Pelister
New member
There is an idea out there that our history is a product of 19th and 20th century nationalism.
It is a common belief among the university professors of Western institutions, that we have absolutely no claim to the ancient Macedonians, and furthermore, that our 'identity' is a construct, a result of nationalism.
None of these professors have ever bothered to actually familiarise themselves with Macedonian culture.
For example, one of the longest Macedonian ballads of Alexander the Great was first recorded in the 1840's. These villagers not only considered themselves to be Macedonians, but believed through oral traditions, that they were the descendants of the ancient Macedonians...
This "ballad" and "their beliefs about who there were" was not a product of 19th century nationalism. In fact most of the same scholars argue that there was no 'Macedonian' nationalism until the early 20th century.
In this context, Indigen has a strong point.
What this example demonstrates is that people were calling themselves just Macedonians, and "believed" through their ballads and songs which were passed on orally (remember they were illiterate peasants) that they were "related" to the ancient Macedonians - before - modern nationalism.
It is a common belief among the university professors of Western institutions, that we have absolutely no claim to the ancient Macedonians, and furthermore, that our 'identity' is a construct, a result of nationalism.
None of these professors have ever bothered to actually familiarise themselves with Macedonian culture.
For example, one of the longest Macedonian ballads of Alexander the Great was first recorded in the 1840's. These villagers not only considered themselves to be Macedonians, but believed through oral traditions, that they were the descendants of the ancient Macedonians...
This "ballad" and "their beliefs about who there were" was not a product of 19th century nationalism. In fact most of the same scholars argue that there was no 'Macedonian' nationalism until the early 20th century.
In this context, Indigen has a strong point.
What this example demonstrates is that people were calling themselves just Macedonians, and "believed" through their ballads and songs which were passed on orally (remember they were illiterate peasants) that they were "related" to the ancient Macedonians - before - modern nationalism.