• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

Knock knock, its God calling

But if morality changes over time, then are you suggesting the Greek occupation of Macedonia was morally good at some stage? Why?

This is a bullshit question. I'm not even going to bother answering it. You know very well what I was alluding to when I discussed morality changes over time.
 
No, I actually don't. You need to be more specific.

Feel free to answer my questions in the previous two posts first.

But for the record I'm referring to things such as abortion, homosexuality, etc.

Also, it is impossible for ALL of the moral grounds adopted thousands of years ago to apply in a modern context. This is because there is no chance that they could've foreseen the type of society we live in today. Cars, computers, etc bring a number of moral issues to the table that weren't relevant a few hundred years ago, let alone thousands of years ago.
 
Last edited:
Refer to my post to Bill. How on earth can you consider someone who commits rape or murder on the same level as someone who steals a loaf of bread to feed their family? Technically they are both sins, and in your view evil, so they are immediately thrown into the same basket in the eyes of God? It's nothing complicated Tom, it just violates my personal view on morality and I'd be extremely worried if you don't see it in the same light. I didn't say God is wrong, I'm questioning His moral compass. But on the flip-side, who are you to tell everyone here that they are wrong and won't be admitted into Heaven for questioning the logic of Christianity? Who are you to say that others who are faithful to another religion won't be accepted into Heaven? If you were born into a Muslim family, you would essentially be a product of such an environment and would likely be here today arguing for their version of events.
Straw man, straw man, straw man. Why is it that you always need to create a straw man? Do you know what straw men are?


I never said anything that I invented myself – I’m simply conveying what God has said.

There is no evidence at all Tom to suggest that a greater being created the universe. Regardless of what you say, there is just none. The problem is, nothing can really explain what existed before the big bang, and what caused it to occur. For this very reason it is possible that a God exists and made it all happen, but unless you were there and saw it with you're own two eyes it is statistically impossibly to verify such an event when you have no evidence. I, and I'm sure many others find it mind-boggling to even imagine the notion of 'nothing' before the big bang. I think our minds are just incapable of projecting or devising such a thought.
Really, no evidence? And yet you’re so sure there was a big bang? I began providing some evidence - more on it below - but you chose to ignore it.

I have created my own universe Tom. Everything I've done in my life has moulded me into the person I am today. I've devised my own rules that I live by and I'll die by. No greater being told me to believe in what I do, it was my own conscious decision.
Where is this universe EM? Can you show it to me? Or is it in your own mind? So you live by your own rules and only by your own rules? Teach me to defy gravity.

Hypothetically speaking, if your children made their own conscious choice to opt out of religion, would you forever hold that against them? Would you try to convert them? Isn't religion all about self-guidance and a kind of awakening? Lecturing others on why they should believe so and so is on the verge of brain-washing. If God loves us, why would he condemn the best of us who are non-religious to Hell, while the worst of us who are religious are given a 'free ticket' so to speak. Like I said earlier, can it really be called Heaven when half the people there could be murderers, rapists, etc? What about all those sell-out Macedonians, I don't know if I'd want to be standing next to them in Heaven.
WTF? Straw man, Straw man, Straw man, Straw man. Random words here completely ignoring what you wrote and just rambling on about nothing…

I don't think I'm 'that' good at all. I'm generally a rather pessimistic person, so I've got no ego problem Tom. Yes, I am guilty of some of those things, but again, how can there possibly be no judgement on a person by person basis?

What about in cases like the one I mentioned earlier? If a father steals a loaf of bread to help his dying son, isn't this a conflict of two different principles? Has God set precedence in such an event? What's stopping people from just putting their faith in God a day before they die? It seems like a rather flexible decision.

Most people who don't believe in God do not demand residence in His Kingdom at all. You know why? Because they don't believe in Him! For them, Heaven does not exist because they do not believe in God. My version of justice is that if Heaven truly does exist, people should be admitted based on their merits, regardless of whether they believe in it or not. Those who have committed horrific crimes should have a higher standard applied to them. What about animals, why aren't they given the same opportunity to put their faith in God? They are God's creations after all...right? I've never seen a dog or cat turning up to church and praising the Lord. They may just be animals, but that doesn't seem very just either.
Nice little universe you’ve created for yourself. After you teach me how to defy gravity, can you teach me to bend other physical laws? Or don’t they exist in your universe where you make the rules that you live by?

Belief and trust IS something. You are giving the church your confidence. All those Catholic families that attended the Catholic church instilled their trust and confidence in the Church, and this was violated with the on-going activity of child sex abuse. This very example shows that belief and trust does amount to giving something. You are giving your time, which evidently gives arise to an opportunity cost.
I put my trust in JESUS. How did you not get that? Where did I say put your trust in a church organisation or a priest or anything else other than JESUS?


I don't have it confused with any cult Tom. Some people donate large amounts of money to the Church. I usually give small donations whenever I attend as well. I believe that people should help others regardless of whether God commands them to or not. It is one of the elements of a decent human being. We shouldn't have to rely on a greater being to tell us to help others, it should be of our own initiative.
What do voluntary donations have to do with your previous comment?


Straw man.

Absolutely certain how? Can you actually back that up with evidence as opposed to just telling me to look outside the window? You ask all these questions, but when the question is reversed you will not be able to provide a viable answer either. That is because there is no definite answer. We will never know how 'something came from nothing.' It is impossible to know. Who created God? Who created the person who created God? It's an never-ending loop that provides no outcome at all.
The question of who created God does not even make sense. It is like asking, “What does blue smell like?” Blue is not in the category of things that have a smell, so the question itself is flawed. In the same way, God is not in the category of things that are created or caused. God is uncaused and uncreated—He simply exists. How do we know this? We know that from nothing, nothing comes. So, if there were ever a time when there was absolutely nothing in existence, then nothing would have ever come into existence. But things do exist. Therefore, since there could never have been absolutely nothing, something had to have always been in existence. That ever-existing thing is what we call God. God is the uncaused Being that caused everything else to come into existence. God is the uncreated Creator who created the universe and everything in it.


Back to looking outside the window – if God does not exist, where did everything come from?


That's what every religion says. 'There can only be one truth.' So who's lying then? Perhaps they are all lying? Perhaps none of them are lying? We will never know.
You'll know one day.
 
Feel free to answer my questions in the previous two posts first.

But for the record I'm referring to things such as abortion, homosexuality, etc.

Also, it is impossible for ALL of the moral grounds adopted thousands of years ago to apply in a modern context. This is because there is no chance that they could've foreseen the type of society we live in today. Cars, computers, etc bring a number of moral issues to the table that weren't relevant a few hundred years ago, let alone thousands of years ago.
What is the etc? ?Don't human rights stem from moral values in your universe? Do you know what moral values are?

Give me an example of something to which Biblical principles do not apply. You said cars and computers - what about them? What moral issues do they pose that aren't covered by God's law? The whole Bible, not just your extremely limited reading of it.

I'll answer your question when you post the full psalm and not just one sentence from it. You know, context and all that stuff.
 
Straw man, straw man, straw man. Why is it that you always need to create a straw man? Do you know what straw men are?


I never said anything that I invented myself – I’m simply conveying what God has said.

Really, no evidence? And yet you’re so sure there was a big bang? I began providing some evidence - more on it below - but you chose to ignore it.

Where is this universe EM? Can you show it to me? Or is it in your own mind? So you live by your own rules and only by your own rules? Teach me to defy gravity.

WTF? Straw man, Straw man, Straw man, Straw man. Random words here completely ignoring what you wrote and just rambling on about nothing…

Nice little universe you’ve created for yourself. After you teach me how to defy gravity, can you teach me to bend other physical laws? Or don’t they exist in your universe where you make the rules that you live by?

I put my trust in JESUS. How did you not get that? Where did I say put your trust in a church organisation or a priest or anything else other than JESUS?


What do voluntary donations have to do with your previous comment?


Straw man.

The question of who created God does not even make sense. It is like asking, “What does blue smell like?” Blue is not in the category of things that have a smell, so the question itself is flawed. In the same way, God is not in the category of things that are created or caused. God is uncaused and uncreated—He simply exists. How do we know this? We know that from nothing, nothing comes. So, if there were ever a time when there was absolutely nothing in existence, then nothing would have ever come into existence. But things do exist. Therefore, since there could never have been absolutely nothing, something had to have always been in existence. That ever-existing thing is what we call God. God is the uncaused Being that caused everything else to come into existence. God is the uncreated Creator who created the universe and everything in it.


Back to looking outside the window – if God does not exist, where did everything come from?


You'll know one day.

Is this really all you've got? I don't see much point in me answering if you are just going to side-step half my questions. Especially when I've addressed all your questions, regardless of how ridiculous I think some of them are. Once again, you are choosing the questions that suit you, and avoiding ones that don't.

Get some sleep, come back tomorrow, and then give it another shot.
 
Is this really all you've got? I don't see much point in me answering if you are just going to side-step half my questions. Especially when I've addressed all your questions, regardless of how ridiculous I think some of them are. Once again, you are choosing the questions that suit you, and avoiding ones that don't.

Get some sleep, come back tomorrow, and then give it another shot.
No EM, I've been addressing every single comment you make while you completely ignore mine, misconstrue it and then just raise up straw men for yourself. If its good enough for you to treat my posts like that, then that is exactly how I'm going to respond to you from now on.

Random text here Random text here Random text here Random text here Random text here Random text here Random text here Random text here Random text here Random text here Random text here Random text here Random text here Random text here Random text here Random text here Random text here Random text here Random text here
 
You said rights were based on feelings. I questioned that, just as you have been questioning my views and I've had the decency to explain them. I'm not sure where you're going with this latest comment?
I question someone who believes rights do not come from feelings. I feel decent in questioning that. I would think feelings can help generate some kind of social acceptance on various matters. What are you relying on? You can change your decent opinion now and suggest God gives us these feelings, that can work in my mind. But, then again, if God gives us free will, then our feelings would be our own I suppose. I'm confused again. But I still think feelings amongst a society will generate actions and motivations and acceptances which will ultimately facilitate the creation of rights.

Lets assume that objective moral values do not exist, as you are now arguing. You stated that we have a right simply because we feel we have a right and that the more people that feel they have such right justifies the right. I pointed out that we are outnumbered. My question was what do we do from here? It appears that we don't have a right to an identity, according to your worldview, if that right is based solely on the number of people that feel we have it.
You have an awful tendency to put words in people's mouth. I haven't really stated objective moral values don't exist. I'm not sure to be honest, but I think they might. I've questioned where they come from. On the identity matter I said nothing of the kind you are suggesting. I made it really clear, Macedonians are putting their identity on the line in this game. The Greeks and FYROMIANS are not. The ranking is clearly in Macedonia's favour in terms of significance.


What happens to Macedonian minorities in Greece, where the vast majority don't feel Macedonians should have the right to a Macedonian identity? We say they do have rights, but according to who or what? The majority in that country feel that they don't. So what do we do there? How do we justify the Macedonian (as we define it) cause there?
The 3 people in Ofchareni can say God is on their side. But the key is the Republic of Macedonia and its identity. The rest will follow if they are desirous. We justify the Macedonian cause because people like my family are victims of the racism that dominated the region, there are still people who are victims of racism there. We remember. And racism is considered bad. Is it objectively bad? You can tell me that.

Specifically on this issue. If God came down to Earth for a bit of a yarn to the Macedonians in Greece and proposed the following options:
- kill that former Turkish national living next to you.
- speak Greek from now on and love that former Turkish national next to you.

Which one is closer to the message from God we assume is correct?

You can talk about objective moral values which empower the Macedonians in Greece, but why not follow it through? God is on the Macedonian side in Greece under your proposal. It is KILLING TIME! Time to unleash! We have God on our side! Glorious stuff here. Tell me when to stop please!

Where am I wrong? God gives us this right according to you. It is an objective moral right according to you. It has nothing to do with numbers according to you. I like it. It is wonderfully empowering. The 3 people in Ofchareni would be champing at the bit I imagine. What are you practically going to do with this justification of yours?

You don't seem to be paying attention to what I'm actually writing. Noone ever suggested that you cannot determine objective moral values apart from the Bible. Sorry RtG, but this is just a straw man.
Cough cough, pig's arse. If you're saying objective moral values do not need to come from the bible, then welcome to the airy fairy club like the rest of us. I prefer your black and white approach. It is comforting to know it is either right or wrong according to God and no further questions need to be asked. So simple! I would prefer it in a perfect world. Objective moral values come from God. God's word is in the bible. Tell me where I'm wrong.

Timothy 3:16-17 ESV
All Scripture is breathed out by God and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for training in righteousness, that the man of God may be competent, equipped for every good work

I asked my question first. The rest of this has nothing to do with anything that I have said. Your merely setting up another straw man.
In fact, the UN has it right. They agree with Macedonia on this issue. The FYROMIANS do not agree and they preferred to call themselves FYROMIAN instead of Macedonian. So my answer is well and truly addressed now. The generally accepted human rights as embraced by the UN would have held Macedonia in good stead. But the FYROMIANS did not agree. They told the UN they wanted to be called FYROM. They signed an agreement to make it so.

Now, are you giving your house to the Aborigines or not? They have seem to meet all your God approved criteria. Why is this line of inquiry in the straw man category? Why don't you address it? Why are you violating their God given rights willfuly?

In relation to 'generally accepted rights', if you're not referring to the UN's Declaration of Human Rights, what exactly are you referring to? What are these generally accepted rights and who accepts them? If we are saying that the UN is wrong in relation to our name, and objective moral values do not exist, and you're not referring to the UN Declaration of Human Rights, then what exactly are we appealing to? How do we justify our cause and why should anyone care, including Macedonians?
I have told you. The UN are right. The FYROMIANS are not.
 
No EM, I've been addressing every single comment you make while you completely ignore mine, misconstrue it and then just raise up straw men for yourself. If its good enough for you to treat my posts like that, then that is exactly how I'm going to respond to you from now on.

Random text here Random text here Random text here Random text here Random text here Random text here Random text here Random text here Random text here Random text here Random text here Random text here Random text here Random text here Random text here Random text here Random text here Random text here Random text here

You're very mature for an admin. Seems like your only form of defence is to attack. The onus is on you to prove the existence of God, Heaven, Hell and whatever else is in the Bible. You're the only one here saying that your stance is absolute and certain, so actually prove it. You should be able to confidently answer any question we throw at you, whether you consider it ridiculous or not.

I've made an effort to address every single question you've posed, for you to say the same is an absolute joke. I'm still waiting for a proper response to my other post.
 
I question someone who believes rights do not come from feelings. I feel decent in questioning that. I would think feelings can help generate some kind of social acceptance on various matters. What are you relying on? You can change your decent opinion now and suggest God gives us these feelings, that can work in my mind. But, then again, if God gives us free will, then our feelings would be our own I suppose. I'm confused again. But I still think feelings amongst a society will generate actions and motivations and acceptances which will ultimately facilitate the creation of rights.
RtG, like you’ve said to me on a number of occasions – I just don’t buy it. The whole notion of rights based on feelings seems flimsy and dangerous to me. Look no further than Gruevski. Some days he feels we have rights and others he doesn’t. The result is a yo-yo policy. Are changing, non-definable feelings really what you want rights to be based on?


Obviously our gut feeling differs from Gruevski’s. Without an objective moral value system to test our feelings against those of Gruevski, how do we know we are right? Maybe we are just deluded? If rights cannot be rationally expressed and their basis cannot be rationally expressed, then I can’t really accept it. Emotion alone is not enough for me. I guess I simply don’t have as much faith as you do J

You have an awful tendency to put words in people's mouth. I haven't really stated objective moral values don't exist. I'm not sure to be honest, but I think they might. I've questioned where they come from.
Actually, you’ve questioned their very existence and your argument that rights are based on feelings denies the existence of objective moral values by definition. If moral values are based on feelings then they are individually created and by definition are subjective. If they are created by individuals’ feelings then they cannot be apart from humanity and cannot be objective.


If you decide that objective moral values do exist, then the question is where could they possibly come from? Where can intelligent moral values that are apart from individual human feeling and opinion possibly come from?

The 3 people in Ofchareni can say God is on their side. But the key is the Republic of Macedonia and its identity. The rest will follow if they are desirous. We justify the Macedonian cause because people like my family are victims of the racism that dominated the region, there are still people who are victims of racism there. We remember. And racism is considered bad. Is it objectively bad? You can tell me that.
This isn’t about saying God is on our side. It’s about objectively analysing whether we are on His side based on His moral law. You need to flip it around.


I consider racism bad because God tells me it’s bad. As the creator of the universe, He is the objective moral law, judge, jury and executioner. On occasions, I might feel differently, but that does not make me right.

You say racism is bad, but if there is no objective moral law, how can we know? There are millions of people who feel that it is good. Who’s to say who’s right and who’s wrong? Is it simply a matter of might is right? If that is that case, then morality does not exist and we have no reason to feel wronged. But we do feel wronged.

Specifically on this issue. If God came down to Earth for a bit of a yarn to the Macedonians in Greece and proposed the following options:
- kill that former Turkish national living next to you.
- speak Greek from now on and love that former Turkish national next to you.

Which one is closer to the message from God we assume is correct? .
Neither. The problem here is that you are not getting any of this from the Bible. You’re just making it up. If you want to know what God thinks, then read the Bible. If not, why even attribute something to God that’s not?

You can talk about objective moral values which empower the Macedonians in Greece, but why not follow it through? God is on the Macedonian side in Greece under your proposal. It is KILLING TIME! Time to unleash! We have God on our side! Glorious stuff here. Tell me when to stop please
Where am I wrong? God gives us this right according to you. It is an objective moral right according to you. It has nothing to do with numbers according to you. I like it. It is wonderfully empowering. The 3 people in Ofchareni would be champing at the bit I imagine. What are you practically going to do with this justification of yours? .
Refer to my comment above.

Cough cough, pig's arse. If you're saying objective moral values do not need to come from the bible, then welcome to the airy fairy club like the rest of us. I prefer your black and white approach. It is comforting to know it is either right or wrong according to God and no further questions need to be asked. So simple! I would prefer it in a perfect world. Objective moral values come from God. God's word is in the bible. Tell me where I'm wrong.
I never suggested that the Bible is the only way to determine objective moral values in a general sense – My comment was specifically in response to your Spanish Inquisition etc etc comments.


God also gave you the ability to reason. Even if you never had access to the Bible, you could still work out right from wrong because objective moral values exist and God has created us with this non-physical characteristic called a conscious that He tugs at every so often.

In fact, the UN has it right. They agree with Macedonia on this issue. The FYROMIANS do not agree and they preferred to call themselves FYROMIAN instead of Macedonian. So my answer is well and truly addressed now. .
Is the UN right? The UN Security Council determined that Macedonia needs to negotiate on its name. This determination was made on a basis of a moral claim by Greece. Greece claimed ownership over the name and identity ‘Macedonia’. The UN Security Council agreed with this claim. So did the fyromians. The point is, the UN was wrong.


The generally accepted human rights as embraced by the UN would have held Macedonia in good stead. But the FYROMIANS did not agree. They told the UN they wanted to be called FYROM. They signed an agreement to make it so .
The IA was signed in 1995, two years after the UN determined that Macedonia was wrong in relation to the name issue. I’m not sure now whether you are appealing to the UN Declaration of Human Rights or not? You’re saying the ‘generally accepted human rights’ as embraced by the UN would have held Macedonia in good stead. But the UN Security Council decided that Macedonia did not have a moral claim to its identity – in 1993, two years before Macedonia agreed to negotiate through the IA. The fact that the fyromians accepted this makes our position (if objective moral values do not exist) even more tenuous. If we are not appealing to objective moral values, then we are quickly losing the battle here. The only thing left is force and we don’t have it.


Now, are you giving your house to the Aborigines or not? They have seem to meet all your God approved criteria. Why is this line of inquiry in the straw man category? Why don't you address it? Why are you violating their God given rights willfuly?
This
is a straw man because I haven’t even stated what objective moral values I think apply here. You’re just making an assumption. All I’ve been trying to argue is that objective moral values do exist and we should be appealing to them.

At the end of the day everyone chooses to believe what they want. These debates are good and healthy. If we didn’t have them we’d turn stale and end up like UMD – directionless.

I believe that God exists, that he created everything and that the Bible is his word. I believe this because existence coming out of nothing makes no sense and is not possible. I also believe it because there is no actual uncontested evidence for the theory of evolution, it’s a flimsy theory with massive gaps and physical impossibilities (such as the problem of information). I believe in God because of the very existence of non-physical properties such as moral values (objective or subjective), beauty, reason etc. Without God, it would not be possible for these things to exist or to come into existence out of physical matter (something that evolutionary theory doesn’t even try to explain).

This is why I chose to accept God’s moral value system, which is unchangeable and easily defined. If you choose to understand morality and rights through your own subjective feelings, then so be it.
 
RtG, like you’ve said to me on a number of occasions – I just don’t buy it. The whole notion of rights based on feelings seems flimsy and dangerous to me. Look no further than Gruevski. Some days he feels we have rights and others he doesn’t. The result is a yo-yo policy. Are changing, non-definable feelings really what you want rights to be based on?

Obviously our gut feeling differs from Gruevski’s. Without an objective moral value system to test our feelings against those of Gruevski, how do we know we are right? Maybe we are just deluded? If rights cannot be rationally expressed and their basis cannot be rationally expressed, then I can’t really accept it. Emotion alone is not enough for me. I guess I simply don’t have as much faith as you do J
If an objective moral right is to smash babies against the wall. How do you reconcile every feeling within our bones that it is wrong? Maybe it is a bad example. Maybe it isn't. But why do you seek to discard feelings from the equation?


Actually, you’ve questioned their very existence and your argument that rights are based on feelings denies the existence of objective moral values by definition. If moral values are based on feelings then they are individually created and by definition are subjective. If they are created by individuals’ feelings then they cannot be apart from humanity and cannot be objective.
The feelings are indeed individually created. When there is consensus or mass acceptance, they constitute values. I haven't said they are objective yet. Though I am absolutely sure many feelings will line up with objective moral values quite succinctly.



If you decide that objective moral values do exist, then the question is where could they possibly come from? Where can intelligent moral values that are apart from individual human feeling and opinion possibly come from?
What on earth would "intelligent" moral values connotate and why would you feel the need to state them as such. Give me an example of an intelligent one.


This isn’t about saying God is on our side. It’s about objectively analysing whether we are on His side based on His moral law. You need to flip it around.
If we are on his side. We are empowered. If we are not, we are not empowered. Do we disagree? If I flip it, I get to the same place.

Do you seriously think God actually gives a shit about nationalities? (maybe a separate question, maybe not)

I consider racism bad because God tells me it’s bad. As the creator of the universe, He is the objective moral law, judge, jury and executioner. On occasions, I might feel differently, but that does not make me right.
Does he really tell you that? The old testament kind of goes against that in a massive way.


You say racism is bad, but if there is no objective moral law, how can we know? There are millions of people who feel that it is good. Who’s to say who’s right and who’s wrong? Is it simply a matter of might is right? If that is that case, then morality does not exist and we have no reason to feel wronged. But we do feel wronged.
Many people who are not with God feel wronged for the same reason. Is God helping those who do not even know of him. I've been to China so many times, it is so interesting for me to see their versions of morality given there rejection of Christianity. They are generally very much like us.


Neither. The problem here is that you are not getting any of this from the Bible. You’re just making it up. If you want to know what God thinks, then read the Bible. If not, why even attribute something to God that’s not? [/COLOR]
'Love your neighbor as yourself.' There is no commandment greater than these Seriously? That is in the bible mate. That would include former Turkish nationals. Get back to me when you re-read that part.

The other one logically flows from your assessment of objective morality. I can't arrive at a different conclusion. You tell me where I should go with it.

I never suggested that the Bible is the only way to determine objective moral values in a general sense – My comment was specifically in response to your Spanish Inquisition etc etc comments.

God also gave you the ability to reason. Even if you never had access to the Bible, you could still work out right from wrong because objective moral values exist and God has created us with this non-physical characteristic called a conscious that He tugs at every so often.
How do you work out right from wrong if your feelings don't help you? Does our consciousness remain apart from our feelings. I think you've lost yourself on this one. Without a conscience, we are unable to feel right or wrong. You can't have one without the other and feelings are a integral part of the equation.

Is the UN right? The UN Security Council determined that Macedonia needs to negotiate on its name. This determination was made on a basis of a moral claim by Greece. Greece claimed ownership over the name and identity ‘Macedonia’. The UN Security Council agreed with this claim. So did the fyromians. The point is, the UN was wrong.

The IA was signed in 1995, two years after the UN determined that Macedonia was wrong in relation to the name issue. I’m not sure now whether you are appealing to the UN Declaration of Human Rights or not? You’re saying the ‘generally accepted human rights’ as embraced by the UN would have held Macedonia in good stead. But the UN Security Council decided that Macedonia did not have a moral claim to its identity – in 1993, two years before Macedonia agreed to negotiate through the IA. The fact that the fyromians accepted this makes our position (if objective moral values do not exist) even more tenuous. If we are not appealing to objective moral values, then we are quickly losing the battle here. The only thing left is force and we don’t have it.
You wanted me to comment on the UN's generally accepted rights. Now you want me to comment on a UN decision (which actually violated those rights). What do you actually want me to talk about? They are two very separate matters.


This is a straw man because I haven’t even stated what objective moral values I think apply here. You’re just making an assumption. All I’ve been trying to argue is that objective moral values do exist and we should be appealing to them.
You are telling me what objective moral values you think apply here. Later you tell me they are black and white. I think they are often grey at best.

And you still haven't offered your house to the Aborigines in the park near you. Isn't that hypocritical?



At the end of the day everyone chooses to believe what they want. These debates are good and healthy. If we didn’t have them we’d turn stale and end up like UMD – directionless.

I believe that God exists, that he created everything and that the Bible is his word. I believe this because existence coming out of nothing makes no sense and is not possible. I also believe it because there is no actual uncontested evidence for the theory of evolution, it’s a flimsy theory with massive gaps and physical impossibilities (such as the problem of information). I believe in God because of the very existence of non-physical properties such as moral values (objective or subjective), beauty, reason etc. Without God, it would be impossible for these things to exist or to come into being out of physical matter (something that evolutionary theory doesn’t even try to explain).

This is why I chose to accept God’s moral value system, which is unchangeable and easily defined. If you choose to understand morality and rights through your own subjective feelings, then so be it.
I think debate is healthy. I tend to think of myself as an uncomfortable fence sitter on matters of faith. I don't think His moral value system is easily defined at all. Because if I am to accept some of your easily defined values, they clash and that causes me all kinds of confusion. Hence my world of grey.
 
RtG, can you honestly say that you've studied the Bible? I mean, really honestly?

The verses you have pointed out as 'contradictory' are based on a superficial reading of them. If I say that I should look out for you (just say you're crossing the street and a bus is about to hit you I would grab you or at least call out), that doesn't mean that I shouldn't defend myself if you decided to get too 'friendly' (if you know what I mean). There is no contradiction there. While as individuals we should look out for each other because we are all human beings, it doens't mean we can't and shouldn't protect ourselves from each other when necessary. I don't see the difficulty there. I don't know why intelligent people get confused when it comes to God.

Besides, in the original greek are there three different words to indicate three types of love. The word used here in the original is agape - it means to look after each other, to look after others as you look after yourself. It doesn't mean let them walk all over you, oppress you, abuse you or whatever else you want to falsly attach to it.

When I said intelligent moral values I mean't it in terms of logical, rational, intelligible - a moral value that can be defined and explained rationally.

You can base your claims to rights where ever you like, but feelings change, which means rights can change.
 
RtG, can you honestly say that you've studied the Bible? I mean, really honestly?
I've tried to read it a few times. I'm still working through Game of Thrones at the moment.

The verses you have pointed out as 'contradictory' are based on a superficial reading of them. If I say that I should look out for you (just say you're crossing the street and a bus is about to hit you I would grab you or at least call out), that doesn't mean that I shouldn't defend myself if you decided to get too 'friendly' (if you know what I mean). There is no contradiction there. While as individuals we should look out for each other because we are all human beings, it doens't mean we can't and shouldn't protect ourselves from each other when necessary. I don't see the difficulty there. I don't know why intelligent people get confused when it comes to God.
I'm not convinced the concept of nationality is an objective moral value. It might be black and white to you. But history has shown us enough nations disappearing to make it clear that this is not black and white!

Besides, in the original greek are there three different words to indicate three types of love. The word used here in the original is agape - it means to look after each other, to look after others as you look after yourself. It doesn't mean let them walk all over you, oppress you, abuse you or whatever else you want to falsly attach to it.
The Macedonians in Greece speak Greek now. Some are intermarried with with the former Turkish Nationals. Most don't really feel desperately oppressed from what I can see. So I ask again, what practically does it mean to feel that they have won the objective morality test in your opinion? How do we rely on it practically? Do we point to the old map and say "it is God's will" now?

If we use "agape" I still arrive at the same conclusion. Don't be killing (or whatever) your neighbour.

When I said intelligent moral values I mean't it in terms of logical, rational, intelligible - a moral value that can be defined and explained rationally.
You mean one that can be defined and explained rationally after reconciling with the mystery of faith. Many people would say you've gone from black and white to an infinite array of greys. But your faith guides you here, which is excellent, but it does not translate as such for everyone else. I think it is greyer for everyone else. And there is a proportion of Christians who seem to carry around a sense of smugness in this regard that some fence sitters find strangely offensive. (A subjective opinion from me)

You can base your claims to rights where ever you like, but feelings change, which means rights can change.
Possibly the subjective ones based on our preceding discussions and conclusions. For me, the jury is still out on objective ones!

All interesting and thought provoking stuff.

I'll assume you don't want to give your house to the Aborigines and you're going to turn a blind eye to that lesson in objective morality.
 
I've tried to read it a few times. I'm still working through Game of Thrones at the moment.
Come on RtG, I expect more from you mate than just going on assumptions without actually trying to learn about the subject matter. Let me know when you've made an attempt to study it. Maybe then we can get back to what moral values I've actually said apply (none yet) and why the Aboriginal example you bring up is a straw man.

Until then, I'm going to put the shoe on the other foot and have a go at explaining why accounting makes no sense :)

Obviously I know absoultely nothing about accounting, so I'm just going to go by my assumptions and things I've heard from other uninformed people. For example, the double ledger system makes no sense. Isn't it just duplication and an exercise in over complication by accountants to keep us uninformed and their pockets lined? And can't accountants just jimmy the books so that noone ever has to pay any taxes? Are accountants in on it with the Tax Office? Don't they just get a percentage of the taxes we pay?

Maybe this quote is of relevance here:

"The opinion of ten thousand men is of no value if none of them know anything about the subject."
-- Marcus Aurelius
 
Obviously I know absoultely nothing about accounting, so I'm just going to go by my assumptions and things I've heard from other uninformed people. For example, the double ledger system makes no sense. Isn't it just duplication and an exercise in over complication by accountants to keep us uninformed and their pockets lined? And can't accountants just jimmy the books so that noone ever has to pay any taxes? Are accountants in on it with the Tax Office? Don't they just get a percentage of the taxes we pay?
I rely heavily on smoke and mirrors. I won't tell you what kind of smoke and I won't tell you what I do with my mirrors. That is the mystery of my profession.

The only difference is that people can work out my mystery.
 
I rely heavily on smoke and mirrors. I won't tell you what kind of smoke and I won't tell you what I do with my mirrors. That is the mystery of my profession.

The only difference is that people can work out my mystery.
literally tens of millions, if not hundreds of millions, have worked out my "mystery" as well and it doesn't take anywhere near as long (I've heard it takes 3-4 years to become an accountant). How many accountants are there in the world?
 
Hundreds of millions of people have not worked it out, not been interested or follow some other mystery. Whatever floats their boat.

With regret I will also inform you that there are nowhere near enough accountants in the world.
 
i watched q&a & one of the people who said god doesn't exist.He said how the universe doesn't need a creator.The universe is self creating with parallel universes.They said time & space created itself.He siad the creation of space & time created all the time.I don't beleive this as i think a creater god created time & space.
 
God’s moral value system

God’s moral value system

OK, back on it. As if I don't have enough other work to do. But eternal salvation sounds cool.

What is God’s moral value system? Are we sure the right to our national identity exists in this system. What makes our identity a God given right?
 
hey brother´s....how could u debate such a issue without me :excl: :D

erich von däniken has absolutley right....thats also my point of view:punk:
 
Back
Top