Quote for me where I said the FIRST Macedonian state was created in 1944... Current or Modern are the terms I have used, and in the context of the statement you found controversial about Macedonia officially being used since 44, it is a valid statement. Regardless of the existence of a Macedonian "State" in antiquity, there is a period of several centuries in between that, where a Macedonian "State" does not exist.Buktop,
As usual, the discussion cannot go into any real substance because you are too busy spamming the thread with contradictory, confusing and irrelevant definitions. The majority of the posters here have taken nearly 40 pages to explain to you that the 1944 state was NOT the FIRST MACEDONIAN STATE, nor was it the FIRST Macedonian state to use the name MACEDONIA, which is in fact the topic of discussion. Yet, you are unable to even get that far because you are still trying to muddy the waters around the definition of a state. Maybe you could spend the next 40 pages trying to work out what the concept of FIRST means...?
A holistic picture of nothing, especially since I haven't even said anything about Tito nor have I involved him in any aspect of the founding of our State.As for the Tito quote, I wouldn't want to take your obsession with Macedonia '44 out of context, hence I included it to provide a more holistic picture.
The quote itself talks about the "brotherhood and unity" (or bratstvo i jedinstvo) of the peopleS - plural. How is that relevant to the Macedonian people - singular? Or are you referring to a unity between Macedonians and some other people? UMD certainly believes that we have a shared culture, history and geography with the Greeks - is that what you have in mind?
Rather than altering the quote, I let it stand as it was. I viewed it as applying to Vardar, Egej and Pirin peoples or a divided Macedonian people.
So given that I have not even mentioned Tito or Yugoslavia anywhere in this thread in the context of our State, and in fact, even went out of my way to highlight that Independence and the founding of the state were completely Macedonian initiatives, why would you bother to bring this quote up? Do you really hate me so much that you would go to any lengths to disprove my argument, or do you just like spitting on one of the most important events in recent Macedonian history?