makedonche
New member
Not to expand this discussion to far off topic, but I'd say that Macedonians in various countries around world are members of UMD. Granted that not every member may like every decision, stipulation UMD has made, but their membership is reaching beyond the borders of "American Diaspora".
CT
This does not qualify UMD to claim they are either "the" voice/representation of "the" Diaspora or authorised by the Diaspora. This is where the misleading occurs and the misrepresentation comes from. Trying to attain credibility by nominating as a party to the survey without discussion or collaboration with the actual Diaspora.
I think they want to represent every possible Macedonian everywhere.
But why blame them for being on the survey? They are pro-active and I don't see any fault with that. In fact, there is actually an option to voice dissatisfaction: check the box "No extent".
CT
They may want to represent every possible Macedonian - but do the diaspora Macedonians want UMD reresenting them?
I like the fact they are pro-active, I don't like the methods used!
I blame them for being on the survey without dialogue from the diaspora. As for the checkbox, it wouldn't be needed if it was done with the diaspora's input.
This way, if those who filled it out check "No extent", then the survey (Australian Macedonians) will reflect no confidence in UMD.
CT
If that is the case it then becomes an embaressment and that information could be used by other parties to do more harm to the Macedonian Cause!
I'm asking because you said or implied that the survey is mis representing Australian Macedonians.
UMD is misrepresenting itself in puporting to act on behalf of the diaspora, the actual name "UMD" is a misrepresentation!
Keep bothering them.
CT
I am, all I got was another copy of the survey!
In your first post that I responded to, I didn't see any open questions, only a one-line statement of "mis-representation". So it would be impossible for me to claim that you are being unreasonable with your questions - Questions are always good, I encourage them.
CT
OK - am I being unreasonable with any of my remarks/questions?
The option of voicing concern before a survey is distributed can often be limited to outsiders, regardless of topic and who is doing it.
CT
Correct, but depending on the purpose and use of the survey, it would be more relevant if the appropriate parties were consulted, in order to have an input into it's substance and intent, otherwise it gives the appearance of a one sided survey designed by the party who has the most to gain from it.
-
CT
I know you are keen to end this discussion, but would appreciate a reply.