• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

Greeks, seriously.

You know what Giorikas, you want me to reply to your "thoughts" on the matter above. Well, they are opinions and that is all they are.

The 2 of us are writing in English, and in 2000 years time someone will quote Risto the Great as a Great Australian who was of obvious English extraction. Your and my ethnicity will not even be questioned because of the overwhelming proof of our written language.

Koine and Greek have a relationship. The Macedonians language has a very strong relationship with the language of Macedonia and Macedonians for the last 1500 years. Your historians write this.

I say to you that the language of the Ancient Macedonians was unable to be understood by their southern neighbours. You keep saying it was. (I am sure you would like to quote the Ancient Macedonian month names here, but before you do, remember to look at Greece's month names now.) We have proof either way it would appear. Therefore I will rely on the last 1500 years of Macedonian language continuity. Do you deny this as well?

I gave you my reason for bringing up antiquity, it was in the original post. Are you senile?

- I am not saying Russian is not a language because they had no script to write it in.
On the contrary, the language is alive and kicking today. There is no comparison. I did not say that that Macedonian could never have been a language because there is no written evidence. There is no evidence at all, neither written nor spoken. Period. It's wishful thinking from your side. If you have evidence, please bring it forward.
The Macedonian language is indeed alive and kicking today.
I will tell you what I do not have proof of .... your favourite historians tell us when the Slavs invaded and subjugated most of Greece (much less Macedonia). Can you tell me any proof of the Slavic language existence prior to Kiril & Metodi? Your historians say it was the dominant language from the slavic invaders and we don't see a hint of written language for 300 years. Please find me something about this, and then reconcile it to your dribble above.

Honestly Risto, let it go. Tell me something, if half of the 'indiginous' slav speaking population was expelled/murdered as you say, and the other half replaced with Turkish Christian settlers, who in the name of God was around to learn the Turkish Christians Greek, and to force the 'indiginous' slav speaking population to speak Greek. Do you realise how far fetched that is? On top of that, I learned from you all that Greece (ex-Macedonia) was full of Vlach and Albanian speakers, so who the hell was teaching what to whom?
Did I say the Macedonians were expelled/murdered? No, you know I did not. Why would you make things up like that? Does it help your arguments? I even told you how quickly they were victims of ethnocide.

The Christians that were transplanted from Turkey DID learn how to speak Macedonian when they came to my people's region of Macedonia. They still know how to speak it based on my recent visits. You say you are not from there, trust me, you need to rely on my first hand observations about this.

A little fascist called Metaxas changed the language the people spoke in the region very quickly. I am sure you have heard of him. You might even be his illegitimate son based on your "logical conclusions".

Do you know what the population was before we ethincally cleansed you as you claim? And do you know the population now?
Please wait for this. I will have a very good report for you very shortly. Can your people still read Turkish? You might not like this report when we get it.
 
venom alki and fatso from maknews are both greeks who understand the issue. next time you are on maknews pm either of them and start a dialogue you will be surprisd at how understanding and supportive they both are.
 
osiris, I know Fatso. Sometimes he is on here too. Alki I don't know. Just how supportive is he?

Its not like "Have your state but you're still Slavs," is it?
 
- What people will say in 2000 years remains to be seen. We are both able to speak and write in our own languages and we both explicitally expressed that we are Macedonian and Greek. We can prove that and people will read that. You are trying to make a link here it seems. In comparison: Alexander has proclaimed that he was Greek, and it has not been recorded that he spoke any other language than that. I repeat: There is no proof of a seperate Macedonian language. If you do, then provide the evidence.

- There you go again being vague again in your next parapraph saying that 'the Macedonians language has a very strong relationship with the language of Macedonia' What are you talking about? Which language and when? What is the relationship with what and how do you know this?

- I deny any relationship between the ancient Macedonian language and Macedonian that you speak today (or in the last 1500 years) because it has not been proven that this ancient Macedonian language existed in the first place. Even if this mysterious ancient Macedonian language existed, then it can not have any relationship with your Macedonian language because your modern Macedonian language is a Slavic language.

- Then, you are trying to prove that ancient Macedonian existed without a written form, because that was also the case with the Slavic invaders who were able to speak their Slavic languages and after learned the Cyrillic alfabet: We are not discussing Slavic languages here in that respect, and wheter they could have existed. It's irrelevant to the question of ancient Macedonians. Anyway, there were Slavic languages and people speak it. We have proof.
That, my friend, is a fact you will hopefully not deny. Ancient Macedonian is completely unkown either spoken or written.

- Antiquity: You and I went a different direction then the orginal post, and you introduced antiquity in this discussion to which I 'objected'.
I actually just wanted to object to the use of the term ' Christian Turk' in this thread. By the way, calling each other names is not civilized Risto. You've been doing that now a few times now and it won't add anything to the discussion. Try to let off steam by disproving what I say, and prove what you say instead of calling me names like 'senile fool' or 'little man'. Eventually I would have to do the same and I really do not want to do that to such a Great person like yourself.

- Now indeed you did not say yourself in this thread that Macedonians were expelled from Greece and murdered. But it sure is the general message here on this and on Maknews when you were still writing there. Do you distance yourself from those statements or not?

- I have asked the question before on this forum: Maybe you'd care to give me a brief summary of what happened to Macedonians in Greek Macedonia? How many Macedonians lived there let's say in 1800, 1900, during the Balkan wars and now and what happened to them. Are they still there, were they murdered, were they expelled, were they forcefully (or voluntarily) integrated or ethnocided? All of the above? Just enlighten an ignorant soul like myself, Risto the Great.

I am just interested to hear from you in your own words what happened and how you know this, not interested in your 'neutral' reports.

- So now you are saying that the Christian Turks were moved from Turkey to Greek Macedonia, then proceeded to learn Macedonian from Macedonians and then I suppose forcefully learned Greek again? That doesn't make sense Risto. Learning a language is not something that you do just like that actually, some never manage, but to do it twice ... ? And all this so quickly too .... They must have a magic language potion in Macedonia.

- Again going to your last points, calling me an illigitimate son of someone is not very polite. Should I start calling you names now too ? For the time being I consider that it just shows your weakness and your unability to formulate some serious answers (since what I read doesn't qualify). But don't push your luck.
 
1) There is no proof of a seperate Macedonian language. If you do, then provide the evidence.

2)
- I deny any relationship between the ancient Macedonian language and Macedonian that you speak today (or in the last 1500 years) because it has not been proven that this ancient Macedonian language existed in the first place.
1)
There are indications all over the Ancient writters, look up here: Ancient Macedonian Language

Britannicca says that some Oxford dude is clasifieing the Ancient Macedonian Language tentatively as Aeolic Greek.

So there is no prove about the Language of the Ancient Macedonians of being what so ever. There is very little material there.

2)
You can or can not deny anything, it does not really matter, can't you understand?

just because today our Language is scuffed with in the Slavic Group, this does not mean that this language begun to exists in around 1500 years ago on the Balkans as you like to poiont out or it is from somewhere else than the Balkans.

Our language is firstly very multy layered language, and does not oblige to the normal "Slavic" Language.

Second, the Term Slavic was most likely a Byzantine Coinage which Political Reasons behind, and no Ethnic or Linguistical affiniation what so ever, for more read here "The Makeing of the Slavs" Florin Curta.



Conclusion, we know less about the Ancient Macedonians and their Language and thats why there is no consensus about them, and scientists are parted in Pro Greek and Non Pro Greek Parties.

But that does not prevents you from claiming that there is absolute no douobt about the Greekness of the Ancient Macedonians, which is very biased.

In my oppinion and research, Ancient Macedonan as well as their Language was mixture of many Ethnicities who came firstly united under one Kingdom and with time they mixed, thus producing Macedonians same goes for the Language.

Some of them specially the Royals were sometimes out of Political motivation Pro Hellenic.

But if they understood the same as you understand under the Term Hellene is not neccesserally a must be, for more look up on my Signature!

All we know is that we don't know for sure.
 
Last edited:
There is really no point in engaging Gorikas, or any other "Greek" for that matter. The Hellenism casts a wide net and has engulfed people of many cultures.
 
Last edited:
Then, you are trying to prove that ancient Macedonian existed without a written form, because that was also the case with the Slavic invaders who were able to speak their Slavic languages and after learned the Cyrillic alfabet: We are not discussing Slavic languages here in that respect, and wheter they could have existed. It's irrelevant to the question of ancient Macedonians. Anyway, there were Slavic languages and people speak it. We have proof.
That, my friend, is a fact you will hopefully not deny. Ancient Macedonian is completely unkown either spoken or written.
Well done, you are almost there. I will repeat myself again and ask you to provide the proof of the slavic language prior to Kiril & Metodi. Your obsession with “slavicness” of the language has already been your undoing. I want proof of the slavic language before Kiril & Metodi. Show me the written form of the language.


- Antiquity: You and I went a different direction then the orginal post, and you introduced antiquity in this discussion to which I 'objected'.
I remained in exactly the same direction as the original post. You chose to make this thread something you could stand on a soap-box about and discuss issues relating to the “Christian Turks”. Quite irrelevant but fine by me I suppose.


I actually just wanted to object to the use of the term ' Christian Turk' in this thread. By the way, calling each other names is not civilized Risto. You've been doing that now a few times now and it won't add anything to the discussion. Try to let off steam by disproving what I say, and prove what you say instead of calling me names like 'senile fool' or 'little man'. Eventually I would have to do the same and I really do not want to do that to such a Great person like yourself.
Thanks for acknowledging my Greatness. I do the same thing every morning to myself. You are indeed correct, I think it is not nice to call each other names. Saying things like “senile” (I did not say "senile fool", but it has a certain panache) and “little man” is not nice at all. Most of the annoyance I feel stems from your inability to comprehend nuance in the English language. You either use it to your advantage by choosing to avoid discussing an issue, or else you shift the focus elsewhere. I actually asked if you were senile. But these little words are nowhere as insidious as the attack on a race of people that you perpetuate on a daily basis here. Your denial of the Macedonian ethnic identity as compared to your willingness to Greekify even the most Asiatic of Orthodox Christian is ... well, typical.

- Now indeed you did not say yourself in this thread that Macedonians were expelled from Greece and murdered. But it sure is the general message here on this and on Maknews when you were still writing there. Do you distance yourself from those statements or not?
Oh, there were murders and people expelled. But this happens in many backward nations and was not the fate of the majority of Macedonians. The majority were simply victims of ethnocide. Their Macedonian identity was simply washed away as quick as they could remove any presence of Macedonian indicators such as language, church inscriptions, place names etc.


You know many Macedonians migrated from Greece. And many remained. They became the minority in their own land. You should visit there, you will learn a lot. Greece will not even allow some Polish people (citizens of Greece) to establish a cultural centre for themselves to this day. So it easy to understand how people are not allowed to carry on their traditions in Greece. These people will soon become perfect Greeks, which I am sure is acceptable to you but hardly a matter of choice for Poles (or indeed Macedonians).


- So now you are saying that the Christian Turks were moved from Turkey to Greek Macedonia, then proceeded to learn Macedonian from Macedonians and then I suppose forcefully learned Greek again? That doesn't make sense Risto. Learning a language is not something that you do just like that actually, some never manage, but to do it twice ... ? And all this so quickly too .... They must have a magic language potion in Macedonia.
Seriously, you should go there. (I hope you have not been lying to me and are actually from Greece) I am saying I have been there on numerous occasions and have spoken Macedonian to the people you describe as Christian Turks. The process of learning Macedonian was out of necessity, if you needed to borrow, buy, sell something … better yet, live in a foreign land … then you learn the language of the land. Most knew enough Macedonian to get by. Everyone was learning Greek at the same time. I said before, it is a phenomena that was never repeated in the 20th century.

I have not forgotten about the number, I will have some for you that will knock your pandofli off. But in the meanwhile, please give me your numbers of Greeks in Macedonia during the late 1800's to mid 1900's.

- Again going to your last points, calling me an illigitimate son of someone is not very polite. Should I start calling you names now too ? For the time being I consider that it just shows your weakness and your unability to formulate some serious answers (since what I read doesn't qualify). But don't push your luck.
I was joking. Are you really that sensitive? It was merely a suggestion that you might share genetic code given that your ideology appears to be very closely related to that of General Metaxas. Who was indeed a filthy fascist cunt. But I would never call you that. I am a gentleman.
 
- Again going to your last points, calling me an illigitimate son of someone is not very polite. Should I start calling you names now too ? For the time being I consider that it just shows your weakness and your unability to formulate some serious answers (since what I read doesn't qualify). But don't push your luck.

Risto you made the poor little baby cry. The frustration of not being able to prove fuck all is getting to him. Poor little girl. Here, suck on this kurche Giokiriakis.
 
Well done, you are almost there. I will repeat myself again and ask you to provide the proof of the slavic language prior to Kiril & Metodi. Your obsession with “slavicness” of the language has already been your undoing. I want proof of the slavic language before Kiril & Metodi. Show me the written form of the language.


I remained in exactly the same direction as the original post. You chose to make this thread something you could stand on a soap-box about and discuss issues relating to the “Christian Turks”. Quite irrelevant but fine by me I suppose.


Thanks for acknowledging my Greatness. I do the same thing every morning to myself. You are indeed correct, I think it is not nice to call each other names. Saying things like “senile” (I did not say "senile fool", but it has a certain panache) and “little man” is not nice at all. Most of the annoyance I feel stems from your inability to comprehend nuance in the English language. You either use it to your advantage by choosing to avoid discussing an issue, or else you shift the focus elsewhere. I actually asked if you were senile. But these little words are nowhere as insidious as the attack on a race of people that you perpetuate on a daily basis here. Your denial of the Macedonian ethnic identity as compared to your willingness to Greekify even the most Asiatic of Orthodox Christian is ... well, typical.

Oh, there were murders and people expelled. But this happens in many backward nations and was not the fate of the majority of Macedonians. The majority were simply victims of ethnocide. Their Macedonian identity was simply washed away as quick as they could remove any presence of Macedonian indicators such as language, church inscriptions, place names etc.


You know many Macedonians migrated from Greece. And many remained. They became the minority in their own land. You should visit there, you will learn a lot. Greece will not even allow some Polish people (citizens of Greece) to establish a cultural centre for themselves to this day. So it easy to understand how people are not allowed to carry on their traditions in Greece. These people will soon become perfect Greeks, which I am sure is acceptable to you but hardly a matter of choice for Poles (or indeed Macedonians).



Seriously, you should go there. (I hope you have not been lying to me and are actually from Greece) I am saying I have been there on numerous occasions and have spoken Macedonian to the people you describe as Christian Turks. The process of learning Macedonian was out of necessity, if you needed to borrow, buy, sell something … better yet, live in a foreign land … then you learn the language of the land. Most knew enough Macedonian to get by. Everyone was learning Greek at the same time. I said before, it is a phenomena that was never repeated in the 20th century.

I have not forgotten about the number, I will have some for you that will knock your pandofli off. But in the meanwhile, please give me your numbers of Greeks in Macedonia during the late 1800's to mid 1900's.

I was joking. Are you really that sensitive? It was merely a suggestion that you might share genetic code given that your ideology appears to be very closely related to that of General Metaxas. Who was indeed a filthy fascist cunt. But I would never call you that. I am a gentleman.

Risto,

I told you before: Slavic languages are irrelevant to the question of the existence of an ancient Macedonian language. I am certainly not obsessed by Slavic languages.

In many words you say you agree with me that we should not call each other names. Fine. If you change your mind, fine too, then we will both call each other names.

Glad you finally take position and make a clear statement about the fate of Macedonians in Greece. That really helps for my understanding and probably other's. Usually you simply answer questions with counter-questions, it seems like your trademark at least. For sure it's safer to do that, and instead you seem to have more interest in Greek matters then actually discussing about Macedonian matters (even if they are sometimes connected).
It's something like the quest for the unique (modern) Macedonian word that they were looking for on Maknews. If you can't find it, better talk about Greeks. If you can't provide any proof of an ancient Macedonian language, except for half a dozen quotes from historians, than you focus on the Greek language. I understand what you're doing. Many of your truths are disputed, unconfirmed, unproven, and unsubstantiated, so it is normal that you should focus on Greeks instead. God forbid that you should provide evidence about your truths.

Now about your statements that 'Christian Turks' learned Macedonian from Macedonians before being brainwashed in Greek (by Vlachs and Arvanites .. ?): What you said before is something completely different then what you wrote in this last message. A nuance I suppose? Or just an Australian being creative with the English language ? Anyway, going back to what you said, sure, I will not be surprised that Slavic words will remain even now in places where Slavic speakers lived (and we know they did live in many parts of Macedonia). But that would be the exception, not the rule. A Macedonian living in today's Macedonia surrounded by Albanian speaking macedonaisn will pick up Albanian too. An interaction of languages is normal to a certain extent, but I guess you got carried away again a bit unleashing your wild imagination. (unsubstantiated again). Which macedonian words I wonder though ...

For your information, I told you that I am not Macedonian. I have no roots there. But I have been many times to Thessaloniki. I like it there very much and will be back on many occasions, probably the end of the month again. Also Drama, Kavala, Halkidiki, Naousa and Vergina for example. Have you?

Didn't you say somewhere that with your name it would be impossible to enter into Greece? Or were you using the 'nuances of the languages' again suggesting that that happened without that actually being the case? How come you got in then ? Were you or were you not refused entry into the country?

Last point, on your last paragraph: The golden rule when you decide to get in touch with your Balkan roots one day is that we try not to make references about family, even if it is for yourself clear that this is an attempt to be funny or to pass a message. If you know that I am not able to pick up the nuances the messages (not being an Anglophone like yourself) then try to avoid it.

Nuff said about that. Looking forward to hearing from you in your own words ( I don't need you to read reports) what happened in Greek Macedonia: How many Macedonians lived there let's say from 1800 onwards up to now, and to which extent were there their numbers diminished. (like you knew had happened, and even much faster then anywhere else in the Balkans)
What was the number of non-Macedonians in comparison, who were they, and last but not least: how do you know what you know. (and is it verifyable) I can't believe that for more then a month you need to research those things ... Please be concrete, no own theories. Gentleman as you are, I'm sure you will keep you word.

Thanks in advance.
 
Thanks for the many words. Is this a German thing?
I note not a single fact was presented in response.
It is easy to talk like this.

It appears you were unable to show me any evidence of the Slavic language BEFORE Kiril & Metodi. As a consequence, they either did not exist (do you believe this?) or they existed without written proof for about 300 years. If a Slavic language can exist for 300 years without any proof thereof, then so can an Ancient Macedonian language. And there you were thinking I meant the Ancient Macedonian language was a Slavic one. Giorikas, you will have to take your blinkers off, they don't let you see the full picture.
 
Gorillas not only doesn't want to see the whole picture, the rather mentally handicapped man wants to bleach the canvas and repaint it as he likes.
 
Thanks for the many words. Is this a German thing?
I note not a single fact was presented in response.
It is easy to talk like this.

It appears you were unable to show me any evidence of the Slavic language BEFORE Kiril & Metodi. As a consequence, they either did not exist (do you believe this?) or they existed without written proof for about 300 years. If a Slavic language can exist for 300 years without any proof thereof, then so can an Ancient Macedonian language. And there you were thinking I meant the Ancient Macedonian language was a Slavic one. Giorikas, you will have to take your blinkers off, they don't let you see the full picture.

Must be those Hellenic coloured glasses :)
 
Thanks for the many words. Is this a German thing?
I note not a single fact was presented in response.
It is easy to talk like this.

It appears you were unable to show me any evidence of the Slavic language BEFORE Kiril & Metodi. As a consequence, they either did not exist (do you believe this?) or they existed without written proof for about 300 years. If a Slavic language can exist for 300 years without any proof thereof, then so can an Ancient Macedonian language. And there you were thinking I meant the Ancient Macedonian language was a Slavic one. Giorikas, you will have to take your blinkers off, they don't let you see the full picture.

I think it was you who promised facts. An opinion will do for the time being. Then back it up if you gather your evidence eventually.

You want facts? Fact is: There is no relation between Slavic languages and the possible existance of a non-Greek ancient Macedonian language. I do not have to prove anything about Slavic languages and I do not intend doing so. When will you understand that?

You brought the Slavic thing up and I do not care to discuss about it since it is irrelevant. It is irreleveant because in any case we have no proof of the existance of a non-Greek ancient Macedonian language in the first place, so our quest stops there. In fact we have not even proof of a single word in modern Macedonian, that can not be found in any other Slavic language.

I challenge you, prove me wrong and show me some evidence. You are not able to it seems. A handful of quotes that can be interpreted any way you want will not be enough to prove the existance of a language. Evidence in written or spoken form will be helpfull to prove your point, or at least fragments (like we have in Etruskian or Thrakian for example).
The quotes you have are I believe (give or take) all related to Alexander the Great, but surely that can not be the proof of a language that must have existed for centuries before. (where there was no mention of this language)
 
1)
There are indications all over the Ancient writters, look up here: Ancient Macedonian Language

Britannicca says that some Oxford dude is clasifieing the Ancient Macedonian Language tentatively as Aeolic Greek.

So there is no prove about the Language of the Ancient Macedonians of being what so ever. There is very little material there.

2)
You can or can not deny anything, it does not really matter, can't you understand?

just because today our Language is scuffed with in the Slavic Group, this does not mean that this language begun to exists in around 1500 years ago on the Balkans as you like to poiont out or it is from somewhere else than the Balkans.

Our language is firstly very multy layered language, and does not oblige to the normal "Slavic" Language.

Second, the Term Slavic was most likely a Byzantine Coinage which Political Reasons behind, and no Ethnic or Linguistical affiniation what so ever, for more read here "The Makeing of the Slavs" Florin Curta.



Conclusion, we know less about the Ancient Macedonians and their Language and thats why there is no consensus about them, and scientists are parted in Pro Greek and Non Pro Greek Parties.

But that does not prevents you from claiming that there is absolute no douobt about the Greekness of the Ancient Macedonians, which is very biased.

In my oppinion and research, Ancient Macedonan as well as their Language was mixture of many Ethnicities who came firstly united under one Kingdom and with time they mixed, thus producing Macedonians same goes for the Language.

Some of them specially the Royals were sometimes out of Political motivation Pro Hellenic.

But if they understood the same as you understand under the Term Hellene is not neccesserally a must be, for more look up on my Signature!

All we know is that we don't know for sure.

Hello Makedonin,

So we are either way making assumptions about things without knowing anything. You can not prove that ancient Macedonian existed, and I can not prove it did not. Just we know for a fact that we don't know anything really. So why making those claims?

Giorikas
 
It appears you were unable to show me any evidence of the Slavic language BEFORE Kiril & Metodi. As a consequence, they either did not exist (do you believe this?) or they existed without written proof for about 300 years. If a Slavic language can exist for 300 years without any proof thereof, then so can an Ancient Macedonian language. And there you were thinking I meant the Ancient Macedonian language was a Slavic one. Giorikas, you will have to take your blinkers off, they don't let you see the full picture.
I will quote myself this time. Since your dribble did not even relate to my text Giorikas. You said you would not enter into a debate about the Slavic language. And I was not even talking about one. Read it again. Just in case English is a problem for you, it highlights how a native language can exist without having a written form. Lets work through this issue with you. Treat it as a lesson in English if you like.

Do you know the Slavic name for Germans? You can tell it to your neighbours next time. There is a good reason why they used the term.

Spolaj Ti (Say this to a Russian next time they try to invade Germany, let me know if they understand) ;)
 
I will quote myself this time. Since your dribble did not even relate to my text Giorikas. You said you would not enter into a debate about the Slavic language. And I was not even talking about one. Read it again. Just in case English is a problem for you, it highlights how a native language can exist without having a written form. Lets work through this issue with you. Treat it as a lesson in English if you like.

Do you know the Slavic name for Germans? You can tell it to your neighbours next time. There is a good reason why they used the term.

Spolaj Ti (Say this to a Russian next time they try to invade Germany, let me know if they understand) ;)

Message #81 of this thread you introduced Cyril, Methodus and Cyrrilic languages. This is what you wrote:

' The Macedonian language is indeed alive and kicking today.
I will tell you what I do not have proof of .... your favourite historians tell us when the Slavs invaded and subjugated most of Greece (much less Macedonia). Can you tell me any proof of the Slavic language existence prior to Kiril & Metodi? Your historians say it was the dominant language from the slavic invaders and we don't see a hint of written language for 300 years. Please find me something about this, and then reconcile it to your dribble above. '

In message # 91 you are still stuck with your Slavic story, but somehow you want to make me believe I made all that up ...?

Before that we shortly discussed about Russian (introduced by you in the discussion) in the sense that the Russian aristocrats were able to speak in French. (which is true without a doubt). In a different context.

So again; you started talking about Slavic languages and I maintained that Slavic languages are irrelevant to the discussion. Read back.

You were about to make a point it seems. You finally made the point here: So Russians do presumably not understand 'Spolaj ti'... Now what, have you proven that ancient Macedonians had their own non-Greek language ? Any idea what you're saying here ?
 
In the 1970's we had a drink in Australia called the Clayton. It was meant to taste like an alcoholic drink but contained no alcohol. Now it is used to refer to something that is not the real thing. Your response above is a Clayton's response.

Should I ask my question yet again? Based upon your responses in the Chento thread, it is obvious you are not here for dialogue (I am not sure you can even understand dialogue). But I am humouring myself with you.

Anyway, I will make it simple. You can't show me proof of the ancient Macedonian language, you can't show me proof of the Slavic language of Macedonia before Kiril & Metodi. What can you say with authority?

I can say with an abundance of proof that my language has been dominant in the region for about 1500 years. I could say more but I would fall into the trap of the modern Greeks in believing in myths.
 
In fact we have not even proof of a single word in modern Macedonian, that can not be found in any other Slavic language.
I gave you a single word (Spolaj ti). It disproved your statement and you decided to go on a verbal jaunt about some other distraction. This is your standard approach.
 
Back
Top