• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

Ivo Petkovski - The Traitor

IP

This is some absurd logic. We are "fanatical" because we exist, but Greece isn't despite its manifestly racist ideology towards Macedonians. Aren't your EU discrimination laws also supposed to guard against discrimination against Macedonians as well? On this note, what concessions exactly has Greece given to its Macedonian minority?

Macedonians aren't "aggravating" anybody by simply existing as Macedonians, rather the issue is Greece's inherent racism. Maybe they should be a bit more "pragmatic" as a modern state and afford Macedonians all of their human rights.

I don't think Greece has accepted our name ever, but even if it did, it's not as if it is a right they have to offer us such a "concession", they are basically irrlevant, we have a right to self identification

"I’m definitely no Greek advocate " - is this line a joke?

You are lost cause. Compromise your own identity, not mine.
 
Ivo,

Reading your post is absolutely mind-boggling.

It seems that you start with the premise that the purpose of existence is to join the EU and that Macedonia should presuppose vassal status as the norm. It also seems that you presuppose that Macedonians do not have an inherent right to exist as a nation.

It seems that the concepts of national sovereignty and the citizens as the ultimate source of political power are completely lost on you. It seems that you consider Macedonia to be a vassal province under the sovereign rule of other foreign governments who can do with our people as they choose.

As a result, it seems that you have readily accepted that Greece has some inherent right to determine our political status and identity (Interim Accord).

Another mindboggling assumption is that Greece has some how made a "concession". How can someone make a "concession" when they have no ownership of, or right to, the very "concession" they are supposedly making?

Finally, explain how the name "Republic of Northern Macedonia" is not renaming our state. Explain how this is not an attack on our identity or how it will prevent the defacto renaming of our people into "Northern Macedonians". Explain how this is not an abolition of our national sovereingty.
 
Vidi vidi, members of the MTO invite this individual Ivo for a discussion regarding his article, and what is the outcome? Bloody abuse by voshkari hiding behind pseudonyms, is this how you hypocrites behave in normal life? Invite someone over for a kafe and beat the living daylights out of ‘em? The Frank character should be banned for threatening to kill someone.
 
Vidi vidi, members of the MTO invite this individual Ivo for a discussion regarding his article, and what is the outcome? Bloody abuse by voshkari hiding behind pseudonyms, is this how you hypocrites behave in normal life? Invite someone over for a kafe and beat the living daylights out of ‘em? The Frank character should be banned for threatening to kill someone.

Boge,

You may be using a pseudonym, but I certainly am not.

Were you the "gansta" from the Gong? Or have I got you mixed up with someone else?
 
Thanks for the invite. Found this by googling my Macedonia blog and then saw you’d sent an invite to my Facebook, which I never open. Well now that I have found it, I’ll try to respond to some of the points here.

@RistoTheGreat, you say:



The Ohrid agreement and the constitutional amendments in 1995 were excellent steps for the Macedonian government, but more and more they are coming to seem like isolated incidents when the Macedonians have been anything less than completely unwilling to compromise. My concern is - how does this look from the outside? Greece have made numerous concessions over the years, the biggest one of course being the name ‘Macedonia’ itself. The argument was won then, and we won - rightly so.

I’m definitely no Greek advocate - I think the problem mostly emanates from Greek insecurity, but if we’re honest, the Macedonians aggravate the issue with our own considerable insecurities. I don’t think we need to be - we are now Macedonians, and the smallest compromise at the end of the process (i.e. Northern Macedonia) not only sends a message that the Macedonians know that nationalist chest-thumping isn’t what a modern European state does, but it also puts a (relatively) amicable end to this ridiculous dispute.

Then Greece would have no need to keep vetoing us from the EU. I said in the article that accession would help with bringing us up to European standard in representation for the Roma and Albanians - I know that the Ohrid agreement accommodated the Macedonian Albanians, but what’s needed is enforced legislation against systematic discrimination, across every layer of RoM society. Eventually, that’s what EU participation will bring. If any of you have ever set foot in Skopje, or Bitola, or anywhere in Macedonia you’ll know that hatred of Cigani and Shiptars is the norm for almost everyone. That’s what we need to move past if we’re ever going to be a successful 21st Century nation.

@Pluto & Bratot

I’m not the guy in the YouTube clip, but I just watched it. Violeta Ackovska is a dishonest debater - every time that other guy says anything, she accuses him of ‘caricaturing’ and then says what she was going to say anyway.

I agree with her that I don’t want anyone renaming me - but that danger passed in 1995 when the Greeks had to concede the name Macedonia. Right now the worst thing that could happen is that some smaller countries would have the name in official documents as ‘Republic of Northern Macedonia’.

And if we went this route, we’d have shown the world that we know how a modern state acts towards other states - by being pragmatic, instead of fanatical.

IvoPetkovski
Firstly :welcome to the MTO!
Thank you for responding to the request and posting here at the forum.
The name dispute is a highly charged and emotionally sensitive issue and as such you will see comments here that are also highly charged and emotional. I would ask that, as a professional, you take these in your stride and respond to as many questions as possible.
Looking forward to your posts!
 
Greece have made numerous concessions over the years, the biggest one of course being the name ‘Macedonia’ itself. The argument was won then, and we won - rightly so.

Hello Ivo, thanks for coming over. Could you please expand on this point. What concessions has Greece made regarding the name Macedonia? And what other concessions have they made? How would you verbalise the expected concessions that RoM is supposed to make? And in your mind, how do these concessions relate to the Greek ones, in terms of gravitas and consequences?
 
Thanks for the invite. Found this by googling my Macedonia blog and then saw you’d sent an invite to my Facebook, which I never open. Well now that I have found it, I’ll try to respond to some of the points here.

@RistoTheGreat, you say:



The Ohrid agreement and the constitutional amendments in 1995 were excellent steps for the Macedonian government, but more and more they are coming to seem like isolated incidents when the Macedonians have been anything less than completely unwilling to compromise. My concern is - how does this look from the outside? Greece have made numerous concessions over the years, the biggest one of course being the name ‘Macedonia’ itself. The argument was won then, and we won - rightly so.

I’m definitely no Greek advocate - I think the problem mostly emanates from Greek insecurity, but if we’re honest, the Macedonians aggravate the issue with our own considerable insecurities. I don’t think we need to be - we are now Macedonians, and the smallest compromise at the end of the process (i.e. Northern Macedonia) not only sends a message that the Macedonians know that nationalist chest-thumping isn’t what a modern European state does, but it also puts a (relatively) amicable end to this ridiculous dispute.

Then Greece would have no need to keep vetoing us from the EU. I said in the article that accession would help with bringing us up to European standard in representation for the Roma and Albanians - I know that the Ohrid agreement accommodated the Macedonian Albanians, but what’s needed is enforced legislation against systematic discrimination, across every layer of RoM society. Eventually, that’s what EU participation will bring. If any of you have ever set foot in Skopje, or Bitola, or anywhere in Macedonia you’ll know that hatred of Cigani and Shiptars is the norm for almost everyone. That’s what we need to move past if we’re ever going to be a successful 21st Century nation.

@Pluto & Bratot

I’m not the guy in the YouTube clip, but I just watched it. Violeta Ackovska is a dishonest debater - every time that other guy says anything, she accuses him of ‘caricaturing’ and then says what she was going to say anyway.

I agree with her that I don’t want anyone renaming me - but that danger passed in 1995 when the Greeks had to concede the name Macedonia. Right now the worst thing that could happen is that some smaller countries would have the name in official documents as ‘Republic of Northern Macedonia’.

And if we went this route, we’d have shown the world that we know how a modern state acts towards other states - by being pragmatic, instead of fanatical.

Ivo, welcome to this forum. You clearly are a Greek advocate. We are yet to determine how much of an advocate you are but you are fueling the misguided Greek justifications in relation to Macedonia. Your suggestion that Macedonia has already had a "win" with the Greek concession is disturbing. It suggests we Macedonians are lucky to be calling ourselves Macedonians.

You say the Ohrid agreement and the constitutional amendments are excellent steps for the Macedonian government. Do you actually know the content and nature of these changes? I will assume you do. Given your affirmation of the Ohrid agreement and the constitutional amendments, it means you embrace the notion that the will of the Macedonian people (in both an ethnic and national sense) is now strangled by the ethnic Albanian minority. You do understand how their vote means more than the Macedonian vote don't you?

Is it fanatical to insist that Macedonia's future is controlled by Macedonians? If this seems a reasonable notion to you, then you are being naive and quite frankly destructive to Macedonia as a result of your ignorance.

Your hyperbole about the EU does not sit well with me. I have seen how Macedonians and Romani are treated in Greece. Greece is in the EU last time I looked.
Right now the worst thing that could happen is that some smaller countries would have the name in official documents as ‘Republic of Northern Macedonia’
That would not mean much to you. But I disagree, the worst thing that happens is that other people have forced you to accept a name change. That somehow you don't qualify to name yourself. That chest beating is not allowed in this modern age by people who are not afforded the same rights as everyone else. You have suggested "smaller" countries would be tempted to use something like "Republic of Northern Macedonia". Do you mean little countries like Germany, France, USA, UK, etc? I think most of these little countries managed to lie their way into the EU and will probably insist on calling Macedonia by whatever people like you agree with. Of course the USA is not in the EU but they have already stated they will call Macedonia whatever it agrees it will change its name to. Is there any bigger countries that will continue to call us Macedonia and Macedonians? I might have missed some. Hey, maybe Albania will call us Macedonia .... or Eastern Albania.

My people funnily enough are Macedonians who come from what is now Greece. Should I call myself Northern Macedonian thanks to your little concession? If I don't, there will be room for confusion on the matter. Especially once the "smaller" countries (Germany, France, USA, UK, etc) start calling us Northern Macedonians or whatever.

I note you chose not to comment on the following issues I raised in an earlier post:
- Accession to the EU being absolutely measurable.
- What is the maddening uncertainty over Macedonia's official legitimacy as a state?
- Define the ultra-nationalistic sentiment.

You seem to be so excited about the EU that you simply cannot fathom any other way for Macedonia. See here how Slovenia (and Slovakia) feel about the EU:
http://macedoniantruth.org/forum/showthread.php?t=3900
Is this one of the limitless benefits Macedonia will be subjected to as well?

What you appear to equate with chest-beating, I actually believe with all of my heart is standing up for your rights. I also equate it more with the actions of Mohandas Gandhi than with the negative connotations you have cast over all Macedonians.

Actually you are a Greek advocate of the highest order. If you want to oppose a more Macedonian focused perspective, you should inform yourself of the issues at hand before commenting on them publicly. But I suspect you are a recipient of some Greek "inspiration" that is usually found in plastic bags. If you can restrain yourself from being the Macedonian devil's advocate for a minute or two, please inform yourself of the real matters at hand before replying.

How do I get to write rubbish articles in the Guardian? I can guarantee they will make more sense than the recent Petkovski one.
 
Ivo, the poster of your messages here appears to have a UK IP address. I will assume it is really you posting on this forum for now.
 
Ivo Petkovski (if that is your real name),

I don't know where to start in expressing disgust with what you have written. So, for now, I will only say that your attempts to justify blatant capitulation to racist terrorists (in the form of the Framework Agreement) and to Greek racist attacks on the human rights and freedoms of the Macedonian people and on the sovereignty of the citizens of the Republic of Macedonia, by blaming and vilifying the victim, should raise some serious questions about your motives and your agenda. I would find it much easier to engage in civil discourse with you if you didn't carry a Macedonian name. This way, I feel like I would be wasting valuable time and words on somebody who knows the truth very well, but insists on making fools of us, in pursuit of a hidden agenda.
 
Ivo, You spoke about concessions, what about our concessions? We changed our flag,constitution and name, do you see how obsurd this is??

We have made more then enough changes and its time we stood up for what is right, Greece is a bankrupt country they got no business in tell us how we should be called.
 
Ivo Petkovski wrote;

Right now the worst thing that could happen is that some smaller countries would have the name in official documents as ‘Republic of Northern Macedonia’

A bit of historical context I hope you will take a few minutes to read.

The idea that there are 'No Macedonians'

In the early 20th century a Serbian ethnographer put foward a compelling proposition. He said that the 'Macedonians' are neither Greeks, or Bulgarians, but neither are they Macedonians - he proposed that they were 'Slavs' with no identity.

Greek historiography, and the official position of the Hellenic Republic with regards to Macedonians today, is that they do not exist. They will argue that there were no Macedonians, and that it was neither a political, nor a cultural, or linguistic entity. The region they argue was inhabited by ethnic Greeks, and ethnic Bulgarians, but no Macedonians. This is still their position.

If the Macedonians add a geographic qualifier to the name of their State, it will be fulfilling the conquest of the New Greeks and Bulgarians, both of who accept that there is a Macedonia (a geography), but no distinct to unique 'Macedonians' - these they argue are ethnic Greeks and Bulgarians.

With this important historical fact in mind, consider what your proposal to change it to geographical means for our identity - our historical and political identity, given we are surrounded by neighbours who say we do not exist.

It would demonstrate that you were in fact (whether you were conscously aware of it or not), working to help the New Greeks complete their conquest, of appropriation.

The 'negotiaton process'

In 1912 and 1913 the Hellenic Republic, seized, through the use of force, Macedonian territory. It ended our existence as a nation. Their intentions were hostile. The Macedonian were specifically targeted for extermination. A quick look at the intentions of Prime Minister Tracoupis, in 1898, reveals all. It managed to use various wars, and internal 'civil' strife to disposses the Macedonians, and colonise the region with 'Greeks' loyal to the Greek state. The dispossession and colonization of Macedonia was financed by the League of Nations, which also provided expertise in the form of project management resources, for the conquest.

1944

The emergence of one part of the divided nation in 1944, changed the nature of the conquest.

This was because the partition was illegal, and the Greek claims to title and possession, highly suspect. The re-emergence of a unified Polish nation in the 18th century repudiated the right of conquest, which the Hellenic Republic uses as the legal basis of its 'right' to territory, and subjects, i.e., the Macedonians.

In international law, in moral law - the Macedonians in the Macedonian Republic have a legitimate right to claim their lands back, whether they explicitly do or not. This is why the Hellenic Republic will not accept a change in the Constitution withdrawing territorical pretension, because the Hellenic Republic understands fully what its legal position is regarding its acquisition of territory, and treatment of the natives, i.e., Macedonians. The Macedonians have the right of self-preservation, they have every moral law and customary law, and international law on their side.

The Hellenic Republic decided to attack the Macedonian Republic, because it realised that its conquest was not over. It does not have full legal rights to title and possession, unless it can bring about the political extinguishment of the Macedonian Republic.

This is what the 'negotiation' process, is for. It is designed to put the question of our extermination, to a vote. To bring about our extinction - or possible extinction - down to a simple vote. A vehicle to drive us toward extinction, so that the Hellenic Republic can complete its conquest.

If it can extinguish the political existence of the Macedonian Republic, that Hellenic Republic has full legal title and rights to Macedonia - not only the place, but the people also.

It fulfills its conquest of not only exterminating the Macedonian people, but of replacing 'the Slavs' with 'the Greeks' AS MACEDONIANS.

What your proposing would be nothing short of handing over the conquest the New Greeks set themselves back in 1913 - nothing less than our extinction, and appropraition of the highsounding name 'Macedonia' - you would be handing them this on a silver platter. As Risto has already pointed out, you are a "Greek advocate of the highest order" and you remind me of UMDists in Washington who have backed and supported the Greek position, fully within the framework of these negotiations that have us teetering on the brink of possible extinction - if it comes down to a vote.
 
Last edited:
Ivo, it really saddens me to read your views. I can't begin to express my disgust at the manner in which you have abandoned your identity for the promise of fools gold.
Although entitled to an opinion, it disturbs me that you would choose to express it through the mass media, thereby dishonestly giving the impression that your compromised views, the views of a dushman are in any way reflective of the majority of the Macedonian people
 
Ivo, nobody gave you the right to speak on behalf of all Macedonians in such a manner. Your views do not align with the majority of Macedonians, and certainly not of the MTO. I suggest you pay a visit to the Macedonian Cause thread before you further demean your own people and culture.
As a journalist, one would expect that you think before you write.
In your case, better still, do not write at all, for you are only damaging the Macedonian fight for independence and spitting upon those who fought for the name and history.
It is one thing to be a dushman in the closet, but it is another to express your prejudice views to the general public.

If any of you have ever set foot in Skopje, or Bitola, or anywhere in Macedonia you’ll know that hatred of Cigani and Shiptars is the norm for almost everyone

Lol, this comment made me laugh. How about in turn, you step foot in any of Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia and Albania and ask about the Macedonians. Have a look at what the Albanian community is doing within Macedonia. They enjoy the best minority rights in the region, yet you want to build them a castle..hey while your at it how about we make an Albanian the next president, seems fair doesn't it?

The majority of Albanians in Macedonia do not respect the country that they live in, it does not take an expert to see the 'hidden' agenda of Albanian 'leaders' such as Menduh Thaci and Ali Ahmeti.

How about instead of undermining the Macedonians, you promote the rights on Macedonians abroad. Here you are insisting that Albanians need more rights and protection, yet you fail to promote the lack of rights for Macedonians in Egej and within other neighboring countries.

You are very disappointing to the Macedonian people, and at a time in which Macedonians need more recognition in the world, you spread lies and deceit about your own people. You should be ashamed to bestow a Macedonian name and act in such a manner.

Za Stramota.
 
Ivo, You spoke about concessions, what about our concessions? We changed our flag,constitution and name, do you see how obsurd this is??

We have made more then enough changes and its time we stood up for what is right, Greece is a bankrupt country they got no business in tell us how we should be called.

Yes exacly prolet.

Ivo how can you say that Grease has "comprimised" alot? They have done fuck all and compromised nothing. I urge you to show us some examples of a grik "compromise" in the "name game".

As prolet mentioned macedonia has already "compromised", more then enough actually/
Macedonia has:
- Changed its flag to due grik demands
- accepted "FYROM" due to grik arrogance
- agreed and signed that macedonia has no claims to grik "territory" in aegean macedonia thanks to grik insecurity
- signed a deal for "friendly relations" between grease
- Macedonia even removed the white tower of solun from its currency


And im sure that there are more examples of macedonia "comprimising"/

So again, what has Grease given up to end this stupid game? The answer is NOTHING. Macedonia is not compromising, its getting bent over a barrel by grease why phony intellectuals like you nod and agree with your racist EU masters and grik pals.
 
True Macedonian said it the best, why do we have to let other nations tell us what we are allowed to call our country and selfs? It is not right that we are to be bullied by other nations and forced to do what they feel is "right". It's our country and only we are the ones who decide what happens with it.

Macedonians are much more tougher then that and arent spineless sell outs like you.
 
Ivo's idea of entry into the EU is obviously about 'Macedonia' becoming a subservient second-class hanger-on. His mentality is very similar to that of the Serbian janichar Kolisevski, who turned the Republic of Macedonia into a de facto Serbian colony, rather than the equal member of the Yugoslav Federation that the majority of Macedonian partizans fought for.

If Ivo truly appreciates what formal European human rights and anti-discrimination standards are about, where is his mention of the daily repression and systematic ethnic cleansing faced by Macedonians living in those parts of the Republic of Macedonia that are dominated by Ahmeti's and Dzaferi's racist Balisti and victorious terrorists? Where is his mention of the genocidal ethnic cleansing and/or forced assimilation that Greece has been unleashing on the Macedonians and other ethnic minorities within its borders for over a century?

If Ivo's praise for the ruinous capitulation known as the Ohrid Framework Agreement comes from a European perspective, I ask him how many EU countries have a political system that obliges the majority of members of parliament to always guarantee ministerial positions and right to other public service, police and military appointments to racist parties whose leaders have been internationally declared as 'terrorist thugs' (in the words of former NATO Secretary, George Robertson) or blacklisted by the US?

If Ivo is genuinely interested in protecting all Macedonian citizens from racial/ethnic discrimination and repression, where is he to tell us to what extent the victims of the racist terrorist attacks on Macedonia from 2001 have been compensated for physical and psychological damage, repatriated to the ancestral homes from which they were displaced by physical force or intimidation, or offered reliable protection from future assault, intimidation or other forms of racist repression and ethnic cleansing?

if Ivo thinks that the Ohrid Framework Agreement is such a great thing, would he agree to ethnic Macedonians who do not consider themselves "Slavo-Macedonians" having the benefit of the Badinter principle when it comes to ratification of any future agreement with Greece or any other agreement that adversely affects them as an ethnic group?

Yes, the Republic of Macedonia needs to protect citizens from being discriminated against purely because they are 'Cigani' or 'Siptari'. But it can only do that if its citizens reclaim their sovereignty and implement legislation that will offer EQUAL protection to ALL citizens, in accordance with internationally codified human rights standards, as opposed to some isolated deal between a bunch of unaccountable vassal rulers and racist terrorists. That protection needs to be afforded against attacks from ANYBODY, including the racist Greek state, the Albanian racist separatists, the Bulgarian racist state, Serbian chauvinists in Macedonia and in Serbia, as well as 'European' and 'US' neoimperialists who presume a right to impose on the Macedonian people standards contrary to those they practice in their own back yards.

If it wasn't for 'Macedonians' like Ivo, who legitimize and encourage repressive demands against the Macedonian people by Greece, the Albanian nationalist movement and their 'international' allies, the Republic of Macedonia may have been admitted into the UN, the EU and NATO as an EQUAL member years ago.

"From the equality of rights springs identity of our highest interests; you cannot subvert your neighbor's rights without striking a dangerous blow at your own." Carl Schurz
 
Ivo, nobody gave you the right to speak on behalf of all Macedonians in such a manner. Your views do not align with the majority of Macedonians, and certainly not of the MTO. I suggest you pay a visit to the Macedonian Cause thread before you further demean your own people and culture.
As a journalist, one would expect that you think before you write.
In your case, better still, do not write at all, for you are only damaging the Macedonian fight for independence and spitting upon those who fought for the name and history.
It is one thing to be a dushman in the closet, but it is another to express your prejudice views to the general public.



Lol, this comment made me laugh. How about in turn, you step foot in any of Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia and Albania and ask about the Macedonians. Have a look at what the Albanian community is doing within Macedonia. They enjoy the best minority rights in the region, yet you want to build them a castle..hey while your at it how about we make an Albanian the next president, seems fair doesn't it?

The majority of Albanians in Macedonia do not respect the country that they live in, it does not take an expert to see the 'hidden' agenda of Albanian 'leaders' such as Menduh Thaci and Ali Ahmeti.

How about instead of undermining the Macedonians, you promote the rights on Macedonians abroad. Here you are insisting that Albanians need more rights and protection, yet you fail to promote the lack of rights for Macedonians in Egej and within other neighboring countries.

You are very disappointing to the Macedonian people, and at a time in which Macedonians need more recognition in the world, you spread lies and deceit about your own people. You should be ashamed to bestow a Macedonian name and act in such a manner.

Za Stramota.

His comments about the Roma tell me that this fellow hasnt set foot in macedonia, or the rest of mainland europe, and is talking out of his @ss.

It is FACT that the roma dont have it any better any where in europe except for macedonia, where they can continue with their culture and have a say in politics.
 
Ivo you say you are not the guy in the video clip yet the guy is called by your name and is from the uk as you say you are. Is this a coincidence two guys both with the same name and surname and being in the uk and both having similar views or after reading some of the posts here you realised the same first thing I thought of when I watched the video the I CANT BELIEVE IT.

I cant believe you are Macedonian and saying these things both in your article and video clip.

I cant believe how stupid you are. Do you realise the uk is a union of different countries and people. Try telling a Scotsman he is no longer Scottish and see if he doesn’t kick your head in. Can you not draw any parallels to Yugoslavia. When travelling abroad I was recognised as a Yugoslav travelling and no one at customs asked was I Macedonian or any other nationality but did it suddenly mean I no longer was a Macedonian.

I cant believe you dare show your face anywhere both out of shame and fear that someone will kick your head in wherever they see you.

I cant believe someone hasn’t already kicked your head in.

And

You cant believe someone hasn’t kicked your head in already so quickly add you are not the guy in the video lest people know what you look like.

Let me dumb it down for you so you can understand it.

An English man can be a uk citizen as can a Scotsman be a uk citizen ect. Even you who are not a native descendent of the countries that make up the uk can be a uk citizen. Even any person from any part of the world can become a uk citizen if they follow the right procedures but none can call themselves English or Scottish ect unless they are a descendent of a native English or Scottish ect respectively. An English person is a kind of uk citizen ect.

By advocating a change to Macedonia’s name you are not only changing the name of the country but you are also changing the identity of the people who now choose to identify themselves as Macedonian people regardless if they are citizens of the country Macedonia or not or even regardless if the live in the country Macedonia or not. By renaming the country to Northern Macedonia or anything else you immediately are saying the identity is changed from being Macedonian to some kind of Macedonian. This then immediately says if you are some kind of Macedonian then are there other kinds and what are they and there in lies the Greek trick. They will not call themselves some kind of Macedonian but simply Macedonian so then the Macedonians become some kind of Macedonians and the Christians brought in from Turkey who didn’t know how to speak Greek let alone Macedonian are now declared the real Macedonians. Try telling a native Englishman that he should now start calling himself some kind of Englishman and some foreigner whose family blew in 100 years ago or less is the only person who can truly call themselves an Englishman and nothing more.

Are you now thinking you cant believe you were so stupid to think Macedonians are so stupid they cant even understand something as stupid as you article or the video clip.

I still cant believe someone hasn’t kicked your head in yet but then it stands as a testament of how civilly advanced Macedonians can be. Try saying your not Greek in Greece and set your stopwatch for how long it takes the thugs to come out and want to thump you.

If for whatever reason you feel you are not Macedonian then that is your choice but you have no right to advocate it for every other Macedonian.

Podobro pomocajsise vo edno virce I udajse vo nego oti ne vredis za nisto drugo.
 
Thanks for the invite. Found this by googling my Macedonia blog and then saw you’d sent an invite to my Facebook, which I never open. Well now that I have found it, I’ll try to respond to some of the points here.

You're welcome. I'm glad that you appeared here cuz we do have many objections about your articles.

I'm not sure if they really represents you personal views, by favouring the naivness.



The Ohrid agreement and the constitutional amendments in 1995 were excellent steps for the Macedonian government, but more and more they are coming to seem like isolated incidents when the Macedonians have been anything less than completely unwilling to compromise.

That's the first point of our disagreement.

The Ohrid agreement and amendments in 1995 were not result of compromise but a result of force. Without even getting inside them, that's the first issue we should point out.

My concern is - how does this look from the outside? Greece have made numerous concessions over the years, the biggest one of course being the name ‘Macedonia’ itself. The argument was won then, and we won - rightly so.

Could you be kind enough to remind us what sort of comrpomises undertook Greece?

Why is Greece insisting so hard on exclusivity over the name 'Macedonia'?

The concession Greece did from her position on the usage of the name 'Macedonia' by us was pure denial of Macedonian ethnicity since the meaning of that word has been made conditional to NOT symbolize the Macedonian ethnic identity.

That's why we were forced to change our ethnic symbols.

So the Greek aim to destroy the Macedonian ethnic identity remained, as a condition.

Ivo, what kind of compromise you are trying to imply having from Greek side?



I’m definitely no Greek advocate - I think the problem mostly emanates from Greek insecurity, but if we’re honest, the Macedonians aggravate the issue with our own consid erable insecurities. I don’t think we need to be - we are now Macedonians, and the smallest compromise at the end of the process (i.e. Northern Macedonia) not only sends a message that the Macedonians know that nationalist chest-thumping isn’t what a modern European state does, but it also puts a (relatively) amicable end to this ridiculous dispute.

So far you are not convincing about the advocate you tend to be.

Insecurity doesn't have anything to do with the right to stand on your rightful position and defend yourself.

1. Even though the UN in 1948 adopted a resolution which strictly prohibited the introduction of new conditions for entry in this world organization we were still prohibited from entering the UN by our chosen name 'Macedonia'.

2. Greece enforced economic blockade on us 'embargo' in violation of article 5 of the GATT agreement which guarantees uninterrupted and obstacle free transit of all goods.
Than after the Interim Accord in 1995 was signed the European court dismissed the case in Strasburg against this Greek illegal blockade pretending that the blockade never happened at all.

3. Greece is obliged not to prevent the Republic of Macedonia from joining international organizations and associations in which Greece is a member according the article 11 from the Interim Accord.
Greece did not respected that right and its own international obligation when, undertook measures to block Macedonia’s entry into NATO at the Bucharest Summit.

Another classic example where politics dominated over fairness and justice.

4. Greece continuously uses the slogan “Macedonia is Greece” which implies territorial claims toward our tiny Republic.


And now you are trying to fool the readers of Guardian how it's time Macedonia finally accept ANOTHER 'compromise'?

Then Greece would have no need to keep vetoing us from the EU. I said in the article that accession would help with bringing us up to European standard in representation for the Roma and Albanians - I know that the Ohrid agreement accommodated the Macedonian Albanians, but what’s needed is enforced legislation against systematic discrimination, across every layer of RoM society. Eventually, that’s what EU participation will bring. If any of you have ever set foot in Skopje, or Bitola, or anywhere in Macedonia you’ll know that hatred of Cigani and Shiptars is the norm for almost everyone. That’s what we need to move past if we’re ever going to be a successful 21st Century nation.

A need to vetoing us?

If you look behind Greek politics with the name it's pretty clear that the problem they have is the name which defines the Macedonian peoples’ ethnic identity.
It's about the existence of a separate Macedonian ethnic identity which is hidden in the name of the country.


And if you look in advocating the discrimination against Roma population start with the existing EU members or maybe take a visit to Roma places such as Kosice in Slovakia. Before criticizing us on this issue make sure the EU has implemented their rights.

Here is an enlightening interview with Stavros Ligeros to point out to you and all other dellusioned Macedonians what are the Greek aims:

http://www.forum.com.mk/mobile/article/3957

A short compilation of his words:

Не е прашање само името, туку и идентитетот.

Ниту на ниво на име на државата не може да се нарекувате Република Македонија, ниту на ниво на идентитет.

Како што на Кипар постојат Грци-Кипрани и Турци-Кипрани и велиме Гркокипрани и Туркокипрани, така и во Македонија има Грци кои се Гркомакедонци, Бугари кои се Бугаромакедонци, Албанци кои се Албаномакедонци и вие. Ве нарекуваме славомакедонци, но Грција нема никаква причина да ве крстува. Ако сакате вашата националност да ја определите со друга одредница - можете, но не можете вие да бидете Македонците

Да расчистиме. Ова што го велите е ваш личен став?
Веќе не. Тогаш, пред 17 години, беше мој личен став, но сега веќе е официјална политика. Ова што ви го велам е она што го кажа господин Караманлис на самитот на НАТО во Букурешт.

Не се согласувам дека треба да биде идентитетот македонски.
Мислам дека идентитетот треба да биде славомакедонски, или што друго одберете како одредница.

Нашиот проблем е дека не може да ги употребувате терминот македонски јазик и македонска нација затоа што на тој начин еден дел, едно парче, се претставува како целината Македонија.

А тоа е дека Македонија како географски поим не е татковина на само една нација. Таа е татковина на повеќе нации.

That's more less all about their intentions, trying to present the secondary identity of the population as primary while we Macedonians will lose our national identity for good.

Because for a local Greek living in Macedonia, being a Macedonian is his secondary local identity, but being a Macedonian for us in the RoM or anywhere else is PRIMARY identity as we do not have other identity to use contrary to the Greek where secondary he is 'Macedonian' and primary a Greek national.

And I will end these citations with his vision of a modern state vs your vision Ivo:

Точно е дека на оние што не се изјаснуваа како Грци им беше ускратено нивното право. Тоа е вистина.
Но, знаете, државите си ги бранат сопствените интереси, тие не се хуманитарни организации.

Exactly. That's the reality and not some demagogy of yours.

As long as there is no ethnic source for the Macedonian identity, there can be no Macedonian ethnic identity and also no Macedonian minority in Greece!

And if we went this route, we’d have shown the world that we know how a modern state acts towards other states - by being pragmatic, instead of fanatical.

What you are offering to us Ivo is the most humiliating retreat.

And why is that when before Yugoslavia’s breakup Greece officially used Macedonia’s historical and constitutional name then part of the Yugoslav Federation – (Socialist) Republic of Macedonia?

1. Never in its own history has Greece used the name “Macedonia” prior to August 1988.

2. In 1988 with a decree Greece renamed the "Northern province" to "Macedonian and Thrace region" by creating districts as named “Western Macedonia”, Central Macedonia” and “Eastern Macedonia and Thrace”.

The nude fact is - There never was nor is a Greek province called "Macedonia".

3. The Republic of Macedonia was the FIRST STATE to make use of the name MACEDONIA when proclaiming it's independent republic in 1944 and with international rights, rightly defined by “Qui prior est tempore, potior est jure”, NO ONE HAS THE RIGHT TO DISPUTE THAT NAME.

Even if Europe has given up on us we are going to fight for the European values by not allowing self serving politics to triumph over the justice.
 
Last edited:
Ivo Petkovski said:
Greece have made numerous concessions over the years, the biggest one of course being the name ‘Macedonia’ itself.
Ivo, you've sold out, and the statement above in which you exhibit your belief in the lies against our people confirms it. Your attempt to hand over Macedonia's heritage to Greece at the expense of the Macedonians is nothing less than treacherous, people of your sort and attitude are irrelevant for the future of our people. Let's face it, you couldn't care less for the future of Macedonia and the Macedonian people in general.

You speak of "numerous concessions", what other "concessions" has Greece made?
 
Back
Top