Pelister
New member
Gj Puleski wrote:
Your right about the Germans making it up.
From what I have been able to gather from the flimsy evidence coming to light is that the Macedonians in rennaisance historical thought were thought of as the same as the ancient Macedonians, and not only that, but that the language of the Macedonians (both modern and ancient) was Slavic.
Procopius's text, which mentions the "Sklavenoi" (in Greek) was discovered for the first time in the early 18th century in the Vatican library.
I think that the semantic resemblances, and the vague analogy of an invasion (by who we have no clue), has confused things alot over the years.
If we look at it objectively we have 1. NO idea what the language of 6th century invaders was, and 2. Very little idea what the language of natives in the balkans was (very little of Macedonian, Illyrian survives - just a few glosses).
From a cultural point of view (dances, songs, motifs, rituals, rites, coats of arms ...etc), we have quite alot in common with native balkan cultures. There is NO evidence that these specific elements of our culture, were practiced by 6th century invaders because we simply do not know a thing about the langauge and culture of 6th century invaders.
no author before 19th century is mentioning the comming of the Slavs on the Balcans in the VI-VII century a.d.
Your right about the Germans making it up.
From what I have been able to gather from the flimsy evidence coming to light is that the Macedonians in rennaisance historical thought were thought of as the same as the ancient Macedonians, and not only that, but that the language of the Macedonians (both modern and ancient) was Slavic.
Procopius's text, which mentions the "Sklavenoi" (in Greek) was discovered for the first time in the early 18th century in the Vatican library.
I think that the semantic resemblances, and the vague analogy of an invasion (by who we have no clue), has confused things alot over the years.
If we look at it objectively we have 1. NO idea what the language of 6th century invaders was, and 2. Very little idea what the language of natives in the balkans was (very little of Macedonian, Illyrian survives - just a few glosses).
From a cultural point of view (dances, songs, motifs, rituals, rites, coats of arms ...etc), we have quite alot in common with native balkan cultures. There is NO evidence that these specific elements of our culture, were practiced by 6th century invaders because we simply do not know a thing about the langauge and culture of 6th century invaders.