• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

Ivo Petkovski - The Traitor

Serdarot, izgleda samo jas i ti sme budni, site drugi spijat vo Avstralija. Izvini, ama ne si mnogu atraktiven prospekt - vreme za televizija i krevet, aj ke se chueme utre vecher.
 
Ivo,

When you suggest that some of the traumatic episodes Macedonia has confronted are "all finished" exposes a level of ignorance. The consequences of the partition in 1913 and the so-called "Greek Civil War" are not finished, indeed a lot of today's "issues" a borne out of those events. A lot of Macedonians, today, suffer direct taumatic experiences from those events. Underpinning a lot of today's "issues" is the overarching existential question, just ask the Macedonians who live in Greece - you seem to have forgotten them. The "issues" today are not mutually exclusive. If you want to look at the experiences of the two nations, you can't simply go back to Ottoman times and stop there - what else happened?

Unfortunately, a lot of your comments do appear suspiciously familiar, in that it is what Greek propaganda has been spewing out for some time.
 
Ivo,

A key reason why Macedonian society is so far behind countries like Australia and Germany is because of the continuing predominance of the defeatist, submissive, slave mentality that people like yourself continue to ignorantly or opportunistically preserve and cultivate.

For a person with 'European' pretensions, you waste way too many words on a dubious version of ethnic history and rely too heavily on an outdated conception of ethnic or national identity. Yet you make no mention at all of internationally codified concepts of national sovereignty and human rights and freedoms.

"You can't see the whole sky through a bamboo tube." - Japanese proverb
 
What I'm saying is that the Ottoman occupation of the Balkans perhaps slowed the arrival of that national identity idea in the region, as the Ottomans classified everyone by religion. Consequent events have been a story of too many competing identities trying to assert themselves in an accelerated way.



I think you are wrong with your assumption.

Ottoman Empire had no power to stop nationalistic ideas flowing through to the Balkans at late 19th. These ideas arrived to Macedonia later than others not because of Ottoman Empire`s influence or power in the region.
The reason for this; there was two competing factor for Macedonia, Russians by using Bulgars as their peons and British was using Greeks for the same goal. Also Macedonia`s demographics wasn't that ideal for it before 1912 but they couldn't wait any longer than that since there was going to be WW-1 to start at 1914.

IMHO, you better re-check your historical comprehension before trying to make an assumption.
 
Thanks to everyone for your responses. I’ll try to cover what I think are the main points raised.


Well this seems to be a point of pride, but it’s interesting to think why people feel this strongly about it. The name change is a geographical designation, not a change of signifier - we’d still be Macedonian, and no one can change that. I think the Macedonians are just as collectively traumatised as the Greeks by the Ottoman invasion, and just as desperate to construct the myths that are perceived as necessary for a modern ethnic identity (Ackovska was honest on this point, to her credit).

If we’re honest, we can all acknowledge that being Macedonian, for us Slavs, is a relatively recent construct. Nothing wrong with that - it’s the same for all formerly occupied territories, and especially true in the Balkans where the national idea took root later than in Western Europe and elsewhere in the world. But 2/3 generations ago, we didn’t think we were Macedonians - the classification just didn’t make sense, we were Orthodox Christians and that was enough. Then, in the late 19th Century, the nation state as an idea swept through the region, and later still, in the 1930s/1940s, the Macedonians settled on that ethnic identity.

For me, those 60 years are enough to create the identity in reality. I’m comfortable with it, I can only be Macedonian, I’m not anything else - not FYROMian, Rumelian, Slavomacedonian, or the rest. But I don’t see why the identity can only be seen as legitimate if it’s projected back in time for the last 2,300 years, and in the face of the available facts. The ancient Macedonians were a Hellenicized culture, and therefore the modern culture that can most claim continuity with them is Greece. I don’t think that continuity is nearly as pronounced as some Greeks make out, but it’s dishonest to act like our Slavic culture has more continuity with the ancient Macedonians. It just doesn’t.

But as inhabitants of the region, I think we can claim that name. That’s why it’s right that we have done, but I don’t see it as a mortal sin to acknowledge that both the Macedonians and the Greeks are in a desperate scramble to piece together a continuous ethnic narrative that somehow stretches across and eclipses the Ottoman occupation. We should understand the Greek irrationality and stubbornness, because we’re just the same, and for the same reasons. And yes, I know that both sides have made compromises.

In fact, I don't see the 'Northern Macedonia' name as the best outcome, my original assertion was that I would find this tolerable, and I have tried to give some reasons for that. But there's equally an argument to be made for holding fast until Greece concede the constitutional name, it just means that we have to continue being embattled on all fronts for a while longer. It's this kind of constant strife in the political landscape that stops us from developing in terms of business, and using the revenue for better education and services, etc...basically progressing as a nation. That's what I really want to see.
Ivo, I do not believe you are Macedonian.
You must understand that your interpretation of matters dear to all Macedonians is completely out of step with all Macedonians. If you were a Greek espousing these beliefs, we simply would not even bother with you as your agenda would be clear.

Again you have demonstrated that you have no concept of the Ohrid agreement and all of its ramifications. I want you to explain to us your interpretation of the Ohrid agreement and why it is a step in the right direction for Macedonians. I will remind you of this until you do, so please take the necessary time to familiarise yourself with it.

Please explain how you feel comfortable with the usage of "Slavs" and "Greeks" as they relate to where Macedonians and Greeks came from. Does it not occur to you that "Greeks" is an equally misleading term as "Slavs"? If you want to talk about the middle ages, you will be very hard pressed to find any reference to "Greeks". Yet you find it easier to say "Greeks" as they apply to the various ethnicities described as Romioi than you would Macedonians.

Tell me what is progressive and "un-Balkan" about your approach? It may well be "un-Balkan" but it is far from progressive. In fact it is an invitation to further de-nationalise Macedonia.
The ancient Macedonians were a Hellenicized culture, and therefore the modern culture that can most claim continuity with them is Greece. I don’t think that continuity is nearly as pronounced as some Greeks make out, but it’s dishonest to act like our Slavic culture has more continuity with the ancient Macedonians. It just doesn’t.
Aside from your interesting choice of American spelling "Hellenicized" which makes me think we are not talking the real Ivo Petkovski, I wish to dispute your ramblings here. The ancient Macedonians had their own identity long before the Athenians decided to develop the Phoenician alphabet. Alexander the Great was equally as fascinated with the Persians as he was with the Athenians. I do not know what you mean by "Hellenicized" but some historians describe a Hellenistic period which other than adopting the Phoenician derived alphabet, means very little. Surely the complete subjugation of the Hellenic city states and beyond is much more appropriately described as a Macedonian period. What precisely is our "Slavic culture"? You would have to define what context you are using "Slavic" in. I genuinely cannot say I feel a close bond with Russians. Are they "Slavic" in the same sense?

Again, tell us your understanding of the Ohrid agreement and the constitutional amendments that ensued.

You are not informed enough and not capable of delivering a relevant Macedonian message Ivo.
 
I know they don’t. And I never claimed to speak on behalf of all Macedonians. But acting like entire world is against us is not doing us any good, that’s clear to me, so I’m ok with being in a minority view on that. Again, not the same as actively advocating a compromise - just trying to see it in perspective, and not as an existential threat.

Most of you seem to live in Australia, and I think someone is in Germany - tell me, what differences do you see between the political landscape there and in RoM? Why is it that we’re the much less successful country, in every sense? In large part, because we waste so much time trying to assert an identity that’s already successfully been asserted. It creates an insecure mindset, and contributes to instability.

The Ohrid agreement was practical - you oppose it on ideological grounds. But modern states don’t act like that - The British brought the Northern Irish into parliament, Australia and NZ bring in legislation to counter discrimination against ethnic minorities - seeing those things as mortal insults to a nation’s integrity, rather than necessary political maneouvring, is counterproductive. It makes no difference if Greece have these neuroses too, or if other countries do - the point is, we should move past it, and we’ll benefit.

In your first point you say that the Macedonians are acting as if the entire world is against them. Instead of highlighting the reason for this, that being the unjust acts committed against Macedonia and the Macedonian people, you say that we should brush it aside because it is a bad image? I respect that you are trying to look at this in a logical sense, but even doing so you lack common sense in this statement.

It is not the fault of the Macedonians that the 'whole world' seems to be against us, and therefore it is not our responsibility to compromise anything as the victim. You continually emphasize the perspective of other countries towards Macedonia as if you are self-conscious of being a Macedonian. Who cares what people think of Macedonia at the present time, people should admire that as Macedonians we are fighting for human rights and recognition. It is our duty to alter this perspective and expose the truth and seek justice for the Macedonians. You are doing the opposite by putting the interests of other nations before Macedonia's interests.

Obviously Macedonia is a lot weaker and poorer than the likes of Australia and Germany, thats something we can all agree on. You cannot blame this on asserting an identity, rather, have a look at what Macedonia has gone through in the past 100 years and even beyond. In this regard Australia cannot compare.
You say we are less successful in every sense?
Maybe we are less successful in being proud and representing our country of origin, you are certainly a good example of this.

As Risto said, I still believe you are unaware of the true implications of the Ohrid framework. I am by no means an expert on this 'agreement,' however I know enough to know that it is only undermining the Macedonians.

Lets see if you feel the same way in 10, 20 years from now if this framework stands. I may not be a fortune-teller but I assure you that spoiling the Albanian minority will have drastic consequences. They will want more and more, aim for a multi-ethnic state, then eventually they will want the whole country. :wacko: :rolleyes1:

Move past what? It is not our fault our neighbours always seem to have a problem with us. By 'moving on,' do you suggest that we surrender our name and identity to the greeks?
Lets just forget about who we are and where we come from, at least that way we may have a chance of starring in a Jason Bourne like movie. :rolleyes1:

I respectfully request you remove that offensive article from the online Guardian website. I'm sure from the responses you've received many other Macedonians feel the same way.
 
Last edited:
1. I would like Ivo to confirm his involvement here on his facebook page, if he expects us to accept his authenticity.
2. I would like an answer to my original question, which has been asked by others repeatedly.
3. Then I will address the situation in Australia as well as his attitudes.
 
Just another mouthpiece of the West. Another 'mouth' unable to defend our nationality on the basis of basic principles enshrined in international law. We have seen this kind of mind set rear its ugly face with some of the other lunatics of the diaspora in Washington, who have put foward the same case this guy is right now. The value of understanding 'context' is completely lost on him. Imagine suggesting we add a geographical determinant to the name of our State ? In which case we lose our nationality, and the New Greeks and Bulgarians who have been telling the rest of the world that there are no distinctive Macedonians per se anywhere - win. Imagine That is what this imbecile is proposing - at the very least.

Ivo Petkovski must be entirely oblivious to the the sacrifices made by millions of Macedonians to win their freedom and independance, their own state. Any mention of our rights under Greek domination, and Bulgarian domination? If the relationship between the New Greeks and the Macedonians, is not a relationship of domination, oppression and conquest - well, then what is? I mean he needs to make an effort or stop writing altogether. We are recognised by over 125 countries, and not recognised by how many - 2, 3, 4 + 1 Club ? I mean whatever happened to doing your best to asking for our rights, or pointing out the the New Greeks do not have a case, the terms they bring to the table are non-negotiable, and that the assumption they bring to the table are an attempt to complete their conquest and appropriate the name 'Macedonia' for themselves? I mean 'context' again. Why not point out the the New Greeks have a long history of appropriating all the high-sounding names in the region, dating back to 1830 ? Its not really 'theirs' and doesn't really belong to 'them' - does it ? If the purpose of this clown is to inform his readers, he has failed. Instead all we have seen from him is telling the 'politicians' what they already know is happening. This guy is part of the "establishment" pushing to have us change our name - that tiny group of 'Macedonians' fking us over one word at a time.
 
Last edited:
I don't believe this Petkovski is a Macedonian at all. Not because of his anti Macedonian stance, but because he/she seems not to have a grasp on Macedonian matters. I'd like to be proven wrong, but i believe we Macedonians are being baited by an individual portraying himself as one of us. Don't fall for it...
 
Ivo's use of words are no different to those of any other charlatan or fifth columnist.

Whilst equating his pseudo understanding of politics to a game and placing it on such a pedestal, he also completely eliminates or disregards any meaning of Macedonia's national identity, any purpose of the existence of the Republic of Macedonia, undermines the sovereignty of the Republic of Macedonia and espouses a deep disrespect or a clear lack of understanding of Internationally accepted and codified Laws and Human Rights.

I wont delve into the historical fallacies, all of which are debatable, that he has accepted as foregone conclusions and facts.

He is using his post here, as little more than self promotion, a PR exercise if you will, and a promotion of his shameless and unsupported views. A charlatan or a fifth columnist; we've yet to determine which of the two, if not both.

At the conclusion of this thread, when all is said and done, I will offer a complete summary and rebuttal to all of his assertions and arguments, none of which are based on fact and none of which would indeed be worth responding to, had it not been for the abhorrence for his person.



That all said, the one reassuring thing I find with people such as the likes of Ivo Petkovski is that, despite him having written an article titled 'Being Macedonian', he knows very little on the subject and will leave no lasting impact.

More to the point however, those of his ilk are the one's who will over time entirely give up their Macedonian heritage, completely assimilating in their new homeland, in his case it may be England.

Furthermore, anyone he may have influenced, including his four year old son, will have no real understanding and knowledge of Macedonia and of Macedonian affairs, nor have any interest in Macedonia and Macedonian affairs.

Thus, perhaps you may call it the natural order of things, or some kind of natural selection, though the end result is that only the Macedonians who care to be Macedonian, will remain Macedonian and will impact on Macedonia.
 
Last edited:
Thanks to everyone for your responses. I’ll try to cover what I think are the main points raised.

Well this seems to be a point of pride, but it’s interesting to think why people feel this strongly about it. The name change is a geographical designation, not a change of signifier - we’d still be Macedonian, and no one can change that. I think the Macedonians are just as collectively traumatised as the Greeks by the Ottoman invasion, and just as desperate to construct the myths that are perceived as necessary for a modern ethnic identity (Ackovska was honest on this point, to her credit).

If we’re honest, we can all acknowledge that being Macedonian, for us Slavs, is a relatively recent construct. Nothing wrong with that - it’s the same for all formerly occupied territories, and especially true in the Balkans where the national idea took root later than in Western Europe and elsewhere in the world. But 2/3 generations ago, we didn’t think we were Macedonians - the classification just didn’t make sense, we were Orthodox Christians and that was enough. Then, in the late 19th Century, the nation state as an idea swept through the region, and later still, in the 1930s/1940s, the Macedonians settled on that ethnic identity.

For me, those 60 years are enough to create the identity in reality. I’m comfortable with it, I can only be Macedonian, I’m not anything else - not FYROMian, Rumelian, Slavomacedonian, or the rest. But I don’t see why the identity can only be seen as legitimate if it’s projected back in time for the last 2,300 years, and in the face of the available facts. The ancient Macedonians were a Hellenicized culture, and therefore the modern culture that can most claim continuity with them is Greece. I don’t think that continuity is nearly as pronounced as some Greeks make out, but it’s dishonest to act like our Slavic culture has more continuity with the ancient Macedonians. It just doesn’t.

But as inhabitants of the region, I think we can claim that name. That’s why it’s right that we have done, but I don’t see it as a mortal sin to acknowledge that both the Macedonians and the Greeks are in a desperate scramble to piece together a continuous ethnic narrative that somehow stretches across and eclipses the Ottoman occupation. We should understand the Greek irrationality and stubbornness, because we’re just the same, and for the same reasons. And yes, I know that both sides have made compromises.

In fact, I don't see the 'Northern Macedonia' name as the best outcome, my original assertion was that I would find this tolerable, and I have tried to give some reasons for that. But there's equally an argument to be made for holding fast until Greece concede the constitutional name, it just means that we have to continue being embattled on all fronts for a while longer. It's this kind of constant strife in the political landscape that stops us from developing in terms of business, and using the revenue for better education and services, etc...basically progressing as a nation. That's what I really want to see.

Wow, that’s the probably the biggest load of garbage I have ever read on this forum. Easily the worst thing I have read here. I personally am having my doubts about you being the real Ivo as you seem to keep going on about the poor grik ”suffering” under ottoman occupation and your view on the people in the Balkans is that people are either Griks or “slavs”. Signs of a grik if you ask me, but if you are the real Ivo then you are nothing more then a sell-out grkoman and if you had any decency in you would stop spreading rubbish about the Macedonians through the internet.

But I will play along….

Macedonia and Macedonians don’t just have a “60 year” history – if you were a real Macedonian and decided to spend a few hours researching into Macedonian history you will find Macedonians fighting for a Macedonia and claiming to be nothing more then Macedonians and claiming alexander the great as far back as the 1800’.s With a bit more work you can even go more back into history to find Macedonians.

You talk about the “slavs” – who are they exactly? Are you talking about the bosniaks, serbs, Bulgarian slavs and croats that live in Macedonia? Or are you talking about Czechs, Poles or Ukranians?
What is this “Slavic culture” you talk about? I used to go to many Polish and Slovene culture nights and I can certainly say their culture is totally different to the Macedonian one. Maybe you should stop just hanging out with griks?

Finally I know you are definitely lying about the griks and the rest of our idiot neighbours just being happy with “Northern Macedonia”. There is absolutely NO WAY that the griks will accept our peoples name and language to be simply Macedonian. If we where to accept Northern Macedonia it just shows our neighbours we capitulate again and again and it would be easier for the griks to force us to change our identity and language’s name.

And finally, I asked you to name a few “compromises” the griks have made, and you have ignored me and continued to talk up how grease has been fair and made many “compromises”. Just as I thought, you cant even name one REAL compromise that grease has given up
 
and i thought homer simpson was funny

we have wasted 8 pages on a non entity who has obviously had to much retsina to think clearly.

is it really ivo or grchko pivo that he represents
 
I decided to making easier for Ivo to give concrete answers without distortioning the subject in this argument.

Here are the questions and posts he owe us answers:

Ivo,


Another mindboggling assumption is that Greece has some how made a "concession". How can someone make a "concession" when they have no ownership of, or right to, the very "concession" they are supposedly making?

Finally, explain how the name "Republic of Northern Macedonia" is not renaming our state. Explain how this is not an attack on our identity or how it will prevent the defacto renaming of our people into "Northern Macedonians". Explain how this is not an abolition of our national sovereingty.

Hello Ivo, thanks for coming over. Could you please expand on this point. What concessions has Greece made regarding the name Macedonia?
And what other concessions have they made?
How would you verbalise the expected concessions that RoM is supposed to make?
And in your mind, how do these concessions relate to the Greek ones, in terms of gravitas and consequences?

You say the Ohrid agreement and the constitutional amendments are excellent steps for the Macedonian government. Do you actually know the content and nature of these changes? I will assume you do. Given your affirmation of the Ohrid agreement and the constitutional amendments, it means you embrace the notion that the will of the Macedonian people (in both an ethnic and national sense) is now strangled by the ethnic Albanian minority. You do understand how their vote means more than the Macedonian vote don't you?


I note you chose not to comment on the following issues I raised in an earlier post:
- Accession to the EU being absolutely measurable.
- What is the maddening uncertainty over Macedonia's official legitimacy as a state?
- Define the ultra-nationalistic sentiment.






Could you be kind enough to remind us what sort of comrpomises undertook Greece?

Why is Greece insisting so hard on exclusivity over the name 'Macedonia'?

The concession Greece did from her position on the usage of the name 'Macedonia' by us was pure denial of Macedonian ethnicity since the meaning of that word has been made conditional to NOT symbolize the Macedonian ethnic identity.

That's why we were forced to change our ethnic symbols.

So the Greek aim to destroy the Macedonian ethnic identity remained, as a condition.

Ivo, what kind of compromise you are trying to imply having from Greek side?



I’m definitely no Greek advocate - I think the problem mostly emanates from Greek insecurity, but if we’re honest, the Macedonians aggravate the issue with our own consid erable insecurities. I don’t think we need to be - we are now Macedonians, and the smallest compromise at the end of the process (i.e. Northern Macedonia) not only sends a message that the Macedonians know that nationalist chest-thumping isn’t what a modern European state does, but it also puts a (relatively) amicable end to this ridiculous dispute.

So far you are not convincing about the advocate you tend to be.

Insecurity doesn't have anything to do with the right to stand on your rightful position and defend yourself.

1. Even though the UN in 1948 adopted a resolution which strictly prohibited the introduction of new conditions for entry in this world organization we were still prohibited from entering the UN by our chosen name 'Macedonia'.

2. Greece enforced economic blockade on us 'embargo' in violation of article 5 of the GATT agreement which guarantees uninterrupted and obstacle free transit of all goods.
Than after the Interim Accord in 1995 was signed the European court dismissed the case in Strasburg against this Greek illegal blockade pretending that the blockade never happened at all.

3. Greece is obliged not to prevent the Republic of Macedonia from joining international organizations and associations in which Greece is a member according the article 11 from the Interim Accord.
Greece did not respected that right and its own international obligation when, undertook measures to block Macedonia’s entry into NATO at the Bucharest Summit.

Another classic example where politics dominated over fairness and justice.

4. Greece continuously uses the slogan “Macedonia is Greece” which implies territorial claims toward our tiny Republic.


And now you are trying to fool the readers of Guardian how it's time Macedonia finally accept ANOTHER 'compromise'?

A need to vetoing us?

If you look behind Greek politics with the name it's pretty clear that the problem they have is the name which defines the Macedonian peoples’ ethnic identity.
It's about the existence of a separate Macedonian ethnic identity which is hidden in the name of the country.


And if you look in advocating the discrimination against Roma population start with the existing EU members or maybe take a visit to Roma places such as Kosice in Slovakia. Before criticizing us on this issue make sure the EU has implemented their rights.

Here is an enlightening interview with Stavros Ligeros to point out to you and all other dellusioned Macedonians what are the Greek aims:

http://www.forum.com.mk/mobile/article/3957

A short compilation of his words:

Не е прашање само името, туку и идентитетот.

Ниту на ниво на име на државата не може да се нарекувате Република Македонија, ниту на ниво на идентитет.

Како што на Кипар постојат Грци-Кипрани и Турци-Кипрани и велиме Гркокипрани и Туркокипрани, така и во Македонија има Грци кои се Гркомакедонци, Бугари кои се Бугаромакедонци, Албанци кои се Албаномакедонци и вие. Ве нарекуваме славомакедонци, но Грција нема никаква причина да ве крстува. Ако сакате вашата националност да ја определите со друга одредница - можете, но не можете вие да бидете Македонците

Да расчистиме. Ова што го велите е ваш личен став?
Веќе не. Тогаш, пред 17 години, беше мој личен став, но сега веќе е официјална политика. Ова што ви го велам е она што го кажа господин Караманлис на самитот на НАТО во Букурешт.

Не се согласувам дека треба да биде идентитетот македонски.
Мислам дека идентитетот треба да биде славомакедонски, или што друго одберете како одредница.

Нашиот проблем е дека не може да ги употребувате терминот македонски јазик и македонска нација затоа што на тој начин еден дел, едно парче, се претставува како целината Македонија.

А тоа е дека Македонија како географски поим не е татковина на само една нација. Таа е татковина на повеќе нации.

That's more less all about their intentions, trying to present the secondary identity of the population as primary while we Macedonians will lose our national identity for good.

Because for a local Greek living in Macedonia, being a Macedonian is his secondary local identity, but being a Macedonian for us in the RoM or anywhere else is PRIMARY identity as we do not have other identity to use contrary to the Greek where secondary he is 'Macedonian' and primary a Greek national.

And I will end these citations with his vision of a modern state vs your vision Ivo:

Точно е дека на оние што не се изјаснуваа како Грци им беше ускратено нивното право. Тоа е вистина.
Но, знаете, државите си ги бранат сопствените интереси, тие не се хуманитарни организации.

Exactly. That's the reality and not some demagogy of yours.

As long as there is no ethnic source for the Macedonian identity, there can be no Macedonian ethnic identity and also no Macedonian minority in Greece!



What you are offering to us Ivo is the most humiliating retreat.

And why is that when before Yugoslavia’s breakup Greece officially used Macedonia’s historical and constitutional name then part of the Yugoslav Federation – (Socialist) Republic of Macedonia?

1. Never in its own history has Greece used the name “Macedonia” prior to August 1988.

2. In 1988 with a decree Greece renamed the "Northern province" to "Macedonian and Thrace region" by creating districts as named “Western Macedonia”, Central Macedonia” and “Eastern Macedonia and Thrace”.

The nude fact is - There never was nor is a Greek province called "Macedonia".

3. The Republic of Macedonia was the FIRST STATE to make use of the name MACEDONIA when proclaiming it's independent republic in 1944 and with international rights, rightly defined by “Qui prior est tempore, potior est jure”, NO ONE HAS THE RIGHT TO DISPUTE THAT NAME.

Even if Europe has given up on us we are going to fight for the European values by not allowing self serving politics to triumph over the justice.

You speak of "numerous concessions", what other "concessions" has Greece made?
 
anyone fantasizing that the 'name issue' is solely about the name has either no grasp of reality or is a paid agent to the ones who wish to further destroy and take what is ours
 
Boge, do you also share the opinion of the individual you've jumped in to defend?

Solder of Macedon I have not jumped to Ivitsa’s defence, I merely asked for restraint in comments prior to Ivo’s presence on this forum. You know, ask questions then shoot.

Never the less Ivitsa has proven to be a Yugo nostalgic with a total disdain for the Diaspora Macedonians and Macedonia’s history. The man seems to have begged the papers to publish his article.
 
http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2010/mar/15/madedonia-being-macedonian

As one of the 9,000 or so Macedonians living in England, I have long been aware of the contrast between the unselfconscious patriotism that is the norm in Macedonia, and the awkward evasion that accompanies the national identity question in England.

Having been in England since the age of 11, I have a foot in both camps – or, more accurately, find myself foreign in both places. I used to speak no English, then accented English, then accented Macedonian, and now I struggle to remember Macedonian words. This duality is no hardship to me – I'm equally happy to apologise when someone steps on my foot as I am to go around the house closing windows to avoid promaja.

One of the most instantly recognisable Macedonian traits across class boundaries is a fierce devotion to the idea of being "Macedonian". You will not find many in the Macedonian mainstream asking what nationality means because enough questions surround the Macedonian nationality already – and they all come from neighbouring countries. The most persistent of these is a typically Balkan diplomatic deadlock – the 19-year-old name dispute with Greece.

Accession to the EU is among the Macedonian government's top priorities, a process hindered by the veto Greece has on any accessions. Greek objections also mean that Macedonia is referred to in official UN or Nato documents as FYROM (Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia), to much consternation in Skopje. Athens disputes Macedonia's constitutional name (Republic of Macedonia) because they see the term "Macedonia" and the identity it designates as part of their ancient cultural heritage. Some on the Macedonian side argue that, on the contrary, it is the Macedonian people who can claim cultural and ethnic continuity with the ancient kingdom of Alexander the Great, on the basis that those people never went away from the region.

Both Greek and Macedonian claims to continuity with the ancient kingdom are tenuous at best. Though a Hellenic culture, the ancient Macedonians were not "Greek" in any sense we would understand today, and they certainly weren't Slavic.

Macedonia's Eastern neighbour Bulgaria was among the first countries to officially recognise the Macedonian state. However, they still refuse to recognise it as a nation, seeing the country and its people as prodigal Bulgarians. Many in Bulgaria consider the Macedonian language to be a regional Bulgarian dialect. As with Greece, the Bulgarian ambivalence is rooted in the region's convoluted history – in this case a more recent episode.

In the 19th century, regional revolutionaries such as Goce Delčev and Jane Sandanski fought the Ottomans, making little headway politically, but attaining near-mythical status among the locals. Both Macedonia and Bulgaria are fiercely possessive of these figures, but cannot agree about their nationality. Both states have towns named after Delčev, and statues of him watch over Macedonian and Bulgarian town squares. A portrait of Delčev hung in my primary school classroom, and both he and Sandanski are name-checked in the Macedonian national anthem.

The Bulgarians, like Greece, feel that they would lose a cherished part of their historical narrative if they ceded a separate Macedonian identity. The confusion is not helped by the fact that the Ottoman bureaucrats who carried out every census in the region before the 20th century did not see the need to differentiate between regional identities – "Christian Slavs" generally sufficed. Later studies are not much more helpful – the anthropologist Robert Newman, travelling through the Macedonian part of the Kingdom of Yugoslavia in 1935, found that many locals were happy to be known as Bulgarians, Serbs, Macedonians or Turks – whichever identity seemed appropriate for whatever situation they found themselves in.

In Macedonia today, conversations about politics are ubiquitous and heated – the frustration with the diplomatic disputes is palpable, because everyone knows what and who they are and are impatient for everyone else to acknowledge what already exists.

Macedonians drink Turkish coffee, a tar-like espresso; the elderly watch subtitled Argentinian soap operas, while teenagers listen to American pop, and everyone takes Eurovision seriously. Byzantine ruins, Ottoman souks, medieval Orthodox churches and Yugoslav-era concrete sprawls are scattered across the country. As with any nation, the essence is impossible to convey but easy to understand when you're part of it; it is an aggregate of many different things, some good and some bad (as the Roma minority will attest), but all of them inherently Macedonian.

I have had conversations with Greek and Bulgarian people along the lines of "why do you deny you're Greek/Bulgarian?" I can't remember what my reply was, probably something uninspiring like "erm … not sure?"

What I wish I had said to them is this: it makes no difference if Goce Delčev was Bulgarian or if Alexander was Greek and my 19th century ancestors considered themselves Serbs or Turks – I'm not any of those things. To be FYROM-ian is meaningless, and to be Bulgarian is out of the question. Perhaps it is the case that we have taken Greek terms and symbols, added a variant of the Bulgarian language, and fused them to create a nation and people that reflect the region's mixed heritage. None of that alters the fact that the Macedonians living today have never been anything other than Macedonians, and should have the right to be known as such.

Irrespective of some of your unfortunate interpretations, I have highlighted your final sentence. What has changed since you have written this? What will your (very public) opinion change to next time?
 
Phoenix pal, let's hear the answers Ivo has on the posts I selected upper and than he is "yours" :)

Ivo,

how long it will take you to provide those answers and is there anything you disagree with in my post?
 
Phoenix pal, let's hear the answers Ivo has on the posts I selected upper and than he is "yours" :)

Ivo,

how long it will take you to provide those answers and is there anything you disagree with in my post?

Bratot, Maybe if you slipped in $50 for each question he might respond sooner? :laugh: :laugh:
 
Back
Top