• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

Interesting definition of nationalism - how it relates to Macedonia

Risto the Great

Senior Member
http://wiki.answers.com/Q/Define_nation_and_nationalism
Nationalism is a conscious effort put forward by a group of people to extricate, emancipate and liberate themselves from every form of political subjugation, economic exploitation, social inequalities and cultural alienation impose on them by a foreign invader. A country not under colonial rule would not be able to define nationalism.

Would you say Macedonia is presently under a form of colonial rule?
How do you rate Macedonia in terms of nationalism?
Can you offer a better definition for "nationalism"?
 
KOMENTAR

Gledano odnadvor

Pishuva: Slavko MANGOVSKI

Националистите против космополитите (антинационалистите)

Од својата независност до денес во Република Македонија на власт се македонските космополити понекогаш заедно со албанските и крипто-бугарските националисти. Земајќи ја предвид агресивната сила на национализмот и кроткоста на космополитизмот, резултатот од таквата комбинација можеше да биде само еден: слабеење и пропаѓање на македонската држава. Тука, се разбира, голема улога покрај албанскиот одигра и бугарскиот национализам на водечките луѓе на ДПМНЕ. Резултатот на дејствувањата на двата национализми е присутен денес околу нас: Македонија е на работ на амбисот. Најголемата иронија е дека македонскиот космополитизам за најголем непријател го сметаше, и продолжува да го смета, македонскиот национализам – единствената сила која беше и е способна да им се спротивстави на соседните национализми. Македонските интелектуалци во најголем дел беа и се приврзаници на космополитизмот и според тоа остануваат антинационалисти. Велат дека интелектуалците се движечките сили кои ги водат државите. Ако тоа е така, тогаш лошо ни се пишува.

http://www.makedonskosonce.com/broevis/2001/sonce368/Tekst04.htm

For fair use only.

-------------

The below Google translation is as (feel free to edit it):
Nationalists against kosmopolitite (antinacionalistite)

From independence until today in the Republic of Macedonian power cosmopolitan sometimes together with the Albanian and Bulgarian crypto-nationalists. Taking into account the effect of aggressive nationalism and cosmopolitanism krotkosta of the result of such combination could be only one: the weakening and collapse of the Macedonian state. Here, of course, despite the important role played Albanian and Bulgarian nationalism of leading people DPMNE. The result of the actions of both nationalisms is present around us today: Macedonia to the brink of the abyss. The biggest irony is that the Macedonian cosmopolitanism's biggest enemy has seen, and continues to consider, Macedonian nationalism - the only force that was and is able to confront the neighbor nationalism. Macedonian intellectuals were mostly supporters and cosmopolitanism and therefore remain antinacionalisti. They say that intellectuals are moving forces that lead states. If so, then we are badly written.

http://translate.google.com/?hl=en&sl=mk&tl=en#

---------------------

I think the above Makedonsko sonce editorial commentary by Slavko Mangovski should be seriously considered and taken into account whenever analysis and remedies are sought for navigating our way out of the pitiful mess the Macedonian nation currently finds itself in (and as has been languishing in for a long, long time).
 
Indigen, we have pseudo intellectuals here espousing some very anti-nationalist ideologies. Mr Mangovski clearly understands the danger of placing Macedonia's future in the hands of such people.

Do you agree with the definition above?
 
http://wiki.answers.com/Q/Define_nation_and_nationalism


Would you say Macedonia is presently under a form of colonial rule?
How do you rate Macedonia in terms of nationalism?
Can you offer a better definition for "nationalism"?

I think the traditional definitions are a little out of date, considering the current world order. You can argue that Macedonia, like other countries is under a somewhat abstract form of colonial rule, an ideological and cultural dominance exerted by 'western powers.'


My understanding of nationalism reduces it to the promotion of one's own nation at the expense of others'.

For me, the opposite of nationalism isn't cosmopolitanism, but patriotism: the love for one's country and the actions taken to strengthen it and assert its rightful place as a respected member in the international community. Patriotism is a positive self-affirming approach.
 
Why is that, why most of Macedonian intelectuals are cosmopolitan?

And why the right to defend its own existance, identity and language is marked as - nationalism?

Even Mangovski should re-edit a bit his opinion.

Me, not accepting a name change, me working for general Macedonian interests in the place I live and work, the support of any kind to all other activists for the Macedonian rights doesn't make me an - nationalist of the Greek or Bulgarian type and I will not accept such comparation.


I would put it straight, there is no cosmopolitism in Macedonian intelectual circle, but there are simply traitors who depend on side financing, need of being in rule and getting material use of their ordered opinions.

Macedonian cosmopolitism could be defined in the freedom for all ethnic minorities in the country, their given right to use their language and preserve their culture, everyone to be himself and freely expressing his origin. A balance between all communities in Macedonia based on mutual respect and shared morality.

Macedonian cause is not nationalistic by the same definition of how Greek or Bulgarian nationalism is.

What we are facing in Macedonia is enforcement of a "radical democracy" where our people should stop considering themselfs as heirs of the previous generations and should forcibly shelve the burden of their heritage.

But do we really get enlightened, open minded and free if we accept such radical democracy and reject our heritage?
 
Last edited:
I think the traditional definitions are a little out of date, considering the current world order. You can argue that Macedonia, like other countries is under a somewhat abstract form of colonial rule, an ideological and cultural dominance exerted by 'western powers.'


My understanding of nationalism reduces it to the promotion of one's own nation at the expense of others'.
Given you accept Macedonia is under a form of abstract colonial rule, would it then be more appropriate to say:

"the promotion of one's own nation in defiance of others"

I do not see patriotism as being the opposite of nationalism. You make nationalism sound bad. Why?
 
Here's a good website on nationalism everyone should check out if they are interested in the subject - http://www.nationalismproject.org/

Here's an explanation on nationalism by Eric G.E. Zuelow-http://www.nationalismproject.org/what.htm

There are four core debates which permeate the study of nations and nationalism. First among these is the question of how to define the terms "nation" and "nationalism." Second, scholars argue about when nations first appeared. Academics have suggested a variety of time frames, including (but not limited to!) the following:

Nationalists argue that nations are timeless phenomena. When man climbed out of the primordial slime, he immediately set about creating nations.


The next major school of thought is that of the perennialists who argue that nations have been around for a very long time, though they take different shapes at different points in history.


While postmodernists and Marxists also play in the larger debates surrounding this topic, the modernization school is perhaps the most prevalent scholarly argument at the moment. These scholars see nations as entirely modern and constructed.
It should not be surprising that the third major debate centers on how nations and nationalism developed. If nations are naturally occurring, then there is little reason to explain the birth of nations. On the other hand, if one sees nations as constructed, then it is important to be able to explain why and how nations developed. Finally, many of the original "classic" texts on nationalism have focused on European nationalism at the expense of non-western experiences. This has sparked a debate about whether nationalism developed on its own in places like China, or whether it merely spread to non-western countries from Europe.

In this section of The Nationalism Project you will find a collection of quotations from prominent scholars of nationalism. Of course, individual quotations are not a substitute for reading the important books being cited, but I hope that you will find this resource a helpful introduction to the scholarly views of nations and nationalism.
 
There's alot of info on nationalismproject.org from alot of revered scholars in the field. This is Eric Hobsbawm's explanation;

Neither objective nor subjective definitions are thus satisfactory, and both are misleading. In any case, agnosticism is the best initial posture of a student in this field, and so this book assumes no a priori definition of what constitutes a nation. As an initial working assumption any sufficiently large body of people whose members regard themselves as members of a 'nation', will be treated as such. However, whether such a body of people does so regard itself cannot be established simply by consulting writers or political spokesmen of organizations claiming the status of 'nation' for it. The appearance of a group of spokesmen for some 'national idea' is not insignificant, but the word 'nation' is today used so widely and imprecisely that the use of the vocabulary of nationalism today may mean very little indeed.

Nevertheless, in approaching 'the national question' 'it is more profitable to begin with the concept of "the nation" (i.e. with "nationalism") than with the reality it represents'. For 'The ‘nation’ as conceived by nationalism, can be recognized prospectively; the real "nation" can only be recognized a posteriori.'

This is the approach of the present book. It pays particular attention to the changes and transformations of the concept, particularly towards the end of the nineteenth century. Concepts, of course, are not part of free-floating philosophical discourse, but socially, historically and locally rooted, and must be explained in terms of these realities.

For the rest, the position of the writer may be summarized as follows.

I use the term 'nationalism' in the sense defined by Gellner, namely to mean 'primarily a principle which holds that the political and national unit should be congruent.' I would add that this principle also implies that the political duty of Ruritanians to the polity which encompasses and represents the Ruritanian nation, overrides all other public obligations, and in extreme cases (such as wars) all other obligations of whatever kind. This implication distinguishes modern nationalism from other and less demanding forms of national or group identification which we shall also encounter.


Like most serious students, I do not regard the 'nation' as a primary nor as an unchanging social entity. It belongs exclusively to a particular, and historically recent, period. It is a social entity only insofar as it relates to a certain kind of modern territorial state, the 'nation-state', and it is pointless to discuss nation and nationality except insofar as both relate to it. Moreover, with Gellner I would stress the element of artifact, invention and social engineering which enters into the making of nations. 'Nations as a natural, God-given way of classifying men, as an inherent ... political destiny, are a myth; nationalism, which sometimes takes preexisting cultures and turns them into nations, sometimes invents them, and often obliterates preexisting cultures: that is a reality.' In short, for the purposes of analysis nationalism comes before nations. Nations do not make states and nationalisms but the other way round.


The 'national question', as the old Marxists called it, is situated at the point of intersection of politics, technology and social transformation. Nations exist not only as functions of a particular kind of territorial state or the aspiration to establish one - broadly speaking, the citizen state of the French Revolution - but also in the context of a particular stage of technological and economic development. Most students today will agree that standard national languages, spoken or written, cannot emerge as such before printing, mass literacy and hence, mass schooling. It has even been argued that popular spoken Italian as an idiom capable of expressing the full range of what a twentieth-century language needs outside the domestic and face-to-face sphere of communication, is only being constructed today as a function of the needs of national television programming. Nations and their associated phenomena must therefore be analyzed in terms of political, technical, administrative, economic and other conditions and requirements.


For this reason they are, in my view, dual phenomena, constructed essentially from above, but which cannot be understood unless also analyzed from below, that is in terms of the assumptions, hopes, needs, longings and interests of ordinary people, which are not necessarily national and still less nationalist. If I have a major criticism of Gellner's work it is that his preferred perspective of modernization from above, makes it difficult to pay adequate attention to the view from below.

That view from below, i.e. the nation as seen not by governments and the spokesmen and activists of nationalist (or non-nationalist) movements, but by the ordinary persons who are the objects of their action and propaganda, is exceedingly difficult to discover. Fortunately social historians have learned how to investigate the history of ideas, opinions and feelings at the sub-literary level, so that we are today less likely to confuse, as historians once habitually did, editorials in select newspapers with public opinion. We do not know much for certain. However, three things are clear.

First, official ideologies of states and movements are not guides to what it is in the minds of even the most loyal citizens or supporters. Second, and more specifically, we cannot assume that for most people national identification - when it exists - excludes or is always or ever superior to, the remainder of the set of identifications which constitute the social being. In fact, it is always combined with identifications of another kind, even when it is felt to be superior to them. Thirdly, national identification and what it is believed to imply, can change and shift in time, even in the course of quite short periods. In my judgment this is the area of national studies in which, thinking and research are most urgently needed today.


The development of nations and nationalism within old-established states such as Britain and France, has not been studied very intensively, though it is now attracting attention. The existence of this gap is illustrated by the neglect, in Britain, of any problems connected with English nationalism - a term which in itself sounds odd to many ears - compared to the attention paid to Scots, Welsh, not to mention Irish nationalism. On the other hand there have in recent years been major advances in the study of national movements aspiring to be states, mainly following Hroch's pathbreaking comparative studies of small European national movements. Two points in this excellent writer's analysis are embodied in my own. First, 'national consciousness' develops unevenly among the social groupings and regions of a country; this regional diversity and its reasons have in the past been notably neglected. Most students would, incidentally, agree that, whatever the nature of the social groups first captured by 'national consciousness', the popular masses - workers, servants, peasants - are the last to be affected by it. Second, and in consequence, I follow his useful division of the history of national movements into three phases. In nineteenth-century Europe, for which it was developed, phase A was purely cultural, literary and folkloric, and had no particular political or even national implications, any more than the researches (by non-Romanies) of the Gypsy Lore Society have for the subjects of these enquiries. In phase B we find a body of pioneers and militants of 'the national idea' and the beginnings of political campaigning for this idea. The bulk of Hroch's work is concerned with this phase and the analysis of the origins, composition and distribution of this minorité agissante. My own concern in this book is more with phase C when - and not before - nationalist programmes acquire mass support, or at least some of the mass support that nationalists always claim they represent. The transition from phase B to phase C is evidently a crucial moment in the chronology of national movements. Sometimes, as in Ireland, it occurs before the creation of a national state; probably very much more often it occurs afterwards, as a consequence of that creation. Sometimes, as in the so- called Third World, it does not happen even then.
Finally, I cannot but add that no serious historian of nations and nationalism can be a committed political nationalist, except in the sense in which believers in the literal truth of the Scriptures, while unable to make contributions to evolutionary theory, are not precluded from making contributions to archaeology and Semitic philology. Nationalism requires too much belief in what is patently not so. As Renan said: 'Getting its history wrong is part of being a nation.' Historians are professionally obliged not to get it wrong, or at least to make an effort not to. To be Irish and proudly attached to Ireland - even to be proudly Catholic-Irish or Ulster Protestant Irish - is not in itself incompatible with the serious study of Irish history. To be a Fenian or an Orangeman, I would judge, is not so compatible, any more than being a Zionist is compatible with writing a genuinely serious history of the Jews; unless the historian leaves his or her convictions behind when entering the library or the study. Some nationalist historians have been unable to do so. Fortunately, in setting out to write the present book I have not needed to leave my non-historical convictions behind.

Hobsbawm, Eric J. Nations and Nationalism Since 1780. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1990.
 
http://wiki.answers.com/Q/Define_nation_and_nationalism


Would you say Macedonia is presently under a form of colonial rule?
How do you rate Macedonia in terms of nationalism?
Can you offer a better definition for "nationalism"?

It is under colonial rule. It has been for hundreds of years.
Macedonian nationalism has been strong, principled and disciplined, unlike our neighbours. We just had too much going against us - namely Europe. Its a good definition. I always thought that there had to be a distinction between nationalism that basically comes from a grass roots level or is reflective of the natural cultural landscape, and a kind of top-down nationalism - which seeks to impose a false schemata, or doesn't accept people the way they find them.
 
Given you accept Macedonia is under a form of abstract colonial rule, would it then be more appropriate to say:

"the promotion of one's own nation in defiance of others"

I do not see patriotism as being the opposite of nationalism. You make nationalism sound bad. Why?

On your first point, you can also reapply your definition to patriotism. The point being that there will always be contention and disagreements with others, therefore the issue becomes one of attitude and behaviour.

TM mentioned/cited the origins of classical nationalism in Europe. I believe that it developed in Europe through a logical progression of events: the Renaissance; the break up of the old feudal system in Europe and the re-emergence of city states; the English Reformation; and most importantly the Age of Enlightenment and the subsequent Atlantic Revolutions. Nationalism was a response to Imperialism.

However, the international political scene had changed. Currently, we have a political community of nation-states. Our western principles suppose that all these states have a right to self-determination and should be treated on equal terms. In this context, nationalism has taken a different meaning. The nationalist argument focuses on creating false differences and exploiting those for political needs. In this climate, states are repositioned from 'equal' members to ones claiming and vying for superiority above others.

Patriotism vs Nationalism. If for the point of this discussion, I were to reduce the core values of each notion to their most basic level, I would say that patriotism is characterised by one's love for their country (widely accepted definition) while nationalism is characterised by one's hatred of other country/ies/peoples.

Patriotism is introspective and is about accepting, preserving and promoting the positive characteristics and values (unique or not) of your country as well as recognizing and remedying the faults. It is about setting and aspiring to ideals. Threats to these ideals can then be better dealt with.

Nationalism focuses on the external, positioning the self against the other (people vs people, country vs country). At best, it aspires to being better than the other and if that can't be achieved, at worst it aspires to maintaining a position by keeping the other down. This type of nationalism is a negative force that leads to conflict and ironically renders the country vulnerable to unforeseen dangers.

Which finally brings us back to the seemingly abstract 'colonial rule' mentioned earlier. Unfortunately, the international community does not comprise of equal member-states. To paraphrase George Orwell, some are more equal than others. But even this interpretation doesn't fully reflect the new world order. The Globalisation that started centuries ago has taken a new form. The Empires of old have been replaced by trans-national corporations and banks, as well as the structures to support this. Countries, especially small ones like Macedonia, are threatened with loss of political, cultural and economic independence.

People here have spoken about secret conspiracies (eg Brandeburg), but the evidence is there in plain sight. And nationalism, with its focus on states and outdated political concepts, doesn't account for the imminent dangers brought on by the nwo.

If that makes any sense.
 
Last edited:
On your first point, you can also reapply your definition to patriotism. The point being that there will always be contention and disagreements with others, therefore the issue becomes one of attitude and behaviour.

TM mentioned/cited the origins of classical nationalism in Europe. I believe that it developed in Europe through a logical progression of events: the Renaissance; the break up of the old feudal system in Europe and the re-emergence of city states; the English Reformation; and most importantly the Age of Enlightenment and the subsequent Atlantic Revolutions. Nationalism was a response to Imperialism.

However, the international political scene had changed. Currently, we have a political community of nation-states. Our western principles suppose that all these states have a right to self-determination and should be treated on equal terms. In this context, nationalism has taken a different meaning. The nationalist argument focuses on creating false differences and exploiting those for political needs. In this climate, states are repositioned from 'equal' members to ones claiming and vying for superiority above others.

Patriotism vs Nationalism. If for the point of this discussion, I were to reduce the core values of each notion to their most basic level, I would say that patriotism is characterised by one's love for their country (widely accepted definition) while nationalism is characterised by one's hatred of other country/ies/peoples.

Patriotism is introspective and is about accepting, preserving and promoting the positive characteristics and values (unique or not) of your country as well as recognizing and remedying the faults. It is about setting and aspiring to ideals. Threats to these ideals can then be better dealt with.

Nationalism focuses on the external, positioning the self against the other (people vs people, country vs country). At best, it aspires to being better than the other and if that can't be achieved, at worst it aspires to maintaining a position by keeping the other down. This type of nationalism is a negative force that leads to conflict and ironically renders the country vulnerable to unforeseen dangers.

Which finally brings us back to the seemingly abstract 'colonial rule' mentioned earlier. Unfortunately, the international community does not comprise of equal member-states. To paraphrase George Orwell, some are more equal than others. But even this interpretation doesn't fully reflect the new world order. The Globalisation that started centuries ago has taken a new form. The Empires of old have been replaced by trans-national corporations and banks, as well as the structures to support this. Countries, especially small ones like Macedonia, are threatened with loss of political, cultural and economic independence.

People here have spoken about secret conspiracies (eg Brandeburg), but the evidence is there in plain sight. And nationalism, with its focus on states and outdated political concepts, doesn't account for the imminent dangers brought on by the nwo.

If that makes any sense.

You put it nicely, but there are more aspects of nationalism from what you've focused on.

There is healthy nationalism, as our great visioner Goce Delchev have stated:
"Јас го разбирам светот единствено како поле за културен натпревар меѓу народите"

"I understand the world solely as a field for cultural competition among nations"
 
SF that's an interesting view. I would like to point out the many types of nationalism's as defined by Michael Hechter;

"It is widely appreciated that there are important differences between nationalist movements. Much effort has been made to create typologies that aim to capture some of the relevant distinctions (see, for example, Hall 1993). Most of these distinguish the liberal, culturally inclusive (Sleeping Beauty) nationalisms characteristic of Western Europe from the illiberal, culturally exclusive (Frankenstein's monster) nationalisms more often found elsewhere. Whereas these normative differences between nationalist movements have been enormously important in history, it is doubtful that they can be explained if the dimensions of nationalism are chosen on normative grounds. To explain why nationalism has taken such different forms in different societies, it is better to seek a typology that is derived from analytical considerations.

"If nationalism is collective action designed to render the boundaries of the nation congruent with those of its governance unit, then a simple analytic typology of nationalism flows directly out of this definition. Further, this typology helps account for the normative differences between types of nationalism.

"State-building nationalism is the nationalism that is embodied in the attempt to assimilate or incorporate culturally distinctive territories in a given state. It is the result of the conscious efforts of central rulers to make a multicultural population culturally homogeneous. Thus, beginning in the sixteenth century and continuing into the twentieth, the rulers of England and France attempted fitfully perhaps, and with more or less success-to foster homogeneity in their realms by inducing culturally distinctive populations in each country's Celtic regions to assimilate to their own culture. Since the rationale for state-building nationalism is often geopolitical - to secure borders from real or potential rivals - this kind of nationalism tends to be culturally inclusive. However, much less liberal means of skinning a culturally homogeneous cat have been resorted to in history, as well. Central rulers of a given culture also can unify their country by expelling culturally alien populations (as in the Spanish Reconquista), or by exterminating them (often the fate of the indigenous peoples of North America).

"Peripheral nationalism occurs when a culturally distinctive territory resists incorporation into an expanding state, or attempts to secede and set up its own government (as in Quebec, Scotland and Catalonia). Often this type of nationalism is spurred by the the very efforts of state-building nationalism described above.

"Irredentist nationalism occurs with the attempt to extend the existing boundaries of a state by incorporating territories of an adjacent state occupied principally by co-nationals (as in the case of the Sudeten Germans).

"Finally, unification nationalism involves the merger of a politically divided but culturally homogeneous territory into one state, as famously occurred in nineteenth-century Germany and Italy. In this case, the effort to render cultural and governance boundaries congruent requires the establishment of a new state encompassing the members of the nation. Whereas state-building nationalism tends to be culturally inclusive, unification nationalism is often culturally exclusive.

"Although patriotism - the desire to raise the prestige and power of one's own nation state relative to rivals in the international system - is often considered to be nationalistic, the present definition rules this usage out. Patriotism is no form of nationalism at all, for here the boundaries of the nation and governance unit are already congruent. This limitation is not, however, very damaging. Since few states, if any, qualify as nation states, patriotism (as defined in this book) hardly exists. Most of what passes as patriotism in common parlance implicitly advances the interests of one nation at the expense of others in multinational states. In the present framework, such activities are instances of state-building nationalism.

"The preceding typology is not exhaustive. It has no place for nationalist movements - like Zionism and Mormonism - that resulted from the migration of religious groups to distant promised lands. Such movements have been exceedingly rare, however..."

Hechter, Michael. Containing Nationalism. Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press, 2000. See pages 15-17.

http://www.nationalismproject.org/what.htm
 
I accept that it depends on which definition of nationalism you agree with before you can say it is a bad or good thing.
TrueMacedonian said:
patriotism - the desire to raise the prestige and power of one's own nation state relative to rivals in the international system
This definition of patriotism defies what sf has said earlier. It sounds like all that many appear to hate about nationalism.

If we accept the following statement from TM's last post:
nationalism is a collective action designed to render the boundaries of the nation congruent with those of its governance unit

Is nationalism good for Macedonia?
 
I accept that it depends on which definition of nationalism you agree with before you can say it is a bad or good thing.

This is true.

patriotism - the desire to raise the prestige and power of one's own nation state relative to rivals in the international system

This definition of patriotism defies what sf has said earlier. It sounds like all that many appear to hate about nationalism.

It's an unusual definition, one probably similar to Bratot's view on healthy forms of nationalism.

If we accept the following statement from TM's last post:

nationalism is a collective action designed to render the boundaries of the nation congruent with those of its governance unit

Is nationalism good for Macedonia?

Our nation exists outside the boundaries of our state. How would you answer this last question?
 
It's an unusual definition, one probably similar to Bratot's view on healthy forms of nationalism.
If you think about it, it is quite reasonable. You think it is about being in love with your country. But why love your country? What is so special about it? Clearly you love it because it is better than all other countries. Otherwise you would not love it. By declaring your love for your country (in a patriotic way), you are declaring there is none better.

I think nationalism can come from patriotism.

Our nation exists outside the boundaries of our state. How would you answer this last question?

I would then refer to TM's post above which includes an assessment of such a scenario such that:
"Finally, unification nationalism involves the merger of a politically divided but culturally homogeneous territory into one state, as famously occurred in nineteenth-century Germany and Italy. In this case, the effort to render cultural and governance boundaries congruent requires the establishment of a new state encompassing the members of the nation. Whereas state-building nationalism tends to be culturally inclusive, unification nationalism is often culturally exclusive.

I would say we would fail in this regard in Greece because of their strategy to de-homogenise the population. Bulgaria represents a greater opportunity due to the lack of population transfers and closer cultural elements.

But that has nothing to do with my question about whether nationalism is good for Macedonia.
 
If you think about it, it is quite reasonable. You think it is about being in love with your country. But why love your country? What is so special about it? Clearly you love it because it is better than all other countries. Otherwise you would not love it. By declaring your love for your country (in a patriotic way), you are declaring there is none better.

Then you do not understand me. I love Macedonia and the Macedonians because they are my people and it's my culture and heritage. This is why I want to see the country and people prosper. It has nothing to do with notions of superiority. Do I believe that Macedonians are better? No. Worse? No. People are generally the same the world over.




But that has nothing to do with my question about whether nationalism is good for Macedonia.

There's no need to go in circles here. We've established that the assessment of the notions depends on the definition used. I provided my definitions/interpretations and based my answers on this.
 
Then you do not understand me. I love Macedonia and the Macedonians because they are my people and it's my culture and heritage. This is why I want to see the country and people prosper. It has nothing to do with notions of superiority. Do I believe that Macedonians are better? No. Worse? No. People are generally the same the world over.
I want to see Macedonia prosper too. I accept that other nations will potentially have to suffer for Macedonia to be better off. We are indeed talking about competition amongst nations and should take note of Delchev's famous quote. You want lovely things for Macedonia and choose to look at the rosier side of things.


There's no need to go in circles here. We've established that the assessment of the notions depends on the definition used. I provided my definitions/interpretations and based my answers on this.
Your opinion appears to be as follows:
sf. said:
People here have spoken about secret conspiracies (eg Brandeburg), but the evidence is there in plain sight. And nationalism, with its focus on states and outdated political concepts, doesn't account for the imminent dangers brought on by the nwo.
I am not trying to attack you in any way. Just trying to make sense of your conclusions. Are you suggesting a better development for Macedonia would bypass nationalism? What would it entail?
 
I'm not sure that it is right in purpose and correct in definition to equate Nationalism with some sort of zero-sum notion.
 
Edit: @ RTG

OK, perhaps I'm not being understood here. Let's try a little exercise.

I don't know you personally, but from your posts here and the testimonials others have posted, I feel I understand your character well and that we're more on the same page than you think. So with confidence, I would like you to indulge me for a moment and contemplate the following (I don't want or expect an answer here): how would you describe your character, values, and role in society (professional, personal, family relationships)? Who or what experiences instilled these in you? How do these inform your actions as a man?

Now think of someone that you personally know that perhaps rubs you the wrong way. What is so disagreeable about this person?

Then reflect on my argument. If you still don't understand my POV after this, then no amount of words I expend here will suffice.
 
sf., I will let you know what colour jocks I wear later. (My hint is Red & Gold)
I am still trying to understand your argument. What are you actually saying? I think it is "Patriotism is good, nationalism is bad ... nationalism is out of date we need something new" ??

What is it?
How do we replace "nationalism" with something else and develop a future for Macedonia?
 
Back
Top