aleksandrov
New member
The general concept looks pretty good, but I see a few problems:
1. I would hope that by 2014, the Macedonian people will finally do away with a flag that is a symbol of subservience to our oppressors and denial of the indigenous Macedonian identity. I know the Greek Gligorov/Crvenkovski ventilator is not part of the architecture, but it's got a central place in the visualization, so I had to comment.
2. Where are the monuments to Philip and Alexander of Macedon? Did I miss them? Is the monument on the fountain that of Alexander? It hasn't been named in the video. Even if that's Alexander, I think that Philip's role in the establishment of the ancient Macedonian kingdom as a superpower, including Alexander's accomplishments, was more fundamental.
3. If we are going to have a church at the Square, it should reflect traditional Macedonian church aesthetics. The one in the visualizations looks too much like a Russian Orthodox church.
4. I am not convinced that Car Samuil deserves such a central monument. Historical records about him are more susceptible to exploitation by Bulgarian theories about Macedonia than they are significant to the existence and development of the Macedonian identity. I would rather have a monument to Basil II.
5. As Bill has remarked, Porta Makedonija is too much of a copy of Paris' Arc De Triomphe. It's too reflective of the national inferiority complex that infects and impedes the dignity and progress of the Macedonian people. Surely our architects and artists can come up with something more authentic?
6. The Macedonian Philharmonic building looks too trendy to have lasting aesthetic value. In that sense, it reminds me a bit of the disposable aesthetic of the now embarrassing Macedonian People's Theater building. I would like to see a more classic, everlasting, yet still modern aesthetic, especially since it's going to be a centre of Classical (including modern Classical) music.
7. The 'kupoli' of the new Parliament make it look almost like a mosque.
I am particularly glad to see the monument to the "Defenders of Macedonia", which I presume is a reference to those who defended the Macedonian people against terrorist attacks in 2001. I am also very glad to see that the ASNOM participants and VMRO founders get equal prominence. The monuments to Justinian and Karpos are also well overdue, especially for the centre of Skopje. I like the monuments to Nikola Karev, the "Gemidzii" and Sv. Kliment and Naum, but I think they should be constructed and placed in such a way as to recongize the fact that their impact on the general Macedonian struggle or global influence was not as central or widespread as that of figures like Philip and Alexander of Macedon, Sv. Kiril & Metodi, Karposh, Goce Delchev, Dame Gruev, Cento, and, dare I say it, Boris Sarafov and Todor Aleksandrov.
I applaud those who are behind this for showing some vision, national pride and respect for leaders who have sacrificed their lives for freedom and justice of the Macedonian people. However, I think the details in the concept require more critical thought and courage, given that it's not something that can't be changed as quickly and easily as fashionable Government policies.
1. I would hope that by 2014, the Macedonian people will finally do away with a flag that is a symbol of subservience to our oppressors and denial of the indigenous Macedonian identity. I know the Greek Gligorov/Crvenkovski ventilator is not part of the architecture, but it's got a central place in the visualization, so I had to comment.
2. Where are the monuments to Philip and Alexander of Macedon? Did I miss them? Is the monument on the fountain that of Alexander? It hasn't been named in the video. Even if that's Alexander, I think that Philip's role in the establishment of the ancient Macedonian kingdom as a superpower, including Alexander's accomplishments, was more fundamental.
3. If we are going to have a church at the Square, it should reflect traditional Macedonian church aesthetics. The one in the visualizations looks too much like a Russian Orthodox church.
4. I am not convinced that Car Samuil deserves such a central monument. Historical records about him are more susceptible to exploitation by Bulgarian theories about Macedonia than they are significant to the existence and development of the Macedonian identity. I would rather have a monument to Basil II.
5. As Bill has remarked, Porta Makedonija is too much of a copy of Paris' Arc De Triomphe. It's too reflective of the national inferiority complex that infects and impedes the dignity and progress of the Macedonian people. Surely our architects and artists can come up with something more authentic?
6. The Macedonian Philharmonic building looks too trendy to have lasting aesthetic value. In that sense, it reminds me a bit of the disposable aesthetic of the now embarrassing Macedonian People's Theater building. I would like to see a more classic, everlasting, yet still modern aesthetic, especially since it's going to be a centre of Classical (including modern Classical) music.
7. The 'kupoli' of the new Parliament make it look almost like a mosque.
I am particularly glad to see the monument to the "Defenders of Macedonia", which I presume is a reference to those who defended the Macedonian people against terrorist attacks in 2001. I am also very glad to see that the ASNOM participants and VMRO founders get equal prominence. The monuments to Justinian and Karpos are also well overdue, especially for the centre of Skopje. I like the monuments to Nikola Karev, the "Gemidzii" and Sv. Kliment and Naum, but I think they should be constructed and placed in such a way as to recongize the fact that their impact on the general Macedonian struggle or global influence was not as central or widespread as that of figures like Philip and Alexander of Macedon, Sv. Kiril & Metodi, Karposh, Goce Delchev, Dame Gruev, Cento, and, dare I say it, Boris Sarafov and Todor Aleksandrov.
I applaud those who are behind this for showing some vision, national pride and respect for leaders who have sacrificed their lives for freedom and justice of the Macedonian people. However, I think the details in the concept require more critical thought and courage, given that it's not something that can't be changed as quickly and easily as fashionable Government policies.
Last edited: