Pelister
New member
"They call themselves Macedonians"
I thought I'd introduce this brief analysis of the typical colonial narrative of Macedonia, in order to bring to light some of the assumptions, and presumptions that forces historically outside the region of Macedonia have been pushing in the effort of influencing the mind and thoughts of Westerners as to who lived there, and what they called themselves.
Example 1 of the colonial legacy.
Book: The Macedonian Problem and Its Proper Solution, by Dr. Stanislav J. Shoomkof and George N. Chakaloff, M.D (1904).
The typical Bulgarian colonial narrative:
Macedonia Ill-defined and 'mixed
No Macedonian Nationality / No 'distinctive' Macedonian
Appeals to objectivity
nb: the assumption here is that the 'testimonies of foriegn writers' are reliable. This leads the way for introduction of Westerners who represent the regions inhabitants as 'Bulgarian'/.
What they call themselves
The use of European 'classifications' and 'statistics'
A couple things to note about this colonial narrative.
1. We never actually here from the Macedonians themselves\
2. The narrative must assume that what these Westerners have to say about the Macedonian demographic is 'objective' and reliable.
3. Once again, it is a case of foriegners and outsiders (Bulgarians, Greeks, Serbians...etc), informing foriegners and outsiders (Westerners), about the state of things on the ground, and then recycling the representations, again and again.
Any evidence that "they call themselves Macedonians" directly challenges the interpretive mischief and propoganda in this kind of colonial narrative.
I thought I'd introduce this brief analysis of the typical colonial narrative of Macedonia, in order to bring to light some of the assumptions, and presumptions that forces historically outside the region of Macedonia have been pushing in the effort of influencing the mind and thoughts of Westerners as to who lived there, and what they called themselves.
Example 1 of the colonial legacy.
Book: The Macedonian Problem and Its Proper Solution, by Dr. Stanislav J. Shoomkof and George N. Chakaloff, M.D (1904).
The typical Bulgarian colonial narrative:
Macedonia Ill-defined and 'mixed
"It is almost impossible to form a definite idea as to the extent of territory to which the name 'Macedonia' would imply". p.12
A "conglomerate of races", p. 13
No Macedonian Nationality / No 'distinctive' Macedonian
"It must be remembered at the outset that there is no such race as 'Macedonians' if we mean to describe the national affiliations of the people by that term", p.13
Appeals to objectivity
In order to arrive at an impartial and just conclusion as to the character and number of the Macedonian population, we must resort to the testimonies of foriegn writers who have travelled through the country and are competent to give accurate information, p.13
nb: the assumption here is that the 'testimonies of foriegn writers' are reliable. This leads the way for introduction of Westerners who represent the regions inhabitants as 'Bulgarian'/.
What they call themselves
In this province we find people who call themselves and are known to be Bulgarians
The use of European 'classifications' and 'statistics'
"According to Herr Ritter...the remaining population, i.e., 1,117,643, are Bulgarians.", p.14
A couple things to note about this colonial narrative.
1. We never actually here from the Macedonians themselves\
2. The narrative must assume that what these Westerners have to say about the Macedonian demographic is 'objective' and reliable.
3. Once again, it is a case of foriegners and outsiders (Bulgarians, Greeks, Serbians...etc), informing foriegners and outsiders (Westerners), about the state of things on the ground, and then recycling the representations, again and again.
Any evidence that "they call themselves Macedonians" directly challenges the interpretive mischief and propoganda in this kind of colonial narrative.
Last edited: