• Welcome to the new Macedonian Truth Forum. All posts, members and private messages have been moved over from the old forum.

    Passwords from the old forum could not be carried over, so please use Forgot your password? to set a new one. The reset link is emailed to the address on your account.

  • Rules and Regulations at the forum of the Macedonian Truth Organisation (MTO)

    (1) The national-ethnic and cultural-linguistic identity of the Macedonian people is historically Macedonian, and derives its character from the native, indigenous and geographic homeland of the Macedonians, which is called Macedonia. To ensure that their human rights, integrity and heritage are appropriately respected, the only nouns and adjectives acceptable when reference is made to the above character and identity markers is Macedon, Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians.

    (2) The nation-state of the Macedonian people is the Republic of Macedonia, and is to be referred to by this official title so long as the 'republic' prefix is consistently applied to other states. Alternative references are the Macedonian Republic, or simply, Macedonia.

    (3) The 'ethnic' prefix is only acceptable for Macedonians in cases where differentiation is specifically required - so long as it is in context and consistent where it concerns its application to other ethnic groups.

    (4) Should any other differentiation be specifically required, the names of other ethnic groups that reside with Macedonians in either the Republic of Macedonia or the occupied Macedonian regions in Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia or Albania, are to be given a prefix.

    (5) Negating the identity, language and culture of the Macedonian people by deliberate avoidance of the terms Macedonia, Macedonian and Macedonians, or by any other means, is not permitted.

    (6) Systematic anti-Macedonian propaganda and rhetoric are not permitted.

    (7) Threads irrelevant to the Macedonian Cause, the community at the Macedonian Truth Organisation or the Macedonians in general may be considered as spam or not in the spirit of the forum. In such cases they are not permitted.

    (8) Continual posting of messages in threads with the sole purpose of deviating from the initial topics with the use of unrelated and unnecessary information is not permitted.

    (9) All posts, external articles, reports, etc that are cited in languages other than Macedonian or English, must be accompanied with a translation in one or both of the said languages.

    (10) Despite the possibility of some conversations and debates becoming heated, extreme abuse and/or racism, vulgar language and/or terminology, threats, revelation of personal information about others, harassment, and other such behavior will not be permitted. If deemed necessary all relevant information including member details will be reported to the appropriate authorities for investigation which may result in legal action.

    (11) Threads that are created must have a summary of a topic or excerpt of an article found in pertinent link(s) that have been included. One line threads will be considered unaccetable spam and are therefore not permitted.

    (12) Compulsive and deliberate lies, irrespective of the topic, are not permitted.

    (13) Any symbols or avatars found to be perceived as offensive to Macedonians are not permitted.

    (13) Any explicit or extreme material is not permitted.

    Failure to adhere to the above rules and regulations will result in a ban after 3 breaches. This may be reconsidered in some cases should the circumstances be of an unorthodox nature and/or require special consideration. To assure an effective deterrent against an individual or individuals with the sole purpose of causing dissent through spamming, racism or other improper means, the above rules will be strictly enforced.

    The MTO administration will monitor all discussions as reasonably practical and reserve the right to remove any post and/or member from the forum, and update the rules and regulations as required. Members are encouraged to immediately report any post and/or member to the MTO administration if they feel that these rules have not been abided by.

    The views expressed on this forum are those of the individuals. The only official representation of the MTO is made by the "Macedonian Truth Organisation (Site Owner)" username, and no other.

  • Macedonian Cause

    The Macedonian Truth Organisation calls on God in Heaven to protect, bless and guide the endeavour it is committing to undertake, and that is to work towards:

    Securing Macedonia as a free, independent and democratic republic in which sovereignty lies with the Macedonian citizens; as the nation-state of the Macedonian people in which they can preserve their culture, language and identity; as a state in which the Macedonian language and culture form the basis of public life and act as important unifying elements of Macedonian society; as the home of all its citizens to which it guarantees and obliges their inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The acknowledgment as self-evident and irrefutable the existence of the:

    1) Indigenous, ethnonational name of Macedonia;
    2) Macedonian people, language and identity;
    3) Macedonian culture, symbols and folklore;
    4) Macedonian ancestry, heritage and history in its entirety; and
    5) Macedonian Orthodox Church;

    Securing recognition by the International Community of the tragedies endured by the Macedonian people, of the division of Macedonia with the signing of the Treaty of Bucharest on August 10, 1913, and the genocide committed against the Macedonian people at the hands of the Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian states and their respective churches during the 19th and 20th centuries;

    Ensuring that the Interim Accord is declared ‘null and void’ and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies or programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Interim Accord are also declared ‘null and void’, including the use of any symbols and the completion of any acts imposed by, or originating from, the Interim Accord.

    Ensuring that the Framework Agreement is abolished and that all constitutional provisions, acts, commitments, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs emanating from, supporting or consequential to the Framework Agreement are also abolished and replaced by a framework of constitutional and statutory law based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities and universally codified human rights mechanisms.

    Securing the abolishment of any existing constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs that discriminate against the Macedonian people, in any international organisation or any of the countries of the International Community where such constitutional provisions, acts, agreements, legislation, regulations, policies and programs exist, and thereby ensuring the freedom for Macedonians to exercise their inalienable natural rights and fulfil their corresponding responsibilities, and practice their culture, language and religious faiths in all the countries of the International Community without hindrance;

    The empowerment of Macedonians to undertake a moral revolution and to instil and/or reinvigorate within themselves a deep-rooted national, cultural, linguistic and historical dignity and a commitment to the exercise of freedom based on inalienable natural rights and corresponding responsibilities;

    The recognition of the Macedonian minorities in the neighbouring states of Macedonia as well as the respect for the inalienable rights and freedoms of the Macedonian minorities, as provided for by natural law and as codified by the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other universally codified human rights mechanisms;

    The full and unreserved respect of, and the support for, the rights of all people of non-Macedonian descent living in Macedonia and around the world, who share a reciprocal full and unreserved respect for the Macedonian people, their homeland and their state;

    The cultural unification and solidarity of the Macedonian people living in all parts of historical Macedonia and adjacent territories, as well as Macedonians throughout the world;

    The unity of all Macedonians on the principles, objectives and achievement of the Macedonian cause as defined by this declaration.

2016 Macedonian Elections

This week, renders were unveiled (SEE BELOW) for new mega mosque that will be built in the center of Skopje. The mosque will be financed by the government of Turkey but plans and permits were approved previously under the DPMNE-DUI administration. And I can't help but ask,

-why aren't the so called patriotic protesters in Macedonia, who have been protesting for weeks for a unitary Macedonia, saying anything about this mosque project?

-Where were these protesters in 2012 during the Smilkovci lake killings that took the lives of 5 young innocent Macedonians?

-Where were these protesters in 2015 during the Kumanovo clashes that took the lives of 8 Macedonian police officers?

-Where were these protesters during the last 10 years when schools in Skopje were being renamed after Albanian terrorists and activists, statues of Albanian prime ministers, heroes, and UCK memorials were being installed in the center of Skopje, Albanian signs were being installed in municipalities with no Albanian population, former UCK commander Talat Xhaferi became minister of defence, etc etc?

-How is it that despite all of these horrible events, these protesters only came out when SDSM created a government with DUI but were nowhere to be seen under the DPMNE-DUI government?


thumbs_b_c_1ae53ab283ffc05cfce385093769991d_zps8slff1js.jpg


xhami2_zpsgta71l7h.jpg


Good points Nik.

So do you think these current protests should be stopped or opposed?
 
Good points Nik.

So do you think these current protests should be stopped or opposed?

You cannot stop a protest, that's their right to do so and so far they've protested peacefully. The problem is they are directing their anger only against SDSM for a "platform" that hasn't been implemented, yet they completely ignore the DPMNE-DUI platform that has been implemented and has Albanianzed the country for the last 10 years! (and is still continuing, with the new mosque, for example). That gives me reason to believe that these protesters are mobilized by DPMNE only to prevent SDSM from taking power, not to stop the Albanian platform.
 
Only when I see these protesters directing their anger towards both Zaev and Gruevski will I truly believe in their message of a unitary Macedonia. Zaev's acceptance of the Tirana platform needs to be stopped AND Gruevski needs to be held accountable for his deals with Ahmeti.
 
Only when I see these protesters directing their anger towards both Zaev and Gruevski will I truly believe in their message of a unitary Macedonia. Zaev's acceptance of the Tirana platform needs to be stopped AND Gruevski needs to be held accountable for his deals with Ahmeti.

Not much to disagree with there
 
If only it were so simple that the protesters are just DPMNE lap dogs. The sad truth is that they majority are not. They are just ignorant people who think they are standing up for something. When I talk about the Albanization of Macedonia to Macedonians, most of them have no idea what I'm talking about, or will chalk it up as propaganda. They are totally brainwashed. Either way Macedonian intellectualism and patriotism are rotten to the core, these protests can never amount to anything useful because people in Macedonia still lack a sense of responsibility and morality. With out a major cultural shift Macedonia can never improve politically or economically. As is the case with Greece, Bulgaria, Albania and all the rest. We are ignorant, lazy, and morally bankrupt people, and the Europeans have every right to disregard us.
 
I don't know about "morally bankrupt". I think Macedonians are family loving people who strive to protect "their own". Many Macedonians I have met in RoMacedonia and Greece are so proud of their identity. The Macedonian identity is simply and proudly assumed by them as a natural perspective. Yet anyone looking at them from the outside would call it "wishy washy" because they don't seem to fight for it. The reality is that Macedonians are still locked in the village mentality where their village is the only thing worth protecting. By "village" I now mean their own little place in the world along with their own people.

Given their meagre existence allows them to survive, I am positive they fear anything which will further diminish their options.

This is a 500 year old phenomena. They have been cheated by and cheating the tax man for 500+ years. They are a resourceful people and don't want to lose whatever they have in a war imposed on them.

I do think Macedonians are a little too intellectual to bother getting their hands dirty though. And now is the time for some dirt.
 
http://www.balkaninsight.com/en/article/macedonia-parliament-reconvenes-amid-crisis-03-27-2017

Macedonia Parliament Reconvenes Amid Crisis

After a three month delay, Macedonia's parliament is set to resume sessions on Monday in an effort to elect a new speaker and unblock the democratic processes amid a deep political rift.

Parliament has two topics on its agenda: The election of a commission for appointments, which was agreed on last Thursday between the political parties, as well as the election of a new speaker.

The new parliamentary majority comprising the main opposition Social Democratic Union of Macedonia (SDSM), and most ethnic Albanian parties, hopes to get the work done as soon as possible, which would pave the way for the new government to be swiftly elected.

Together they control 67 MPs sitting in the 120-seat parliament.

"We expect on Monday, and in the days to come, serious and stately conduct from the institutions who must respect the will of the majority of the citizens, and facilitate the election of a new speaker and of a new government!" said SDSM in a press release published Sunday.

The party once again urged their political rivals, the right-wing VMRO-DPMNE party led by embattled former Prime Minister Nikola Gruevski, to stop obstructing the election of a new administration, which they say holds Macedonia hostage. Gruevski served as prime minister from 2006 for nearly a decade.

“We won't allow Macedonia to be stuck in further political crisis due to Gruevski and his associates’ fears of change and facing justice – the new reform government will be formed soon” SDSM said.

Over the weekend, the country’s main ethnic Albanian party, the Democratic Union for Integration (DUI), said that it would put forward its seasoned MP and former Defence Minister, Talat Xhaferi as the new speaker. It is expected that the SDSM will endorse this proposal.

Macedonia's has not managed to form a new government since early elections in December last year. They were held in the hope that a two-year-long political crisis could be resolved.

The crisis took a turn for the worse on March 1 this year, when current president Gjorge Ivanov refused to grant SDSM leader Zoran Zaev the mandate to form a government, despite the opposition leader having secured a majority in parliament.

Ivanov, reflecting the stands of VMRO-DPMNE, said that Zaev’s alleged acceptance of the so-called “Albanian Platform” might destroy the country.

The resumption of parliament's work comes amid ongoing daily protests held by VMRO-DPMNE supporters against the announced opposition-led government. The opposition however hopes that once the majority elects the new speaker, President Ivanov would have no more excuses not to grant the mandate.

While VMRO-DPME has seen its leaders faced confronted by ongoing criminal investigations and Special Prosecution indictments, it nsists that its political adversary, SDSM, is the one being corrupt.

“In an attempt to save himself and his comrades, who are up to their necks in crime, Zaev is prepared to completely implement the 'Tirana [Albanian] Platform' and thus redefine Macedonia,” the party said in a press release on Sunday, reiterating its demand for yet another round of early elections as the best way out of the current stalemate.

The resumption of parliament's work comes more than three months after the December 11 elections and after parliament first reassembled on December 30.

However, that session was held only to verify MPs' mandates. The session was interrupted because no party or coalition then mustered a majority that could elect a new speaker.
 
I don't know about "morally bankrupt". I think Macedonians are family loving people who strive to protect "their own". Many Macedonians I have met in RoMacedonia and Greece are so proud of their identity. The Macedonian identity is simply and proudly assumed by them as a natural perspective. Yet anyone looking at them from the outside would call it "wishy washy" because they don't seem to fight for it. The reality is that Macedonians are still locked in the village mentality where their village is the only thing worth protecting. By "village" I now mean their own little place in the world along with their own people.

Given their meagre existence allows them to survive, I am positive they fear anything which will further diminish their options.

This is a 500 year old phenomena. They have been cheated by and cheating the tax man for 500+ years. They are a resourceful people and don't want to lose whatever they have in a war imposed on them.

I do think Macedonians are a little too intellectual to bother getting their hands dirty though. And now is the time for some dirt.

I think this is a good observation of the situation.
 
http://www.balkaninsight.com/en/article/macedonia-parliament-stuck-in-long-discussions-03-28-2017

Macedonian Parliament Stalled by VMRO DPMNE Filibuster

For a second consecutive day, Macedonian MPs discussed the election of a new speaker, as the VMRO DPMNE party attempts to delay proceedings and prevent a new government coming to office.

Observers say the VMRO DPMNE’s stalling tactics, which involve the party’s MPs making long speeches and holding discussions amongst themselves in order to prevent a vote on a new parliamentary speaker for as long as possible, are set to continue on Wednesday - and could drag out the process for weeks or possibly months.

Until a new speaker is chosen, a new government cannot take office, and the VMRO DPMNE, the former ruling party, wants to prevent the former opposition Social Democrats, SDSM, who have put together a parliamentary majority, from coming to power.

All 51 VMRO DPMNE MPs have put themselves down to speak, and during the ongoing debate, which started on Monday, they have mainly been talking amongst themselves.

"Unfortunately, this is an indicator that the complete constitution of the new parliament, which means the election of a new speaker and its normal functioning, will face further obstructions," said former MP Nazer Ziberi.

Despite being banned in the parliamentary rulebook, provisional parliamentary speaker Trajko Veljanoski, who comes from the VMRO DPMNE, allowed MPs from the same party to reply to each other during the debate because he said party caucuses have not yet been formalised.

The long-awaited parliamentary session comes after a three-month delay and amid deep a political rift centred around the VMRO DPMNE’s refusal to allow the formation of a new SDSM-led government.

The new parliamentary majority led by the SDSM hoped to get the session finished as soon as possible, which would pave the way for the new government to be swiftly elected.

In an attempt to speed things up, the SDSM this week filed a motion for the election of Talat Xhaferi, an MP from their new coalition partners, the Democratic Union for Integration, as the new speaker, insisting on direct voting without lengthy discussions.

"Talking amongst each other is a breach of the [parliamentary] rulebook... the parliamentary majority has an obligation to prevent further blocking of the democratic processes," said SDSM MP Petre Shilegov.

But VMRO DPMNE MP Ilija Dimovski insisted on Tuesday that "debate is a basic democratic principle" and that the party was not deliberately stalling the session.

Macedonia has not managed to form a new government since early elections in December last year. The polls were held in the hope that a two-year-long political crisis could be resolved.

The crisis took a turn for the worse on March 1, when President Gjorge Ivanov, who was the VMRO DPMNE’s candidate, refused to grant SDSM leader Zoran Zaev the mandate to form a government, despite the opposition leader having secured a majority in parliament.

Ivanov, reflecting the stance of the VMRO DPMNE, which had been in power since 2006, said that Zaev’s alleged acceptance of a so-called ‘Albanian Platform’ granting more rights to the country’s ethnic Albanians might destroy Macedonia.

The resumption of parliament's work comes amid ongoing daily protests held by VMRO-DPMNE supporters against the announced opposition-led government.

The opposition however hopes that once the new speaker is elected, President Ivanov will have no more excuses not to grant the mandate.

The SDSM sees the stalling of the transfer of power as a reflection of VMRO DPMNE's fear of facing justice. Its leaders are currently facing criminal investigations and Special Prosecution indictments, which they claim are politically motivated.
 
As I have said previously Albanians currently make up 26% of the country and if a proper census is completed they will number approximately 470000 of the population. What this number means is that their population has not changed and has stayed stable since independence where the census in both 1991 and 1994 counted them as approximately 440000 people. This means that in 25 years the Albanians only added 20-30000 people.

I have been studying the statistics on the Macedonian State Statistical office for the past 2 years and have read all news releases and publications based on birth stats, proportion of Albanian students in the school system

Albanian students have always been 30-35% of the student population since independence. The reason their number has not increased in 25 years as a larger proportion of the population is because of emigration.

Albanians tend to emigrate more frequently than Macedonians have since independence however from around 2006 there has been a huge wave of them trying to (and successfully) leaving the country.

One example of this is comparing the Albanian students at the end of the school year from 2008-2015 school years. The Albanian students over 8 years has collapsed by 17% or roughly 12000 students. These are students that are emigrating and leaving with their mom and dad to another country. Since Albanian births are holding stable at around 7500 kids per year the only explanation for this is emigration.

Link for stats are here at the SSO


http://www.stat.gov.mk/PrethodniSoopstenijaOblast_en.aspx?id=19&rbrObl=5


Albanian primary school students at the end of the school year
2008/2009: 71,436
2009/2010: 69,034
2010/2011: 65,121
2011/2012: 64,213
2012/2013: 62,660
2013/2014: 61,298
2014/2015: 61,608
2015/2016: 59,437


Furthermore, looking at statistics on birth what you will notice is that the number of both Macedonian and Albanian births per year are stagnated. Most populations tend to decrease after their Total Fertility rate drops below 2.1 (in Macedonia and Kosovo the Albanian fertility rate is about 2.1 right now).

Macedonians
2004: 12.488 (53.5%)
2005: 11.923 (53%)
2006: 11.707 (51,8%)
2007: 11.807 (52%)
2008: 12.254 (53,3%)
2009: 12.490 (52,7%)
2010: 12.658 (52,1%)
2011: 11.544 (50,6%)
2012: 11.995 (50,8%)
2013: 11.550 (49,9%)
2014: 12.099 (51,2%)
2015: 12.308 (53.3%)

Albanians
2004: 7.390 (31.6%)
2005: 7.230 (32,1%)
2006: 7.396 (32,7%)
2007: 7.392 (32,5%)
2008: 7.309 (31,8%)
2009: 7.454 (31,4%)
2010: 7.888 (32,4%)
2011: 7.727 (33,9%)
2012: 8.035 (34,1%)
2013: 8.137 (35,1%)
2014: 7.908 (33,5%)
2015: 7.604 (32.9%)

Over the next 10 years or so, the population of Albanians will start to decrease. This is again why they are trying to make Macedonia Binational by having their language recognized as co-official. They realize that over the next 10 years or so they wont have the numbers to reach 20% of the population (if these trends continue).


It seems you know a bit about Statistics and how to analyse them.. .
I understand this is a touchy subject for all and I'm sure most Macedonians aren't awear of these statistics..

According to you how many Albanians would you say have migrated from Macedonia since independence?

Had migration rates been equal among Macedonians and Albanians over the last 50 years what would the Albanian percentage be today?

Do you have an idea on numbers of Albanians who originate from Macedonia and migrated to Turkey during Yugoslavia who could still be eligible for citizenship? (This number is said to be in the hundreds of thousands today.)

I have found some interesting figures regarding Skopje and the ethnic breakdown of students..
It seems to be similar to the national average.

DPSEUSG.png



2006/2007

Maqedone: 32,925 = 49.75%
Shqiptare: 24,066 = 36.37%
Serb: 899 = 1.35%

2007/2008

Maqedone: 33,278 = 50.19%
Shqiptare: 24,027 = 35.24%
Serb: 817 = 1.23%

2008/2009

Maqedone: 33,097 = 50.43%
Shqiptare: 23,781 = 36.23%
Serb: 749 = 1.14%

2009/2010

Maqedone: 32,441 = 50.19%
Shqiptare: 23,323 = 36.08%
Serb: 730 = 1,12%

2010/2011

Maqedone: 32,138 = 50.66%
Shqiptare: 22,286 = 36.05%
Serb: 667 = 1.05%

2011/2012

Maqedone: 32,225 = 50.75%
Shqiptare: 22,775 = 35.86%
Serb: 692 = 1.08%

2012/2013

Maqedone: 31,636 = 50.46%
Shqiptare: 22,793 = 36.35%
Serb: 594 = 0.94%

2013/2014

Maqedone: 31,647 = 50.77%
Shqiptare: 22,635 = 36.31%
Serb: 551 = 0.88%

2014/2015

Maqedone: 31,679 = 50.13%
Shqiptare: 23,704 = 37.51%
Serb: 471 = 0.74%



Not sure if these figures include the students of the eastern Skopje rural Municipality of Saraj which has an overwhelming
Albanian majority


According to the last national census from 2002, Saraj has 35,408 inhabitants.[1] Ethnic groups in the municipality include:

Albanians = 32,408 (91.5%)
Macedonians = 1,377 (3.9%)
Bosniaks = 1,120 (3.2%)
others.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saraj_Municipality

Do you know what the breakdown in other mixed controversial towns like Kicevo and Struga may be?
 
It seems you know a bit about Statistics and how to analyse them.. .
I understand this is a touchy subject for all and I'm sure most Macedonians aren't awear of these statistics..

According to you how many Albanians would you say have migrated from Macedonia since independence?

Had migration rates been equal among Macedonians and Albanians over the last 50 years what would the Albanian percentage be today?

Do you have an idea on numbers of Albanians who originate from Macedonia and migrated to Turkey during Yugoslavia who could still be eligible for citizenship? (This number is said to be in the hundreds of thousands today.)


I have heard this as a common argument Albanians use to claim "had we not emigrated there would have been more Albanians than Macedonians" in Macedonia. Well the reality is, there have been many hundred of thousands of Macedonians who have left as well. While they may or may not have some sort of property rights/claims on the country the fact is that they are not in the country and dont play a political role.

As far as independence there is no way of knowing exactly how many Albanians have left as the government does not keep these stats. This article which you may have already read says that from 1981-2011 approximately 140000 Albanians have emigrated from Macedonia. The way they determined this number was by data collected from the Council of Europe in each expat country (ie. Germany, Italy, Netherlands etc etc)

www.etd.ceu.hu/2013/agich_erlin.pdf


I have found some interesting figures regarding Skopje and the ethnic breakdown of students..
It seems to be similar to the national average.

DPSEUSG.png



2006/2007

Maqedone: 32,925 = 49.75%
Shqiptare: 24,066 = 36.37%
Serb: 899 = 1.35%

2007/2008

Maqedone: 33,278 = 50.19%
Shqiptare: 24,027 = 35.24%
Serb: 817 = 1.23%

2008/2009

Maqedone: 33,097 = 50.43%
Shqiptare: 23,781 = 36.23%
Serb: 749 = 1.14%

2009/2010

Maqedone: 32,441 = 50.19%
Shqiptare: 23,323 = 36.08%
Serb: 730 = 1,12%

2010/2011

Maqedone: 32,138 = 50.66%
Shqiptare: 22,286 = 36.05%
Serb: 667 = 1.05%

2011/2012

Maqedone: 32,225 = 50.75%
Shqiptare: 22,775 = 35.86%
Serb: 692 = 1.08%

2012/2013

Maqedone: 31,636 = 50.46%
Shqiptare: 22,793 = 36.35%
Serb: 594 = 0.94%

2013/2014

Maqedone: 31,647 = 50.77%
Shqiptare: 22,635 = 36.31%
Serb: 551 = 0.88%

2014/2015

Maqedone: 31,679 = 50.13%
Shqiptare: 23,704 = 37.51%
Serb: 471 = 0.74%



Not sure if these figures include the students of the eastern Skopje rural Municipality of Saraj which has an overwhelming
Albanian majority

According to the last national census from 2002, Saraj has 35,408 inhabitants.[1] Ethnic groups in the municipality include:

Albanians = 32,408 (91.5%)
Macedonians = 1,377 (3.9%)
Bosniaks = 1,120 (3.2%)
others.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saraj_Municipality

Do you know what the breakdown in other mixed controversial towns like Kicevo and Struga may be?

Albanians have made up around 30-35% of the primary and lower secondary student population since independence. Their capacity in the country is to reach 30% of the population assuming ZERO emigration. They dont have the demographic capacity to reach a higher percentage than that.

As far as student breakdown for Kichevo its 50/50 Macedonian and Albanian students. As for Struga Im not sure but Ill have to check.

For Kichevo, Macedonians have a chance to take Kicevo back in the next local elections and elect a Macedonian Mayor (If SDSM doesn't sell out again). If you read the same article above you will notice that 5000-8000 Albanian diaspora voted in the 2013 local elections. Since Kicevo (zajas, oslomej) were falsified in the 2002 census and because these areas are high Emigration areas for Albanians and since the student population in Kicevo is 50/50 with Macedonians their numbers will decrease long term. In order for Albanians to keep Kicevo with an Albanian mayor they will have to have their diaspora keep returning every 4 years for local elections.

Now for other regions like Skopje etc, all that matters are future trends. The Albanian student population has grown almost every year from 1966 to 2005. Since then it has dropped almost every year (collapsed more than 20%). The unique thing is that it has dropped faster than the Macedonian student population in the past 9 years.


Macedonian primary school students
2006/2007: 122,016 = 53,4% share of the total
2007/2008: 118,507 = 53,6%
2008/2009: 115,605 = 53,7%
2009/2010: 112,293 = 53,7%
2010/2011: 109,765 = 54,3%
2011/2012: 107,564 = 54,3%
2012/2013: 105,648 = 54.3%
2013/2014: 104,254 = 54.7%
2014/2015: 103,036 = 54.7%

15.5% DECREASE in 9 years

Albanian primary school students
2006/2007: 78,467 = 34,3% share of the total
2007/2008: 75,141 = 34,0%
2008/2009: 72,570 = 33,7%
2009/2010: 69,922 = 33,4%
2010/2011: 66,156 = 32,7%
2011/2012: 65,085 = 32,8%
2012/2013: 63,483 = 32,7%
2013/2014: 62,188 = 32.6%
2014/2015: 62,012 = 32.9%

21% DECREASE in 9 years

Had this decrease not happened it would have been Game over for Macedonians. Now although there is no way of predicting for certain, I assume these trends will probably continue for the next 10-15 years. The days of Albanians having 3-5 kids are over and the moment Births < Deaths + Emigration then the Albanian population will start to decrease.
 
I understand what your saying about the decrease..
But the decrease isn't that high if we count the amount of children who have recently moved moved abroad with their families who are of school age.. the students have decreased over the years due to migration but they still exist as legal citizens they just haven't been registed..

Plus the thousands of other second generation Albanians who may have been born in the west but regularly frequent Macedonia but don't have citizenship but are legally entitled to be granted citizenship are also not counted ...

I know many Second generation Macedonians who were born abroad and have taken up duel citizenship and have voting rights, even though they hardly ever step foot in Macedonia.. This is not the case amongst the second generation Albanians.

Should there be a drive from the Albanian diaspora community to register the many unregisted who legally have the right to be registered and then some form of electronic Internet voting was implimented.. then Albanians would possibly have upto 40% parliamentary representation..
 
I understand what your saying about the decrease..
But the decrease isn't that high if we count the amount of children who have recently moved moved abroad with their families who are of school age.. the students have decreased over the years due to migration but they still exist as legal citizens they just haven't been registed..

Plus the thousands of other second generation Albanians who may have been born in the west but regularly frequent Macedonia but don't have citizenship but are legally entitled to be granted citizenship are also not counted ...

I know many Second generation Macedonians who were born abroad and have taken up duel citizenship and have voting rights, even though they hardly ever step foot in Macedonia.. This is not the case amongst the second generation Albanians.

Should there be a drive from the Albanian diaspora community to register the many unregisted who legally have the right to be registered and then some form of electronic Internet voting was implimented.. then Albanians would possibly have upto 40% parliamentary representation..

The reality of this happening is extremely low. Also this system has already been implemented and diaspora can vote for up to only 3 MPs.

These MPs include:
Americas - Mostly Macedonian expats live here
Europe/Africa - Mix of Macedonians/Albanian expats live here
Asia/Australia - Mostly Macedonian expats live here

So the most influence the Albanian diaspora can have on parliament is by either not de-registering from Macedonia and flying back to vote (which will decrease over time as Albanians become accustomed to their new country) or by voting for the 1 MP seat in Parliament for the Albanian diaspora in Europe.

Second as far as second or third or fourth generation Albanians laying some sort of Claim to Macedonia - you can forget it. The longer they live elsewhere, the less impact they have on their "homeland"
 
Maybe.. but there was a proposal from one of the Albanian parties to change the diaspora voting system and the current electoral system into one electoral zone where even diaspora voters who would vote at embassies and consulates around the world to me pooled into 1 zone instead of the 6 we have now.. (plus 3 diaspora zones)

This would definitely increase the number of Albanian deputies in the parliament. Also it would insure that all deputies are elected with an equal number of votes throughout the country..
 
Maybe.. but there was a proposal from one of the Albanian parties to change the diaspora voting system and the current electoral system into one electoral zone where even diaspora voters who would vote at embassies and consulates around the world to me pooled into 1 zone instead of the 6 we have now.. (plus 3 diaspora zones)

This idea isn't new, it's something that is mentioned prior to each electoral cycle (if I'm not mistaken I believe Stojanche Angelov and the Third Bloc supported it at the last Dec.11 elections), but it never gets to materialize.
I believe the main reason is because the current electoral system favors big parties at the expense of the smaller ones (which explained why only DPMNE and SDSM won seats despite the other Macedonian participants receiving over 50 000 votes), they would lose seats if they accept it.
Experience so far shows that a party needs around 7000 votes in an electoral unit (not 7000 in the whole territory of Macedonia) to win a seat.
So hypothetically, you can have a scenario where a party wins 6500 votes in each of the 6 electoral units, summing up to 39 000 votes, and will still not win a single seat in the parliament.
 
Last edited:
Hi all..

New to the forum, ive been reading these threads in moments of high drama as an additional source of information. hence i thought id join up and give my two cents worth..

Now to the topic.. i find the status quo absolutely shocking.. i see this simply as a battle between the communist left ideals and the centre right. To me both are just as corrupt with the left being souless and the centre right incompetent. I cant believe people would entertain the idea of ZZ becomming PM. Pure evil.
 
Welcome to the forum Pelagonija..

What in your opinion makes Zaev "Evil" in your eyes?
And not the people who have made Macedonia totally dysfunctional and undemocratic just as Evil?
 
Welcome to the forum Pelagonija..

What in your opinion makes Zaev "Evil" in your eyes?
And not the people who have made Macedonia totally dysfunctional and undemocratic just as Evil?

Thanks for the welcome.

Firstly democracy is a tool used by western governments to overthrow non friendly governments. If democracy was real then ZZs/Albanians backers would firstly overthrow the Suadi government where women can't drive, where dissenting ends in decapitation, where people get whip lashed for not believing and where the Saudis bomb children in Yemen.

Is team VMRO corrupt stupid? Yes and so is every other government in the Balkans and beyond, at least they have a red line and won't go as far as ZZ.

As for ZZ, the peasant turned millionaire, the man who has on camera been recorded taking bribes, the man who has gone on record that he is going to eat raw people. The man who could only muster couple thousand left leaning homo liberals to vandalise Skopje and called that a revolution. This is a serpent who is coming to power with force and and support from the outside, do you think ZZ would have got this far without the support from the west, the bombs( as if all governments don't wiretap) and the platform.?

Maybe Macedonias problem is that it is more democratic than west? I mean how else do uneducated drug/gun smuggling murderous thugs like Ali Ahmeti get to sit in tax funded positions in government?

If ZZ was so democratic then why don't they go to the polls again and include in detail the Tirana platform? He won't do it as he knows he won't even come close ;)
 
Is team VMRO corrupt stupid? Yes and so is every other government in the Balkans and beyond, at least they have a red line and won't go as far as ZZ.
And exactly what red line is that?
If you refer to the so-called "Tirana platform", let me remind you that DUI confirmed several times (as did most pro-government media few hours before the DPMNE-DUI talks collapsed, although the term "Tirana platform" hadn't been coined yet, it was then called "Albanian parties' platform") that Grujo had accepted it, their denial now is only to score political points with the Macedonian voters and nothing more.
The only difference between SDSM and DPMNE was that the latter didn't accept extending SJO's mandate so that they don't go to jail. And that's about it.
DPMNE and SDSM are two sides of the same coin. Anyone thinking otherwise is just delusional.

As for ZZ, the peasant turned millionaire, the man who has on camera been recorded taking bribes, the man who has gone on record that he is going to eat raw people.
In any normal country he would have been serving long prison terms by now for all of that, but then again this is Macedonia.

The man who could only muster couple thousand left leaning homo liberals to vandalise Skopje and called that a revolution
Well, first of all, SDSM didn't muster the protests, what mustered them was the president's decision to pardon criminals that were caught on tape in heavy criminal activities.
Then, just as now, he was only trying to save Grujo's ass from going to jail instead of acting as a true statesmen (as a recent example, the Romanian president went among his people in the recent protests in Romania, the largest protests in that country since the fall of communism).

Secondly,"couple thousand" is a big underestimation.
I don't know if you live in Macedonia or you're another diaspora member, but if you had seen live images of the protests you could see there were much more than that.

And thirdly, I had participated in my hometown's protests and I can tell you that the protesters weren't "left leaning homo liberals".
Even though there was large SDSM presence at the protests, especially in the front rows, most of the people were average citizens of this country that were fed up with all the bullshit. Like me.
The tapped conversations and especially Ivanov's subsequent amnesty were only the drop that had filled the cup.

This is a serpent who is coming to power with force and and support from the outside, do you think ZZ would have got this far without the support from the west, the bombs( as if all governments don't wiretap) and the platform.?
Not in a million years, what they did in the first decade of our independence would have been enough to seal their faith as an opposition party in the next few decades at least.
But saying that all governments wiretap is the same as some Macedonians say "ама и овие крадеа". So we just have to forget it and move on?
This is crime of the highest level, in any normal country they would have been incarcerated by now for what's on those tapes!

Maybe Macedonias problem is that it is more democratic than west?
So what is the solution according to you, do we need to follow Erdogan's example and transform from the authoritarian regime that we are to a de jure dictatorship?
History has shown over and over how dictatorships end, and it's not pretty each time.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top