• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

Albanians in Greece

The Arvanites and the Arvanitika Language
http://www.reference-global.com/doi/abs/10.1515/ijsl.1998.134.39
ijsl.1998.134.39.fp.png_v03
 
Anti-Arvanitika campaigns

Educational policies played a chief role in the assimilation and the suppression of the practice of Arvanitika from native speakers. Official authorities also played a role through "subliminal hindrance" for the eradication of a language spoken for at least seven centuries. Below we are publishing some excerpts where direct and indirect pressures and "guidance" from authorities lead not only to the termination of Arvanitika language but also to the impediment of Arvanitika scholarship.*

"People told me that they were scared of reprisals on the part of authorities but also ashamed of still speaking "this bastardized language" I was once even reported to the police by the son of one of my informants but was set free after a few hours when the superior officers confirmed by telephone from Athens that my activities were entirely harmless and tolerated by official institutions." (This has occurred way too often with various foreign and local scholars, researchers and anthropologists.)

"A male informant from a village in Andros born in 1899 reported in an interview that his father had placed a big knife on a board above the entrance door, threatening his children that he would cut their tongue if he caught them speaking Arvanitika again.

Another speaker from a Corinthian village, likewise born around 1900, recalled having been beaten repeatedly for speaking Arvanitika with his sisters in the courtyard. Similar anecdotal evidence emerges from tape recorded biographies of very old speakers from Attica, taped in the late 1960's and early 1970's. Those who were not prevented from speaking Arvanitika by their parents were severely punished and ridiculed in school.

A conversation recorded in 1969 between a (not extremely well educated) monolingual Greek from Athens and an Arvanite peasant:

Monolingual Greek: "Shame on you for still speaking Arvanitika"

Peasant: "But we are Arvanites, aren't we? All of our ancestors have been Arvanites and have been speaking Arvanitika

Monolingual Greek: "But you live in Greece here, don't you? If you want to speak Arvanitika go to Tirana. In this country people speak Greek." *

Peasant: "But I'm Greek like you!"

Monolingual Greek: Then stop speaking that ugly jargon."

In 1969 there were definitely no Arvanites from Tirana. Twenty years later however,* the story changes as Arvanites could not relate economically and politically to the incoming Albanian refugees. The only cultural and linguistic commonalities that existed were invalidated by strong and convincing media images that depicted these refugees as barbarous and criminal. However, we are not talking about Arvanites as refugees, we are referring to Arvanites Greek citizens.

Regardless of their chronology, these examples can certainly be applied to other minority language speakers, but Arvanitika is a key example since it represents a significant portion of the modern Greek population.

To date there are no Arvanitika schools operating in Greece (October 2010).

Source: H.J.Sasse - Small languages and small language communities in Int'l J.Soc.Lang 1998.
 
Kato Idroussa, and Ano Idroussa are Dolno & Gorno Kotori by the way.
Apparently 'Kotora' means 'battle' in Old Macedonian/Church Slavonic.

http://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/Appendix:Proto-Indo-European_roots
Epirot said:
The most credible of all promoted theories down to our days is Illyrian one. It has linguistical, geographical, historical, anthropological, ethnographical and genetical evidences.
There is no direct link to an Illyrian or another Paleo-Balkan heritage. You've shown nothing credible on any of the other threads Epirot, the only thing I would be prepared to accept at the moment are a few lexical correspondences.
[QUOTE="True Macedonian]The Folllowing is from 1901 from Madam Tsilka's unpublished memoirs about the story of her being kidnapped with Miss Stone by Macedonians;

Very soon a man emerged from a pile of branches and came near us. He looked nervous and confused and hesitated in his speech. "Please," I said, "Tell us, are you Christian bandits of Turks?"
"Oh," he said "We are a mixture of faiths and nationalities. Among us are Bulgarians and Albanians, Serbs and Macedonians. We even have a Jew with us. But we are no bandits. You shall know very soon why you were captured."

The man who spoke was Jane Sandanski. There's been newspaper articles of Boris Sarafov meeting with Albanian Revolutionaries in Albania when they began fighting the Turks in their own ground. But we must not forget that these Albanians were most likely christian as opposed to the muslims who did fight the Macedonians.[/QUOTE]
TM, do you have any more on this?
 
Potekloto na Majka Tereza.
Podolu spodeluvam eden tekst na albanski jazik objaven vo nekolku albanski vesnici od Aurel Plasari, direktor na Nacionalnata Bibloteka na Albanija, koj go podrzuva mislenjeto deka Majka Tereza, majka mu ja imashe katolicka albanka dodeka tatko mu vlav od familijata Bojaxhi.

Origjina e nene Terezes
Me poshte do te sjell nje artikull te Aurel Plasarit, drejtor i Bibliotekes Kombetare, i cili mbeshtet mendimin se Nene Tereza kishte te emen katolike shqiptare, kurse te atin shqiptar-vllah nga familja vllahe e Bojaxhinjve.
Me pas do sjell kundershtimet dhe reagimet e skandalizuara te disa gazetareve shqiptare.

Bojaxhitë e nënë Terezës


nga dr. Aurel PLASARI


“Travestí elitash” e quante para do kohe në shtyp një kolegu ynë fushatën kinse-nacionaliste për mbrojen me çdo kusht të “shqiptarësisë” së të misionares së madhe të krishterë Nënë Tereza. Përfytyroni tani se ç’mund të ndodhë kur ta dojë rasti që në këtë spektakël e sipër të kesh për duarsh një punim ende të papërfunduar për familjet e mëdha voskopojare dhe “voskopjarët e mëdhenj”: Kavaliotët, Sinat, Shagunat, Dumbat, Gondut, Bellot, Qopekat, Ballaurët/Vallaurët, Fundot etj.; ndër to edhe familja Bojaxhi.
Bojaxhitë qenë dhe janë një familje në zë aromane (angl. Aromanians), e përhapur në disa vise të Ballkanit, si dhe përtej tij, në degë të ndryshme. Përfaqësuesi më në zë i Bojaxhive mbahet historikisht Mihail G. Bojaxhi (Boiagi), me të cilin llogaritet të fillojë historia moderne e aromanëve. Së toku me tjetrin filolog aroman Gjorgje Kosta Roza, me të cilin vepruan në dy dhjetëvjeçarët e parë të shek. XIX, ai u bë bashkëthemelues i teorisë së “latinitetit” të aromanëve në Ballkan. Që të dy punuan në qytetet e Perandorisë së Habsburgëve, por qenë me prejardhje voskopojare. Sa i përket vendlindjes së Mihail G. Bojaxhiut, opinionet ndahen dysh: Max Peyfuss-i mendon që ai të ishte lindur në Budë më 1780 (Die Druckerei von Moschopolis, 26), ndërsa Candroveanu e shënon Bojaxhiun të lindur në Voskopojë më 1770 (Antologie de proza aromana, 195).
Duke vijuar traditën e shkollës filologjike të Voskopojës, përuruar në gjysmën e dytë të shek. XVIII, Mihail G. Bojaxhiu botoi të parën gramatikë të aromanishtes (Gramatica romana sau macedo-romana, 1818) të shoqëruar edhe me përkthimet greqishte dhe rumanishte. Ai hartoi edhe një gramatikë të bullgarishtes dhe një të serbishtes, si dhe një libër mësimi të greqishtes, duke dhënë pjesën e vet të ndihmës në standardizimin e këtyre gjuhëve. Bindja e tij prej poligloti në pluralitetin gjuhësor e shtynte të nënvizonte: “Çdo gjuhë është një hipostazë e shpirtit njerëzor; sa më shumë gjuhë të nxëjë një njeri, aq më shumë gjëra ai di. Njeriu nuk mund t’i fitojë të gjitha dijet vetëm nga një gjuhë e vetme, edhe sikur ajo gjuhë të jetë më e përkryera në botë. Të këmbëngulësh mbi një gjuhë të vetme është njëherësh kotësi dhe marrëzi nga pikëpamja praktike” (Gramatica, X).
Degë të ndryshme të familjes Bojaxhi u përhapën jo vetëm në qytetet e mëdha habsburgjike (Vjenë, Budë, Pest etj.), por edhe në qytete të Ballkanit, kështu edhe në Shkup. Në periudhën e Perandorisë osmane Shkupi paraqitej si qytet etnikisht i përzier: bashkëjetonin aty shqiptarë, aromanë (vllehë), maqedonë dhe një bashkësi e vogël familjesh hebreje. Këtë situatë përzierjeje e pati ndeshur qysh në shek. XIII rabini udhëtar nga Spanja Benjamin i Tudelës; po këtë regjistronte në shek. XIX Ami Bué-ja; dhe po kjo situatë, me ndryshimet e kuptueshme në të mirë të bashkësive maqedone e shqiptare, rezulton aty edhe sot e gjithë ditën. Në Shkup aromanët jetonin në një lagje veçan, sikurse ishte traditë për qytetet orientale, që quhej “Lagjja e vllehëve”: “Vlaškoj mahala”. Në këtë lagje jetonte edhe familja Bojaxhi në të cilën u lind më 27 gusht 1910 Gonxhe Bojaxhiu, e ardhshmja Nënë Terezë. Në ditën e sotme lagjja në fjalë është shpërbërë në një masë të madhe: aty tek ishte shtëpia e Bojaxhive është tani një autorrugë pranë një qendre tregtare ngjitur me “Sheshin Maqedonia”. Nuk ka ndonjë dëshmi që të dëftojë se ku Gonxhe Bojaxhiu është pagëzuar, por është e besueshme që ajo të jetë pagëzuar në kishën e lagjes ku u lind: në “kishën e vllehëve”. Për mësimet fillore ka ndjekur një shkollë jokatolike: këtë e tregon edhe vetë në kujtimet e saj. Po t’i lexohen me vëmendje kujtimet dhe t’i ndiqen prononcimet, le të vihet re: ishte shqipja apo maqedonishtja ndër gjuhët që ajo njihte? Apo ishte “the aromanian”? Aromanishtja/vllahishtja nuk është ndonjë gjuhë qarkullimi të gjerë, gjuhë kulture moderne, nga ato që mësohen nëpër kolegjet e Anglisë apo universitetet e SHBA-së. Të diturit e aromanishtes/ vllahishtes nga një njeri i rritur shpjegohet vetëm nëpërmjet një fakti: dhe dihet se cili është ai fakt.
Në moshën dhjetëvjeçare Gonxhes i vdiq i ati, Nikollë Bojaxhiu dhe, me vdekjen e tij, është e kuptueshme të vinte duke u zbehur edhe identiteti i të parëve nga linja e gjakut. Nën përkujdesjen e s’ëmës Drane, që ishte katolike nga rrethinat e Gjakovës, Gonxhja nisi të shpihej rregullisht tanimë në kishën katolike të qytetit, të këndonte në kor, derisa rreth të dymbëdhjetave, sikurse ka treguar vetë, t’i lindte dëshira për t’u bërë “motër e shenjtë”.
Pinjoj të familjes së Bojaxhive të Maqedonisë ndeshen aty-këtu, nëpër regjistrat e shpëtuar rastësisht të shkollave aromane, qysh me themelimin e tyre në gjysmën e dytë të shek. XIX aty. Në shkollën aromane të Gopeshit, për shembull, themeluar më 1867, ndër regjistrimet e vitit shkollor 1889-90 del Jani Bojaxhi, ndërsa në shkollën aromane të Krushovës, themeluar më 1868, ndër regjistrimet e vitit 1889-90 dalin Ana N. Bojaxhi, Taku Bojaxhi etj. Bojaxhi të tjerë të mbetur në Maqedoni dhe të lidhur mbas kishës ortodokse (pravosllave), me dhjetra emra në kulturë, politikë, shkencë, sport (Aleksandër Bojaxhi, Jani Bojaxhi, Dhimitri Bojaxhi) etj., mbahen tanimë të “maqedonizuar”, ndryshe prej fatit të Gonxhes që u zhvendos në mjedisin shqiptar katolik të s’ëmës, në Shqipëri.
Pavarësisht ndonjë mëtimi joserioz të FYROM-it zyrtar, Kryetari i Unionit për Kulturën të Aromanëve në Maqedoni Dimo Dimcev e ka përshkruar me korrektësi prejardhjen e familjes së Gonxhe Bojaxhiut në një intervistë për NIN-in. Si kujton se dikur “Jerusalemi” i aromanëve pati qenë Voskopoja dhe se, me prishjen e saj, shumë familje voskopojare u hapërdanë në qytete në ndryshme të Ballkanit, si dhe të Perandorisë austro-hungare, ai përshkruan edhe kalimin e pjesëve të ndryshme të familjes Bojaxhi në Shkup, Prizren etj. Ai ka vërejtur se i ati i Gonxhes, Nikolla, ishte përfaqësues i vllehëve (vlasi) në kuvendin e qytetit të Shkupit; për këtë ekziston edhe dokumenti përkatës bërë i njohur prej Stojan Tren?evskit (“Mutter Teresa, Gondje Boiagi, ist von ihrem Vater Nikola Boiagi her wlachischer Abstammung; wir berufen uns auf das von dem Autor Stojan Trencevski entdeckte Dokument, das belegt, dass Nikola Boiagi in den Fuhrungsorganen der wlachischen Gemeinschaft in Skopje tatig gewesen war”). Nga një anë tjetër, as akademiku maqedon Tome Serafimovski nuk e ka pasur të vështirë ta pranojë këtë prejardhje: “Askush në Maqedoni nuk ka mëtuar ndonjëherë që Nënë Tereza të ketë qenë maqedone, kurse në Shkup dihet që ati i saj Nikolla Bojaxhi ka qenë jo shqiptar, por vllah” (“Niko nikada u Makedoniji nije tvrdio da je Majka Tereza bila Makedonka, ali u Skoplju se zna da joj otac Nikola Bojadzi bio ne Albanac, vec Cincar”).
Që të gjitha këto orvatje për të depërtuar në prejardhjen e një figure si Nënë Tereza, këto tërheqje litari me jo “është jona”, jo “nuk është juaja”, mund të jenë në thelb absurde: me këtë jam një mendjeje edhe unë. E Krishtera e Madhe e Kalkutës është një figurë tanimë e shenjtë që i përkiste/ i përket humanizmit të krishterë mbarëkombëtar, madje jokombëtar ose mbikombëtar. E para që do të neveritej prej tërheqjesh të tilla litari do të ishte ajo vetë, e cila refuzoi me ngul të merrej ndonjëherë me përkatësinë e saj etnike apo me prejardhjen e saj. Por atëherë përse këta burra shteti ose minishteti, presidentë, kryebashkiakas etj., marrin përsipër të caktojnë a të mbrojnë prejardhjen e njërit apo të tjetrit pa pasur haber as nga gjenealogjia, as nga filologjia, as nga historia? Madje, më së shumti, pa e ditur as ku bien me shtëpi këto dije? Dhe çfarë argumentesh shtien në punë në këtë spektakël kinse-nacionalist që kolegu ynë me të drejtë e quante “travestí elitash”?
Ja ndonjë prej argumenteve, qëmtuar nëpër mediat shqiptare prej niveleve të bulevardit deri tek ato të profesionistëve të ATSh-së, madje nga ato që u shërbehen të huajve në anglishte të Tiranës: “Her real name is Agnes Bojaxhi. “Bojaxhi” in the Albanian language means “painter”!” Ose: “Mother Teresa was Albanian - her real name was Agnes Gonxhe Bojaxhiu. In the Albanian language Gonxhe means “bud” and Bojaxhi means “painter”!” Me një fjalë: një logjikë infantile, simbas të cilës Blend Gonxhja (më doli pikërisht ky përpara për shoqërim idesh) do të qitej anglez, sepse: “His real name is Blend Gonxhe and the English Blend means “përzierje”!” As u shkon mendja këtyre farë filologëve gjenelogjistë të shpjegojnë se fjalë si bojë (në shqip ngjyrë) dhe bojaxhi janë huazime nga turqishtja dhe si të tilla kanë hyrë në më shumë se një gjuhë të Ballkanit. Sepse: si vallë i thonë bojaxhiut në aromanishte? Në aromanishte bojaxhiut i thonë bojaxhi. (Të ma falë lexuesi, por m’u desh të merrem këtu me një këso shpjegimi ordiner.)
Përtej spektaklit të “travestisë së elitave” kthjellimi i këtij të sjelluri ka rëndësi në kulturën shqiptare edhe për diç tjetër: sepse me emërtime si “aroman”, apo më keq “vllah”, “kucovllah”, deri edhe “çoban” është abuzuar tradicionalisht (ndonjëherë vijon të abuzohet) për të detraktuar personazhe në zë të kulturës shqiptare kur kanë qenë “të padëshirueshëm” për dikë apo për diçka. Ky abuzim ka qenë (në mos vijon të jetë) një mjet rëndomqar në luftën e ideve: atëherë kur njëra prej palëve “ndërluftuese” nuk ka kundër tjetrës kurrfarë argumenti të fushës së mendimit. Mandej? Mandej, si të jenë marrë në vitet ‘20-30 tridhjetë me qitjen e Konicës “kucovllah të konvertuar”, si ta kenë zbuluar Fan. S. Nolin “aroman” dhe “joshqiptar” (mjerisht edhe ky vetë e kishte bërë dikur të atillë Konicën), si ta kenë përgojuar Lasgushin për “vllah Pogradeci” etj., një ditë prej ditësh i shpallin ata “shqiptarë të mëdhenj”. Po si kështu, me këta shqiptaromëdhenj? Atëherë, nëse të qëllon që në këtë spektakël e sipër të kesh për duarsh punimin për familjet e mëdha voskopojare dhe “voskopjarët e mëdhenj”, nga njëri prej gjenalogjistëve bashkëkohorë nuk mund të mos nënvizosh këtë vërejtje: “Në ekogjenetikën e kohës së sotme bihet një mendjeje nga të gjithë shkencëtarët se problemi më therës për botën e gjallë është ai i erozionit të gjeneve, që në gjenetikën humane përkon me erozionin e gjeneve njerëzore. Erozioni gjenetik i njeriut në skakierën sociale kryhet edhe nga persekutimi i njeriut prej njeriut”. Vërejtje që të bën të mendosh në thellësi: “nga persekutimi i njeriut prej njeriut”, çfarë të kujton mënyrën se si u sollën për një kohë të gjatë në Shqipëri me mëmën e Gonxhe Bojaxhiut, me të motrën dhe me vetë Gonxhen tanimë Nënë Terezë.




Bota Shqiptare nr. 93, 2-16 tetor 2003
Botuar njëkohësisht edhe në të përditshmen shqiptare "Shekulli"
 
There is no direct link to an Illyrian or another Paleo-Balkan heritage. You've shown nothing credible on any of the other threads Epirot

I would put that In emphasis we have been through this discussion before and nothing posted has really been convincing.

Again Albanians regarding themselves as such, which is a Historical fact proves nothing beyond the desire to prove a lineage to the past and the to expand territorially, Albanians time in the Sun was very recently the Kosovo exercise then before that the Formation of the Prizren League with a very notable Nazi collaborator and Support, Tetovo still remains the heart of it
 
Ethnic Albanians in Greece

Ethnic Albanians in Greece

I've the honor to present a well-documented study where the Albanians of Greece are studied thoroughly. The summary has been written by experts of Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Turkey (published in Ankara, on 1999).

You may think that this material is biased since it's written by Turkish officials, however, the details given here are treated neutrally and are supported even by western sources who confirm the same.

Nice reading!

Photosoftheblock145.jpg


Photosoftheblock146.jpg


Photosoftheblock147.jpg


Photosoftheblock148.jpg


Photosoftheblock149.jpg


Photosoftheblock150.jpg


Photosoftheblock151.jpg


Photosoftheblock152.jpg


Photosoftheblock153.jpg


Photosoftheblock154.jpg


Photosoftheblock155.jpg


Photosoftheblock156.jpg
 
Epirot thanks for supplying this stuff it's important to show what the greeks are upto & still doing it.It's bad enough being forced into assimmilation but not to recognize your human rights is nothing short of atrocius.Is there anywhere apart from greece that has to be the worst case scenario of what it's doing & denying people's human rights.
 
Everything is long lost for the christian Albanians in Greece. Their leaders already willingly assimilated in to the modern Greek identity and the Greek authorities assimilated the rest of them. They are also getting indoctrinated by despising anything about Albania and Albanians for about a century. I am sure that if someone reminds deputy PM Pangalos that his grandparents didn't even know Greek and he was speaking Albanian only, probably he curses on him. Just like some formerly Turkish christians, e.g. Kara-zafer(is), these Albanians are the champions of hellenes now!!

But Cham Albanian issue is different. They have been banished from their ancestral lands without a reason and all of a sudden. I know that few 100 of them seek asylum in Turkey too, shortly after WW-2. I wonder if Albanian state does something about that issue? Is there any 3rd party country other than Turkey who speaks about this?


Btw, one of oldest settlement records of Ottoman empire is "Sancak-i Arnavut". It`s dated from 1420s. I read it b4 and it contains all the information about how many feudal landowners in there, how many villages, towns, population and the map of the Sanjak (province) of Albania. The map includes all the current Albania and Chameria, northwest of Greece. Found it on web;

ChamMapUS01Web.jpg



I think rather than dealing with their ancestral lands in Greece, Albanians are looking for a wrong direction for expanding, the Macedonia. Because even in early 15th century Ottoman records, current northwestern Greece was the sanjak of Albania. While it`s obvious that these places was inhabited by Albanians for centuries `till the WW-2, they seems totally forgot it and eyed for western Macedonia instead.

As you know, current northern Greece was Macedonia, northwest was called as Albania, northeast was Thrace, central Greece was Morea. So, there was no Greece at all during whole Ottoman reign. And while Istanbul patriarchy had full authority over the Balkan christians, they never ever complained about non-existence of the name Greece in current Greece . It sounds strange isn't it?
 
Their leaders already willingly assimilated in to the modern Greek identity and the Greek authorities assimilated the rest of them

Hi Onur...nice to hear from you again. In regard with your statement, I'd say that the state of things after the establishing of 'Greek' Kingdom was pretty complicated than it appears in first sight. The fact that a sizable number of them preserve their Albanian features even under the condition of a strict regime of a deliberately assimilation by the Greek authorities, indicate that they receive Hellenism only superficially. Greek politics never achieved to erase their Albanian identity. It's another thing that Greece did with a lot of success: they indoctrinated Arvanites to felt nothing for the Albanians. Since that time, Arvanites looked with a lot of disdain upon Albanians: they viewed us as 'Turko-Albanians'.

I wonder if Albanian state does something about that issue? Is there any 3rd party country other than Turkey who speaks about this?

Unfortunately not. The Albanian state never dare to rise its voice in protecting Cham issue. After the collapse of Communist regime in Albania and constant weakening of the state, Greece could extend in a great proportion its services and by doing so, to put under its control some important political figures. Then, Greece ruin the independence of Albanian Orthodox Church. This enable her to greacize a lot of Orthodox Albanians and Vlachs. Whether we like it or not, Turkey and some Aegean Macedonian organizations advocated Cham issue more than Albanian state itself. But this has also its negative side: this gives to Greece sufficient room to damage the Cham issue because it treat as a problem fabricated by Turkey and Macedonia. I hope you get my point!

Because even in early 15th century Ottoman records, current northwestern Greece was the sanjak of Albania.

You're right. The sandjak of Albania, according to Ottoman records, encompassed most of modern Albania as far as Ambracia with an evident Albanian majority. This is also accepted by Turkish historians.

It would be a mistake to minimize the Albanian problem only in Chameria. It's evidently larger than that. What about thousands of Christian Albanian natives scattered all over Greece (Attica, Eubea, Thrace, etc)? If this problem would be solved correctly, then it must include all Albanians. We should not fall on Greek intrigues to abandon thousands of Christian Albanians...
 
Last edited:
It's another thing that Greece did with a lot of success: they indoctrinated Arvanites to felt nothing for the Albanians. Since that time, Arvanites looked with a lot of disdain upon Albanians: they viewed us as 'Turko-Albanians'.

Because you were Turk Alvanos. Full Stop. There is no doubt that the Albanians were the henchmens of the Ottoman empire in the Balkans.
The ones that were were sell outs and as far as Im concerned they have every right to view you this way. Even Scanderbeg would spit on them.

Next time your in Greece, why dont you inform your Arvanite brothers of how you feel and the oppression they suffer. Hope your insured. :lol:
 
sir george rights of secession,??you have no idea about rights when you look at greeks who forbade people to even speak macedonian & you tal;k on the same level as if we are affecting albanian human rights.You look at the albanian consciousness in greece completely wiped oit because of the mentality & extent the govt will go.Look at poor macedonia is virtually given everything away to them at the expense of sovereignity.
 
Epirot i agree about indoctrination by the greeks.What if the albanians in greece start revolting & join up with the rest of the albanians then they will wonder,Once they wake up & realise that the whole thing is a sham & just propping up the last vestitude of greece.But then they must be zonked out on the ouso to think greek all the time.
 
It's another thing that Greece did with a lot of success: they indoctrinated Arvanites to felt nothing for the Albanians. Since that time, Arvanites looked with a lot of disdain upon Albanians: they viewed us as 'Turko-Albanians'.

Thanks Epirot, and you got a valuable document here too.

I know that mate. This is unfortunately a typical Balkan behaviour and a cliche. After Ottoman regime ended, they transformed the term Turk into a bad label to brand people they dislike or demonize some group in the eyes of a particular people. The Slovak guy in the forum said that the Serbs in northern Serbia looks like Germans and they dislike their southern kinsmen and calls them as "Turks"!! Then you know, Bosnian Serbs calls Bosnian muslims as Turks and so on. It`s ridicules!

Btw, Bulgarians did same for the christian Gagauz Turks in there. They branded them as Turks first, because of their Turkish mothertongue and then they became hesitant to speak Turkish laters, they kept their identity in Bulgaria as secret. My brother`s Bulgarian Turkish wife told me that Gagauzs remains hidden in Bulgaria. She told me that when she was walking in the streets of Sofia or sitting in a cafe, sometimes a Gagauz comes by them to ask something cuz she hears that they speak in Turkish. She said that they usually speak Turkish by whispering in low voice even when they are in privacy and returning to Bulgarian language in public. It creates some kind of psychological pressure upon them, it`s already that`s why they do that, demonizing their true identity, language etc., so they prefer to be assimilated among them by their own will after some time.


After the collapse of Communist regime in Albania and constant weakening of the state, Greece could extend in a great proportion its services and by doing so, to put under its control some important political figures. Then, Greece ruin the independence of Albanian Orthodox Church. This enable her to greacize a lot of Orthodox Albanians and Vlachs.

I think i already told you that b4 but you are actually lucky that Italy was on your side in post WW-1 Paris peace conference. Greeks was doing immense propaganda at that time and Venizelos was aiming to get Albania up to Tirana after they seized Thrace, calling it as "northern Epirus, ancient hellenic territory". British supported that but Italy defied them. So, Albania was inch close to be destroyed in 1920 after being formed in 1913.

We all can guess what would happen shortly afterwards; hellenizing the christian Albanians and rape/kill/dump the rest of muslims to the Turkey!!!, Voila, 5000 year old pure Greek Epirus, just like Aegean Macedonia.


You're right. The sandjak of Albania, according to Ottoman records, encompassed most of modern Albania as far as Ambracia with an evident Albanian majority. This is also accepted by Turkish historians.
This is actually not an issue of acceptance or denial by the historians. It`s fact, mate. In the documents, written in 1420, it was Albania and it remained so for the next ~500 years.


It would be a mistake to minimize the Albanian problem only in Chameria. It's evidently larger than that. What about thousands of Christian Albanian natives scattered all over Greece (Attica, Eubea, Thrace, etc)? If this problem would be solved correctly, then it must include all Albanians. We should not fall on Greek intrigues to abandon thousands of Christian Albanians...
Yes, that`s true but i gave emphasis to the Chams cuz it`s more recent, happened only ~60 years ago. I am sure there are many first hand victims alive today, in Albania and in Turkey.

Btw, did you see one of these videos in youtube b4?;
YouTube - ‪tsamiko ellinikos xoros - Traditional Greek dance‬‏

Rape them, kill them and expel the rest of the Chams. Then pick up their cloths, music and dances, advertise it as "tsamiko ellinikos", traditional Greek dance from antiquity!!! Thats outrageous!!!
 
Last edited:
Because you were Turk Alvanos. Full Stop. There is no doubt that the Albanians were the henchmens of the Ottoman empire in the Balkans.
The ones that were were sell outs and as far as Im concerned they have every right to view you this way. Even Scanderbeg would spit on them.

:lol:


Give it a break, you smartass! The question is not that Arvanites pejoratively label Albanians as 'Turk Alvanos' because in a certain historical period they were "henchmens" of the Ottoman Empire. The reason why Arvanites label Albanians as 'Turks' is because they're in a great proportion Muslims. But they counfound the term 'Muslim' with the 'Turk'. Indeed, there is no other people in Balkans to have profited so much from Ottoman mercy than your folk. You know it better than me. Why you don't use a more realistic term like 'Turk Greek' or something like that. It suit well with your historical past.

I highly recommand to you to have a reading on the following paper:

untitl10.png


1. For the sake of argument let admit for a second that Greeks clearly formed the majority of population in Kingdom. If they were a majority then they would be main champions of their independence. How come that the best and highest officers of the Greek army were either foreign Phil-Hellenes, Albanians from all corners of Ottoman empire, cadets from Germany, etc. Why is that minor Greek presence into main institutions of the state?
2. If Greeks again were the majority, then how come that Greece owes every achievement to the strangers? Why those ‘strangers’ were in every corner of ‘Greek’ life: universities were full of Phil-Hellen professors, highest ranks of the army were full of Germans, Albanians, etc, trade was predominated by Vlachs, Albanians, etc.
3. If Greeks were a majority in Kingdom, then why James H. Skene said that they ‘do not contribute much’?
4. Let suppose that Phanariotes exercised a prominent influence in fortunes of the new emerged state…then why these ‘champions’ of Free Greece were one of the most loyal subjects to the Sultan?

Next time your in Greece, why dont you inform your Arvanite brothers of how you feel and the oppression they suffer. Hope your insured.

Why do you question their oppression, which is so evident? Is there any school, where they can learn their native language? But the reality is, whether you like or not, most of Arvanites preserve up to our days their ancestral language, even in circumstances of constant assimilation.

The Albanians are found in the north of Eubea and in other islands ; in Attica, away from Athens and the Piraeus, nearly all the people are Albanians, many of whom are completely fused with the Greeks.

^The London quarterly review: Volume 84, William Lonsdale Watkinson, John Telford, William Theophilus Davison – 1895,

There is not much difference after 80 years:

"It is not too widely known outside Greece that the majority of villages in the immediate vicinity of Athens are (or were) Albanian rather than Greek speaking. (…)In Attica and Biotia Albanian-Greeks today number perhaps 140000, and form the majority of the population of most of the villages concerned. They are, therefore, typically a rural rather than an urban people. These Albanians for a long

^ Language, ethnicity and intergroup relations, Howard Giles, Academic Press, 1977, p. 172
 
Last edited:
Rape them, kill them and expel the rest of the Chams. Then pick up their cloths, music and dances, advertise it as "tsamiko ellinikos", traditional Greek dance from antiquity!!! Thats outrageous!!!

Yes I am aware of it. Aristidh Kola, a prominent Arvanite intellectual in his book "Arvanites and the origin of Greeks' notice that Neo-Byzantines (a term which he uses constantly to describe the wannabe Greeks) pick up this dance from Chameria. But they dance it so worst, as every Cham would laugh seeing Neo-Hellenes playing it.
 
Lost my post again. :31:

Next time Epirot. Youll have your answer.

Just be thankful to the Turks that settled you here. If it wasnt for them you would still be in the Caucaus mountains.
Your only link to antiquity in the Balkans is through us. Remember that next time you decide to post Pyrro.
 
Lost my post again. :31:

Next time Epirot. Youll have your answer.

Just be thankful to the Turks that settled you here. If it wasnt for them you would still be in the Caucaus mountains.
Your only link to antiquity in the Balkans is through us. Remember that next time you decide to post Pyrro.

Why this anal fixation to Antiquity Voltron?
 
Amazing how the greeks have denied the macedonians their existence where as they themselves are everything but greek.If the world knew about it they would be a laughing stock & ridiculed.
 
Surely your joking Daskale. Look around you. Half the Avatars here are of ppl that are dead 2000 + yrs ago not to mention symbols of antiquity. Heck, look at your own, and Im the one with the fixation ?

Im just enlightning our friend Pyrros who is spreading propaganda against Greeks and Arvanties. I would love for him to try to sell this crap to Arvanites.
 
Back
Top