AMHRC,
Without going into its historical validity, I just want to make a few comments in relation to the statement used by Chris Popov below. And I do this in the spirit of genuine and open debate, so please don’t misunderstand my comments, as you know I do support many of your activities.
I'll admit that I have (naively) used this line two or three times in the past. However, I asked myself the following:
Firstly, how does this statement assist our struggle for self-identification?
Secondly, (and here I'm thinking about the impact on the reader), if Macedonians really are a mixture of all these people, then when, why and how was the identity marker/symbol “Macedonian” chosen over other possible markers? What precludes the Macedonians from reassessing their national historiography and choosing an identity marker/symbol from a less distant (culturally and genetically) and less politically contentious historical people?
If, on the other hand, can we claim that “Macedonian” has been used as an identity marker/symbol continuously (regardless of the cultural structures it may or may not have represented at various times) why introduce the “mongrel” perspective and the implications it has on culture/identity? What value does it add to the overall argument?
Vangelovski,
This is the very last time we shall respond on this matter.
First, if we want to avoid being mocked by serious people, we have to concern ourselves with historical validity.
Second, the struggle for the right to self-identification, is a legal and moral cause, it cannot be based on historical interpretations about the origins of nations etc. - especially as these interpretations, are often no more than vague speculation. Moreover, if you take that quotation in isolation from the rest of the letter; you are being unjust. Because the letter explains that exactly the same applies to the modern Greeks and others.
To answer your second question about the history of identity formation, would require the writing of a book and we at present do not have the time to undertake such an enterprise. What is not questionable, is that Macedonians today exist, regardless of how their identity was formed. Moreover, if people decide to freely change their identity, that is their right; however, if others from outside are attempting to force this upon them, then that is something we will resist, because it constitutes abuse. We, as human rights activists, cannot accept this as legitimate.
Thirdly, on the basis of the available evidence, as we already explained, it is difficult to maintain that our direct ancestors have from ancient times to the present, continuously referred to themselves as Macedonians. We do not like to make claims without evidence. This does not harm our human rights cause at all, because neither can any other ethnic or national group in Europe, demonstrate such a thing.
The human rights cause is about norms and laws that are meant to apply to all people - yet as we all know, Macedonians are often excluded from the benefits of these laws. This is discrimination which implies that Macedonians are something less than human and we shall therefore continue to resist this mistreatment. And we do not need to prove that we are not "mongrels" to do it. Such matters are completely irrelevant and we only ever bring them up, when the need arises to expose the lies propagated by the Greek state and its supporters.
Regards,
AMHRC.
Tom,
I will add a PS here as our final comment; in our advocacy work over the last 26 years, we have often found that our honesty on historical matters, whenever we have felt the need to bring them up to expose Greek lies, has often impressed authorities and has been a factor in swaying them to view our cause positively and equally, we have found that various institutions and academics etc. have been repulsed by the ridiculous fairy tales the Greeks use to argue their cause. This has been our experience, we do not claim that it always applies, but in general we have often been rewarded for our honesty. This, we suppose, can be counted as a positive benefit of facing facts honestly.
Last edited: