blow?
 
Bill77,

I think Petar's actions in Australia fit in quite well with the attempts of the Macedonian Government, starting from the early 90's, to control the diaspora. In fact, although some of the activists who have been fighting Petar all these years fail to recognise it - or just don't want to deal with it, I think UMD is the Macedonian Government's latest instillation that will eventually replace Petar and will do so without the need to attack our churches. They'll attempt to infiltrate our communities through much more subtle methods and may in fact (this is a guess) end up looking like 'peacemakers' or the ones who defeated Petar when the MK Government finally pulls him out and lays it all out on a platter for UMD.
 
Last edited:
Given the long history of this saga, which is well documented above, what exactly would you negotiate with him about?

On what basis would you expect that he will honor any agreement that may eventuate, as distinct from using it as a tactical opportunity for another low blow?
Well let me rephrase that. Talks don't have to be directly with Petar. There has to have some sort of dialog. But both sides need to have the will to do it. Its clear you have the upper hand with the success of the Bill not being passed. The Macedonian Orthodox Church don't have much options now but to surrender but under your terms. Some sort of unification is needed because we are divided in all sorts of fronts all over the world.

On what basis would i expect that he will honor any agreement that may eventuate, a legal agreement drawn up by Aussie lawyers even our own Parliamentary Bill to protect us incase of future low blows.

The way things are now, is ridiculous on both sides. Thank God i am an Macedonian Orthodox only by name.
 
Who needs legal agreements when you can hang millenniums of Christian guilt upon your flock? This is how Petar convinces his supporters that they are in the right. Unfortunately most of the clergy I have met are extremely manipulative and he is one of the supreme masters.
 
Bill77,

Who would you suggest talking to? Aleksandrov has made it quite clear that neither the MOC or the Macedonian Government are interested. So who does that leave?
 
Last edited:
Bill,

Please re-read through this thread to identify past efforts that at resolution by dialogue with the Synod. Ever since Stefan became Archbishop, all of our efforts have been completely ignored by him and the Synod, with the pathetic excuse that this is an internal matter for Petar's Diocese.

Archbishop Stefan is either a collaborator in Petar's mission to destroy our community or Petar has some really dangerous dirt on him that we don't know about. If we don't know about it, we can't do anything about it.

As far as a legal settlement with Petar is concerned, we have tried that on numerous occasions as well, including through court-appointed and very expensive mediators. The last mediator, a former Federal Court judge, ultimately advised us that he regretted having taken on the matter and wasting our money. After a day of mediation, he concluded that our dispute is not capable of being resolved by compromise because the bishop will settle for nothing less than our complete capitulation. MOCC St. Petka had to spend tens of thousands of dollars on its lawyers and the mediator for that mediation process, only to rediscover what we already knew.

Petar's defeat in relation to the Bill has not changed his attitude. His delusions of divinity won't allow him to face defeat. He is now persuading his uncritical followers that the Bill hasn't been defeated, but only suffered a temporary set-back, even though the Parliamentary Inquiry's report clearly states that it would not recommend the Bill in this or any other amended form unless community consensus can be reached (something that Petar is undoubtedly not capable of and is not even attempting).

Even if we were to achieve a legal agreement with Petar, that would not resolve the war in the long term. Legal agreements to which one of the parties has no good will, no integrity and is serially prone to deception and cheating are bound to produce more and not less litigation. Actions for breaches of legally binding contracts make up a substantial portion of legal proceedings in this country.
 
Last edited:
This is nothing to argue against. It is a fact that Petar has done much to cripple the Macedonian Orthodox Christian community in Australia, he is the cause of this mess, and until he is ejected from the equation, it will remain a mess.

Some of you closet Petar supporters need to come to terms with the truth. The man is a thief who poisons the minds of Macedonian Christians so they can turn on each other. Even his henchmen and lackeys do his work for him. There are two churches in Melbourne which I would frequent when required, one is in Petar's control, the other isn't. It has been a while since I engaged in discussions pertaining to this issue with the local priests and parishioners, I will be much more vocal with my thoughts going forward.

SOM, To me there is alot more to it then simply replacing Bishop Petar what happens after that? The Sveta Petka Church in Mill Park was built to rival the Sveti Gjorgjija Church in Epping, The Soborna Crkva in Sydenham is only a 100 meters away from the Jane Sandanski Church, so basically every church that is not under his control there is one built close by.

Even the Manastir in DonnyBrook was made to rival the one in King Lake which tragically burned down in the black Saturday bush fires 2 years ago.

Aleksandrov, The latest news is that the church in Gold Coast Sveta Nedela is in a legal dispute (The Legal Costs have topped $70,000) and just before new years there was a break in their office and documents were stolen and police was called in. There were two doors, one was destroyed the other was not which means somebody had a key to get in.
 
Bill,

Please re-read through this thread to identify past efforts that at resolution by dialogue with the Synod. Ever since Stefan became Archbishop, all of our efforts have been completely ignored by him and the Synod, with the pathetic excuse that this is an internal matter for Petar's Diocese.
I am aware there has been past efforts made. I am not sure of the details of these efforts, what was said, what was offered as an olive branch thats if anything was offered. Its a good sign non the less that you previously showed the will to communicate. I just don't think you should give up regardless how hopeless you may think it is.

Do you get any response at all? or are you completely ignored. If you received a written response, could you post it. I apologise if you have already done so and making you repeat it.

Its a shame we can't get anyone normal from the opposite side where they can voice their concerns on behalf of the MOC, where we can get a fair and balanced argument instead of hearing one side of the story. Instead, we get rabble that curse and threaten you which does not do justice to the MOC.

Bill77,
Who would you suggest talking to? Aleksandrov has made it quite clear that neither the MOC or the Macedonian Government are interested. So who does that leave?
I don't think the government have any say in church politics. Well they shouldn't anyway.

But if they have responded, i would love to see their response aswell thats if its in writing. At the moment i can only treat any information as hearsay.

Edit: Not all information is taken as hearsay, there is clear indisputable evidence that Petar is what people make him out to be. I just don't know the situation regarding communication amongst the two sides.
 
Last edited:
There has not been a single written response by the Synod to any of our written and elaborated proposals for resolution by dialogue and compromise.
 
SOM, To me there is alot more to it then simply replacing Bishop Petar what happens after that? The Sveta Petka Church in Mill Park was built to rival the Sveti Gjorgjija Church in Epping, The Soborna Crkva in Sydenham is only a 100 meters away from the Jane Sandanski Church, so basically every church that is not under his control there is one built close by.

Even the Manastir in DonnyBrook was made to rival the one in King Lake which tragically burned down in the black Saturday bush fires 2 years ago.

Aleksandrov, The latest news is that the church in Gold Coast Sveta Nedela is in a legal dispute (The Legal Costs have topped $70,000) and just before new years there was a break in their office and documents were stolen and police was called in. There were two doors, one was destroyed the other was not which means somebody had a key to get in.

Where the hell do you get your information? Who the hell are you?

Time you start answering some serious questions pal!
 
Mikail, This is old news a few months old. Stefan Georgievski from AMW mentioned the legal costs about Sveta Nedela, while i saw the damage first hand while i was at the church. I've been going to that church since they started building it and its still not fully built.

Mikail, Im actually surprised by your comments, you make it sound like im giving out top secret information here when infact its old news and pretty much everybody knows about it.
 
Petar's anti-Macedonian agenda, influenced by the Serbian Orthodox Church (which in turn is influenced by the Greek Church), is gaining ground in the Synod of the Macedonian Orthodox Church (which, as part of that agenda, recently changed its name to "Macedonian Orthodox Church - Ohrid Archdiocese", without much public scrutiny):

http://www.dnevnik.com.mk/default.asp?ItemID=E12B60567020A04F95E235D315838396

Синодот на Македонската православна црква донел скандалозна одлука за враќање на српското ‘мокрањчево’ народно пеење и за негово повторно изучување во средната Богословија и на Богословскиот факултет, а најверојатно и во православните храмови, за сметка на источното православно византиско пеење, дознава ‘Публика’.

На својата последна седница на 17-ти овој месец, македонските владици се согласиле тие и сиот клир на МПЦ да им се вратат на ‘српските корени’, бидејќи, според нашите сознанија, на дел од црковните великодостојници, посебно на поранешните белградски студенти, им било тешко да го научат византиското пеење.

Целиот парадокс на македонските православни христијани е тоа што е повторно наметнато прашањето на една туѓа, во минатото окупаторска црковна традиција во Македонија. Станува збор за црковното пеење во нашите цркви и една насилно наметната традиција против православниот македонски народ.

Со развојот на историските настани и придобивките за некои земји по Првата светска војна, во 1918 година, Македонија потпаѓа под српска окупација, односно влегува во рамките на Кралството Југославија како Јужна бановина на Србите. Во исто време, на македонската црква ~ е наметната и српска црковно-окупаторска власт. Во тоа време, тогашниот државно-политички режим на Кралството, територијално и духовно е поробен и наметнати му се црковно-национални интереси и традиции од Србите. Во минатото сме виделе голем број сведоштва за србизација на македонскиот народ и култура, но, во исто време, тогаш е извршена и интервенција над вековната црковна традиција во земјава, па црковното пеење во Македонија од источна традиција било принудно заменето со т.н. ‘мокрањчево’, т.е. црковно народно пеење кое за промоција на новосрпството, пред крајот на 19. век го основал српскиот композитор Стеван Стевановиќ - Мокрањац.

Токму поради тоа, дел од клириците, што по потекло биле Македонци, долги години биле жртви на црковен терор, со оглед на тоа што во сопствената земја биле принудени да се откажат од својата традиција и да станат робови на туѓа.



И Србите го исфрлаат Мокрањац!



Поради таа репресија, осоколено од прогласувањето на независната република Македонија во рамките на СФРЈ во 1945 година, три години подоцна, дел од македонското свештенство, неможејќи да ја поднесе неправдата, свикува црковно-народен собор на кој одлучува да ги започне првите чекори за обнова на македонската традиција и да се избори за своите права. Малку подоцна, во 1956/57 година, Македонската православна црква добива некакви условни права од Српската црква, но и тогаш продолжува лицемерната политика на црковно-државните власти во Србија, поради што МПЦ во 1967 година, самостојно прогласува автокефалност и се издвојува од СПЦ. И покрај ваквиот потег во тоа време, српското влијание во македонските цркви продолжило уште долго и ја наметнувало својата црковно-политичка пропаганда. Влијанието било посебно забележано во црковните училишта, со оглед на тоа што во нив одамна бил заменет стариот црковен кадар со нов - српски! Стравот кај локалното население и огромниот притисок и тортура од страна на државните комунистички власти над неистомислениците, го принудил народот да ја прифати наметнатата српска традиција која станала дел од македонскиот народ и пред с` на нашата православна црква.

Периодот на едноумието и атеизмот за време на комунистичкиот режим, исто така на одреден начин ‘помогнал’ тој процес да продолжи и МПЦ долго време била жртва на овие наметнати услови.

Но, и покрај ваквите услови, византиското пеење живеело со векови во нашата култура и во народните песни, кои биле нотирани токму со источно-православната нотација. Во 19. век, македонските црковни дејци како Калистрат Зографски, Хармосин Охридски, Манасиј Поп Тодоров и други, направиле реформа на византиските црковни ноти и преведувајќи ги мелодиите од грчки на словенски јазик, ги создале првите книги со нотно пеење уште за време на Отоманската империја.

Со обнова на монаштвото во независна Македонија во последната деценија на минатиот век, започна и обновата на старата црковна традиција и борбата против туѓото влијание и туѓите црковни традиции во МПЦ. Сите млади личности, монаси и верници, кои својата младост ја жртвувале за доброто на својот народ, неуморно го започнаа процесот на духовна преродба на македонскиот народ. Во манастирите и дел од храмовите во Македонија повторно се врати старото, изворното, источно (византиско) црковно пеење, кое насилно било искоренувано од нашата православна традиција претходните години.

Токму благодарение на пожртвуваноста и макотрпната работа на новоформираниот црковен клир на МПЦ, во 2004/2005 година, во Македонија се создадоа услови источно-православното црковно пеење и официјално да се врати во духовните училишта и да се обнови нашата вековна традиција. Светиот архиерејски синод на МПЦ тогаш составил комисија во состав: митрополит струмички Наум, архимандрит Партениј и д-р Јане Коџабашија (екперт за византиско црковно пеење), по што подоцна и официјално било одлучено во Православната Богословија (средното училиште) и на Богословскиот факултет да започне изучување на источното црковно пеење, за што бил вработен и стручен кадар. На тој начин, по многугодишно духовно ропство, во македонското православие конечно е исправена една голема историска неправда. Во моментов, ширум државава речиси и да не постои храм каде што на богослужбите се слуша српското народно пеење. Сепак, југоносталгијата кај поединци во МПЦ очигледно с` уште живее.

Оттаму и одлуката на Синодот на македонската црква, донесена на последното заседание на 17-ти овој месец, според која во македонската богословија повторно е вратено изучувањето на мокрањчевото српско народно пеење!

А за апсурдот да биде поголем, ова црковно пеење дури и во Србија полека се исфрла од употреба, па во угледниот Ковиљски манастир, во Хиландар на Света Гора и во сите свети српски храмови на Косово - веќе ечи византиското, односно источно-православното пеење кое и се изучува на Богословскиот факултет во Белград! Во Романија и Бугарија и во другите православни земји, пак, одамна единствено функционира само источното пеење, додека во Русија допрва почнува да се изучува. Значи, иако и самите Срби и останатите правлославци ширум светот ја разбраа пораката дека византиското е единствено светоотечко пеење, само македонските архиереи го мислат спротивното!



Удар врз борбата за македонската култура



Според нашите информации, на седницата на Синодот на МПЦ на која е донесена оваа себепотценувачка одлука, единствено биле против владиците Климент, Наум и Методиј, односно она ‘младо крило’ во нашата највисока црковна власт, наспроти старите владици, од кои поголемиот дел имаат дипломи од Богословскиот факултет во Белград и на кои очигледно дека им е поблиско српското народно пеење. ‘Старите српски кадри’ во свештено-монашкиот клир на МПЦ изминативе шест-седум години не можеле да се навикнат на единственото вистинско православно пеење, па си се вратиле на ‘корените’!

Во борбата да бидеме признаени од Српската црква, сега голем дел од негативно настроените владици во Синодот на СПЦ ќе ни се смеат, а расколникот Јован Вранишковски ќе ликува што нашите владици одлучиле да му се вратат на српството. Сега останува само да ја прифатиме понудената автономија од Србите и да станеме дел од Пеќската патријаршија, велат нашите извори.

Портпаролот на Светиот архиерејски синод на МПЦ, дебарско-кичевскиот митрополит Тимотеј, ни посочи дека оваа одлука на САС е само времена, а не трајна.

- Додека се создадат посоодветни кадри што ќе бидат способни да предаваат старомакедонско пеење, предавањата на Богословијата се пренасочуваат на т.н. ‘мокрањчево пеење’. Онаму каде што знаат да пејат славомакедонско црковно пеење, ние апсолутно нема да го исфрламе. Само треба да се создадат услови и потоа с` ќе биде вратено на старо. Сега-засега, паралелно ќе се изучуваат ‘мокрањчевото’ и византиското црковно пеење - напоменува владиката Тимотеј.

Но, работата е далеку посериозна и според високи црковни лица од МПЦ кои не се согласуваат со Синодот на нашата црква, ваквата одлука е удар врз борбата за македонизмот и македонската култура. Во одбрана на источното-православно црковно пеење треба да застанат сите интелектуалци во државава, велат тие.



Идните богослови ќе учат од осмогласникот на СПЦ!



Иако образложението на предлагачите од САС на МПЦ за враќање на мокрањчевото пеење во македонската црква било дека во иднина ќе бидат применувани и двете пеења, според нашите информации, Синодот веќе подготвува да го исфрли псалтивниот воскресеник - осмогласникот (тоа се осумте мелодии што се образец на едно црковно пеење) за источно пеење, што пред две години беше издаден како синодско издание и чиј автор е Манасиј Поп Тодоров. А, на негово место да биде вратен осмогласникот на Српската православна црква на Мокрањац. Со оглед на тоа што на МПЦ ќе ~ треба долго време да добие авторски права за издавање во Македонија на тој осмогласник, можеме само да замислиме како идните студенти, псалти (црковни пејачи) и хорови, за да ја добијат оваа црковна книга со ноти, ќе мора во иднина да ја порачуваат од Белград, а на неа како издавач е потпишана нам непријателската Српска православна црква!

Потрагична е и информацијата дека во иднина уште студентите од 4-та и 5-та година на Богословијата ќе го изучуваат византиското учење, а оние од 1-ва, 2-ра и 3-та година, како и идните студенти - ќе мораат да му се вратат на српското пеење. Без работа ќе останат и двајцата професори по источно-православно пеење, од кои еден е и д-р Јане Коџабашија, експерт по источна музика, кој докторирал на оваа тема во Букурешт.

- Не се работи за одлука за менување на источното со српско црковно пеење, туку во недостиг на стручен кадар, само за идните две-три години правиме замена во првите генерации на Богословијата - ни изјави митрополитот европски Пимен. ‘Апсолутно не се работи за исфрлање од употреба на византиското пеење, напротив, ние имаме наши кадри пратени на дошколување во Солун, Грција, токму на источно православно црковно пеење, кои откако ќе го завршат школувањето, ќе дојдат да предаваат на Богословија. Значи, сега само ќе се ангажираат двајца професори во 1-ва, 2-ра и 3-та година на Богословија од наредната година, кои ќе предаваат ‘мокрањчево’ црковно пеење, додека не се врати нашиот кадар од Грција. Тоа стои и во Синодската одлука’, додава младиот владика Пимен.

Но, дали ќе биде така и дали оваа одлука, како многу други одлуки на Синодот на МПЦ ќе биде само ‘екскурзија со умот’ на нашите владици без компас или навистина ќе опстои и сите во иднина ќе пееме по српски ноти во нашите православни храмови - останува да видиме.

Бобан Нонковсиќ



Што значи источното византиско пеење?

Осмогласникот на Манасија Поп Тодоров дава детално објаснување за тоа што значи источното (византиско) пеење во православието. Според Поп Тодоров, на територијата на Византија, но и во другите православни кралства и царства што повремено или трајно се издигнувале во текот на историјата, се негувал специфичен вид пеење, кое денес е познато под две имиња: источно црковно пеење и византиско пеење. Според некои музиколози, ова црковно пеење ја апсорбира во себе сета музичка уметност што е создавана во Византиската империја. А, според други, терминот византиско пеење ја опфаќа целата христијанска музичка традиција, од првите моменти па до денес, музиката пред основањето на Константинопол, но и таа по пропаста на Византија во 1453 година. Тоа значи дека тука не спаѓа само пеењето изведувано на грчки јазик, туку и на јазиците на сите православни народи.

Источното црковно пеење во своето музичко искуство и сознание ја содржи мелодиската инспирација од старозаветното пеење, но и мелодиските елементи што ги добило од допирот со музиката на нехристијанските народи. Под поимот на ова пеење се подразбира една фаза од христијанската богослужбена музика што го довела до совршенство изразувањето на верата преку пеење и кое во својата многувековна историја како стожерни ги задржало следните вредности: Дамаскиновиот осмогласник (систем од четири автентични и четири плагални гласови); Трите основни скали (дијатонската, хроматската и енхармонската; Невматското музичко пеење; Вокалниот карактер на пеењето.

Најстариот систем на знаци за нотирање во источното црковно пеење што се развил уште во 6. век, а се употребувал до 14. век е познат како екфонетска нотација (читање со висок глас). На почетокот се користеле нотните знаци на античките Грци, но поради нивната комплексност тие биле исфрлени од употреба и се вовеле нови знаци т.н. невми. Бидејќи византиското пеење со текот на времето растело квантитативно и излегле на површина нови напеви, се јавила потреба за проширување на постоечкиот нотен систем и почнал процес на екфонетскиот систем во четири фази: Палеовизантиска нотација (се користела од 9. до 12. век); Медиовизантиска нотација (од 12. до 15. век); Неовизантиска нотација (позната и како Кукузелова нотација, бидејќи Св. Јован Кукузел е нејзин автор, а се користела од 14. до 19. век); Хрисантова нотација (од 19. век па до сега, кога е само упростено кукузеловото писмо).

Постојат четири стилови кои се употребуваат при источното црковно пеење: Рецитивен (припевен) стил, кој се изведува слободно, без ограничување во однос на интензитетот на ритамот; Ирмолошки стил (се одликува со забрзано темпо на пеење и е едноставен и концизен); Стихирарски стил (се употребува при изведба на посвечени песни и сите оние што се самогласни); Пападикиски стил (се пее во бавно темпо, при што на еден слог од текстот се пеат голем број тонови).

Какво е српското мокрањчево народно пеење?

За да се шири српскиот национал-романтизам, во 1908 година, композиторот Стеван Стевановиќ - Мокрањац создава осмогласник за т.н. српско црквено пеење во кое, наводно, ги става нотите според пеењето на старите пејачи и познавачи на српското црковно пеење, како Јован Костиќ, архимандритите Арсениј Бранковиќ, Кирил Јовичиќ и други црковни лица од Српската православна црква. Според објаснувањето што Мокрањац го дава во предговорот на својот осмогласник, кој со благослов на Синодот на СПЦ и тогашниот патријарх Герман е отпечатен во Белград во 1964 година, кога тој започнал да го пишува црковното пеење во ноти, мелодиите и нотите ги пишувал со брзината со која му пееле неговите советодавци.

- Токму затоа, овие песни ги создадаов во силни бои, мелизми и т.н. трили, а во овој осмогласник ги вметнав старинските мелодиски фигури, кои можеби би можел и да ги упростам, но така би ја загубиле својата вистинска мелодиска карактеристика. Сепак, во ова издание ги избегнав сите китења и претераните игри со грлото на одделните тонови што нашите стари пејачи ги употребувале - појаснува Мокрањац во предговорот на својот осмогласник.

Под редните броеви 1, 2 и 3 во оваа книга се наоѓаат одделни мелодиски отстапки (варијанти), но не е поделен ритамот на мелодиите во тактови, бидејќи авторот објаснува дека во српските народни песни и нема онаков такт, каков што се подразбира во музиката. Тој посочува дека српските црковни мелодии се смислени да бидат најпрости и во дводелен такт.

Целиот осмогласник е напишан во тонот Еф, што, според Мокрањац, е направено за учениците да немаат многу работа и мака околу читањето на разните тонски родови, туку сите гласови да ги читаат во едноимен дур и мол. Нотацијата на песните е во осум гласа (баритон и тенор), за пејачите полесно да можат да ја најдат висината со која ќе ги започнат мелодиите.
 
Below is the English translation of the above article. I never got past the first two paragraphs myself. Utterly disgraceful.

This is what all you Petar faithful are supporting.
-------------
Synod of the Macedonian Orthodox Church made the scandalous decision to return Serbian 'mokranjchevo' folk singing and for his re-learning in middle and Theological Seminary faculty, and possibly in the orthodox churches, on account of the eastern Orthodox Byzantine singing, teach 'Attendance'.

At its last meeting on 17 March, the Macedonian bishops had agreed they and all the clergy of the Orthodox Church to return to 'Serbian roots', because, according to our knowledge on the part of church dignitaries, especially the former Belgrade students, their was difficult to learn the Byzantine singing.

The whole paradox of the Macedonian Orthodox Christians is being re-imposed the issue of a foreign, occupying in the past, church tradition in Macedonia. It is a church singing in our church and forcibly imposed Orthodox tradition against Macedonian people.

With the development of historical events and benefits for some countries after World War II, in 1918, Macedonia falls under Serbian occupation, that comes within the Kingdom of Yugoslavia as the Serbs South Banovina. At the same time, the Macedonian church ~ is imposed and Serbian church occupying power. At that time, then-state political regime of the Kingdom, territorial and spiritual is enslaved and imposed his religious-national interests and traditions of the Serbs. In the past we have seen many testimonies of srbizacija the Macedonian people and culture, but at the same time, then it is executed and intervention over the centuries of church tradition in the country, church and singing in the tradition of eastern Macedonia was forcefully replaced by so-called 'Mokranjchevo', ie church folk singing that to promote novosrpstvoto before the end of the 19th century founded the Serbian composer Stevan Stevanovic - Mokranjac.

That is why part of the clergy, which originally were Macedonians, many years were victims of ecclesiastical terror, given that in his country were forced to give up its tradition and become slaves to the alien.



And Serbs expelled Mokranjac!



Because of this repression, osokoleno by proclamation of the independent republic of Macedonia within the SFRY in 1945, three years later, part of the Macedonian clergy, unable to stand the injustice called Clergy and Laity Assembly which decided to begin the first steps to rebuild Macedonian tradition and fight for their rights. A little later, in 1956/57, the Macedonian Orthodox Church receives some conditional rights of the Serbian church, and then continues hypocritical policy of church-state authorities in Serbia, that the MOC in 1967, self-proclaimed autocephaly and stands out from SOC. Despite this move at this time, the Serbian influence in the Macedonian churches continued for long and nametnuvalo his church and political advocates. The impact was particularly noted in church schools, as they have long been replaced old clergyman with a new - Serbian! The fear among the local population and the huge pressure and torture by state authorities over the communist neistomislenicite, forced people to accept the imposition of Serbian tradition that has become part of the Macedonian people and above all 'of our Orthodox Church.

Period ednoumieto and atheism during the communist regime, also in a certain way 'helping' the process to continue MPC has long been a victim of these imposed conditions.

But despite these conditions, Byzantine chanting lived for centuries in our culture and folk songs that were exactly noted Eastern Orthodox notation. In 19th century, the Macedonian church activists as Kalistrat Zografski, Harmosini Ohrid, Manasseh Pop Todorov and others have made reform of the Byzantine church notes and melodies are translating from Greek into Slavonic, they created the first-note singing books still under the Ottoman Empire.

With the renewal of monasticism in independent Macedonia in the last decade of last century, and began rebuilding the old church tradition and the fight against alien influence and alien religious traditions in the MOC. All young people, monks and believers who sacrificed their youth for the sake of his people, tirelessly began the process of spiritual revival of the Macedonian people. In monasteries and churches of Macedonia returned to the old, original, eastern (Byzantine) church singing, which was forcibly eradicate from our Orthodox tradition of previous years.

Thanks to the sacrifice and hard work of the newly established church clergy of the Orthodox Church, in 2004/2005, in Macedonia created conditions Eastern Orthodox church singing and officially returned to the spiritual schools and to renew our centuries-old tradition. Holy Synod of the MOC then compiled a committee consisting of Metropolitan Nahum of Strumica, Archimandrite Parthenius and Dr. Jane Kodzabashija (expert on Byzantine ecclesiastical singing), and later was officially decided in the Orthodox Seminary (high school) and the Faculty of Theology to begin the study of the eastern church singing, which was employed and professional staff. Thus, after many years of spiritual slavery, in the Macedonian Orthodoxy is finally corrected a great historical injustice. Currently, almost all over the country and there is no church where religious services are listening to Serbian folk singing. However, among individuals jugonostalgijata MOC `s obviously still alive.

Hence the decision of the Synod of the Macedonian church, passed the last session of the 17th this month, according to which Macedonia is again returned to seminary study of mokranjchevoto Serbian folk singing!

And be more absurd, this church singing even in Serbia slowly dropped from use, so in Koviljski prestigious monastery in Hilandar of Mount Athos and in all the holy shrines of Kosovo Serb - have echoed the Byzantine, or Eastern Orthodox which singing and studied at the Theological Faculty in Belgrade! In Romania and Bulgaria and other Orthodox countries, however, long single work just east singing, while Russia is just starting to be studied. So, although the Serbs themselves and others around the world pravloslavci understood the message that is the only Byzantine patristic singing, only the Macedonian bishops thought the opposite!



Blow on the struggle for Macedonian Culture



According to our information session of the Synod of the Orthodox Church which has taken this decision sebepotcenuvachka only bishops were against Clement, Naum and Methodius, or what 'young wing' in our highest ecclesiastical authority, as opposed to the old bishops, most of which have degrees Faculty of Theology in Belgrade and that obviously is closer Serbian folk singing. 'The old Serbian cadres' in clerical-monastic clergy of the Orthodox Church the last six-seven years could not get used to the only true Orthodox singing, so I returned to the 'roots'!

In the struggle to be recognized by the Serbian church, now a part of a negative hip bishops in the Synod of the SOC we laugh and schismatic John Vraniskovski will rejoices that our bishops have decided to return to srpstvoto. Now it only remains to accept the autonomy offered by the Serbs to become part of the Pec Patriarchate, say our sources.

A spokesman for the Holy Synod of the MOC, Debar and Kicevo Metropolitan Timothy, we suggested that this decision of the NAC is only temporary, not permanent.

- While the creation of suitable staff will be able to teach ancient Macedonian singing classes of the Seminary are redirected to the so-called 'Mokranjchevo singing'. Where who can sing Slavo-Macedonian church singing, we absolutely will not crawl. Just need to create conditions and then s' will be returned to the old. Now the time being, will be taught alongside 'mokranjchevoto' and Byzantine church singing - Timothy Bishop cautioned.

But work is far more serious and according to senior church people from MPC who disagree with the Synod of our church, this decision is a blow to the struggle for Macedonism and the Macedonian culture. In defense of the Eastern-Orthodox church singing to stand all intellectuals in the country, they say.



The future will learn from theologians osmoglasnikot the SOC!



Although the rationale of the proponents of the SAS of the MOC for the return of Macedonian mokranjchevoto singing in church was that in the future will be applied both singing, according to our information, III already preparing to throw psaltivniot voskresenik - osmoglasnikot (it eight melodies that form a church singing) singing the east, which two years ago was released as synodal issue and whose author is Manasseh Pop Todorov. And in his place to be returned osmoglasnikot of the Serbian Orthodox church Mokranjac. Given that the MPC will need ~ long time to get a copyright issue in Macedonia that osmoglasnik, we can only imagine how future students psalti (religious singers) and choirs, to get this church book with notes, will have in future to order the Belgrade, and it was signed as a publisher we hostile Serbian Orthodox Church!

Tragic is that information for future students of 4th and 5th year of the Seminary to study the Byzantine learning, and those from the 1st, 2nd and 3rd year, and prospective students - will have to be returned to the Serb singing. No work would remain both professors of Eastern Orthodox singing, one of whom is Dr. Jane Kodzabashija, an expert in Eastern music, which his PhD on this subject in Bucharest.

- There is a decision to amend the eastern Serb church singing, but the lack of professional staff, only for the next two or three years we replaced the first generation of the Seminary - told us European Metropolitan Pimen. 'Absolutely not about phasing out of Byzantine singing, on the contrary, we have sent our staff to further education in Thessaloniki, Greece, just east of the Orthodox Church singing that once you finish school, will come to teach at seminary. So, now will only engage two professors in the 1st, 2nd and 3rd year of seminary next year that will teach 'mokranjchevo' church singing, until our staff come back from Greece. It stands in Sinodskata decision, 'added the young bishop Pimen.

But will it be and whether this decision, like many other decisions of the Synod of the MOC will be the only 'trip with the mind' of our bishops without compass or indeed will survive in the future and all will sing notes Mon Serbian Orthodox churches in our - remains to be seen.

Boban Nonkovsikj



What does the eastern Byzantine singing?

Osmoglasnikot of Manasseh Pop Todorov gives a detailed explanation of what it means eastern (Byzantine) singing in Orthodoxy. According to Pop Todorov, in the territory of Byzantium, and in other Orthodox kingdoms and empires that temporarily or permanently izdignuvale throughout history, it nurtured a specific kind of singing, which today is known under two names: Eastern Byzantine church singing and chanting. According to some musicologists, this church singing absorb within himself all the music that is created in the Byzantine Empire. And, according to others, the term Byzantine singing covers the entire Christian music tradition, from the first moment until today, the music before the founding of Constantinople, but it after the collapse of the Byzantine Empire in 1453. This means that there is one just singing performed in Greek, but also the languages of all the Orthodox peoples.

Eastern church singing in his musical experience and knowledge has inspired the Old Testament melodic singing, and melodic elements that got out of touch with the music of non-Christian peoples. The notion of singing this means a phase of bogosluzhbena Christian music led him to perfection expression of faith through singing and which in its centuries-long history as a pivotal had kept the following values: Damaskinoviot osmoglasnik (system of four authentic plagalni four votes), three basic steps (dijatonskata, chromatic and enharmonskata; Nevmatskoto Music Singing Vocal character singing.

The oldest system of signs notiranje in the eastern church singing that has developed since the sixth century and was used until the 14th century is known as ekfonetska notation (reading aloud). Initially used musical signs of the ancient Greeks, but because of their complexity they were ejected from the use and introducing new characters called nevmi. Since Byzantine singing with time growing quantitatively and got new tunes to the surface, appeared a need to expand the existing system noten and began the process of ekfonetskiot system in four phases: Paleovizantiska notation (used from the 9th to the 12th century); Mediovizantiska notation (from 12th to 15th century); Neovizantiska notation (also known as Kukuzelova notation because St. Kukuzel John is the author, and are used by the 14th to 19th century); Hrisantova notation (from 19th century till now that is only gradually kukuzelovoto letter).

There are four styles used in the eastern church singing: Recitiven (pripeven) style, which is performed freely, without constraints on the intensity of the rhythm; Irmoloshki style (characterized by the rapid pace of singing is simple and concise); Stihirarski style (used in the performance of posvecheni songs and all those vowel); Papadikiski style (sing in a slow pace, at one syllable of text is sung by a number of tones).

What is mokranjchevo Serbian folk singing?

To spread the Serbian national romanticism, in 1908, the composer Stevan Stevanovic - Mokranjac osmoglasnik creates so-called Serbian church singing, which reportedly put the notes by singing the old singers and fans of the Serbian church singing as John Kostic, arhimandritite Arsenius Brankovic, Cyril Jovicic and other church people from the Serbian Orthodox Church. According to the explanation that Mokranjac gives in the preface to his osmoglasnik, who with the blessing of the Synod of the Serbian Patriarch German and then is printed in Belgrade in 1964, when he began to write notes in church singing, melodies and the notes are written with speed which he sang his advisors.

- Therefore, these songs create the strong colors, etc. melizmi trills, and in this osmoglasnik to insert starinskite melodic figures that maybe I could and uprostam, but also would have lost its true melodic feature. However, in this volume avoid being decorated and all games with exaggerated cervical individual tones that our old singer used - Mokranjac explains in the preface to his osmoglasnik.

Under the ordinal numbers 1, 2 and 3 in this book are certain melodic concessions (variants), but it is divided into the rhythm of the melodies in tact, because the author explains that in Serbian folk songs and will habitually written savvy, as implied in the music. He pointed out that Serbian church melodies are meant to be the sorriest in the two-part time.

All osmoglasnik is written in Eph tone, which, Mokranjac is made for students to have a lot of work and worry about reading the various tone genera, but all voices to read in ednoimen major and minor. Annotation of the songs in eight voices (tenor and baritone), the singers can easily find the amount that would take up melodies.
 
In the state election of rockdale,they had some Phd woman macedonian called strezevova running under the christian banner with the votes going to fred nile.Did she have Petars backing & blessing?What is petar upto with fred nile is he hoping to get the church bill on track???She didn't get many votes.
 
George,

Fred Nile is the guru of extinction. He is the proudest terminator of religious denomination. The Presbyterian church does not exist , he proudly shoved them under the "uniting church" , my mother-in-law, was Presbyterian. He is the anti=christ of subordination .

What astounds me, its so blatantly obvious the divisiveness Petar has caused amongst the Macedonians, and to be placed under the banner of SOC, Petar can screw himself, including all of his pathetic followers.

Mindless numb nuts
 
Back
Top