In 274 B.C., when Antigonus Gonatas was King
of Macedonia, Pyrrhus, the King of Epirus, invaded Macedonia and arrived at Aeges
(Vergina),
where he pillaged all royal tombs and
scattered the bones of all kings, among which
there were those of Philip II and his son's, Philip III
Arrhidaeus'.
(Diodorus Siculus, Plutarch,Pausanias)
Professor Andronikos in his book refers to the pillaging of the royal tombs by Pyrrhus, but claims that “it was by mere coincidence that the tomb of King Philip II escaped from being pillaged”.
However, this tomb was well known to everyone
and would have been impossible for it to have
escaped, just like no other royal tomb in Vergina
escaped before 274 BC .
This view on which Professor Andronikos' final
conclusions on the identity of the dead and the
tombs of Vergina were based was, in my opinion,
a serious historical error of facts in the field of
archaeology.
This error of facts was significantly reinforced by
the conclusions of a group of
British scientists
under Anatomist
Dr. J. Musgrave, who supported
in their report that “…they succeeded in restoring
the head of King Philip II based on the skull bones
discovered in Tomb II”
(Transactions of the International Congress of Classical Archaeology XII, Athens 4 10.9.1983).
FIRST DISPUTED POINT
Based on the evidence
presented above in combination
with the age of the
dead of Tombs II and III
as well as the building
construction and artefacts,
I have formed completely
different views from those
of Professor Andronikos', after these had already been
established in Greece andabroad. In 1993 I undertook
the writing of a book on the subject (“To Philip II or to
Alexander the Great belongs the royal tomb of
Vergina?”,1993) and expressed my counter-arguments
concerning ProfessorAndronikos' conclusions and
Dr. J. Musgrave's findings. My conclusion was that:
The bones of Tomb II do not belong to King
Philip II and his last wife,Cleopatra.
The same conclusion is expressed in the relevant
report by Mr. N. I. Xirotiris, Professor of Anthropology
at the University of Thrace and his colleague, Mrs.
Franziska Langenscheidt (Archaiologike Ephimeris
1981).T h is was also later confirmed by Mr. A. Bartsiokas,
Professor of Anthropology as well (Science
Magazine, 21.4.2000).
Historical evidence leads us to the conclusion that in
316 BC King Philip III Arrhidaeus was buried in this
tomb by Cassander, following his murder by
Olympias in 317 BC at Pella (Pausanias).
King Philip II was buried between 336 and 335 B.C.
in the adjacent Tomb III. There is important
evidence proving his identity.
TOMB II AND THE FAMOUS
HUNTING SCENE
After Pyrrhus was driven away in 273 BC, Tomb II
was prepared by Antigonus Gonatas and acquired
the form we know today with the Hunting Scene
Mural (Fig. 1); this hunting incident had taken place
in Bactria in 327 BC, nine years after Philip's death
(Arrian). The rider seen in the middle on the mural
is Alexander the Great, while both King Philip II and
Philip III Arrhidaeus are missing. Alexander's attire
(Fig. 1) confirms what Diodorus Siculus writes that in
Persia “…he wore a white tunic and a Persian belt
without Persian breeches (anaxyrides)”. Also what
Herodotus writes is verified, i.e. that “in Persia, those
who were about to make
a sacrifice wore a wreath
of myrtle leaves” (as the
mural confirms).
As for Professor Andronikos'
view that the lionhunter
on horseback is
Philip II, because of his
physical similarity to the
king, I hold a different
point of view. This is the
chief of Alexander's bodyguards,
Ptolemy, son
of Lagus, who according to ancient sources was the biological son of Philipbut
inname the son of General Lagus, since Philip had
given to Lagus theboy's mother, Arsinoe, Philip's
concubine, as a wife while she was pregnant (Ploutarch).
It was, therefore,natural for the young man to
look like his natural father, Philip II.
The other view held by a team of archaeologists, that
the hunter on horseback (Fig. 1) is King Philip III
Arrhidaeus, is wrong for the following reasons:
Hunting wild animals was considered truly dangerous
and it was common sense that those participating in the
sport should be physically fit, bold, quick-thinking,
experienced and agile.
Philip III Arrhidaeus suffered from a physical
disability, an incurable mental disease, was
mentally retarded and after the death of
Alexander the Great was made king due to
the order of succession to the throne, given
that he was Alexander's half-brother and
there was no other successor, other than the
expected son of Alexander (Ploutarch,
Diodorus Siculus).Therefore, it is out of the
question that Philip III Arrhidaeus was the
lion-hunter on horseback.
A brief extract of evidence contained in the recently
published book The Royal Tomb II at Vergina Reveals
Alexander the Great by historian researcher
Triandafyllos D. Papazois
http://www.tdpapazois.gr/english_research.pdf