• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

The book that should not exist, Macedonian-Greek lexicon from 1907!

These were among the most insignificant, poor and mountainous areas populated by Greeks. That was actually, one of the reasons why revolution started there. It was the most remote part of Ottoman Empire. The biggest city was probably Tripoli/Tripolitsa, I doubt there was even a printery in it.


Yes, current southern Greece was the remote part of the Empire but that was probably the least important reason.

The most important reasons was;
Because it was impossible to convince the Greeks of Istanbul for a revolt at that time. They were proud to be considered as the descendants of Roman Empire. They were considering themselves as Romans and there was no such a thing called "Hellas" existed for them at 1820s. Also they were enjoying the privileges given to them by the Turks, like controlling all the Christians in Ottoman Empire. Similarly, Greeks of Izmir was also happy to live there by being merchants and tradesmen. Just in case if you didn't know, Salonika and Izmir was Europe`s biggest commercial ports at 19th century and the population of Italian and French tradesmen in Izmir, called as "Levantines", was even more than local Greeks.

As for the central Anatolia. Greek population wasn't more than %1 already. Cappadocians and in broader term, Karamanlides people was just christian Turks since 12th century. They published books, magazines and spoke in Turkish only. Even the patriarchy of Istanbul was publishing and delivering Turkish bibles to them.

So, what left? The peasants of current southern Greece. The nomadic shepherd Vlachs with black headscarfs, christian Albanians with their white skirts and some other romaika speaking people. But these revolting peasants wasn't the big factor, but their financiers was.
 
Which notable Greeks during this period were born in the borders of 1821 Greece? How many Vlachs and Albanians counted as 'Greeks'?
Greekhistory.GIF

Here's a list of the most notable Greeks from that period (1400-1800) born in the area of Peloponnisos-Roumeli (the blue part of the map). I have noted aside when someone is Vlach or Arvanite.
This is a subjective view. You may notify me, if I have forgotten someone important or have made any mistakes.

15th Century
Constantine XI Palaiologos (born in Mistra) last Roman Emperor
Helena Palaiologina (born in Mistra) Queen of Cyprus and Armenia
Krokodilos Kladas (probably born in Bardunia of Mani) military leader in the Turkish-Venetian wars and the 1480s insurgency
Theodoros Bua (probably born in Angelokastro) military leader in the 1480s insurgency (Arvanite)
Maximos III (=Manuel Christonymos) Patriarch of Constantinople
Dionysios I (born in Dimitsana) Patriarch of Constantinople
Nyfon II (born in Messinia) Patriarch of Constantinople
Laonikos Halkokondylis (born in Athens) historian
Antonios Pyropoulos (born in Koroni), religious author and monk
Georgios Ermonymos (=Charitonymos or Spartiatis) (born in Sparta) religious author, teacher and monk

16th Century
Mercurios Bua (probably born in Angelokastro) military leader of Greek mercenaries, mostly for Venetians (Arvanite)
Thomas Eleavoulkos (born in Koroni), theologian, monk
Manouel Malaxos (born in Nafplio), translator, minor poet and historian
Saint Filothei (=Paraskevi Benizelou) (born in Athens), nun, teacher and philanthropist
Symeon Kavasilas (born in Akarnania) translator and author
Gabriel Seviros (born in Monemvasia) author, bishop of Philadelphia, Lydia
Ioannis Zigomalas (born in Nafplio) author
Theodosios Zigomalas (born in Nafplio) author, historian, philologist
Antonio Millo (born in Milos) chartographer

17th Century
Leonardos Philaras (born in Athens) diplomat and advisor to the French Court
Liberakis Gerakaris (born in Itilos), Pirate, Bay of Mani
Philotheos (Charitopoulos) (born in Agia Efthymia) Bishop of Salona, leader of the 1680s insurgency during the Turkish-Venetian war
Callinicos II (=Poulos or Akarnan, born in Kastania, Agrafa) Patriarch of Constantinople
Dionysios III Vardalis (born in Andros) Patriarch of Constantinople
Eugenious the Aetolian (=Ioannoulis, born in Mega Dendron) Author, Priest, Teacher, Saint
Antonios Vasilakis (=Antonio Vassilacchi, born in Milos) Painter

18th Century
Panayiotis Benakis (born in Kalamata) merchant, financier of the 1770s Orlov insurgency
Pieros (Ilias) Mavromichalis (born in Mani) leader in the 1770s Orlov insurgency
Labros Katsonis (born in Livadia) admiral of Russian Navy in the 1780s Russian-Turkish war
Nicholas Mavrogenes (born in Paros) Prince of Wallachia
Cosmas of Aetolia (=Kostas Dimitrou, born in Mega Dendro) Saint, prophet, monk
Macarius of Corinth (born in Corinth) Bishop of Corinth, author, philosopher of Hesychasm
Nicodemus the Hagiorite (=Nicholas Kallivourtsis, born in Naxos) author, philosopher of Hesychasm
Serapheim I (born in Akarnania) Patriarch of Constantinople
Cyril V (born in Dimitsana) Patriarch of Constantinople
Prokopios (Pelekasis) (born in Sitsova/Alagonia) Patriarch of Constantinople
Gregory V (=Georgios Angelopoulos, born in Dimitsana) Patriarch of Constantinople
Athanasios Parios (born in Paros) theologian, philosopher, hymnographer
Dionysious of Fourna (=Chalkias, born in Fourna) hagiographer
Panagiotis Doxaras (born in Katifori of Mani) painter
Nikolaos Doxaras (born in Kalamata) painter
______________________________________
Odysseas Elytis - Our name is our soul
 
Last edited:
Lets start with the first name you posted.

Constantine XI Palaiologos (born in Mistra)

Apart from being known as a "Roman Emperor"

His mother was what you would call a "Slav". Helena Dragaš, the daughter of the Serbian prince Constantine Dragaš

His Father was Manuel II Palaiologus.
Now Manuel II was the son of Emperor John V Palaiologus, who's mother was "Anna of Savoy" (born Giovanna) who was the second wife of "Andronikos III" and had had four children:

*Maria (renamed Eirene) Palaiologina (1327 - after 1356), who married Michael Asen IV оf Bulgaria. Her husband was the eldest son of Ivan Alexander of Bulgaria and his first wife Theodora of Wallachia.

*Michael Palaiologos, despotes (1337 - before 1370). He entered the court of Stefan Uroš IV Dušan of Serbia in 1351/1352.

*John V Palaiologos (18 June 1332 - 16 February 1391).

*Eirene (renamed Maria) (d. 1401), who married Francesco I of Lesbos






Manuel II maternal grandparents were Emperor John VI Kantakouzenos (1347–1354) and Irene Asanina.

Now try and stay with me if you can,

Irene's paternal Grand parents were "Ivan Asen III of Bulgaria" (the name "Asen sounds a bit suspect, but Early rulers from the Asen dynasty (particularly Kaloyan) referred to themselves as "Emperors of Bulgarians and Vlachs").


So thats how we get the term "its all Greek to me" Bloody confusing isn't it. :huh:

But if you really think about it, and it should not be that hard, You would conclude that, Just like modern Greeks (who are a mixed race) that are not realy Greeks, neither was Constantine.


(A Monthly Review – Greece, Spoilt Child of Europe)

QUOTE: "…….It was during these centuries, that what remained, if indeed anything remained, of even degenerate Hellenic blood absorbed or was absorbed into that of the Slav……"

But it gets worse for you thessa

QUOTE: "Indeed, the Albanians appear to have done for Greece in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries something like that which that Sclavonians had done in the sixth and seventh…"
 
Last edited:
Manuel II maternal grandparents were Emperor John VI Kantakouzenos (1347–1354) and Irene Asanina.

Now try and stay with me if you can,

Irene's paternal Grand parents were "Ivan Asen III of Bulgaria" (the name "Asen sounds a bit suspect, but Early rulers from the Asen dynasty (particularly Kaloyan) referred to themselves as "Emperors of Bulgarians and Vlachs").


Asen dynasty was founded by Cuman-Kipchak Turks;

clipboard33m.jpg


"Cumans and Tatars: Oriental Military in the Pre-Ottoman Balkans, 1185-1365" by Istvan Vasary;

http://www.macedoniantruth.org/forum/showthread.php?p=52110#post52110



"Asena" means wolf, "Terterids" means Tatars, "Shismanids" means stouts and "Basarabids" means ruling father in Turkish. While "Basar-aba" is kinda old Turkic but we still use the words "şişman", "tatar" and "asena"(as a name only) today in Turkish.
 
Last edited:
Were Still waiting for a pure greek to show up Vlachos in your archives :1eye:


Good info Bill77

Ps Bill i love your avatar! Ajde Ajde! :gunsmilie:
 
You can download the book here:

http://anemi.lib.uoc.gr/metadata/1/6/f/metadata-292-0000004.tkl

At the bottom of the page you press download book and you type the number you'll see in the picture. I took a quick look, there's an extended vocabulary where he tries to relate what he calls Slav-like Macedonian words with Greek words (ancient or modern). Unfortunately, this is in Greek (published in 1907) and Macedonian words are also in Greek script.

This is 200 pages, of which 175 is the vocabulary.

A superficial opinion; this doesn't seem very good, but it's a start and a reference point. I can't see Homeric references. Usually, there's a Greek word or name and a similar Macedonian one, but the rate of similarity and the real origin of the words is not scrutinised. For instance, the word may be... Italian. Sometimes, the two words (of which the meaning is often explained) do not even seem similar enough.

I would like to write a few examples (probably the first 5-10 pairs in letter A) but I don't understand the (very) first ones! (Now, that is a bad start). I'll give you the first ones in letter T:

Tabla-Tabla (table)
Taxis-Tax (class?)
Tarasso-Tresam (to shake)
Tazo-Taxam (to promise)
Tekea-Decham (children)
Tekos-Dette (child)
Teino-Tegnam (to stress)
Tekmairomai-Teknam (conjecture)
Teiro-Terram (to persecute)
Ekteiro-Isterram (to persecute)
....

They are transliterated (by me) from Greek to Latin script.

….
 
Last edited:
ss i read somewhere that homer wrote in the pelazgian language.No wonder we understand those words today in modern Macedonian.Tegnam to stress.dette child deca children.etc etc.You are showing us greek writing of the 15th century .I can't bear to read in greek let alone understand it.BUt homers writings can be understood with modern Macedonian words.Of course you guys carry on that its all greek which it isn't.What it does prove that there were many different tribes of Macedonian origin .Pelazgians was one.
I'm told that the 16 rays of sun on the Macedonian sun symbol represent the 16 Macedonian tribes in Macedonia.That's one of many things we know also that HOMER wrote in the pelazgian language.So your govt stole our Macedonian sun symbol not fully realising what it really stood for.
Also iread that homer wrote about the Mycenian world and not the greek world which is totally different.
 
Last edited:
ss i read somewhere that homer wrote in the pelazgian language. That's one of many things we know also that HOMER wrote in the pelazgian language.

No, he wrote in Greek of his time, in a language that is considered distant to typical classical Greek because it’s not Attic and it is 2-3 centuries earlier. It’s a mix of dialects mostly Ionic (also Aeolic and others). These dialects were spoken in the districts surrounding Attica.

No wonder we understand those words today in modern Macedonian.

Actually you don’t understand it. Or, at least, you haven’t still told us which words you understand and why.

Tegnam to stress. dette child deca children.etc etc.You are showing us greek writing of the 15th century. I can't bear to read in greek let alone understand it. BUt homers writings can be understood with modern Macedonian words. Of course you guys carry on that its all greek which it isn't.

This is a lexicon from 1907, not 15th century. The Macedonian words are modern words of the time including many local peasant words. The Greek words are… about anything ranging from antiquity until 1900 including also local, peasant, slang and words of foreign origins, craftsman words etc.

What it does prove that there were many different tribes of Macedonian origin. Pelazgians was one.

No, Pelasgians are not related to Macedonians. Pelasgians were not a Macedonian tribe. Macedonians were not a Pelasgian tribe. I understand it’s not very clear what Pelasgians were and I see you already checked and copied the Wikipedia article. Well, inside this article and among the many contradictory references you should pay more attention to the extended ones coming from historians (e.g. Herodotus).

I'm told that the 16 rays of sun on the Macedonian sun symbol represent the 16 Macedonian tribes in Macedonia.

That’s not true. Similarly, various imaginative Greek interpretations you can find in the internet are not true either. There isn’t a specific meaning in the symbols of 8, 12 or 16 rays except for the quarter symmetry. There isn’t any ancient reference to such an interpretation.

So your govt stole our Macedonian sun symbol not fully realising what it really stood for.

Greece blocked you from using this symbol in your flag or as a national symbol. From our point of view your state is unrelated to ancient Macedonia.

Also I read that homer wrote about the Mycenian world and not the greek world which is totally different.

Nope. Iliad describes a pan-hellenic campaign against Troy, with the main characters coming from all Greek kingdoms (and Troy of course). Odyssey takes place abroad (in the Mediterranean Sea), the protagonist is the King of Ithaca.


==
 
Last edited:
ss first of all you have gl;ossed over a lot of things homer writing in greek of his time.THe greeks weren't around the time homer is writing .Its about mycenians and not
greeks.The greeks hadn't arrived yet so how can he write in greek.You call pelazgian language classic greek.THere are a lot of words in the illiad (illi in Macedonian) is the sun god.Not in greek.Rubbish the greeks arrived in the greek peninsular centuries later where they adopted the phonecian alphabet .The Macedonians were already in Macedonia much much earlier than the greeks.What a joke you aren't really indigenous to the greek?peninsular.You call it typical greek How can it be when the greek language wasn't around!
The fact is we do understand Homeric writings as the words are similar to today's Macedonian Proof that greeks weren't around that time & also the diversity of people.
You say you have 4000 Years of GREEK HISTORY in a book you only have been around for 3000 years that is a big lie.Macedonians existed prior to your greeks and homer wrote about a time Prior to greeks coming to Greece.IF you can't accept that then you got a problem that the greeks didn't even exist then.Also remember the war with troy the Macedonians WERE EXCLUDED from participating because THEY were not greek centuries later.Why weren't Macedonians included because greek & Macedonians were NOT the SAME.But today you go on as if its all greek to you.Check the words in the illiad you will find hundreds or even thousands of words that are strictly Macedonian.That is proof that our language has retained quite a large amount of words with their roots in Macedonian not GREEK.IF you search you will see How much actrual greek words there are.Makes a mockery of your claims that is all greek.
A good many people are awakening to the lies & deceit you are peddling,for a time even your learnered people did it but now they come to a realization that its not laa greek & its cracked up to be.Before the greeks there were different people on the greek peninsular I say GREEK with reservation as the people were totally different to the greeks.You call that classical greek of course you call it even when you wasn't around then
 
Last edited:
ss first of all you have gl;ossed over a lot of things homer writing in greek of his time.THe greeks weren't around the time homer is writing.

According to Herodotus, Homer lived and composed his work around 850 BC. Modern scholars tend to put him earlier and earlier, in 700s or even 650BC. Either way, Greeks (including Homer) were certainly there.

Its about mycenians and not greeks.

Mycenians were Greeks too, but it’s not solely about Mycenians. Homer uses various epithets for Greeks, he mostly calls them Achaeans, but also Argives, Danaans and rarely (actually once) Hellenes and pan-Hellenes. All these names are used alternately for the Greek side that campaigned against Troy.

The greeks hadn't arrived yet so how can he write in greek.

They had “arrived” far earlier.

You call pelazgian language classic greek.

Pelasgians are irrelevant to the discussion. I referred to Greek language of the classic era meaning the attic dialect of Plato, Aristotle, Euripides etc. That is what most foreigners (and modern Greeks) study and learn and mean when they refer to “ancient Greek”. Yet, not everything Greek is Attic. For instance, Sappho’s poetry is not in Attic.

THere are a lot of words in the illiad (illi in Macedonian) is the sun god. Not in greek.

Iliad (Ilias in Greek) comes from Ilion (an alternate name for Troy) which in turn comes from King Ilus, the founder of Troy. Ilus is not related to Helios (the Sun). It was written with a digamma (FI), pronounced Wilus.

Rubbish the greeks arrived in the greek peninsular centuries later where they adopted the phonecian alphabet. The Macedonians were already in Macedonia much much earlier than the greeks. What a joke you aren't really indigenous to the greek? peninsular. You call it typical greek How can it be when the greek language wasn't around!

The Greek alphabet is different from the Phoenician that was only a consonantal alphabet. It was adopted around 800s BC. Previously to that, it was the era of (what is now called) Linear B.

The fact is we do understand Homeric writings as the words are similar to today's Macedonian Proof that greeks weren't around that time & also the diversity of people.

Actually, I have understood that you understand shit!

You say you have 4000 Years of GREEK HISTORY in a book you only have been around for 3000 years that is a big lie.

The origin of Greek history is of course unclear. Linear A is not deciphered yet, but Linear B is considered Greek and connects distant kingdoms of Crete and Mycenae to one entity. This is around 1600-1200 BC. Linear A starts around 1800 BC. So, it’s safe to say we have a Greek historical period of around 3500-3800 years.

Macedonians existed prior to your greeks and homer wrote about a time Prior to greeks coming to Greece.IF you can't accept that then you got a problem that the greeks didn't even exist then.

Homer does not refer to Macedonians, which is probably an indication they were not called Macedonians at the time. On the contrary he refers to Paeonians in the area we today understand as Macedonia.

Also remember the war with troy the Macedonians WERE EXCLUDED from participating because THEY were not greek centuries later.Why weren't Macedonians included because greek & Macedonians were NOT the SAME.

The Paeonians (according to Homer) were indeed fighting on the side of Trojans.

But today you go on as if its all greek to you. Check the words in the illiad you will find hundreds or even thousands of words that are strictly Macedonian. That is proof that our language has retained quite a large amount of words with their roots in Macedonian not GREEK. IF you search you will see How much actrual greek words there are. Makes a mockery of your claims that is all greek.

Actually all the words are Greek. Their origins (if possible) can be discussed. I don’t have to check anything. It is you who has to do the checking and point out one or two of these “hundreds or even thousands of words that are strictly Macedonian”. We haven’t seen even one yet.

A good many people are awakening to the lies & deceit you are peddling,for a time even your learnered people did it but now they come to a realization that its not laa greek & its cracked up to be.Before the greeks there were different people on the greek peninsular I say GREEK with reservation as the people were totally different to the greeks.You call that classical greek of course you call it even when you wasn't around then.

Maybe, you don’t understand what Greek is, or you have a personal definition about Greek people or language. You will have to share it with the rest of the world, as Homer’s work is universally considered a prominent part of Greek poetry.


---------
 
Last edited:
homers poetry is about mycenians that you have so easily adopted as greeks.It is about people who were on the greek?peninsular prior to the greeks.Your claims are bs .You weren't around.Homer wasNOT a GREEK that you claim ,.He was born in asia mynor.The words ili are the name of the Macedonian sun god Not Greek.Odyssey is a Macedonian word Not greek.How you can just gloss & deny things is beyond me .Its all propaganda to you.
You mention the paeonians not fighting on the greek side but on the Trojans side.Whats that got to do with the price of fish.WE are talking greeks not Macedonians.Obviously you got the two mixed up.At one point your so called greek writers were saying the Trojans were similar to the greeks that is a lie.You said that homer was around 800 bc but that's when you got your alphabet how can you be called a newcomer to the area & still claim prior history such as "being around"" constitute.The so called GREEK classical era is not cracked out to be ANYTHING but greek.What makes you an authority on what is greek & what isn't.YOu just take(steal) in ancient times and call it your own.Funny that you did it in 1913 to Macedonia.Funny that.A lot of the words DO form our Macedonian words that you call slav are our words & there is nothing you can say or do to change that .You can't accept that.You are just deniars.SLAV is used mainly as a derogatory words.One finally realizes that our language originally comes from the ancient Macedonian.So don't use the slav terminology here its from your greek buddies.
 
Last edited:
Homer wasNOT a GREEK that you claim ,.He was born in asia mynor.

Homer's birthplace (or deathplace) are unknown, but Asia Minor (Ionia) was Greek too.

At one point your so called greek writers were saying the Trojans were similar to the greeks that is a lie.

Ancient Greek authors respect Trojans, but don't consider them Greeks. This may be because there were no Trojans at their time.

What makes you an authority on what is greek & what isn't.

I guess the fact that I can read and understand Greek makes me an authority. I would never argue that a Swedish text is actually Danish.
 
Why are the greeks so hell bent on saying there are NO Slavic WORDS full stop.We need to look at the original texts in the PELASGIAN NOT greek texts .There was a time when evidence was deliberately destroyed so that it ALL agrees with their ideology.Nothing new about greek propaganda or Bulgarian etc
Why are the greeks so hell bent on saying there are NO Slavic WORDS full stop.We need to look at the original texts in the PELASGIAN NOT greek texts .There was a time when evidence was deliberately destroyed so that it ALL agrees with their ideology.Nothing new about greek propaganda or Bulgarian etc
On one side you got falsified texts on the other you got texts that prove the Macedonian existence as distinct from greek,Arrian,plutarch etc.These are texts that haven't been tampered.How about the literary crusade of the 200 million dollars to bribe greek journalists to write
Macedonia is greek.THat offer was open to Macedonian journalists money for comment that Macedonia is greek.The other thing is that texts have been revised & rewritten in schools.There has been a greater emphasis on the Macedonia is greek.Why because the greek govt has upped the ante.It's all to counteract is the fact the Rom govt. has tried to seek independeence.Can one imagine another govt interfering in the affairs of another,vetoing for the sake to stop all recognition of rom.THe so called red line was Greece's concession to Macedonia.Fyrom was a another so called concession what is Greece is hiding from.?
Look at the way it behaves towards Macedonia calling people Bulgarians slavophones etc when they themselves are nothing but roms,albanians,vlachs etc except greeks of who it says is pure.Yes its got a lot to hide.The same thing can be said of Macedonian history that they try & appropriate it now they are calling themselves Macedonians.Confusing yes??How confusing is it when it says there are NO MACEDONIANS in the Aegean area.
 
Last edited:
Why are the greeks so hell bent on saying there are NO Slavic WORDS full stop.We need to look at the original texts in the PELASGIAN NOT greek texts .There was a time when evidence was deliberately destroyed so that it ALL agrees with their ideology.Nothing new about greek propaganda or Bulgarian etc

Slavs arrived at the area more than a millennium later; finding Slavic elements in Homer seems (from the starting point) problematic, so I’m curiously waiting. If a Greek word is used in Slavic languages it may be the other way around (taken from Greeks), it may be a sign of a distant (unknown) common past, it may even be a coincidence. Words as domos (house), odos (way) etc. have more than a 1000 years of continuous documented use in Greek literature before appearing in the Slavonic one (if they do).

What you see in the internet are the Homeric texts as (officially) written down in the 500s BC. Pelasgians are not related to Homer or any literature.

That leads us to the paradox that if you want to seriously support and advance your propaganda (whatever it is) you will have to study Greek, i.e. you will have to do the thing you jubilantly claimed you managed to avoid.

On one side you got falsified texts on the other you got texts that prove the Macedonian existence as distinct from greek,Arrian,plutarch etc.These are texts that haven't been tampered.

Which ancient texts are tampered or falsified?

How about the literary crusade of the 200 million dollars to bribe greek journalists to write
Macedonia is greek.THat offer was open to Macedonian journalists money for comment that Macedonia is greek.The other thing is that texts have been revised & rewritten in schools.There has been a greater emphasis on the Macedonia is greek.Why because the greek govt has upped the ante.It's all to counteract is the fact the Rom govt. has tried to seek independeence.Can one imagine another govt interfering in the affairs of another,vetoing for the sake to stop all recognition of rom.THe so called red line was Greece's concession to Macedonia.Fyrom was a another so called concession what is Greece is hiding from.?
Look at the way it behaves towards Macedonia calling people Bulgarians slavophones etc when they themselves are nothing but roms,albanians,vlachs etc except greeks of who it says is pure.Yes its got a lot to hide.The same thing can be said of Macedonian history that they try & appropriate it now they are calling themselves Macedonians.Confusing yes??How confusing is it when it says there are NO MACEDONIANS in the Aegean area.

YOU are confusing. Not the situation.
 
AM I confusing the siyuation I think you are when you see the reality you are taking your biased govts attitude to all this it actually coincides with that.
your answers are too simplistric why you say that the slavs arrived in the 6 or seven centuries.WE ARE TALKING OF PROTO SLAVIC WORDS.THESE ARE NOT GREEK WORDS these are prior to the greeks.
THese proto Slavic words were in the pelasgian language,illyrian ,Macedonian, There is a clear distinction you are good at denying the existence.Also the greeks go on as if they were immune from Slavic influences you go on that its a VERY BAD thing & you think ITs altered the people .THe greeks were subject to the same influences yet they have retained their identity.THE MACEDONIANS HAVE HAD CELTS<ROMANS LAVS etc go through them with slight linguistic effects.YOU are UTTERLY wrong when you say we are just slavs.YOU ARE SLAVS TOO BY THE SAME LOGIC.
IT is written that the same slavs WENT through HELLAS.
SO you are hypocritical when you put labels on things.AS I have said prior to 1913 Macedonia was in its entirety as a country your govt along with 3 others decided to just take the Macedonian lands but they forgot that there were MACEDONIAN people of which they label falsly as SLAVS.Its all to justify to keep and a pretext to keep Macedonian lands.
WE do know the real reason you want to keep OUR lands of which your govt occupied illegally.SO to justify everything your govt in 1913 merely took what was not theirs .STOLE is the word.TO justify what it took they said that there are no Macedonians in the Aegean area.The Macedonians were greeks ,triedto twist history aroundby rewriting it with a greek slant PROPAGANDA stuff here.
SO in effect because WE know the REAL TRUTH you have no justification to hold on to the Macedonian lands.JUst as you are a manufactured people after 1832.For the first time a consolidated COUNTRY.CAlled GREECE.YOU can't decide who you are today you think you are Macedonian.If greeks & Macedonians were the same people .Why did the romans create TWO distinct PROVINCES.ALso why did Greece wage wars together joining the romans against the Macedonians Why did Greece wage ANTI MACEDONIAN wars against Macedonia if THEY were THE SAME>??
There is a clear distinction that ALL is not greek,WE can see the fallacy in your arguments as you argue for your govts Policies.NO use to aergue with us as we go to the heart of the issue.Just picture your logic if anyone speaks greek they MUST be greek.Picture the LOGIC your govt has made sure to muddy the waters about the truth about Macedonia.But they forgot to destroy everything as we have real glimpses that shows a clear distinction of what is Macedonian & what is greek.SO stop lying to yourselves that we are NOT Macedonians & your not Macedonian you are GREEK.
DID I say glimpses because we know today that the Macedonians had their OWN language of which you DENY as well as their existence.YOu called it barbaric Your greeks couldn't understand Macedonian as it was a babble to them Once again clear differences have emerged ,the truth is out you cant JUST assume greek & Macedonian TO BE THE SAME.NO you are the one who is confused here as its all GREEK to you.
a VERY IMPORTANT POINT.While the ethnogenesis of the so-called “ancient Greeks” is based on the composition of the participants in the Trojan War such as the Dannans, Achaeans, Argaeds etc., who were mentioned by Homer in his “Iliad” were presumed by modern Hellenists to be all “Greek people” or

“Hellenic people”, but they were wrong - because according to history, the

“Hellenes” did not colonize the Peloponnesus until 80 years after the

Trojan War.
__________________
 
Last edited:
a VERY IMPORTANT POINT.The ethnogenesis of the so-called “ancient Greeks” is based on the composition of the participants in the Trojan War such as the Dannans, Achaeans, Argaeds etc., who were mentioned by Homer in his “Iliad” were presumed by modern Hellenists to be all “Greek people” or

“Hellenic people”, but they were wrong - because according to history, the

“Hellenes” did not colonize the Peloponnesus until 80 years after the

Trojan War.
 
WE ARE TALKING OF PROTO SLAVIC WORDS.THESE ARE NOT GREEK WORDS these are prior to the greeks.
THese proto Slavic words were in the pelasgian language,illyrian ,Macedonian,

We’re talking a lot about Proto-Slavic words but we’re not seeing them.

Also the greeks go on as if they were immune from Slavic influences you go on that its a VERY BAD thing & you think ITs altered the people .THe greeks were subject to the same influences yet they have retained their identity. THE MACEDONIANS HAVE HAD CELTS<ROMANS LAVS etc go through them with slight linguistic effects.YOU are UTTERLY wrong when you say we are just slavs.YOU ARE SLAVS TOO BY THE SAME LOGIC. IT is written that the same slavs WENT through HELLAS.

Being linguistically Slavic is not a slight influence. It makes it impossible to find out if your people were fully Slavicised or were simply the… Slavs. It’s not the same with Greeks.

SO you are hypocritical when you put labels on things. AS I have said prior to 1913 Macedonia was in its entirety as a country your govt along with 3 others decided to just take the Macedonian lands but they forgot that there were MACEDONIAN people of which they label falsly as SLAVS. Its all to justify to keep and a pretext to keep Macedonian lands.

Actually, the Greek propaganda was naming your people as Macedonians. Your language was impossible to be neglected by anyone who wrote about your people and debated on their nature and identity.

If greeks & Macedonians were the same people .Why did the romans create TWO distinct PROVINCES.ALso why did Greece wage wars together joining the romans against the Macedonians Why did Greece wage ANTI MACEDONIAN wars against Macedonia if THEY were THE SAME>??

The Romans created more than two provinces. Which anti-Macedonian wars are you referring to?
 
THe Macedonians are not slavs and the grereks use it as a derogatory statement.Slav ,slavophone all terms to discredit Macedonians of thei r real glorious heritage,What do I think of greeks they are just frauds you only look at where they all come from;You have a very dishonourable past that's why alexander didn't trust you.Look at what you are doing to Macedonia you have a problem with the name.We don't have a problem.Our name IS our name we are not slavs ,we are not Bulgarians WE ARE THE REAL THING UNLIKE YOUR FAKE GREEK MACEDONIAN.YOu got no right to stand up and call yourselves Macedonians.SO stop pretending you are Macedonians.Remember how you reffered to Macedonians who were the original settlers .ENDOPI.to distinguish from the recent settlers.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top