Thanks for the invite. Found this by googling my Macedonia blog and then saw you’d sent an invite to my Facebook, which I never open. Well now that I have found it, I’ll try to respond to some of the points here.
You're welcome. I'm glad that you appeared here cuz we do have many objections about your articles.
I'm not sure if they really represents you personal views, by favouring the naivness.
The Ohrid agreement and the constitutional amendments in 1995 were excellent steps for the Macedonian government, but more and more they are coming to seem like isolated incidents when the Macedonians have been anything less than completely unwilling to compromise.
That's the first point of our disagreement.
The Ohrid agreement and amendments in 1995 were not result of compromise but a
result of force. Without even getting inside them, that's the first issue we should point out.
My concern is - how does this look from the outside? Greece have made numerous concessions over the years, the biggest one of course being the name ‘Macedonia’ itself. The argument was won then, and we won - rightly so.
Could you be kind enough to remind us what sort of comrpomises undertook Greece?
Why is Greece insisting so hard on exclusivity over the name 'Macedonia'?
The concession Greece did from her position on the usage of the name 'Macedonia' by us was pure denial of Macedonian ethnicity since the meaning of that word
has been made conditional to NOT symbolize the Macedonian ethnic identity.
That's why we were forced to change our ethnic symbols.
So the Greek aim to destroy the Macedonian ethnic identity remained, as a condition.
Ivo, what kind of compromise you are trying to imply having from Greek side?
I’m definitely no Greek advocate - I think the problem mostly emanates from Greek insecurity, but if we’re honest, the Macedonians aggravate the issue with our own consid erable insecurities. I don’t think we need to be - we are now Macedonians, and the smallest compromise at the end of the process (i.e. Northern Macedonia) not only sends a message that the Macedonians know that nationalist chest-thumping isn’t what a modern European state does, but it also puts a (relatively) amicable end to this ridiculous dispute.
So far you are not convincing about the advocate you tend to be.
Insecurity doesn't have anything to do with the right to stand on your rightful position and defend yourself.
1. Even though the UN in 1948 adopted a resolution which strictly prohibited the introduction of new conditions for entry in this world organization
we were still prohibited from entering the UN by our chosen name 'Macedonia'.
2.
Greece enforced economic blockade on us 'embargo' in violation of article 5 of the GATT agreement which guarantees uninterrupted and obstacle free transit of all goods.
Than after the Interim Accord in 1995 was signed the European court dismissed the case in Strasburg against this Greek illegal blockade
pretending that the blockade never happened at all.
3.
Greece is obliged not to prevent the Republic of Macedonia from joining international organizations and associations in which Greece is a member according the article 11 from the Interim Accord.
Greece did not respected that right and its own international obligation when, undertook measures to block Macedonia’s entry into NATO at the Bucharest Summit.
Another classic example where politics dominated over fairness and justice.
4. Greece continuously uses the slogan
“Macedonia is Greece” which implies
territorial claims toward our tiny Republic.
And now you are trying to fool the readers of Guardian how it's time Macedonia finally accept ANOTHER 'compromise'?
Then Greece would have no need to keep vetoing us from the EU. I said in the article that accession would help with bringing us up to European standard in representation for the Roma and Albanians - I know that the Ohrid agreement accommodated the Macedonian Albanians, but what’s needed is enforced legislation against systematic discrimination, across every layer of RoM society. Eventually, that’s what EU participation will bring. If any of you have ever set foot in Skopje, or Bitola, or anywhere in Macedonia you’ll know that hatred of Cigani and Shiptars is the norm for almost everyone. That’s what we need to move past if we’re ever going to be a successful 21st Century nation.
A need to vetoing us?
If you look behind Greek politics with the name it's pretty clear that the problem they have is the name which defines the Macedonian peoples’ ethnic identity.
It's about the existence of a separate Macedonian ethnic identity which is hidden in the name of the country.
And if you look in advocating the discrimination against Roma population start with the existing EU members or maybe take a visit to Roma places such as Kosice in Slovakia. Before criticizing us on this issue make sure the EU has implemented their rights.
Here is an enlightening interview with
Stavros Ligeros to point out to you and all other dellusioned Macedonians what are the Greek aims:
http://www.forum.com.mk/mobile/article/3957
A short compilation of his words:
Не е прашање само името, туку и идентитетот.
Ниту на ниво на име на државата не може да се нарекувате Република Македонија, ниту на ниво на идентитет.
Како што на Кипар постојат Грци-Кипрани и Турци-Кипрани и велиме Гркокипрани и Туркокипрани, така и во Македонија има Грци кои се Гркомакедонци, Бугари кои се Бугаромакедонци, Албанци кои се Албаномакедонци и вие. Ве нарекуваме славомакедонци, но Грција нема никаква причина да ве крстува. Ако сакате вашата националност да ја определите со друга одредница - можете, но не можете вие да бидете Македонците
Да расчистиме. Ова што го велите е ваш личен став?
Веќе не. Тогаш, пред 17 години, беше мој личен став, но сега веќе е официјална политика. Ова што ви го велам е она што го кажа господин Караманлис на самитот на НАТО во Букурешт.
Не се согласувам дека треба да биде идентитетот македонски.
Мислам дека идентитетот треба да биде славомакедонски, или што друго одберете како одредница.
Нашиот проблем е дека не може да ги употребувате терминот македонски јазик и македонска нација затоа што на тој начин еден дел, едно парче, се претставува како целината Македонија.
А тоа е дека Македонија како географски поим не е татковина на само една нација. Таа е татковина на повеќе нации.
That's more less all about their intentions, trying to present the secondary identity of the population as primary while we Macedonians will lose our national identity for good.
Because for a local Greek living in Macedonia, being a Macedonian is his secondary local identity, but
being a Macedonian for us in the RoM or anywhere else is PRIMARY identity as we do not have other identity to use contrary to the Greek where secondary he is 'Macedonian' and primary a Greek national.
And I will end these citations with his vision of a modern state vs your vision Ivo:
Точно е дека на оние што не се изјаснуваа како Грци им беше ускратено нивното право. Тоа е вистина.
Но, знаете, државите си ги бранат сопствените интереси, тие не се хуманитарни организации.
Exactly. That's the reality and not some demagogy of yours.
As long as there is no ethnic source for the Macedonian identity, there can be no Macedonian ethnic identity and also no Macedonian minority in Greece!
And if we went this route, we’d have shown the world that we know how a modern state acts towards other states - by being pragmatic, instead of fanatical.
What you are offering to us Ivo is the most humiliating retreat.
And why is that when before Yugoslavia’s breakup Greece officially used Macedonia’s historical and constitutional name then part of the Yugoslav Federation – (Socialist) Republic of Macedonia?
1.
Never in its own history has Greece used the name “Macedonia” prior to August 1988.
2. In 1988 with a decree
Greece renamed the "Northern province" to "Macedonian and Thrace region" by creating districts as named “Western Macedonia”, Central Macedonia” and “Eastern Macedonia and Thrace”.
The nude fact is - There
never was nor is a Greek province called "Macedonia".
3. The Republic of Macedonia was the
FIRST STATE to make use of the name MACEDONIA when proclaiming it's independent republic in 1944 and with international rights, rightly defined by
“Qui prior est tempore, potior est jure”, NO ONE HAS THE RIGHT TO DISPUTE THAT NAME.
Even if Europe has given up on us we are going to fight for the European values by not allowing self serving politics to triumph over the justice.