• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

Zoran Vraniskovski proposes Slav Macedonia

Bratot I think the ``continuation theories`` (of states and nations) are being labeled as absurd for a long time, at least by the academic community. They were dominant when nation-states started to form and that was in the end of the 18 and beginning of the 19 century. You, many others and even states (particularly in the Balkans) still try to cling on to such theories which supposedly are the corner-stone of every nation. We, the Macedonians are not excluded. We are just following our neighbors, trying to beat them in who will make a more stupid claim. The Greeks for example have `` our state is a continuation of the Ancient Greek state(which in fact never existed)`` while we have `` our state is a continuation of the Ancient Macedonian one``. Both claims are beyond reasoning even if we take your thoughts into consideration!! Here’s how you try to explain the existence of the Macedonian statehood trough the centuries:


That's how you perceive the history and claiming that something did not existed because of the lack of evidences doesn't also mean evidence of unexistence.

The history as a science is a selective one and the things we know are only fragments of a broader developments in the suggested period.

It's up to you and me how we can define those fragments on the assumption that they are only a slice of the whole circumstances.

Now I would like from you to explain how would this apply to the period from 146 BC up to 976 AD. That’s the period between the end of the Ancient Macedonian state and the beginning of the Tzar Samuil state. A period of about 11 centuries of occupation for the Macedonian people- as you put it!! Tell us how many organized resistance and rebellions were there in this huge period of 1100 years?


Enough to gain civil freedom and semi-authonomous rule under the Roman Empire.

http://books.google.com/books?id=K0...q=macedonian resistance against Roman&f=false


Also you can simply google for the: civil wars of the late Roman Republic.

Roman Empire can be defined as ancient federation, where Macedonia remained as a territorial unit.

With Justinian begins a new trend...
 
Last edited:
Buktop,

Read the books and you'll see for yourself - at the moment your "notions" are beyond ridiculous. Though, I'll give you credit for your most recent definition of a state where you finally acknowledge that the 1944 state was NOT the FIRST and hence you have gone against your Metovist tendancies.

I am asking for your opinion Vangelovski, not the opinion of a book. I will gladly read them once you can identify the differences in my notions and the authors.

You label my notions ridiculous, yet you are unable to substantiate your claims, or rather choose not to. Can you point to specific points in my notions that are ridiculous?

Once again, in a broader sense of the definition of State, we may label ancient entities as States, but this in no way connects the modern State with the Ancient. Even looking at historical contexts with modern concepts causes discrepancies. The Identity and the territory are proven to be continuous, evidence of a related line of States however is lacking.
 
Last edited:
I am asking for your opinion Vangelovski, not the opinion of a book. I will gladly read them once you can identify the differences in my notions and the authors.

You label my notions ridiculous, yet you are unable to substantiate your claims, or rather choose not to. Can you point to specific points in my notions that are ridiculous?

Once again, in a broader sense of the definition of State, we may label ancient entities as States, but this in no way connects the modern State with the Ancient. Even looking at historical contexts with modern concepts causes discrepancies. The Identity and the territory are proven to be continuous, evidence of a related line of States however is lacking.

Buktop,

First you claimed that you've read these books, now you say you'll only read them if I tell you which parts!?!?

Its difficult to be specific about which part of your idea of states and nations are wrong as you change your understanding with every post. And although your understanding changes, it does not improve. This is because you refuse to do any research, rather, you're relying on your own preconcieved (uninformed and ill-reasoned) ideas and attempting to defend Meto at the same time. In a nutshell, your understanding of what a state IS and what a nation IS, is funamendally wrong.

As I suggested in my post with the references to those books, you should read that first one - its nicely set out, providing short (1-3 pages) discussions on each key concept. You should read the section titled "State", its only 3 pages long. You can find the page number in at the front in the "Table of Contents". For further, and more detailed information, you should read the following books on states. The second half of that list relates to nations.

The good thing about these particular books, and most academic works, is that they don't only put forward their theories (however well-reasoned they may be), but they actually test them against real case studies and then have them peer reviewed (by critics). In contrast, when relying on Google information, most of it is garbage someone wrote off the top of their heads, which neither makes any sense or has any basis in reality. I think that is the most important thing that you need to know. That's why if you want to be serious in your debate, you should refer to scholarly work - not to 'look' smart, but to actually make sense.
 
Buktop
You asked for these reference materials, they have been provided so at the very least you should go and read them and then make your posts!
 
That says something about your opinion of this forum.. I did not know you knew everyone here so intricately.
What does it say? And why is it a concern (or suprise) for you that Rogi is familiar with others here so 'intricately'? Were you supposed to know?
Buktop said:
Officially meaning that we attained an independent state, before then there was no state, just like Greece only officially used the name Hellas in 1832......
Refer me to the evidence where there was a continued unofficial reference to Hellas or Hellenes prior to the 1800's, as this will validate your point about the parallel made with Greece.
Mastika said:
This was the case too in Albania, Greece of 1830, Bulgaria of 1878, however not to the extent as it was in Macedonia.
Macedonia was more diverse in 1900 than Greece was in 1830? Can you show me the population census', demographic statistics or any other material that corroborates your assertion?
Nonetheless, it is the word Macedonia which has gone down in history due to its diversity and cultural abundance.
That is one interpretation from people who didn't recognise the Macedonian identity, why are you espousing their arguments?
The state of Philip II was a state for the Ancient Macedonians, not what we are today, which is Modern Macedonians. We are our own people with our own customs, language, traditions, religion etc., however some of our descent lies with the Ancient Macedonians.
Whatever heritage there is of the ancient Macedonians in modern populations, cultural, genetic or otherwise, it is the Macedonians of today who carry the greatest share. I don't see a break, like you seem to do, I see evolution. Your efforts to distance the Macedonians of today from their history in the past, be it ancient or medieval, are misguided.
Marko was a medieval king ruling parts of Macedonia. He was not "the King of Macedonia" and was never titled as such.
Your technicalities are irrelevant, RoM is also "parts of Macedonia", yet still, a Macedonian state. Marko was indeed the king of Macedonia, irrespective if such a title wasn't in existence during that period, you may want to look a little deeper.
There were many medieval kings and princes who ruled over Macedonia, however none ruled the Kingdom of Macedonia.
Marko's was a kingdom in Macedonia, consisting of Macedonian territory, it wasn't a peripheral region that was ruled by somebody with no ties to the region.
What do I consider Krali Marko as? Hmm, Macedonian, Serbian, Bulgarian? None. The modern nation states which arose from the 18th-20th centuries simply did not exist in the 1300s. It would be wrong to associate any historical figure with a movement/nationalism that simply did not exist in their lifetime.
I don't cosider the Macedonian identity a "movement", I consider it a continued reality for centuries that has evolved over time, that has been overshadowed by other elements during certain periods, but one that has never died. I consider Marko a figure more relevant to Macedonians than any Serbs or Bulgars. His state was in Macedonia, his capital was in the Macedonian city of Prilep, his citizens and soldiers were therefore of Macedonia, he is also identified in church frescoes with Macedonian saints such as Clement of Ohrid. If any nation of today has a legitimate right to consider Marko an ancestor and significant part of their heritage, it is the Macedonians.
 
That's how you perceive the history and claiming that something did not existed because of the lack of evidences doesn't also mean evidence of unexistence.

The history as a science is a selective one and the things we know are only fragments of a broader developments in the suggested period.

It's up to you and me how we can define those fragments on the assumption that they are only a slice of the whole circumstances.


It’s true!! History is both selective and subjective! Still some subjective thoughts are in conflict with pure logic and rational way of thinking!! The ``continuation theories`` of the nation and state through time(as far as 300 or 500 BC) is one of them. Furthermore those are the theories in which the selective approach flourishes. Emphasizing one thing, while ``forgetting`` dozen others which contradict with it. Clinging on to them like ``davenik za stap `` is not something that a free mind should do.


Enough to gain civil freedom and semi-authonomous rule under the Roman Empire.

http://books.google.com/books?id=K0...q=macedonian resistance against Roman&f=false

Civil freedom yes, but as citizens of Rome, not of Macedonia!! They obeyed Roman laws, paid taxes to Rome etc. And Macedonia was never a semi-autonomous state. It was just a province governed by a Roman proconsul elected by the Roman Senate. So what kind of sovereignty did Macedonia had when it’s consuls were elected by the Roman senate??

And the link that you provided speaks about the period up to 148 BC. I was speaking about the period from 148 BC up to 972 AD. That's the period where your explanation doesn't make any sence.
 
Last edited:
Macedonia was more diverse in 1900 than Greece was in 1830? Can you show me the population census', demographic statistics or any other material that corroborates your assertion?

I managed to name over 20 cultural/religious groups living in the Macedonia of 1900. As for those who lived in Greece of 1830; Orthodox Greeks, Muslims Turks, Orthodox Albanians/Arvanites, Muslim Greeks, Orthodox Aromanians (if there were any in the extreme north of the country), Catholic Greeks, Jewish Romaniots and Orthodox Armenians. Have I missed any out? I do not have time to go trawling through the internet looking for sources, however I am sure that you will bombard me with many showing the truly Albanian nature of the Greek state etc. etc. My point is that Macedonia of 1900 was less ethnically homogenous in regards to the number of different cultures coexisting and operating (not like in the case of Greece of 1830 where is was largely Greek with some Albanian).

Although I do not like it, the Wikipedia page [Demographic history of Macedonia] gives a number of different views regarding the ethnic composition of Macedonia at the time and will save me listing them all here.

That is one interpretation from people who didn't recognise the Macedonian identity, why are you espousing their arguments?

What argument? That Macedonia was a "mixed salad"? It has been for hundreds of years and hopefully will always be. Are you suggesting that it is not a 'mixed salad'?

Whatever heritage there is of the ancient Macedonians in modern populations, cultural, genetic or otherwise, it is the Macedonians of today who carry the greatest share. I don't see a break, like you seem to do, I see evolution. Your efforts to distance the Macedonians of today from their history in the past, be it ancient or medieval, are misguided.

You are right about us having the greatest share of the legacy of the Ancient Macedonians. Does this make them us? No. We are own people only partly descended from them with our own language and culture, these people lived 2000 years ago for heavens sake. Should we be proud of them? Yes, of course they are apart of our history. Should we live in their shadow? No, we have no reason to live in the shadow of a people who disapeared thousands of years ago. I reject the notion of some claiming that we are the direct and "cisti" descendants of these people. Interesting how we try to avoid claiming descent from less glorious nations who ruled over Macedonia, sadly many people are obsessed with competing with the prostotija which is espoused by many Greeks, in some sort of attempt of proving how much older/better we are then them, when in reality we should look to the present rather then the past to do this.

Your technicalities are irrelevant, RoM is also "parts of Macedonia", yet still, a Macedonian state. Marko was indeed the king of Macedonia, irrespective if such a title wasn't in existence during that period, you may want to look a little deeper.

In the case of titles technicalities are relevant. Marko was the King of Prilep and ruled that Kingdom. The only such Kingdom of Macedonia/Macedon was the one that existed in the ancient era. As for your RoM example, Mount Athos could declare independance tomorrow it too would be a "Macedonian state", but unlike RoM it wouldn't be an "ethnic Macedonian State".

Marko's was a kingdom in Macedonia, consisting of Macedonian territory, it wasn't a peripheral region that was ruled by somebody with no ties to the region.

Stefan Dushan's capital was in the Macedonian city of Skopje. He proclaimed himself emperor in Ser. Does this mean that he was somebody with no ties to the region? Does this mean he was ethnically Macedonian? No, such a concept didn't exist back then. Neither did other modern concepts of nationalism such as being "ethnically Greek" or "ethnically Bulgarian" (before somebody accuses me of working for their interests). Constantine Dragas probably ruled a similar amount of Macedonia as did Krale Marko, we dont suddenly claim direct descendence from his realm either.

I don't cosider the Macedonian identity a "movement", I consider it a continued reality for centuries that has evolved over time, that has been overshadowed by other elements during certain periods, but one that has never died. I consider Marko a figure more relevant to Macedonians than any Serbs or Bulgars. His state was in Macedonia, his capital was in the Macedonian city of Prilep, his citizens and soldiers were therefore of Macedonia, he is also identified in church frescoes with Macedonian saints such as Clement of Ohrid. If any nation of today has a legitimate right to consider Marko an ancestor and significant part of their heritage, it is the Macedonians.

Of course he is relevant to us, our nation state occupies the area which his realm did 600 years ago. I am not suggesting that we shouldn't be proud of him however I am suggesting that we should treat him as a medieval Macedonian, not an 'ethnic Macedonian', there is a difference. Ideologies such as Macedonism/Macedonian nationalism, Serbian nationalism etc. etc. simply did not exist back then and it is these ideas that have given rise to people calling themselves 'ethnically this' or 'ethnically that'.

I disagree with you in regards to Macedonian identity as not being a movement. Personally I believe that the nationalism/ethnic identity assertion of the past/present will eventually give way to much broader identifiers which is already happening in many parts of the world for example. 1. due to mass intermarriage between different groups and 2. the arising of pan-ethnicity and regional affiliation above that of national ones. All movements run their course (nationalism being one) and if conflict doesn't break out to reassert this nationalism and patriotism (as is the case across history), there is no reason to suggest that maybe in 100 years time our great-grandchildren will identify firstly not as ethnically this or that but as "European", "Australian", "American".
 
It’s true!! History is both selective and subjective! Still some subjective thoughts are in conflict with pure logic and rational way of thinking!! The ``continuation theories`` of the nation and state through time(as far as 300 or 500 BC) is one of them. Furthermore those are the theories in which the selective approach flourishes. Emphasizing one thing, while ``forgetting`` dozen others which contradict with it.

If you pay attention to most of European states there is a same continuity, if you want take the German tribal states, Polabians, Gauls, Romans, I'm not advocating special status of some national-state of ours but why would we be the exception?

I have the right to flourish my selective approach, if you want to follow Greek approach it is your choice.


Civil freedom yes, but as citizens of Rome, not of Macedonia!! They obeyed Roman laws, paid taxes to Rome etc. And Macedonia was never a semi-autonomous state. It was just a province governed by a Roman proconsul elected by the Roman Senate. So what kind of sovereignty did Macedonia had when it’s consuls were elected by the Roman senate??

There were Macedonians involved in the administration and Macedonia was divided into 4 republics with the duty of paying tax and millitary support.

You have dozens of generals and later even Emperors originated from Macedonian soil.

The term Romans as citizens was only a political term, but if you start reading some of the sources there is clear ethnic differentiation.

And the link that you provided speaks about the period up to 148 BC. I was speaking about the period from 148 BC up to 972 AD. That's the period where your explanation doesn't make any sence.

I provided only a start point for you but I got the feeling that you haven't read the whole text properly.

However you may go now with the marble from Isar Marvinci which stands in front of the Government:

gredaipasko1.JPG


"MAKEDONIARHΩNTON NAONTHPATRIDI
PANTITΩKOΣMO TO ΘKT ETEI".

meaning:

"To Macedonian kings, a shrine of the Fatherland
from the whole nation"

That was a marblestone from the shrine/temple in 329 year or first half of the 4 century A.D.(officially) or according to Kamburovski year 56-65 A.D.; dedicated to the great Macedonian kings and represents a symbol of pride and disobeying.
 
Mastika said:
I do not have time to go trawling through the internet looking for sources........
But you have the time to go 'trawling' through the forums making such statements? Show some principle and corroborate your statements.
...........in the case of Greece of 1830 where is was largely Greek with some Albanian).
Another fantastic statement. You are either extremely uninformed, or Greek, or both.
What argument? That Macedonia was a "mixed salad"? It has been for hundreds of years and hopefully will always be. Are you suggesting that it is not a 'mixed salad'?
I am suggesting that it is not as 'mixed' a salad as has been assumed by foreigners. You, on the other hand, have bought the stories of foreigners over your own people, hook, line and sinker, either that, or you are on some sort of agenda. Your understanding of Macedonian history is naive.
I reject the notion of some claiming that we are the direct and "cisti" descendants of these people.
So do I, as it isn't possible to be directly descended from populations that lived thousands of years ago. Our difference is that I still consider the heritage we have from them as significant, whereas you seem to consider it irrelevant.
In the case of titles technicalities are relevant. Marko was the King of Prilep and ruled that Kingdom.
Mate, don't waste my time by playing word games, your point of argument is irrelevant. There is no title called "King of Prilep" either, and Marko was king of much more than Prilep, you obviously don't know much about Macedonian history during that or any other period.
As for your RoM example, Mount Athos could declare independance tomorrow it too would be a "Macedonian state", but unlike RoM it wouldn't be an "ethnic Macedonian State".
Another irrelevant comparison, with which you're implying that the ancestors of the Macedonians, the people who spoke our language, who practiced our culture and religion, etc, did not exist in Marko's kingdom. You clearly have no clue, and I am starting to realise this with each of your replies.
Stefan Dushan's capital was in the Macedonian city of Skopje. He proclaimed himself emperor in Ser. Does this mean that he was somebody with no ties to the region? Does this mean he was ethnically Macedonian?
Macedonia was a peripheral territory that was absorbed into Dushan's empire, someone who had no prior ties to the region. Marko's kingdom was solely based in Macedonia, his mother was from the greater region, his father and uncle ruled there before him. Have a closer look at all of the particulars before you continue to utter ignorance.
I am suggesting that we should treat him as a medieval Macedonian, not an 'ethnic Macedonian', there is a difference.
I don't need your opinion for confirmation that differences exist between the people of the medieval period and today. The issue here is that you're using elements of the modern interpretation of 'ethnicity' to diminish the significance of Macedonia's heritage.
I disagree with you in regards to Macedonian identity as not being a movement.
The Macedonians asserting their identity during efforts at gaining liberty, self-empowerment, etc was a movement, the Macedonian identity itself is not a movement, it is a historical reality to all Macedonians, except those like you who are so sure of Greece's 'homogenous' population yet so quick to comment against any Macedonian demonstrating an established link to our historical past.
 
I managed to name over 20 cultural/religious groups living in the Macedonia of 1900. As for those who lived in Greece of 1830; Orthodox Greeks, Muslims Turks, Orthodox Albanians/Arvanites, Muslim Greeks, Orthodox Aromanians (if there were any in the extreme north of the country), Catholic Greeks, Jewish Romaniots and Orthodox Armenians. Have I missed any out? I do not have time to go trawling through the internet looking for sources, however I am sure that you will bombard me with many showing the truly Albanian nature of the Greek state etc. etc. My point is that Macedonia of 1900 was less ethnically homogenous in regards to the number of different cultures coexisting and operating (not like in the case of Greece of 1830 where is was largely Greek with some Albanian).

Although I do not like it, the Wikipedia page [Demographic history of Macedonia] gives a number of different views regarding the ethnic composition of Macedonia at the time and will save me listing them all here.



What argument? That Macedonia was a "mixed salad"? It has been for hundreds of years and hopefully will always be. Are you suggesting that it is not a 'mixed salad'?



You are right about us having the greatest share of the legacy of the Ancient Macedonians. Does this make them us? No. We are own people only partly descended from them with our own language and culture, these people lived 2000 years ago for heavens sake. Should we be proud of them? Yes, of course they are apart of our history. Should we live in their shadow? No, we have no reason to live in the shadow of a people who disapeared thousands of years ago. I reject the notion of some claiming that we are the direct and "cisti" descendants of these people. Interesting how we try to avoid claiming descent from less glorious nations who ruled over Macedonia, sadly many people are obsessed with competing with the prostotija which is espoused by many Greeks, in some sort of attempt of proving how much older/better we are then them, when in reality we should look to the present rather then the past to do this.



In the case of titles technicalities are relevant. Marko was the King of Prilep and ruled that Kingdom. The only such Kingdom of Macedonia/Macedon was the one that existed in the ancient era. As for your RoM example, Mount Athos could declare independance tomorrow it too would be a "Macedonian state", but unlike RoM it wouldn't be an "ethnic Macedonian State".



Stefan Dushan's capital was in the Macedonian city of Skopje. He proclaimed himself emperor in Ser. Does this mean that he was somebody with no ties to the region? Does this mean he was ethnically Macedonian? No, such a concept didn't exist back then. Neither did other modern concepts of nationalism such as being "ethnically Greek" or "ethnically Bulgarian" (before somebody accuses me of working for their interests). Constantine Dragas probably ruled a similar amount of Macedonia as did Krale Marko, we dont suddenly claim direct descendence from his realm either.



Of course he is relevant to us, our nation state occupies the area which his realm did 600 years ago. I am not suggesting that we shouldn't be proud of him however I am suggesting that we should treat him as a medieval Macedonian, not an 'ethnic Macedonian', there is a difference. Ideologies such as Macedonism/Macedonian nationalism, Serbian nationalism etc. etc. simply did not exist back then and it is these ideas that have given rise to people calling themselves 'ethnically this' or 'ethnically that'.

I disagree with you in regards to Macedonian identity as not being a movement. Personally I believe that the nationalism/ethnic identity assertion of the past/present will eventually give way to much broader identifiers which is already happening in many parts of the world for example. 1. due to mass intermarriage between different groups and 2. the arising of pan-ethnicity and regional affiliation above that of national ones. All movements run their course (nationalism being one) and if conflict doesn't break out to reassert this nationalism and patriotism (as is the case across history), there is no reason to suggest that maybe in 100 years time our great-grandchildren will identify firstly not as ethnically this or that but as "European", "Australian", "American".

Look stop playing make believe. We know you're a imposter hellene. It's sad you people always have to play make believe, don't you think? You make believe you're descendents of the ancient hellenes, you make believe you're descendents of the ancient Macedonians, and now you're making believe that you're a Macedonian. Isn't it sad that your toilet bowl state is chin deep in financial collapse and you're here posing as one of us? All because this is how you are brought up from birth. To live in a lie and in other peoples shadows. Another notch on the headboard of greatness for the counterfeit hellenes, yet again.
 
TM,

I would hope it is a Greek pretending to be Macedonian, which would explain their (predictable) naivety about Macedonian (and Greek, for that matter) history, rather than an actual Macedonian who supports such ridiculous notions.
 
I don't think he is Greek, but he needs to further study our history. Macedonia was overwhelmingly populated by Macedonians, and like most flurishing regions of the empire, had elements of many ethnic communities.

The 'Macedonian salad' reference is a foreign one that a) was introduced by foreign western forces after their increased interest and involvement in the region; b) represents the suppression of the Macedonian people and their voice; c) is indicative of neighbouring aspirations and strateigies in the country; d) is a satirical description of the absurdity of the situation caused by the previous 3 points.
 
I am suggesting that we should treat him as a medieval Macedonian, not an 'ethnic Macedonian', there is a difference. Ideologies such as Macedonism/Macedonian nationalism, Serbian nationalism etc. etc. simply did not exist back then and it is these ideas that have given rise to people calling themselves 'ethnically this' or 'ethnically that'.

Mastika, today's Macedonians are the sole inheritors of everything Macedonian. Identities change and evolve, however who has a right to our forefathers past?
 
Look stop playing make believe. We know you're a imposter hellene. It's sad you people always have to play make believe, don't you think? You make believe you're descendents of the ancient hellenes, you make believe you're descendents of the ancient Macedonians, and now you're making believe that you're a Macedonian. Isn't it sad that your toilet bowl state is chin deep in financial collapse and you're here posing as one of us? All because this is how you are brought up from birth. To live in a lie and in other peoples shadows. Another notch on the headboard of greatness for the counterfeit hellenes, yet again.

Look I am not Greek and have nothing at all to do with Greece. I can see how some of my comments may have been taken that way, I do apologise if that is how they may have come across. What I do like to see however is history to be shown without bias or strong influence from nationalism and patriotism (I know that this is hard). A non-biased history is the best history, sadly the Balkans is such a petty region that this is not possible. Hopefully this bickering will one day end and maybe the people of the Balkans can work together. And I know that this requires Greece and Bulgaria to get their heads of their arses so to speak and show some respect towards the Macedonian people. However it does not help if we lower our historical standards and knowledge to a level parallel to theirs. Why should we degrade ourselves just to make a point to some Greeks? Who gives a f*&k what the Greeks or Bulgarians think?! I'm not going to say things just to compete with the "historical" bullshit which comes out of Athens every year for the sake of it.

Look from now on i'll stick to social issues, clearly an opinion about history which strays from the Aleksandar Donski style - Македонизам is not accepted here.
 
Mastika said:
However it does not help if we lower our historical standards and knowledge to a level parallel to theirs.
How have I done that?
Look from now on i'll stick to social issues, clearly an opinion about history which strays from the Aleksandar Donski style - Македонизам is not accepted here.
What a terribly inaccurate, and stupidly moronic thing to write. You are starting to sound even more 'Greek'.
 
ps. everyone keeps questioning me about who has the right to inherit the history of the people who lived in macedonia in the past. The Macedonian people do of course, however what I am saying I do not feel it is correct to label people from the past as belonging to a certain ethnic group when such a notion was not present in their lifetime, this goes for all histories. This is what our neighbours have done and this is why their history is generally bullshit in a textual form.
 
Buktop,

First you claimed that you've read these books, now you say you'll only read them if I tell you which parts!?!?
I said I had read some of the authors works, not that I had read all the references you posted. I asked you to point out the differences in my notions in comparison to those of the authors so I would have a better idea of what to identify when reading. If my notions and there's are the same then why should I waste what little free time I have confirming my own notions?

Its difficult to be specific about which part of your idea of states and nations are wrong as you change your understanding with every post. And although your understanding changes, it does not improve. This is because you refuse to do any research, rather, you're relying on your own preconcieved (uninformed and ill-reasoned) ideas and attempting to defend Meto at the same time. In a nutshell, your understanding of what a state IS and what a nation IS, is funamendally wrong.
My understanding of the words and concepts have not changed throughout my posts in this thread, I would ask you to please identify where they have. If my idea's are so ill-reasoned and uninformed, then it should not be difficult to state your opinion or view of how my notions differ from the authors.

As I suggested in my post with the references to those books, you should read that first one - its nicely set out, providing short (1-3 pages) discussions on each key concept. You should read the section titled "State", its only 3 pages long. You can find the page number in at the front in the "Table of Contents". For further, and more detailed information, you should read the following books on states. The second half of that list relates to nations.
Thanks, I will look into it when I get the time. But I still asked for your detailed opinion, and I don't think that is too much to ask, considering that you are qualified in the area of Nations and States.

The good thing about these particular books, and most academic works, is that they don't only put forward their theories (however well-reasoned they may be), but they actually test them against real case studies and then have them peer reviewed (by critics). In contrast, when relying on Google information, most of it is garbage someone wrote off the top of their heads, which neither makes any sense or has any basis in reality. I think that is the most important thing that you need to know. That's why if you want to be serious in your debate, you should refer to scholarly work - not to 'look' smart, but to actually make sense.
I said look to google books, which may have made your search for the scholarly works easier, like this book that you recommended. It offers a good general preview, although slightly limited, but allows access to key information contained in the works. I did not say to just google state and post me the first site that pops up. It took me all of 5 minutes to locate all the references you posted. It would be wise to utilize the wonders of modern technology, it might make your life easier.

Heywood, A., 2000, Key Concepts in Politics, Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke.

http://books.google.com/books?id=ai...DCS6PfBqOKzASCqMjaCA&cd=1#v=onepage&q&f=false


In this particular Google Book, the chapter on State is provided, and the definition is as follows,

The state can most simply be defined as a political association that establishes sovereign jurisdiction within a defined territorial borders and exercises *authority through a set of permanent institutions. It is possible to identify five key features of the state. First, the state exercises *sovereignty - it exercises absolute and unrestricted *power in that it stands above all other associations and groups in society; Thomas Hobbes (1588-1679), for this reason, portrayed the state as a 'leviathan', a gigantic monster. Second, state institutions are recognisably 'public', in contrast to the 'private' institutions of *civil society - state bodies are responsible for making and enforcing collective decisions in society and are funded at the public's expense. Third, the state is an exercise in legitimation - its decisions are usually (although not necessarily) accepted as binding on its citizens because, it is claimed, it reflects the permanent interests of society. Fourth, the state is an instrument in domination - it possesses the coercive power to ensure that its *laws are obeyed and that transgressors are punished; as Max Weber (1864-1920) put it, the state has a monopoly of the means of 'legitimate violence'. Fifth, the state is a territorial association - it exercises jurisdiction within a geographically defined borders and in international politics is treated (at least in theory) as an autonomous entity.
Now tell me how my notions differ from those of this scholarly work.
 
What a terribly inaccurate, and stupidly moronic thing to write. You are starting to sound even more 'Greek'.

Hey I tried to word it diplomatically. From what i can see that is the type of history favoured here, that is fine by me. I have no objections to people holding that view.
 
Look I am not Greek and have nothing at all to do with Greece. I can see how some of my comments may have been taken that way, I do apologise if that is how they may have come across. What I do like to see however is history to be shown without bias or strong influence from nationalism and patriotism (I know that this is hard). A non-biased history is the best history, sadly the Balkans is such a petty region that this is not possible. Hopefully this bickering will one day end and maybe the people of the Balkans can work together. And I know that this requires Greece and Bulgaria to get their heads of their arses so to speak and show some respect towards the Macedonian people. However it does not help if we lower our historical standards and knowledge to a level parallel to theirs. Why should we degrade ourselves just to make a point to some Greeks? Who gives a f*&k what the Greeks or Bulgarians think?! I'm not going to say things just to compete with the "historical" bullshit which comes out of Athens every year for the sake of it.

Look from now on i'll stick to social issues, clearly an opinion about history which strays from the Aleksandar Donski style - Македонизам is not accepted here.


And how about giving a full answer what you are since you claim something else?


For those who haven't came accross your multipli forum personalities I'm introducing you the Bulgarian stipendist from Macedonian origin whose real name doesn't really matter, it's enough to explain him as the mental twin of Vasilije Gligorijevic.
 
Back
Top