Risto the Great
Senior Member
You know what Giorikas, you want me to reply to your "thoughts" on the matter above. Well, they are opinions and that is all they are.
The 2 of us are writing in English, and in 2000 years time someone will quote Risto the Great as a Great Australian who was of obvious English extraction. Your and my ethnicity will not even be questioned because of the overwhelming proof of our written language.
Koine and Greek have a relationship. The Macedonians language has a very strong relationship with the language of Macedonia and Macedonians for the last 1500 years. Your historians write this.
I say to you that the language of the Ancient Macedonians was unable to be understood by their southern neighbours. You keep saying it was. (I am sure you would like to quote the Ancient Macedonian month names here, but before you do, remember to look at Greece's month names now.) We have proof either way it would appear. Therefore I will rely on the last 1500 years of Macedonian language continuity. Do you deny this as well?
I gave you my reason for bringing up antiquity, it was in the original post. Are you senile?
I will tell you what I do not have proof of .... your favourite historians tell us when the Slavs invaded and subjugated most of Greece (much less Macedonia). Can you tell me any proof of the Slavic language existence prior to Kiril & Metodi? Your historians say it was the dominant language from the slavic invaders and we don't see a hint of written language for 300 years. Please find me something about this, and then reconcile it to your dribble above.
The Christians that were transplanted from Turkey DID learn how to speak Macedonian when they came to my people's region of Macedonia. They still know how to speak it based on my recent visits. You say you are not from there, trust me, you need to rely on my first hand observations about this.
A little fascist called Metaxas changed the language the people spoke in the region very quickly. I am sure you have heard of him. You might even be his illegitimate son based on your "logical conclusions".
The 2 of us are writing in English, and in 2000 years time someone will quote Risto the Great as a Great Australian who was of obvious English extraction. Your and my ethnicity will not even be questioned because of the overwhelming proof of our written language.
Koine and Greek have a relationship. The Macedonians language has a very strong relationship with the language of Macedonia and Macedonians for the last 1500 years. Your historians write this.
I say to you that the language of the Ancient Macedonians was unable to be understood by their southern neighbours. You keep saying it was. (I am sure you would like to quote the Ancient Macedonian month names here, but before you do, remember to look at Greece's month names now.) We have proof either way it would appear. Therefore I will rely on the last 1500 years of Macedonian language continuity. Do you deny this as well?
I gave you my reason for bringing up antiquity, it was in the original post. Are you senile?
The Macedonian language is indeed alive and kicking today.- I am not saying Russian is not a language because they had no script to write it in.
On the contrary, the language is alive and kicking today. There is no comparison. I did not say that that Macedonian could never have been a language because there is no written evidence. There is no evidence at all, neither written nor spoken. Period. It's wishful thinking from your side. If you have evidence, please bring it forward.
I will tell you what I do not have proof of .... your favourite historians tell us when the Slavs invaded and subjugated most of Greece (much less Macedonia). Can you tell me any proof of the Slavic language existence prior to Kiril & Metodi? Your historians say it was the dominant language from the slavic invaders and we don't see a hint of written language for 300 years. Please find me something about this, and then reconcile it to your dribble above.
Did I say the Macedonians were expelled/murdered? No, you know I did not. Why would you make things up like that? Does it help your arguments? I even told you how quickly they were victims of ethnocide.Honestly Risto, let it go. Tell me something, if half of the 'indiginous' slav speaking population was expelled/murdered as you say, and the other half replaced with Turkish Christian settlers, who in the name of God was around to learn the Turkish Christians Greek, and to force the 'indiginous' slav speaking population to speak Greek. Do you realise how far fetched that is? On top of that, I learned from you all that Greece (ex-Macedonia) was full of Vlach and Albanian speakers, so who the hell was teaching what to whom?
The Christians that were transplanted from Turkey DID learn how to speak Macedonian when they came to my people's region of Macedonia. They still know how to speak it based on my recent visits. You say you are not from there, trust me, you need to rely on my first hand observations about this.
A little fascist called Metaxas changed the language the people spoke in the region very quickly. I am sure you have heard of him. You might even be his illegitimate son based on your "logical conclusions".
Please wait for this. I will have a very good report for you very shortly. Can your people still read Turkish? You might not like this report when we get it.Do you know what the population was before we ethincally cleansed you as you claim? And do you know the population now?