• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

Macedonians and their 'slave' names, time to change?

Ancient Greeks didn't enslave Macedonia and force the people to adopt slave names. Modern Greeks did. As for the language of the invaders from the 6th century, it was related to the Paleo-Balkan langauges, the linguistic shift resulted in the loss of the Indo-European suffixes -is and -os among other changes. Afterwards, the native language of the Macedonians no longer had a requirement for those suffixes. You can't justify the current slave names by using a silly and anachronistic argument like ancient Macedonians used to have names with such suffixes.

Fair enough response.
 
EM, I don't think its misguided at all.
A name means everything to a persons identity. Just like the Name Macedonia and what it means to our identity as our ethnicity.
Or the "symbolism" of having a Greek sounding surname imposed is no different "symbolically" to having the ventilator imposed.

If we are to be true to our selves and our cause, it is a no brainer, to show acts of defiance and show self respect even at a measly cost of having complications acquiring land that many of todays generation would probably never see anyway. Regarding visiting rights......no nation (even Greece) as bad as they are, have power if you carry a Australian or American passport and citizenship.

EM with all due respect, these are irrelevant issues and i see them nothing but excuses. My family is split 50/50 with keeping the village "prekar" surname on arrival to Australia, and those changing it to something else for whatever reason. Their is no complication, division or any difficulty between us what so ever.

My point is this. We keep preaching "act of defiance" "self respect" (which i am not against that idea). But some "barat rachki" for Egejci but its not good enough for Vardarci. Making one victims, and the others as weak and traitorous. This is really what causes divisions.
To be honest, Egejci and Pirinci have more of a reason to rebel, show defiance. Yet for decades, all i hear from Egejci is, (what some call reasons) i call excuses. A slave mentality if you ask me, the same mentality accusations thrown at Vardarci. And.....i have heard that Egejci are perceived to be the torch bearers. Well mabe they are to blame for the Vardarci's slave mentality if they are the shining example and lead the way.

I will finish by saying, all sides of the borders have ideological issues. And its about time the finger gets pointed to one self.


PS: i am mixed Vardarec/Egejec more towards Egejec. its important to let you know this so you don't think i favour one side, and that i am just being real.

Bill, I'm not advocating that Egejci should keep their altered names, however it irritates me that some people here would belittle others based on their surname. It also annoys me how people say that the decision is a no-brainer and able to be made in a 'heart-beat.' Such a one-dimensional perspective fails to realise that this issue is more complex than altering a few letters in ones' name. The issues prevalent in the Republic are irrelevant, as Macedonians ultimately have the power to govern the future of their nation, whether they know it or not. When you are systematically oppressed by a foreign government, the scenario is entirely different. The ventilator was imposed by the Macedonian government, our altered names were imposed by the Greek government. Despite inviting obvious comparisons emerging from placing these two issues side by side, it is a poor stance to do so. There is a difference between your own people destroying your sovereignty and that of the enemy.

I may change the name once I am legally able to, or even down the road, but here is an interesting thought to think about. The name wasn't imposed on me, I was born in Australia and have carried the altered name all my life, it has become a part of my identity, whether I like it or not. Therefore, the decision in regards to showing self-respect and preserving your identity should rest with those who the name was imposed upon, i.e grandparents, great-grandparents, etc. They are the ones who had their names changed, and I think it is primarily their responsibility to nullify the imposition. As a result, regardless of whether young generation Australian Macedonians have an interest in property in the Aegean region, the complications for the oldies are far more substantial and thus any concerns in relation to this matter are further escalated.

The majority of my relatives still have the imposed name, so perhaps that is adding to my conservative view, however it also places me in a position to prove that not everyone is in the same boat. The transition process may be a cakewalk for some and difficult for others, we cannot assume that all Egejci are prepared or even readily able to change their name back.

The Egejci may be in a position to hold the torch, and the opportunity still awaits them, but let's not forget that this 'rebel' factor has been extinguished from the souls of many Egejci. It's a really sad thing to see, but I cannot entirely blame them. Visiting relatives overseas who have almost been completely 'hellenised' draws more sympathy than anything for me. These people have been brainwashed beyond belief, and are in no state of mind to act as an example to those within the Republic. To refrain from generalising however, there are still many Egejci who are aware and proud of their true identity and culture.

I'm aware of your Egej origins Bill and I respect your views, but I can't help but feel pissed off that people here would label these people as slaves. And for the others here (not you Bill), don't ask me 'Oh when did we call them slaves?' crap. By labeling their names as a slave name, you are implying they are slaves. I'm sorry that all we have accomplished under these names are a result of slaving away for our Greek masters.:glare: That's an outright insult if you ask me.


Let me ask everyone this. If a Macedonian woman, preferably with a surname ending in -ov or -ski, married a Greek man with a 'Greek sounding' surname, are they a 'slave' by identifying themselves by a name that is imposed and of Greek origin? Perhaps they should argue that the Greek name was imposed and opt to change it back? What you say of these people? Are they signing away their name and identity?
I acknowledge that this cannot be used as a direct comparison, however I raise the point in relation to a few of the recent posts I haven't quoted, in regards to married women changing their name.


EM
Very thought provokoing response! i'm not going to argue with you about any of what's been written but I would like to address one paragraph that stuck in my mind and also gave me the inspiration for a proposal that I would like to put to you and all MTO & all Macedonians.



For quite some time now I have advocated for the dismissal of things that divide Macedonians and the embracing of things that unite us.
From the highlighted section above you can see I have chosen this aspect to comment on. As a distinct ethnicity/language/culture/history it is obvious to me that many obstacles have been put before the Macedonians to inflict division/disharmony/disunity(DDD) in the past and even currently so, this DDD comes from without and within Macedonia/Macedonians throughout the world, it's impact and influence is evident in many aspects of daily life and has been for quite some time - a specific example of this is the "Bucharest Treaty", so when you take a closer look at things that cause and sustain DDD, you will notice among these things the forced changing of people's names - why? because it was designed to cause conflict among the victims and is obviously doing it's job - hence this discussion and the differing viewpoints and opinions. What came to my mind, as a subsequence of thinking about your comments, is that we could view this name change for what it really is - an imposition - and we could use this impostion to begin a movement of defiance and intolerance to actions enforced upon us and subsequently stand up for our rights in the process. I would therefore suggest that we get as many people to change their imposed (slave) names back to thier original family names "en mass' through a coordinated effort, perhaps driven by AMHRC and channelled through the individual state Macedonian Communities - it is my firm belief that this process would have a very stong unifying effect by virtue of a common action for a common purpose for common human rights!
If there is one thing in this world we have that nobody can take away from us is our individual "names", that very thing which identifies us and we identify with, must never be allowed to be changed/altered/taken away from us without our consent and most certainly without a fight, using all of our available resources!
I know that talk is easy and what I propose will ruffle many feathers and take great effort,time and money but for me it is worth it, particularly when i think about the big "Fuck You & The Horse You Rode in on" message that it will send to all those who have been terrorizing our individual and collective identities!
:detective:

One could argue that individual name changes will result in further division and confusion, something the Macedonian community does not need. However, as you have highlighted, a uniform approach by all Macedonians with imposed names would show a great sense of empowerment and definitely send a strong message to our oppressors and even to the everyday Australian. A good project to think about and plan for the future, yet the success of such an initiative would be quite low. For the majority of Egejci in Australia, I highly doubt that their imposed surname is ranked high on their priority list. Perhaps raising awareness may conjure some discussion and action, however in this case, patience would ultimately be the key to success. We cannot expect thousands of people to make this decision in 'a heartbeat' as some suggest, for not only is that extremely unrealistic, but also expecting too much. An idea such as this would need to gradually gather support and set a specific future date for all Macedonians to revert to their traditional family name. But wouldn't this also raise the question of prolonging changing the name, thus further contradicting the immediate dismissal of a name that was imposed by a foreign Government? The vibe here suggests that any name change should be done ASAP, yet such a project would rely on effective future planning in order to achieve an 'en mass' turnout.

Good points though Makedonche, something for Macedonian organisations to keep in mind.


Would you change someone's name against their will?
To impose your will on someone else in relation to their identity is nothing short of oppression at the highest level. It is a "slave name" only if we use nice terminology.

They weren't even allowed to use Macedonian names for their livestock.

Disgraceful.

No I wouldn't, but by some of you referring to it as a 'slave name,' aren't you pressuring people to change their names? I'll admit I feel uneasy at the moment carrying an altered name, but I believe that is fueled moreso with disappointment in regards to this name-calling, as opposed to guilt.



Can you show us who has suggested it is a mere "one step process", or is this you being creative again?

I first heard Risto use that term with respect to Aegean Macedonians, and I agree with it. Are you suggesting it isn't a slave name, just because it is "harsh"?

Just because many African-American people kept their slave names doesn't discount the fact that they are still slave names.

You just answered your own question. To people who don't know any better about the situation, which is most people in this world, the automatic assumption is that you're Greek. Future generations who don't know any better will think the same.

Those suffixes form part of the Macedonian langauge, and our language naturally shares affinities with other Slavic languages. In the end, it will still be a Macedonian surname, and at least the assumption won't be that you're a Greek. I understand that it may be a complex process to change the name given that not all of your family members would be willing to do the same, that you have achieved certain things by your slave name, etc, but nobody said it would be easy. I would ask you to look at Risto's example for inspiration.

SoM, I don't need to personally highlight words to raise points people imply.The intention of the words speaks far more than breaking down each individual word into their definitions. By a one-step process, I mean that people imply that changing the name back is a decision that can be made in the 'blink of an eye,' 'in a heartbeat,' 'a no brainer,' 'easy.' Call it what you want, but those who say 'If I had an imposed name...I would immediately change it,' aren't aware or immersed in the complexities that arise. This is one area I feel confident in my opinion, as I can personally relate to it. Risto set an example, and perhaps the decision was easy for him, but this cannot be said for all Egejci or Macedonians alike. There's a difference between making excuses, and asking for a bit of respect and understanding into what is a very complicated and sensitive issue.

"Bitch name" = When someone makes you their bitch.
Is that better?

Yeh well even though your joking, this almost seems like the general consensus around here at the moment...
 
EgejskaMakedonia said:
Let me ask everyone this. If a Macedonian woman, preferably with a surname ending in -ov or -ski, married a Greek man with a 'Greek sounding' surname, are they a 'slave' by identifying themselves by a name that is imposed and of Greek origin? Perhaps they should argue that the Greek name was imposed and opt to change it back? What you say of these people? Are they signing away their name and identity?
I am sorry if you're offended, but your sentiment is misguided. Be upset at the people who imposed slave names on your ancestors. And do something about it. As for your above example, it is irrelevant, because if a Macedonian lady married a Greek she changes her surname by consent, and not through a forceful act with the purpose of eradicating her identity. The circumstances are completely different.
 
I am sorry if you're offended, but your sentiment is misguided. Be upset at the people who imposed slave names on your ancestors. And do something about it. As for your above example, it is irrelevant, because if a Macedonian lady married a Greek she changes her surname by consent, and not through a forceful act with the purpose of eradicating her identity. The circumstances are completely different.

How is my sentiment misguided, when I myself have an altered name? Unless your willing to speak on behalf of me, and thousands of others, please enlighten me into why my opinion and views are misguided?

I am deeply upset at the atrocities the Greeks committed, yet it doesn't help when we are labeled as 'slaves.' The way I see it, any accomplishments I have made under this name are the work of a slave, am I right? I'm disappointed that people here like to rub salt into the wounds inflicted by our oppressors. You lot are meant to be supporting fellow Macedonians, not belittling them and implying they are 'slaves.' Surely there is a better term for these altered names?

SoM, don't try and be sneaky, read what I said under that example and save yourself the trouble of pointing the irrelevancy out for me. I merely said that as a point of discussion, also to incite that the parallels drawn with the Republic hold a similar nature, and are also irrelevant.

I understand that you don't intend to insult anyone, but I can't help but feel both pissed off and inferior with all these words thrown around. People need to remember that we are all Macedonians, there is little points drawing divisions among the people of the differing regions, for we all share the same plight.
Our circumstances may differ, but that does not make any one of us worth more or worthless in comparison to other Macedonians.
 
How is my sentiment misguided, when I myself have an altered name? Unless your willing to speak on behalf of me, and thousands of others, please enlighten me into why my opinion and views are misguided?

I am deeply upset at the atrocities the Greeks committed, yet it doesn't help when we are labeled as 'slaves.' The way I see it, any accomplishments I have made under this name are the work of a slave, am I right? I'm disappointed that people here like to rub salt into the wounds inflicted by our oppressors. You lot are meant to be supporting fellow Macedonians, not belittling them and implying they are 'slaves.' Surely there is a better term for these altered names?

SoM, don't try and be sneaky, read what I said under that example and save yourself the trouble of pointing the irrelevancy out for me. I merely said that as a point of discussion, also to incite that the parallels drawn with the Republic hold a similar nature, and are also irrelevant.

I understand that you don't intend to insult anyone, but I can't help but feel both pissed off and inferior with all these words thrown around. People need to remember that we are all Macedonians, there is little points drawing divisions among the people of the differing regions, for we all share the same plight.
Our circumstances may differ, but that does not make any one of us worth more or worthless in comparison to other Macedonians.

Very well said EM, damn your very eloquent when your in the mood :)


Negatively labelling the victim and their families for generations to come is irresponsible and counter productive

We expect to have positive support from each other not a witch hunt, finger pointing and labelling

It's a time to be more sensitive not less

We are our sensitivities, our emotions, play with that under the guise of logic and your in for a surprise

None of us would be here if it wasn't for our sensitivities, it's what motivates us, and ultimately makes us human
 
How is my sentiment misguided, when I myself have an altered name?
It is misguided because you seem to be more upset at me and the others for highlighting the obvious rather than the maggots who did this to your ancestors.
I am deeply upset at the atrocities the Greeks committed, yet it doesn't help when we are labeled as 'slaves.'
You're not a slave. Your ancestors who this was forced upon were. So were mine during Serbian occupation pre-WWII.
You lot are meant to be supporting fellow Macedonians, not belittling them and implying they are 'slaves.' Surely there is a better term for these altered names?
That "lot" merely speaks the truth. What is a "better" term? How could it possibly be "better" if it essentially means the same thing? I don't understand why you wish to dance around the obvious. If it is that offensive to you, why don't you drop the slave name and revert back to an ancestral Macedonian name? You already said you're thinking about doing it. Do it, and set an example for other Macedonians.
SoM, don't try and be sneaky, read what I said under that example and save yourself the trouble of pointing the irrelevancy out for me. I merely said that as a point of discussion.........
I thought I was rather straight forward by highlight the irrelevance of your example. I have no reason to be "sneaky", there is no hidden agenda here EM.
........also to incite that the parallels drawn with the Republic hold a similar nature, and are also irrelevant.
Which parallels? The flag and name change? They aren't irrelevant, they are just another example of the slave mentality among many Macedonians, it transcends the (artifical) borders.
I understand that you don't intend to insult anyone, but I can't help but feel both pissed off and inferior with all these words thrown around.
I don't consider any Macedonian that still uses a slave name as "inferior" and I never would, but I don't agree with any attempt at justifying the continued use of that slave name.
People need to remember that we are all Macedonians, there is little points drawing divisions among the people of the differing regions, for we all share the same plight.
A superficial division was drawn by the Greeks when they imposed slave names on our people. Nevertheless, you are still as Macedonian to me as Peter Daikos or Darko Pancev. But can't you see how dropping the slave name will break down some of the barriers caused by this superficial division?
 
blackcactus said:
We expect to have positive support from each other not a witch hunt, finger pointing and labelling
There is neither a "witch hunt" or "finger pointing". You're conjuring this in your own mind because you're being too sensitive.
It's a time to be more sensitive not less
No, it's time for the exact opposite. Macedonians need to toughen up and confront reality. The overly sensitive approach has never worked for us when it comes to these situations and has only led to a false sense of security by naive Macedonians. That eventually leads to acceptance, just like with this ventilator disgrace. Not wanting to hurt sensitivities is the reason why it is accepted as commonplace among many Macedonians these days.
 
My reaction will be reflected in others outside this forum

Some others that take on this crusade may not be as "nice" as you, when this occurs expect the normal human reaction of push back and distancing

I must admit I don't see much finesse in how Macedonians treat each other, this sensitive approach your talking about must of happened before my time
 
Yeh well even though your joking, this almost seems like the general consensus around here at the moment...
I'm sorry EM. The Greeks government made your (and my) people their bitches. They changed their names and denied them the most fundamental of human rights. Is there a nice way to put it?

I'm getting so tired of not being allowed to call a spade a spade. If it offends, think about why it offends. Smart people like you will understand. I am sympathetic to some reasons but I oppose the injustice of changing my family name more. If more Macedonians were principled like this, we would have a Macedonia that is the homeland of Macedonians.

I changed my name before anyone else did in my family. Was I the most patriotic, hell no. My father's voice is still remembered by many Macedonians throughout the world and some (less than patriotic) people might nervously play down his ferocious approach to his identity. He changed his name after I did but was fully supportive of my decision. I got mine before I received my degree. If you are reluctant to change yours because you have forged so much of an identity in your 17 years you fear the world might forget you, then you must have little faith in your future. I'm confident the new you with an empowering surname will do even better.
 
I must admit I don't see much finesse in how Macedonians treat each other, this sensitive approach your talking about must of happened before my time
BC, why is it so bad to challenge people thoroughly in regards to their stance. Testing their stance in this manner can reveal a great deal. The simple reality is that people can be nice to each other and get along very well but can be no good for the Macedonian Cause in the process. Do you accept that if I went hugging every Serbian flag waving supporter of SDSM that it will be of no use whatsoever? Some people are simply not worth it, the sooner we find out, the sooner we can move along and focus attention where it counts.

Not all enemies of Macedonia will come around to your way of thinking if you are nice to them.
 
No I wouldn't, but by some of you referring to it as a 'slave name,' aren't you pressuring people to change their names? I'll admit I feel uneasy at the moment carrying an altered name, but I believe that is fueled moreso with disappointment in regards to this name-calling, as opposed to guilt.
No. It isn't the name calling and it isn't guilt. You just don't know it yet. When I changed my name it was positively electrifying for me. It was empowering and made me feel great. You are feeling down about it because it is something worthy of feeling down about.

It is the weak option and you are justifying your position on the back foot. You know why your position stinks but you are trying to build an arsenal to defend it. It is futile mate. I mean it with respect.

Am I pressuring you .... shit yeah ... we need more Macedonians in every sense. You are another Greek statistic in your electorate and you don't even know it. Have you received any letters in Greek from your local politician? I used to ... once upon a slavery. :28:
 
EgejskaMakedonia
It sounds like you are saying a Greek sounding name doesn't matter ('a rose by any other name'), then why are we bitching about not wanting to change RoM's name to Northern/New/Vardarska/Skopje/ect. In fact, while were at it, why don't we just go with Makedonik-os/ous/is/ogoulu/ect. Pathetic.

I'm not trying to justify people who keep these so called 'slave' names, but since many of you are attacking the thousands upon thousands on Egejci who have kept the altered name, something needed to be said.

I have heard so many excuses by Egej Macedonians as to why not to change their names, so the following is not personally directed at you, but the word 'you' is to every Egej Macedonia who has said, "You Macedonians from Yugoslavia don't know what it's like."

Here in lies one of the unfortunate divides between Macedonians. What "needs to be said"? Is there ANY defence? If you think there is, then re-read the first paragraph and tell us why you are against a name change for RoM, or what your preferred new name should be. Seeing we used to be part of the Ottoman Empire, maybe we can go with ogoulu or something. Oh yeah, the Ottomans didn't force us to change our names - dang it, we will have to go with os or is or something. Pathetic.

At the end of the day, legally it isn't my choice.

Are you a minor? Then YES, legally it IS your choice. Pathetic statement.

I wouldn't mind changing it and may do so in the future, but at the same time I've had this surname since I was born and all my achievements have been recognised under this surname.

And this has what to do with anything? Do you think that somehow someone is going to take away your few sporting trophies or your Uni degree hanging on your wall? Or is the loss a mental/emotional one? Pathetic.

What if one person in the family changes their surname, and the rest don't follow suit? As far as I'm concerned we don't need further division than what we currently have. For example, when our family came, the same family name was changed to end in os for some, ou for others, and some entirely different...to go further and put ov, ski or whatever would make it incredibly difficult to keep track of family roots. Unless everybody puts their word in to change it, the process is quite complicated.

If you recognise having a Greek sounding name was wrongfully imposed on your family at a time when they couldn't do anything about it, then talking about it to your wider family and convincing them is exactly what you need to do. If some members don't want to follow your suggestion, and the injustice of an imposed name means anything to you, then you need to have the conviction to follow through and change it, even if you are the only one. We stand as men with dignity when we are true to our own principles and beliefs and have the conviction to stay true to them. Don't get me wrong - it may have been the case, back in the day when the names were imposed on you - "take this name or we will shoot you" - but that is hardly the case today, let alone in the diaspora, and so does not exist as an excuse.

Changing the name back would require a uniform decision from the entire family, some with established businesses and others with a multitude of accomplishments that have been achieved under the title of their altered name. The common rebuttal in regards to people asking 'Are you Greek?' would still likely apply in a different sense. The question would appear time and time again if there is a stimulus to the altered name, such as a degree, previous documents, etc...Is that you? OR why did you change your name?

Seriously??? So as to not be bothered by departments/ect, when filling out forms/applications, with the "why have you changed your name" question you see this a valid reason to stay with your imposed name? Pathetic.

As for people running "established businesses", unless you are passing your self off as 'Grekos' Authentic Greek Tavern', there is NO other business that cannot change it's name with minimal expense of replacing the stationary and government fees for filling a company name change. Is there going to be a cost to do this? - Yes, but it can only be minimal. Does your dignity mean less to you than a few hundred dollars? Pathetic. Or are you trying to flog your self off as authentic 'Greko' in your business? Pathetic. You don't have to have an 'ethnic' name for most businesses. Or are you worried you have a lot of Greek customers/suppliers who would be put-off by discovering your not Greek and how it might affect the business? Pathetic.

Secondly, the argument that down the line, future apathetic generations may look at their ancestry and see an -os, -ou, etc ending surname and assume they had a Greek ancestor is also a load of crap. Although these are essentially 'Greek' sounding, why should they be consider as exclusively Greek?

Because that's what people do when they see a os/ou/is.ect name. Your decedents may be aware that they are not Greek, much like you are aware, but that's beside the point. The real question is, are you, or will they in the future, be happy to be assumed to be Greek by the world? Or does it not bother you one way or the other? Then why does it bother you if the world assumes Macedonia is Greek? Pathetic.

I would like to change the name, and may do so in the future, however calling it a slave name is a bit insulting.

This is the MOST pathetic sentence in your whole post. Firstly, is there any other way to look at it then a 'slave' name? If Greece invaded RoM and forced everyone to call themselves 'New Vardakikos', should we view it anything less then a 'slave' name?

Why is calling it a slave name "a bit insulting."? Because you think people will look down upon the Macedonians from Egej for not fighting to the death to protect their names? Or because 'slave' doesn't sound nice and we should use maybe, 'imposed' name, instead. If that was your point, then it would be the only thing not pathetic so far. We'll try to remember that in future.

Some of you seem to have the misguided impression that changing the name is a one step process and a no-brainer.

No, I think most people would not think it's a one-step process and would be aware that
1. Births/Deaths would have to be contacted
2. Driver's Licence changed (and ID card in countries that have one)
3. Passport changed
4. Property Deeds changed
5. Car registration (deeds) changed
6. House/Car/ect insurance changed
7. Utility bills changed
8. Bank/Investment accounts changed
9. School enrolment records/work records changed
10. Tax file number details/records changed
11. For those that have a business, Directorship/Secretary details changed.
12. Where the business name bears their name, then also the business name and stationary changed.

Maybe I have left something off, but it's still quite a list, and most people would be aware of it and the effort and time it would take. Noone is saying it is an easy "one-step process", but is it an (non pathetic) excuse to keep an imposed name when divorced women have done the same out of spite (and practicality/factuallity) to not to keep their husband's name??? So are you saying you feel, with a Greek imposed name, less bothered than a divorcee would feel for her husband's name? Pathetic.

The only "no-brainer" is the need to change it. Everything else so far has been a pathetic excuse.

The 'property rights' in Greece is a weak one at best. In days gone by it may have had merit, but today Macedonians (Egej and not) go to Greece on holiday. I would think that Greece would have the same laws pertaining to name changes (I'm sure they also have divorced women in Greece). Is it too difficult to go there and do the above first, and then in your Western country, if that's the procedure you have to take - cojekos can become cojekov and, with his new Greek officially recognised documentation, continue any claim to land/houses in Greece. What do you think the Greeks are going to do if you made a change of name application in Greece? - shoot you?

Is there any real reason not to change your name? Or is it the old, 'it's easier to get along to get along', and not suffer any discrimination from Greeks (here and over in Greece), as I have seen all too often in the past?

It is not that I am unsympathetic to the plight of the Egej Macedonians and the murder and torture they went through. It isn't your generation that went through it, but with obvious reason you would feel strongly about what happened to your parents?/grand parents/great-grand parents. Is that not more reason to throw off an imposed name. Empires sometimes last centuries and generations suffer all sorts of injustices, but one day, one generation throws off their oppressors and what they have imposed on them. Aren't you that generation? Someone has to do it sometime.
 
Last edited:
Brian, he is a minor.
There are valid reasons as to why a name change can impact on a number of issues that will effect relatives overseas and locally. I do not wish to portray Macedonians with Greek sounding names as being bad Macedonians. I do wish they thought about it much more though.

The arguments for changing the Republic of Macedonia's name are not dissimilar to keeping a Greek sounding name though (in almost all instances).
 
As for people running "established businesses", unless you are passing your self off as 'Grekos' Authentic Greek Tavern', there is NO other business that cannot change it's name with minimal expense of replacing the stationary and government fees for filling a company name change. Is there going to be a cost to do this? - Yes, but it can only be minimal. Does your dignity mean less to you than a few hundred dollars? Pathetic. Or are you trying to flog your self off as authentic 'Greko' in your business? Pathetic. You don't have to have an 'ethnic' name for most businesses. Or are you worried you have a lot of Greek customers/suppliers who would be put-off by discovering your not Greek and how it might affect the business? Pathetic.

Wow, you have just determined "goodwill" has no value for any business. That is blindingly stupid and sours the rest of your statements.

I think Coca Cola should change its name for a few hundred bucks too!
 
EM,

This is a really interesting topic for me. Unfortunately, I cannot really provide any comments of substance as I have not really thought it through, nor have I been in a position where I have had an imposed personal name.

I imagine there would be a host of considerations, not least which name you would revert to, should you decide to change it. I do consider, however, that it would be a liberating move for you personally and a small but significant step for Macedonians in general.

Ultimately, it is your decision to make and one you need to live with, which ever way you go.
 
There is much to hate about what Greeks have done, and continue to do, to Macedonians. The stories are horrendous and it is with good reason people remember them. My comments were meant to reflect the need for an awakening and self empowerment.

The grand-father or great-grand-father generation were caught-up in a whirlwind of global circumstances that nobody could do anything about - noone can blame them for that. Even when later generations were able to be free in the West or elsewhere, fear of reprisals for loved-ones would have been a factor. Time moves forward, and times change, and each generation looks to the day when the tyranny can be overthrown, not knowing if it will be in their lifetime.

No generation growing up knows that when they reach their prime they will be the generation to strike a blow for all the preceding generations - 'grand-son, smack him one for me too', even when that voice is from the grave. I would have thought, and expected, that each generation would carry forward not only the stories of past events, but the desire to be free. With circumstances as they are, and have been for some time, it looks like this is the generation that will be able to claw back what is theirs, beginning with their name.

The Greek diaspora is large, but I have no doubt their numbers are made to be much more than what they are by all the 'Greek sounding names'. By taking back their names (to begin with) the Macedonians will be making a bold statement - 'I exist!' - much like the "Our Name Is Macedonia" campaign. When Macedonians are visible here, there, and everywhere, they cannot continue to be ignored. I would not be surprised if there were much more Macedonians from Egej than RoM in the diaspora. It all begins with a name - "Our Name Is Macedonia" and then a chorus of, "I too am Macedonian".

Every action has it's risks and costs and needs to be evaluated - there is no point in winning the battle and loosing the war. Times have changed, and now is the time to win the 'war'. It all begins with a name.

This thread is about 'Greek sounding names' and my criticisms are directed to the topic, but in no way should they be construed to mean that I cannot, and am not, critical of the whimper in RoM, but that's another topic and another thread.
 
Last edited:
EM,

This is a really interesting topic for me. Unfortunately, I cannot really provide any comments of substance as I have not really thought it through

So what you are saying is that you choose not to comment because you haven't thought it through. What an interesting idea. Imagine if more people did that. ha ha
 
Before i continue my discussion with EM, Message to Brian.
EM is far from pathetic, so is his response to this change of name issue.
The young lad puts many of us to shame with his intelligence he has shown many occasions. He might feel uncomfortable knowing he is living with it and when the issue (like any unsavoury issue one must live with) its natural to go on the back foot and defend the situation.
Human nature... When our pride is challenged by feeling unworthy, our emotions take over which acts as a defence. Boy have i been there in a big way :(

So using the word "Pathetic" at every paragraph is not only an inaccurate picture you are trying to (intentionally or not) paint EM, it also serves no benefit in achieving a change in EM's situation or any other Egejci in his position.

Bill, I'm not advocating that Egejci should keep their altered names, however it irritates me that some people here would belittle others based on their surname.
i agree.

It is a sensitive situation, that needs to be handled with sensitivity. The end of the day mate, remember our intention is to benefit the Macedonian race and we mean no harm.


The issues prevalent in the Republic are irrelevant, as Macedonians ultimately have the power to govern the future of their nation, whether they know it or not. When you are systematically oppressed by a foreign government, the scenario is entirely different.
There is a difference but not "entirely" different. ROM was also once oppressed by a foreign government. A Serb dominated Yugoslavia. Not as severe as the Greek authorities thats for sure, but a master none the less that neglected the Macedonian citizens within its own state that was like Egej illegally obtained. Credit to the Macedonians in ROM, they courageously voted in a referendum to break away from the Serb stronghold under such circumstances, where there was a blood bath happening next door, must be praised.

The ventilator was imposed by the Macedonian government,
Realistically yes. But i was talking symbolically, The ventilator symbolises foreign imposed. Yes a Macedonian might have designed it and government implemented the flag, but it was due to foreigners (mainly Greece) influencing the removal of our original flag (in the case of my example comparing the surname) to something new, unmacedonian.


I may change the name once I am legally able to, or even down the road, but here is an interesting thought to think about. The name wasn't imposed on me, I was born in Australia and have carried the altered name all my life, it has become a part of my identity, whether I like it or not.
Lets hope the future generation don't say the same and accept it once Macedonia's name gets changed. Yes i am comparing a personal name issue with a Nation name issue, but i fail to see the difference when it comes to importance in what is in a name.
 
Lets hope the future generation don't say the same and accept it once Macedonia's name gets changed. Yes i am comparing a personal name issue with a Nation name issue, but i fail to see the difference when it comes to importance in what is in a name.
There are so many valid parallels here Bill. It is a reasonable comparison.
 
Wow, I'm so glad that someone started this topic, I didn't see it before!

For a long time I have wondered how come some Egejci haven't changed their names back to their real Macedonian ones.

I can certainly understand how HUGE it would be to change the name that you've had your whole life, but when it comes down to it, this name is degrading. It was forced on either you or your relatives, and by accepting it you are accepting occupation/slavery (not literally slavery ofcourse, but you know what I mean).

For those of you worried about your achievements being forgotten, think about this: Your achievements are the knowledge you learned in school, not the piece of paper diploma with a name on it. Your knowledge will help you guide yourself through life. THAT is your achievement. Your trophies (if that's the case) are just a symbol of what you have accomplished. When you grow older and have kids, you probably won't even have any childhood chinese-made trophies lying around. You will only have stories to tell your children, and there is nothing shameful about changing your name. People do it every day. In fact, the sooner you do it, the better. You have a long life ahead of yourselves, and if you are reading this forum, then I'm sure you would like others to know you are Macedonian. The last thing you would want is for people to think you are greek, or for people to think "oh well, his name is georgios, but he's Macedonian, so greeks and Macedonians must be basically the same since their names sound the same".

Imagine if one day Macedonia was united again, would we call Solun thessaloniki?? No WAY! Solun is Solun. If your name was Georgievski, then it will never be Georgios, and cannot remain that way.

No disrespect to anybody, absolutely none, because it is not your fault or anyone in your family's fault, but you have the power in your hands to make a choice for yourself. A choice that I guarantee you will never harm you, and will certainly bring some justice back for you and your relatives.
 
Back
Top