Risto the Great
Senior Member
Warrior, you make some very solid points. But I must disagree with you about the Albanians sticking together fighting for civil rights. Clearly the Greek air is different from across the borders because the Albanians in Greece did not even put up a whimper .... unlike the Macedonians (in the "civil" war). The Albanians in Greece are proud Greeks nowadays. It is the perception that Greeks are higher on the culturally developed food chain that empowers these various ethnicities in Greece to embrace Hellenism. It is a mass duping of proportions that we will never see again.
I think it is still the victim or slave mentality that effects all Macedonians that causes this. Why would they feel inferior culturally? I mean, if we compare the Greeks to the French, then the French have an air of sophistication that the Greeks wished and dreamed about 100 years ago. The Russians fancied the French as well. So this Greek identity is deeply rooted in a desire to be culturally superior and permeates every aspect of their lives. You don't compare with the French .... well nobody compares with us Greeks because we created democracy, maths, logical thought, alphabets, [insert other dreamy un-qualified attributes here].
Unless pride can be instilled in the Macedonian identity, nothing will ever change. Even if they all learn Macedonian in Greece. Then (as far as they are concerned) they can sound like better peasant farmers. That is what speaking Macedonian means to many Macedonians in Greece.
So, just to weigh in on the debate a little, unless the Republic of Macedonia steps up and implements some powerful initiatives and becomes more representative of what successful Macedonians can be (as opposed to being victims/slaves), there will be no reason for the Macedonians of Greece to discard their newly embraced Greek identity.
I think it is still the victim or slave mentality that effects all Macedonians that causes this. Why would they feel inferior culturally? I mean, if we compare the Greeks to the French, then the French have an air of sophistication that the Greeks wished and dreamed about 100 years ago. The Russians fancied the French as well. So this Greek identity is deeply rooted in a desire to be culturally superior and permeates every aspect of their lives. You don't compare with the French .... well nobody compares with us Greeks because we created democracy, maths, logical thought, alphabets, [insert other dreamy un-qualified attributes here].
Unless pride can be instilled in the Macedonian identity, nothing will ever change. Even if they all learn Macedonian in Greece. Then (as far as they are concerned) they can sound like better peasant farmers. That is what speaking Macedonian means to many Macedonians in Greece.
So, just to weigh in on the debate a little, unless the Republic of Macedonia steps up and implements some powerful initiatives and becomes more representative of what successful Macedonians can be (as opposed to being victims/slaves), there will be no reason for the Macedonians of Greece to discard their newly embraced Greek identity.